MyoD(-/-) satellite cells in single-fiber culture are differentiation defective and MRF4 deficient

MyoD-deficient mice are without obvious deleterious muscle phenotype during embryogenesis and fetal development, and adults in the laboratory have grossly normal skeletal muscle and life span. However, a previous study showed that in the context of muscle degeneration on a mdx (dystrophin null) genetic background, animals lacking MyoD have a greatly intensified disease phenotype leading to lethality not otherwise seen in mdx mice. Here we have examined MyoD(-/-) adult muscle fibers and their associated satellite cells in single myofiber cultures and describe major phenotypic differences found at the tissue, cellular, and molecular levels. The steady-state number of satellite cells on freshly isolated MyoD(-/-) fibers was elevated and abnormal branched fiber morphologies were observed, the latter suggesting chronic muscle regeneration in vivo. Single-cell RNA coexpression analyses were performed for c-met, m-cadherin, and the four myogenic regulatory factors (MRFs.) Most mutant satellite cells entered the cell cycle and upregulated expression of myf5, both characteristic early steps in satellite cell maturation. However, they later failed to normally upregulate MRF4, displayed a major deficit in m-cadherin expression, and showed a significant diminution in myogenin-positive status compared with wildtype. MyoD(-/-) satellite cells formed unusual aggregate structures, failed to fuse efficiently, and showed greater than 90% reduction in differentiation efficiency relative to wildtype. A further survey of RNAs encoding regulators of growth and differentiation, cell cycle progression, and cell signaling revealed similar or identical expression profiles for most genes as well as several noteworthy differences. Among these, GDF8 and Msx1 were identified as potentially important regulators of the quiescent state whose expression profile differs between mutant and wildtype. Considered together, these data suggest that activated MyoD(-/-) satellite cells assume a phenotype that resembles in some ways a developmentally "stalled" cell compared to wildtype. However, the MyoD(-/-) cells are not merely developmentally immature, as they also display novel molecular and cellular characteristics that differ from any observed in wild-type muscle precursor counterparts of any stage.     

Differentiation of activated satellite cells in denervated muscle following single fusions in situ and in cell culture

Satellite cells represent a cellular source of regeneration in adult skeletal muscle. It remains unclear why a large pool of stem myoblasts in denervated muscle does not compensate for the loss of muscle mass during post-denervation atrophy. In this study, we present evidence that satellite cells in long-term denervated rat muscle are able to activate synthesis of contractile proteins after single fusions in situ. This process of early differentiation leads to formation of abnormally diminutive myotubes. The localization of such dwarf myotubes beneath the intact basal lamina on the surface of differentiated muscle fibers shows that they form by fusion of neighboring satellites or by the progeny of a single satellite cell following one or two mitotic divisions. We demonstrated single fusions of myoblasts using electron microscopy, immunocytochemical labeling and high resolution confocal digital imaging. Sequestration of nascent myotubes by the rapidly forming basal laminae creates a barrier that limits further fusions. The recruitment of satellite cells in the formation of new muscle fibers results in a progressive decrease in their local densities, spatial separation and ultimate exhaustion of the myogenic cell pool. To determine whether the accumulation of aberrant dwarf myotubes is explained by the intrinsic decline of myogenic properties of satellite cells, or depends on their spatial separation and the environment in the tissue, we studied the fusion of myoblasts isolated from normal and denervated muscle in cell culture. The experiments with a culture system demonstrated that the capacity of myoblasts to synthesize contractile proteins without serial fusions depended on cell density and the availability of partners for fusion. Satellite cells isolated from denervated muscle and plated at fusion-permissive densities progressed through the myogenic program and actively formed myotubes, which shows that their myogenic potential is not considerably impaired. The results of this study suggest that under conditions of denervation, progressive spatial separation and confinement of many satellite cells within the endomysial tubes of atrophic muscle fibers and progressive interstitial fibrosis are the important factors that prevent their normal differentiation. Our findings also provide an explanation of why denervated muscle partially and temporarily is able to restore its functional capacity following injury and regeneration: the release of satellite cells from their sublaminal location provides the necessary space for a more active regenerative process.     

