A microbead-based system for identifying and characterizing RNA-protein interactions by flow cytometry

We present a high throughput, versatile approach to identify RNA-protein interactions and to determine nucleotides important for specific protein binding. In this approach, oligonucleotides are coupled to microbeads and hybridized to RNA-protein complexes. The presence or absence of RNA and/or protein fluorescence indicates the formation of an oligo-RNA-protein complex on each bead. The observed fluorescence is specific for both the hybridization and the RNA-protein interaction. We find that the method can discriminate noncomplementary and mismatch sequences. The observed fluorescence reflects the affinity and specificity of the RNA-protein interaction. In addition, the fluorescence patterns footprint the protein recognition site to determine nucleotides important for protein binding. The system was developed with the human protein U1A binding to RNAs derived from U1 snRNA but can also detect RNA-protein interactions in total RNA backgrounds. We propose that this strategy, in combination with emerging coded bead systems, can identify RNAs and RNA sequences important for interacting with RNA-binding proteins on genomic scales.     

Plaque-lift testing of expression vector lambda gt11 with gold-labeled immunoglobulins

Colloidal gold particles were coated with affinity-purified antibodies against the human plasma protein, C1 inhibitor, and used to probe for fusion proteins of C1 inhibitor with beta-galactosidase encoded by recombinant bacteriophage lambda gt11 DNA. Plaque-lift tests were done with recombinant proteins immobilized on nitrocellulose applying anti-C1 inhibitor gold particles followed by the silver enhancement treatment. This procedure resulted in a sensitive and specific staining of the recombinant proteins and allowed the selective detection of relevant clones in a complex cDNA expression library. Under optimized conditions, plaque-lift testing was completed within 2.5 h after removal of nitrocellulose filters from the plate. Hence, the immunogold detection method provides an alternative to conventional enzyme- or radionuclide-based screening procedures for cDNA expression libraries.     

Cyclic nucleotide-dependent screening of a lamda expression library for nucleic acid binding activities

Here we describe a modified ligand screening strategy for the expression cloning of mammalian proteins that require the activation of protein kinase cascades to activate ligand binding activity. The manipulation of prokaryotic signaling pathways by the application of appropriate inhibitors or agonists to the nitrocellulose filter during functional screening of standard bacteriophage cDNA expression libraries can permit detection of activities that would not otherwise be found in their active state. We have applied this strategy to a A expression library to clone a novel renal cDNA that exhibits cAMP-dependent RNA binding activity when subsequently tested by ectopic expression in mammalian cells.     

RNA-protein cross-linking in Eschericia coli 30S ribosomal subunits: a method for the direct analysis of the RNA regions involved in the cross-links.

A prerequisite for topographical studies on ribosomal subunits involving RNA-protein cross-linking is that the cross-linking sites on the RNA should be determined. Methodology is presented which offers a solution to this problem, using as a test system 30S subunits in which protein S7 has been cross-linked to the 16S RNA by ultraviolet irradiation. The method is based on a gel separation system in the presence of a non-ionic detergent. When a ribonucleoprotein fragment containing RNA-protein cross-links is applied to this system, non-cross-linked protein is removed, and simultaneously the cross-linked RNA-protein complex is separated from non-cross-linked RNA. Oligonucleotide analysis of the S7-RNA complex isolated in this manner showed it to consist of a region of RNA from sections P-A of the 16S RNA. A single characteristic oligonucleotide was absent from this region, and it was tentatively concluded that this missing oligonucleotide contains the actual site of cross-linking.     

