Building high affinity human antibodies by altering the glycosylation on the light chain variable region in N-acetylglucosamine-supplemented hybridoma cultures

We attempted to improve antibody affinity by varying glycosylation on the light chain variable region. The human hybridoma line HB4C5 produces an antibody reactive to lung adenocarcinoma, which possess a N-glycosylated carbohydrate chain on the light chain hypervariable region. It has been shown that altering this carbohydrate structure can be accomplished by varying the level of N-acetylglucosamine in glucose free medium, a change in the carbohydrate chain could be induced which resulted in modifying antigen binding. By culturing the cells in media containing more than 20 mM N-acetylglucosamine, cells produced antibody with 10 fold improved affinity as compared with antibody produced in 20 mM glucose-containing medium. A newly induced light chain glycoform produced in the N-acetylglucosamine-containing medium was shown to be responsible for this antigen binding enhancement. Addition of glucose in the N-acetylglucosamine-containing media led to decreased antibody affinity and slightly inhibited production of a new light chain in a dose-dependent manner. Combination of 20 mM N-acetylglucosamine and 0.5 mM glucose gave a higher antibody production without the decrease of the antigen binding. These results indicate that optimization of N-glycosylation on the light chain, which leads to higher antigen binding, can be accomplished by adjusting a ratio of glucose and N-acetylglucosamine in the culture medium.     

Altered hapten recognition by two anti-digoxin hybridoma variants due to variable region point mutations

Two spontaneous variants of the murine anti-digoxin antibody-producing hybridoma cell line 26-10 were isolated by two-color fluorescence-activated cell sorting on the basis of altered hapten binding. The variable region sequences of the antibodies produced by the mutant lines revealed that each contains a single amino acid change in the heavy chain second complementarity determining region. A Tyr to His change at position 50 leads to a 40-fold reduction in affinity for digoxin. A Ser to Phe mutation at position 52 results in a 300-fold reduction in affinity for digoxin. A competition assay involving 33 digoxin analogues was used to examine the specificity of hapten binding of 26-10 and the two mutant antibodies. The position 50 mutant has a distinct specificity change; it exhibits a preference for digoxin congeners containing a hydroxyl group at the steroid 12 position, whereas the 26-10 parent does not. The affinities of all three antibodies for hapten are progressively lowered by substitutions of increasing size at the digoxin steroid D ring 16 position. Although 26-10 binds digoxin and its genin form equally, 12 and 16 steroid position substitutions which lower affinity also confer a preference for a sugar at the steroid 3 position. These results suggest that position 50 contributes to specificity of the antibody and that alterations of the hapten can lead to differences in recognition, possibly through a shift in hapten orientation within the binding site.     

Amino acid sequence of the light chain variable region from a mouse anti-digoxin hybridoma antibody

A hybridoma cell line (26-10) derived from the A/J strain of mice secretes an immunoglobulin (IgG2a-k) which binds digoxin with an association constant of 1.2 nM. Such high-affinity antibodies have been utilized in clinical radioimmunoassays as well as in the reversal of toxicity due to excess digoxin. The amino acid sequence of the light chain variable region of this antibody was derived by automated sequencing of the following: the intact chain; a fragment beginning C terminal to the tryptophan residue 40, obtained by cleavage with iodosobenzoic acid; a fragment beginning C terminal to arginine residue 82, obtained by trypsin cleavage on the completely reduced, alkylated, and succinylated chain. Difficulties which had previously prevented the automated Edman sequencing of this chain (and, presumably, similar ones of the same subgroup) were overcome by increasing the duration of the cleavage step at proline residues 8 and 12. The sequences of the first two hypervariable and framework regions of this chain are virtually identical with those of the dinitrophenol- and menadione-binding myeloma light chain MOPC 460 (95% homology). This anti-digoxin hybridoma from the A/J strain makes use of a Vk gene which is similar to that utilized by some BALB/c 2,4-dinitrophenol-binding myelomas.     

