A combined FT-IR microscopy and principal component analysis on softwood cell walls

A combined FT-IR microscopy and principle component analysis was used to investigate chemical variations between softwood species as well as types of wood cell walls; latewood tracheids, earlywood tracheids and earlywood ray parenchyma cells. The method allowed us to detect small spectral differences between cell types rather than species and to predict characteristic chemical components of each cell type. The method enabled information to be obtained which allowed a evaluation of the polysaccharide composition even in lignified woody plant cell walls.     

Distribution of pectic epitopes in cell walls of the sugar beet root

Immunolabelling techniques with antibodies specific to partially methyl-esterified homogalacturonan (JIM5: unesterified residues flanked by methylesterified residues. JIM7: methyl-esterified residues flanked by unesterified residues), a blockwise de-esterified homogalacturonan (2F4), 1,4-galactan (LM5) and 1,5-arabinan (LM6) were used to map the distribution of pectin motifs in cell walls of sugar beet root (Beta vulgaris). PME and alkali treatments of sections were used in conjunction with JIM5-7 and 2F4. The JIM7 epitope was abundant and equally distributed in all cells. In storage parenchyma, the JIM5 epitope was restricted to some cell junctions and the lining of intercellular spaces while in vascular tissues it occurred at cell junctions in some phloem walls and in xylem derivatives. After secondary wall formation, the JIM5 epitope was restricted to inner cell wall regions between secondary thickenings. The 2F4 epitope was not detected without de-esterification treatment. PME treatments prior to the use of 2F4 indicated that HG at cell corners was not acetylated. The LM5 epitope was mainly present in the cambial zone and when present in storage parenchyma, it was restricted to the wall region closest to the plasma membrane. The LM6 epitope was widely distributed throughout primary walls but was more abundant in bundles than in medullar ray tissue and storage parenchyma. These data show that the occurrence of oligosaccharide motifs of pectic polysaccharides are spatially regulated in sugar beet root cell walls and that the spatial patterns vary between cell types suggesting that structural variants of pectic polymers are involved in the modulation of cell wall properties.     

The positional distribution of cell death of ray parenchyma in a conifer, Abies sachalinensis

We monitored the distribution of death of secondary xylem cells in a conifer, Abies sachalinensis. The cell death of tracheids, which are tracheary elements, occurred successively and was related to the distance from cambium. Thus, it resembled programmed cell death. By contrast, the death of long-lived ray parenchyma cells had the following features: (1) ray parenchyma cells remained alive for several years or more; (2) in many cases, no successive cell death occurred even within a given radial cell line of a ray; and (3) the timing of cell death differed among upper and lower radial cell lines and other lines of cells within a ray. These results indicate that the death of long-lived ray parenchyma cells involves a different process from the death of tracheids. The initiation of secondary wall formation and the lignification of ray parenchyma cells in the current year's annual ring were delayed in the upper and lower radial cell lines of a ray. In addition, the density of distribution and orientation of cortical microtubules in such cells were different from those in cells in other radial lines. Ray parenchyma cells in the previous year's annual ring within the upper and lower radial cell lines of a ray contained many starch grains. Our results indicate that positional information is an important factor in the control of the pattern of differentiation and, thus, of the functions of ray parenchyma cells that are derived from the same cambial ray cells.     

New applications for an old lignified element staining reagent

The use is reported of Mirande's reagent in epifluorescence microscopy which permits a clear distinction between cellulosic and lignified tissues. Homogeneous Prespermatophytae and gymnosperm xylem appeared entirely green with Mirande's reagent under ultraviolet excitation, whereas heteroxyled angiosperm wood showed a mixed pink and blue–green colour. This coloration was due to the fluorescence of cellulose, since certain elements in dicotyledonous wood (parenchyma, fibres, xylem rays) are not entirely lignified. Monocotyledonous (Poaceae) lignin showed an intense blue fluorescence due to hydroxycinnamic acids bound to the cell wall.The method showed that lignification occurs first in the middle lamella, and later in the secondary wall of xylem cells. In addition, this staining technique proved useful in the study of lignin and suberin deposition in response to various stress factors.     

