Contribution of trehalose biosynthetic pathway to drought stress tolerance of Capparis ovata Desf

Trehalose and the trehalose biosynthetic pathway are important contributors and regulators of stress responses in plants. Among recent findings for trehalose and its metabolism, the role of signalling in the regulation of growth and development and its potential for use as a storage energy source can be listed. The xerophytic plant Capparis ovata (caper) is well adapted to drought and high temperature stress in arid and semi‐arid regions of the Mediterranean. The contribution of trehalose and the trehalose biosynthetic pathway to drought stress responses and tolerance in C. ovata are not known. We investigated the effects of PEG‐mediated drought stress in caper plants and analysed physiological parameters and trehalose biosynthetic pathway components, trehalose‐6‐phosphate synthase (TPS), trehalose‐6‐phosphate phosphatase (TPP), trehalase activity, trehalose and proline content in drought stress‐treated and untreated plants. Our results indicated that trehalose and the trehalose biosynthetic pathway contributed to drought stress tolerance of C. ovata. Overall growth and leaf water status were not dramatically affected by drought, as both high relative growth rate and relative water content were recorded even after 14 days of drought stress. Trehalose accumulation increased in parallel to induced TPS and TPP activities and decreased trehalase activity in caper plants on day 14. Constitutive trehalose levels were 28.75 to 74.75 μg·g·FW^?1, and drought stress significantly induced trehalose accumulation (385.25 μg·g·FW^?1 on day 14) in leaves of caper. On day 14 of drought, proline levels were lower than on day 7. Under drought stress the discrepancy between trehalose and proline accumulation trends might result from the mode of action of these osmoprotectant molecules in C. ovata.     

Drought impact on water use efficiency and intra‐annual density fluctuations in Erica arborea on Elba (Italy)

Erica arborea (L) is a widespread Mediterranean species, able to cope with water stress and colonize semiarid environments. The eco‐physiological plasticity of this species was evaluated by studying plants growing at two sites with different soil moistures on the island of Elba (Italy), through dendrochronological, wood‐anatomical analyses and stable isotopes measurements. Intra‐annual density fluctuations (IADFs) were abundant in tree rings, and were identified as the key parameter to understand site‐specific plant responses to water stress. Our findings showed that the formation of IADFs is mainly related to the high temperature, precipitation patterns and probably to soil water availability, which differs at the selected study sites. The recorded increase in the ¹³C‐derived intrinsic water use efficiency at the IADFs level was linked to reduced water loss rather than to increasing C assimilation. The variation in vessel size and the different absolute values of δ¹⁸O among trees growing at the two study sites underlined possible differences in stomatal control of water loss and possible differences in sources of water uptake. This approach not only helped monitor seasonal environmental differences through tree‐ring width, but also added valuable information on E. arborea responses to drought and their ecological implications for Mediterranean vegetation dynamics.     

Arbuscular mycorrhizal symbiosis induces strigolactone biosynthesis under drought and improves drought tolerance in lettuce and tomato

Arbuscular mycorrhizal (AM) symbiosis alleviates drought stress in plants. However, the intimate mechanisms involved, as well as its effect on the production of signalling molecules associated with the host plant–AM fungus interaction remains largely unknown. In the present work, the effects of drought on lettuce and tomato plant performance and hormone levels were investigated in non‐AM and AM plants. Three different water regimes were applied, and their effects were analysed over time. AM plants showed an improved growth rate and efficiency of photosystem II than non‐AM plants under drought from very early stages of plant colonization. The levels of the phytohormone abscisic acid, as well as the expression of the corresponding marker genes, were influenced by drought stress in non‐AM and AM plants. The levels of strigolactones and the expression of corresponding marker genes were affected by both AM symbiosis and drought. The results suggest that AM symbiosis alleviates drought stress by altering the hormonal profiles and affecting plant physiology in the host plant. In addition, a correlation between AM root colonization, strigolactone levels and drought severity is shown, suggesting that under these unfavourable conditions, plants might increase strigolactone production in order to promote symbiosis establishment to cope with the stress.     

