Increasing stability reduces conformational heterogeneity in a protein folding intermediate ensemble

A multi-site, time-resolved fluorescence resonance energy transfer methodology has been used to study structural heterogeneity in a late folding intermediate ensemble, IL, of the small protein barstar. Four different intra-molecular distances have been measured within the structural components of IL. The IL ensemble is shown to consist of different sub-populations of molecules, in each of which one or more of the four distances are native-like and the remaining distances are unfolded-like. In very stable conditions that favor formation of IL, all four distances are native-like in most molecules. In less stable conditions, one or more distances are unfolded-like. As stability is decreased, the proportion of molecules with unfolded-like distances increases. Thus, the results show that protein folding intermediates are ensembles of different structural forms, and they demonstrate that conformational entropy increases as structures become less stable. These observations provide direct experimental evidence in support of a basic tenet of energy landscape theory for protein folding, that available conformational space, as represented by structural heterogeneity in IL, becomes restricted as the stability is increased. The results also vindicate an important prediction of energy landscape theory, that different folding pathways may become dominant under different folding conditions. In more stable folding conditions, uniformly native-like compactness is achieved during folding to IL, whereas in less stable conditions, uniformly native-like compactness is achieved only later during the folding of IL to N.     

Non-redox-active small-molecules can accelerate oxidative protein folding by novel mechanisms

Multi-disulfide-bond-containing proteins acquire their native structures through an oxidative folding reaction which involves formation of native disulfide bonds through thiol-disulfide exchange reactions between cysteines and disulfides coupled to a conformational folding event. Oxidative folding rates of the four-disulfide-bond-containing protein bovine pancreatic ribonuclease A (RNase A) in the presence of the synthetic redox-active molecule, (+/-)-trans-1,2-bis(2-mercaptoacetamido)cyclohexane (BMC), and in combination with non-redox-active trimethylamine-N-oxide (TMAO), and trifluorethanol were determined by HPLC analysis. The data indicate that regeneration of RNase A is enhanced 2-fold by BMC (50 microM) and 3-fold upon addition of TMAO (0.2 M) and TFE (3% v/v) relative to control experiments performed in the absence of small-molecules. Examination of the native tendency of the fully-reduced polypeptide and the stability of key folding intermediates suggests that the increased oxidative folding rate can be attributed to native-like elements induced within the fully-reduced polypeptide and the stabilization of native-like species by added non-redox-active molecules.     

Mechanism of insulin chain combination. Asymmetric roles of A-chain alpha-helices in disulfide pairing

The A and B chains of insulin combine to form native disulfide bridges without detectable isomers. The fidelity of chain combination thus recapitulates the folding of proinsulin, a precursor protein in which the two chains are tethered by a disordered connecting peptide. We have recently shown that chain combination is blocked by seemingly conservative substitutions in the C-terminal alpha-helix of the A chain. Such analogs, once formed, nevertheless retain high biological activity. By contrast, we demonstrate here that chain combination is robust to non-conservative substitutions in the N-terminal alpha-helix. Introduction of multiple glycine substitutions into the N-terminal segment of the A chain (residues A1-A5) yields analogs that are less stable than native insulin and essentially without biological activity. (1)H NMR studies of a representative analog lacking invariant side chains Ile(A2) and Val(A3) (A chain sequence GGGEQCCTSICSLYQLENYCN; substitutions are italicized and cysteines are underlined) demonstrate local unfolding of the A1-A5 segment in an otherwise native-like structure. That this and related partial folds retain efficient disulfide pairing suggests that the native N-terminal alpha-helix does not participate in the transition state of the reaction. Implications for the hierarchical folding mechanisms of proinsulin and insulin-like growth factors are discussed.     

