C4 photosynthesis and water stress

Background

In contrast to C₃ photosynthesis, the response of C₄ photosynthesis to water stress has been less-well studied in spite of the significant contribution of C₄ plants to the global carbon budget and food security. The key feature of C₄ photosynthesis is the operation of a CO₂-concentrating mechanism in the leaves, which serves to saturate photosynthesis and suppress photorespiration in normal air. This article reviews the current state of understanding about the response of C₄ photosynthesis to water stress, including the interaction with elevated CO₂ concentration. Major gaps in our knowledge in this area are identified and further required research is suggested.

Scope

Evidence indicates that C₄ photosynthesis is highly sensitive to water stress. With declining leaf water status, CO₂ assimilation rate and stomatal conductance decrease rapidly and photosynthesis goes through three successive phases. The initial, mainly stomatal phase, may or may not be detected as a decline in assimilation rates depending on environmental conditions. This is because the CO₂-concentrating mechanism is capable of saturating C₄ photosynthesis under relatively low intercellular CO₂ concentrations. In addition, photorespired CO₂ is likely to be refixed before escaping the bundle sheath. This is followed by a mixed stomatal and non-stomatal phase and, finally, a mainly non-stomatal phase. The main non-stomatal factors include reduced activity of photosynthetic enzymes; inhibition of nitrate assimilation, induction of early senescence, and changes to the leaf anatomy and ultrastructure. Results from the literature about CO₂ enrichment indicate that when C₄ plants experience drought in their natural environment, elevated CO₂ concentration alleviates the effect of water stress on plant productivity indirectly via improved soil moisture and plant water status as a result of decreased stomatal conductance and reduced leaf transpiration.

Conclusions

It is suggested that there is a limited capacity for photorespiration or the Mehler reaction to act as significant alternative electron sinks under water stress in C₄ photosynthesis. This may explain why C₄ photosynthesis is equally or even more sensitive to water stress than its C₃ counterpart in spite of the greater capacity and water use efficiency of the C₄ photosynthetic pathway.Key words: C₃ and C₄ photosynthesis, stomatal and non-stomatal limitation, high CO₂, water stress     

Responses of leaf stomatal density to water status and its relationship with photosynthesis in a grass

Responses of plant leaf stomatal conductance and photosynthesis to water deficit have been extensively reported; however, little is known concerning the relationships of stomatal density with regard to water status and gas exchange. The responses of stomatal density to leaf water status were determined, and correlation with specific leaf area (SLA) in a photosynthetic study of a perennial grass, Leymus chinensis, subjected to different soil moisture contents. Moderate water deficits had positive effects on stomatal number, but more severe deficits led to a reduction, described in a quadratic parabolic curve. The stomatal size obviously decreased with water deficit, and stomatal density was positively correlated with stomatal conductance (g(s)), net CO(2) assimilation rate (A(n)), and water use efficiency (WUE). A significantly negative correlation of SLA with stomatal density was also observed, suggesting that the balance between leaf area and its matter may be associated with the guard cell number. The present results indicate that high flexibilities in stomatal density and guard cell size will change in response to water status, and this process may be closely associated with photosynthesis and water use efficiency.     

Drought limitation of photosynthesis differs between C3 and C4 grass species in a comparative experiment

Phylogenetic analyses show that C₄ grasses typically occupy drier habitats than their C₃ relatives, but recent experiments comparing the physiology of closely related C₃ and C₄ species have shown that advantages of C₄ photosynthesis can be lost under drought. We tested the generality of these paradoxical findings in grass species representing the known evolutionary diversity of C₄ NADP‐me and C₃ photosynthetic types. Our experiment investigated the effects of drought on leaf photosynthesis, water potential, nitrogen, chlorophyll content and mortality. C₄ grasses in control treatments were characterized by higher CO₂ assimilation rates and water potential, but lower stomatal conductance and nitrogen content. Under drought, stomatal conductance declined more dramatically in C₃ than C₄ species, and photosynthetic water‐use and nitrogen‐use efficiency advantages held by C₄ species under control conditions were each diminished by 40%. Leaf mortality was slightly higher in C₄ than C₃ grasses, but leaf condition under drought otherwise showed no dependence on photosynthetic‐type. This phylogenetically controlled experiment suggested that a drought‐induced reduction in the photosynthetic performance advantages of C₄ NADP‐me relative to C₃ grasses is a general phenomenon.     