Kinetic studies of RNA-protein interactions using surface plasmon resonance

Although structural, biochemical, and genetic studies have provided much insight into the determinants of specificity and affinity of proteins for RNA, little is currently known about the kinetics that underlie RNA-protein interactions. Protein-RNA complexes are dynamic, and the kinetics of binding and release could influence many processes, such as the ability of RNA-binding proteins to compete for binding sites, the sequential assembly of ribonucleoprotein complexes, and the ability of bound RNA to move between cellular compartments. Therefore, to attain a complete and biologically relevant understanding of RNA-protein interactions, complex formation must be studied not only in equilibrated reactions, but also as a dynamic process. BIACORE, a surface plasmon resonance-based biosensor technology, allows intermolecular interactions to be measured in real time, and can provide both equilibrium and kinetic information about complex formation. This technology is a powerful tool with which to study the dynamics of RNA-protein interactions. We have used BIACORE extensively to obtain detailed insight into the interaction between RNA and proteins carrying RNA recognition motif domains. Here we discuss the physical principles on which BIACORE is based, and the required instrumentation. We describe how to design well-controlled RNA-protein interaction experiments aimed at yielding high-quality data, and outline the steps required for data analysis. In addition, we present examples to illustrate how kinetic studies have provided us with unique insights into the interaction of the spliceosomal U1A protein and the neuronal HuD protein with their respective RNA targets.     

GTPase activity of a bacterial SRP-like complex.

We have recently identified a protein (SRPM54) in Mycoplasma mycoides homologous to SRP54, a subunit of the mammalian signal recognition particle (SRP). This protein forms a complex with a mycoplasma RNA related to the RNA component of SRP. We have now demonstrated that the protein has an intrinsic GTPase activity in vitro and kinetic parameters for the enzymatic reaction have been determined. The GTPase activity was not significantly affected by the presence of the mycoplasma SRP RNA. Different regions of the SRPM54 protein were expressed as recombinant proteins in E. coli and were purified to near homogeneity. On the basis of the properties of these SRPM54 fragments two different functional domains of the protein could be distinguished. An N-terminal part was found to contain the GTPase activity and this domain had approximately the same kinetic properties as the full-length protein. Another domain corresponding to a C-terminal fragment contained the RNA binding activity as shown using an assay based on the retention of RNA-protein complexes to nitrocellulose filters.     

Recent advances in protein methylation: Enzymatic methylation of nucleic acid binding proteins

Summary Heterogeneous nuclear RNP protein A1, one of the major proteins in hnRNP particle (precursor for mRNA), is known to be post-translationally arginine-methylatedin vivo on residues 193, 205, 217 and 224 within the RGG box, the motif postulated to be an RNA binding domain. Possible effect of N^G-arginine methyl-modification in the interaction of protein A1 to nucleic acid was investigated. The recombinant hnRNP protein A1 wasin vitro methylated by the purified nuclear protein/histone-specific protein methylase I (S-adenosylmethionine:protein-arginine N-methyltransferase) stoichiometrically and the relative binding affinity of the methylated and the unmethylated protein A1 to nucleic acid was compared: Differences in their binding properties to ssDNA-cellulose, pI values and trypsin sensitivities in the presence and absence of MS2-RNA all indicate that the binding property of hnRNP protein A1 to single-stranded nucleic acid has been significantly reduced subsequent to the methylation. These results suggest that posttranslational methyl group insertion to the arginine residue reduces protein-RNA interaction, perhaps due to interference of H-bonding between guanidino nitrogen arginine and phosphate RNA.Abbreviations hnRNP heterogeneous ribonucleoprotein particle - AdoMet S-adenosyl-L-methionine - AdoHcy S-adenosyl-L-homocysteine - MBP myelin basic protein - HMG high mobility group - ss single stranded     

Identification and characterization of proteins binding A + U-rich elements

A + U-Rich elements (AREs) have been extensively investigated as cis-acting determinants of rapid mRNA turnover. Recently, a number of RNA-binding proteins interacting with AREs have been described. This article presents strategies and techniques used by our laboratory to identify and characterize a family of ARE-binding proteins collectively termed AUF1. However, these techniques may be applied to the study of any protein displaying sequence-specific RNA binding activity. The techniques described here include the purification of native AUF1 from cultured cells as well as the preparation of recombinant AUF1 proteins using a bacterial expression system. Analyses of RNA-protein interactions are also described, including the use of gel mobility shift assays with synthetic RNA probes to monitor specific RNA binding activity in cell extracts or with recombinant proteins. Variations of this technique are also described to evaluate the RNA binding affinity of recombinant proteins and the use of specific RNA competitors to assess RNA determinants of protein binding specificity. Other techniques presented include the identification of specific proteins in RNA:protein complexes using antibody supershifts and the estimation of molecular weights of RNA-binding proteins by UV crosslinking. Results of individual experiments are presented as examples of some techniques. Throughout the article, suggestions are included to avoid commonly encountered problems and to assist in the optimization of these techniques for the study of other RNA-binding proteins.     

