Contacts between the LexA repressor--or its DNA-binding domain--and the backbone of the recA operator DNA.

Using hydroxyl radical footprinting and ethylation interference experiments, we have determined the backbone contacts made by the entire LexA repressor and its amino-terminal fragment with the recA operator DNA. These techniques reveal essentially the same contacts between both proteins and one side of the DNA helix if one assumes that the DNA stays in the normal B-conformation. This result is somewhat unexpected because protection of guanine bases against methylation suggested a somewhat twisted recognition surface. The backbone contacts revealed by both methods are symmetrically disposed with respect to the center of the operator, providing further evidence that the operator binds two LexA monomers. Each half-operator contains seven interfering phosphates. These phosphates are found on both sides of the 5'-CTGT sequence that is believed to be the principal recognition target. On the side close to the center of the operator are found two phosphates, whereas the other five are clustered on the side apart from the dyad axis. We are not aware of such an extended cluster of interfering phosphates for any other DNA-binding protein. A quantification of the hydroxyl radical footprints allowed us to compare further the affinity of the LexA repressor for the recA operator with that of its isolated DNA binding domain. We find an only 13-fold higher binding constant for LexA than for its amino-terminal domain, which is in good agreement with our earlier results for the uvrA operator using a completely different binding assay.     

TraY DNA recognition of its two F factor binding sites

F factor TraY, a ribbon-helix-helix DNA-binding protein, performs two roles in bacterial conjugation. TraY binds the F origin of transfer (oriT) to promote nicking of plasmid DNA prior to conjugative transfer. TraY also binds the P(Y) promoter to up-regulate tra gene expression. The two plasmid regions bound by TraY share limited sequence identity, yet TraY binds them with similar affinities. TraY recognition of the two sites was first probed using in vitro footprinting methods. Hydroxyl radical footprinting at both oriT and P(Y) sites indicated that bound TraY protected the DNA backbone bordering three adjacent DNA subsites. Analytical ultracentrifugation results for TraY:oligonucleotide complexes were consistent with two of these subsites being bound cooperatively, and the third being occupied at higher TraY concentrations. Methylation protection and interference footprinting identified several guanine bases contacted by or proximal to bound TraY, most located within these subsites. TraY affinity for variant oriT sequences with base substitutions at or near these guanine bases suggested that two of the three subsites correspond to high-affinity, cooperatively bound imperfect inverted GA(G/T)A repeats. Altering the spacing or orientation of these sites reduced binding. TraY mutant R73A failed to protect two symmetry-related oriT guanine bases in these repeats from methylation, identifying possible direct TraY-DNA contacts. The third subsite appears to be oriented as an imperfect direct repeat with its adjacent subsite, although base substitutions at this subsite did not reduce binding. Although unusual for ribbon-helix-helix proteins, this binding site arrangement occurs at both F TraY sites, consistent with it being functionally relevant.     

Binding of the Bacillus subtilis LexA protein to the SOS operator

The Bacillus subtilis LexA protein represses the SOS response to DNA damage by binding as a dimer to the consensus operator sequence 5′-CGAACN₄GTTCG-3′. To characterize the requirements for LexA binding to SOS operators, we determined the operator bases needed for site-specific binding as well as the LexA amino acids required for operator recognition. Using mobility shift assays to determine equilibrium constants for B.subtilis LexA binding to recA operator mutants, we found that several single base substitutions within the 14 bp recA operator sequence destabilized binding enough to abolish site-specific binding. Our results show that the AT base pairs at the third and fourth positions from the 5′ end of a 7 bp half-site are essential and that the preferred binding site for a LexA dimer is 5′-CGAACATATGTTCG-3′. Binding studies with LexA mutants, in which the solvent accessible amino acid residues in the putative DNA binding domain were mutated, indicate that Arg-49 and His-46 are essential for binding and that Lys-53 and Ala-48 are also involved in operator recognition. Guided by our mutational analyses as well as hydroxyl radical footprinting studies of the dinC and recA operators we docked a computer model of B.subtilis LexA on the preferred operator sequence in silico. Our model suggests that binding by a LexA dimer involves bending of the DNA helix within the internal 4 bp of the operator.     