Allele mining in diverse accessions of tropical grasses to improve forage quality and reduce environmental impact

Background and AimsThe C₄Urochloa species (syn. Brachiaria) and Megathyrsus maximus (syn. Panicum maximum) are used as pasture for cattle across vast areas in tropical agriculture systems in Africa and South America. A key target for variety improvement is forage quality: enhanced digestibility could decrease the amount of land required per unit production, and enhanced lipid content could decrease methane emissions from cattle. For these traits, loss-of-function (LOF) alleles in known gene targets are predicted to improve them, making a reverse genetics approach of allele mining feasible. We therefore set out to look for such alleles in diverse accessions of Urochloa species and Megathyrsus maximus from the genebank collection held at the CIAT.MethodsWe studied allelic diversity of 20 target genes (11 for digestibility, nine for lipid content) in 104 accessions selected to represent genetic diversity and ploidy levels of U. brizantha, U. decumbens, U. humidicola, U. ruziziensis and M. maximum. We used RNA sequencing and then bait capture DNA sequencing to improve gene models in a U. ruziziensis reference genome to assign polymorphisms with high confidence.Key ResultsWe found 953 non-synonymous polymorphisms across all genes and accessions; within these, we identified seven putative LOF alleles with high confidence, including those in the non-redundant SDP1 and BAHD01 genes present in diploid and tetraploid accessions. These LOF alleles could respectively confer increased lipid content and digestibility if incorporated into a breeding programme.ConclusionsWe demonstrated a novel, effective approach to allele discovery in diverse accessions using a draft reference genome from a single species. We used this to find gene variants in a collection of tropical grasses that could help reduce the environmental impact of cattle production.     

Climate and the U.S. distribution of C4 grass subfamilies and decarboxylation variants of C4 photosynthesis

I compared the C(4) grass flora and climatic records for 32 sites in the United States. Consistent with previous studies, I found that the proportion of the grass flora that uses the NADP malic enzyme (NADP-ME) variant of C(4) photosynthesis greatly increases with increasing annual precipitation, while the proportion using the NAD malic enzyme (NAD-ME) variant (and also the less common phosphoenolpyruvate carboxykinase [PCK] variant) decreases. However the association of grass subfamilies with annual precipitation was even stronger than for the C(4) decarboxylation variants. Analysis of the patterns of distribution by partial correlation analysis showed that the correlations between the frequency of various C(4) types and rainfall were solely due to the association of the C(4) types with particular grass subfamilies. In contrast, there was a strong correlation of the frequency of the different subfamilies with annual precipitation that was independent of the influence of the different C(4) variants. It therefore appears that other, as yet unidentified, characteristics that differ among grass subfamilies may be responsible for their differences in distribution across natural precipitation gradients.     

Microscopic investigation of changes in histology and digestibility in the rumen of a forage grass and a forage legume during the first growth stage.

An Italian "Dalita" ryegrass (Lolium italicum) and a European lucerne (Medicago sativa) were harvested at 5 different growth stages to determine the anatomical factors limiting their digestibility and in particular the effects of lignification of the tissues. In vitro digestibility, cell wall contents of the whole plant and stem of lucerne and of the whole plant, stem and leaf blade of ryegrass were determined. The rate and the extent of degradation in the rumen of the different tissues were observed by scanning electron microscopy. This degradation occurred very rapidly with the lucerne stems; the xylem of lucerne was the only undegradable tissue whatever the stage. The collenchyma was degraded in the rumen although with acid phloroglucinol it stained positive for the presence of phenolic compounds. Ryegrass stems were digested more slowly than lucerne stems, and the sclerenchyma and xylem of ryegrass were indigestible whatever the stage. The parenchyma located close to the sclerenchyma became indigestible as the cell walls lignified progressively from the third stage. These results contribute to the understanding of the decrease in digestibility over the first growth stage and the variation in rate of digestion of lucerne and ryegrass in the rumen.     

