Conversion of AFLP markers to high-throughput markers in a complex polyploid,sugarcane

The application of DNA markers linked to traits of commercial value in sugarcane may increase the efficiency of sugarcane breeding. The majority of markers generated for quantitative trait locus mapping in sugarcane have been single sequence repeats or AFLPs (amplified fragment length polymorphisms). Since AFLP markers are not adapted for large-scale implementation in plant breeding, our objective was to assess the feasibility of converting AFLP markers to fast, cheap and reliable PCR-based assays in a complex polyploid, sugarcane. Three AFLP markers were selected on the basis of an association to resistance to the fungal pathogen Ustilago scitaminea, the causal agent of smut in sugarcane. We developed an approach which enabled the identification of polymorphisms in these AFLP markers. Towards this goal, we employed GenomeWalking and 454 sequencing to isolate sequences adjacent to the linked AFLP markers and identify SNP (single nucleotide polymorphisms) haplotypes present in the homo(eo)logous chromosomes of sugarcane. One AFLP marker was converted to a cleavage amplified polymorphic sequence marker, another to a SCAR (sequence characteristered amplified region) marker and the final AFLP marker to a SNP PCR-based assay. However, validation of each of the markers in 240 genotypes resulted in 99, 90 and 60% correspondence with the original AFLP marker. These experiments indicate that even in a complex polyploid such as sugarcane, polymorphisms identified by AFLP can be converted to high-throughput marker systems, but due to the complexity this would only be carried out for high-value markers. In some cases, the polymorphisms identified are not transferable to more sequence-specific PCR applications.     

Conversion of AFLP markers associated with FHB resistance in wheat into STS markers with an extension-AFLP method.

Amplified fragment length polymorphism (AFLP) has proven a powerful tool for tagging genes or quantitative trait loci (QTLs) of interest in plants. However, conversion of AFLP markers into sequence-tagged site (STS) markers is technically challenging in wheat owing to the complicated nature of its genome. In this study, we developed an "extension-AFLP" method to convert AFLP markers associated with Fusarium head blight (FHB) resistance into STS markers. When an AFLP marker of interest was detected with an EcoRI+3-MseI+4-selective primer combination, the PCR product was used as a template for an additional selective amplification with four primer pairs, in which one additional selective base (either A, C, G, or T) was added to the 3' end of one of the two primers. The extended primer pair that produced the targeted band was further extended by adding each of the four selective nucleotide bases for the next round of selective amplification. Extension selective amplification was performed until the target bands became clear enough for subsequent cloning and sequencing. By using the extension-AFLP method, we successfully converted two AFLP markers located on chromosome 3BS and associated with FHB resistance into STS markers. Our results indicated that the extension-AFLP method is an efficient approach for converting AFLP markers into STS markers in wheat. The developed STS markers might be used for marker-assisted selection (MAS) for FHB resistance in wheat breeding programs.     

Conversion of AFLP markers to sequence-specific PCR markers in barley and wheat

 Conversion of amplified fragment length polymorphisms (AFLPs) to sequence-specific PCR primers would be useful for many genetic-linkage applications. We examined 21 wheat nullitetrasomic stocks and five wheat-barley addition lines using 12 and 14 AFLP primer combinations, respectively. On average, 36.8% of the scored AFLP fragments in the wheat nullitetrasomic stocks and 22.3% in the wheat-barley addition lines could be mapped to specific chromosomes, providing approximately 461 chromosome-specific AFLP markers in the wheat nullitetrasomic stocks and 174 in the wheat-barley addition lines. Ten AFLP fragments specific to barley chromosomes and 16 AFLP fragments specific to wheat 3BS and 4BS chromosome arms were isolated from the polyacrylamide gels, re-amplified, cloned and sequenced. Primer sets were designed from these sequences. Amplification of wheat and barley genomic DNA using the barley derived primers revealed that three primer sets amplified DNA from the expected chromosome, five amplified fragments from all barley chromosomes but not from wheat, one amplified a similar-sized fragment from multiple barley chromosomes and from wheat, and one gave no amplification. Amplification of wheat genomic DNA using the wheat-derived primer sets revealed that three primer sets amplified a fragment from the expected chromosome, 11 primer sets amplified a similar-sized fragment from multiple chromosomes, and two gave no amplification. These experiments indicate that polymorphisms identified by AFLP are often not transferable to more sequence-specific PCR applications. Received: 30 June 1998 / Accepted: 26 October 1998     

