The evolution of low mutation rates in experimental mutator populations of Saccharomyces cerevisiae

Mutation is the source of both beneficial adaptive variation and deleterious genetic load, fueling the opposing selective forces than shape mutation rate evolution. This dichotomy is well illustrated by the evolution of the mutator phenotype, a genome-wide 10- to 100-fold increase in mutation rate. This phenotype has often been observed in clonally expanding populations exposed to novel or frequently changing conditions. Although studies of both experimental and natural populations have shed light on the evolutionary forces that lead to the spread of the mutator allele through a population, significant gaps in our understanding of mutator evolution remain. Here we use an experimental evolution approach to investigate the conditions required for the evolution of a reduction in mutation rate and the mechanisms by which populations tolerate the accumulation of deleterious mutations. We find that after ～6,700 generations, four out of eight experimental mutator lines had evolved a decreased mutation rate. We provide evidence that the accumulation of deleterious mutations leads to selection for reduced mutation rate clones in populations of mutators. Finally, we test the long-term consequences of the mutator phenotype, finding that mutator lines follow different evolutionary trajectories, some of which lead to drug resistance.     

The contribution of endogenous sources of DNA damage to the multiple mutations in cancer

There is increasing evidence that most human cancers contain multiple mutations. By the time a tumor is clinically detectable it may have accumulated tens of thousands of mutations. In normal cells, mutations are rare events occurring at a rate of 10(-10) mutations per nucleotide per cell per generation. We have argued that the mutation rates exhibited by normal human cells are insufficient to account for the large number of mutations found in human cancers, and therefore, that an early event in tumorigenesis is the development of a mutator phenotype. In normal cells, spontaneous and induced DNA damage is balanced by multiple pathways for DNA repair, and most DNA damage is repaired without error. However, in tumor cells this balance may be shifted such that damage overwhelms the repair capacity, resulting in the accumulation of multiple mutations. Our hypothesis is that multiple random mutations occur during carcinogenesis. The sequential mutations that are observed in some human tumors result from selective events required for tumor progression. We consider the possibility that endogenous sources of DNA damage, in particular oxidative DNA damage, may contribute to genomic instability and to a mutator phenotype in some tumors. Endogenous and environmental sources of reactive oxygen species (ROS) are abundant. In tumor cells, antioxidant or DNA repair capacity may be insufficient to compensate for the production of ROS, and these endogenous ROS may be capable of damaging DNA and inducing mutations in critical DNA stability genes. The possibility that oxidative DNA damage could be a significant source of the genomic instability characteristic of human cancers is exciting, because it may be feasible to modulate the extent of oxidative damage through antioxidant therapy. The use of antioxidants to reduce the extent of molecular damage by ROS could delay the progression of cancer.     

DNA polymerase beta imbalance increases apoptosis and mutagenesis induced by oxidative stress

Oxidative stress has been proposed to be one of the major causes leading to the accumulation of mutation that is associated with the initiation and progression of cancers. Elevated expression of DNA polymerase beta, an event found in many human tumors, has been shown to generate a mutator phenotype. Here, we demonstrated that overexpression of DNA polymerase beta strengthens the mutagenicity of oxidative damages, concomitantly with a higher cellular sensitivity and increased apoptosis. Deregulated expression of DNA polymerase beta could represent a predisposition factor for mutagenic effects of oxidative stress and thus have implication in the generation and/or evolution of cancer.     