Nucleotide sequences of five anti-lysozyme monoclonal antibodies.

The nucleotide sequences of the heavy and light chain immunoglobulin mRNAs derived from five hybridomas (Gloop 1-5) secreting IgGs specific for the loop region of hen egg lysozyme were determined. These monoclonal antibodies recognise three distinct but overlapping epitopes within the loop region. The sequences of two pairs of antibodies with indistinguishable fine specificities were similar in both chains whereas the sequences of antibodies of non-identical specificities were very different. It is proposed that the D-segments expressed in two of the antibodies (Gloop3 and Gloop4) are the products of one, or perhaps two, previously unidentified germ line D-genes. Gloop1 and Gloop2 use a D-segment previously identified in antibodies specific for the hapten 2-phenyloxazolone; however it is recombined in a different reading frame in the anti-lysozyme antibodies, producing a different amino acid sequence.     

Identification of variable region differences in Neisseria meningitidis class 3 protein sequences among five group B serotypes

Strains of Neisseria meningitidis express one of two porin proteins. These porins have been identified as the class 2 and class 3 proteins, and express serotype-specific epitopes. The gene for the class 3 protein was amplified by the polymerase chain reaction from the DNA of a serotype 4 strain as a 1025 bp fragment. The nucleotide sequence of this gene was determined and compared with two recently published sequences. On the basis of this comparison we have identified two major variable regions in the translated protein sequence, VR1 and VR2, that may be associated with serotype specificity. Three other variable regions were also identified. The sequences in the VR1 and VR2 regions from five additional group B N. meningitidis strains of serotypes 1, 4, 8, 12, and 15, all expressing class 3 proteins, were determined. The VR1 and VR2 regions were variable and were flanked by highly conserved regions among eight different class 3 sequences. These two variable regions of 15 and 9 amino acids are predicted to be in surface-exposed loops.     

The specificity properties that distinguish members of a set of homologous anti-digoxin antibodies are controlled by H chain mutations

Five murine A/J strain anti-digoxin mAb (35-20, 40-40, 40-120, 40-140, and 40-160) have highly homologous H and L chain V regions, only differing by somatic mutation, yet differ in affinity and specificity. The availability of the VH and VL genomic clones from one hybridoma, 40-140, has now allowed studies involving in vitro mutagenesis and chain recombination among these five hybridomas. To determine the relative contributions of the mutations found in either VH or VL to the overall binding properties of these antibodies, we recombined the 40-140VH with the VL of each hybridoma. The 40-140VH gene was transfected into hybridoma variants that produce only VL. The recombinant antibodies show that the mutations present in VH, rather than in VL, affect the fine specificity properties of these antibodies, whereas, the mutations among both VH and VL chains are important in determining antigen affinity. From mutations present in VH that affect fine specificity properties, the comparison of the antibody sequences, and from the previously measured binding properties, we predicted and tested selected VH mutations for their ability to alter specificity or affinity by doing site-directed in vitro mutagenesis. The results for the somatic mutations found in this group of antibodies show: 1) VH mutations control the fine specificity properties that distinguish different members of this group; 2) in particular, VH residues 54 and 55 in CDR2 control the distinguishing characteristics of specificities between these antibodies; and 3) by mutagenesis, we had the unusual result of being able to alter Ag specificity without affecting affinity. A computer model of the 40-140 antibody binding site was generated which indicates that VH residues 54 and 55 are highly accessible.     

Phenotypic and genotypic characterization of monoclonal anti-digoxin antibodies

Eleven hybridoma cell lines secreting monoclonal anti-digoxin antibody have been produced. They are primarily gamma heavy chain and kappa light chain molecules. Affinity constants for digoxin range from 2 X 10(6) to 3.5 X 10(8) liters/mole. Fine specificity analysis using a series of digoxin congeners demonstrates that an unsaturated lactone ring attached to the aglycone at the C-17 position is necessary for hapten recognition. The impact of other changes in digoxin's structure on antibody binding were also studied. DNA hybridization analysis demonstrates that there are at least three different variable region gene arrangements used to produce the heavy chains of the different hybridoma antibodies. Correlations between antigen binding characteristics and antibody V-gene arrangements are demonstrable.     