Brain-derived Neurotrophic Factor Regulates Satellite Cell Differentiation and Skeltal Muscle Regeneration

In adult skeletal muscle, brain-derived neurotrophic factor (BDNF) is expressed in myogenic progenitors known as satellite cells. To functionally address the role of BDNF in muscle satellite cells and regeneration in vivo, we generated a mouse in which BDNF is specifically depleted from skeletal muscle cells. For comparative purposes, and to determine the specific role of muscle-derived BDNF, we also examined muscles of the complete BDNF^−/− mouse. In both models, expression of the satellite cell marker Pax7 was significantly decreased. Furthermore, proliferation and differentiation of primary myoblasts was abnormal, exhibiting delayed induction of several markers of differentiation as well as decreased myotube size. Treatment with exogenous BDNF protein was sufficient to rescue normal gene expression and myotube size. Because satellite cells are responsible for postnatal growth and repair of skeletal muscle, we next examined whether regenerative capacity was compromised. After injury, BDNF-depleted muscle showed delayed expression of several molecular markers of regeneration, as well as delayed appearance of newly regenerated fibers. Recovery of wild-type BDNF levels was sufficient to restore normal regeneration. Together, these findings suggest that BDNF plays an important role in regulating satellite cell function and regeneration in vivo, particularly during early stages.     

Influence of icing on muscle regeneration after crush injury to skeletal muscles in rats

The influence of icing on muscle regeneration after crush injury was examined in the rat extensor digitorum longus. After the injury, animals were randomly divided into nonicing and icing groups. In the latter, ice packs were applied for 20 min. Due to the icing, degeneration of the necrotic muscle fibers and differentiation of satellite cells at early stages of regeneration were retarded by ～1 day. In the icing group, the ratio of regenerating fibers showing central nucleus at 14 days after the injury was higher, and cross-sectional area of the muscle fibers at 28 days was evidently smaller than in the nonicing group. Besides, the ratio of collagen fibers area at 14 and 28 days after the injury in the icing group was higher than in the nonicing group. These findings suggest that icing applied soon after the injury not only considerably retarded muscle regeneration but also induced impairment of muscle regeneration along with excessive collagen deposition. Macrophages were immunohistochemically demonstrated at the injury site during degeneration and early stages of regeneration. Due to icing, chronological changes in the number of macrophages and immunohistochemical expression of transforming growth factor (TGF)-β1 and IGF-I were also retarded by 1 to 2 days. Since it has been said that macrophages play important roles not only for degeneration, but also for muscle regeneration, the influence of icing on macrophage activities might be closely related to a delay in muscle regeneration, impairment of muscle regeneration, and redundant collagen synthesis.     

Dysfunctional autophagy is a driver of muscle stem cell functional decline with aging

Regeneration of skeletal muscle relies on its resident stem cells, also known as satellite cells, which are normally quiescent. With aging, satellite cell quiescence is lost concomitant with a muscle regenerative decline. Here we demonstrate that autophagy sustains quiescence over time and that its failure with age drives senescence, which accounts for stem cell loss of function. Pharmacological and genetic reestablishment of autophagy restores homeostasis and regenerative functions in geriatric satellite cells, which has relevance for the elderly population.     

Alterations in sarcomere structure, collagen organization, mitochondrial activity, and protein metabolism in the avian low score normal muscle weakness

Skeletal muscle fibers are surrounded by an extracellular matrix. The extracellular matrix is composed of glycoproteins, collagen, and proteoglycans. Proteoglycans have been suggested to play an important functional role in tissue differentiation. However, an understanding of how the extracellular matrix affects skeletal muscle development and function is largely unknown. In the avian genetic muscle weakness, low score normal (LSN), a late embryonic increase in the expression of decorin is followed by a subsequent increase in collagen crosslinking. The sarcomere organization, collagen fibril diameter and organization were investigated using transmission electron microscopy. Measurements were made at 20 days of embryonic development and 6 weeks posthatch. These studies showed changes in sarcomere organization and deterioration of muscle fibril structure in the LSN pectoral muscle. In vitro satellite cell cultures were developed and assayed for mitochondrial activity, and protein synthesis and degradation. In these analyses, mitochondrial activity from LSN satellite cells was significantly higher than those from normal pectoral muscle satellite cells. Protein synthesis rates between the normal and LSN satellite cell-derived myotubes were similar, but protein degradation rates were higher in the LSN cultures. Based on the reported functions of decorin as a regulator of cell proliferation and collagen fibril organization, it is possible that the late embryonic increase in decorin may be influencing the alterations in LSN sarcomere and collagen organization.     

