FRET study of membrane proteins: simulation-based fitting for analysis of membrane protein embedment and association

A new formalism for the simultaneous determination of the membrane embedment and aggregation of membrane proteins is developed. This method is based on steady-state F?rster (or fluorescence) resonance energy transfer (FRET) experiments on site-directed fluorescence labeled proteins in combination with global data analysis utilizing simulation-based fitting. The simulation of FRET was validated by a comparison with a known analytical solution for energy transfer in idealized membrane systems. The applicability of the simulation-based fitting approach was verified on simulated FRET data and then applied to determine the structural properties of the well-known major coat protein from bacteriophage M13 reconstituted into unilamellar DOPC/DOPG (4:1 mol/mol) vesicles. For our purpose, the cysteine mutants Y24C, G38C, and T46C of this protein were produced and specifically labeled with the fluorescence label AEDANS. The energy transfer data from the natural tryptophan at position 26, which is used as a donor, to AEDANS were analyzed assuming a helix model for the transmembrane domain of the protein. As a result of the FRET data analysis, the topology and bilayer embedment of this domain were quantitatively characterized. The resulting tilt of the transmembrane helix of the protein is 18 +/- 2 degrees. The tryptophan is located at a distance of 8.5 +/- 0.5 A from the membrane center. No specific aggregation of the protein was found. The methodology developed here is not limited to M13 major coat protein and can be used in principle to study the bilayer embedment of any small protein with a single transmembrane domain.     

Adventures in membrane protein topology. A study of the membrane-bound state of colicin E1.

The molecular aggregate size of the closed state of the colicin E1 channel was determined by fluorescence resonance energy transfer experiments involving a fluorescence donor (three tryptophans, wild-type protein) and a fluorescence acceptor (5-(((acetyl)amino)ethyl)aminonaphthalene-1-sulfonic acid (AEDANS), Trp-deficient protein). There was no evidence of energy transfer between the donor and acceptor species when bound to membrane large unilamellar vesicles. These experiments led to the conclusion that the colicin E1 channel is monomeric in the membrane-bound closed channel state. Experiments were also conducted to study the membrane topology of the closed colicin channel in membrane large unilamellar vesicles using acrylamide as the membrane-impermeant, nonionic quencher of tryptophan fluorescence in a battery of single tryptophan mutant proteins. Furthermore, additional fluorescence parameters, including fluorescence emission maximum, fluorescence quantum yield, and fluorescence decay times, were used to assist in mapping the topology of the closed channel. Results suggest that the closed channel comprises most of the polypeptide of the channel domain and that the hydrophobic anchor domain does not transverse the membrane bilayer but nonetheless is deeply embedded within the hydrocarbon core of the membrane. Finally, a model is proposed which features at least two states that are in rapid equilibrium with each other and in which one state is more heavily populated than the other.     

Effects of chlorpromazine HCl on the structural parameters of bovine brain membranes

Fluorescence probes located in different membrane regions were used to evaluate the effects of chlorpromazine .HCl on structural parameters (transbilayer lateral mobility, annular lipid fluidity, protein distribution, and lipid bilayer thickness) of synaptosomal plasma membrane vesicles (SPMVs) isolated from bovine cerebral cortex. The experimental procedure was based on the selective quenching of 1,3-di(1-pyrenyl)propane (Py-3-Py) by trinitrophenyl groups, radiationless energy transfer from the tryptophan of membrane proteins to Py-3-Py, and energy transfer from Py-3-Py monomers to 1-anilinonaphthalene-8-sulfonic acid (ANS). In this study, chlorpromazine .HCl decreased the lateral mobility of Py-3-Py in a concentration dependent-manner, showed a greater ordering effect on the inner monolayer than on the outer monolayer, decreased annular lipid fluidity in a dose dependent-manner, and contracted the membrane lipid bilayer. Furthermore, the drug was found to have a clustering effect on membrane proteins.     

Calculation of resonance energy transfer in crowded biological membranes.

Analytical and numerical models were developed to describe fluorescence resonance energy transfer (RET) in crowded biological membranes. It was assumed that fluorescent donors were linked to membrane proteins and that acceptors were linked to membrane lipids. No restrictions were placed on the location of the donor within the protein or the partitioning of acceptors between the two leaflets of the bilayer; however, acceptors were excluded from the area occupied by proteins. Analytical equations were derived that give the average quantum yield of a donor at low protein concentrations. Monte Carlo simulations were used to generate protein and lipid distributions that were linked numerically with RET equations to determine the average quantum yield and the distribution of donor fluorescence lifetimes at high protein concentrations, up to 50% area fraction. The Monte Carlo results show such crowding always reduces the quantum yield, probably because crowding increases acceptor concentrations near donor-bearing proteins; the magnitude of the reduction increases monotonically with protein concentration. The Monte Carlo results also show that the distribution of fluorescence lifetimes can differ markedly, even for systems possessing the same average lifetime. The dependence of energy transfer on acceptor concentration, protein radius, donor position within the protein, and the fraction of acceptors in each leaflet was also examined. The model and results are directly applicable to the analysis of RET data obtained from biological membranes; their application should result in a more complete and accurate determination of the structures of membrane components.     

