Growth of coniferous trees exposed to SO2 and O3 using an open-air fumigation system

Scots pine (Pinus sylvestris L.), Norway spruce (Picea abies (L.) Karst.) and Sitka spruce (Picea sitchensis Bong. Carr.) were planted as 2-year-old seedlings in an open-air fumigation facility at Liphook in southern England in March 1985. The soil was a humoferric podzol of pH 4. SO₂ fumigation began in May 1987 and continued until December 1990. Long-term mean SO₂ concentrations were 4,13 and 22 nmol mo^?1. Three plots, one at each SO₂ level, were also exposed to O₃ at an average of 1–3.times the ambient level. O₃ fumigation ran from March to December 1988, May to December 1989 and February to December 1990. Each species reacted differently to treatment. Scots pine showed no growth response to either pollutant, although other work on the site demonstrated a number of deleterious effects of SO₂ on this species, including increased leaf loss and foliar injury. Stem basal diameter growth of Norway spruce was depressed in SO₂-treated plots. In contrast, extension growth of shoots of Sitka spruce increased in SO₂-treated plots, in apparent response to codeposition of NH₃-N. However, diameter growth of Sitka spruce main stems did not increase. No effects of O₃ on growth were recorded for any species.     

The effects of SO2 and O3 on the foliar nutrition of Scots pine, Norway spruce and Sitka spruce in the Liphook open-air fumigation experiment

Foliar elements were analysed in Scots pine, Sitka spruce and Norway spruce over a 6 year period before and during continuous exposure to SO₂ and O₃ in an open-air fumigation experiment. Sulphur dioxide treatment elevated foliar sulphur concentration in all species, and there were increases in foliar nitrogen in the two spruce species but not in pine. The concentrations of cations were frequently increased by SO₂ treatment, but there was no correlation between the sulphur concentration of needles and their total cation charge. SO₂-related elevations of foliar magnesium were correlated with the concentration of this element in soil solution, but the mechanism by which other cations were enhanced remains unclear. The only consistent effects on nutrient ratios were for SO₂ treatments to increase sulphur/cation ratios.     

The Liphook Forest Fumigation Project: an overview

The aim of the Liphook Project was to assess the effects of SO₂ and O₃, singly and in combination, on coniferous forest ecosystems. More than 4000 trees of Scots pine (Pinus sylvestris), Norway spruce (Picea abies) and Sitka spruce (P. sitchensis) were fumigated for nearly 4 years using an open-air fumigation technique especially developed for the purpose. The technique eliminated artifacts due to chambers and enabled a variety of effects of the pollutant gases on forest ecosystems to be studied. Most symptoms of forest decline did not occur, but each species reacted in a different way to SO₂ stress, providing no evidence for universal forest decline symptoms. However, some of the mechanisms hypothesized to underlie forest declines were observed as an effect of SO₂ treatment, though others were not, notably any major effect of O₃. The results are assessed against proposed regulatory standards (critical loads and levels) for the protection of forest ecosystems against pollution.     

The effects of SO2 and O3 fumigation on acid deposition and foliar leaching in the Liphook forest fumigation experiment

The ambient pollution climate at the Liphook forest fumigation site, where coniferous trees were fumigated with SO₂ and O₃, for 4 years under field conditions, was characteristic of the fringes of the areas where pollutant effects are a problem. Experimental treatments increased SO₂ concentrations to levels more characteristic of Eastern Europe, and summer O₃ concentrations by 30%. Deposition of SO₂ to the soil between the trees (inferred from shallow lysimeters) was significant, the deposition velocity being 2–1 mms^?1. Deposition to Scots pine and Sitka spruce canopies was greater, deposition velocities being 8.5 and 9.4 mm s^?1, respectively. These high values may perhaps be explained by co-deposition with NH₃. Calculations assume that dry deposition was the sole source of SO₄^2? gain in throughfall, and that there was no significant retention by the trees. There was a trend for O₃ to enhance SO₂ deposition to both soil and trees. Fumigation with SO₂ led to a significant increase in leaching of cations from foliage. Each species neutralized about 63% of the dry-deposited SO₂, predominantly by ion exchange for Ca and K. Equations are provided which allow calculation of foliar leaching given SO₂ concentrations or SO₄^2? deposition. Fumigation increased the rate of nutrient cycling considerably, without affecting foliar concentrations or damaging the trees. Ozone treatments did not enhance foliar leaching, calling into question some suggested mechanisms for the causes of forest decline.     