Amyloid formation under physiological conditions proceeds via a native-like folding intermediate

Although most proteins can assemble into amyloid-like fibrils in vitro under extreme conditions, how proteins form amyloid fibrils in vivo remains unresolved. Identifying rare aggregation-prone species under physiologically relevant conditions and defining their structural properties is therefore an important challenge. By solving the folding mechanism of the naturally amyloidogenic protein beta-2-microglobulin at pH 7.0 and 37 degrees C and correlating the concentrations of different species with the rate of fibril elongation, we identify a specific folding intermediate, containing a non-native trans-proline isomer, as the direct precursor of fibril elongation. Structural analysis using NMR shows that this species is highly native-like but contains perturbation of the edge strands that normally protect beta-sandwich proteins from self-association. The results demonstrate that aggregation pathways can involve self-assembly of highly native-like folding intermediates, and have implications for the prevention of this, and other, amyloid disorders.     

Conformational restrictions on the pathway of folding and unfolding of the pancreatic trypsin inhibitor

The kinetic roles of the partially folded, intermediate protein species with two disulphide bonds in folding and unfolding of the pancreatic trypsin inhibitor have been investigated further. Formation of a second disulphide bond between Cys5 and Cys55 during refolding of the reduced inhibitor, which would yield the species with the 30–51 and 5–55 disulphide bonds and, possibly, the native-like conformation of the protein, is not significant. Instead, three other second disulphide bonds (5–14, 5–38 and 14–38) are formed approximately 10⁵ times more readily, but each of these two-disulphide species then rearranges intramolecularly to the native-like, two-disulphide intermediate. Therefore, the reduced protein does not simply form sequentially the three disulphide bonds of the native state. Unfolding of the native state takes place by the reverse of this process.The kinetic importance for folding and unfolding of this transition between two-disulphide intermediates under the conditions used here was illustrated experimentally by a modified form of the inhibitor in which the thiols of Cys14 and Cys38 were blocked irreversibly. In the folded conformation, this modified protein is more stable to unfolding than normal, but after unfolding cannot readily regain the native-like conformation, because Cys14 or Cys38 are required to be involved in disulphide bonds during the interconversion of the two-disulphide intermediates.Some conception of the conformational transitions that take place at each stage of the folding transition may be inferred from the relative propensities of the six cysteine residues to make or rearrange disulphide bonds. It is concluded that the inhibitor probably does not refold by sequential adoption of the native conformation by the unfolded polypeptide chain. Instead, it appears that essentially all elements of the native conformation are attained simultaneously in the final stage of folding, within an unstable and flexible, yet relatively compact, form of the entire polypeptide chain produced by weak interactions between groups distant in the primary structure.     

Formation of a native-like subdomain in a partially folded intermediate of bovine pancreatic trypsin inhibitor.

In the folding of bovine pancreatic trypsin inhibitor (BPTI), the single-disulfide intermediate [30-51] plays a key role. We have investigated a recombinant analog of [30-51] using a 2-dimensional nuclear magnetic resonance (2D-NMR). This recombinant analog, named [30-51]Ala, contains a disulfide bond between Cys-30 and Cys-51, but contains alanine in place of the other cysteines in BPTI to prevent the formation of other intermediates. By 2D-NMR, [30-51]Ala consists of 2 regions-one folded and one predominantly unfolded. The folded region resembles a previously characterized peptide model of [30-51], named P alpha P beta, that contains a native-like subdomain with tertiary packing. The unfolded region includes the first 14 N-terminal residues of [30-51] and is as unfolded as an isolated peptide containing these residues. Using protein dissection, we demonstrate that the folded and unfolded regions of [30-51]Ala are structurally independent. The partially folded structure of [30-51]Ala explains many of the properties of authentic [30-51] in the folding pathway of BPTI. Moreover, direct structural characterization of [30-51]Ala has revealed that a crucial step in the folding pathway of BPTI coincides with the formation of a native-like subdomain, supporting models for protein folding that emphasize the formation of cooperatively folded subdomains.     

Conformational study of a native monodisulfide bridge analogue of EETI II

Summary Trypsin inhibitor EETI II, possessing six cysteines engaged in three disulfide bridges, shares a common structural motif with other proteins of different origins and functions. To understand the principles that govern folding of this largely distributed basic scaffold, mainly composed of a small triple-stranded β-sheet, we have studied different stages in the folding of EETI II. The conformational properties of a synthetic analogue of EETI II possessing only one native (15–27) disulfide bridge were investigated with the combined use of¹H NMR and molecular modelling. Although two native-like reverse turns were observed, formation of β-sheet could not be evidenced in the one disulfide analogue, while the motif has been shown to be present in a folding intermediate with two native disulfide bridges (9–21 and 15–27). These results suggest that the structural motif requires stabilisation by two disulfide bridges.     