Cambial activity,annual rhythm of xylem production in relation to phenology and climatic factors and lignification pattern during xylogenesis in drum-stick tree (Moringa oleifera)

The interrelationship among seasonality of cambium, wood formation, cell size variation, lignification, tree phenology and climatic factors has been examined in Moringa oleifera, a tropical evergreen tree. The vascular cambium in Moringa is a storied with a distinct seasonal variation in its structure due to dimensional changes in rays. Though cambium remains active throughout the year it is sensitive to water availability. Peak cambial cell division and rate of xylem differentiation are influenced by average rainfall during the monsoon period. Cambial cell division reaches higher up in the tree trunk when it is supporting a high number of branches and leaves. Statistical analysis of cell size variation and climate factors revealed that xylem cell development is greatly influenced by rainfall and rarely by temperature. Lengths of fusiform initials and vessel elements are positively correlated. The pattern of lignification during xylogenesis shows that the vessels are the first element to develop lignified walls and ray cells are the last elements to become lignified. Fiber cell walls show more syringyl lignin, while the cell walls of other xylem elements are characterized by relatively more guaiacyl lignin units.     

Localisation and characterisation of cell wall mannan polysaccharides in<Emphasis Type="Italic"> Arabidopsis thaliana</Emphasis>

Polysaccharides containing -1,4-mannosyl residues (mannans) are abundant in the lignified secondary cell walls of gymnosperms, and are also found as major seed storage polysaccharides in some plants, such as legume species. Although they have been found in a variety of angiosperm tissues, little is known about their presence and tissue localisation in the model angiosperm, Arabidopsis thaliana (L.) Heynh. In this study, antibodies that specifically recognised mannans in competitive ELISA experiments were raised in rabbits. Using these antibodies, we showed that Golgi-rich vesicles derived from Arabidopsis callus were able to synthesise mannan polysaccharides in vitro. Immunofluorescence light microscopy and immunogold electron microscopy of Arabidopsis inflorescence stem sections revealed that the mannan polysaccharide epitopes were localised in the thickened secondary cell walls of xylem elements, xylem parenchyma and interfascicular fibres. Similarly, mannan epitopes were present in the xylem of the leaf vascular bundles. Surprisingly, the thickened epidermal cell walls of both leaves and stems also contained abundant mannan epitopes. Low levels were observed in most other cell types examined. Thus, mannans are widespread in Arabidopsis tissues, and may be of particular significance in both lignified and non-lignified thickened cell walls. Polysaccharide analysis using carbohydrate gel electrophoresis (PACE) of cell wall preparations digested with a specific mannanase showed that there is glucomannan in inflorescence stems. The findings show that Arabidopsis can be used as a model plant in studies of the synthesis and functions of mannans.Abbreviations BSA bovine serum albumin - ELISA enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay - PACE polysaccharide analysis by carbohydrate gel electrophoresis     

Covalent linkages between cellulose and lignin in cell walls of coniferous and nonconiferous woods

Covalent linkages between wall polysaccharides and lignin, especially linkage between cellulose and lignin were discussed by carboxymethylation technique of whole cell walls of coniferous and nonconiferous woods. Hydroxyl groups of plant cell walls polysaccharides were highly substituted, but not those of lignin by carboxymethyl groups under the used conditions, and separated into water-soluble and insoluble fractions by water extraction. Carboxymethylated wall polysaccharides linked covalently with lignin were distributed into the water-insoluble fractions. Composition of carboxymethylated sugar residues in the both fractions was analyzed quantitatively by 1H NMR spectroscopy after hydrolyzation with D2SO4 in D2O. More than half of cellulose linked covalently with lignin in coniferous wood, but only one-sixth of cellulose was involved in the linkage in nonconiferous wood. The major noncellulosic wall polysaccharides of coniferous wood also linked significantly with lignin. On the other hand, noncellulosic wall polysaccharides of nonconiferous wood were involved slightly in the covalent linkage with lignin. The situation of linkage between wall polysaccharides containing cellulose and lignin was visualized by scanning electron micrographs.     