The effect of open-air fumigation with SO2 and O3 on carbohydrate metabolism in Scots pine (Pinus sylvestris) and Norway spruce (Picea abies)

The carbohydrate metabolism of the needles of Scots pine (Pinus sylvestris) and Norway spruce (Picea abies) has been examined in trees that were exposed to SO₂, and O₃, in an open-air fumigation experiment located in the Liphook forest in southern England. Two-year-old seedlings were planted in 1985 in seven experimental plots. Five plots received fumigation treatments of SO₂, O₃ or a combination of these gases to give a 2 × 3 factorial design with one additional ambient plot Fumigation with SO₂, occurred from May 1987 to December 1990 and O₃, fumigation occurred from March to December 1988, May to December 1989 and February to December 1990. Five samples of needles for investigation of carbohydrate metabolism were taken between February and July 1989. The concentrations of soluble carbohydrates (including sucrose and hexoses) were greatly reduced in the needles taken from Scots pine growing in the treated plots, and were also reduced, but to a lesser extent, in the needles taken from Norway spruce. Little variation in the concentration of starch in the needles of either species was detected. The activities of the two final enzymes of sucrose synthesis, sucrose phosphate synthase and sucrose 6-phos-phate phosphatase, were greatly reduced in the needles of Scots pine and were also reduced, but to a lesser extent, in the needles of Norway spruce in the fumigated plots. These reductions could be correlated with decreases in rates of photosynthetic CO₂ assimilation determined by independent groups of researchers working on the Liphook site.     

Photosynthetic performance, chloroplast pigments and mineral content of Norway spruce (Picea abies (L.) Karst.) exposed to SO2 and O3 in an open-air fumigation experiment

Photosynthetic performance, mineral content and chloroplast pigments were investigated in August-September 1988 and 1989 in Norway spruce trees (Picea abies (L.) Karst.) exposed to SO₂, and O₃ in an open-air fumigation facility at Liphook, England. The data do not suggest a treatment effect on the mineral content of the needles in terms of nutrient leaching from the foliage. In addition, there were no direct SO₂ and/or O₃ effects on the content and/or composition of the chloroplast pigments. However, the long-term application of SO₂ resulted in a depression of net photosynthesis under light saturation and ambient CO₂ (A ₃₄₀) which was probably caused by a treatment-related depression of the carboxylation efficiency (CE). In 1989, the supposed treatment effects were apparently masked by an insufficient N-supply and probably also by low water availability during summer. However, fumigation appeared to accelerate an N-deficiency-related decrease of CE, stomatal closure and the age-dependent development of the chlorophyll content of the needles. In 1989, an observed depression of the photosynthetic capacity (A₂₅₀₀) was in part accompanied by a decrease in light use efficiency (α), suggesting an enhanced photosensitivity resulting from the impact of several possible interacting stresses (drought, N deficiency and fumigation). The results support the general conclusion that long-term low-level SO₂ dosage adversely affects the photosynthetic performance of the needle, whether directly or indirectly, and may also interact with other environmental stresses. The findings of our investigations are discussed with regard to the hypothesis of forest decline in the mountain regions of the Fichtelgebirge (north-eastern Bavaria, Germany).     