Stress magnitude matters: different intensities of pulsed water stress produce non‐monotonic resistance responses of host plants to insect herbivores

Abstract 1. Water stress may increase or reduce the suitability of plants for herbivores. The recently proposed ‘pulsed stress hypothesis’ suggests consideration of stress phenology (pulsed vs. continuous stress) to explain these conflicting effects of plant water stress on herbivore performance. 2. This hypothesis was tested for the effect of differing stress intensity on performance and preference of insect herbivores belonging to different feeding guilds, namely leaf‐chewing insects (Spodoptera littoralis caterpillars) and phloem‐feeding insects (Aphis pomi aphids), on apple plants (Malus domestica). The plants were non‐stressed or exposed to a low or high intensity of pulsed water stress. 3. Plant responses to the different stress levels were generally monotonic. Growth, stomatal conductance (g_s), leaf water, and old‐leaf nitrogen concentration decreased, whereas young‐leaf nitrogen concentration and leaf mass per area (LMA) increased with increasing stress intensity. The stable isotope composition of foliar carbon (δ¹³C) responded non‐monotonically to the drought treatments. The δ¹³C values were highest in low‐stress plants, intermediate in high‐stress plants, and lowest in non‐stressed plants. 4. The preference and performance responses of the caterpillars were also non‐monotonic. Non‐stressed plants were intermediately, low‐stress plants least, and high‐stress plants most attractive or suitable. Aphid population growth was highest on non‐stressed plants and lowest on low‐stress plants. 5. The results highlight the importance of water stress intensity for the outcome of interactions between herbivores and drought‐affected plants. They show that pulsed water stress may enhance or reduce insect herbivore performance and plant resistance, depending on stress intensity.     

Physiological and morphological traits associated with adaptation of lucerne (Medicago sativa) to severely drought‐stressed and to irrigated environments

Adaptation to severe drought and to irrigated cropping can both contribute to increased water use efficiency of lucerne, but knowledge on the relevant adaptive traits is limited. Five cultivars featuring contrasting adaptive responses for 3‐year forage yield across 10 agricultural environments of the western Mediterranean basin were currently studied, to identify physiological and morphological traits associated with specific and wide‐adaptation responses. The landraces Mamuntanas, Demnat 203 and Erfoud 1, and the varieties SARDI 10 and Prosementi, were grown in replicated metal containers (55 cm long × 12 cm wide × 75 cm deep; 21 plants per container) under irrigation (weekly restoring soil field capacity) and under moderate and severe drought stress (implying decreased irrigation for 30 days followed by withheld irrigation for 33 and 58 days, respectively). Cultivar post‐stress survival reflected the known cultivar adaptation to drought‐prone agricultural environments. Demnat 203, specifically adapted to irrigated, frequently mown environments, displayed higher amounts of starch, soluble proteins and total nitrogen in the crown and the root under irrigation. This was due to outstanding organ size and, for starch, higher concentrations. Mamuntanas, specifically adapted to drought‐prone environments, exhibited high water‐soluble carbohydrate concentration in storage organs under severe stress, along with a water‐conservation strategy implying less water used in initial drought‐stress phases due to limited early root development that resulted in more water available under severe stress. Drought‐tolerant germplasm also displayed lower wilting under early stress, more plants with green tissues under severe stress, and more stems per plant in stress or favourable conditions. Multivariate patterns of cultivar variation for physiological and morphological traits were strictly associated with cultivar variation for adaptation pattern. Our results highlighted the difficulty to combine some traits of environment‐specific adaptive value into a unique widely adapted variety, supporting the selection of varieties specifically adapted to irrigated or severely drought‐prone environments.     

Induction of abiotic stress tolerance in plants by endophytic microbes

Endophytes are micro‐organisms including bacteria and fungi that survive within healthy plant tissues and promote plant growth under stress. This review focuses on the potential of endophytic microbes that induce abiotic stress tolerance in plants. How endophytes promote plant growth under stressful conditions, like drought and heat, high salinity and poor nutrient availability will be discussed. The molecular mechanisms for increasing stress tolerance in plants by endophytes include induction of plant stress genes as well as biomolecules like reactive oxygen species scavengers. This review may help in the development of biotechnological applications of endophytic microbes in plant growth promotion and crop improvement under abiotic stress conditions.

Significance and Impact of the Study

Increasing human populations demand more crop yield for food security while crop production is adversely affected by abiotic stresses like drought, salinity and high temperature. Development of stress tolerance in plants is a strategy to cope with the negative effects of adverse environmental conditions. Endophytes are well recognized for plant growth promotion and production of natural compounds. The property of endophytes to induce stress tolerance in plants can be applied to increase crop yields. With this review, we intend to promote application of endophytes in biotechnology and genetic engineering for the development of stress‐tolerant plants.     