Engineering the variable region of therapeutic IgG antibodies

Since the first generation of humanized IgG1 antibodies reached the market in the late 1990s, IgG antibody molecules have been extensively engineered. The success of antibody therapeutics has introduced severe competition in developing novel therapeutic monoclonal antibodies, especially for promising or clinically validated targets. Such competition has led researchers to generate so-called second or third generation antibodies with clinical differentiation utilizing various engineering and optimization technologies. Parent IgG antibodies can be engineered to have improved antigen binding properties, effector functions, pharmacokinetics, pharmaceutical properties and safety issues. Although the primary role of the antibody variable region is to bind to the antigen, it is also the main source of antibody diversity and its sequence affects various properties important for developing antibody therapeutics. Here we review recent research activity in variable region engineering to generate superior antibody therapeutics.Key words: antibody therapeutics, variable region, engineering, affinity, pharmacokinetics, stability, immunogenicity     

Engineering the variable region of therapeutic IgG antibodies

Since the first generation of humanized IgG1 antibodies reached the market in the late 1990s, IgG antibody molecules have been extensively engineered. The success of antibody therapeutics has introduced severe competition in developing novel therapeutic monoclonal antibodies, especially for promising or clinically validated targets. Such competition has led researchers to generate so-called second or third generation antibodies with clinical differentiation utilizing various engineering and optimization technologies. Parent IgG antibodies can be engineered to have improved antigen binding properties, effector functions, pharmacokinetics, pharmaceutical properties and safety issues. Although the primary role of the antibody variable region is to bind to the antigen, it is also the main source of antibody diversity and its sequence affects various properties important for developing antibody therapeutics. Here we review recent research activity in variable region engineering to generate superior antibody therapeutics.     

The significant conservative and variable regions of the homologous protein sequences.

A method of identification of significant conservative and variable regions in homologous protein sequences is presented. A set of aligned homologous sequences is divided into two groups consisting of m and n most related sequences. Each pair of sequences from different group is compared using unitary similarity matrix. The superposition of pairwise comparisons scanned by a window of 10 amino acid residues gives intergroup local variability profile (VP). Area S of the figure between the VP and its mean value line is compared with averaged area S(r) of 1000 VPs of artificial homologous protein families. The difference (S-S(r)) given in standard deviation units sigma r is believed to be the amino acid substitution overall irregularity along the homologous protein sequences OI = (S-S(r))/sigma r. If OI greater than 2, the real VP extrema containing the surplus of area S-(S(r) + 2 sigma r) are cut off. The cut off stretches are likely to be significant conservative and variable regions. The significant conservative and variable regions of six homologous sequence families (phospholipases A2, cytochromes b, alpha-subunits of Na, K-ATPase, L- and M-subunits of photosynthetic bacteria photoreaction centre and human rhodopsins) were identified. It was shown that for artificial homologous protein sequences derived by k-fold lengthening of natural proteins the OI value rises as square root of k. To compare the degree of substitution irregularity in homologous protein sequence families of different length L the value of standard substitution overall irregularity for L = 250 is proposed.     