Effects of sulphur dioxide and ozone on stilbenes and disease resistance in spruce trees from the Liphook Forest Fumigation Project

Levels of the stilbene glucosides astringin and isorhapontin, the main constitutive antifungal compounds in bark tissues of spruce trees, were not altered in young Picea sitchensis (Bong.) Carr. or Picea abies (L.) Karst. trees exposed to sulphur dioxide and ozone in the Liphook Forest Fumigation Project. These trees had received computer-controlled fumigation treatments with two levels of SO₂ (long-term means 13 and 22nmol mol^?1) or one level of O³ (1–3.times ambient), or a combination of these treatments, from spring until December. Resistance of bark tissues from these trees to colonization by the root- and butt-rot pathogen Heterobasidion annosum (Fr.) Bref., assessed in vitro using excised stem lengths, was not significantly altered in fumigated plants compared with those exposed to ambient pollutant levels only. This study therefore provided no evidence for altered disease resistance in P. abies and P. sitchensis trees exposed to SO² and O³.     

Temperature and light dependent modifications of chlorophyll fluorescence kinetics in spruce needles during winter

Prompt chlorophyll a fluorescence kinetics at room temperature were measured from intact spruce needles. The fluorescence signal was recorded after varying light pretreatments. During the winter, induction curves showed characteristic changes in both the initial peak of fluorescence FV/FP (FP-FO/FP) and the steady state level F_dr (FP-FT/FP). Winter stress induced decreases in both values which showed close correlation to the light and temperature pre-history of the plants. In February changes in fluorescence induction indicative of a restoration of photosynthesis were detected and these corresponded to a rise of temperature above zero in combination with low light levels. In March increasing light intensity combined with chilling temperatures induced again decreases of both values of chlorophyll fluorescence induction suggesting the occurrence of photoinhibition.     

Influence of UV-B radiation on photosynthetic activity and chlorophyll fluorescence kinetics in Norway spruce [Picea abies (L.) Karst.] seedlings

Norway spruce [Picea abies (L.) Karst.] seedlings were grown in greenhouses with two supplemental levels of ultraviolet-B (UV-B) radiation. Photochemical efficiency of photosystem II and vitality index were determined monthly. At the end of the experiment, growth, chlorophyll content and photosynthetic rates were measured. The data indicate that low temperature in winter affected light dependent processes in experimental plants including control, while the rise of ambient temperatures, moderate this effect. The synergistic effects of UV-B radiation and low temperatures could only be observed in the second winter period. Measurements of net photosynthetic activity in the second winter period showed significant differences between treated and untreated plants.     

Responses of Photosynthesis,Carbohydrates and Antioxidants in Needles of Norway Spruce to Slow and Rapid Changes in Ozone

The goal of the present study was to examine the effects of slow and rapid changes of ozone (O₃) concentrations on the physiological behaviour of current-year needles of Norway spruce (Picea abies (L.) Karst.). For this purpose five-year-old spruce seedlings were exposed in growth chambers for 49 days to either charcoal-filtered air, slowly increasing O₃ concentrations from zero up to 100 nl I^?1 in weekly steps of 25 nl I^?1, or immediately to 100 nl I^?1 of O₃. During the investigation period gas exchange, carbohydrate and antioxidant contents of the current flush were measured. In needles which experienced slowly increasing O₃ concentrations, cumulative O₃ uptake was approximately 30 % lower than in needles continuously fumigated with 100 nl I^?1 of O₃. The higher 0₃ uptake in the permanent 100 nl I^?1 O₃ treatment caused a pronounced decline in net photosynthesis, in the efficiency of CO₂ uptake and in the starch content of the seedlings. Initially the ascorbate pool increased, but after 5 weeks of exposure ascorbate concentrations declined and were comparable to values obtained in charcoal-filtered controls, while the thiol contents were enhanced during fumigation with permanent 100 nl I-^?1 O₃. On the contrary, slowly increasing O₃ caused a significant increase in total needle ascorbate throughout the fumigation period, which probably prevented an O₃-induced decline in the photosynthetic machinery as photosynthesis was not affected although the thiol contents were not enhanced. Furthermore, starch content was slightly higher than in O₃-free controls. These results suggest that seedlings of Norway spruce have the possibility to acclimate to O₃ stress, as slowly increasing O₃ concentrations seemed to increase resistance and the seedlings were able to compensate.     