Evolution of drought tolerance and defense: dependence of tradeoffs on mechanism, environment and defense switching

Plants evolve defenses against herbivores and pathogens in stressful environments; however, plants that evolve tolerances to other environmental stressors may have compromised defenses. Such tradeoffs involving defenses may depend on limited resources or otherwise stressful environments; however, the effect of stressful environments on defense expression might be different for different genotypes (G×E). To test these predictions, we studied genetic variation and co‐variation of drought stress tolerance and defenses at two levels of genetic variation: between and within closely related species. We did this across an experimental drought stress gradient in a growth room for species for which genetic variation in drought tolerance was likely. In apparent contrast to predictions, the species Boechera holboellii (Brassicaceae) from lower and dryer elevations had slower inherent growth rates and correspondingly higher total defensive glucosinolate concentrations than the closely related species B. stricta from higher elevations. Thus, B. holboellii was both drought tolerant and defended; however, optimality theory does predict tradeoffs between defense and growth. Differences between species in the direct effect of water deficiency on glucosinolate production did not obscure the grow‐or‐defend tradeoff. B. holboellii may also have been more resistant to the specialist herbivore Plutella xylostella; a trend that was less clear because it depended on plant development and water deficient conditions. At finer scales of genetic variation, there was significant variation among families and naturally occurring inbred lines of B. stricta in drought tolerance measured as inherent growth, the reaction norm of growth across drought treatments, shoot water potential, and transpiration rates. Evidence for tradeoffs was also found within B. stricta in genetic correlations between resistance and transpiration rates, or glucosinolates and growth rates. No G×E was detected at these finer scales of genetic variation, although sometimes the tradeoff was dependent on drought conditions. Direct effects of drought stress resulted in an apparent plastic switch between resistance and tolerance to damage, which might be a cost avoidance mechanism because tradeoffs never involved tolerance to damage. Thus, when drought tolerance is manifest as slow inherent growth rates, plants may also have relatively high defense levels, especially in stressful environments. Otherwise, defenses may be compromised by drought‐coping mechanisms, although plastic switches to less costly defenses may alleviate constraints in stressful environments.     

Increasing intraspecific facilitation in exposed environments: consistent results from mountain birch populations in two subarctic stress gradients

The stress‐gradient hypothesis predicts that the importance of facilitation relative to competition should increase with increasing stress. The hypothesis has received support from several environments, but multi‐gradient studies on the generality of the hypothesis are exceptionally rare. A within‐species experiment with mountain birch Betula pubescens subsp. czerepanovii was conducted to test the hypothesis in the extreme ends of two subarctic stress gradients (elevation and seashore) in the Kola Peninsula, northwestern Russia. The high stress sites were characterized by strong winds, temperature extremes and potentially drought. The negative effects of abiotic stress on the study seedlings were verified from performance characteristics. Effects of adult hosts as well as seedling–seedlings interactions were studied. Positive host–seedling interactions dominated in each study site, and three out of four performance variables indicated stronger positive net effects in the high stress sites. In the seashore gradient also seedling survival gave similar interpretations. Also a temporal shift towards host–seedling competition was detected in a low stress site after two study years. In seedling–seedling interactions competition dominated, but the effects were weak, likely due to the ‘noise’ caused by genetic and environmental factors. Our results support the stress‐gradient hypothesis and its generality in subarctic environments, as the interpretations were similar for both stress gradients and several fitness‐related variables. The temporal variation in host–seedling interactions and the difference between host–seedling and seedling–seedling effects hint on size‐dependency of plant interactions: facilitation might dominate when the benefactor is substantially larger than the beneficiary, while competition may be stronger when the plants are of similar size and developmental status.     