The oxidized deoxynucleoside triphosphate pool is a significant contributor to genetic instability in mismatch repair-deficient cells

Oxidation is a common form of DNA damage to which purines are particularly susceptible. We previously reported that oxidized dGTP is potentially an important source of DNA 8-oxodGMP in mammalian cells and that the incorporated lesions are removed by DNA mismatch repair (MMR). MMR deficiency is associated with a mutator phenotype and widespread microsatellite instability (MSI). Here, we identify oxidized deoxynucleoside triphosphates (dNTPs) as an important cofactor in this genetic instability. The high spontaneous hprt mutation rate of MMR-defective msh2(-/-) mouse embryonic fibroblasts was attenuated by expression of the hMTH1 protein, which degrades oxidized purine dNTPs. A high level of hMTH1 abolished their mutator phenotype and restored the hprt mutation rate to normal. Molecular analysis of hprt mutants showed that the presence of hMTH1 reduced the incidence of mutations in all classes, including frameshifts, and also implicated incorporated 2-oxodAMP in the mutator phenotype. In hMSH6-deficient DLD-1 human colorectal carcinoma cells, overexpression of hMTH1 markedly attenuated the spontaneous mutation rate and reduced MSI. It also reduced the incidence of -G and -A frameshifts in the hMLH1-defective DU145 human prostatic cancer cell line. Our findings indicate that incorporation of oxidized purines from the dNTP pool may contribute significantly to the extreme genetic instability of MMR-defective human tumors.     

Mismatch repair genes of Streptococcus pneumoniae: HexA confers a mutator phenotype in Escherichia coli by negative complementation.

DNA repair systems able to correct base pair mismatches within newly replicated DNA or within heteroduplex molecules produced during recombination are widespread among living organisms. Evidence that such generalized mismatch repair systems evolved from a common ancestor is particularly strong for two of them, the Hex system of the gram-positive Streptococcus pneumoniae and the Mut system of the gram-negative Escherichia coli and Salmonella typhimurium. The homology existing between HexA and MutS and between HexB and MutL prompted us to investigate the effect of expressing hex genes in E. coli. Complementation of mutS or mutL mutations, which confer a mutator phenotype, was assayed by introducing on a multicopy plasmid the hexA and hexB genes, under the control of an inducible promoter, either individually or together in E. coli strains. No decrease in mutation rate was conferred by either hexA or hexB gene expression. However, a negative complementation effect was observed in wild-type E. coli cells: expression of hexA resulted in a typical Mut- mutator phenotype. hexB gene expression did not increase the mutation rate either individually or in conjunction with hexA. Since expression of hexA did not affect the mutation rate in mutS mutant cells and the hexA-induced mutator effect was recA independent, it is concluded that this effect results from inhibition of the Mut system. We suggest that HexA, like its homolog MutS, binds to mismatches resulting from replication errors, but in doing so it protects them from repair by the Mut system. In agreement with this hypothesis, an increase in mutS gene copy number abolished the hexA-induced mutator phenotype. HexA protein could prevent repair either by being unable to interact with Mut proteins or by producing nonfunctional repair complexes.     

Volatility of Mutator Phenotypes at Single Cell Resolution

Mutator phenotypes accelerate the evolutionary process of neoplastic transformation. Historically, the measurement of mutation rates has relied on scoring the occurrence of rare mutations in target genes in large populations of cells. Averaging mutation rates over large cell populations assumes that new mutations arise at a constant rate during each cell division. If the mutation rate is not constant, an expanding mutator population may contain subclones with widely divergent rates of evolution. Here, we report mutation rate measurements of individual cell divisions of mutator yeast deficient in DNA polymerase ε proofreading and base-base mismatch repair. Our data are best fit by a model in which cells can assume one of two distinct mutator states, with mutation rates that differ by an order of magnitude. In error-prone cell divisions, mutations occurred on the same chromosome more frequently than expected by chance, often in DNA with similar predicted replication timing, consistent with a spatiotemporal dimension to the hypermutator state. Mapping of mutations onto predicted replicons revealed that mutations were enriched in the first half of the replicon as well as near termination zones. Taken together, our findings show that individual genome replication events exhibit an unexpected volatility that may deepen our understanding of the evolution of mutator-driven malignancies.     