Behavior of cysteine mutants of human lysozyme in de novo synthesis and in vivo secretion

To investigate the mechanism of disulfide-bond-coupled de novo folding of human lysozyme, we have constructed 23 mutant enzymes in which cysteine residue(s) were replaced by alanine(s). The mutant genes were translated in vitro in a system composed of rabbit reticulocyte lysate, canine pancreatic microsomal vesicles and oxidized glutathione. This system allows the formation of intramolecular disulfide bonds in translation products translocated into the microsomal lumen. The mobilities of the translation products were analyzed by SDS/PAGE in nonreducing conditions. Some mutant lysozymes were found to form a compact conformation with native-like mobility in the presence of SDS. The de novo formation of the SDS-resistant compact conformation of each mutant correlated well with its efficiency of secretion by Saccharomyces cerevisiae. Our results suggest that the de novo synthesized products reflect the conformational states in vivo to some extent, and that the formation of SDS-resistant compact conformation can be regarded as a necessary condition for allowing lysozyme to be secreted. In addition, the analysis of a mutant C116A (Cys116----Ala) under different oxidative conditions suggests two distinct pathways for the disulfide-bond-coupled formation of the compact conformation.     

Probing the energy landscape of protein folding/unfolding transition states

Previous molecular dynamics (MD) simulations of the thermal denaturation of chymotrypsin inhibitor 2 (CI2) have provided atomic-resolution models of the transition state ensemble that is well supported by experimental studies. Here, we use simulations to further investigate the energy landscape around the transition state region. Nine structures within approximately 35 ps and 3 A C(alpha) RMSD of the transition state ensemble identified in a previous 498 K thermal denaturation simulation were quenched under the quasi-native conditions of 335 K and neutral pH. All of the structures underwent hydrophobically driven collapse in response to the drop in temperature. Structures less denatured than the transition state became structurally more native-like, while structures that were more denatured than the transition state tended to show additional loss of native structure. The structures in the immediate region of the transition state fluctuated between becoming more and less native-like. All of the starting structures had the same native-like topology and were quite similar (within 3.5 A C(alpha) RMSD). That the structures all shared native-like topology, yet diverged into either more or less native-like structures depending on which side of the transition state they occupied on the unfolding trajectory, indicates that topology alone does not dictate protein folding. Instead, our results suggest that a detailed interplay of packing interactions and interactions with water determine whether a partially denatured protein will become more native-like under refolding conditions.     

The kinetic pathway of folding of barnase

To search for folding intermediates, we have examined the folding and unfolding kinetics of wild-type barnase and four representative mutants under a wide range of conditions that span two-state and multi-state kinetics. The choice of mutants and conditions provided in-built controls for artifacts that might distort the interpretation of kinetics, such as the non-linearity of kinetic and equilibrium data with concentration of denaturant. We measured unfolding rate constants over a complete range of denaturant concentration by using by 1H/2H-exchange kinetics under conditions that favour folding, conventional stopped-flow methods at higher denaturant concentrations and continuous flow. Under conditions that favour multi-state kinetics, plots of the rate constants for unfolding against denaturant concentration fitted quantitatively to the equation for three-state kinetics, with a sigmoid component for a change of rate determining step, as did the refolding kinetics. The position of the transition state on the reaction pathway, as measured by solvent exposure (the Tanford beta value) also moved with denaturant concentration, fitting quantitatively to the same equations with a change of rate determining step. The sigmoid behaviour disappeared under conditions that favoured two-state kinetics. Those data combined with direct structural observations and simulation support a minimal reaction pathway for the folding of barnase that involves two detectable folding intermediates. The first intermediate, I(1), is the denatured state under physiological conditions, D(Phys), which has native-like topology, is lower in energy than the random-flight denatured state U and is suggested by molecular dynamics simulation of unfolding to be on-pathway. The second intermediate, I(2), is high energy, and is proven by the change in rate determining step in the unfolding kinetics to be on-pathway. The change in rate determining step in unfolding with structure or environment reflects the change in partitioning of this intermediate to products or starting materials.     

