DNA sequence determinants for binding of the Escherichia coli catabolite gene activator protein.

The consensus DNA site for binding of the Escherichia coli catabolite gene activator protein (CAP) is 22 base pairs in length and is 2-fold symmetric: 5'-AAATGTGATCTAGATCACATTT-3'. Positions 4 to 8 of each half of the consensus DNA half-site are the most strongly conserved. In this report, we analyze the effects of substitution of DNA base pairs at positions 4 to 8, the effects of substitution of thymine by uracil and by 5-methylcytosine at positions 4, 6, and 8, and the effect of dam methylation of the 5'-GATC-3' sequence at positions 7 to 10. All DNA sites having substitutions of DNA base pairs at positions 4 to 8 exhibit lower affinities for CAP than does the consensus DNA site, consistent with the proposal that the consensus DNA site is the ideal DNA site for CAP. Specificity for T:A at position 4 appears to be determined solely by the thymine 5-methyl group. Specificity for T:A at position 6 and specificity for A:T at position 8 appear to be determined in part, but not solely, by the thymine 5-methyl group. dam methylation has little effect on CAP.DNA complex formation. The thermodynamically defined consensus DNA site spans 28 base pairs. All, or nearly all, DNA determinants required for maximal affinity for CAP and for maximal thermodynamically defined CAP.DNA ion pair formation are contained within a 28-base pair DNA fragment that has the 22-base pair consensus DNA site at its center. The quantitative data in this report provide base-line thermodynamic data required for detailed investigations of amino acid-base pair and amino acid-phosphate contacts in this protein-DNA complex.     

In vitro specificity of EcoRI DNA methyltransferase.

The sequence selectivity of enzyme-DNA interactions was analyzed by comparing discrimination between synthetic oligonucleotides containing the canonical site GAATTC and altered DNA sequences with the EcoRI DNA methyltransferase. The specificities (kcat/KmDNA) are decreased from 5- to 23,000-fold relative to the unmodified site. For several substrates the decrease in kcat makes a disproportionate contribution to the specificity difference, suggesting that discrimination is mediated by the placement of critical catalytic residues rather than binding interactions. This is supported by our observation that specificity changes are generally not followed by changes in the stability of the methyltransferase-DNA complexes. Also, base pair substitutions near the site of methylation result in greater decreases in complex stability, suggesting that recognition and catalytic mechanisms overlap.     

Both substrate and target oligonucleotide sequences affect in vitro integration mediated by human immunodeficiency virus type 1 integrase protein produced in Saccharomyces cerevisiae.

Integration of retroviral DNA into the host cell genome requires the interaction of retroviral integrase (IN) protein with the outer ends of both viral long terminal repeats (LTRs) to remove two nucleotides from the 3' ends (3' processing) and to join the 3' ends to newly created 5' ends in target DNA (strand transfer). We have purified the IN protein of human immunodeficiency virus type 1 (HIV-1) after production in Saccharomyces cerevisiae and found it to have many of the properties described for retroviral IN proteins. The protein performs both 3' processing and strand transfer reactions by using HIV-1 or HIV-2 attachment (att) site oligonucleotides. A highly conserved CA dinucleotide adjacent to the 3' processing site of HIV-1 is important for both the 3' processing and strand transfer reactions; however, it is not sufficient for full IN activity, since alteration of nucleotide sequences internal to the HIV-1 U5 CA also impairs IN function, and Moloney murine leukemia virus att site oligonucleotides are poor substrates for HIV-1 IN. When HIV-1 att sequences are positioned internally in an LTR-LTR circle junction substrate, HIV-1 IN fails to cleave the substrate preferentially at positions coinciding with correct 3' processing, implying a requirement for positioning att sites near DNA ends. The 2 bp normally located beyond the 3' CA in linear DNA are not essential for in vitro integration, since mutant oligonucleotides with single-stranded 3' or 5' extensions or with no residues beyond the CA dinucleotide are efficiently used. Selection of target sites is nonrandom when att site oligonucleotides are joined to each other in vitro. We modified an in vitro assay to distinguish oligonucleotides serving as the substrate for 3' processing and as the target for strand transfer. The modified assay demonstrates that nonrandom usage of target sites is dependent on the target oligonucleotide sequence and independent of the oligonucleotide used as the substrate for 3' processing.     

