Mesophyll cells of C4 plants have fewer chloroplasts than those of closely related C3 plants

The evolution of C₄ photosynthesis from C₃ ancestors eliminates ribulose bisphosphate carboxylation in the mesophyll (M) cell chloroplast while activating phosphoenolpyruvate (PEP) carboxylation in the cytosol. These changes may lead to fewer chloroplasts and different chloroplast positioning within M cells. To evaluate these possibilities, we compared chloroplast number, size and position in M cells of closely related C₃, C₃–C₄ intermediate and C₄ species from 12 lineages of C₄ evolution. All C₃ species had more chloroplasts per M cell area than their C₄ relatives in high‐light growth conditions. C₃ species also had higher chloroplast coverage of the M cell periphery than C₄ species, particularly opposite intercellular air spaces. In M cells from 10 of the 12 C₄ lineages, a greater fraction of the chloroplast envelope was pulled away from the plasmalemma in the C₄ species than their C₃ relatives. C₃–C₄ intermediate species generally exhibited similar patterns as their C₃ relatives. We interpret these results to reflect adaptive shifts that facilitate efficient C₄ function by enhancing diffusive access to the site of primary carbon fixation in the cytosol. Fewer chloroplasts in C₄ M cells would also reduce shading of the bundle sheath chloroplasts, which also generate energy required by C₄ photosynthesis.     

Photosynthetic innovation broadens the niche within a single species

Adaptation to changing environments often requires novel traits, but how such traits directly affect the ecological niche remains poorly understood. Multiple plant lineages have evolved C₄ photosynthesis, a combination of anatomical and biochemical novelties predicted to increase productivity in warm and arid conditions. Here, we infer the dispersal history across geographical and environmental space in the only known species with both C₄ and non‐C₄ genotypes, the grass Alloteropsis semialata. While non‐C₄ individuals remained confined to a limited geographic area and restricted ecological conditions, C₄ individuals dispersed across three continents and into an expanded range of environments, encompassing the ancestral one. This first intraspecific investigation of C₄ evolutionary ecology shows that, in otherwise similar plants, C₄ photosynthesis does not shift the ecological niche, but broadens it, allowing dispersal into diverse conditions and over long distances. Over macroevolutionary timescales, this immediate effect can be blurred by subsequent specialisation towards more extreme niches.     

Recent developments in mesophyll conductance in C3, C4, and crassulacean acid metabolism plants

The conductance of carbon dioxide (CO₂) from the substomatal cavities to the initial sites of CO₂ fixation (g_m) can significantly reduce the availability of CO₂ for photosynthesis. There have been many recent reviews on: (i) the importance of g_m for accurately modelling net rates of CO₂ assimilation, (ii) on how leaf biochemical and anatomical factors influence g_m, (iii) the technical limitation of estimating g_m, which cannot be directly measured, and (iv) how g_m responds to long‐ and short‐term changes in growth and measurement environmental conditions. Therefore, this review will highlight these previous publications but will attempt not to repeat what has already been published. We will instead initially focus on the recent developments on the two‐resistance model of g_m that describe the potential of photorespiratory and respiratory CO₂ released within the mitochondria to diffuse directly into both the chloroplast and the cytosol. Subsequently, we summarize recent developments in the three‐dimensional (3‐D) reaction‐diffusion models and 3‐D image analysis that are providing new insights into how the complex structure and organization of the leaf influences g_m. Finally, because most of the reviews and literature on g_m have traditionally focused on C₃ plants we review in the final sections some of the recent developments, current understanding and measurement techniques of g_m in C₄ and crassulacean acid metabolism (CAM) plants. These plants have both specialized leaf anatomy and either a spatially or temporally separated CO₂ concentrating mechanisms (C₄ and CAM, respectively) that influence how we interpret and estimate g_m compared with a C₃ plants.     

Leaf hydraulic conductance varies with vein anatomy across Arabidopsis thaliana wild‐type and leaf vein mutants

Leaf venation is diverse across plant species and has practical applications from paleobotany to modern agriculture. However, the impact of vein traits on plant performance has not yet been tested in a model system such as Arabidopsis thaliana. Previous studies analysed cotyledons of A. thaliana vein mutants and identified visible differences in their vein systems from the wild type (WT). We measured leaf hydraulic conductance (K_leaf), vein traits, and xylem and mesophyll anatomy for A. thaliana WT (Col‐0) and four vein mutants (dot3‐111 and dot3‐134, and cvp1‐3 and cvp2‐1). Mutant true leaves did not possess the qualitative venation anomalies previously shown in the cotyledons, but varied quantitatively in vein traits and leaf anatomy across genotypes. The WT had significantly higher mean K_leaf. Across all genotypes, there was a strong correlation of K_leaf with traits related to hydraulic conductance across the bundle sheath, as influenced by the number and radial diameter of bundle sheath cells and vein length per area. These findings support the hypothesis that vein traits influence K_leaf, indicating the usefulness of this mutant system for testing theory that was primarily established comparatively across species, and supports a strong role for the bundle sheath in influencing K_leaf.     

