The RNA origin of transfer RNA aminoacylation and beyond

Aminoacylation of tRNA is an essential event in the translation system. Although in the modern system protein enzymes play the sole role in tRNA aminoacylation, in the primitive translation system RNA molecules could have catalysed aminoacylation onto tRNA or tRNA-like molecules. Even though such RNA enzymes so far are not identified from known organisms, in vitro selection has generated such RNA catalysts from a pool of random RNA sequences. Among them, a set of RNA sequences, referred to as flexizymes (Fxs), discovered in our laboratory are able to charge amino acids onto tRNAs. Significantly, Fxs allow us to charge a wide variety of amino acids, including those that are non-proteinogenic, onto tRNAs bearing any desired anticodons, and thus enable us to reprogramme the genetic code at our will. This article summarizes the evolutionary history of Fxs and also the most recent advances in manipulating a translation system by integration with Fxs.     

Multiple incorporation of non-natural amino acids into a single protein using tRNAs with non-standard structures

The ability to introduce non-natural amino acids into proteins opens up new vistas for the study of protein structure and function. This approach requires suppressor tRNAs that deliver the non-natural amino acid to a ribosome associated with an mRNA containing an expanded codon. The suppressor tRNAs must be absolutely protected from aminoacylation by any of the aminoacyl-tRNA synthetases in the protein synthesizing system, or a natural amino acid will be incorporated instead of the non-natural amino acid. Here, we found that some tRNAs with non-standard structures could work as efficient four-base suppressors fulfilling the above orthogonal conditions. Using these tRNAs, we successfully demonstrated incorporation of three different non-natural amino acids into a single protein.     

A tRNA aminoacylation system for non-natural amino acids based on a programmable ribozyme

The ability to recognize tRNA identities is essential to the function of the genetic coding system. In translation aminoacyl-tRNA synthetases (ARSs) recognize the identities of tRNAs and charge them with their cognate amino acids. We show that an in vitro evolved ribozyme can also discriminate between specific tRNAs, and can transfer amino acids to the 3' ends of cognate tRNAs. The ribozyme interacts with both the CCA-3' terminus and the anticodon loop of tRNA(fMet), and its tRNA specificity is controlled by these interactions. This feature allows us to program the selectivity of the ribozyme toward specific tRNAs, and therefore to tailor effective aminoacyl-transfer catalysts. This method potentially provides a means of generating aminoacyl tRNAs that are charged with non-natural amino acids, which could be incorporated into proteins through cell-free translation.     

Four-base codon/anticodon strategy and non-enzymatic aminoacylation for protein engineering with non-natural amino acids

Techniques for position-specific incorporation of non-natural amino acids in an in vitro protein synthesizing system are described. First, a PNA-assisted non-enzymatic tRNA aminoacylation with a variety of natural and non-natural amino acids is described. With this technique, one can aminoacylate a specific tRNA simply by adding a preformed amino acid activated ester-PNA conjugate into an in vitro protein biosynthesizing system. Second, the genetic code is expanded by introducing 4-base codons that can be exclusively translated to non-natural amino acids. The most advantageous point of the 4-base codon strategy is to introduce multiple amino acids into specific positions in single proteins by using mutually orthogonal 4-base codons and orthogonal tRNAs. An easy and quick method for preparation of tRNAs possessing 4-base anticodons is also described. Combination of the non-enzymatic aminoacylation and the 4-base codon/anticodon strategy gives an easy and widely applicable technique for incorporating a variety of non-natural amino acids into proteins in vitro.     

In vitro selection of tRNAs for efficient four-base decoding to incorporate non-natural amino acids into proteins in an Escherichia coli cell-free translation system

Position-specific incorporation of non-natural amino acids into proteins is a useful technique in protein engineering. In this study, we established a novel selection system to obtain tRNAs that show high decoding activity, from a tRNA library in a cell-free translation system to improve the efficiency of incorporation of non-natural amino acids into proteins. In this system, a puromycin-tRNA conjugate, in which the 3'-terminal A unit was replaced by puromycin, was used. The puromycin-tRNA conjugate was fused to a C-terminus of streptavidin through the puromycin moiety in the ribosome. The streptavidin-puromycin-tRNA fusion molecule was collected and brought to the next round after amplification of the tRNA sequence. We applied this system to select efficient frameshift suppressor tRNAs from a tRNA library with a randomly mutated anticodon loop derived from yeast tRNA CCCG Phe. After three rounds of the selection, we obtained novel frameshift suppressor tRNAs which had high decoding activity and good orthogonality against endogenous aminoacyl-tRNA synthetases. These results demonstrate that the in vitro selection system developed here is useful to obtain highly active tRNAs for the incorporation of non-natural amino acid from a tRNA library.     