On the recognition and cleavage mechanism of Escherichia coli endodeoxyribonuclease V, a possible DNA repair enzyme

Escherichia coli endodeoxyribonuclease V acts at many sites of damage in duplex DNA, including apurinic/apyrimidinic sites, lesions induced by ultraviolet light which are not pyrimidine dimers, adducts of 7-bromomethylbenz[a]anthracene, and, as demonstrated earlier (Gates, F. T., and Linn, S. (1977a) J. Biol. Chem. 252. 1647-1653), it degrades uracil-containing duplex DNA most efficiently. The cleavage rate increases with increasing substitution of uracil for thymine in T5 DNA, with a replacement of one-eight of thymine generating the apparent maximum cleavage rate. However, the apparent reaction limit with DNA containing 3.8% of thymine replaced by uracil corresponds to cleavage at only 6% of the dUMP residues. Evidently, the enzyme recognizes some peculiarities of abnormal DNA structure, but not simply distortions, since some lesions, including pyrimidine dimers, are not substrates. Endonuclease V generates double strand breaks in a constant ratio to single strand nicks, regardless of the substrate. It degrades DNA processively, completing the digestion of one substrate molecule before proceeding to the next. The enzyme also appears to act cooperatively. Cleavage at methylbenz[a]anthracene adducts is usually or always 5' to the lesion. Endonuclease V seems well suited to act as a DNA repair enzyme, surveying the genome for structural distortions generated by lesions for which specific repair systems might not exist.     

Unmasking Anticooperative DNA-binding interactions of vaccinia DNA topoisomerase I

Vaccinia DNA topoisomerase (vTopo) catalyzes highly specific nucleophilic substitution at a single phosphodiester linkage in the pentapyrimidine recognition sequence 5'-(C/T)+5C4+C3+T+2T+1p \N-1 using an active-site tyrosine nucleophile, thereby expelling a 5' hydroxyl leaving group of the DNA. Here, we report the energetic effects of subtle modifications to the major-groove hydrogen-bond donor and acceptor groups of the 3'-GGGAA-5' consensus sequence of the nonscissile strand in the context of duplexes in which the scissile strand length was progressively shortened. We find that the major-groove substitutions become energetically more damaging as the scissile strand is shortened from 32 to 24 and 18 nucleotides, indicating that enzyme interactions with the duplex region present in the 32-mer but not the 24- or 18-mer weaken specific interactions with the DNA major groove. Regardless of strand length, the destabilizing effects of the major-groove substitutions increase as the reaction proceeds from the Michaelis complex to the transition state for DNA cleavage and, finally, to the phosphotyrosine-DNA covalent complex. These length-dependent anticooperative interactions involving the DNA major groove and duplex regions 3' to the cleavage site indicate that the major-groove binding energy is fully realized late during the reaction for full-length substrates but that smaller more flexible duplex substrates feel these interactions earlier along the reaction coordinate. Such anticooperative binding interactions may play a role in strand exchange and supercoil unwinding activities of the enzyme.     

Dam methylase from Escherichia coli: kinetic studies using modified DNA oligomers: hemimethylated substrates.

We have measured steady-state kinetics of the N6-adenine methyltransferase Dam Mtase using as substrates non-selfcomplementary tetradecamer duplexs (d[GCCGGATCTAGACG]-d[CGTCTAGATCC-GGC]) containing the hemimethylated GATC target sequence in one or the other strand and modifications in the GATC target sequence of the complementary strands. Modifications included substitution of guanine by hypoxanthine (I), thymine by uracil (U) or 5-ethyl-uracil (E) and adenine by 2,6-diamino-purine (D). Thermodynamic parameters were obtained from the concentration dependence of the melting temperature (Tm) of the duplexes. Large differences in DNA methylation of duplexes containing single dI for dG substitution of the Dam recognition site were observed compared with the canonical substrate, if the substitution involved the top strand (on the G.C rich side). Substitution in either strand by uracil (dU) or 5-ethyluracil (dE) resulted in small perturbation of the methylation patterns. When 2,6-diamino-purine (dD) replaced the adenine to be methylated, small, but significant methylation was observed. The kinetic parameters of the methylation reaction were compared with the thermodynamic free energies and significant correlation was observed.     