Mesophyll cell properties for some C3 and C4 species with high photosynthetic rates

Leaves of twelve C₃ species and six C₄ species were examined to understand better the relationship between mesophyll cell properties and the generally high photosynthetic rates of these plants. The CO₂ diffusion conductance expressed per unit mesophyll cell surface area (g_CO2^cell) cell was determined using measurements of the net rate of CO₂ uptake, water vapor conductance, and the ratio of mesophyll cell surface area to leaf surface area (A^mes/A). A^mes/A averaged 31 for the C₃ species and 16 for the C₄ species. For the C₃ species g_CO2^cell ranged from 0.12 to 0.32 mm s^-1, and for the C₄ species it ranged from 0.55 to 1.5 mm s^-1, exceeding a previously predicted maximum of 0.5 mm s^-1. Although the C₃ species Cammissonia claviformis did not have the highest g_CO2^cell, the combination of the highest A^mes and highest stomatal conductance resulted in this species having the greatest maximum rate of CO₂ uptake in low oxygen, 93 μmol m^-2 s^-1 (147 mg dm^-2 h^-1). The high g_CO2^cell of the C₄ species Amaranthus retroflexus (1.5 mm s^-1) was in part attributable to its thin cell wall (72 nm thick).     

Differentiation of bundle sheath,mesophyll, and distinctive cells in the C4 grass Arundinella hirta (Poaceae)

The C₄ grass Arundinella hirta is characterized by unusual leaf blade anatomy: veins are widely spaced and files of bundle-sheath-like cells, the distinctive cells, form longitudinal strands that are not associated with vascular tissue. While distinctive cells (DCs) appear to function like bundle sheath cells (BSCs), they differ developmentally in two ways: they are derived from ground meristem rather than procambium and they are formed 1–2 plastochrons later. This study describes ultrastructural features of differentiating of BSCs, DCs, and associated mesophyll cells (MCs) during leaf development. BSCs and DCs differ from adjacent MCs by undergoing earlier cell enlargement, greater rates of chloroplast enlargement, reduction of chloroplast thylakoids at late stages of differentiation, more extensive starch formation, greater wall thickening, and deposition of a suberin lamella. The precocious delimitation of the bundle sheath layer is reflected in earlier BSC enlargement and vacuole growth. Derivation of DCs from ground meristem is correlated with late developmental changes in chloroplast size, wall thickness, and plasmodesmatal density. Despite these differences in timing of events, particularly at early stages, the development of the specialized structural features of BSCs and DCs is essentially similar. Thus, proximity to vascular tissue appears to be nonessential for the coordination and regulation of BSC- and MC-specific developmental events.     

Leaf anatomy and subgeneric affiliations of C3 and C4 species of Suaeda (Chenopodiaceae) in North America

The halophytic genus Suaeda (Chenopodiaceae) includes species with the C3 and C4 photosynthetic pathways. North American species of this genus were investigated to determine whether C3 and C4 leaf anatomy are consistent within the two sections of Suaeda, Chenopodina and Limbogermen, present on this continent. All species from section Chenopodina were found to possess C3 anatomy, whereas all species from section Limbogermen were found to be C4 species. Characteristics of leaf anatomy and chloroplast ultrastructure are similar to those reported from C3 and C4 species, respectively, from the Eastern Hemisphere. All species from section Limbogermen have the suaedoid type of leaf anatomy, characterized by differentiation of the mesophyll into palisade parenchyma and a chlorenchymatous sheath surrounding central water-storage tissue, as well as leaf carbon isotope ratios (_13C) of above -20. All species from section Chenopodina have austrobassioid leaf anatomy without a chlorenchymatous sheath and _13C values of below -20. According to our literature review, the photosynthetic pathway has now been reported for about half (44) of the Suaeda species worldwide. The C3 and C4 photosynthetic syndromes are with few exceptions distributed along sectional or subsectional lines. These findings throw new light on the infrageneric taxonomy of this genus.     