Array-based high-throughput DNA markers for crop improvement

The last two decades have witnessed a remarkable activity in the development and use of molecular markers both in animal and plant systems. This activity started with low-throughput restriction fragment length polymorphisms and culminated in recent years with single nucleotide polymorphisms (SNPs), which are abundant and uniformly distributed. Although the latter became the markers of choice for many, their discovery needed previous sequence information. However, with the availability of microarrays, SNP platforms have been developed, which allow genotyping of thousands of markers in parallel. Besides SNPs, some other novel marker systems, including single feature polymorphisms, diversity array technology and restriction site-associated DNA markers, have also been developed, where array-based assays have been utilized to provide for the desired ultra-high throughput and low cost. These microarray-based markers are the markers of choice for the future and are already being used for construction of high-density maps, quantitative trait loci (QTL) mapping (including expression QTLs) and genetic diversity analysis with a limited expense in terms of time and money. In this study, we briefly describe the characteristics of these array-based marker systems and review the work that has already been done involving development and use of these markers, not only in simple eukaryotes like yeast, but also in a variety of seed plants with simple or complex genomes.     

Conversion of AFLP fragments tightly linked to SCMV resistance genes Scmv1 and Scmv2 into simple PCR-based markers

In a previous study, bulked segregant analysis with amplified fragment length polymorphisms (AFLPs) identified several markers closely linked to the sugarcane mosaic virus resistance genes Scmv1 on chromosome 6 and Scmv2 on chromosome 3. Six AFLP markers (E33M61-2, E33M52, E38M51, E82M57, E84M59 and E93M53) were located on chromosome 3 and two markers (E33M61-1 and E35M62-1) on chromosome 6. Our objective in the present study was to sequence the respective AFLP bands in order to convert these dominant markers into more simple and reliable polymerase chain reaction (PCR)-based sequence-tagged site markers. Six AFLP markers resulted either in complete identical sequences between the six inbreds investigated in this study or revealed single nucleotide polymorphisms within the inbred lines and were, therefore, not converted. One dominant AFLP marker (E35M62-1) was converted into an insertion/deletion (indel) marker and a second AFLP marker (E33M61-2) into a cleaved amplified polymorphic sequence marker. Mapping of both converted PCR-based markers confirmed their localization to the same chromosome region (E33M61-2 on chromosome 3; E35M62-1 on chromosome 6) as the original AFLP markers. Thus, these markers will be useful for marker-assisted selection and facilitate map-based cloning of SCMV resistance genes.     

The chromosomal location of rye AFLP bands

23 AFLP bands were assigned to different rye chromosomes by means of two different sets of wheat-rye addition lines. Only one AFLP band could be assigned to 4R, and no specific AFLPs were found on the 5R chromosome. Only one AFLP band was explicitly assigned to 4R, and no specific AFLPs were found on the 5R chromosome. At least seven co-migrating AFLPs showed the same chromosomal location in both sets of addition lines. A total of 22 AFLPs were assigned to chromosome 1R using wheat-rye substitution lines. Six of them have counterparts in one of the addition lines analyzed, but only four have the same chromosomal location. Six and four of the total AFLPs located using addition (23) and substitution (22) lines segregated in the mapping population DS2 x RXL10, but only six were simultaneously assigned to the same chromosome by both approaches. Although co-migrating AFLPs could be located on different rye chromosomes using addition and substitution lines, we believe that AFLPs can be useful as rye chromosome markers.     

Identification of sex-linked DNA markers by AFLP in Portunus trituberculatus

To investigate the mechanism of sex determination of crabs, amplified fragment-length polymorphism DNA analysis was applied to identify sex-specific markers for Portunus trituberculatus. Eleven pairs of primers were used to amplify DNA isolated from male and female crabs. A total of 481 and 499 fragments were amplified for females and males, respectively, and the ratios of polymorphic fragments were 20.59–65.52% and 27.27–62.22%, respectively. Distribution difference values between female and male groups for 10 polymorphisms were greater than 40%; Cluster analysis revealed that Nei's genetic distances for 57 polymorphisms clustered according to sex. The results indicate that a difference at the DNA level exists between female and male crabs and provide data for further study on sex determination.     