Binding of proteins from the large ribosomal subunits to 5.8 S rRNA of Saccharomyces cerevisiae

Specific binding of purified proteins from the large ribosomal subunits of Saccharomyces cerevisiae to 5.8 S rRNA was examined by three different methods: nitrocellulose membrane filtration, sucrose density gradient centrifugation, and RNA-Sepharose column chromatography. RNA-protein complex formation was proportional to the amount of proteins added to the reaction mixture. The binding of proteins to the RNA could be saturated. Such RNA-protein complexes were isolated on sucrose density gradients. Protein species present in these complexes were isolated, iodinated, and analyzed by two-dimensional polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis. Eleven proteins, L13, L14, L17, L19, L21, L24, L25, L29, L30, L33, and L39, were identified. By comparison, only six proteins interacted with the 5.8 S rRNA-Sepharose under similar ionic conditions. They were proteins L14, L21, L24, L27, L29, and L30. To better characterize these binding proteins, the interaction of individual proteins with 5.8 S rRNA was studied by nitrocellulose membrane filtration. Proteins L14, L19, L21, L29, L33, and L39 were observed to bind individually with 5.8 S rRNA. Binding of each protein to the RNA could be saturated. The apparent association constants (K'a), measured at 4 degrees C and in 30 mM Tris-HCl, pH 7.4, 20 mM MgCl2, 330 mM KCl, and 6 mM beta-mercaptoethanol, ranged from 1.05 to 3.70 X 10(6) M-1.     

Analysis of a sequence region of 5S RNA from E. coli cross-linked in situ to the ribosomal protein L25.

70S ribosomes from E. coli were chemically cross-linked under conditions of in vitro protein biosynthesis. The ribosomal RNAs were extracted from reacted ribosomes and separated on sucrose gradients. The 5S RNA was shown to contain the ribosomal protein L25 covalently bound. After total RNase T1 hydrolysis of the covalent RNA-protein complex several high molecular weight RNA fragments were obtained and identified by sequencing. One fragment, sequence region U103 to U120, was shown to be directly linked to the protein first by protein specific staining of the particular fragment and second by phosphor cellulose chromatography of the covalent RNA-protein complex. The other two fragments, U89 to G106 and A34 to G51, could not be shown to be directly linked to L25 but were only formed under cross-linking conditions. While the fragment U89 to G106 may be protected from RNase T1 digestion because of a strong interaction with the covalent RNA-protein complex, the formation of the fragment A34 to G51 is very likely the result of a double monovalent modification of two neighbouring guanosines in the 5S RNA. The RNA sequences U103 to U120 established to be in direct contact to the protein L25 within the ribosome falls into the sequence region previously proposed as L25 binding site from studies with isolated 5S RNA-protein complexes.     

RNA Whole-Mount In situ Hybridisation Proximity Ligation Assay (rISH-PLA), an Assay for Detecting RNA-Protein Complexes in Intact Cells

Techniques for studying RNA-protein interactions have lagged behind those for DNA-protein complexes as a consequence of the complexities associated with working with RNA. Here we present a method for the modification of the existing In Situ Hybridisation–Proximity Ligation Assay (ISH-PLA) protocol to adapt it to the study of RNA regulation (rISH-PLA). As proof of principle we used the well-characterised interaction of the Xenopus laevis Staufen RNA binding protein with Vg1 mRNA, the complex of which co-localises to the vegetal pole of Xenopus oocytes. The applicability of both the Stau1 antibody and the Locked Nucleic Acid probe (LNA) recognising Vg1 mRNA were independently validated by whole-mount Immunohistochemistry and whole-mount in situ hybridisation assays respectively prior to combining them in the rISH-PLA assay. The rISH-PLA assay allows the identification of a given RNA-protein complex at subcellular and single cell resolution, thus avoiding the lack of spatial resolution and sensitivity associated with assaying heterogenous cell populations from which conventional RNA-protein interaction detection techniques suffer. This technique will be particularly usefully for studying the activity of RNA binding proteins (RBPs) in complex mixtures of cells, for example tissue sections or whole embryos.     