Mutational analysis of endonuclease V from Thermotoga maritima

Endonuclease V nicks damaged DNA at the second phosphodiester bond 3' to inosine, uracil, mismatched bases, or abasic (AP) sites. Alanine scanning mutagenesis was performed in nine conserved positions of Thermotoga maritima endonuclease V to identify amino acid residues involved in recognition or endonucleolytic cleavage of these diverse substrates. Alanine substitution at D43, E89, and D110 either abolishes or substantially reduces inosine cleavage activity. These three mutants gain binding affinity for binding to double-stranded or single-stranded inosine substrates in the absence of a metal ion, suggesting that these residues may be involved in coordinating catalytic metal ion(s). Y80A, H116A, and, to a lesser extent, R88A demonstrate reduced affinities for double-stranded or single-stranded inosine substrates or nicked products. The lack of tight binding to a nicked inosine product accounts for the increased rate of turnover of inosine substrate since the product release is less rate-limiting. Y80A, R88A, and H116A fail to cleave AP site substrates. Their activities toward uracil substrates are in the following order: H116A > R88A > Y80A. These residues may play a role in substrate recognition. K139A maintains wild-type binding affinity for binding to double-stranded and single-stranded inosine substrate, but fails to cleave AP site and uracil substrate efficiently, suggesting that K139 may play a role in facilitating non-inosine substrate cleavage.     

Direct comparison of A- and T-strand minor groove interactions in DNA curvature at A tracts

To investigate the relative contributions of minor-groove electrostatic interactions in the mechanism of A-tract DNA curvature, we carried out experiments with modified DNA bases in both strands of the tract. We employed 3-deazaadenine nucleoside (D), which lacks the adenine N3 nitrogen in the minor groove and thus cannot act as an electron donor, as well as difluorotoluene (F), a nonpolar thymine mimic. The effects of these analogues in A-tract curvature were quantified using ligation ladder gel mobility methods developed by Crothers and by Maher. Through single substitutions of D in A(5) tracts, we found that this analogue results in decreased curvature only when situated toward the 3' end of the tract. This is distinct from the behavior in the T-rich strand where F substitution causes the greatest reductions in curvature toward the 5' end. To test for cooperative pairwise effects, we also studied 10 different D + F double substitutions and found evidence supporting a number of localized cooperative electrostatic interactions but not between the two most sensitive sites in the opposite strands. These results suggest that there are two discrete locations in the A-tract minor groove where electrostatic interactions are important in causing curvature: one near the 5' end of the T-rich strand, and one near the 3' end of the A-rich strand. The results are consistent with an important role of localized cations in the minor groove. Possible effects of groove solvation and stacking at the A-tract junction are also discussed.     

Non-additivity of sequence-specific enzyme-DNA interactions in the EcoRI DNA methyltransferase.

We describe a novel strategy to characterize protein-DNA interactions involving monomeric enzymes such as DNA methyltransferases (Mtases). This strategy is applied to our investigation of the EcoRI DNA Mtase, which binds its double stranded recognition site 5'-G-AATTC-3' and methylates the central adenosine of each strand using S-adenosyl-L-methionine as the methyl donor. We show that prior methylation of adenosine in either strand does not perturb catalysis. In contrast, substrates substituted with deoxyinosine at either guanosine position (T-BMI5 and TI5-BM) show the minor groove residing N2 amino group of both guanosines contribute to DNA recognition since specificity constants for the modified substrates are reduced 13 and 39 fold. Similar analysis of a substrate containing deoxyinosine at both positions (TI5-BMI5) clearly shows that some communication occurs between the sites. To determine the extent to which structural changes in the DNA alone contribute to this lack of additivity, we performed DNA melting analysis of the singly and doubly substituted substrates, and also found non-additivity. Although our functional and structural analyses suggest that deoxyinosine incorporation causes long range conformational effects, the similarity of KmAdoMet for all substrates suggests that no large-scale structural changes occur in the Mtase-DNA-AdoMet complex. Our results support the following conclusions: 1) The non-additivity shown in this system contrasts with the widespread demonstration of additivity involving repressors [Lehming et al., 1990; Takeda et al., 1989; Ebright et al., 1987], suggesting that sequence discrimination by enzymes may involve more complex mechanisms. Further, this non-additivity precludes quantitative assignment of individual interactions and we suggest that future analyses of this and related enzyme systems with base analogs include detailed information about the long range structural consequences of individual substitutions. 2) Although TI5-BM and T-BMI5 are shown to be radically different by thermodynamic analysis, the similar specificity constants with the Mtase suggest that the underlying structural differences (e.g., altered helical parameters of the DNA) are not critical for sequence-recognition. 3) The significance of minor groove Mtase-DNA interactions to specificity is confirmed.     