Analysis of DNA methylation in Arabidopsis thaliana based on methylation-sensitive AFLP markers

AFLP analysis using restriction enzyme isoschizomers that differ in their sensitivity to methylation of their recognition sites has been used to analyse the methylation state of anonymous CCGG sequences in Arabidopsis thaliana. The technique was modified to improve the quality of fingerprints and to visualise larger numbers of scorable fragments. Sequencing of amplified fragments indicated that detection was generally associated with non-methylation of the cytosine to which the isoschizomer is sensitive. Comparison of EcoRI/ HpaII and EcoRI/ MspI patterns in different ecotypes revealed that 35-43% of CCGG sites were differentially digested by the isoschizomers. Interestingly, the pattern of digestion among different plants belonging to the same ecotype is highly conserved, with the rate of intra-ecotype methylation-sensitive polymorphisms being less than 1%. However, pairwise comparisons of methylation patterns between samples belonging to different ecotypes revealed differences in up to 34% of the methylation-sensitive polymorphisms. The lack of correlation between inter-ecotype similarity matrices based on methylation-insensitive or methylation-sensitive polymorphisms suggests that whatever the mechanisms regulating methylation may be, they are not related to nucleotide sequence variation.     

Chemiluminescent detection of AFLP markers

Nonradioactive amplified fragment-length polymorphism (AFLP) marker detection, a PCR-based, DNA-fingerprinting technique, was achieved by blotting AFLP products after electrophoresis onto a nylon membrane and subsequently hybridizing the blot with an alkaline phosphatase-labeled AFLP probe. Similar AFLP profiles were obtained by both a nonradioactive, chemiluminescent detection technique and by conventional AFLP marker detection using 32P-labeled AFLP primers. The suitability of the method using different gel systems combined with subsequent chemiluminescent detection of AFLP markers is validated by similar dendrograms that were generated using the unweighted pair group method with arithmetic averages (UPGMA). Moreover, chemiluminescent detection of AFLP markers using a universal AFLP nonradioactive probe has been successfully applied on prokaryotes such as Agrobacterium and eukaryotic genomes such as soybean and fungi.     

Conversion of AFLP markers to sequence-specific markers for closely related lines in rice by use of the rice genome sequence

DNA polymorphism between two major japonica rice cultivars, Nipponbare and Koshihikari, was identified by AFLP. Eighty-four polymorphic AFLP markers were obtained by analysis with 360 combinations of primer pairs. Nucleotide sequences of 73 markers, 29 from Nipponbare and 44 from Koshihikari, were determined, and 46 AFLP markers could be assigned to rice chromosomes based on sequence homology to the rice genome sequence. Specific primers were designed for amplification of the regions covering the AFLP markers and the flanking sequences. Out of the 46 primer pairs, 44 amplified single DNA fragments, six of which showed different sizes between Nipponbare and Koshihikari, yielding codominant SCAR markers. Eight primer pairs amplified only Nipponbare sequences, providing dominant SCAR markers. DNA fragments amplified by 13 primer pairs showed polymorphism by CAPS, and polymorphism of those amplified by 13 other primer pairs were detected by PCR-RF-SSCP (PRS). Nucleotide sequences of the other four DNA fragments were determined in Koshihikari, but no difference was found between Koshihikari and Nipponbare. In total, 40 sequence-specific markers for the combination of Nipponbare and Koshihikari were produced. All the SNPs identified by AFLP were detectable by CAPS and PRS. The same method was applicable to a combination of Kokoromachi and Tohoku 168, and 23 polymorphic markers were identified using these two rice cultivars. The procedure of conversion of AFLP-markers to the sequence-specific markers used in this study enables efficient sequence-specific marker production for closely related cultivars.     

Conversion of barley SNPs into PCR-based markers using dCAPS method

Molecular genetic research relies heavily on the ability to detect polymorphisms in DNA. Single nucleotide polymorphisms (SNPs) are the most frequent form of DNA variation in the genome. In combination with a PCR assay, the corresponding SNP can be analyzed as a derived cleaved amplified polymorphic sequence (dCAPS) marker. The dCAPS method exploits the well-known specificity of a restriction endonuclease for its recognition site and can be used to virtually detect any SNP. Here, we describe the use of the dCAPS method for detecting single-nucleotide changes by means of a barley EST, CK569932, PCR-based marker.     