Repression of the E coli recA gene requires at least two LexA protein monomers

To analyze the DNA binding domain of E coli LexA repressor and to test whether the repressor binds as a dimer to DNA, negative dominant lexA mutations affecting the binding domain have been isolated. A large number of amino acid substitutions between amino acid positions 39 and 46 were introduced using cassette mutagenesis. Mutants defective in DNA binding were identified and then examined for dominance to lexA+. A number of substitutions weakened repressor function partially, whereas other substitutions led to a repressor with no demonstrable activity and a defective dominant phenotype. Since the LexA binding site has dyad symmetry, we infer that this dominance results from interaction of monomers of wild-type LexA protein with mutant monomers and that an oligomeric form of repressor binds to operator. The binding of LexA protein to operator DNA was investigated further using a mutant protein, LexA408, which recognizes a symmetrically altered operator mutant but not wild-type operator. A mixture of mutant LexA408 and LexA+ proteins, but neither individual protein, bound to a hybrid recA operator consisting of mutant and wild-type operator half sites. These results suggest that at least 1 LexA protein monomer interacts with each operator half site. We discuss the role of LexA oligomer formation in binding of LexA to operator DNA.     

Tet repressor-tet operator contacts probed by operator DNA-modification interference studies

Contacts between tet operator DNA and Tet repressor protein are characterized by modification interference studies. The modified DNA fragments are separated into fractions with high, intermediate and low affinities for Tet repressor by polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis. Ethylation of the phosphates with N-ethylnitrosourea reveals 12 contacts of a repressor dimer to tet operator. Eight of these contacts appear to be important for Tet repressor binding, as judged by the strong interference at these positions, while four contacts are probably less important. All of the phosphate contacts are located on the same side of the B-DNA structure. The sequences of tet operators proposed to interact with the recognition alpha-helix of Tet repressor are TCTATC in three cases and CCTATC in one case. After methylation of N-7 with dimethylsulfate, strong interference is observed at the guanine residues at positions +/- 2. None of the N-7 functions of other guanine residues seems to be involved in tight contacts to Tet repressor. Tet repressor subunits form identical phosphate and guanine N-7 contacts with each half side of the two tet operators indicating twofold dyad symmetry of the complexes. Attempts to analyze the methylation interference at the adenine N-3 sites reveal different results for the operators. Modification of DNA fragments with diethylpyrocarbonate yields hypersensitive sites in the tet operators, indicating different local DNA structures. Carbethoxylation interference studies confirm the contacts at the purines found by methylation interference. All of the sequence-specific protein-DNA contacts detected in this study are centered at the inside four base-pairs in each tet operator half side. The contacts are discussed with respect to the structure of the repressor-operator complex.     

Operator DNA sequence variation enhances high affinity binding by hinge helix mutants of lactose repressor protein

The mechanism by which genetic regulatory proteins discern specific target DNA sequences remains a major area of inquiry. To explore in more detail the interplay between DNA and protein sequence, we have examined binding of variant lac operator DNA sequences to a series of mutant lactose repressor proteins (LacI). These proteins were altered in the C-terminus of the hinge region that links the N-terminal DNA binding and core sugar binding domains. Variant operators differed from the wild-type operator, O(1), in spacing and/or symmetry of the half-sites that contact the LacI N-terminal DNA binding domain. Binding of wild-type and mutant proteins was affected differentially by variations in operator sequence and symmetry. While the mutant series exhibits a 10(4)-fold range in binding affinity for O(1) operator, only a approximately 20-fold difference in affinity is observed for a completely symmetric operator, O(sym), used widely in studies of the LacI protein. Further, DNA sequence influenced allosteric response for these proteins. Binding of this LacI mutant series to other variant operator DNA sequences indicated the importance of symmetry-related bases, spacing, and the central base pair sequence in high affinity complex formation. Conformational flexibility in the DNA and other aspects of the structure influenced by the sequence may establish the binding environment for protein and determine both affinity and potential for allostery.     