Protein folding and misfolding: mechanism and principles

Two fundamentally different views of how proteins fold are now being debated. Do proteins fold through multiple unpredictable routes directed only by the energetically downhill nature of the folding landscape or do they fold through specific intermediates in a defined pathway that systematically puts predetermined pieces of the target native protein into place? It has now become possible to determine the structure of protein folding intermediates, evaluate their equilibrium and kinetic parameters, and establish their pathway relationships. Results obtained for many proteins have serendipitously revealed a new dimension of protein structure. Cooperative structural units of the native protein, called foldons, unfold and refold repeatedly even under native conditions. Much evidence obtained by hydrogen exchange and other methods now indicates that cooperative foldon units and not individual amino acids account for the unit steps in protein folding pathways. The formation of foldons and their ordered pathway assembly systematically puts native-like foldon building blocks into place, guided by a sequential stabilization mechanism in which prior native-like structure templates the formation of incoming foldons with complementary structure. Thus the same propensities and interactions that specify the final native state, encoded in the amino-acid sequence of every protein, determine the pathway for getting there. Experimental observations that have been interpreted differently, in terms of multiple independent pathways, appear to be due to chance misfolding errors that cause different population fractions to block at different pathway points, populate different pathway intermediates, and fold at different rates. This paper summarizes the experimental basis for these three determining principles and their consequences. Cooperative native-like foldon units and the sequential stabilization process together generate predetermined stepwise pathways. Optional misfolding errors are responsible for 3-state and heterogeneous kinetic folding.     

Modeling the role of disulfide bonds in protein folding: Entropic barriers and pathways

The role of disulfide bonds in directing protein folding is studied using lattice models. We find that the stability and the specificity of the disulfide bond interactions play quite different roles in the folding process: Under some conditions, the stability decreases the overall rate of folding; the specificity, however, by yielding a simpler connectivity of intermediates, always increases the rate of folding. This conclusion is intimately related to the selection mechanism entailed by entropic driving forces, such as the loop formation probability, and entropic barriers separating the native and the many native-like metastable states. The folding time is found to be a minimum for a certain range of the effective disulfide bond interaction. Examination of a model, which allows for the formation of disulfide bonded intermediates, suggests that folding proceeds via a threestage multiple pathways kinetics. We show that there are pathways to the native state involving only native-like intermediates, as well as those that are mediated by nonnative intermediates. These findings are interpreted in terms of the appropriate energy landscape describing the barriers connecting low energy conformations. The consistency of our conclusions with several experimental studies is also discussed. © 1995 Wiley-Liss, Inc.     

Order of steps in the cytochrome C folding pathway: evidence for a sequential stabilization mechanism

Previous work used hydrogen exchange (HX) experiments in kinetic and equilibrium modes to study the reversible unfolding and refolding of cytochrome c (Cyt c) under native conditions. Accumulated results now show that Cyt c is composed of five individually cooperative folding units, called foldons, which unfold and refold as concerted units in a stepwise pathway sequence. The first three steps of the folding pathway are linear and sequential. The ordering of the last two steps has been unclear because the fast HX of the amino acid residues in these foldons has made measurement difficult. New HX experiments done under slower exchange conditions show that the final two foldons do not unfold and refold in an obligatory sequence. They unfold separately and neither unfolding obligately contains the other, as indicated by their similar unfolding surface exposure and the specific effects of destabilizing and stabilizing mutations, pH change, and oxidation state. These results taken together support a sequential stabilization mechanism in which folding occurs in the native context with prior native-like structure serving to template the stepwise formation of subsequent native-like foldon units. Where the native structure of Cyt c requires sequential folding, in the first three steps, this is found. Where structural determination is ambiguous, in the final two steps, alternative parallel folding is found.     

Structural heterogeneity of the various forms of apomyoglobin: implications for protein folding.