A new and versatile method for the successful conversion of AFLP markers into simple single locus markers

Genetic markers can efficiently be obtained by using amplified fragment length polymorphism (AFLP) fingerprinting because no prior information on DNA sequence is required. However, the conversion of AFLP markers from complex fingerprints into simple single locus assays is perceived as problematic because DNA sequence information is required for the design of new locus-specific PCR primers. In addition, single locus polymorphism (SNP) information is required to design an allele-specific assay. This paper describes a new and versatile method for the conversion of AFLP markers into simple assays. The protocol presented in this paper offers solutions for frequently occurring pitfalls and describes a procedure for the identification of the SNP responsible for the AFLP. By following this approach, a high success rate for the conversion of AFLP markers into locus-specific markers was obtained.     

Development of AFLP markers in barley

To investigate the application of amplified fragment length polymorphism (AFLP) markers in barley, 96 primer combinations were used to generate AFLP patterns with two barley lines, L94 and Vada. With seven primer combinations, only a few intense bands were obtained, probably derived from repeated sequences. With the majority of the remaining 89 primer combinations, on average about 120 amplification products were generated, and the polymorphism rate between the two lines was generally over 18%. Based on the number of amplified products and the polymorphism rate, the 48 best primer combinations were selected and tested on 16 barley lines, again including L94 and Vada. Using a subset of 24 primer combinations 2188 clearly visible bands within the range from 80 to 510 bp were generated; 55% of these showed some degree of polymorphism among the 16 lines. L94 versus Vada showed the highest polymorphism rate (29%) and Proctor versus Nudinka yielded the lowest (12%). The polymorphism rates per primer combination showed little dependence on the barley lines used. Hence the most efficient and informative primer combinations identified for a given pair of lines turned out to be highly efficient when applied to others. Generally, more than 100 common markers (possibly locus specific) among populations or crosses were easily identified by comparing 48 AFLP profiles of the parent lines. The existence of such a large number of markers common to populations will facilitate the merging of molecular marker data and other genetic data into one integrated genetic map of barley. Received: 28 October 1996 / Accepted: 27 November 1996     

Identification ofporphyra lines (rhodophyta) by AFLP DNA fingerprinting and molecular markers

Twenty-sevenPorphyra lines from 5 classes, including lines widely used in China, wild lines, and lines introduced to China from abroad in recent years, were screened by means of amplified fragment length polymorphism (AFLP) with 24 primer pairs. From the generated AFLP products, 13 bands that showed stable and repeatable AFLP patterns amplified by primer pairs M-CGA/E-AA and M-CGA/E-TA were scored and used to develop the DNA fingerprints of the 27Porphyra lines. Moreover, the DNA fingerprinting patterns were converted into computer language expressed with digitals 1 and 0, which represented the presence (numbered as 1) or absence (numbered as 0) of the corresponding band. On the basis of these results, computerized AFLP DNA fingerprints were constructed in which each of the 27Porphyra lines has its unique AFLP fingerprinting pattern and can be easily distinguished from others. Software called PGI-AFLP (Porphyra germ-plasm identification-AFLP) was designed for identification of the 27Porphyra lines. In addition, 21 specific AFLP markers from 15Porphyra lines were identified; 6 AFLP markers from 4Porphyra lines were sequenced, and 2 of them were successfully converted into SCAR (sequence characterized amplification region) markers. The developed AFLP DNA fingerprinting and specific molecular markers provide useful ways for the identification, classification, and resource protection of thePorphyra lines.     

优化AFLP阳性带回收克隆技术

通过将AFLP聚丙烯酰胺变性胶切小、适当曝光过量、以聚丙烯酰胺凝胶电泳代替琼脂糖电泳检测克隆片段大小的方法 ,增加了回收克隆AFLP阳性带的准确性。该方法对于从变性和非变性大page胶上回收克隆目的片段具有普遍意义。     