The functional significance of C3-C4 intermediate traits in Heliotropium L. (Boraginaceae): gas exchange perspectives

We demonstrate for the first time the presence of species exhibiting C3-C4 intermediacy in Heliotropium (sensu lato), a genus with over 100 C3 and 150 C4 species. CO2 compensation points (Gamma) and photosynthetic water-use efficiencies (WUEs) were intermediate between C3 and C4 values in three species of Heliotropium: Heliotropium convolvulaceum (Gamma = 20 micromol CO2 mol(-1) air), Heliotropium racemosum (Gamma = 22 micromol mol(-1)) and Heliotropium greggii (Gamma = 17 micromol mol(-1)). Heliotropium procumbens may also be a weak C3-C4 intermediate based on a slight reduction in Gamma (48.5 micromol CO2 mol(-1)) compared to C3Heliotropium species (52-60 micromol mol(-1)). The intermediate species H. convolvulaceum, H. greggii and H. racemosum exhibited over 50% enhancement of net CO2 assimilation rates at low CO2 levels (200-300 micromol mol(-1)); however, no significant differences in stomatal conductance were observed between the C3 and C3-C4 species. We also assessed the response of Gamma to variation in O2 concentration for these species. Heliotropium convolvulaceum, H. greggii and H. racemosum exhibited similar responses of Gamma to O2 with response slopes that were intermediate between the responses of C3 and C4 species below 210 mmol O2 mol(-1) air. The presence of multiple species displaying C3-C4 intermediate traits indicates that Heliotropium could be a valuable new model for studying the evolutionary transition from C3 to C4 photosynthesis.     

植物叶片解剖结构的量化及其在C4植物高粱中的应用

测量切片内所有细胞或细胞器的总周长,并乘以切片厚度和校正因子是一种量化植物叶片解剖结构的常用方法。前人在使用该方法时因忽视了细胞大小、切片厚度等影响估算精确度的因素,从而导致计数样本偏少并产生较大误差。通过分析该方法误差产生的原因及其与精确度的关系,明确了该方法在实际应用中不同精确度所要求对应的切片数量。在此基础上,将该方法用于C4植物高粱(Sorghum bicolor)叶片结构的量化,提出叶肉细胞与维管束鞘细胞接触面积(CABM)等参数,发展并完善了植物叶片解剖结构的量化方法。     

Reporter‐based forward genetic screen to identify bundle sheath anatomy mutants in A. thaliana

The evolution of C₄ photosynthesis proceeded stepwise with each small step increasing the fitness of the plant. An important pre‐condition for the introduction of a functional C₄ cycle is the photosynthetic activation of the C₃ bundle sheath by increasing its volume and organelle number. Therefore, to engineer C₄ photosynthesis into existing C₃ crops, information about genes that control the bundle sheath cell size and organelle content is needed. However, very little information is known about the genes that could be manipulated to create a more C₄–like bundle sheath. To this end, an ethylmethanesulfonate (EMS)‐based forward genetic screen was established in the Brassicaceae C₃ species Arabidopsis thaliana. To ensure a high‐throughput primary screen, the bundle sheath cells of A. thaliana were labeled using a luciferase (LUC68) or by a chloroplast‐targeted green fluorescent protein (sGFP) reporter using a bundle sheath specific promoter. The signal strengths of the reporter genes were used as a proxy to search for mutants with altered bundle sheath anatomy. Here, we show that our genetic screen predominantly identified mutants that were primarily affected in the architecture of the vascular bundle, and led to an increase in bundle sheath volume. By using a mapping‐by‐sequencing approach the genomic segments that contained mutated candidate genes were identified.     

Aggregative movement of C4 mesophyll chloroplasts is promoted by low CO2 under high intensity blue light

• C₄ plants supply concentrated CO₂ to bundle sheath (BS) cells, improving photosynthetic efficiency by suppressing photorespiration. Mesophyll chloroplasts in C₄ plants are redistributed toward the sides of the BS cells (aggregative movement) in response to environmental stresses under light. Although this chloroplast movement is common in C₄ plants, the significance and mechanisms underlying the aggregative movement remain unknown.
• Under environmental stresses, such as drought and salt, CO₂ uptake from the atmosphere is suppressed by closing stomata to prevent water loss. We hypothesized that CO₂ limitation may induce the chloroplast aggregative movement. In this study, the mesophyll chloroplast arrangement in a leaf of finger millet, an NAD-malic enzyme type C₄ plant, was examined under different CO₂ concentrations and light conditions.
• CO₂ limitation around the leaves promoted the aggregative movement, but the aggregative movement was not suppressed, even at the higher CO₂ concentration than in the atmosphere, under high intensity blue light. In addition, mesophyll chloroplasts did not change their arrangement under darkness or red light.
• From these results, it can be concluded that CO₂ limitation is not a direct inducer of the aggregative movement but would be a promoting factor of the movement under high intensity blue light.