Identification of the COMM-domain containing protein 1 as specific binding partner for the guanine-rich RNA sequence binding factor 1

BackgroundThe guanine-rich RNA sequence binding factor 1 (GRSF1) is an RNA-binding protein of the hnRNP H/F family, which has been implicated in erythropoiesis, regulation of the redox homeostasis, embryonic brain development, mitochondrial function and cellular senescence. The molecular basis for GRSF1-RNA interaction has extensively been studied in the past but for the time being GRSF1 binding proteins have not been identified.MethodsTo search for GRSF1 binding proteins we first employed the yeast two-hybrid system and screened a cDNA library of human fetal brain for potential GRSF1 binding proteins. Subsequently, we explored the protein-protein-interaction of the recombiant proteins, carried out immunoprecipitation experiments to confirm the interaction of the native proteins in living cells and performed truncation studies to identify the protein-binding motif of GRSF1.ResultsUsing the yeast two-hybrid system we identified the COMM-domain containing protein 1 (COMMD1) as specific GRSF1 binding protein and in vitro truncation studies suggested that COMMD1 interacts with the alanine-rich domain of GRSF1. Co-immunoprecipitation strategies indicated that COMMD1-GRSF1 interaction was RNA independent and also occurred in living cells expressing the two native proteins.ConclusionIn mammalian cells the COMM-domain containing protein 1 (COMMD1) specifically interacts with the Ala-rich domain of GRSF1 in an RNA-independent manner.General significanceThis is the first report describing a specific GRSF1 binding protein.     

Enhanced specificity in immunoscreening of expression cDNA clones using radiolabeled antigen overlay

A highly sensitive and specific method has been developed for immunoscreening clones from an expression cDNA library. The procedures utilize a radiolabeled antigen detection method described originally for the immunoblotting of plasma proteins (5). Screening of rat alpha 1-antitrypsin clones was used. Comparison between Western blots of alpha 1-antitrypsin using both labeled antigen and protein A detection methods showed that the former yielded lower background and greater sensitivity than the latter. Further, this technique was shown to have a lower detection limit of less than 20 ng through Western blot analysis of varying concentrations of alpha 1-antitrypsin. The procedures are based on the expression of the protein by cDNA clones containing the DNA inserts in the correct reading frame. Following the transfer of phage proteins to nitrocellulose membranes, the bivalent antibodies bind monovalently to both nitrocellulose-bound-antigen in the phage lysates and radiolabeled antigen. The radiolabeled antigen overlay method is superior to the protein A detection method in sensitivity, specificity and reproducibility. This improved method can be applied in general for screening expression cDNA libraries, provided that the specific antiserum and radiolabeled antigen are available.     

Molecular dynamics simulations of the complex between human U1A protein and hairpin II of U1 small nuclear RNA and of free RNA in solution.

RNA-protein interactions are essential to a wide range of biological processes. In this paper, a 0.6-ns molecular dynamics simulation of the sequence-specific interaction of human U1A protein with hairpin II of U1 snRNA in solution, together with a 1.2-ns simulation of the free RNA hairpin, is reported. Compared to the findings in the x-ray structure of the complex, most of the interactions remained stable. The nucleotide U8, one of the seven conserved nucleotides AUUGCAC in the loop region, was unusually flexible during the simulation, leading to a loss of direct contacts with the protein, in contrast to the situation in the x-ray structure. Instead the sugar-phosphate backbone of nucleotide C15 was found to form several interactions with the protein. Compared to the NMR structure of U1A protein complexed with the 3'-untranslated region of its own pre-mRNA, the protein core kept the same conformation, and in the two RNA molecules the conserved AUUGCAC of the loop and the closest CG base pair were located in very similar positions and orientations, and underwent very similar interactions with the protein. Therefore, a common sequence-specific interaction mechanism was suggested for the two RNA substrates to bind to the U1A protein. Conformational analysis of the RNA hairpin showed that the conformational changes of the RNA primarily occurred in the loop region, which is just involved in the sites of binding to the protein and in agreement with experimental observation. Both the loop and stem of the RNA became more ordered upon binding to the protein. It was also demonstrated that the molecular dynamics method could be successfully used to simulate the dynamical behavior of a large RNA-protein complex in aqueous solution, thus opening a path for the exploration of the complex biological processes involving RNA at a molecular level.     