The occurrence of C4 photosynthesis in Yunnan province, a tropical region in South-western China

Floristic composition, morphological functional types, and altitudinal distribution pattern for C₄ species were studied in Yunnan province, South-western China. 159 species, in 6 families and 60 genera, were identified with C₄ photosynthesis. 93 % of these C₄ species were found in Monocotyledoneae, e.g. Cyperaceae (18 species), Gramineae (129 species), and Commelinaceae (1 species), the other 7 % was in Dicotyledoneae, e.g. Amaranthaceae (5 species), Portulacaceae (4 species), and Chenopodiaceae (2 species). Hence C₄ plants mainly occurred in very few families in the tropical region. Compared with those in semi-arid grasslands and arid deserts in North China, more C₄ grasses and much less Chenopodiaceae C₄ species occurred in the tropical region. This indicates the physiological responses of C₄ plants from the two families are very different. Chenopodiaceae C₄ species may be more fit semi-arid and arid environments, while C₄ grasses are more fit the moist tropical conditions. There was a strong relationship between C₄ distribution and altitude in the tropical region. Altitudinal distribution pattern for C₄ species in the region was consistent with altitude, climate, and habitats.     

Silicon distribution and accumulation in shoot tissue of the tropical forage grass Brachiaria brizantha

Silicon (Si) accumulation in organs and cells is one of the most prominent characteristics of plants of the family Poaceae. Many species from this family are used as forage plants for animal feeding. The present study investigates in Brachiaria brizantha (Hochst. ex A. Rich.) Stapf. cv. Marandu: (1) the dry matter production and Si content in shoot due to soil Si fertilizations; (2) the Si distribution among shoot parts; and (3) the silica deposition and localization in leaves. Plants of B. brizantha cv. Marandu were grown under contrasting Si supplies in soil and nutrient solution. Silica deposition and distribution in grass leaf blades were observed using light microscope and scanning electron microscope equipped with an energy dispersive X-ray spectrometer (SEM-EDXS). Silicon concentration in the B. brizantha shoot increased according to the Si supply. Silicon in grass leaves decreased following the order: mature leaf blades > recently expanded leaf blades > non-expanded leaf blades. Silicon accumulates mainly on the upper (adaxial) epidermis of the grass leaf blades and, especially, on the bulliform cells. The Si distribution on adaxial leaf blade surface is non uniform and reflects a silica deposition exclusively on the cell wall of bulliform cells.     

Coexistence of a C4 grass and a leaf succulent shrub in an arid ecosystem. The relationship between rooting depth, water and nitrogen

Here we aim to demonstrate that in arid environments the competitive balance between species can be determined by niche separation with either nitrogen or water as the relevant niche axis. To do this we sampled roots <2 mm in diameter for 5 soil pits equidistant between two coexisting species, a shrub and a grass. Using stable carbon and nitrogen isotope ratios of fine roots we determine both photosynthetic pathway and rooting depth. We also examine the distribution of soil moisture and nitrogen relative to root biomass. Our results for root biomass and stable isotope ratios of fine roots demonstrate both niche separation and competition for resources. Root biomass is highest at the top of the profile where soil nitrogen is highest and soil moisture is lowest. We conclude that while there is competition for resources in the middle of the profile, competition is mitigated by photosynthetic pathway. The facultative CAM shrub grows whenever the soil at the surface is wet enough. The C₄ photosynthetic pathway of the grass is more nitrogen and water use efficient making it better adapted to the low nitrogen in the middle of the profile and low summer rainfall.     

Properties of leaf NAD malic enzyme from plants with C4 pathway photosynthesis

C₄ acid decarboxylation in one group of C₄-pathway species is mediated by an NAD malic enzyme. This paper reports on the partial purification and properties of this enzyme from three species of this group, Atriplex spongiosa, Amaranthus edulis, and Panicum miliaceum. Depending upon the conditions, the Atriplex spongiosa enzyme was 5–30% as active with NADP compared with NAD but the enzyme from the other species was specific for NAD. The enzyme from each species had an absolute requirement for Mn²⁺ that could not be replaced by Mg²⁺, and activity was increased several fold by low concentrations of either CoA or acetyl CoA. For the enzyme from Atriplex spongiosa and Amaranthus edulis, there was cooperativity for malate binding and the activators CoA and acetyl CoA functioned to increase the affinity of malate for the enzyme. The Hill coefficients for malate binding were approximately 2 and 4, respectively. However, with the enzyme from Panicum miliaceum, cooperative binding of malate was not apparent and activators operated by increasing V rather than the affinity for malate. Bicarbonate inhibited the enzyme from Atriplex spongiosa and Amaranthus edulis and its effect was inversely related to the concentrations of malate, NAD, and activators. The possible significance of these various allosteric effects on the regulation of the enzyme in vivo is discussed. Reactant concentrations and other conditions required for maximum activity are reported.     