     

Physiological advantages of C4 grasses in the field: a comparative experiment demonstrating the importance of drought

Global climate change is expected to shift regional rainfall patterns, influencing species distributions where they depend on water availability. Comparative studies have demonstrated that C₄ grasses inhabit drier habitats than C₃ relatives, but that both C₃ and C₄ photosynthesis are susceptible to drought. However, C₄ plants may show advantages in hydraulic performance in dry environments. We investigated the effects of seasonal variation in water availability on leaf physiology, using a common garden experiment in the Eastern Cape of South Africa to compare 12 locally occurring grass species from C₄ and C₃ sister lineages. Photosynthesis was always higher in the C₄ than C₃ grasses across every month, but the difference was not statistically significant during the wettest months. Surprisingly, stomatal conductance was typically lower in the C₃ than C₄ grasses, with the peak monthly average for C₃ species being similar to that of C₄ leaves. In water‐limited, rain‐fed plots, the photosynthesis of C₄ leaves was between 2.0 and 7.4 μmol m^?2 s^?1 higher, stomatal conductance almost double, and transpiration 60% higher than for C₃ plants. Although C₄ average instantaneous water‐use efficiencies were higher (2.4–8.1 mmol mol^?1) than C₃ averages (0.7–6.8 mmol mol^?1), differences were not as great as we expected and were statistically significant only as drought became established. Photosynthesis declined earlier during drought among C₃ than C₄ species, coincident with decreases in stomatal conductance and transpiration. Eventual decreases in photosynthesis among C₄ plants were linked with declining midday leaf water potentials. However, during the same phase of drought, C₃ species showed significant decreases in hydrodynamic gradients that suggested hydraulic failure. Thus, our results indicate that stomatal and hydraulic behaviour during drought enhances the differences in photosynthesis between C₄ and C₃ species. We suggest that these drought responses are important for understanding the advantages of C₄ photosynthesis under field conditions.     

Influence of salt stress on C4 photosynthesis in Miscanthus sinensis Anderss.

• Miscanthus sinensis Anderss. is a good candidate for C₄ bioenergy crop development for marginal lands. As one of the characteristics of marginal lands, salinization is a major limitation to agricultural production. The present work aimed to investigate the possible factors involved in the tolerance of M. sinensis C₄ photosynthesis to salinity stress.
• Seedlings of two accessions (salt‐tolerant ‘JM0119’ and salt‐sensitive ‘JM0099’) were subjected to 0 mm NaCl (control) or 250 mm NaCl (salt stress treatment) for 2 weeks. The chlorophyll content, parameters of photosynthesis and chlorophyll a fluorescence, activity of C₄ enzymes and expression of C₄ genes were measured.
• The results showed that photosynthesis rate, transpiration rate, chlorophyll content, PSII operating efficiency, coefficient of photochemical quenching, activity of phosphoenolpyruvate carboxylase (PEPC) and pyruvate, orthophosphate dikinase (PPDK) and gene expression of PEPC and PPDK under salinity were higher after long‐term salinity exposure in ‘JM0119’ than in ‘JM0099’, while activity of NADP‐malate dehydrogenase (NADP‐MDH) and NADP‐malic enzyme (NADP‐ME), together with expression of NADP‐MDH and NADP‐ME, were much higher in ‘JM0099’ than in ‘JM0119’.
• In conclusion, the increased photosynthetic capacity under long‐term salt stress in the salt‐tolerant relative to the salt‐sensitive M. sinensis accession was mainly associated with non‐stomatal factors, such as reduced chlorophyll loss, higher PSII operating efficiency, enhanced activity of PEPC and PPDK and relatively lower activity of NADP‐ME.

     

Comparison of leaf structure and photosynthetic characteristics of C3 and C4 Alloteropsis semialata subspecies