The effects of enhanced ozone and enhanced carbon dioxide concentrations on biomass, pigments and antioxidative enzymes in spruce needles (Picea abies L.)

During one growing period, 5-year-old spruce trees (Picea abies L., Karst.) were exposed in environmental chambers to elevated concentrations of carbon dioxide (750 cm³ m^?3) and ozone (008 cm³ m^?3) as single variables or in combination. Control concentrations of the gases were 350cm³ m^?3CO₂ and 0.02 cm³ m ^?3 ozone. To investigate whether an elevated CO₂ concentration can prevent adverse ozone effects by reducing oxidative stress, the activities of the protective enzymes superoxide dismutase, catalase and peroxidase were determined. Furthermore, shoot biomass, pigment and protein contents of two needle age classes were investigated. Ozone caused pigment reduction and visible injury in the previous year's needles and growth reduction in the current year's shoots. In the presence of elevated concentrations of ozone and CO₂, growth reduction in the current year's shoots was prevented, but emergence of visible damage in the previous year's needles was only delayed and pigment reduction was still found. Elevated concentrations of ozone or CO₂ as single variables caused a significant reduction in the activities of superoxide dismutase and catalase in the current year's needles. Minimum activities of superoxide dismutase and catalase and decreased peroxidase activities were found in both needle age classes from spruce trees grown at enhanced concentrations of both CO₂ and ozone. These results suggest a reduced tolerance to oxidative stress in spruce trees under conditions of elevated concentrations of both CO₂ and ozone.     

SO2-dependent cation competition and compartmentalization in Norway spruce needles

Ion contents in needles from Norway spruce trees [Picea abies (L.) Karst.] growing in Würzburg and in the SO₂-polluted Erzgebirge mountains were analysed to quantify cations which accumulate together with sulphate. In Würzburg there was a positive correlation of potassium (0.680 ± 0.300 Eq Eq^?1 SO₄^?2), magnesium (0.415 ± 0.111 Eq Eq^?1 SO₄^?2) and zinc (0.059 ± 0.006 Eq Eq^?1 SO₄^2?). In the Erzgebirge, potassium was also the stoichiometrically most important cation (0–887 ± 0–180 Eq K⁺ Eq^?1 SO₄^2?). All other correlations examined were weak or statistically non-significant. At both sites the calcium content of spruce needles did not depend on the sulphate content. The lack of a role for Ca²⁺ in neutralizing sulphate is a consequence of the presence of free oxalic acid in needles. Soluble oxalic acid precipitates Ca²⁺, which thereby becomes unavailable as a counterion for SO₄^2?. The activity coefficients of Ca²⁺ and oxalate^2?, and the solubility product of Ca-oxalate, were determined from in vivo data. It is concluded that the chronic accumulation of atmospheric sulphate in spruce needle vacuoles depletes available potassium and thereby strongly interferes with spruce growth and canopy turnover. This leads to impaired spruce vitality, even at sites where acute SO₂ disease symptoms are absent.     

The influence of elevated CO2 and O3 on fine roots and mycorrhizas of naturally growing young Scots pine trees during three exposure years

Young Scots pine trees naturally established at a pine heath were exposed to two concentrations of CO₂ (ambient and doubled ambient) and two O₃ regimes (ambient and doubled ambient) and their combination in open-top field chambers during growing seasons 1994, 1995 and 1996 (late May to 15 September). Filtered ozone treatment and chamberless control trees were also included in the treatment comparisons. Root ingrowth cores were inserted to the undisturbed soil below the branch projection of each tree at the beginning of the fumigation period in 1994 and were harvested at the end of the fumigation periods in 1995 and 1996. Root biomasses were determined from different soil layers in the ingrowth cores, and the infection levels of different mycorrhizal types were calculated. Elevated O₃ and CO₂ did not have significant effects on the biomass production of Scots pine coarse (Ø > 2 mm) or fine roots (Ø < 2 mm) and roots of grasses and dwarf shrubs. Elevated O₃ caused a transient stimulation, observable in 1995, in the proportion of tuber-like mycorrhizas, total mycorrhizas and total short roots but this stimulation disappeared during the last study year. Elevated CO₂ did not enhance carbon allocation to root growth or mycorrhiza formation, although a diminishing trend in the mycorrhiza formation was observed. In the combination treatment increased CO₂ inhibited the transient stimulating effect of ozone, and a significant increase of old mycorrhizas was observed. Our conclusion is that doubled CO₂ is not able to increase carbon allocation to growth of fine roots or mycorrhizas in nutrient poor forest sites and realistically elevated ozone does not cause a measurable limitation to roots within a period of three exposure years.     