Substrate-induced tryptophan fluorescence changes in EmrE, the smallest ion-coupled multidrug transporter

Tryptophan residues may play several roles in integral membrane proteins including direct interaction with substrates. In this work we studied the contribution of tryptophan residues to substrate binding in EmrE, a small multidrug transporter of Escherichia coli that extrudes various positively charged drugs across the plasma membrane in exchange with protons. Each of the four tryptophan residues was replaced by site-directed mutagenesis. The only single substitutions that affected the protein's activity were those in position 63. While cysteine and tyrosine replacements yielded a completely inactive protein, the replacement of Trp63 with phenylalanine brought about a protein that, although it could not confer any resistance against the toxicants tested, could bind substrate with an affinity 2 orders of magnitude lower than that of the wild-type protein. Double or multiple cysteine replacements at the other positions generate proteins that are inactive in vivo but regain their activity upon solubilization and reconstitution. The findings suggest a possible role of the tryptophan residues in folding and/or insertion. Substrate binding to the wild-type protein and to a mutant with a single tryptophan residue in position 63 induced a very substantial fluorescence quenching that is not observed in inactive mutants or chemically modified protein. The reaction is dependent on the concentration of the substrate and saturates at a concentration of 2.57 microM with the protein concentration of 5 microM supporting the contention that the functional unit is a dimer. These findings strongly suggest the existence of an interaction between Trp63 and substrate, and the nature of this interaction can now be studied in more detail with the tools developed in this work.     

Quenching of tryptophan phosphorescence in Escherichia coli alkaline phosphatase by long-range transfer mechanisms to external agents in the rapid-diffusion limit.

Quenching of the room-temperature phosphorescence of Escherichia coli alkaline phosphatase by several freely diffusing molecules was studied, each of whose absorption spectrum overlaps the long-lived emission of this protein and which therefore can quench the excited triplet state by diffusion-enhanced F?rster energy transfer. The presence of additional nonresonance transfer mechanisms was also detected, from a lack of linear dependence of quenching rate on spectral overlap. The quenching agents used were the dye molecules methyl red, methyl orange, and 2-[(4-hydroxyphenyl)azo]benzoic acid, as well as the embedded heme groups of myoglobin, metmyoglobin, and the reduced and oxidized forms of cytochrome c. Quenching was found to be greatly diminished upon reduction of each acceptor, indicating that electron transfer occurs efficiently from the excited tryptophan to the oxidized form of the acceptors. The elimination of this electron transfer in the reduced form affords the opportunity to separately measure the F?rster transfer rates for the heme proteins. When the transfer rate constant thus measured for myoglobin is applied to a model where both donor and acceptor proteins are taken to be spherical with both tryptophan and the heme group placed off center (a model whose quenching rate equation is newly presented here), the depth of the phosphorescent tryptophan beneath the surface of alkaline phosphatase is found to be 16 A. This value is close to the depth of tryptophan 109 (which is known to be the phosphorescent residue in alkaline phosphatase), showing that with properly chosen probes this technique is indeed valuable for distance determinations in protein structure studies.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)     

A model for multiexponential tryptophan fluorescence intensity decay in proteins.

Tryptophan fluorescence intensity decay in proteins is modeled by multiexponential functions characterized by lifetimes and preexponential factors. Commonly, multiple conformations of the protein are invoked to explain the recovery of two or more lifetimes from the experimental data. However, in many proteins the structure seems to preclude the possibility of multiple conformers sufficiently different from one another to justify such an inference. We present here another plausible multiexponential model based on the assumption that an energetically excited donor surrounded by N acceptor molecules decays by specific radiative and radiationless relaxation processes, and by transferring its energy to acceptors present in or close to the protein matrix. If interactions between the acceptors themselves and back energy transfer are neglected, we show that the intensity decay function contain 2N exponential components characterized by the unperturbed donor lifetime, by energy transfer rates and a probability of occurrence for the corresponding process. We applied this model to the fluorescence decay of holo- and apoazurin, ribonuclease T1, and the reduced single tryptophan mutant (W28F) of thioredoxin. Use of a multiexponential model for the analysis of the fluorescence intensity decay can therefore be justified, without invoking multiple protein conformations.     