Temperature-induced denaturation transitions of different structural forms of apomyoglobin were studied monitoring intrinsic tryptophan fluorescence. It was found that the tryptophans are effectively screened from solvent both in native and acid forms throughout most of the temperature range tested. Thus, the tryptophans' surrounding do not show a considerable change in structure where major protein conformational transitions have been found in apomyoglobin using other techniques. At high temperatures and under strong destabilizing conditions, the tryptophans' fluorescence parameters show sigmoidal thermal denaturation. These results, combined with previous studies, show that the structure of this protein is heterogeneous, including native-like (tightly packed) and molten globule-like substructures that exhibit conformation (denaturation) transitions under different conditions of pH and temperature (and denaturants). The results suggest that the folding of this protein proceeds via two "nucleation" events whereby native-like contacts are formed. One of these events, which involves AGH "core" formation, appears to occur very early in the folding process, even before significant hydrophobic collapse in the rest of the protein molecule. From the current studies and other results, a rather detailed picture of the folding of myoglobin is presented, on the level of specific structures and their thermodynamical properties as well as formation kinetics.     

Origin of apparent fast and non-exponential kinetics of lysozyme folding measured in pulsed hydrogen exchange experiments.

Folding of lysozyme at pH 5.2 is a complex processes. After rapid collapse (<1 ms) kinetic partitioning into a slow and fast folding pathway occurs. The fast pathway leads directly to the native structure (N), whereas the slow pathway goes through a partially folded intermediate (I(1)) with native-like secondary structure in the alpha-domain. This mechanism is in agreement with data from a large number of spectroscopic probes, from changes in the radius of gyration and from measurements on the time-course of the populations of the different species. Results from pulsed hydrogen exchange experiments, in contrast, revealed that the secondary structure of I(1) and of N is formed significantly faster than changes in spectroscopic properties occur and showed large variations in the protection kinetics of individual amide sites. We investigated the molecular origin of the rapid amide protection by quantitatively simulating all kinetic processes during the pulse-labeling experiments. Absorbance and fluorescence-detected folding kinetics showed that the early events in lysozyme folding are accelerated under exchange conditions (pH 9.2) and that a change in folding mechanism occurs due to the transient population of an additional intermediate (I(2)). This leads to kinetic competition between exchange and folding during the exchange pulse and to incomplete labeling of amide sites with slow intrinsic exchange rates. As a result, apparently faster and non-exponential kinetics of amide protection are measured in the labeling experiments. Our results further suggest that collapsed lysozyme (C) and I(1) have five and ten-times reduced free exchange rates, respectively, due to limited solvent accessibility.     

Side chain burial and hydrophobic core packing in protein folding transition states

A critical step in the folding pathway of globular proteins is the formation of a tightly packed hydrophobic core. Several mutational studies have addressed the question of whether tight packing interactions are present during the rate-limiting step of folding. In some of these investigations, substituted side chains have been assumed to form native-like interactions in the transition state when the folding rates of mutant proteins correlate with their native-state stabilities. Alternatively, it has been argued that side chains participate in nonspecific hydrophobic collapse when the folding rates of mutant proteins correlate with side-chain hydrophobicity. In a reanalysis of published data, we have found that folding rates often correlate similarly well, or poorly, with both native-state stability and side-chain hydrophobicity, and it is therefore not possible to select an appropriate transition state model based on these one-parameter correlations. We show that this ambiguity can be resolved using a two-parameter model in which side chain burial and the formation of all other native-like interactions can occur asynchronously. Notably, the model agrees well with experimental data, even for positions where the one-parameter correlations are poor. We find that many side chains experience a previously unrecognized type of transition state environment in which specific, native-like interactions are formed, but hydrophobic burial dominates. Implications of these results to the design and analysis of protein folding studies are discussed.     

