Escherichia coli cAMP receptor protein: evidence for three protein conformational states with different promoter binding affinities

Cyclic AMP receptor protein (CRP) from Escherichia coli is assumed to exist in two states, namely, those represented by the free protein and that of the ligand-protein complex. To establish a quantitative structure-function relation between cAMP binding and the cAMP-induced conformational changes in the receptor, protein conformational change was quantitated as a function of cAMP concentration up to 10 mM. The protein conformation was monitored by four different methods at pH 7.8 and 23 degrees C, namely, rate of proteolytic digestion by subtilisin, rate of chemical modification of Cys-178, tryptophan fluorescence, and fluorescence of the extrinsic fluorescence probe 8-anilino-1-naphthalenesulfonic acid (ANS). Each of these techniques reveals a biphasic dependence of protein conformation on cAMP concentration. At low cAMP concentrations ranging from 0 to 200 microM, the rates of proteolytic digestion and that of Cys-178 modification increase, whereas the fluorescence intensity of the ANS-protein complex is quenched, and there is no change in the fluorescence intensity of the tryptophan residues in the protein. At higher cAMP concentrations, the rates of proteolytic and chemical modification of the protein decrease, while the fluorescence intensity of the ANS-protein complex is further quenched but there is an increase in the intensity of tryptophan fluorescence. These results show unequivocally that there are at least three conformational states of the protein. The association constants for the formation of CRP-cAMP and CRP-(cAMP)2 complexes derived from conformational studies are in good agreement with those determined by equilibrium dialysis, nonequilibrium dialysis, and ultrafiltration. Therefore, the simplest explanation would be that the protein exhibits three conformational states, free CRP and two cAMP-dependent states, which correspond to the CRP-cAMP and CRP-(cAMP)2 complexes. The binding properties of CRP-cAMP and CRP-(cAMP)2 to the lac promoter were studied by using the gel retardation technique. At a high concentration of cAMP which favors the formation of the CRP-(cAMP)2 complex, binding of the protein to DNA is decreased. This, together with conformational data, strongly suggests that only the CRP-cAMP complex is active in specific DNA binding whereas CRP and CRP-(cAMP)2 are not.     

Interaction between the cyclic AMP receptor protein and DNA. Conformational studies

The binding of the cyclic adenosine 3',5' monophosphate receptor protein (CRP or CAP) of Escherichia coli to non-specific DNA and to a specific lac recognition sequence has been investigated by circular dichroism (c.d.) spectroscopy. The effect of cAMP and cGMP on the co-operative non-specific binding was also studied. For the non-specific binding in the absence of cAMP a c.d. change (decrease of the intensity of the positive band with a shift of its maximum to longer wavelength) indicates that the DNA undergoes a conformational change upon CRP binding. This change might reflect the formation of the solenoidal coil previously observed by electron microscopy. The amplitude of the c.d. change increases linearly with the degree of saturation of the DNA and does not depend on the size of the clusters of CRP bound. From the variation of the c.d. effect as a function of the ionic strength, the product K omega (K, the intrinsic binding constant and omega, the co-operativity parameter) could be determined. The number of ion pairs involved in complex formation between CRP and DNA was found to be six to seven. Experiments performed with several DNAs, including the alternating polymers poly[d(A-T)] and poly[d(G-C)], demonstrated that the conformational change does not depend on the DNA sequence. However, in the presence of cAMP the c.d. spectrum of the DNA shows only a small variation upon binding CRP. In contrast, in the presence of cGMP the conformational change of the DNA is similar to that observed when non-liganded CRP binds. For the specific lac operon binding, the c.d. change is different from those observed for non-specific binding in the presence or absence of cAMP. These results emphasize the high variability of the DNA structure upon binding the same protein.     