Resonance energy transfer study using a rhenium metal-ligand lipid conjugate as the donor in a model membrane.

We measured steady state and time-resolved resonance energy transfer between donors and acceptors in model membranes. The donor was a long lifetime rhenium-lipid complex, which displayed a mean lifetime of 1 microsecond and lifetime components as long as 3 microseconds in the labeled DOPC membranes. The transfer efficiencies were found to be substantially larger than those predicted without consideration of lateral diffusion. The larger transfer efficiencies are consistent with a mutual lateral diffusion coefficient in the membrane near 2 x 10(-8) cm2/s. These results demonstrate that lateral diffusion in membranes can be detected with microsecond lipid probes.     

Association of the internal membrane protein with the lipid bilayer in influenza virus. A study with the fluorescent probe 12-(9-anthroyl)-stearic acid

The lipid fluorescent probe 12-(9-anthroyl)-stearic acid was introduced into the lipid bilayer of influenza virus particles. Fluorescent energy transfer was observed from the viral protein to the probe. This transfer persisted after removal of the glycoprotein spikes which cover the outside of the viral particle, demonstrating that the energy donor was an internal protein. It was concluded that the energy donor was the non-glycosylated membrane protein (M protein), the major protein component of the spikeless particle. Analysis of the emission spectrum of the spikeless particle excited at 275 nm shows that a substantial portion of the fluorescence arises from tyrosine residues, in contrast to most other proteins which contain both tryptophan and tyrosine.It is suggested that the donor residue(s) are located no more than 11 Å exterior to the bilayer surface, and that a portion of the M protein may penetrate into the bilayer.     

Fluorescence energy transfer in two dimensions. A numeric solution for random and nonrandom distributions.

A method of Monte Carlo calculations has been applied to the problem of fluorescence energy transfer in two dimensions in order to provide a quantitative measure of the effects of nonideal mixing of lipid and protein molecules on the quenching profiles of membrane systems. These numerical techniques permit the formulation of a detailed set of equations that describes in a precise manner the quenching and depolarization properties of planar donor-acceptor distributions as a function of specific spectroscopic and organizational parameters. Because of the exact nature of the present numeric method, these results are used to evaluate critically the validity of previous approximate treatments existing in the literature. This method is also used to examine the effects of excluded volume interactions and distinct lattice structures on the expected transfer efficiencies. As a specific application, representative quenching profiles for protein-lipid mixtures, in which donor groups are covalently linked to the protein molecules and acceptor species are randomly distributed within lipid domains, have been obtained. It is found that the existence of phase-separated protein domains gives rise to a shielding effect that significantly decreases the transfer efficiencies with respect to those expected for an ideal distribution of protein molecules. The results from the present numerical study indicate that the experimental application of fluorescence energy transfer measurements in multicomponent membrane systems can be used to obtain organizational parameters that accurately reflect the lateral distribution of protein and lipid molecules within the bilayer membrane.     

Studies of phosphorescent probes for proteins

1. Certain capabilities and limitations of using bound phosphorescent chromophores to study protein structure were investigated. Carbonic anhydrase inhibitors with three different arrangements of singlet and triplet energy levels relative to those of tryptophan were used to determine their ability to transfer triplet energy. 2. Ligands representing each of the three spectroscopic energy level arrangements were found to exhibit triplet-triplet energy transfer with a tryptophan residue at the active site of carbonic anhydrase. This greatly increases the number of ligands which may be useful as phosphorescent probes. 3. The efficiency of energy transfer occurs to varying degrees depending upon the inhibitor. This is a potential source of data for determining the position of the ligand in the binding site.     

pH-induced reorganization of synaptic membrane as revealed by fluorescence anisotropy and energy transfer

Two fluorescent probes, 2-(9-anthroyloxy)stearate and 12-(9-anthroyloxy)stearate, were used to investigate the effects of the neutralization of membrane charges on the organization of synaptic plasma membrane. Steady state fluorescence anisotropy measurements showed that a pH decrease provoked a rigidification of the synaptic membrane surface, whereas the bilayer core remained unaffected. The same effect was observed with negatively charged lipid vesicles. The relative distribution of proteins and the probes was estimated by fluorescence energy transfer from protein tryptophans to fluorescent probes: a pH decrease provoked an increase of the energy transfer, which was most pronounced with the surface probe, indicating an average closer packing between proteins and the probes. The modifications induced by a pH decrease were temperature dependent and were most marked at low temperatures. The results suggest that neutralization of the membrane charges provoked a redistribution of both membrane lipids and proteins. These findings are discussed in terms of a heterogeneous distribution of these membrane components.     