Spontaneously arising mutL mutators in evolving Escherichia coli populations are the result of changes in repeat length

Over the course of thousands of generations of growth in a glucose-limited environment, 3 of 12 experimental populations of Escherichia coli spontaneously and independently evolved greatly increased mutation rates. In two of the populations, the mutations responsible for this increased mutation rate lie in the same region of the mismatch repair gene mutL. In this region, a 6-bp repeat is present in three copies in the gene of the wild-type ancestor of the experimental populations but is present in four copies in one of the experimental populations and two copies in the other. These in-frame mutations either add or delete the amino acid sequence LA in the MutL protein. We determined that the replacement of the wild-type sequence with either of these mutations was sufficient to increase the mutation rate of the wild-type strain to a level comparable to that of the mutator strains. Complementation of strains bearing the mutator mutations with wild-type copies of either mutL or the mismatch repair gene uvrD rescued the wild-type mutation rate. The position of the mutator mutations-in the region of MutL known as the ATP lid-suggests a possible deficiency in MutL's ATPase activity as the cause of the mutator phenotype. The similarity of the two mutator mutations (despite the independent evolutionary histories of the populations that gave rise to them) leads to a discussion of the potential adaptive role of DNA repeats.     

An overview of the mechanisms of mutagenesis and carcinogenesis

Cancer is a genetic disease due to the accumulation of numerous mutations rendering the tumour cell insensitive to control by the local cellular environment and by the whole organism. Analysis of the frequency of appearance of human cancer as a function of age shows that between four and seven mutations in key genes are usually necessary to produce most human cancers. Interesting debates in the literature are concerned with the idea that normal mutation rates followed by selective advantage of mutated clones are enough to produce the numerous mutations found in human cancers. Alternatively, the mutator phenotype hypothesis is based on the idea that the normal mutation rates are insufficient to account for the multiple mutations found in tumours. It is, however, difficult not only to know this exact mutation frequency in cells but also to know the total number of cell divisions giving rise to a cancer. Therefore, during at least one step in the carcinogenic process, a mutator phenotype in target cells may occur due to mutations controlling the fidelity of DNA replication or DNA repair, the apoptosis pathways or the cell cycle checkpoint regulations. Among the multiple mutations found in human cancers such as gene amplification, chromosome alterations and translocations, point mutations are very important and the molecular mechanisms of their production are well documented. I will describe in detail the various mechanisms that a cell can use to produce point mutations due to lower fidelity in the DNA polymerisation step or to inefficient repair pathways. The presence of multiple mutations in human cancer is interesting not only in terms of understanding the carcinogenesis process in humans but also in eventually promoting strategies to decrease the efficiency of this process and to increase cancer therapy regimen.     

Endogenous mutagenesis and cancer

Mutations in DNA accrue relentlessly, largely via stochastic processes. Random changes accumulate, eventually disabling genetic components which result in the formation of the cancer phenotype. Given the infrequency of measured nucleotide changes and the requirement for several mutations to occur in the same cell, it has been postulated that the rate of mutation must become elevated early in the course of evolution of the cancer. Recently, large scale sequencing of tumor DNA has sought to directly measure random mutations. We discuss the implications of these findings and the factors that must be considered in order for fruitful determination of whether a mutator phenotype is a necessary precursor for cancer.     

Protein evolution constraints and model-based techniques to study them

There have been substantial improvements in statistical tools for assessing the evolutionary roles of mutation and natural selection from interspecific sequence data. The importance of having the rate at which a point mutation occurs depend on the DNA sequence at sites surrounding the mutation is now better appreciated and can be accommodated in probabilistic models of protein evolution. To quantify the evolutionary impact of some aspect of phenotype, one promising strategy is to develop a system for predicting phenotype from the DNA sequence and to then infer how the evolutionary rates of sequence change are affected by the predicted phenotypic consequences of the changes. Although statistical tools for characterizing protein evolution are improving, the list of candidate phenomena that can affect rates of protein evolution is long and the relative contributions of these phenomena are only beginning to be disentangled.     

