The effect of the length of direct repeats and the presence of palindromes on deletion between directly repeated DNA sequences in bacteriophage T7.

The frequency of genetic deletion between directly repeated DNA sequences in bacteriophage T7 was measured as a function of the length of the direct repeat. The non-essential ligase gene (gene 1.3) of bacteriophage T7 was interrupted with pieces of synthetic DNA bracketed by direct repeats of various lengths. Deletion of these 76 bp long inserts was too low to be measured when the direct repeats were less than 6 bp long. However, the frequency of deletion of inserts with longer direct repeats increased exponentially as the length of the repeats increased from 8 to 20 bp. When inverted repeats (palindromes) were designed in the midst of the insert there was essentially no increase in deletion frequency between 10 bp direct repeats. But, the same palindromic sequences increased the deletion frequency between 5 bp direct repeats by at least two orders of magnitude. Thus, in this system homology at the endpoints is a more important determinant of deletion frequency than is the presence of palindromes between the direct repeats.     

Genetic deletions between directly repeated sequences in bacteriophage T7

Summary DNA sequence analysis of genetic deletions in bacteriophage T7 has shown that these chromosomal rearrangements frequently occur between directly repeated DNA sequences. To study this type of spontaneous deletion in more quantitative detail synthetic fragments of DNA, made by hybridizing two complementary oligonucleotides, were introduced into the non-essential T7 gene 1.3 which codes for T7 DNA ligase. This insert blocked synthesis of functional ligase and made the phage that carried an insert unable to form plaques on a host strain deficient in bacterial ligase. The sequence of the insert was designed so that after it is put into the T7 genome the insert is bracketed by direct repeats. Perfect deletion of the insert between the directly repeated sequences results in a wild-type phage. It was found that these deletion events are highly sensitive to the length of the direct repeats at their ends. In the case of 5 bp direct repeats excision from the genome occurred at a frequency of less than 10⁻¹⁰, while this value for an almost identical insert bracketed by 10 bp direct repeats was approximately 10⁻⁶. The deletion events were independent of a hostrecA mutation.     

Double-strand breaks increase the incidence of genetic deletion associated with intermolecular recombination in bacteriophage T7

An in vitro DNA replication system based on extracts prepared from Escherichia coli cells infected with bacteriophage T7 was used to study deletion associated with the repair of double-strand breaks. The gene for T7 ligase was interrupted by a DNA insert which included 17-bp direct repeats. Deletion between the repeats restored the reading frame of the gene, and these DNA molecules could be detected by their ability to give rise to ligase-positive phage after in vitro packaging. T7 genomes that had a pre-existing double-strand break located between the direct repeats were incubated together with intact genomes which had the same direct repeats. Genetic markers placed on either side of the insert in the ligase gene allowed identification of the source of DNA molecules that underwent deletion between the direct repeats. This allowed an assessment of the participation of the molecules with strand breaks in the deletion process, under conditions where any mechanism could contribute to deletion. Approximately three-quarters of the T7 molecules that had lost the region between the direct repeats contained one or both of the partial genomes originally introduced into the reactions. About 50% of the genomes which had undergone deletion had recombined markers between the partial and intact genomes. The data demonstrate that double-strand breaks substantially enhance the contribution of intermolecular recombination to deletion. Received: 19 November 1996 / Accepted: 26 February 1997     

Deletion between direct repeats in T7 DNA stimulated by double-strand breaks.

An in vitro system based on extracts of Escherichia coli infected with bacteriophage T7 was used to study genetic deletions between directly repeated sequences. The frequency of deletion was highest under conditions in which the DNA was actively replicating. Deletion frequency increased markedly with the length of the direct repeat both in vitro and in vivo. When a T7 gene was interrupted by 93 bp of nonsense sequence flanked by 20-bp direct repeats, the region between the repeats was deleted in about 1 out of every 1,600 genomes during each round of replication. Very similar values were found for deletion frequency in vivo and in vitro. The deletion frequency was essentially unaffected by a recA mutation in the host. When a double-strand break was placed between the repeats, repair of this strand break was often accompanied by the deletion of the DNA between the direct repeats, suggesting that break rejoining could contribute to deletion during in vitro DNA replication.     