Degradation of lignified secondary cell walls of lucerne (Medicago sativa L.) by rumen fungi growing in methanogenic co-culture

Aims: To compare the abilities of the monocentric rumen fungi Neocallimastix frontalis, Piromyces communis and Caecomyces communis, growing in coculture with Methanobrevibacter smithii, to colonize and degrade lignified secondary cell walls of lucerne (alfalfa) hay. Methods and Results: The cell walls of xylem cylinders isolated from stems of lucerne contained mostly xylans, cellulose and lignin together with a small proportion of pectic polysaccharides. All of these major components were removed during incubation with the three fungi, and differing cell wall polysaccharides were degraded to different extents. The greatest dry weight loss was found with N. frontalis and least with C. communis, and scanning electron microscopy revealed that these extensively colonized different cell types. C. communis specifically colonized secondary xylem fibres and showed much less degradation than N. frontalis and P. communis. Conclusions: Neocallimastix frontalis and P. communis were efficient degraders of the cell walls of lucerne xylem cylinders. Degradation occurred of pectic polysaccharides, xylan and cellulose. Loss of lignin from the xylem cylinders probably resulted from the cleavage of xylan releasing xylan–lignin complexes. Significance and Impact of the Study: Unlike rumen bacteria, the rumen fungi N. frontalis, P. communis and C. communis are able to degrade lignified secondary walls in lucerne stems. These fungi could improve forage utilization by ruminants and may have potential in the degradation of lignocellulosic biomass in the production of biofuels.     

What is disjunctive xylem parenchyma? A case study of the African tropical hardwood Okoubaka aubrevillei (Santalaceae)

The morphological variation and structure-function relationships of xylem parenchyma still remain open to discussion. We analyzed the three-dimensional structure of a poorly known type of xylem parenchyma with disjunctive walls in the tropical hardwood Okoubaka aubrevillei (Santalaceae). Disjunctive cells occurred among the apotracheal parenchyma cells and at connections between axial and ray parenchyma cells. The disjunctive cells were partly detached one from another, but their tubular structures connected them into a continuous network of axial and ray parenchyma. The connecting tubules had thick secondary walls and simple pits with plasmodesmata at the points where one cell contacted a tubule of another cell. The imperforate tracheary elements of the ground tissue were seven times longer than the axial parenchyma strands, a fact that supports a hypothesis that parenchyma cells develop disjunctive walls because they are pulled apart and partly separated during the intrusive growth of fibers. We discuss unresolved details of the formation of disjunctive cell walls and the possible biomechanical advantage of the wood with disjunctive parenchyma: the proportion of tissue that improves mechanical strength is increased by the intrusive elongation of fibers (thick-walled tracheids), whereas the symplastic continuum of the parenchyma is maintained through formation of disjunctive cells.     

The function of intercellular spaces along the ray parenchyma in sapwood, intermediate wood, and heartwood of Cryptomeria japonica (Cupressaceae)

? Premise of the study: Intercellular spaces along ray parenchyma (ISRP) are common in many conifer xylems, but their function is uncertain because the in-situ structural network among ISRP, ray parenchyma, and tracheids has not been evaluated. Analysis of water distribution in ISRP from sapwood to heartwood is needed to elucidate the function of ISRP in sapwood, intermediate wood, and heartwood. ? Methods: We used cryo-scanning electron microscopy, x-ray photography, and water content measurement in xylem to analyze the presence of liquids in ISRP, ray parenchyma, and tracheids from sapwood to heartwood in Cryptomeria japonica (Cupressaceae). ? Key results: In sapwood, almost all ISRP were empty. "Cingulate-cavitated regions", which lose water along the tangential direction within one annual ring, formed in the earlywood tracheids, and their frequency increased toward the inner annual rings, whereas ray parenchyma cells were alive and not involved in the partial cavitation. In intermediate wood, almost all ISRP and earlywood tracheids and many of the ray cells were empty, and only some latewood tracheids retained liquid in their lumina. The ISRP were connected with tracheids via gas-filled ray parenchyma cells. ? Conclusions: The ISRP work as a pathway of gas for aspiration of ray parenchyma cells in sapwood. On the other hand, the occurrence of a gas network between ISRP, ray parenchyma, and tracheids facilitates cavitation of tracheids, resulting in the generation of low-moisture, intermediate wood.     