Mutation, replicative infidelity of DNA and aneuploidy sequentially in the formation of malignant pleomorphic tumors

Mutations are thought to be involved in tumor formation because (i) tumor cells transmit their abnormalities to their descendants; and (ii) many carcinogens are mutagens. Aneuploidy is thought to be involved in tumor formation because (i) it is a common phenomenon, especially among malignant neoplasms; (ii) certain particular types of tumors are associated with specific karyotypic changes; and (iii) many immortal tumor cell lines are hyperploid. In recent years, acquired somatic cell replicative infidelity of DNA ("mutator phenotype") has been suggested as a mechanism of tumor formation, because more somatic genomic events occur in malignant tumor cells than could be caused by repeated exogenous mutagenic insults. Previously, theories of the genomic pathogenesis of tumors have involved these mechanisms individually. Here it is suggested that all three mechanisms may play roles in the formation of certain tumor types. For example, a sequence could occur such that first, a mutation affects genomic elements for control of growth, and for replicative fidelity of DNA, leading to "mutator phenotype". Second, when replicative infidelity of DNA results in mutation of genomic elements for mitotic-and-chromosomal stability, aneuploidy develops. Third, an asymmetric mitosis (in the course of the aneuploid stage) could produce occasional cells in which the "bad copy" is lost (or an extra "good copy" is gained) of the original genomic element which had supported replicative fidelity of DNA. These resulting cells would regain fidelity of replication of DNA, and hence could give rise to populations which are relatively genomically stable, hyperploid and immortal.     

DNA methylation alters the pattern of spontaneous mutation in Escherichia coli cells (mutD) defective in DNA polymerase III proofreading

We have shown previously that dam mutants of Escherichia coli have a weak mutator phenotype which generates mostly transition mutations in the P22 mnt gene. In contrast, in mutD5 cells, which have a strong mutator phenotype, transversion mutations were the most prevalent. A dam-16 mutD5 strain, defective in both DNA polymerase III associated-proofreading and Dam-directed mismatch repair exhibits a strong mutator phenotype but, surprisingly, its mutation spectrum is similar to that of the dam rather than the mutD parent. The most likely explanation is that Dam-directed mismatch repair in the mutD5 strain corrects most of the potential transition mutations (therefore yielding transversions) in the newly synthesised strand. When the dam-16 allele is present together with mutD5 a reduced efficiency of repair as well as loss of strand discrimination and misdirected repair results in the appearance of transition mutations at high frequency.     

Evidence of a Mild Mutator Phenotype in Cambodian Plasmodium falciparum Malaria Parasites

Malaria control efforts have been continuously stymied by drug-resistant strains of Plasmodium falciparum, which typically originate in Southeast Asia prior to spreading into high-transmission settings in Africa. One earlier proposed explanation for Southeast Asia being a hotbed of resistance has been the hypermutability or “Accelerated Resistance to Multiple Drugs” (ARMD) phenotype, whereby multidrug-resistant Southeast Asian parasites were reported to exhibit 1,000-fold higher rates of resistance to unrelated antimalarial agents when compared to drug-sensitive parasites. However, three recent studies do not recapitulate this hypermutability phenotype. Intriguingly, genome sequencing of recently derived multidrug-resistant Cambodian isolates has identified a high proportion of DNA repair gene mutations in multidrug-resistant parasites, suggesting their potential role in shaping local parasite evolution. By adapting fluctuation assays for use in P. falciparum, we have examined the in vitro mutation rates of five recent Cambodian isolates and three reference laboratory strains. For these studies we also generated a knockout parasite line lacking the DNA repair factor Exonuclease I. In these assays, parasites were typed for their ability to acquire resistance to KAE609, currently in advanced clinical trials, yielding 13 novel mutations in the Na⁺/H⁺-ATPase PfATP4, the primary resistance determinant. We observed no evidence of hypermutability. Instead, we found evidence of a mild mutator (up to a 3.4-fold increase in mutation rate) phenotype in two artemisinin-resistant Cambodian isolates, which carry DNA repair gene mutations. We observed that one such mutation in the Mismatch Repair protein Mlh1 contributes to the mild mutator phenotype when modeled in yeast (scmlh1-P157S). Compared to basal rates of mutation, a mild mutator phenotype may provide a greater overall benefit for parasites in Southeast Asia in terms of generating drug resistance without incurring detrimental fitness costs.     