Survival of satellite cells following exposure to the local anesthetic bupivacaine (Marcaine)

Summary Rat lumbrical muscles were incubated in a concentration of 10^-2 M bupivacaine for 5 or 15 min and examined after further incubation in the absence of the drug for periods totalling 1, 2, and 3h. Electron microscopy showed that muscle fibers and their component organelles and myonuclei underwent a series of irreversible degenerative changes. However, satellite cells retained their normal morphology under similar conditions. It is concluded that satellite cells are responsible for the rapid regeneration of muscles that follows degeneration induced by bupivacaine. The role of satellite cells in muscle regeneration is discussed.This investigation was supported by United States Public Health Service Research Grant NS 13296 from the National Institutes of Health. A supply of bupivacaine was kindly made available by Winthrop Laboratories, New York, N.Y., USA     

Implication of the satellite cell in dystrophic muscle fibrosis: a self-perpetuating mechanism of collagen overproduction

Because of its mechanical function, skeletal muscle is heavily influenced by the composition of its extracellular matrix (ECM). Fibrosis generated by chronic damage, such as occurs in muscular dystrophies, is thus particularly disastrous in this tissue. Here, we examined the interrelationship between the muscle satellite cell and the production of collagen type I, a major component of fibrotic ECM, by using both C2C12, a satellite cell-derived cell line, and primary muscle satellite cells. In C2C12 cells, we found that expression of collagen type I mRNA decreases substantially during skeletal muscle differentiation. On a single-cell level, collagen type I and myogenin became mutually exclusive after 3 days in differentiation medium, whereas addition of collagen markedly suppressed differentiation of C2C12 cells. Primary cultures of satellite cells associated with isolated single fibers of the young (4 wk old) mdx dystrophic mouse and of C57BL/10ScSn wild-type controls expressed collagen type I and type III mRNA and protein. This pattern persisted in wild-type mice at all ages. But, curiously, in older (18-mo-old) mdx mice, although the myogenic cells continued to express type III collagen, type I expression became restricted to nonmyogenic cells. These cells typically constituted part of a cellular sheet surrounding the old mdx fibers. This combination of features strongly suggests that the progression to fibrosis in dystrophic muscle involves changes in the mechanisms controlling matrix production, which generates positive feedback that results in a reprogramming of myoblasts to a profibrotic function. collagen type I; myogenin; muscle single fibers; Duchenne muscular dystrophy     

Differentiation rather than aging of muscle stem cells abolishes their telomerase activity

A general feature of stem cells is the ability to routinely proliferate to build, maintain, and repair organ systems. Accordingly, embryonic and germline, as well as some adult stem cells, produce the telomerase enzyme at various levels of expression. Our results show that, while muscle is a largely postmitotic tissue, the muscle stem cells (satellite cells) that maintain this biological system throughout adult life do indeed display robust telomerase activity. Conversely, primary myoblasts (the immediate progeny of satellite cells) quickly and dramatically downregulate telomerase activity. This work thus suggests that satellite cells, and early transient myoblasts, may be more promising therapeutic candidates for regenerative medicine than traditionally utilized myoblast cultures. Muscle atrophy accompanies human aging, and satellite cells endogenous to aged muscle can be triggered to regenerate old tissue by exogenous molecular cues. Therefore, we also examined whether these aged muscle stem cells would produce tissue that is “young” with respect to telomere maintenance. Interestingly, this work shows that the telomerase activity in muscle stem cells is largely retained into old age wintin inbred “long” telomere mice and in wild‐derived short telomere mouse strains, and that age‐specific telomere shortening is undetectable in the old differentiated muscle fibers of either strain. Summarily, this work establishes that young and old muscle stem cells, but not necessarily their progeny, myoblasts, are likely to produce tissue with normal telomere maintenance when used in molecular and regenerative medicine approaches for tissue repair. © 2009 American Institute of Chemical Engineers Biotechnol. Prog., 2009     