Equilibrium studies of the cyclic AMP receptor protein-DNA interaction

The binding of the Escherichia coli cyclic AMP receptor protein (CAP) to restriction fragments containing the lac promoter-operator region has been investigated as a function of cAMP concentration, using a sensitive gel electrophoresis assay. Under standard conditions (13 mM ionic strength), the equilibrium constant for CAP binding to its primary site on a 203 base-pair lac promoter fragment is 6.3 X 10(8) M-1 at 0.2 microM-cAMP, and increases to 8.4 X 10(10) M-1 at 5.0 microM-cAMP. The latter is about 10(5) times larger than the equilibrium constant for binding to an isolated, non-specific site. The L8 mutation, which renders the lac promoter unresponsive to CAP in vivo, lowers this binding affinity by five- to tenfold. Analysis of the cAMP dependency of binding over the concentration range of 0.2 microM to 10 microM reveals that uptake of a single equivalent of cAMP is required for site-specific binding. Similarly, the transfer of CAP from a non-specific DNA site to a specific site requires the net uptake of a single molecule of cAMP. In contrast, co-operative non-specific binding to DNA was found to be independent of cAMP concentration with an equilibrium binding constant of 6 X 10(6) M-1. We conclude that the cAMP affinity of the two CAP subunits in the specific promoter complex is not equal, and that the complex structure therefore deviates significantly from twofold symmetry. A model for the regulation of the lac promoter by the intracellular cAMP concentration is proposed on the basis of the equilibrium binding results.     

Salt-dependent changes in the DNA binding co-operativity of Escherichia coli single strand binding protein

The co-operative nature of the binding of the Escherichia coli single strand binding protein (SSB) to single-stranded nucleic acids has been examined over a range of salt concentrations (NaCl and MgCl2) to determine if different degrees of binding co-operativity are associated with the two SSB binding modes that have been identified recently. Quantitative estimates of the binding properties, including the co-operativity parameter, omega, of SSB to single-stranded DNA and RNA homopolynucleotides have been obtained from equilibrium binding isotherms, at high salt (greater than or equal to 0.2 M-NaCl), by monitoring the fluorescence quenching of the SSB upon binding. Under these high salt conditions, where only the high site size SSB binding mode exists (65 +/- 5 nucleotides per tetramer), we find only moderate co-operativity for SSB binding to both DNA and RNA, (omega = 50 +/- 10), independent of the concentration of salt. This value for omega is much lower than most previous estimates. At lower concentrations of NaCl, where the low site size SSB binding mode (33 +/- 3 nucleotides/tetramer) exists, but where SSB affinity for single-stranded DNA is too high to estimate co-operativity from classical binding isotherms, we have used an agarose gel electrophoresis technique to qualitatively examine SSB co-operativity with single-stranded (ss) M13 phage DNA. The apparent binding co-operativity increases dramatically below 0.20 M-NaCl, as judged by the extremely non-random distribution of SSB among the ssM13 DNA population at low SSB to DNA ratios. However, the highly co-operative complexes are not at equilibrium at low SSB/DNA binding densities, but are formed only transiently when SSB and ssDNA are directly mixed at low concentrations of NaCl. The conversions of these metastable, highly co-operative SSB-ssDNA complexes to their equilibrium, low co-operativity form is very slow at low concentrations of NaCl. At equilibrium, the SSB-ssDNA complexes seem to possess the same low degree of co-operativity (omega = 50 +/- 10) under all conditions tested. However, the highly co-operative mode of SSB binding, although metastable, may be important during non-equilibrium processes such as DNA replication. The possible relation between the two SSB binding modes, which differ in site size by a factor of two, and the high and low co-operativity complexes, which we report here, is discussed.     