Immunolocalization of β-1-4-galactan and its relationship with lignin distribution in developing compression wood of Cryptomeria japonica

Compression wood (CW) contains higher quantities of β-1-4-galactan than does normal wood (NW). However, the physiological roles and ultrastructural distribution of β-1-4-galactan during CW formation are still not well understood. The present work investigated deposition of β-1-4-galactan in differentiating tracheids of Cryptomeria japonica during CW formation using an immunological probe (LM5) combined with immunomicroscopy. Our immunolabeling studies clearly showed that differences in the distribution of β-1-4-galactan between NW (and opposite wood, OW) and CW are initiated during the formation of the S₁ layer. At this stage, CW was strongly labeled in the S₁ layer, whereas no label was observed in the S₁ layer of NW and OW. Immunogold labeling showed that β-1-4-galactan in the S₁ layer of CW tracheids significantly decreased during the formation of the S₂ layer. Most β-1-4-galactan labeling was present in the outer S₂ region in mature CW tracheids, and was absent in the inner S₂ layer that contained helical cavities in the cell wall. In addition, delignified CW tracheids showed significantly more labeling of β-1-4-galactan in the secondary cell wall, suggesting that lignin is likely to mask β-1-4-galactan epitopes. The study clearly showed that β-1-4-galactan in CW was mainly deposited in the outer portion of the secondary cell wall, indicating that its distribution may be spatially consistent with lignin distribution in CW tracheids of Cryptomeria japonica.     

Safranine fluorescent staining of wood cell walls

Safranine is an azo dye commonly used for plant microscopy, especially as a stain for lignified tissues such as xylem. Safranine fluorescently labels the wood cell wall, producing green/yellow fluorescence in the secondary cell wall and red/orange fluorescence in the middle lamella (ML) region. We examined the fluorescence behavior of safranine under blue light excitation using a variety of wood- and fiber-based samples of known composition to interpret the observed color differentiation of different cell wall types. We also examined the basis for the differences in fluorescence emission using spectral confocal microscopy to examine lignin-rich and cellulose-rich cell walls including reaction wood and decayed wood compared to normal wood. Our results indicate that lignin-rich cell walls, such as the ML of tracheids, the secondary wall of compression wood tracheids, and wood decayed by brown rot, tend to fluoresce red or orange, while cellulose-rich cell walls such as resin canals, wood decayed by white rot, cotton fibers and the G-layer of tension wood fibers, tend to fluoresce green/yellow. This variation in fluorescence emission seems to be due to factors including an emission shift toward red wavelengths combined with dye quenching at shorter wavelengths in regions with high lignin content. Safranine fluorescence provides a useful way to differentiate lignin-rich and cellulose-rich cell walls without counterstaining as required for bright field microscopy.     

Sequential cell wall transformations in response to the induction of a pedicel abscission event in Euphorbia pulcherrima (poinsettia)

Alterations in the detection of cell wall polysaccharides during an induced abscission event in the pedicel of Euphorbia pulcherrima (poinsettia) have been determined using monoclonal antibodies and Fourier transform infrared (FT-IR) microspectroscopy. Concurrent with the appearance of a morphologically distinct abscission zone (AZ) on day 5 after induction, a reduction in the detection of the LM5 (1→4)-β- d -galactan and LM6 (1→5)-α- l -arabinan epitopes in AZ cell walls was observed. Prior to AZ activation, a loss of the (1→4)-β- d -galactan and (1→5)-α- l -arabinan epitopes was detected in cell walls distal to the AZ, i.e. in the to-be-shed organ. The earliest detected change, on day 2 after induction, was a specific loss of the LM5 (1→4)-β- d -galactan epitope from epidermal cells distal to the region where the AZ would form. Such alteration in the cell walls was an early, pre-AZ activation event. An AZ-associated de-esterification of homogalacturonan (HG) was detected in the AZ and distal area on day 7 after induction. The FT-IR analysis indicated that lignin and xylan were abundant in the AZ and that lower levels of cellulose, arabinose and pectin were present. Xylan and xyloglucan epitopes were detected in the cell walls of both the AZ and also the primary cell walls of the distal region at a late stage of the abscission process, on day 7 after induction. These observations indicate that the induction of an abscission event results in a temporal sequence of cell wall modifications involving the spatially regulated loss, appearance and/or remodelling of distinct sets of cell wall polymers.     