Complete heavy and light chain variable region sequence of anti-arsonate monoclonal antibodies from BALB/c and A/J mice sharing the 36-60 idiotype are highly homologous

Structural and serologic studies on murine A/J monoclonal anti-arsonate antibodies resulted in the identification of a second idiotype family (Id36-60) in addition to the predominant idiotype family (IdCR). Id36-60, unlike IdCR, is a dominant idiotype in the BALB/c strain but is a "minor" idiotype in the A/J strain. The complete heavy and light chain variable region (VH and VL) amino acid sequences of a representative Id36-60 hybridoma protein from both the A/J and BALB/c strains have been determined. There are only four amino acid sequence differences between the VH of antibody 36-60 (A/J) and antibody 1210.7 (BALB/c). Two of these differences arise from single nucleotide changes in which the A/J and BALB/c Id36-60 VH germline gene sequences differ. The two other differences are the result of somatic mutation in hybridoma protein 36-60. In addition, Id36-60 heavy chains employ the same D and JH3 segments in both strains. The entire Vk2 VL of 36-60 and 1210.7 differ by only two amino acids, suggesting that like the heavy chains, they are derived from highly homologous VL genes. The same Jk segment is used in both antibodies. A comparison of the amino acid sequence data from Id36-60-bearing hybridomas suggests that a heavy chain amino acid difference accounts for the diminished arsonate binding by the 1210.7 hybridoma protein. Because the 1210.7 heavy chain is the unmutated product of the BALB/c VH gene, somatic mutation in VH may be required to enhance Ars affinity in this system.     

Complementary combining site contact residue mutations of the anti-digoxin Fab 26-10 permit high affinity wild-type binding

Antibody 26-10, obtained in a secondary immune response, binds digoxin with high affinity (K(a) = 1.3 x 10(10) M(-1)) because of extensive shape complementarity. We demonstrated previously that mutations of the hapten contact residue HTrp-100 to Arg (where H refers to the heavy chain) resulted in increased specificity for digoxin analogs substituted at the cardenolide 16 position. However, mutagenesis of H:CDR1 did not result in such a specificity change despite the proximity of the H:CDR1 hapten contact residue Asn-35 to the cardenolide 16 position. Here we constructed a bacteriophage-displayed library containing randomized mutations at H chain residues 30-35 in a 26-10 mutant containing Arg-100 (26-10-RRALD). Phage were selected by panning against digoxin, gitoxin (16-OH), and 16-acetylgitoxin coupled to bovine serum albumin. Clones that retained wild-type Asn at position 35 showed preferred binding to gitoxin, like the 26-10-RRALD parent. In contrast, clones containing Val-35 selected mainly on digoxin-bovine serum albumin demonstrated a shift back to wild-type specificity. Several clones containing Val-35 bound digoxin with increased affinity, approaching that of the wild type in a few instances, in contrast to the mutation Val-35 in the wild-type 26-10 background, which reduces affinity for digoxin 90-fold. It has therefore proven possible to reorder the 26-10 binding site by mutations including two major contact residues on opposite sides of the site and yet to retain high affinity for binding for digoxin. Thus, even among antibodies that have undergone affinity maturation in vivo, different structural solutions to high affinity binding may be revealed.     

The production of high affinity monoclonal antibodies to progesterone

Using different immunisation regimens and the antigens 6β-hydroxyprogesterone hemisuccinate and 11α-hydroxyprogesterone hemisuccinate conjugated to bovine serum albumin, we have produced 35 monoclonal antibodies against progesterone with a wide range of specificities and affinities (K_a = 8 × 10⁷−3 × 10¹⁰ M⁻¹). The 10 antibodies raised against the 6β-antigen showed no advantage in terms of specificity when compared with those raised against the 11α-antigen. The four antibodies with the best binding characteristics were all derived from fusion experiments performed after long (5 booster injections) immunisation with the 11α-antigen. Although the specificities of these monoclonal antibodies were similar to those of a high affinity rabbit antiserum raised against the same antigen, a measurable improvement in sensitivity was obtained when one of these four antibodies was used for radioimmunoassay.     