Stomatal SO2 uptake and sulfate accumulation in needles of Norway spruce stands (Picea abies) in Central Europe

Monthly uptake rates and the annual deposition of gaseous SO₂ via the stomata of six Norway spruce canopies (Picea abies (L.) Karst.) in Germany (Königstein im Taunus, Witzenhausen, Grebenau, Frankenberg, Spessart, Fürth im Odenwald) were calculated (i) from statistical response functions of stomatal aperture depending on meteorological data, and (ii) from the synchronously measured SO₂ immission at these stands. The stomatal response functions had been derived on the basis of thorough stomatal water conductance measurements in the field. Calculations of the SO₂ conductance of spruce twigs and SO₂ uptake rates via stomata need continuously measured complete data sets of the (i) light intensity, (ii) air temperature, (iii) air humidity and (iv) SO₂ concentration in spruce forests from all the year. These data were recorded half hourly in different German spruce forests. The apparent needle water vapour pressure difference and transpiration rates were calculated from meteorological data. Additional use of canopy through flow data in dry years allowed the estimation of the mean stomatal conductance for H₂O and SO₂ of whole spruce canopies. The annual SO₂ uptake of a mean unit needle surface in spruce forests was 32% of the SO₂ uptake rate of exposed needles at the top of spruce crowns. There is significant SO₂ uptake all the year. The mean SO₂ dose at all sites and years received through the stomata was (0.25±0.07) mol SO₂ m^-2 (total needle surface) (nPa Pa^-1)^-1 (annual mean of SO₂ immission; 1 nPa (SO₂) Pa^-1 (air) = 1 ppb) day^-1 (vegetation period per year). Comparison of calculated SO₂ uptake rates into needles with measured SO₄ ^2- accumulation rates in needles from the mentioned sites and additionally from Würzburg, Schneeberg (Fichtelgebirge) and from three sites in the eastern Erzgebirge (Höckendorf, Kahleberg, Oberbärenburg) revealed that oxidative SO₂ detoxification (SO₄ ^2- formation) dominates only at sites with high SO₂ immission and short vegetation periods. Under these conditions 70 to 90% of the annual stomatal SO₂ uptake is detoxified via SO₄ ^2- accumulation in needles. Cations are needed for neutralization of accumulating SO₄ ^2- which are inavailable to support growth. Thus, SO₂ induces a dominant and competitive additional nutrient cation demand, cation deficiency symptoms and enhanced needle loss (spruce decline symptoms) mainly at sites, where the ratio R=(SO₂ immission): (length of the vegetation period) is higher than R=0.07 nPa Pa^-1 day^-1. Correlation analysis of the relative needle loss versus the SO₂-dependent SO₄ ^2- formation rate revealed a significant increase of needle loss at the 98% level (Student). At sites with small SO₂ immission and long vegetation periods (R<0.07 nPa Pa^-1 day^-1) reductive SO₂ detoxification via growth (and/or phloem export of SO₄ ^2-) is not kinetically overburdened. Under these conditions only 30% of the annual SO₂ uptake is detoxified via SO₄ ^2- formation and spruce decline is small or absent. On the basis of the critical value R0.07 nPa Pa^-1 day^-1 recommended SO₂ immission limits can be deduced on a mere ecophysiological basis. These deduced values are close to the proposed SO₂ immission limits of the IUFRO, WHO and the UNECE.