Lac repressor–operator interaction: N-terminal peptide backbone 1H and 15N chemical shifts upon complex formation with DNA

When the lac repressor tetramer is bound to its DNA operator, methylation protection shows the nearly symmetric operator half-sites are contacted asymmetrically. This asymmetric binding results from the DNA sequence/structure. The reported structure of lac repressor N-terminal fragment and an 11 base-pair operator left half-site provides no information concerning the effect of asymmetric binding, from left operator half-site to right half-site, upon the polypeptide backbone. We isolated uniformly ¹⁵N labeled 56 amino acid wild-type (HP56WT) and 64 residue mutant [Pro3>Tyr3] (HP64tyr3) lac repressor N-terminal DNA binding fragments for ¹H/¹⁵N NMR studies with the left and right operators separately. Spectral coincidence of these longer fragments, indicating structural similarity with a protease derived 51 amino acid fragment for which the amide correlations are assigned, allows for assignment of the common amide resonances. For both HP56WT and HP64tyr3, spectral overlap of the amide correlation peaks reveals the polypeptide backbones of the uncomplexed polypeptides are structurally similar. Likewise the complexes of the peptides to the 11 base-pair lac left operator half-site are similar. On the other hand, complexes of HP56WT and the left compared to the right lac operator half-site show different residues of the polypeptide are affected by binding different half-sites of the operator. Thus, the DNA sequence/structure transmits asymmetry to the polypeptide backbone of the interacting protein.     

bZIP proteins bind to a palindromic sequence without an ACGT core located in a seed-specific element of the pea lectin promoter

Previously, it has been shown that a trimer of a 22 bp fragment of the promoter of the seed-specific pea lectin gene confers high expression in seed. Here it is reported that this fragment contains a binding site for the cloned basic domain/leucine zipper (bZIP) proteins TGA1a and Opaque-2 (02). Gel shift assays, DNasel footprinting and methylation interference assays using purified TGA1a were performed to determine whether additional binding sites are present in the psl promoter. Within the 469 bp upstream region only one other TGAla binding site was found, which is much weaker than the one present in the 22 bp element. Both O2 and TGAla bound to the odd base palindromic C-box sequence, ATGAGTCAT, present within the 22 bp fragment. The 22 bp fragment also contains the sequence CACGTA, which contains the ACGT core usually found in binding sites for bZIP proteins. However, this sequence did not significantly contribute to bZIP protein binding. The binding affinity of TGAla for the odd base palindromic sequence was low relative to a high-affinity C-box (ATGACGTCAT). By contrast, O2 strongly bound to the odd base C-box; the affinity was comparable with that for high-affinity G-(GACACGTGTC) and C-boxes. It is concluded that the presence of an ACGT core sequence is not a prerequisite for high-affinity binding of O2.     

Template-directed interference footprinting of cytosine contacts in a protein-DNA complex: potent interference by 5-aza-2'-deoxycytidine.

In the template-directed interference (TDI) footprinting method (Hayashibara & Verdine, 1990), analogs of the naturally occurring DNA bases are incorporated into DNA enzymatically and assayed for interference of sequence-specific binding by a protein. Here we extend this method to include analysis of contacts of amino acid residues to the major groove surface of cytosine residues (TDI-C footprinting). The base analog 5-aza-2'-deoxycytidine, in which the hydrophobic 5-CH of cytosine is replaced by a hydrophilic aza nitrogen, was incorporated into DNA via the corresponding 5'-triphosphate. The analog was found to base pair with guanine during polymerization, resulting in substitution of 2'-deoxycytidine residues. TDI-C footprints of the lambda repressor-OL1 operator complex revealed apparent contacts to the cytosines at operator positions 7 and 8. Inspection of the high-resolution X-ray crystal structure of the lambda-OL1 complex (Clarke et al., 1992; Beamer & Pabo, 1992) revealed that C8 makes a hydrogen binding contact with the Lys3; C7, on the other hand, makes a previously unnoticed hydrophobic contact with the alkane side chain of Lys3. In only the consensus operator half-site was cytosine interference observed, suggesting that the nonconsensus arm binds DNA very differently if at all. The N-terminal arm represents the archetypal case of a sequence-specific peptide-DNA complex characterized at high resolution; thus, the present studies suggest strategies for design and screening of DNA binding peptides. The finding that 5-aza-2'-deoxycytidine inhibits sequence-specific DNA binding proteins may suggest an alternative rationale for the biological activities of this and related azapyrimidine nucleosides.     