Phage display-selected sequences of the heavy-chain CDR3 loop of the anti-digoxin antibody 26-10 define a high affinity binding site for position 16-substituted analogs of digoxin

The heavy-chain CDR3 region of the high affinity (K(a) = 1.3 x 10(10) M(-)1) anti-digoxin monoclonal antibody 26-10 was modified previously to shift its specificity, by substitution of tryptophan 100 by arginine, toward binding analogs of digoxin containing substitutions at position 16. To further change specificity, two 5-mer libraries of the randomly mutagenized phage-displayed 26-10 HCDR3 region (positions 94-98) were panned against digoxin-bovine serum albumin (BSA) as well as against 16-acetylgitoxin-BSA. When a mutant Fab that binds 16-substituted analogs preferentially was used as a parent sequence, clones were obtained with affinities for digoxin increased 2-4-fold, by panning on digoxin-BSA yet retaining the specificity shift. Selection on 16-acetylgitoxin-BSA, however, resulted in nine clones that bound gitoxin (16-OH) up to 150-fold higher than the wild-type 26-10, due to a consensus mutation of Ser(H95) to Gly(H95). The residues at both position H95 (serine) and position H100 (tryptophan) contact hapten in the crystal structure of the Fab 26-10-digoxin complex. Thus, by mutating hapten contact residues, it is possible to reorder the combining site of a high affinity antibody, resulting in altered specificity, yet retain or substantially increase the relative affinity for the cross-reactive ligand.     

Probing high affinity sequences of DNA aptamer against VEGF165

Vascular endothelial growth factor (VEGF(165)) is a potent angiogenic mitogen commonly overexpressed in cancerous cells. It contains two main binding domains, the receptor-binding domain (RBD) and the heparin-binding domain (HBD). This study attempted to identify the specific sequences of the VEa5 DNA aptamer that exhibit high binding affinity towards the VEGF(165) protein by truncating the original VEa5 aptamer into different segments. Using surface plasmon resonance (SPR) spectroscopy for binding affinity analysis, one of the truncated aptamers showed a >200-fold increase in the binding affinity for HBD. This truncated aptamer also exhibited high specificity to HBD with negligible binding affinity for VEGF(121), an isoform of VEGF lacking HBD. Exposing colorectal cancer cells to the truncated aptamer sequence further confirmed the binding affinity and specificity of the aptamer to the target VEGF(165) protein. Hence, our approach of aptamer truncation can potentially be useful in identifying high affinity aptamer sequences for the biological molecules and targeting them as antagonist for cancer cell detection.     

Heavy and light chain variable region sequences and antibody properties of anti-phosphotyrosine antibodies reveal both common and distinct features.

Phosphotyrosine and similar analogs have been used to elicit antibodies that have found widespread use in the study of cellular tyrosine phosphorylation. In order to better understand the anti-phosphotyrosine immune response and to elucidate the details of the specific association between a tyrosine phosphate and an antibody combining site, we have undertaken a detailed comparison of antibody stability, specificity, apparent affinity, and primary structure for eight different anti-phosphotyrosine antibodies derived from immunizations with three different antigens. Two of these, 2G8 and 1G2, were derived from an immunization using azobenzylphosphonate conjugated to carrier, and five others, Py2, Py20, Py42, Py54, and Py69, were the products of an immunization with phosphotyrosine conjugated to carrier. Each of these anti-hapten antibodies was an IgG. One antibody, 129, an IgM, was the result of an immunization with a mixture of tyrosine-phosphorylated proteins which had been purified from growth factor treated cells. We found that antibody binding was significantly inhibited by millimolar levels of divalent cations or high concentrations of monovalent salt, with the exception of the antibody 129 where binding was significantly enhanced by both. Under optimal conditions, the highest apparent affinities for phosphotyrosine were observed for antibodies Py69 and Py20 (10(-6)-10(-7) M) and the lowest for 129 and 1G2 (10(-3)-10(-4). The heavy and light chain variable regions of seven of these antibodies were cloned and sequenced and a predominant anti-phosphotyrosine response was observed. The light chains of these antibodies could be assigned to one of two major VK groups, VK10 and VK19, with sequence identity between the different light chains of each class ranging from 65 to 100% at the amino acid level. Similar sequence identity was found among the heavy chain sequences (89-98% identity at the amino acid level) with the exception of one antibody, 2G8, which was only distantly related to the others (61-64% amino acid identity). These heavy chains belong to the same heavy chain family, J558. Two of the antibodies, Py20 and Py69, were clearly derived from the same progenitor cell since both share a highly unusual apparent V-D-D-JH organization. However, a significant level of somatic mutation has occurred between the two antibodies resulting in subtle changes in their apparent affinity and specificity.     