A spin-labeled abasic DNA substrate for AP endonuclease.

We report the first observation of a spin-labeled ds 23-mer oligonucleotide by high-field electron spin resonance (ESR) and demonstrate that it interacts with AP endonuclease, the key enzyme in DNA abasic site repair. The spin labeled 23-mer with a U at position 12 of the upper strand is processed by uracil DNA glycosylase to provide the abasic substrate. With a spin-label two nucleotides away from the abasic site, AP endo binds and cleaves when the label is 3' but not 5' to the abasic site. These results confirm that the disposition of the bases immediately upstream of the abasic site is particularly critical for cleavage by AP endo, and establish that DNA-protein interactions in this important enzyme can be examined using spin-labeled substrates.     

DNA recognition of base analogue and chemically modified substrates by the TaqI restriction endonuclease.

It has been proposed that protein-DNA recognition is mediated via specific hydrogen bond, hydrophobic, and/or electrostatic interactions between the protein and DNA surfaces. We have attempted to map and quantitate the energies of these interactions for the TaqI endonuclease by constructing substrates substituted with base or phosphate analogues that either remove or sterically obstruct particular functional groups in the canonical TCGA sequence. The DNA backbone was also modified using a chemical approach (phosphate ethylation) which identified several phosphates in the recognition sequence essential for cleavage. The base analogues, N6-methyl-A, N7-deaza-A, N7-deaza-G, inosine, N4-methyl-C, 5-methyl-C, uracil, 5-bromo-U, and the phosphate analogues, alpha-thio-A, alpha-thio-G, alpha-thio-T, alpha-thio-A, were substituted for their corresponding unmodified counterpart in one strand of the TCGA duplex. The effects of these analogues were monitored by measuring the steady state (Km, kcat) and single-turnover (kst) kinetic constants. Only the N6-methyl-A-substituted DNA, which mimics in vivo methylation, was unreactive while the remaining analogue substitutions exhibited Michaelis-Menten kinetics. In general, the Km was either unchanged or lowered by the analogue substitutions. In contrast, many of the analogues severely reduced kcat, suggesting the modified functional groups served mainly to destabilize the transition state. Single-turnover measurements paralleled the kcat results, pointing to the N7 and N6 of A, the N7 of G, and one of the nonbridging oxygens 3' to T as putative contacts made in achieving the transition state. Substrates with double substitutions displayed simple additivity of delta delta G" implying that these changes behaved independently. The unmodified strand in 10 out of 12 hemisubstituted substrates had a normal kst value suggesting that a particular cleavage center is controlled predominantly by recognition of determinants on the same strand as the scissile bond. These results are discussed in relation to base analogue work from the EcoRI, RsrI, and EcoRV restriction endonucleases.     

Recognition of unusual DNA structures by human DNA (cytosine-5)methyltransferase

The symmetry of the responses of the human DNA (cytosine-5)methyltransferase to alternative placements of 5-methylcytosine in model oligodeoxynucleotide duplexes containing unusual structures has been examined. The results of these experiments more clearly define the DNA recognition specificity of the enzyme. A simple three-nucleotide recognition motif within the CG dinucleotide pair can be identified in each enzymatically methylated duplex. The data can be summarized by numbering the four nucleotides in the dinucleotide pair thus: 1 4/2 3. With reference to this numbering scheme, position 1 can be occupied by cytosine or 5-methylcytosine; position 2 can be occupied by guanosine or inosine; position 3, the site of enzymatic methylation, can be occupied only by cytosine; and position 4 can be occupied by guanosine, inosine, O6-methylguanosine, cytosine, adenosine, an abasic site, or the 3' hydroxyl group at the end of a gapped molecule. Replacing the guanosine normally found at position 4 with any of the moieties introduces unusual (non-Watson-Crick) pairing at position 3 and generally enhances methylation of the cytosine at that site. The exceptional facility of the enzyme in actively methylating unusual DNA structures suggests that the evolution of the DNA methyltransferase, and perhaps DNA methylation itself, may be linked to the biological occurrence of unusual DNA structures.     