DNA damage tolerance,mismatch repair and genome instability

DNA mismatch repair is an important pathway of mutation avoidance. It also contributes to the cytotoxic effects of some kinds of DNA damage, and cells defective in mismatch repair are resistant, or tolerant, to the presence of some normally cytotoxic base analogues in their DNA. The absence of a particular mismatch binding function from some mammalian cells confers resistance to the base analogues O⁶-methylguanine and 6-thioguanine in DNA. Cells also acquire a spontaneous mutator phenotype as a consequence of this defect. Impaired mismatch binding can cause an instability in DNA microsatellite regions that comprise repeated dinucleotides. Microsatellite DNA instability is common in familial and sporadic colon carcinomas as well as in a number of other tumours. Several independent lines of investigation have identified defects in mismatch repair proteins that are causally related to these cancers.     

Rapid Evolution of Novel Traits in Microorganisms

The use of natural microorganisms in biotransformations is frequently constrained by their limited tolerance to the high concentrations of metabolites and solvents required for effective industrial production. In many cases, more robust strains have to be generated by random mutagenesis and selection. This process of directed evolution can be accelerated in mutator strains, which carry defects in one or more of their DNA repair genes. However, in order to use mutator strains, it is essential to restore the normal low mutation rate of the selected organisms immediately after selection to prevent the accumulation of undesirable spontaneous mutations. To enable this process, we constructed temperature-sensitive plasmids that temporarily increase the mutation frequency of their hosts by 20- to 4,000-fold. Under appropriate selection pressure, microorganisms transformed with mutator plasmids can be quickly evolved to exhibit new, complex traits. By using this approach, we were able to increase the tolerance of three bacterial strains to dimethylformamide by 10 to 20 g/liter during only two subsequent transfers. Subsequently, the evolved strains were returned to their normal low mutation rate by curing the cells of the mutator plasmids. Our results demonstrate a new and efficient method for rapid strain improvement based on in vivo mutagenesis.     

Rapid evolution of novel traits in microorganisms

The use of natural microorganisms in biotransformations is frequently constrained by their limited tolerance to the high concentrations of metabolites and solvents required for effective industrial production. In many cases, more robust strains have to be generated by random mutagenesis and selection. This process of directed evolution can be accelerated in mutator strains, which carry defects in one or more of their DNA repair genes. However, in order to use mutator strains, it is essential to restore the normal low mutation rate of the selected organisms immediately after selection to prevent the accumulation of undesirable spontaneous mutations. To enable this process, we constructed temperature-sensitive plasmids that temporarily increase the mutation frequency of their hosts by 20- to 4,000-fold. Under appropriate selection pressure, microorganisms transformed with mutator plasmids can be quickly evolved to exhibit new, complex traits. By using this approach, we were able to increase the tolerance of three bacterial strains to dimethylformamide by 10 to 20 g/liter during only two subsequent transfers. Subsequently, the evolved strains were returned to their normal low mutation rate by curing the cells of the mutator plasmids. Our results demonstrate a new and efficient method for rapid strain improvement based on in vivo mutagenesis.     