Steady-state and time-resolved fluorescence studies of conformational changes induced by cyclic AMP and DNA binding to cyclic AMP receptor protein from Escherichia coli.

cAMP receptor protein (CRP), allosterically activated by cAMP, regulates the expression of several genes in Escherichia coli. As binding of cAMP leads to undefined conformational changes in CRP, we performed a steady-state and time-resolved fluorescence study to show how the binding of the ligand influences the structure and dynamics of the protein. We used CRP mutants containing a single tryptophan residue at position 85 or 13, and fluorescently labeled with 1,5-I-AEDANS attached to Cys178. Binding of cAMP in the CRP-(cAMP)2 complex leads to changes in the Trp13 microenvironment, whereas its binding in the CRP-(cAMP)4 complex alters the surroundings of Trp85. Time-resolved anisotropy measurements indicated that cAMP binding in the CRP-(cAMP)2 complex led to a substantial increase in the rotational mobility of the Trp13 residue. Measurement of fluorescence energy transfer (FRET) between labeled Cys178 and Trp85 showed that the binding of cAMP in the CRP-(cAMP)2 complex caused a substantial increase in FRET efficiency. This indicates a decrease in the distance between the two domains of the protein from 26.6 A in apo-CRP to 18.7 A in the CRP-(cAMP)2 complex. The binding of cAMP in the CRP-(cAMP)4 complex resulted in only a very small increase in FRET efficiency. The average distance between the two domains in CRP-DNA complexes, possessing lac, gal or ICAP sequences, shows an increase, as evidenced by the increase in the average distance between Cys178 and Trp85 to approximately 20 A. The spectral changes observed provide new structural information about the cAMP-induced allosteric activation of the protein.     

Is DNA unwound by the cyclic AMP receptor protein?

Superhelical pBR 322 derivatives have been relaxed by eukaryotic topoisomerase I in the presence or in the absence of E. coli cyclic AMP receptor protein (CRP) and of cyclic AMP (cAMP). CRP alone, or cAMP alone do not affect the average linking number of the distribution of the relaxed topoisomers. Hence, they do not unwind the template. In the presence of cAMP, CRP induces a small unwinding. The extent of this unwinding is barely modified when the relaxation is carried out on a similar vector plasmid where the CRP binding site of the lac or of the gal operon has been inserted. Under these conditions, we checked that CRP occupies the lactose control site and that upon addition of RNA polymerase, the corresponding promoter is readily activated. These findings are difficult to reconcile with the proposal that activation of these promoters results from the binding of the CRP-cAMP complex to left-handed DNA sequences.     

Comparison of cAMP receptor protein (CRP) and a cAMP-independent form of CRP by Raman spectroscopy and DNA binding.

The secondary structures of the cAMP receptor protein (CRP), a complex of CRP and cAMP, and a cAMP-independent receptor protein mutant (CRP*141 gln) were examined by using Raman spectroscopy. Spectra were obtained from CRP and CRP*141 gln dissolved in 0.3 M NaCl and 30 mM sodium phosphate at protein concentrations of 30-40 mg/mL. CRP and CRP.cAMP1 were compared at lower protein concentrations (10-12 mg/mL) in a solvent of 0.35 M NaCl and 20 mM sodium phosphate. Raman analysis indicates that CRP structural changes induced by one bound cAMP or by the Gly to Gln mutation at residue 141 are small. Spectra of the three CRP samples are essentially identical from 400 to 1900 cm-1. This result differs from the Raman spectroscopy study of CRP and CRP.cAMP2 cocrystals [DeGrazia et al. (1990) Biochemistry 29, 3557]. The latter work showed spectral differences between CRP and CRP.cAMP2 consistent with alterations in the protein conformation. These studies indicate that CRP and CRP.cAMP1 in solution are similar in structure and differ from CRP.cAMP2 cocrystals. Protease digestion and a DNA binding assay were also employed to characterize the wild-type and mutant proteins. CRP*141 gln exhibited the same conformational characteristics of previously reported cAMP-independent mutant proteins. It was sensitive to proteolytic attack in the absence of cAMP, or upon addition of cGMP. In the absence of cAMP, both wild-type and mutant CRPs bound noncooperatively to a 62 bp lac promoter DNA. The equilibrium constants were approximately 10(6) M-1 in 0.1 M Na+. CRP*141 gln had a 2-4-fold higher affinity for the 62 bp DNA than CRP.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)     