The effect of temperature on C(4)-type leaf photosynthesis parameters

C(4)-type photosynthesis is known to vary with growth and measurement temperatures. In an attempt to quantify its variability with measurement temperature, the photosynthetic parameters - the maximum catalytic rate of the enzyme ribulose 1.5-bisphosphate carboxylase/oxygenase (Rubisco) (V(cmax)), the maximum catalytic rate of the enzyme phosphoenolpyruvate carboxylase (PEPC) (V(pmax)) and the maximum electron transport rate (J(max)) - were examined. Maize plants were grown in climatic-controlled phytotrons, and the curves of net photosynthesis (A(n)) versus intercellular air space CO(2) concentrations (C(i)), and A(n) versus photosynthetic photon flux density (PPFD) were determined over a temperature range of 15-40 degrees C. Values of V(cmax), V(pmax) and J(max) were computed by inversion of the von Caemmerer & Furbank photosynthesis model. Values of V(pmax) and J(max) obtained at 25 degrees C conform to values found in the literature. Parameters for an Arrhenius equation that best fits the calculated values of V(cmax), V(pmax) and J(max) are then proposed. These parameters should be further tested with C(4) plants for validation. Other model key parameters such as the mesophyll cell conductance to CO(2) (g(i)), the bundle sheath cells conductance to CO(2) (g(bs)) and Michaelis-Menten constants for CO(2) and O(2) (K(c), K(p) and K(o)) also vary with temperature and should be better parameterized.     

Metabolism of phosphoenolpyruvate in the C4 cycle during photosynthesis in the phosphoenolpyruvate-carboxykinase C4 grass Spartina anglica Hubb.

The aim of this work was to investigate the fate of phosphoenolpyruvate (PEP) produced by decarboxylation of oxaloacetate during photosynthesis in the bundle sheaths of leaves of the PEP-carboxykinase C₄ grass Spartina anglica Hubb. Mesophyll protoplasts and bundle sheath cells were separated enzymically and used to investigate activities and distributions of putative enzymes of the C₄ cycle and the photosynthetic carbon metabolism of bundle sheath cells. The results indicate that neither conversion of PEP to pyruvate nor its conversion to 3-phosphoglycerate can account for all of the carbon flux through the C₄ cycle during photosynthesis. It is likely, therefore, either that PEP moves directly from bundle sheath to mesophyll or that more than one pathway of regeneration of PEP is involved in the C₄ cycle in this plant.Abbreviations Chl chlorophyll - PEP phosphoenolpyruvate - Pi phosphate - RuBP ribulose-1,5-bisphosphate     

Coordinated changes in photosynthesis,water relations and leaf nutritional traits of canopy trees along a precipitation gradient in lowland tropical forest

We investigated leaf physiological traits of dominant canopy trees in four lowland Panamanian forests with contrasting mean annual precipitation (1,800, 2,300, 3,100 and 3,500 mm). There was near complete turn-over of dominant canopy tree species among sites, resulting in greater dominance of evergreen species with long-lived leaves as precipitation increased. Mean structural and physiological traits changed along this gradient as predicted by cost–benefit theories of leaf life span. Nitrogen content per unit mass (N_mass) and light- and CO₂-saturated photosynthetic rates per unit mass (P_mass) of upper canopy leaves decreased with annual precipitation, and these changes were partially explained by increasing leaf thickness and decreasing specific leaf area (SLA). Comparison of 1,800 mm and 3,100 mm sites, where canopy access was available through the use of construction cranes, revealed an association among extended leaf longevity, greater structural defense, higher midday leaf water potential, and lower P_mass, N_mass, and SLA at wetter sites. Shorter leaf life spans and more enriched foliar ¹⁵N values in drier sites suggest greater resorption and re-metabolism of leaf N in drier forest. Greater dominance of short-lived leaves with relatively high P_mass in drier sites reflects a strategy to maximize photosynthesis when water is available and to minimize water loss and respiration costs during rainless periods. Overall, our study links coordinated change in leaf functional traits that affect productivity and nutrient cycling to seasonality in lowland tropical forests.     