Lignification and lignin heterogeneity for various age classes of bamboo (Phyllostachys pubescens) stems

The lignification process and lignin heterogeneity of fibre, vessel and parenchyma cell walls for various age classes of bamboo stems of Phyllostachys pubescens Mazel were investigated. It was shown that protoxylem vessels lignified in the early stage of vascular bundle differentiation, metaxylem vessel and fibre walls initiated lignification from the middle lamella and cell corners after the completion of vascular bundle differentiation. Most of the parenchyma cell walls lignified after the stem reached its full height, while a few parenchyma cells remained non-lignified even in the mature culm. The cell walls of fibres and most parenchyma cells thickened further during the stem growth to form polylamellate structure and the lignification process of these cells may last even up to 7 years. The fibre walls were rich in guaiacyl lignin in the early stage of lignification, and lignin rich in syringyl units were deposited in the later stage. Vessel walls mainly contained guaiacyl lignin, while both guaiacyl and syringyl lignin were present in the fibre and parenchyma cell walls.     

Highly substituted glucuronoarabinoxylans (hsGAXs) and low-branched xylans show a distinct localization pattern in the tissues of Zea mays L

Polyclonal antibodies which recognized highly substituted glucuronoarabinoxylans (hsGAXs) and low-branched xylans and did not cross-react with each other, were raised in order to examine localization of these epitopes in internodes of maize. Immunofluorescent labeling revealed different pattern between two succeeding developmental stages. The hsGAX epitope was localized evenly in primary walls in all tissue types, and strongly in unlignified secondary walls in phloem. However, lignified secondary walls in protoxylem, parenchyma and a part of fibers were faintly labeled with this epitope. Moreover, the epitope showed limited binding in lignified parenchyma and fiber walls at ultrastructural level. Low-branched xylan epitope was localized evenly throughout lignified walls in all tissue types. This epitope was also localized only in lignified walls of other organs such as leaf, root apex and dark-grown mesocotyl. Low-branched xylans are significantly related to lignification. Localization of hsGAX epitope in their organs was similar to that in internodes. The hsGAX epitope was distributed both in unlignified walls of all tissues and in lignified walls of parenchyma and annular thickening of protoxylem. We propose that hsGAX has separate functions in lignified and unlignified tissues. In conclusion, at tissue level, hsGAX is localized mainly in unlignified walls, and low-branched xylans in lignified walls.     

Microfibril orientation in plant cell walls

Summary The distribution of particles on the surface of the plasmalemma in the collenchyma of Apium graveolens was studied by the freeze-etching technique. The aim was to determine whether the distribution of particles was related to the known longitudinal or transverse orientation of cellulose microfibrils in different layers of the walls of these cells. Preliminary statistical studies have shown no obvious correlation between particle distribution and microfibril orientation although the distribution appeared uniform rather than random. Qualitatively, the particle distribution on the plasmalemma of differentiating xylem fibres of Eucalyptus maculata and of the cortical parenchyma of Avena sativa coleoptiles appeared to be similar to that observed on the plasmalemma of Apium. No correlation between the particle distribution and the microfibril orientation known to exist in the walls of these cells could be discerned.The orientation of microtubules in the cytoplasm of collenchyma cells of Apium graveolens was parallel to the microfibril orientation in many instances, but exceptions were noted. A possible interpretation for this variation is discussed. It is concluded that the microtubules are the structures which are most likely to be involved in determining microfibril orientation in the cell wall.     

Ascorbic acid and xylem development in trunks of the Siberian larch trees

The contents of ascorbic acid (AA) and its oxidized form, dehydroascorbic acid (DHA), were assessed as related to the tracheid differentiation in the course of early and late wood development in the Siberian larch (Larix sibirica Ldb.) trees. The samples of the cambium, cell enlargement zone and mature cells were collected at the successive developmental stages by scraping tissues off layer by layer from trunk segments of the 20-year-old trees according to anatomical and histochemical criteria. While cambium initials were rapidly dividing, the AA contents per dry weight and per cell considerably exceeded the corresponding values characteristic of the late xylem development; such difference corresponded to the higher number of early tracheids per annual ring, as compared to the late tracheids. The AA content decreased as cells enlarged. The radial growth of the early wood tracheids, as compared to the late wood tracheids, was accompanied with a threefold increase in the AA and a decline in the DHA contents. The AA/DHA ratio was in line with the early tracheid enlargement. The maximum AA content was observed at the early stage of the secondary cell wall thickening in the tracheids of early and late xylem preceding lignification. During this stage of early wood development, the DHA content exceeded sixfold the corresponding value in the late xylem; as a result, the initial rates of lignification were different in two tissues. The rate of lignification in a newly developing layer of the early xylem increased gradually and was the highest in the completely differentiated tracheids. In the late xylem, the lignification rate was at its highest at the very beginning and then declined in the course of tracheid maturation. The dissimilar patterns of lignification in the early and late xylem were primarily associated with the DHA content, which increased in the early xylem and decreased in the maturing late xylem. Thus, the AA content and its accessibility to oxidation in the growing and mature xylem cells exhibited the diverse developmental patterns in the early and late xylem: two tissues differed in the tracheid number and radial diameter as well as in the rate of lignification.Translated from Fiziologiya Rastenii, Vol. 52, No. 1, 2005, pp. 97–107.Original Russian Text Copyright © 2005 by Antonova, Chaplygina, Varaksina, Stasova.     