Palindromy and the Location of Deletion Endpoints in Escherichia Coli

The contributions of direct and inverted repeats to deletion formation were studied by characterizing Ampr revertants of plasmids with a series of insertion mutations at a specific site in the pBR322 ampicillin resistance (amp) gene. The inserts at this site are palindromic, variable in length, and bracketed by 9- or 10-bp direct repeats of amp sequence. There is an additional direct repeat composed of 4 bp within the insert and 4 bp of adjoining amp sequence. DNA sequencing and colony hybridization of Ampr revertants showed that they contained either the parental amp sequence, implying deletion endpoints in the flanking 9- or 10-bp repeats, or a specific 1-bp substitution, implying endpoints in the 4-bp repeats. Although generally direct repeats seem to be used as deletion endpoints with a frequency proportional to their lengths, we found that with uninterrupted palindromes longer than 32 bp, the majority of deletions ended in the 4 bp, not the 9- or 10-bp repeats. This preferential use of the shorter direct repeats associated with palindromes is interpreted according to a DNA synthesis-error model in which hairpin structures formed by intrastrand pairing foster the slippage of nascent strands during DNA synthesis.     

RecA-independent high-frequency deletion of recombinant cosmid DNA in Escherichia coli

Segments of DNA were deleted from recombinant cosmid DNAs during propagation in Escherichia coli hosts in liquid culture. DNAs of more than 1000 cosmids propagated in various E. coli hosts were analysed by agarose gel electrophoresis (AGE). The effects of vectors, insert DNAs and host genetic characters on the formation of deletions were examined. The probability of deletion and the pattern of deletion bands observed by AGE differed from clone to clone, and after extensive culture the deletion band patterns remained almost constant during further culture. Most recombinant clones eventually showed deletion during prolonged liquid culture. Mutations in the recA gene of E. coli hosts, including a deletion mutation, did not prevent deletion. Most deletions occurred in the insert portions of cosmid DNAs. Nucleotide sequence analysis of six deletion junctions in test cosmid cMB15 demonstrated that deletions occurred between two short complete direct repeats of about 4-10 bp, irrespective of whether the cosmid was propagated in a recA host or a rec+ host. Some deletions occurred at the same sites either in a recA host or a rec+ host. These results suggest that the deletion events are mainly mediated by a recA-independent recombination system(s) of E. coli host cells.     

The Influence of Primary and Secondary DNA Structure in Deletion and Duplication between Direct Repeats in Escherichia Coli

We describe a system to measure the frequency of both deletions and duplications between direct repeats. Short 17- and 18-bp palindromic and nonpalindromic DNA sequences were cloned into the EcoRI site within the chloramphenicol acetyltransferase gene of plasmids pBR325 and pJT7. This creates an insert between direct repeated EcoRI sites and results in a chloramphenicol-sensitive phenotype. Selection for chloramphenicol resistance was utilized to select chloramphenicol resistant revertants that included those with precise deletion of the insert from plasmid pBR325 and duplication of the insert in plasmid pJT7. The frequency of deletion or duplication varied more than 500-fold depending on the sequence of the short sequence inserted into the EcoRI site. For the nonpalindromic inserts, multiple internal direct repeats and the length of the direct repeats appear to influence the frequency of deletion. Certain palindromic DNA sequences with the potential to form DNA hairpin structures that might stabilize the misalignment of direct repeats had a high frequency of deletion. Other DNA sequences with the potential to form structures that might destabilize misalignment of direct repeats had a very low frequency of deletion. Duplication mutations occurred at the highest frequency when the DNA between the direct repeats contained no direct or inverted repeats. The presence of inverted repeats dramatically reduced the frequency of duplications. The results support the slippage-misalignment model, suggesting that misalignment occurring during DNA replication leads to deletion and duplication mutations. The results also support the idea that the formation of DNA secondary structures during DNA replication can facilitate and direct specific mutagenic events.     

Stability of an inverted repeat in a human fibrosarcoma cell.