Interplay between site-specific mutations and cyclic nucleotides in modulating DNA recognition by Escherichia coli cyclic AMP receptor protein

Mutagenesis of various amino acids in Escherichia coli cyclic AMP receptor protein (CRP) has been shown to modulate protein compressibility and dynamics [Gekko et al. (2004) Biochemistry 43, 3844-3852]. Cooperativity of cAMP binding to CRP and the apparent DNA binding affinity are perturbed [Lin and Lee (2002) Biochemistry 41, 11857-11867]. The aim of this study is to explore the effects of mutation on the surface chemistry of CRP and to define the consequences of these changes in affecting specific DNA sequence recognition by CRP. Furthermore, the role of the interplay between mutation and specific identity of the bound cyclic nucleotide in this DNA recognition was explored. In the current study, effects of eight site-specific mutations (K52N, D53H, S62F, T127L, G141Q, L148R, H159L, and K52N/H159L) on DNA recognition of four sequences (Class I (site PI of lac), Class II (site PI of gal), and synthetic sequences that are hybrids of Classes I and II sites) modulated by three different cyclic nucleotides (cAMP, cCMP, and cGMP) were investigated. All mutations altered the surface chemistry of CRP as evidenced by the change in elution properties of these proteins from different matrixes. While T127L, S62F, K52N, and H159L exhibited unexpected behavior under combinations of specific experimental conditions, such as the identity of bound cyclic nucleotide and DNA sequence, in general, results showed that the affinities of CRP for DNA were sequence-dependent, increasing in the order of lacgal26 < gal26 < lac26 < gallac26 for all the mutants in the presence of 200 microM cAMP. The apparent association constants significantly increased in the order of no cyclic nucleotide approximately cGMP < cCMP < cAMP for all the examined DNA sequences. Linear correlation between the DeltaG for CRP-DNA complex formation and the cooperativity energy for cAMP binding was observed with gallac26, gal26, and lacgal26; however, the slope of this linear correlation is DNA sequence dependent. Structural information was presented to rationalize the interplay between CRP sequence and cyclic nucleotides in defining the recognition of DNA sequences.     

Interaction of cAMP receptor protein from Escherichia coli with cAMP and DNA studied by differential scanning calorimetry

The cyclic AMP receptor protein (CRP) regulates the expression of many genes in Escherichia coli. The protein is a homodimer, and each monomer is folded into two distinct structural domains. In this study, we have used differential scanning calorimetry (DSC) and circular dichroism (CD) to measure the enthalpy change and melting temperature of the apo-CRP and CRP complexes with cAMP or DNA sequences lac, gal, and palindromic ICAP. DSC and CD measurements showed irreversible thermal denaturation process of CRP. Enthalpy of dissociation of the protein–DNA complex, as measured by DSC, depends on the DNA sequence. The thermal transition of the protein in CRP-DNA complexes, measured by CD, indicates that the protein stability in the complex is also DNA sequence-dependent.     

Cooperative non-specific DNA binding of the N-terminal core of the cyclic AMP receptor protein of Escherichia coli and its modulation by cyclic AMP

The non-specific DNA binding of CRP and its N-terminal core, alpha CRP, to a 298 base pair DNA fragment, in the presence and absence of cAMP, has been studied using the nitrocellulose filter binding technique and analysed quantitatively using the theory of Clore et al. [J. Mol. Biol. (1982) 155, 447-466]. It is shown that both CRP and alpha CRP bind cooperatively to DNA. At an ionic strength of 100 mM and pH 7.5, the intrinsic equilibrium association constant for the binding of alpha CRP to DNA is approximately 10-times smaller than that for CRP, but the cooperativity parameter is approximately 17-times larger for alpha CRP than CRP. cAMP exerts its effect solely on the intrinsic equilibrium constant and does not alter the cooperativity. In the case of alpha CRP, cAMP reduces the intrinsic equilibrium association constant by a factor of 3, in contrast to the case of CRP where cAMP increases it by a factor of 3. The possible location of the DNA binding site present in the N-terminal core of CRP is discussed in the light of crystallographic data on the cAMP . CRP complex [McKay et al. (1982) J. Biol. Chem. 257, 9518-9524].     