The transverse location of tryptophan residues in the purple membranes of Halobacterium halobium studied by fluorescence quenching and energy transfer

Fluorescence quenching by a series of spin-labelled fatty acids is used to map the transverse disposition of tryptophan residues in bacteriorhodopsin (the sole protein in the purple membranes of Halobacterium halobium). A new method of data analysis is employed which takes into account differences in the uptake of the quenchers into the membrane. Energy transfer from tryptophan to a set of $\text{n-(9-}\text{anthroyloxy)}$ fatty acids is used as a second technique to confirm the transverse map of tryptophan residues revealed by the quenching experiments. The relative efficiencies of quenching and energy transfer obtained experimentally are compared with those predicted on the basis of current models of bacteriorhodopsin structure. Most of the tryptophan fluorescence is located near the surface of the purple membrane. When the retinal chromophore of bacteriorhodopsin is removed, tryptophan residues deep in the membrane become fluorescent. These results indicate that the deeper residues transfer their energy to retinal in the native membrane. The retinal moiety is therefore located deep within the membrane rather than at the membrane surface.     

Quantitation of the förster energy transfer for two-dimensional systems: II. Protein distribution and aggregation state in biological membranes

Analytical solutions are presented of the average rate of the Förster energy transfer for several processes affecting intrinsic membrane proteins within a phospholipid bilayer. The physical phenomena considered here are lateral phase separation of the protein, i.e., formation of eutectic mixtures, changes in the aggregation state of the protein and non-random distribution of protein molecules. It is shown that the average rate of energy transfer among protein and phospholipid molecules labelled with donor and acceptor molecules, respectively, allows differentiation between them and also that the average rate of energy transfer can be used to quantitate these phenomena.     

Sensitive monitoring of the dynamics of a membrane-bound transport protein by tryptophan phosphorescence spectroscopy

This paper presents a tryptophan phosphorescence spectroscopy study on the membrane-bound mannitol transporter, EII(mtl), from E. coli. The protein contains four tryptophans at positions 30, 42, 109, and 117. Phosphorescence decays in buffer at 1 degrees C revealed large variations of the triplet lifetimes of the wild-type protein and four single-tryptophan-containing mutants. They ranged from <70 microseconds for the tryptophan at position 109 to 55 ms for the residue at position 30, attesting to widely different flexibilities of the tryptophan microenvironments. The decay of all tryptophans is multiexponential, reflecting multiple stable conformations of the protein. Both mannitol binding and enzyme phosphorylation had large effects on the triplet lifetimes. Mannitol binding induces a more ordered structure near the mannitol binding site, and the decay becomes significantly more homogeneous. In contrast, enzyme phosphorylation induces a large relaxation of the protein structure at the reporter sites. The implications of these structural changes on the coupling mechanism between the transport and the phosphorylation activity of EII(mtl) are discussed. Taken as a whole, our data show that tryptophan phosphorescence spectroscopy is a very sensitive technique to explore conformational dynamics in membrane proteins.     

Reactions of fluorescent probes with normal and chemically modified myelin basic protein and proteolipid. Comparisons with myelin.