Development of large-scale AFLP markers in jute

Amplified fragment length polymorphism (AFLP) analysis was conducted to investigate the level of polymorphism in four jute genotypes including two genotypes (JRC 321 and CMU 010) of Corchorus capsularis (the white jute) and two genotypes (JRO 524 and PPO4) of Corchorus olitorius (the tossa jute). Out of 1024 primer combinations that were tried, as many as 281 combinations of selective primers (13 EcoRI and 64 MseI) were selected, which produced a total of 9092 amplicons, including 752 (8.3%) polymorphic bands in C. capsularis and a total of 8856 amplicons including 1477 (16.7%) polymorphic bands in C. olitorius. The average number of bands/primer combination was 32.3 for C. capsularis and 31.5 for C. olitorius. For C. capsularis, highest polymorphism of 56.6% was shown by primer combination E35M50, while for C. olitorius highest polymorphism of 50% was shown by E41M91. In C. olitorius, 30–50% polymorphism was observed with 27 primer combinations, but in C. capsularis only 3 primer combinations gave this level of polymorphism. Similarly, in C. capsularis <10% polymorphism was detected by 115 primer combinations while in C. olitorius, <10% polymorphism was shown by only 56 primer combinations. These results indicate a higher level of polymorphism in C. olitorius relative to that in C. capsularis. The occurrence of such a large number of polymorphic AFLP markers will facilitate preparation of molecular maps and QTL analysis in jute.     

Estimating levels of inbreeding using AFLP markers

In the absence of detailed pedigree records, researchers have attempted to estimate individuals' levels of inbreeding using molecular markers, generally making use of heterozygosity measures based on microsatellite markers. Here we report and validate a method for estimating an individual's inbreeding coefficient, f, using amplified fragment length polymorphism (AFLP) markers. We use simulations to confirm that our measure scales appropriately with f when allele frequencies can be estimated from a subset of outbred individuals. We also present an approach for obtaining satisfactory estimates even in the absence of an independent set of known outbred individuals from which to estimate allele frequencies. We then test our method against empirical data from 179 wild and captive-bred old-field mice, Peromyscus polionotus subgriseus, comprising pedigree-based estimates of f, along with genetic data from 94 AFLP markers and 12 microsatellites. Inbreeding estimates based on both AFLP and microsatellite markers were found to correlate strongly with pedigree-based inbreeding coefficients. Owing to their ease of amplification in any species, AFLP markers may prove to be a valuable new tool for estimating f in natural populations and for examining correlations between heterozygosity and fitness.     

Identification of molecular markers in soybean comparing RFLP,RAPD and AFLP DNA mapping techniques

Three different DNA mapping techniques—RFLP, RAPD and AFLP—were used on identical soybean germplasm to compare their ability to identify markers in the development of a genetic linkage map. Polymorphisms present in fourteen different soybean cultivars were demonstrated using all three techniques. AFLP, a novel PCR-based technique, was able to identify multiple polymorphic bands in a denaturing gel using 60 of 64 primer pairs tested. AFLP relies on primers designed in part on sequences for endonuclease restriction sites and on three selective nucleotides. The 60 diagnostic primer pairs tested for AFLP analysis each distinguished on average six polymorphic bands. Using specific primers designed for soybean fromEco RI andMse I restriction site sequences and three selective nucleotides, as many as 12 polymorphic bands per primer could be obtained with AFLP techniques. Only 35% of the RAPD reactions identified a polymorphic band using the same soybean cultivars, and in those positive reactions, typically only one or two polymorphic bands per gel were found. Identification of polymorphic bands using RFLP techniques was the most cumbersome, because Southern blotting and probe hybridization were required. Over 50% of the soybean RFLP probes examined failed to distinguish even a single polymorphic band, and the RFLP probes that did distinguish polymorphic bands seldom identified more than one polymorphic band. We conclude that, among the three techniques tested, AFLP is the most useful.     

Conversion of DNA methyltransferases into azidonucleosidyl transferases via synthetic cofactors

Aziridine-based cofactor mimics have been synthesized and are shown to undergo methyltransferase-dependent DNA alkylation. Notably, each cofactor mimic possesses an azide functionality, to which can be attached an assortment of unnatural groups following methyltransferase-dependent DNA delivery. DNA duplexes modified with these cofactor mimics are capable of undergoing the Staudinger ligation with phosphines tethered to biological functionalities following enzymatic modification. This methodology provides a new tool by which to selectively modify DNA in a methyltransferase-dependent way. The conversion of biological methyltransferases into azidonucleosidyl transferases demonstrated here also holds tremendous promise as a means of identifying, as yet, unknown substrates of methylation.