Deletions and rearrangements of DNA sequences within the genome of human cells result in mutations associated with human disease. We have developed a selection system involving a neo gene containing a DNA sequence inserted into the NcoI site that can be used to quantitatively assay deletion of this sequence from the chromosome. The spontaneous deletion from the neo gene of a 122 bp inverted repeat occurred at a rate of 2.1 x 10(-8) to <3.1 x 10(-9) revertants/cell/generation in three different cell lines. Deletion of the 122 bp inverted repeat occurred between 6 bp flanking direct repeats. Spontaneous deletion of a 122 bp non-palindromic DNA sequence flanked by direct repeats was not observed, indicating a rate of deletion of <3.1 x 10(-9) revertants/cell/generation. This result demonstrates that a 122 bp inverted repeat can exhibit a low level of instability in some locations in the chromosome of a human cell line.     

Limits to the role of palindromy in deletion formation.

We tested the effect of palindromy on deletion formation. This involved a study of reversion of insertion mutations in the pBR322 amp gene at a site where deletions end either in 9-bp direct repeats or in adjoining 4-bp direct repeats. Inserts of palindromic DNAs ranging from 10 to more than 26 bp and related nonpalindromic DNAs were compared. The frequency of deletions (selected as Ampr revertants) was stimulated by palindromy only at lengths greater than 26 bp. The 4-bp direct repeats, one component of which is located in the palindromic insert, were used preferentially as deletion endpoints with palindromes of at least 18 bp but not of 16 or 10 bp. We interpret these results with a model of slippage during DNA replication. Because deletion frequency and deletion endpoint location depend differently on palindrome length, we propose that different factors commit a molecule to undergo deletion and determine exactly where deletion endpoints will be.     

Analysis of repeat-mediated deletions in the mitochondrial genome of Saccharomyces cerevisiae

Mitochondrial DNA deletions and point mutations accumulate in an age-dependent manner in mammals. The mitochondrial genome in aging humans often displays a 4977-bp deletion flanked by short direct repeats. Additionally, direct repeats flank two-thirds of the reported mitochondrial DNA deletions. The mechanism by which these deletions arise is unknown, but direct-repeat-mediated deletions involving polymerase slippage, homologous recombination, and nonhomologous end joining have been proposed. We have developed a genetic reporter to measure the rate at which direct-repeat-mediated deletions arise in the mitochondrial genome of Saccharomyces cerevisiae. Here we analyze the effect of repeat size and heterology between repeats on the rate of deletions. We find that the dependence on homology for repeat-mediated deletions is linear down to 33 bp. Heterology between repeats does not affect the deletion rate substantially. Analysis of recombination products suggests that the deletions are produced by at least two different pathways, one that generates only deletions and one that appears to generate both deletions and reciprocal products of recombination. We discuss how this reporter may be used to identify the proteins in yeast that have an impact on the generation of direct-repeat-mediated deletions.     

Different mechanisms inferred from sequences of human mitochondrial DNA deletions in ocular myopathies.

We have sequenced the deletion borders of the muscle mitochondrial DNA from 24 patients with heteroplasmic deletions. The length of these deletions varies from 2.310 bp to 8.476 bp and spans from position 5.786 to 15.925 of the human mitochondrial genome preserving the heavy chain and light chain origins of replication. 12 cases are common deletions identical to the mutation already described by other workers and characterized by 13 bp repeats at the deletion boundaries, one of these repeats being retained during the deletion process. The other cases (10 out of 12) have shown deletions which have not been previously described. All these deletions are located in the H strand DNA region which is potentially single stranded during mitochondrial DNA replication. In two cases, the retained Adenosine from repeat closed to the heavy strand origin of replication would indicate slippage mispairing. Furthermore in one patient two mt DNA molecules have been cloned and their sequences showed the difference of four nucleotides in the breakpoint of the deletion, possibly dued to slippage mispairing. Taken together our results suggest that deletions occur either by slippage mispairing or by internal recombination at the direct repeat level. They also suggest that different mechanisms account for the deletions since similarly located deletions may display different motives at the boundaries including the absence of any direct repeat.     