丛枝菌根真菌与植物共生对植物水分关系的影响及机理

自1885年Frank首次提到菌根(mykorhiza)概念以来,大量的试验证实了丛枝菌根真菌(AMF)与植物根系之间形成具有一定结构和功能的共生体,促进植物生长并提高干旱耐受能力,在干旱生态系统中发挥重要的作用。该研究多集中在对宿主植物生理生态的影响及其机制方面,然而菌根共生对宿主植物水分吸收和信号产生、传递的影响研究少而分散,缺少系统总结。综述了最近四十多年丛枝菌根真菌与植物共生体对宿主植物干旱适应性影响研究进展,讨论了菌根共生对植物根冠通讯的影响及机理。干旱胁迫下AMF与植物共生,通过影响宿主植物一系列生理生态过程,提高宿主植物横向根压和纵向蒸腾拉力。经典的Ohm吸水模型是该方向最有代表性的研究成果,该模型揭示了菌根共生的根外菌丝具有不同于根细胞的细胞结构和水分运输性能,这为宿主植物提供一种特殊的快速吸水方式,可提高植物对土壤水分的吸收和运输能力。研究表明,AMF会影响宿主植物根冠通讯过程,如诱发信号级联反应,诱导根系尽早感知水分胁迫并产生非水力根源信号,提高宿主对干旱的耐受性。讨论了AMF在根冠通讯分子机制研究方面存在的问题及可能的解决途径,展望了AMF在干旱农业生产中的应用潜力。     

二氧化硫增强拟南芥植株对干旱的适应性

以模式植物拟南芥为材料,研究SO_2对植物干旱适应性的影响。采用分光光度法检测植物干旱生理指标的变化,并用半定量RT-PCR技术分析了拟南芥热激基因和干旱响应基因的转录水平。研究发现:4周龄拟南芥植株暴露于30mg/m3的SO_2后,6—72h间叶面气孔开度显著低于对照并逐渐减小,在暴露48h和72h时,热激转录因子HsfA2和热激基因Hsp17.7、Hsp17.6B、Hsp17.6C转录上调,干旱响应基因DREB2A、DREB2B和RD29A表达增强;在SO_2熏气72h后进行干旱胁迫,干旱期间SO_2预暴露植株的叶片相对含水量高于非熏气干旱处理组,植株萎蔫程度比后者明显减轻,且SO_2预暴露植株的地上组织中可溶性糖和脯氨酸含量升高,超氧化物歧化酶活性提高,丙二醛含量降低。结果表明:SO_2能降低气孔开度、提高抗氧化能力、上调热激基因和干旱响应基因转录,并能促进干旱期间植物细胞内渗透调节物质的合成和积累,促使抗氧化酶活性提高,从而降低干旱胁迫对植株造成的氧化损伤,增强拟南芥对干旱的适应性。植物通过基因转录应答、酶活性改变、渗透调节物质积累等,在适应环境高浓度SO_2的同时,提高了对干旱的适应性。     

Azospirillum brasilense ameliorates the response of Arabidopsis thaliana to drought mainly via enhancement of ABA levels

Production of phytohormones is one of the main mechanisms to explain the beneficial effects of plant growth‐promoting rhizobacteria (PGPR) such as Azospirillum sp. The PGPRs induce plant growth and development, and reduce stress susceptibility. However, little is known regarding the stress‐related phytohormone abscisic acid (ABA) produced by bacteria. We investigated the effects of Azospirillum brasilense Sp 245 strain on Arabidopsis thaliana Col‐0 and aba2‐1 mutant plants, evaluating the morphophysiological and biochemical responses when watered and in drought. We used an in vitro‐grown system to study changes in the root volume and architecture after inoculation with Azospirillum in Arabidopsis wild‐type Col‐0 and on the mutant aba2‐1, during early growth. To examine Arabidopsis development and reproductive success as affected by the bacteria, ABA and drought, a pot experiment using Arabidopsis Col‐0 plants was also carried out. Azospirillum brasilense augmented plant biomass, altered root architecture by increasing lateral roots number, stimulated photosynthetic and photoprotective pigments and retarded water loss in correlation with incremented ABA levels. As well, inoculation improved plants seed yield, plants survival, proline levels and relative leaf water content; it also decreased stomatal conductance, malondialdehyde and relative soil water content in plants submitted to drought. Arabidopsis inoculation with A. brasilense improved plants performance, especially in drought.     