Interaction of R17 coat protein with its RNA binding site for translational repression

The interaction between bacteriophage R17 coat protein and its RNA binding site for translational repression was studied as an example of a sequence-specific RNA-protein interaction. A nitrocellulose filter retention assay is used to demonstrate equimolar binding between the coat protein and a synthetic 21 nucleotide RNA fragment. The Kd at 2 degrees C in a buffer containing 0.19 M salt is about 1 nM. The relatively weak ionic strength dependence of Ka and a delta H = -19 kcal/mole indicates that most of the binding free energy is due to non-electrostatic interactions. Since a variety of RNAs failed to compete with the 21 nucleotide fragment for coat protein binding, the interaction appears highly sequence specific. We have synthesized more than 30 different variants of the binding site sequence in order to identify the portions of the RNA molecule which are important for protein binding. Out of the five single stranded residues examined, four were essential for protein binding whereas the fifth could be replaced by any nucleotide. One variant was found to bind better than the wild type sequence. Substitution of nucleotides which disrupted the secondary structure of the binding fragment resulted in very poor binding to the protein. These data indicated that there are several points of contact between the RNA and the protein and the correct hairpin secondary structure of the RNA is essential for protein binding.     

Detection of double-stranded RNA-protein interactions by methylene blue-mediated photo-crosslinking.

Double-stranded(ds) RNA-binding proteins have diverse functions in the cell. An obstacle to investigating the interactions between these proteins and dsRNA is the relative inefficiency of traditional UV-crosslinking methods for extended regions of dsRNA. We have therefore developed an alternative procedure for RNA-protein photo-crosslinking that efficiently induces RNA-protein crosslinks in double-stranded regions of RNA. We show that dsRNA-protein crosslinks can be induced by visible light in the presence of the dye methylene blue, which most likely mediates crosslinking by intercalating in the dsRNA helix. A recombinant dsRNA binding domain from the Drosophila staufen protein and human protein kinase R were crosslinked by UV or methylene blue to a series of dsRNAs. In each case, the degree of crosslinking was greater with methylene blue, particularly with RNAs with few single-stranded loops. Methylene blue-mediated crosslinking therefore complements and extends the existing repertoire of crosslinking methods for detecting RNA-protein interactions.     

U1 small nuclear ribonucleoprotein studied by in vitro assembly

The small nuclear RNAs are known to be complexed with proteins in the cell (snRNP). To learn more about these proteins, we developed an in vitro system for studying their interactions with individual small nuclear RNA species. Translation of HeLa cell poly(A)+ mRNA in an exogenous message-dependent reticulocyte lysate results in the synthesis of snRNP proteins. Addition of human small nuclear RNA U1 to the translation products leads to the formation of a U1 RNA-protein complex that is recognized by a human autoimmune antibody specific for U1 snRNP. This antibody does not react with free U1 RNA. Moreover, addition of a 10- to 20-fold molar excess of transfer RNA instead of U1 RNA does not lead to the formation of an antibody-recognized RNP. The proteins forming the specific complex with U1 RNA correspond to the A, B1, and B2 species (32,000, 27,000, and 26,000 mol wt, respectively) observed in previous studies with U1 snRNP obtained by antibody- precipitation of nuclear extracts. The availability of this in vitro system now permits, for the first time, direct analysis of snRNA- protein binding interactions and, in addition, provides useful information on the mRNAs for snRNP proteins.