Gene deletions causing human genetic disease: mechanisms of mutagenesis and the role of the local DNA sequence environment

Summary Reports describing short (< 20 bp) gene deletions causing human genetic disease were collated in order to study underlying causative mechanisms. Deletion break-point junction regions were found to be non-random both at the nucleotide and dinucleotide sequence levels, an observation consistent with an endogenous sequencedirected mechanism of mutagenesis. Direct repeats of between 2 bp and 8 bp were found in the immediate vicinity of all but one of the 60 deletions analysed. Direct repeats are a feature of a number of recombination, replication or repair-based models of deletion mutagenesis and the possible contribution of each to the spectrum of mutations examined was assessed. The influence of parameters such as repeat length and lenght of DNA between repeats was studied in relation to the frequency, location and extent of these deletions. Findings were broadly consistent with a slipped mispairing model but the predicted deletion of one whole repeat copy was found only rarely. A modified version of the slipped mispairing hypothesis was therefore proposed and was shown to possess considerable explanatory value for 25% of deletions examined. Whereas the frequency of inverted repeats in the vicinity of gene deletions was not significantly elevated, these elements may nevertheless promote instability by facilitating the formation of secondary structure intermediates. A significant excess of symmetrical sequence elements was however found at sites of single base deletions. A new model to explain the involvement of symmetric elements in frameshift mutagenesis was devised, which successfully accounted for a majority of the single base deletions examined. In general, the loss of one or a few base pairs of DNA was found to be more compatible with a replication-based model of mutagenesis than with a recombination or repair hypothesis. Seven hitherto unrecognized hotspots for deletion were noted in five genes (AT3, F8, HBA, HBB and HPRT). Considerable sequence homology was found between these different sites, and a consensus sequence (TGA/GA/GG/ TA/C) was drawn up. Sequences fitting this consensus (i) were noted in the immediate vicinity of 41% of the other (sporadic) gene deletions, (ii) were found frequently at sites of spontaneous deletion in the hamster APRT gene, (iii) were found to be associated with many larger human gene deletions/translocations, (iv) act as arrest sites for human polymerase a during DNA replication and (v) have been shown by in vitro studies of human polymerase a to be especially prone to frameshift mutation. It is proposed that dissociation of polymerase a at arrest sites may, by providing a stable single stranded substrate, lead to deletion of a DNA sequence either by slipped mispairing via a number of different secondary structure intermediates, or by strand-switching or base misincorporation. Human gene deletions thus appear to be caused by multiple mechanisms whose relative importance is probably governed by local primary and secondary DNA structure. Our ability to predict precisely the location and extent of a gene deletion is however hampered both by this complexity and by the possibility that these mechanisms may often act in combination.     

Plasmid inverted repeats provide for duplication or precise excision of DNA inserts

A plasmid containing inverted repeats is constructed in Bacillus subtilis. Insertion of DNA fragments into the plasmid inverted repeats results either in the precise excision of the insert or in its duplication in the opposite inverted repeat. These rearrangements are due to the presence of inverted repeats only. Two recombination events are possibly responsible for these phenomena. During the first step of the recombination two plasmid monomers form a dimer molecule. During the second step the intramolecular recombination between the direct repeats in the dimer structure leads to the formation of two rearranged plasmid monomers devoid of insertion or containing two DNA inserts. Proposed dimeric intermediate is unstable in B. subtilis. However, it is isolated from Escherichia coli recA, cells. Plasmids containing the inverted repeats can serve as a model to study plasmid recombination in B. subtilis cells.     

Differential DNA secondary structure-mediated deletion mutation in the leading and lagging strands.

The frequencies of deletion of short sequences (mutation inserts) inserted into the chloramphenicol acetyl-transferase (CAT) gene were measured for pBR325 and pBR523, in which the orientation of the CAT gene was reversed, in Escherichia coli. Reversal of the CAT gene changes the relationship between the transcribed strand and the leading and lagging strands of the DNA replication fork in pBR325-based plasmids. Deletion of these mutation inserts may be mediated by slipped misalignment during DNA replication. Symmetrical sequences, in which the same potential DNA structural misalignment can form in both the leading and lagging strands, exhibited an approximately twofold difference in the deletion frequencies upon reversal of the CAT gene. Sequences that contained an inverted repeat that was asymmetric with respect to flanking direct repeats were designed. With asymmetric mutation inserts, different misaligned structural intermediates could form in the leading and lagging strands, depending on the orientation of the insert and/or of the CAT gene. When slippage could be stabilized by a hairpin in the lagging strand, thereby forming a three-way junction, deletion occurred by up to 50-fold more frequently than when this structure formed in the leading strand. These results support the model that slipped misalignment involving DNA secondary structure occurs preferentially in the lagging strand during DNA replication.     