Contacts between the 5' nuclease of DNA polymerase I and its DNA substrate

The 5' nuclease of DNA polymerase I (Pol I) of Escherichia coli is a member of an important class of prokaryotic and eukaryotic nucleases, involved in DNA replication and repair, with specificity for the junction between single-stranded and duplex DNA. We have investigated the interaction of the 5' nuclease domain with DNA substrates from the standpoint of both the protein and the DNA. Phosphate ethylation interference showed that the nuclease binds to the nucleotides immediately surrounding the cleavage site and also contacts the complementary strand one-half turn away, indicating that contacts are made to one face only of the duplex portion of the DNA substrate. Phosphodiester contacts were investigated further using DNA substrates carrying unique methylphosphonate substitutions, together with mutations in the 5' nuclease. These experiments suggested that two highly conserved basic residues, Lys(78) and Arg(81), are close to the phosphodiester immediately 5' to the cleavage site, while a third highly conserved residue, Arg(20), may interact with the phosphodiester 3' to the cleavage site. Our results provide strong support for a DNA binding model proposed for the related exonuclease from bacteriophage T5, in which the conserved basic residues mentioned above define the two ends of a helical arch that forms part of the single-stranded DNA-binding region. The nine highly conserved carboxylates in the active site region appear to play a relatively minor role in substrate binding, although they are crucial for catalysis. In addition to binding the DNA backbone around the cleavage point, the 5' nuclease also has a binding site for one or two frayed bases at the 3' end of an upstream primer strand. In agreement with work in related systems, 5' nuclease cleavage is blocked by duplex DNA in the 5' tail, but the enzyme is quite tolerant of abasic DNA or polarity reversal within the 5' tail.     

Mechanism of damage recognition by Escherichia coli DNA photolyase

Escherichia coli DNA photolyase binds to DNA containing pyrimidine dimers with high affinity and then breaks the cyclobutane ring joining the two pyrimidines of the dimer in a light- (300-500 nm) dependent reaction. In order to determine the structural features important for this level of specificity, we have constructed a 43 base pair (bp) long DNA substrate that contains a thymine dimer at a unique location and studied its interaction with photolyase. We find that the enzyme protects a 12-16-bp region around the dimer from DNase I digestion and only a 6-bp region from methidium propyl-EDTA-Fe (II) digestion. Chemical footprinting experiments reveal that photolyase contacts the phosphodiester bond immediately 5' and the 3 phosphodiester bonds immediately 3' to the dimer but not the phosphodiester bond between the two thymines that make up the dimer. Methylation protection and interference experiments indicate that the enzyme makes major groove contacts with the first base 5' and the second base 3' to the dimer. These data are consistent with photolyase binding in the major groove over a 4-6-bp region. However, major groove contacts cannot be of major significance in substrate recognition as the enzyme binds equally well to a thymine dimer in a 44-base long single strand DNA and protects a 10-nucleotide long region around the dimer from DNase I digestion. It is therefore concluded that the unique configuration of the phosphodiester backbone in the strand containing the pyrimidine dimer, as well as the cyclobutane ring of the dimer itself are the important structural determinants of the substrate for recognition by photolyase.     

Interactions between the terminal bases of mammalian introns are retained in inosine-containing pre-mRNAs.

Nuclear pre-mRNA splicing has a fundamentally similar two-step mechanism to that employed by group II self-splicing introns. It is believed that nuclear pre-mRNA splicing involves a network of RNA-RNA interactions which form the catalytic core of the active spliceosome. We show here a non-Watson-Crick interaction between the first and last guanosine residues of a mammalian intron. As in Saccharomyces cerevisiae, substitution of the conserved guanosines at the 5' and 3' splice sites by A and C respectively, specifically suppresses step 2 splicing defects resulting from the individual mutations. No other combination of terminal nucleotides was able to restore splicing. We additionally provide independent evidence for an indirect interaction between other nucleotides of the consensus splice sites during step 2 of splicing. Substitution of the nucleotide in the +3 position of the 5' splice site affects competition between closely spaced AG dinucleotides at the 3' splice site, although the interaction is not via direct differential base pairing. Finally, we show that complete substitution of guanosine residues by inosine in a pre-mRNA has only a modest effect upon step 2 of splicing, although earlier spliceosome assembly steps are impaired. Predictions can thus be made about the precise configuration of the non-Watson-Crick interaction between the terminal residues.