Basic (encephalitogenic) protein and water-soluble proteolipid apoprotein isolated from bovine brain myelin bind 8-anilino-1-naphthalenesulfonate and 2-p-toluidinylnaphthalene-6-sulfonate with resulting enhancement of dye fluorescence and a blue-shift of the emission spectrum. The dyes had a higher affinity and quantum yield, when bound to the proteolipid (Kans=2.3x10--6,=0.67) than to the basic protein (Kans=3.3x10--5,=0.40). From the efficiency of radiationless energy transfer from trytophan to bound ANS the intramolecular distances were calculated to be 17 and 27 A for the proteolipid and basic protein, respectively. Unlike myelin, incubation with proteolytic enzymes (e.g., Pronase and trypsin) abolished fluorescence enhancement of ANS or TNS by the extracted proteins. In contrast to myelin, the fluorescence of solutions of fluorescent probes plus proteolipid was reduced by Ca-2+,not affected by La-3+, local anesthetics, or polymyxin B, and only slightly increased by low pH or blockade of free carboxyl groups. The reactions of the basic protein were similar under these conditions except for a two- to threefold increase in dye binding in the presence of La-3+, or after blockade of carboxyl groups. N-Bromosuccinimide oxidation of tryptophan groups nearly abolished native protein fluorescence, but did not affect dye binding. However, alkylation of tryptophan groups of both proteins by 2-hydroxy (or methoxy)-5-nitrobenzyl bromide reduced the of bound ANS (excited at 380 nm) to 0.15 normal. The same effect was observed with human serum albumin. The fluorescence emission of ANS bound to myelin was not affected by alkylation of membrane tryptophan groups with the Koshland reagents, except for abolition of energy transfer from tryptophan to bound dye molecules. This suggests that dye binding to protein is negligible in the intact membrane. Proteolipid incorporated into lipid vesicles containing phosphatidylserine did not bind ANS or TNS unless Ca-2+, La-3+, polymyxin B, or local anesthetics were added to reduce the net negative surface potential of the lipid membranes. However, binding to protein in the lipid-protein vesicles remained less than for soluble protein. Basic protein or bovine serum albumin dye binding sites remained accessible after equilibration of these proteins with the same lipid vesicles. It is proposed that in the intact myelin membrane the proteolipid is probably strongly associated with specific anionic membrane lipids (i.e., phosphatidylserine), and most likely deeply embedded within the lipid hydrocarbon matrix of the myelin membrane. Also, in the intact myelin membrane the fluorescent probes are associated primarily, if not solely with the membrane lipids as indicated by the binding data. This is particularly the case for TNS where the total number of myelin binding sites is three to four times the potential protein binding sites.     

Structure is lost incrementally during the unfolding of barstar

Coincidental equilibrium unfolding transitions observed by multiple structural probes are taken to justify the modeling of protein unfolding as a two-state, N <==> U, cooperative process. However, for many of the large number of proteins that undergo apparently two-state equilibrium unfolding reactions, folding intermediates are detected in kinetic experiments. The small protein barstar is one such protein. Here the two-state model for equilibrium unfolding has been critically evaluated in barstar by estimating the intramolecular distance distribution by time-resolved fluorescence resonance energy transfer (TR-FRET) methods, in which fluorescence decay kinetics are analyzed by the maximum entropy method (MEM). Using a mutant form of barstar containing only Trp 53 as the fluorescence donor and a thionitrobenzoic acid moiety attached to Cys 82 as the fluorescence acceptor, the distance between the donor and acceptor has been shown to increase incrementally with increasing denaturant concentration. Although other probes, such as circular dichroism and fluorescence intensity, suggest that the labeled protein undergoes two-state equilibrium unfolding, the TR-FRET probe clearly indicates multistate equilibrium unfolding. Native protein expands progressively through a continuum of native-like forms that achieve the dimensions of a molten globule, whose heterogeneity increases with increasing denaturant concentration and which appears to be separated from the unfolded ensemble by a free energy barrier.     

Location of the stilbenedisulfonate binding site of the human erythrocyte anion-exchange system by resonance energy transfer.

The stilbenedisulfonate inhibitory site of the human erythrocyte anion-exchange system has been characterized by using serveral fluorescent stilbenedisulfonates. The covalent inhibitor 4-benzamido-4'-isothiocyanostilbene-2,2'-disulfonate (BIDS) reacts specifically with the band 3 protein of the plasma membrane when added to intact erythrocytes, and the reversible inhibitors 4,4'-dibenzamidostilbene-2,2'-disulfonate (DBDS) and 4-benzamido-4'-aminostilbene-2,2'-disulfonate (BADS) show a fluorescence enhancement upon binding to the inhibitory site on erythrocyte ghosts. The fluorescence properties of all three bound probes indicate a rigid, hydrophobic site with nearby tryptophan residues. The Triton X-100 solublized and purified band 3 protein has similar affinities for DBDS, BADS, and 4,4'-dinitrostilbene-2,2'-disulfonate (DNDS) to those observed on intact erythrocytes and erythrocyte ghosts, showing that the anion binding site is not perturbed by the solubilization procedure. The distance between the stilbenedisulfonate binding site and a group of cysteine residues on the 40 000-dalton amino-terminal cytoplasmic domain of band 3 was measured by the fluorescence resonance energy transfer technique. Four different fluorescent sulfhydryl reagents were used as either energy transfer donors or energy transfer acceptors in combination with the stilbenedisulfonates (BIDS, DBDS, BADS, and DNDS). Efficiencies of transfer were measured by sensitized emisssion, donor quenching, and donor lifetime changes. Although these sites are approachable from opposite sides of the membrane by impermeant reagents, they are separated by only 34--42 A, indicating that the anion binding site is located in a protein cleft which extends some distance into the membrane.