塔里木盆地南缘旱生芦苇生态特征与水盐因子关系

选择位于塔里木盆地南缘极端干旱区的克里雅河流域于田绿洲为靶区,结合经典统计学和冗余分析技术,研究了旱生芦苇生态特征与水盐因子的分布规律及相互关系。统计学分析显示:芦苇沿河岸至荒漠方向株高、盖度和地上生物量减少、地下生物量增加,水分与土壤盐分也呈现一定的梯度变化规律。冗余分析结果表明:水分为芦苇生态特征变化的关键驱动因子,地下水埋深和土壤水分与芦苇的生态特征呈现极显著的相关关系,钠吸附比、全盐与芦苇的生态特征呈现显著的相关关系,其他指标与芦苇生态特征的相关性均不显著。水盐因子对芦苇生态特征影响的重要性排序为地下水埋深土壤水分钠吸附比全盐HCO-3pH值Cl-/SO2-4。综合水盐要素,水分对芦苇生态特征的影响大于盐分。     

拟南芥干旱相关突变体的远红外筛选及基因克隆

干旱胁迫是影响植物生长发育的主要限制因素之一。到目前为止, 许多研究都仅关注于植物对干旱反应的信号转导网络, 而对其中一些很重要的中间成分却知之甚少。保卫细胞定位于植物叶片的表皮中, 控制二氧化碳的吸收以及水分的散失, 已经成为一种高度特化的细胞体系, 可用来研究植物早期干旱信号转导机制。控制气孔的开度在提高植物的抗旱性方面具有重要意义。通过使用远红外热成像仪检测植物叶片表面温度的微小差异, 我们成功地筛选并获得了拟南芥(Arabidopsis thaliana)干旱敏感突变体doi1。在干旱胁迫条件下, 该突变体表现为叶面温度低于野生型, 且失水率比野生型高。利用TAIL-PCR技术成功克隆到该突变体基因NCED3, 并利用RT-PCR方法验证了TAIL-PCR结果的可靠性。     

Programmed proteome response for drought avoidance/tolerance in the root of a C(3) xerophyte (wild watermelon) under water deficits

Water availability is a critical determinant for the growth and ecological distribution of terrestrial plants. Although some xerophytes are unique regarding their highly developed root architecture and the successful adaptation to arid environments, virtually nothing is known about the molecular mechanisms underlying this adaptation. Here, we report physiological and molecular responses of wild watermelon (Citrullus lanatus sp.), which exhibits extraordinarily high drought resistance. At the early stage of drought stress, root development of wild watermelon was significantly enhanced compared with that of the irrigated plants, indicating the activation of a drought avoidance mechanism for absorbing water from deep soil layers. Consistent with this observation, comparative proteome analysis revealed that many proteins induced in the early stage of drought stress are involved in root morphogenesis and carbon/nitrogen metabolism, which may contribute to the drought avoidance via the enhancement of root growth. On the other hand, lignin synthesis-related proteins and molecular chaperones, which may function in the enhancement of physical desiccation tolerance and maintenance of protein integrity, respectively, were induced mostly at the later stage of drought stress. Our findings suggest that this xerophyte switches survival strategies from drought avoidance to drought tolerance during the progression of drought stress, by regulating its root proteome in a temporally programmed manner. This study provides new insights into the complex molecular networks within plant roots involved in the adaptation to adverse environments.     

Aphids in a changing world: testing the plant stress,plant vigour and pulsed stress hypotheses

• 1 The plant stress, plant vigour and pulsed stress hypotheses describe the relationships between drought stress, plant quality and herbivore performance. We used an aphid‐Brassica system to test these hypotheses under different drought treatments.
• 2 The quantity of water added per plant/week was 75%, 50% and 25% of the control (unstressed) water regime for low, medium and high drought stress, respectively, and 50% applied fortnightly for pulsed drought stress. The performance of a ‘senescence’ (generalist) and a ‘flush’ feeder (specialist) aphid species and host plant quality were assessed.
• 3 Drought treatments had a similar effect on the fecundity and intrinsic rate of increase of both aphid species. Aphid performance on unstressed and highly drought‐stressed plants was significantly lower compared with medium drought stress. On average, 20% greater fecundity and 40% greater intrinsic rates of increase were recorded for both aphid species at medium drought stress compared with unstressed plants.
• 4 Plant biomass and relative water contents were significantly greater for unstressed plants compared with high and pulsed drought treatments. Foliar nitrogen concentration was significantly greater in the high drought stress and pulsed treatments, and the dominant glucosinolate (glucobrassicin) concentration was significantly greater in drought stress treatments.
• 5 The present study supports the plant stress hypothesis, although the plant vigour and pulsed stress hypotheses are not supported by our data. The implications of these findings for plant–herbivore interactions under changing environmental conditions are discussed.