Investigation of the limitations to photosynthesis induced by leaf water deficit in field-grown sunflower (Helianthus annuus L.)

Abstract. The diurnal cycling of leaf water potential (Ψ_leaf) in field-grown sunflower ( Helianthus annuus ) was used to investigate the cause of water deficitinduced limitation of net photosynthesis. Daily midafternoon decreases in Ψ_leaf of up to 1.5 MPa and in net photosynthesis of up to 50% were typical for irrigated sunflower during seed filling. These midafternoon values were lowered an additional 0.6 to 0.8 MPa by prolonged drought treatment. There was a nearly linear relationship between the decline in net photosynthesis and reductions in leaf conductance over the course of the day. Thus, it was unexpected to find that the low, midafternoon rates of photosynthesis were associated with the highest intercellular CO₂ concentrations. These and other observations suggest that the daily decline in photosynthesis represents a 'down regulation' of the biochemical demand for CO₂ that is coordinated with the diurnally developing need to conserve water, thus establishing a balanced limitation of photosynthesis involving both stomatal and non-stomatal factors. There were no indications that either short term (i.e. diurnal declines in Ψ_leaf) or long term (i.e. drought treatment) water deficits caused any damage or malfunctioning of photosynthesis. Rather, both the daily declines in photosynthesis and the nearly 25% decrease in leaf area induced by prolonged drought appeared to be well-controlled adaptive responses by field-grown sunflower plants to limited water availability.     

Conservative decrease in water potential in existing leaves during new leaf expansion in temperate and tropical evergreen Quercus species

BACKGROUND AND AIMS: This study aimed at clarifying how the water potential gradient (deltapsi) is maintained in the shoots of evergreen trees with expanding leaves, whose leaf water potentials at the turgor loss point (psi(tlp)) are generally high. MATERIALS: The water relations were examined in current-year expanding (CEX) and 1-year-old (OLD) leaves on the same shoots in temperate (Osaka, Japan) and tropical (Bogor, Indonesia) areas. A temperate evergreen species, Quercus glauca growing in both sites, was compared with a temperate deciduous species, Q. serrata, in Osaka, and two tropical evergreen species, Q. gemelliflora and Q. subsericea, in Bogor. KEY RESULTS: (1) In Osaka, the midday leaf water potential (psi(midday)) was slightly higher in OLD (-0.5 MPa) than in CEX leaves (-0.6 MPa), whereas psi(tlp) was significantly lower in OLD (-2.9 MPa) than in CEX leaves (-1.0 MPa). In Bogor, psi(midday) was also higher in OLD leaves (-1.0 MPa) despite the low psi(tlp) (-1.9 MPa), although stomatal conductance was not always low in OLD leaves. In the branch bearing CEX and OLD leaves, most of the hydraulic resistance (86 %) exists in the current-year branch, leading to differences in water supply between CEX and OLD leaves. The removal of buds just before breaking did not affect the high psi(midday) in OLD leaves after 1 month. Psi(midday) in OLD leaves thus appears to be independent of that in CEX leaves. CONCLUSIONS: The moderate decrease in psi(midday) in OLD leaves would contribute to maintenance of deltapsi in the shoots during leaf expansion.     