Alloteropsis semialata (R. Br.) Hitchcock includes both C3 and C4 subspecies: the C3 subspecies eckloniana and the C4 subspecies semialata. We examined the leaf structural and photosynthetic characteristics of these plants. A. semialata ssp. semialata showed high activities of photosynthetic enzymes involved in phosphoenolpyruvate carboxykinase-type C4 photosynthesis and an anomalous Kranz anatomy. Phosphoenolpyruvate carboxylase; pyruvate, Pi dikinase and glycine decarboxylase (GDC) were compartmentalized between the mesophyll (M) and inner bundle sheath cells, whereas ribulose-1,5-bisphosphate carboxylase/oxygenase (Rubisco) occurred in both cells. A. semialata ssp. eckloniana also showed an anomalous non-Kranz anatomy, in which the mestome sheath cells included abundant chloroplasts and mitochondria. Rubisco and GDC accumulated densely in the M and mestome sheath cells, whereas the levels of C4 enzymes were low. The activity levels of photo-respiratory enzymes in both subspecies were intermediate between those in typical C3 and C4 plants. The values of CO2 compensation points in A. semialata ssp. semialata were within the C4 range, whereas those in A. semialata ssp. eckloniana were somewhat lower than the C3 range. These data suggest that the plants are C3-like and C4-like but not typical C3 and C4, and when integrated with previous findings, point to important variability in the expression of C4 physiology in this species complex. A. semialata is therefore an intriguing grass species with which to study the evolutionary linkage between C3 and C4 plants.     

A comparative anatomical and biochemical analysis in salsola (Chenopodiaceae) species with and without a Kranz type leaf anatomy: a possible reversion of C4 to C3 photosynthesis

Leaf anatomy was studied by light and electron microscopy and the leaf activities of RUBP carboxylase, PEP carboxylase, and malic enzyme were assayed in: Salsola australis and S. oreophila grown on the West Pamirs at 1800 m altitude; in S. australis grown on the East Pamirs at 3860 m; and in S. arbusculiformis grown in the Kisil-Kum desert in Middle Asia near 500 m. Carbon isotope fractionation ratio values also were measured on whole leaf tissue for 18 Salsola species field collected in these and other regions of the former USSR. S. australis leaves are cylindrical and in cross section exhibit a peripheral ring of mesophyll and then an inner ring of bundle sheath type cells; and its biochemical characteristics and deltaC values are typical of a C4 species of the NADP-malic enzyme malate-forming group. These traits were expressed independent of the plant growth altitude up to 4000 m. C4 type deltaC values were obtained in 14 of the Salsola species. Anatomical, structural, and biochemical features typical of the C4 syndrome were absent in S. oreophila and S. arbusculiformis. Four Salsola species, including these two, had C3-type deltaC values. Their cylindrical leaves in cross section exhibited two to three peripheral rings as layers of palisade parenchyma. Although their vascular bundles were surrounded by green bundle sheath cells, their organelle numbers were comparable to those in mesophyll cells. Neither bundle sheath cell wall thickenings nor dimorphic chloroplasts in two leaf cell types were observed. In S. oreophila, there was a high activity of RuBP carboxylase, but a low activity of C4 cycle enzymes. Interpretation of these data lends evidence to the hypothesis that a small group of C3 Salsola species, including S. oreophila, S. arbusculiformis, S. montana, and S. pachyphylla, arose as the result of a reversion of a C4 to a C3 type of photosynthetic CO2 fixation in the cooler climates of Middle Asia.     

Characterization of C₃--C₄ intermediate species in the genus Heliotropium L. (Boraginaceae): anatomy, ultrastructure and enzyme activity

Photosynthetic pathway characteristics were studied in nine species of Heliotropium (sensu lato, including Euploca), using assessments of leaf anatomy and ultrastructure, activities of PEP carboxylase and C₄ acid decarboxylases, and immunolocalization of ribulose 1·5‐bisphosphate carboxylase/oxygenase (Rubisco) and the P‐subunit of glycine decarboxylase (GDC). Heliotropium europaeum, Heliotropium calcicola and Heliotropium tenellum are C₃ plants, while Heliotropium texanum and Heliotropium polyphyllum are C₄ species. Heliotropium procumbens and Heliotropium karwinskyi are functionally C₃, but exhibit ‘proto‐Kranz’ anatomy where bundle sheath (BS) cells are enlarged and mitochondria primarily occur along the centripetal (inner) wall of the BS cells; GDC is present throughout the leaf. Heliotropium convolvulaceum and Heliotropium greggii are C₃–C₄ intermediates, with Kranz‐like enlargement of the BS cells, localization of mitochondria along the inner BS wall and a loss of GDC in the mesophyll (M) tissue. These C₃–C₄ species of Heliotropium probably shuttle photorespiratory glycine from the M to the BS tissue for decarboxylation. Heliotropium represents an important new model for studying C₄ evolution. Where existing models such as Flaveria emphasize diversification of C₃–C₄ intermediates, Heliotropium has numerous C₃ species expressing proto‐Kranz traits that could represent a critical initial phase in the evolutionary origin of C₄ photosynthesis.