     

Drought increases freezing tolerance of both leaves and xylem of Larrea tridentata

Drought and freezing are both known to limit desert plant distributions, but the interaction of these stressors is poorly understood. Drought may increase freezing tolerance in leaves while decreasing it in the xylem, potentially creating a mismatch between water supply and demand. To test this hypothesis, we subjected Larrea tridentata juveniles grown in a greenhouse under well‐watered or drought conditions to minimum temperatures ranging from ?8 to ?24 °C. We measured survival, leaf retention, gas exchange, cell death, freezing point depression and leaf‐specific xylem hydraulic conductance (k_l). Drought‐exposed plants exhibited smaller decreases in gas exchange after exposure to ?8 °C compared to well‐watered plants. Drought also conferred a significant positive effect on leaf, xylem and whole‐plant function following exposure to ?15 °C; drought‐exposed plants exhibited less cell death, greater leaf retention, higher k_l and higher rates of gas exchange than well‐watered plants. Both drought‐exposed and well‐watered plants experienced 100% mortality following exposure to ?24 °C. By documenting the combined effects of drought and freezing stress, our data provide insight into the mechanisms determining plant survival and performance following freezing and the potential for shifts in L. tridentata abundance and range in the face of changing temperature and precipitation regimes.     

Evidence of Drought Stress Memory in the Facultative CAM,Aptenia cordifolia: Possible Role of Phytohormones

Although plant responses to drought stress have been studied in detail in several plant species, including CAM plants, the occurrence of stress memory and possible mechanisms for its regulation are still very poorly understood. In an attempt to better understand the occurrence and possible mechanisms of regulation of stress memory in plants, we measured the concentrations of phytohormones in Aptenia cordifolia exposed to reiterated drought, together with various stress indicators, including leaf water contents, photosynthesis and mechanisms of photo- and antioxidant protection. Results showed that plants exposed to drought stress responded differently if previously challenged with a first drought. Gibberellin levels decreased upon exposure to the first drought and remained lower in double-stressed plants compared with those exposed to stress for the first time. In contrast, abscisic acid levels were higher in double- than single-stressed plants. This occurred in parallel with alterations in hydroperoxide levels, but not with malondialdehyde levels, thus suggesting an increased oxidation state that did not result in oxidative damage in double-stressed plants. It is concluded that (i) drought stress memory occurs in double-stressed A. cordifolia plants, (ii) both gibberellins and abscisic acid may play a role in plant response to repeated periods of drought, and (iii) changes in abscisic acid levels in double-stressed plants may have a positive effect by modulating changes in the cellular redox state with a role in signalling, rather than cause oxidative damage to the cell.     

Physiological Integration Ameliorates Negative Effects of Drought Stress in the Clonal Herb Fragaria orientalis

Clonal growth allows plants to spread horizontally and to establish ramets in sites of contrasting resource status. If ramets remain physiologically integrated, clones in heterogeneous environments can act as cooperative systems - effects of stress on one ramet can be ameliorated by another connected ramet inhabiting benign conditions. But little is known about the effects of patch contrast on physiological integration of clonal plants and no study has addressed its effects on physiological traits like osmolytes, reactive oxygen intermediates and antioxidant enzymes. We examined the effect of physiological integration on survival, growth and stress indicators such as osmolytes, reactive oxygen intermediates (ROIs) and antioxidant enzymes in a clonal plant, Fragaria orientalis, growing in homogenous and heterogeneous environments differing in patch contrast of water availability (1 homogeneous (no contrast) group; 2 low contrast group; 3 high contrast group). Drought stress markedly reduced the survival and growth of the severed ramets of F. orientalis, especially in high contrast treatments. Support from a ramet growing in benign patch considerably reduced drought stress and enhanced growth of ramets in dry patches. The larger the contrast between water availability, the larger the amount of support the depending ramet received from the supporting one. This support strongly affected the growth of the supporting ramet, but not to an extent to cause increase in stress indicators. We also found indication of costs related to maintenance of physiological connection between ramets. Thus, the net benefit of physiological integration depends on the environment and integration between ramets of F. orientalis could be advantageous only in heterogeneous conditions with a high contrast.