Interaction of recA protein with single-stranded DNA. Quantitative aspects of binding affinity modulation by nucleotide cofactors

We have investigated quantitative molecular aspects of the interaction of recA protein with single-stranded DNA, by using a fluorescent modified-DNA referred to as etheno-M13 DNA. In addition, the effects of the nucleotide cofactors ATP and ADP, and the analogues ATP-gamma-S, AMP-P-C-P, and AMP-P-N-P on this interaction have been studied. It is shown that ATP, AMP-P-N-P and, in particular, ATP-gamma-S significantly increase the affinity of recA protein for single-stranded DNA, whereas ADP and, to a lesser degree, AMP-P-C-P decrease the affinity. Binding to etheno-M13 single-stranded DNA is co-operative, with the value of the co-operativity parameter, omega, being approximately 50 under all conditions measured. The effect that ADP has on recA protein-DNA affinity is to lower the intrinsic binding constant, but it has no effect on the co-operativity of binding. In addition, the stability of the recA protein-DNA complex is very salt dependent (d log K/d log [NaC1] approximately -10) and it is the intrinsic binding affinity rather than the co-operativity of binding that is affected; thus, under all conditions observed, recA protein binds single-stranded DNA co-operatively with a value of omega = 50 +/- 10. The binding affinity is also influenced by the type of anion present, being approximately 10,000-fold higher when acetate ion is present instead of chloride ion. These data have been interpreted to suggest that recA protein forms up to five ionic interactions when it binds to single-stranded DNA and that five to six anions are displaced upon binding. The modulation of recA protein-DNA complex stability by nucleotide cofactors suggests that these cofactors play a role in the cycling of recA protein on and off single-stranded DNA, with ATP being required for DNA binding under physiological conditions and ADP serving as a "release" factor. These results are discussed in terms of a model for the role of ATP hydrolysis in a recA protein-single stranded DNA binding cycle.     

Specific DNA binding of the cAMP receptor protein within the lac operon stabilizes double-stranded DNA in the presence of cAMP

The effects of varying amounts of cAMP receptor protein (CRP) in the presence and absence of cAMP on the melting and differential melting curves of a 301-bp fragment containing the lac control region in 5 mM Na+ have been investigated. The native 301-bp fragment consists of three cooperatively melting thermalites. At 5 mM Na+, thermalite I (155 bp) has a Tm of 66.4 degrees C and the melting transitions of thermalites II (81 bp) and III (65 bp) are superimposed with a Tm of 61.9 degrees C. The specific DNA target site for CRP and the lac promotor are located within thermalite II. CRP alone exerts no specific effects on the melting of the 301-bp fragment, non-specific DNA binding of CRP resulting in a progressive stabilization of the double-stranded DNA by increasing the number of base pairs melting at a higher Tm in a non-cooperative transition. The cAMP-CRP complex, however, exerts a specific effect with a region of approximately 36 bp, comprising the specific CRP binding site and a neighbouring region of DNA, being stabilized. The appearance of this new cooperatively melting region, known as thermalite IV, is associated with a corresponding decrease in the area of thermalites II/III. The Tm of thermalite IV is 64.4 degrees C, 2.5 degrees C higher than that of thermalites II/III. With two or more cAMP-CRP complexes bound per 301-bp fragment, the stabilization also affects the remaining 110 bp now making up thermalites II/III whose Tm is increased by 1 degrees C to 62.9 degrees C. The implications of these findings for various models of the mode of action of the cAMP-CRP complex are discussed.