Exploring the specificity of bacterial elongation factor Tu for different tRNAs

In order to identify amino acids in Thermus thermophilus elongation factor Tu which contribute to its specificity for different tRNAs, the binding affinities of 20 point mutations were compared to that of wild type protein using four tRNAs of differing affinities. The observed specificity for tRNA is the result of the varying contributions of five amino acids which make contacts with the T-stem and the 3' terminus of tRNA. For three of the amino acids the test tRNAs differ in sequence at the site of contact, presumably explaining the specificity. However, the remaining two amino acids contact tRNA at conserved positions, suggesting that more global structural or dynamic properties of the free tRNA contribute to specificity.     

Extension of biochemical functions by the introduction of nonnatural amino acids and artificial nucleic acid analogs.

Extension of biochemical functions has been attempted by introducing nonatural amino acids and artificial nucleic acid analogs. Nonnatural amino acids have been linked to tRNAs and the amino-acylated tRNAs were added to E. coli in vitro protein synthesizing system to produce nonnatural mutant proteins. The positions of the nonnatural amino acids have been assigned by the 4-base codons, like CGGG and AGGU. The extended codons have been introduced at a specific position or at random positions on a DNA. In the latter case, a DNA library that contains a single 4-base codon at random positions can be obtained. The combination of these new techniques opens a way to the introduction of artificial functions to biochemical systems.     

tRNA-mediated protein engineering

Novel methods of incorporating non-native amino acids and stable isotope labels into proteins using modified tRNAs present new opportunities for basic research and biotechnology that go beyond conventional site-directed mutagenesis. tRNA-mediated protein engineering relies on the development of novel tRNAs and their misacylation with custom-designed amino acids, the recognition of special codons by the tRNAs, and the efficient expression of these modified proteins. Recent progress has been made in all these areas, including the development of more effective suppresor tRNAs and higher yield translation systems, leading to a variety of novel applications.     

ACTIVITY OF AMINOACYL-TRANSFER RNA SYNTHETASES IN BRAIN MITOCHONDRIA 1

Abstract— The binding capacity for amino acids of low molecular wt. RNAs isolated from mitochondrial and cytoplasmic fractions from brain was studied in the presence of partially purified aminoacyl-tRNA synthetases obtained from both subcellular fractions. The ability of mitochondrial tRNAs to bind amino acids was greater by about three times in the presence of mitochondrial aminoacyl-tRNA synthetases than in the presence of cytoplasmic enzymes. In contrast, the amino acid-binding ability of cytoplasmic tRNA was the same in the presence of mitochondrial enzymes as in the presence of those from the cytoplasm. When homologous (rabbit) and heterologous (calf) tRNAs were tested in the presence of mitochondrial or cytoplasmic enzymes obtained from rabbit brain and a mixture of amino acids, a significant species specificity was seen: in both heterologous systems the highest amount of tRNA binding was only 44-66 per cent of that obtained with the homologous enzyme system.     

Percent Charging of Transfer Ribonucleic Acid and Levels of ppGpp and pppGpp in Dormant and Germinated Spores of Bacillus megaterium

The levels of transfer ribonucleic acids (tRNAs) specific for 14 amino acids were almost identical in dormant spores and in spores germinated from 6 to 75 min. Germinated spore tRNAs specific for all amino acids tested were between 63 and 93% charged, and there was no significant change in this value from 6 to 75 min of germination. In contrast, tRNAs isolated from dormant spores specific for nine different amino acids were almost completely(>93%) uncharged. However, some dormant spore tRNAs, i.e., those for arginine, histidine, isoleucine, and valine, showed significant (21 to 72%) levels of aminoacylation. Dormant spores contained no detectable guanosine penta- (pppGpp), tetra- (ppGpp), or triphosphate (GTP). However, these nucleotides appeared in the first minutes of germination, and thereafter all increased in parallel with a ratio of pppGpp plus ppGpp to GTP of 0.07 to 0.11, which is characteristic of unstarved vegetative cells.     

Adaptation of the tRNA population of maize endosperm for zein synthesis.

Maize endosperm, 30 days after pollination is actively synthesizing zein, a storage protein containing high amounts of glutamine. leucine and alanine. Endosperm tRNAs have a higher accepting activity than embryo tRNAs for these three amino acids, but not for some other (control) amino acids. This increase in accepting activity is accompanied by a change in the distribution of the isoaccepting tRNA species corresponding to these three amino acids, but not of the isoacceptors corresponding to some other (control) amino acids. These results are in favor of the theory of functional adaptation of tRNA population.     

Aminoacylation of transfer RNAs with one and two amino acids

The detailed synthesis of (bis)aminoacyl-pdCpAs and the corresponding singly and tandemly activated tRNAs is reported. The synthetic pathway leading to these compounds has been validated for simple amino acid residues as well as for amino acids bearing more complex side chains. Protection/deprotection strategies are described. For the bisaminoacylated tRNAs, both the synthesis of tRNAs bearing the same amino acid residue at the 2' and 3' positions and tRNAs bearing two different aminoacyl moieties are reported. Further, it is shown that the tandemly activated tRNAs are able to participate in protein synthesis.     