Context Effects in the Formation of Deletions in Escherichia Coli

We have examined the frequency with which identical deletions are formed in different chromosomal contexts. A panel of six mutant bla genes containing palindrome/direct repeat structures were moved from pBR322 to three locations: at lambda att, at chromosomal lac, and at F'lac. Deletion of the palindromes and one of the direct repeats results in reversion to Ampr. The frequency of deletion for all alleles declines beyond the reduction in copy number when they are moved from the multicopy plasmid environment to a single-copy chromosome. The magnitude of the declines varies in an allele-specific and location-specific manner. Our data support the hypothesis that context can influence the frequency of mutation independent of the immediate DNA sequence.     

Ac Induces Homologous Recombination at the Maize P Locus

The maize P gene conditions red phlobaphene pigmentation to the pericarp and cob. Starting from two unstable P alleles which carry insertions of the transposable element Ac, we have derived 51 P null alleles; 47 of the 51 null alleles have a 17-kb deletion which removes the 4.5-kb Ac element and 12.5 kb of P sequences flanking both sides of Ac. The deletion endpoints lie within two 5.2-kb homologous direct repeats which flank the P gene. A P allele which contains the direct repeats, but does not have an Ac insertion between the direct repeats, shows very little sporophytic or gametophytic instability. The apparent frequency of sporophytic mutations was not increased when Ac was introduced in trans. Southern analysis of DNA prepared from the pericarp tissue demonstrates that the deletions can occur premeiotically, in the somatic cells during development of the pericarp. Evidence is presented that the deletions occurred by homologous recombination between the two direct repeats, and that the presence of an Ac element at the P locus is associated with the recombination/deletion. These results add another aspect to the spectrum of activities of Ac: the destabilization of flanking direct repeat sequences.     

Recombination between repeats in Escherichia coli by a recA-independent, proximity-sensitive mechanism

We have examined the influence of proximity on the efficiency of recombination between repeated DNA sequences in Escherichia coli. Our experiments have employed a plasmid-based assay to detect deletions between direct repeats of 100 bp. The rate of deletion of the juxtaposed direct repeats was reasonably high at 6 × 10^–5 per cell. A comparison of recA+ and recA mutant strains showed that these deletion events are primarily the result of recA-independent recombination at these homologous sequences. Random restriction fragments of yeast or E. coli genomic DNA were used to separate the two repeats. Deletion rates decreased over two orders of magnitude with increasing separation of up to 7 kb. There was a surprisingly strong effect of even short sequence separations, with insertions of a few hundred base pairs exhibiting 10-fold reductions of deletion rates. No effect of recA on the efficiency of deletion was observed at any distance between repeats.     

Isolation of a dnaE mutation which enhances RecA-independent homologous recombination in the Escherichia coli chromosome

The mechanism of recombination of tandem repeats in the chromosome of Escherichia coli was investigated by genetic means. Tandem repeats 624 bp long were introduced into the lacZ gene of E. coli and the efficiency of deletion of one repeat was compared in different recombination mutants. No effects of the recA , recBC , recF , ruvA or ruvA recG mutations were detected. Hence, tandem repeat deletion appears to not proceed via the RecBCD or RecF homologous recombination pathways. A new mutant in which RecA-independent recombination is increased 15-fold was isolated. The mutation lies in the dnaE gene coding for the alpha subunit of polymerase III: it is a Gly to Asp change at codon 133. Another dnaE mutation, dnaE486 , was tested and also shown to stimulate RecA-independent recombination. It is proposed that tandem-repeat recombination occurs by a replication slippage mechanism. RecA-independent recombination is also enhanced in a rep mutant, in which chromosomal replication is slowed down by the absence of the Rep helicase, suggesting that replication pausing may facilitate slippage.