Cysteine co-oxidation process driven by native peptide folding: an example on HER2 receptor model system

Synthetic models of receptors that have relevant biological roles are valuable tools for studying receptors itself and the corresponding ligands. Their properties can be validated at first by their capacity to fold in solution under native-like conditions and to assume conformations structurally and functionally equivalent to those in the native receptor. In this context, a new strategy to prepare the two-fragments synthetic receptor model HER2-DIVMP, an independent structural and functional motif of HER2, has been developed and the folding properties have been investigated. The strategy is based on a one-step cysteine co-oxidation procedure in slightly alkaline aqueous buffers, whereby the two separate peptide chains are allowed to self-assemble in solution. Under these conditions, the two chains spontaneously form the expected heterodimer with the correct pattern of disulfide bridges. To gain insights on the folding mechanism, we investigated the folding of two scrambled variants of the constituent peptide chains.     

Disulfide bond assignment in human J chain and its covalent pairing with immunoglobulin M.

The assignment of disulfide bonds in human J chain and its covalent pairing with immunoglobulin M was determined under conditions which minimize disulfide bond interchange. We show that in J chain the three intradisulfide bridges are formed between Cys 12 and 100, Cys 71 and 91, and Cys 108 and 133. Previous reports [reviewed by Koshland, M. E. (1985) Annu. Rev. Immunol. 3, 425-453] have proposed that cysteines 12, 14, or 68 were linked to the penultimate cysteine 575 of two mu chain tails. In this work, we demonstrate that cysteines 14 and 68 are disulfide-bridged to mu chains. A revised, albeit putative, model of J chain folding is presented which takes into account the correct disulfide pairing and the predictive secondary structure assignment.     

Folding of the alphaII-spectrin SH3 domain under physiological salt conditions

The SH3 domain has often been used as a model for protein folding due to its typical two-state behaviour. However, recent experimental data at low pH as well as molecular dynamic simulations have indicated that the folding process of SH3 probably is more complicated, and may involve intermediate states. Using both kinetic and equilibrium measurements we have obtained evidence that under native-like conditions the folding of the spectrin SH3 domain does not follow a classic two-state behaviour. The curvature we observed in the Chevron plots is a strong indication of a non-linear activation energy relationship due to the presence of high-energy intermediates. In addition, circular dichroism measurements indicated that refolding after thermal denaturation did not follow the same pattern as thermal unfolding but rather implied less cooperativity and that the refolding transition increased with increasing protein concentration. Further, NMR experiments indicated that upon refolding the SH3 domain gave rise to more than one conformation. Therefore, our results suggest that the folding of the SH3 domain of αII-spectrin does not follow a classical two-state process under high-salt conditions and neutral pH. Heterogeneous folding pathways, which can include folding intermediates as well as misfolded intermediates, might give a more reasonable insight into the folding behaviour of the αII-spectrin SH3 domain.     

Oxidative folding and structural analyses of a Kunitz-related inhibitor and its disulfide intermediates: functional implications

Tick-derived protease inhibitor (TdPI) is a tight-binding Kunitz-related inhibitor of human tryptase β with a unique structure and disulfide-bond pattern. Here we analyzed its oxidative folding and reductive unfolding by chromatographic and disulfide analyses of acid-trapped intermediates. TdPI folds through a stepwise generation of heterogeneous populations of one-disulfide, two-disulfide, and three-disulfide intermediates, with a major accumulation of the nonnative three-disulfide species IIIa. The rate-limiting step of the process is disulfide reshuffling within the three-disulfide population towards a productive intermediate that oxidizes directly into the native four-disulfide protein. TdPI unfolds through a major accumulation of the native three-disulfide species IIIb and the subsequent formation of two-disulfide and one-disulfide intermediates. NMR characterization of the acid-trapped and further isolated IIIa intermediate revealed a highly disordered conformation that is maintained by the presence of the disulfide bonds. Conversely, the NMR structure of IIIb showed a native-like conformation, with three native disulfide bonds and increased flexibility only around the two free cysteines, thus providing a molecular basis for its role as a productive intermediate. Comparison of TdPI with a shortened variant lacking the flexible prehead and posthead segments revealed that these regions do not contribute to the protein conformational stability or the inhibition of trypsin but are important for both the initial steps of the folding reaction and the inhibition of tryptase β. Taken together, the results provide insights into the mechanism of oxidative folding of Kunitz inhibitors and pave the way for the design of TdPI variants with improved properties for biomedical applications.