Studying the evolutionary relationships and phylogenetic trees of 21 groups of tRNA sequences based on complex networks

To find out the evolutionary relationships among different tRNA sequences of 21 amino acids, 22 networks are constructed. One is constructed from whole tRNAs, and the other 21 networks are constructed from the tRNAs which carry the same amino acids. A new method is proposed such that the alignment scores of any two amino acids groups are determined by the average degree and the average clustering coefficient of their networks. The anticodon feature of isolated tRNA and the phylogenetic trees of 21 group networks are discussed. We find that some isolated tRNA sequences in 21 networks still connect with other tRNAs outside their group, which reflects the fact that those tRNAs might evolve by intercrossing among these 21 groups. We also find that most anticodons among the same cluster are only one base different in the same sites when S ≥ 70, and they stay in the same rank in the ladder of evolutionary relationships. Those observations seem to agree on that some tRNAs might mutate from the same ancestor sequences based on point mutation mechanisms.     

Evolution of transfer RNA

Evolution by gene duplication and subsequent divergence is indicated by similarities common to 43 different transfer RNAs. Pairwise comparisons of these tRNAs reveal additional similarity, greatest for certain pairs of tRNAs for the same amino acid in the same organism, and also occurring in certain pairs of tRNAs for different amino acids in the same organism. Although tRNAs functionally interact with several other molecules, there have been surprisingly few restrictions on the divergence of their primary structures. This divergence has proceeded so far that clear phylogenetic separations are absent in most cases: it it impossible to construct a coherent phylogeny for most of the 43. Selection and stochastic processes have both been active in the evolution of tRNA. Selection has favored moderate change more than expected and has reduced radical change below that expected from stochastic processes alone. Two obvious effects of selection are nine invariant loci, another five that are always purines and five others that are always pyrimidines, in the tRNAs involved in protein synthesis. In addition to these constraints in the primary nucleotide sequence, the method of “identical site equivalents”, introduced here, demonstrates that further constraints exist equivalent to about 12 additional invariant loci. These “invisible” restraints reflect disperse chemical forces maintaining the tertiary structure and reducing evolutionary divergence to an extent quantitatively comparable to that of the nine observable invariant loci. The average divergence (49·4%) for pairs of tRNAs for different amino acids involved in protein synthesis represents an equilibrium between natural selection and stochastic processes. These tRNAs have had time to diverge nearly to the 75% maximum expected from stochastic process alone; this is shown by comparing the two glycine tRNAs involved in peptidoglycan synthesis with tRNAs for different amino acids participating in polypeptide synthesis. The rates of nucleotide replacements in genes coding for the tRNAs and the cytochromes c are about the same: 2 × 10 ^?10 replacements per nucleotide site per year.     

Adjustment of the tRNA population to the codon usage in chloroplasts.

In chloroplasts there is a correlation between the amounts of tRNAs specific for a given amino acid and the codons specifying this amino acid. Furthermore, for the amino acids coded for by more than one codon, the population of isoaccepting tRNAs is adjusted to the frequency of synonymous codons used in chloroplast protein genes. A comparison by two-dimensional gel electrophoresis of the tRNA populations extracted from chloroplasts and from chloroplast polysomes shows that all chloroplast tRNAs are involved in protein biosynthesis.     

Control of cell-free protein synthesis by amino acids: effects on tRNA charging

In order to resolve the observation that addition of glutamine and glutamate appears to be of particular importance in enhancing the activity of a cell-free protein synthesis system derived from rat liver (Manchester and Tyobeka, 1980), we have measured the KM of the aminoacyl-tRNA synthetases towards amino acids and the extent of aminoacylation of tRNA under the conditions of our earlier experiments. During incubation of the cell-free system in the presence of an amino acid mixture the extent of acylation to tRNA of 15 amino acids studied showed no clear change from initial time values. When incubation took place in the absence of added amino acids, however, the levels of glutamate and glutamine bound to their appropriate tRNAs dropped more rapidly and to lower levels than for other amino acids except tryptophan. The pronounced drop for these two amino acids does not seem to result from an abnormally high KM value for the synthetases towards the respective amino acids, nor an abnormally low Vmax, but probably from the fact that the amounts of glutamyl and glutaminyl-tRNA in the cell-free system are comparatively low.     

Introduction of specialty functions by the position-specific incorporation of nonnatural amino acids into proteins through four-base codon/anticodon pairs

Position-specific incorporation of nonnatural amino acids into proteins (nonnatural mutagenesis) via an in vitro protein synthesizing system was applied to incorporate a variety of amino acids carrying specialty side groups. A list of nonnatural amino acids thus far successfully incorporated through in vitro translation systems is presented. The position of nonnatural amino acid incorporation was directed by four-base codon/anticodon pairs such as CGGG/CCCG and AGGU/ACCU. The four-base codon strategy was more efficient than the amber codon strategy and could incorporate multiple nonnatural amino acids into single proteins. This multiple mutagenesis will find wide applications, especially in building paths of electron transfer on proteins. The extension of translation systems by the introduction of nonnatural amino acids, four-base codon/anticodon pairs, orthogonal tRNAs, and artificial aminoacyl tRNA synthetases, is a promising approach towards the creation of "synthetic microorganisms" with specialty functions.