Growth and metamorphosis of the rectus abdominis muscle in Rana pipiens

Cross sections through the middle segment of the anuran rectus abdominis muscle were analyzed morphometrically at nine stages of development, from early larval life through full maturity. The numbers, sizes, and relative distributions of twitch and slow muscle fibers, newly differentiated fibers, degenerating fibers, and satellite cells were determined at each stage. The data indicate that the muscle increases slowly in size and fiber content during early larval life. New fibers appear to form primarily along the medial margin of the muscle. During mid-larval stages, when thyroid hormone levels are rising, new fibers form throughout the medial portion of the muscle. At a slightly later stage, fibers in the lateral region of the muscle begin to degenerate. Structurally normal presynaptic elements are present on both degenerating fibers and the empty basal laminae of fibers that had been removed by phagocytes. Both fiber formation and fiber loss slow during midmetamorphic climax, at the time when thyroid hormone levels reach a peak in anurans and begin to decline. Degenerating fibers appear within the body of the muscle at the end of metamorphosis. By the end of the second postmetamorphic month, neither degenerating nor newly differentiated fibers are present. The muscle continues to grow through adult life primarily by fiber hypertrophy.     

A cell-autonomous defect in skeletal muscle satellite cells expressing low levels of survival of motor neuron protein

Mutations in the Survival of Motor Neuron (SMN) gene underlie the development of spinal muscular atrophy (SMA), which currently represents the leading genetic cause of mortality in infants and toddlers. SMA is characterized by degeneration of spinal cord motor neurons and muscle atrophy. Although SMA is often considered to be a motor neuron disease, accumulating evidence suggests that muscle cells themselves may be affected by low levels of SMN. Here, we examine satellite cells, tissue-resident stem cells that play an essential role in the growth and repair of skeletal muscle, isolated from a severe SMA mouse model (Smn(-/-); SMN2(+/+)). We found similar numbers of satellite cells in the muscles of SMA and wild-type (Smn(+/+); SMN2(+/+)) mice at postnatal day 2 (P2), and, when isolated from skeletal muscle using cell surface marker expression, these cells showed comparable survival and proliferative potential. However, SMA satellite cells differentiate abnormally, revealed by the premature expression of muscle differentiation markers, and, especially, by a reduced efficiency in forming myotubes. These phenotypes suggest a critical role of SMN protein in the intrinsic regulation of muscle differentiation and suggest that abnormal muscle development contributes to the manifestation of SMA symptoms.     

Variability in the shapes of satellite cells in normal and injured frog sartorius muscle

Surface topography of satellite cells is examined in the scanning electron microscope after application of a new method to eliminate connective tissue components. We describe the overall shape of satellite cells in normal frog muscle and show the range of variation in normal structure. Small increases in the width of tails and changes in the cell outline occur after muscle injury in vivo and after incubation in vitro. These changes may be signs of early mobilization of satellite cells related to their eventual role in muscle regeneration.     

Frequency of M-cadherin-stained satellite cells declines in human muscles during aging.

To answer the question of whether the satellite cell pool in human muscle is reduced during aging, we detected satellite cells in 30- microm-thick transverse sections under the confocal microscope by binding of M-cadherin antibody. The basal lamina was detected with laminin. Nuclei were stained with bisbenzimide or propidium iodide. Satellite cells were counted by applying the disector method and unbiased sampling design. To determine if there are age-related differences in muscle fiber types, morphometric characteristics of muscle fibers were examined on thin sections stained for myofibrillar ATPase. Autopsy samples of vastus lateralis muscle from six young (28.7 +/- 2.3 years) and six old (70.8 +/- 1.3 years) persons who had suffered sudden death were analyzed. Numbers of satellite cells per fiber length (Nsc/Lfib) and number of satellite cells per total number of nuclei (satellite cell nuclei + myonuclei) (Nsc/Nnucl) were significantly lower in the old group (p < 0.05). We demonstrate the importance of proper sampling and counting in estimation of sparsely distributed structures such as satellite cells. Our results support the hypothesis that the satellite cell fraction declines during aging.     