Impact of mutation rate on the adaptation of gut bacteria

To study the role of mutator bacteria in the evolution of bacterial populations, we followed the impact of the mutation rate of Escherichia coli strains in the colonisation of the gut of axenic mice and the evolution of the mutation rate of bacterial populations living in the gut. We show that mutator bacteria have an advantage during the colonization. This adaptive advantage comes from their ability to generate adaptive mutations faster than wild type strains, mutations that allow their maintenance in the ecosystem. However, while mutator bacteria are becoming specialised to the environment they are living in, they accumulate mutations that may be deleterious or lethal in secondary environments. By following the evolution of the mutation rate of bacterial populations living in the gut of mice receiving antibiotics, we show that this therapy selects not only for antibiotic resistant mutants but also for mutator alleles that enhance mutation rates and are responsible for the appearance of the resistance. The costs of a high mutation rate, due to the accumulation of mutations, is seen in environments where changes are recurrent. In an ever-changing situation where every change is new, mutator bacteria might help the evolution of bacterial populations.     

Increased rates of genomic deletions generated by mutations in the yeast gene encoding DNA polymerase delta or by decreases in the cellular levels of DNA polymerase delta

In Saccharomyces cerevisiae, POL3 encodes the catalytic subunit of DNA polymerase delta. While yeast POL3 mutant strains that lack the proofreading exonuclease activity of the polymerase have a strong mutator phenotype, little is known regarding the role of other Pol3p domains in mutation avoidance. We identified a number of pol3 mutations in regions outside of the exonuclease domain that have a mutator phenotype, substantially elevating the frequency of deletions. These deletions appear to reflect an increased frequency of DNA polymerase slippage. In addition, we demonstrate that reduction in the level of wild-type DNA polymerase results in a similar mutator phenotype. Lowered levels of DNA polymerase also result in increased sensitivity to the DNA-damaging agent methyl methane sulfonate. We conclude that both the quantity and the quality of DNA polymerase delta is important in ensuring genome stability.     

Gene-specific mutagenesis enables rapid continuous evolution of enzymes in vivo

Various in vivo mutagenesis methods have been developed to facilitate fast and efficient continuous evolution of proteins in cells. However, they either modify the DNA region that does not match the target gene, or suffer from low mutation rates. Here, we report a mutator, eMutaT7 (enhanced MutaT7), with very fast in vivo mutation rate and high gene-specificity in Escherichia coli. eMutaT7, a cytidine deaminase fused to an orthogonal RNA polymerase, can introduce up to ∼4 mutations per 1 kb per day, rivalling the rate in typical in vitro mutagenesis for directed evolution of proteins, and promotes rapid continuous evolution of model proteins for antibiotic resistance and allosteric activation. eMutaT7 provides a very simple and tunable method for continuous directed evolution of proteins, and suggests that the fusion of new DNA-modifying enzymes to the orthogonal RNA polymerase is a promising strategy to explore the expanded sequence space without compromising gene specificity.     

Human Pol ɛ-dependent replication errors and the influence of mismatch repair on their correction

Mutations in human DNA polymerase (Pol) ?, one of three eukaryotic Pols required for DNA replication, have recently been found associated with an ultramutator phenotype in tumors from somatic colorectal and endometrial cancers and in a familial colorectal cancer. Possibly, Pol ? mutations reduce the accuracy of DNA synthesis, thereby increasing the mutational burden and contributing to tumor development. To test this possibility in vivo, we characterized an active site mutant allele of human Pol ? that exhibits a strong mutator phenotype in vitro when the proofreading exonuclease activity of the enzyme is inactive. This mutant has a strong bias toward mispairs opposite template pyrimidine bases, particularly T•dTTP mispairs. Expression of mutant Pol ? in human cells lacking functional mismatch repair caused an increase in mutation rate primarily due to T•dTTP mispairs. Functional mismatch repair eliminated the increased mutagenesis. The results indicate that the mutant Pol ? causes replication errors in vivo, and is at least partially dominant over the endogenous, wild type Pol ?. Since tumors from familial and somatic colorectal patients arise with Pol ? mutations in a single allele, are microsatellite stable and have a large increase in base pair substitutions, our data are consistent with a Pol ? mutation requiring additional factors to promote tumor development.