Characterization of high affinity monoclonal antibodies specific for chlamydial lipopolysaccharide

Pathogens belonging to the genus Chlamydia contain lipopolysaccharide with a 3-deoxy-D- manno- oct-2-ulosonic acid (Kdo) trisaccharide of the sequence alpha-Kdo-(2-->8)-alpha-Kdo-(2-->4)-alpha-Kdo. This lipopolysaccharide is recognized in a genus-specific pattern by murine monoclonal antibodies (mAbs), S25-23 and S25-2 (both IgG1kappa), which bind as the minimal structures the trisaccharide and the terminal Kdo-disaccharide, respectively. The variable domains of these mAbs were reverse transcribed from mRNA which was isolated from hybridomas and cloned as single-chain variable fragments (scFvs) in E.coli TG1. The kinetics of binding of whole antibodies, Fab fragments and scFvs to natural and synthetically modified ligands were determined by surface plasmon resonance (SPR) using synthetic neoglycoconjugates. As examples of an antibody-carbohydrate interaction involving anionic carboxyl groups on the ligand, we report that the affinities of these antibodies are higher than usually observed in carbo-hydrate-protein interactions (K(D)of 10(-3)to 10(-5)M). SPR analy-ses of monovalent Fab and scFv binding to the natural trisaccharide epitope gave dissociation constants of 770 nM for S25-2 and 350 nM for S25-23, as determined by global fitting (simultaneous fitting of several measurements at different antibody concentrations) of sensorgram data to a one-to-one interaction model. Local fitting (separate fitting of individual sensorgram data at different antibody concentrations) and Scatchard analysis of the data gave kinetic and affinity constants that were in good agreement with those obtained by global fitting. The SPR data also showed that while S25-2 bound well to several Kdo disaccharides and carboxyl-reduced Kdo ligands, S25-23 did not. Identification of amino acids in the complementarity determining regions revealed the presence of a large number of positively charged amino acids which were located towards the center of the combining site, thus suggesting a different recognition mechanism than that observed for neutral ligands. The latter mainly involves aromatic amino acids for hydrophobic stacking inter-actions and hydrogen bonds.     

Graphic identification of conservative and variable segments in the amino acid sequences of homologous proteins

An algorithm is presented for localizing variable and constant regions in homologous protein sequences. A set of aligned protein sequences is divided into two groups consisting of m and n sequences. Each group contains sequences of most related species. Value of the position dissimilarity of proteins from different groups of m and n sequences is defined as a number of failures to coincide in comparison with all possible mXn pairs of amino acid residues in the position (each from different group) divided by mXn. The position dissimilarity value of m protein sequences within a group is defined as the number of failures to coincide in comparison with all possible mX X(m-1)/2 pairs of amino acid residues divided by mX(m-1)/2. Ten position average of dissimilarity values is plotted vs. the first position number. Area of the figure included between the profile of dissimilarity values and its mean value line characterizes the overall irregularity of amino acid substitutions along the protein sequences. If the area value is greater than the average area for 1000 random profile by more than two standard deviation units, the profile extrema containing the "surplus" of area are cut off. The cut off stretches are likely to be variable and constant regions. In case of "between groups" comparisons it is found that the overall irregularity of amino acid substitutions is very high for all considered families of proteins; phospholipases A2, aspartate aminotransferases, alpha-subunits of Na+,K(+)-ATPase, L- and M-subunits of photosynthetic bacteria photoreaction centre, human rhodopsins.