Warming water and leaf litter quality but not plant origin drive decomposition and fungal diversity in an experiment

The fungi associated with leaf litter play a key role in decomposition and can be affected both by the warming water and the invasion of non-native species in riparian vegetation. Warming water and invasion of non-native riparian species on stream fungal communities have been studied mainly in temperate ecosystems. We tested the effects of warming water and non-native plant Psidium guajava on leaf litter decomposition, conidia density, species richness and beta diversity of tropical stream fungi. Thus, we carried out an experiment using the current mean temperature of streams from northwestern Paraná in South Brazil (22 °C) and two temperatures above the current mean temperature (26 °C and 29 °C). We also used the leaves of a non-native plant (P. guajava), and two native plants (one of similar nutritional quality, and the other of higher nutritional quality than the non-native species) occurring in Neotropical streams riparian vegetation. Warming water accelerated leaf litter decomposition and reduced conidia density and fungal richness in native and non-native plants. However, species composition and beta diversity were not affected by water temperature. Our study showed that warming affects the fungi of streams, the main microorganisms responsible for decomposition and that the nutritional quality of the leaves may be more important than the origin of riparian plant species. Despite this, further investigations should be conducted on the interaction of P. guajava with the flow of nutrients in these environments and how it can affect other ecosystem processes and the food chain. Efforts to study the effects of water warming and biological invasion on the attributes and distribution of fungi in streams are vital, making them a tool for the conservation of riparian ecosystems.     

Determination of relationships between water potential and water saturation deficit in leaf tissue

The mutual relationship between the water potential and water saturation deficit (w.s.d.) was studied on samples of leaf tissue of fodder cabage. Definite values of water potential were obtained by long-term exposure of plant material to an atmosphere with definite constant pressure of water vapour. The resulting w.s.d. values were determined gravimetrically. Water saturation deficit varies indirectly with the water potential. This dependence was linear for values of water potential from ?4·4 to ?43·9 atm. Since the stabilization of equilibrum of water potential between the leaf tissue and surrounding atmosphere was very slow the relationship between water potential and w.s.d. was influenced by the size of samples and by the length of exposure. Therefore this method was more suitable for relative than for absolute measurement.     

A genetic link between leaf carbon isotope composition and whole‐plant water use efficiency in the C4 grass Setaria

Genetic selection for whole‐plant water use efficiency (yield per transpiration; WUE_plant) in any crop‐breeding programme requires high‐throughput phenotyping of component traits of WUE_plant such as intrinsic water use efficiency (WUE_i; CO₂ assimilation rate per stomatal conductance). Measuring WUE_i by gas exchange measurements is laborious and time consuming and may not reflect an integrated WUE_i over the life of the leaf. Alternatively, leaf carbon stable isotope composition (δ¹³C_leaf) has been suggested as a potential time‐integrated proxy for WUE_i that may provide a tool to screen for WUE_plant. However, a genetic link between δ¹³C_leaf and WUE_plant in a C₄ species has not been well established. Therefore, to determine if there is a genetic relationship in a C₄ plant between δ¹³C_leaf and WUE_plant under well watered and water‐limited growth conditions, a high‐throughput phenotyping facility was used to measure WUE_plant in a recombinant inbred line (RIL) population created between the C₄ grasses Setaria viridis and S. italica. Three quantitative trait loci (QTL) for δ¹³C_leaf were found and co‐localized with transpiration, biomass accumulation, and WUE_plant. Additionally, WUE_plant for each of the δ¹³C_leaf QTL allele classes was negatively correlated with δ¹³C_leaf, as would be predicted when WUE_i influences WUE_plant. These results demonstrate that δ¹³C_leaf is genetically linked to WUE_plant, likely to be through their relationship with WUE_i, and can be used as a high‐throughput proxy to screen for WUE_plant in these C₄ species.     

Recovery of photosynthesis in sunflower after a period of low leaf water potential

Photosynthesis was studied in sunflower plants subjected to 1 to 2 days of desiccation and then permitted to recover. The leaf water potential to which leaves returned after rewatering was dependent on the severity of desiccation and the evaporative conditions. Under moderately evaporative conditions, leaf water potential returned to predesiccation levels after 3 to 5 hours when desiccation was slight. Leaf water potentials remained below predesiccation levels for several days after rewatering when leaf water potentials decreased to −13 to −19 bars during desiccation. Leaf water potential showed no sign of recovery when leaf water potentials decreased to −20 bars or below during desiccation. The lack of full recovery of leaf water potential was attributable to increased resistance to water transport in the roots and stem. The resistance ultimately became large enough to result in death of the leaves because net water loss continued even after the soil had been rewatered.