Interactions of sulfur oxidation repressor with its promoters involve different binding geometries

The divergently transcribed sulfur oxidation (sox) operon of a sulfur chemolithotrophs, Pseudaminobacter salicylatoxidans KCT001, comprising sox TRS-VW-XYZABCD, is regulated by a repressor (SoxR). SoxR binds to two disparate operators, sv (present in between soxS and soxV) and wx (present in between soxW and soxX). Here we report details of the interaction between SoxR and these two operator regions of the sox operon, using methylation interference and hydroxyl radical footprinting. We propose that the sv operator is symmetric and compact, while the wx operator is asymmetric and extended. We report an interesting difference between the SoxR-sv interaction and the SoxR-wx interaction through a competition assay involving groove-specific ligands. SoxR binds in the major groove of the sv operator, but binds in the minor groove of the wx operator. The structural flexibility of the SoxR helps it to act differentially in its interactions with these two operators. Mutational analysis shows that SoxR uses different amino acid residues when binding to the sv operator versus the wx operator. Taken together, the results indicate that interaction between SoxR and the two operator sites involves different binding geometries. This makes SoxR the only known example of a ArsR-family protein that binds differentially to different operators.     

Biochemical and genetic analysis of operator contacts made by residues within the beta-sheet DNA binding motif of Mnt repressor.

Residues 2, 6, 8 and 10 of Mnt repressor are the major determinants of operator DNA binding and recognition. Here, we investigate the interaction of wild-type Mnt and mutants bearing the Arg2----Lys, His6----Ala, Asn8----Ala and Arg10----Lys mutations with operator DNA modified by methylation or by symmetric base substitutions. The wild-type pattern of methylation interference is altered in specific ways for each of the mutant proteins. In addition, some of the mutant proteins show a 'loss of contact' phenotype with specific mutant operators. Taken together, these and previous results predict the following contacts between side chains in the Mnt tetramer and operator DNA: Arg2 recognizes the guanines at operator positions 10 and 12; His6 contacts the guanines at operator positions 5 and 17; Asn8 contacts operator positions 4, 7, 15 and 18; Arg10 contacts the guanines at operator positions 8 and 14. The proposed contacts can be accommodated in a structural model in which the anti-parallel beta-sheet motifs of Mnt dimers lie in the major grooves of each operator half-site, centered over pseudo-symmetry axes that are 5.5 bp from the central dyad axis of the operator.     

In vitro binding of LexA repressor to DNA: evidence for the involvement of the amino-terminal domain.

Both the amino-terminal and the carboxy-terminal domain of the LexA repressor have been purified using the LexA protein autodigestion reaction at alkaline pH, which leads to the same specific products as the physiological RecA-catalyzed proteolysis of repressor. We show by circular dichroism (c.d) that, upon non-specific binding to DNA, the purified amino-terminal domain induces a very similar if not identical conformational change of the DNA as does the entire repressor. The positive c.d. signal increases approximately 3-fold if the DNA lattice is fully saturated with protein. Further, the amino-terminal domain of the LexA protein binds specifically to the operator of the recA gene, producing qualitatively the same effects on the methylation pattern of the guanine bases by dimethylsulfate as the entire repressor, consisting of a methylation inhibition effect at four distal operator guanines and a slight enhancement at the central bases. The spacing between these contacts suggests that LexA does not bind to the operator along the same face of the DNA helix. As shown by c.d. studies the amino-terminal domain harbours a substantial amount of residues in alpha-helical conformation, a prerequisite for DNA recognition via a helix--turn--helix structural motif as proposed for many other regulatory proteins.     