Structural cell-wall proteins in protoxylem development: evidence for a repair process mediated by a glycine-rich protein

Polyclonal antibodies were used to localize structural cell-wall proteins in differentiating protoxylem elements in etiolated bean and soybean hypocotyls at the light- and electron-microscopic level. A proline-rich protein was localized in the lignified secondary walls, but not in the primary walls of protoxylem elements, which remain unlignified, as shown with lignin-specific antibodies. Secretion of the proline-rich protein was observed during lignification in different cell types. A glycine-rich protein (GRP1.8) was specifically localized in the modified primary walls of mature protoxylem elements and in cell corners between xylem elements and xylem parenchyma cells. The protein was secreted by Golgi bodies both in protoxylem cells after the lignification of their secondary walls and in the surrounding xylem parenchyma cells. The modified primary walls of protoxylem elements were visualized under the light microscope as filaments or sheets staining distinctly with the protein stain Coomassie blue. Electron micrographs of these walls show that they are composed of an amorphous material of moderate electron-density and of polysaccharide microfibrils. These materials form a three-dimensional network, interconnecting the ring- or spiral-shaped secondary wall thickenings of protoxylem elements and xylem parenchyma cells. The results demonstrate that the modified primary walls of protoxylem cells are not simply breakdown products due to partial hydrolysis and passive elongation, as believed until now. Extensive repair processes produce cell walls with unique staining properties. It is concluded that these walls are unusually rich in protein and therefore have special chemical and physical properties.     

Cambial Activity and Distribution of Rubber in Guayule (Parthenium argentatum)

Vascular cambium in Guayule, a rubber producing Mexican shrubof Asteraceae family is non-storied. Cambial activity variesperiodically, and the vascular cambium and its immediate derivativesdo not contain rubber. However, as the xylem and phloem parenchymacells derived from the vascular cambium age, rubber depositionstarts from the cell periphery along the walls and later towardstheir cell lumen. Though the sieve tubes and companion cellsof phloem contain no rubber, all parenchyma cells of xylem andphloem, show the presence of rubber, though its amount varies.However, certain lignified xylem ray cells and lignified pithcells are devoid of rubber accumulation. Microfluorescence studiesshow that the epithelial, phloem ray parenchyma, cortical andpith cells, in descending order, have the highest to lowestrubber content. The size and number of rubber particles observedin the parenchyma cells are greatest during the period of cambialdormancy than in an active cambial period Cambium, guayule, rubber     

Morphology, wood structure and cell wall composition of rolC transgenic and non-transformed aspen trees

Morphology, wood structure and cell wall composition of 35S-rolC transgenic hybrid aspen (P. tremula2tremuloides) were compared with non-transformed control trees. The transgenics are characterised by stunted growth, altered physiological parameters and light green leaves of reduced size. Histometric measurements revealed thinner fibre walls as compared to the controls. UV microspectrophotometry of individual wall layers did not reveal distinctive differences in the lignification of xylem cells, but in the extremely thin-walled fibres of the transgenics the secondary walls were less lignified as revealed by KMnO₄ staining in transmission electron microscopy. In the transgenics the formation of xylem cells was delayed and the differentiation zone reduced to only a few rows. Immunocytochemical analyses revealed the deposition of lignins in less differentiated xylem cells as compared to the controls. The first labelling of condensed lignin appeared in cell corners and of non-condensed lignin in secondary walls near cell corners during the deposition of S1 polysaccharides. Because of alterations in the formation and differentiation of xylem cells, 35S-rolC transgenic aspen may be useful for studies on molecular factors controlling the differentiation continuum.