Age‐related changes in miR‐143‐3p:Igfbp5 interactions affect muscle regeneration

A common characteristic of aging is defective regeneration of skeletal muscle. The molecular pathways underlying age‐related decline in muscle regenerative potential remain elusive. microRNAs are novel gene regulators controlling development and homeostasis and the regeneration of most tissues, including skeletal muscle. Here, we use satellite cells and primary myoblasts from mice and humans and an in vitro regeneration model, to show that disrupted expression of microRNA‐143‐3p and its target gene, Igfbp5, plays an important role in muscle regeneration in vitro. We identified miR‐143 as a regulator of the insulin growth factor‐binding protein 5 (Igfbp5) in primary myoblasts and show that the expression of miR‐143 and its target gene is disrupted in satellite cells from old mice. Moreover, we show that downregulation of miR‐143 during aging may act as a compensatory mechanism aiming at improving myogenesis efficiency; however, concomitant upregulation of miR‐143 target gene, Igfbp5, is associated with increased cell senescence, thus affecting myogenesis. Our data demonstrate that dysregulation of miR‐143‐3p:Igfbp5 interactions in satellite cells with age may be responsible for age‐related changes in satellite cell function.     

Skeletal muscle satellite cell diversity: satellite cells form fibers of different types in cell culture

Following skeletal muscle injury, new fibers form from resident satellite cells which reestablish the fiber composition of the original muscle. We have used a cell culture system to analyze satellite cells isolated from adult chicken and quail pectoralis major (PM; a fast muscle) and anterior latissimus dorsi (ALD; a slow muscle) to determine if satellite cells isolated from fast or slow muscles produce one or several types of fibers when they form new fibers in vitro in the absence of innervation or a specific extracellular milieu. The types of fibers formed in satellite cell cultures were determined using immunoblotting and immunocytochemistry with monoclonal antibodies specific for avian fast and slow myosin heavy chain (MHC) isoforms. We found that satellite cells were of different types and that fast and slow muscles differed in the percentage of each type they contained. Primary satellite cells isolated from the PM formed only fast fibers, while up to 25% of those isolated from ALD formed fibers that were both fast and slow (fast/slow fibers), the remainder being fast only. Fast/slow fibers formed from chicken satellite cells expressed slow MHC1, while slow MHC2 predominated in fast/slow fibers formed from quail satellite cells. Prolonged primary culture did not alter the relative proportions of fast to fast/slow fibers in high density cultures of either chicken or quail satellite cells. No change in commitment was observed in fibers formed from chicken satellite cell progeny repeatedly subcultured at high density, while fibers formed from subcultured quail satellite cell progeny demonstrated increasing commitment to fast/slow fiber type formation. Quail satellite cells cloned from high density cultures formed colonies that demonstrated a similar change in commitment from fast to fast/slow, as did serially subcloned individual satellite cell progeny, indicating that the observed change from fast to fast/slow differentiation resulted from intrinsic changes within a satellite cell. Thus satellite cells freshly isolated from adult chicken and quail are committed to form fibers of at least two types, satellite cells of these two types are found in different proportions in fast and slow muscles, and repeated cell proliferation of quail satellite cell progeny may alter satellite cell progeny to increasingly form fibers of a single type.     

Single-fiber isolation and maintenance of satellite cell quiescence.