Human UP1 as a model for understanding purine recognition in the family of proteins containing the RNA recognition motif (RRM)

Heterogeneous ribonucleoprotein A1 (hnRNP A1) is a prototype for the family of eukaryotic RNA processing proteins containing the common RNA recognition motif (RRM). The region consisting of residues 1-195 of hnRNP A1 is referred to as UP1. This region has two RRMs and has a high affinity for both single-stranded RNA and the human telomeric repeat sequence d(TTAGGG)(n). We have used UP1's novel DNA binding to investigate how RRMs bind nucleic acid bases through their highly conserved RNP consensus sequences. Nine complexes of UP1 bound to modified telomeric repeats were investigated using equilibrium fluorescence binding and X-ray crystallography. In two of the complexes, alteration of a guanine to either 2-aminopurine or nebularine resulted in an increase in K(d) from 88nM to 209nM and 316nM, respectively. The loss of these orienting interactions between UP1 and the substituted base allows it to flip between syn and anti conformations. Substitution of the same base with 7-deaza-guanine preserves the O6/N1 contacts but still increases the K(d) to 296nM and suggests that it is not simply the loss of affinity that gives rise to the base mobility, but also the stereochemistry of the specific contact to O6. Although these studies provide details of UP1 interactions to nucleic acids, three general observations about RRMs are also evident: (1) as suggested by informatic studies, main-chain to base hydrogen bonding makes up an important aspect of ligand recognition (2) steric clashes generated by modification of a hydrogen bond donor-acceptor pair to a donor-donor pair are poorly tolerated and (3) a conserved lysine position proximal to RNP-2 (K(106)-IFVGGI) orients the purine to allow stereochemical discrimination between adenine and guanine based on the 6-position. This single interaction is well-conserved in known RRM structures and appears to be a broad indicator for purine preference in the larger family of RRM proteins.     

Improved model of a LexA repressor dimer bound to recA operator

A complete three dimensional model for the LexA repressor dimer bound to the recA operator site consistent with relevant biochemical and biophysical data for the repressor was proposed from our laboratory when no crystal structure of LexA was available. Subsequently, the crystal structures of four LexA mutants Delta(1-67) S119A, S119A, G85D and Delta(1-67) quadruple mutant in the absence of operator were reported. It is examined in this paper to what extent our previous model was correct and how, using the crystal structure of the operator-free LexA dimer we can predict an improved model of LexA dimer bound to recA operator. In our improved model, the C-domain dimerization observed repeatedly in the mutant operator-free crystals is retained but the relative orientation between the two domains within a LexA molecule changes. The crystal structure of wild type LexA with or without the recA operator cannot be solved as it autocleaves itself. We argue that the 'cleavable' cleavage site region found in the crystal structures is actually the more relevant form of the region in wild-type LexA since it agrees with the value of the pre-exponential Arrhenius factor for its autocleavage, absence of various types of trans-cleavages, difficulty in modifying the catalytic serine by diisopropyl flourophosphate and lack of cleavage at Arg 81 by trypsin; hence the concept of a 'conformational switch' inferred from the crystal structures is meaningless.     

Intradomain LexA rotation is a prerequisite for DNA binding specificity

In the absence of DNA damage the LexA protein represses the bacterial SOS system. We performed molecular dynamic simulations of two LexA dimers bound to operators. Our model predicted that rotation of the LexA DNA binding domain, with respect to the dimerised C-terminal domain, is required for selective DNA binding. To confirm the model, double and quadruple cysteine LexA mutants were engineered. Electrophoretic mobility-shift assay and surface plasmon resonance showed that disulfide bond formation between the introduced cysteine residues precluded LexA specific DNA binding due to blocked domain reorientation. Our model could provide the basis for novel drug design.