The activity of satellite cells during myogenesis, development, or skeletal muscle regeneration is strongly modelled using cultures of single muscle fibers. However, there are variations in reported features of gene or protein expression as examined with single-fiber cultures. Here, we examined the potential differences in activation of satellite cells on normal mouse muscle fibers produced during a standard isolation protocol, with or without agitation during collagenase digestion. Activation was detected in satellite cells on fibers after 24 and 48 h of culture in basal growth medium using immunodetection of the incorporation of bromodeoxyuridine (BrdU) into DNA and quantification of the number of BrdU-positive cells per fiber. After 24 and 48 h in culture under nonactivating conditions, the number of activated (BrdU+) satellite cells was greater on fibers that had received gentle agitation during collagenase digestion than on those that were subject to digestion without agitation during isolation. The findings are interpreted to mean that at least some of the variation among published reports may derive from the application of various methods of fiber isolation. The information should be useful for maintaining satellite cell quiescence during studies of the regulatory steps that lead to satellite cell activation.     

Satellite-cell pool size does matter: defining the myogenic potency of aging skeletal muscle

The deteriorating in vivo environment is thought to play a major role in reduced stem cell function with age. The capacity of stem cells to support tissue maintenance depends not only on their response to cues from the surrounding niche, but also on their abundance. Here, we investigate satellite cell (myogenic stem cell) pool size and its potential to participate in muscle maintenance through old age. The numbers and performance of mouse satellite cells have been analyzed using molecular markers that exclusively characterize quiescent satellite cells and their progeny as they transit through proliferation, differentiation and generation of reserve cells. The study establishes that abundance of resident satellite cells declines with age in myofibers from both fast- and slow-twitch muscles. Nevertheless, the inherent myogenic potential of satellite cells does not diminish with age. Furthermore, the aging satellite cell niche retains the capacity to support effective myogenesis upon enrichment of the mitogenic milieu with FGF. Altogether, satellite cell abundance, but not myogenic potential, deteriorates with age. This study suggests that the population of satellite cells that participate in myofiber maintenance during routine muscle utilization is not fully replenished throughout life.     

Myotube morphology, and expression and distribution of collagen type I during normal and low score normal avian satellite cell myogenesis

Myogenic satellite cells are essential for postnatal muscle growth and the regeneration of muscle in response to injury. An understanding of how the extracellular matrix affects satellite cell activity, and the temporal and spatial expression of extracellular matrix macromolecules is largely unknown. In the avian genetic muscle weakness, low score normal (LSN), satellite cell proliferation and differentiation rates are significantly lower than that observed in normal chicken satellite cells, which may be attributed to a late embryonic increase in the expression of decorin. Satellite cell-derived morphological properties, collagen type I expression, and the spatial distribution of collagen type I were investigated during normal and LSN satellite cell proliferation and differentiation. These studies showed a decrease in LSN myotube length and the number of nuclei per myotube. Collagen type I expression was similar between the LSN and normal satellite cell cultures during the course of proliferation and differentiation. However, the spatial distribution of collagen type I was altered in the LSN cultures 48 h after the initiation of fusion. The LSN cultures exhibited a premature extracellular distribution of collagen type I compared to the normal satellite cells.     

Muscle fiber structure in an aging long-lived seabird,the black-legged kittiwake (Rissa tridactyla)

Many long-lived animals do not appear to show classic signs of aging, perhaps because they show negligible senescence until dying from “catastrophic” mortality. Muscle senescence is seldom examined in wild animals, yet decline in muscle function is one of the first signs of aging in many lab animals and humans. Seabirds are an excellent study system for physiological implications of aging because they are long-lived animals that actively forage and reproduce in the wild. Here, we examined linkages between pectoralis muscle fiber structure and age in black-legged kittiwakes (Rissa tridactyla). Pectoralis muscle is the largest organ complex in birds, and responsible for flight and shivering. We obtained and fixed biopsies from wild black-legged kittiwakes of known age. We then measured muscle fiber diameter, myonuclear domain and capillaries per fiber area among birds of differing ages. All muscle parameters were independent of age. Number of nuclei per mm of fiber showed a positive correlation with muscle fiber cross-sectional area, and myonuclear domain increased with muscle fiber diameter. Thus, as muscle fibers increased in size, they may not have recruited satellite cells, increasing the protein turnover load per nuclei. We conclude that senescence in a long-lived bird with an active lifestyle, does not entail mammalian-like changes in muscle structure.