Animal carcinogenicity studies: implications for the REACH system

The 2001 European Commission proposal for the Registration, Evaluation and Authorisation of Chemicals (REACH) aims to improve public and environmental health by assessing the toxicity of, and restricting exposure to, potentially toxic chemicals. The greatest benefits are expected to accrue from decreased cancer incidences. Hence the accurate identification of chemical carcinogens must be a top priority for the REACH system. Due to a paucity of human clinical data, the identification of potential human carcinogens has conventionally relied on animal tests. However, our survey of the US Environmental Protection Agency's (EPAs) toxic chemicals database revealed that, for a majority of the chemicals of greatest public health concern (93/160, i.e. 58.1%), the EPA found animal carcinogenicity data to be inadequate to support classifications of probable human carcinogen or non-carcinogen. A wide variety of species were used, with rodents predominating; a wide variety of routes of administration were used; and a particularly wide variety of organ systems were affected. These factors raise serious biological obstacles that render accurate extrapolation to humans profoundly difficult. Furthermore, significantly different International Agency for Research on Cancer assessments of identical chemicals, indicate that the true human predictivity of animal carcinogenicity data is even poorer than is indicated by the EPA figures alone. Consequently, we propose the replacement of animal carcinogenicity bioassays with a tiered combination of non-animal assays, which can be expected to yield a weight-of-evidence characterisation of carcinogenic risk with superior human predictivity. Additional advantages include substantial savings of financial, human and animal resources, and potentially greater insights into mechanisms of carcinogenicity.     

Quantum chemical studies of methylbenz[a]anthracenes: Metabolism and correlations with carcinogenicity

In the context of the bay region, K-region and radical cation hypotheses for polycyclic aromatic carcinogens, molecular properties were calculated for fourteen methyl derivatives of benz[a]anthracene (BA) related to (1) intrinsic substrate reactivities towards activating and detoxifying metabolism and (2)-the stabilities of the putative carbocation ultimate carcinogens. Allvalence electron methods were used, avoiding the inherent difficulties found in the π-electron methods. The calculated substrate reactivities were found to predict major metabolites sucessfully, supporting the validity of their use in attempted correlations with observed carcinogenic potencies. Positive correlations were found between observed carcinogenic potencies and (1) the reactivities of the parent polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons (PAH) towards the initial distal bay region epoxidation and (2) the stabilities of the diol epoxide carbocations. This latter correlation holds when both the methyl derivatives of BA and previously studied unsubstituted PAH are considered together, indicating its potential usefulness as a screening parameter for carcinogenic activity.     

Polychlorinated biphenyls (PCBs): mutagenicity and carcinogenicity

The potential mutagenicity and carcinogenicity of commercial PCBs has been investigated in both in vivo and in vitro systems and several conclusions can be drawn from these studies. (1) PCBs can covalently adduct DNA both in vivo and in vitro (using a source of metabolic activation); the more highly chlorinated biphenyls are poorly metabolized and these compounds tend to exhibit very low binding to DNA. Based on the structure-activity relationships for PCBs (Safe, 1984) it is unlikely that the more toxic compounds such as 3,3',4,4',5-penta- and 3,3',4,4',5,5'-hexachlorobiphenyl, would form covalent adducts with DNA. (2) PCB mixtures and individual compounds exhibit minimal mutagenic activity in most assay systems. (3) The more highly chlorinated PCB mixtures (i.e. greater than 50% Cl by weight) are hepatocarcinogens in rodents whereas data from a limited number of studies suggest that the lower chlorinated mixtures are not carcinogenic. (4) In some model systems, the higher chlorinated PCB mixtures act as promoters of preneoplastic lesions and hepatocellular carcinomas in rodents treated with a variety of initiators. (5) Aroclor 1254 acts as a promoter of skin papilloma formation in HRS/J hairless mice and structure-activity and genetic studies suggest that the Ah receptor is necessary but not sufficient for the activity of halogenated aryl hydrocarbons as promoters in hairless mice. (6) Individual PCB congeners and higher chlorinated commercial mixtures also exhibit anti-carcinogenic activity in the CD-1 mouse skin cancer model. (7) Results from occupational studies suggest that individuals exposed to PCBs may have an excess of cancer at some sites, however, the most comprehensive study (Brown, 1987) suggests that there are no significant increases in the overall cancer rate in workers exposed to PCBs. Follow-up and continuing epidemiological studies on the PCB-exposed workers are required to further clarify the potential carcinogenic effects of PCBs on humans. In several strains of rats and mice, there is a high incidence of hepatic preneoplastic lesions and carcinomas and these lesions can be induced by diverse promoting agents (Schulte-Hermann et al., 1983; Weinstein, 1984). Since PCBs are not mutagenic and do not readily form covalent adducts with cellular DNA, it is likely that the higher chlorinated biphenyls are not genotoxic and act as promoters of carcinogenesis in rodents. A comparable mechanism has been suggested for 2,3,7,8-TCDD (Shu et al., 1987; Weinstein, 1984). For PCBs, the role of the Ah receptor in mediating their activity as promoters has not been delineated.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 400 WORDS)     

The possible role of azoreduction in the bacterial mutagenicity of 4-dimethylaminoazobenzene (DAB) and 2 of its analogues (6BT and 5I)

The extent to which azoreductive cleavage contributes to the bacterial mutagenicity of 3 azo compounds has been investigated. The compounds studied were the rodent-liver carcinogens 4-dimethylaminoazobenzene (DAB) and 6-dimethylaminophenylazobenzthiazole (6BT), and the reported non-carcinogenic isostere 5-dimethylaminophenylazoindoline (5I). Although each of these compounds is mutagenic to Salmonella when evaluated using a pre-incubation protocol and in the presence of an induced rat-liver S9 mix, the constituent amines (cleavage products) were essentially inactive. It is therefore concluded that the mutagenic response reported for DAB, 6BT and 5I is related to metabolic activation of the intact molecules. In addition, the non-mutagenicity of 4'-phenyl-4-dimethylaminoazobenzene (4PhDAB) suggests that azoreductase activity is low in the Salmonella preincubation assay, at least as conducted in this laboratory. In the case of 4PhDAB, less than 1.4% azoreduction would yield sufficient quantities of the derived amine, 4-aminobiphenyl, for a positive mutagenic response to have been observed.     

Quantum chemical studies of polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons and their metabolites: correlations to carcinogenicity.

In the context of the bay region hypothesis for polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbon (PAH) carcinogenesis, molecular properties were calculated for seventeen polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons related to (1) intrinsic substrate reactivities towards activating and detoxifying metabolism and (2) the stabilities of the putative carbocation ultimate carcinogens. All-valence electron methods were used, avoiding the inherent difficulties found in the pi-electron methods. The calculated substrate reactivities were found to predict major metabolites successfully, supporting the validity of their use in attempted correlations with observed carcinogenic potencies. Positive correlations were found between observed carcinogenic potencies and (1) the reactivities of the parent polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons towards the initial distal bay region epoxidation and (2) the stabilities of the diol epoxide carbocations. The reactivities of the distal bay region diol epoxides, were high for both carcinogenic and non-carcinogenic compounds, implying that the second epoxidation does not determine relative carcinogenic activity. Support for a possible alternative hypothesis, that polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons are activated by one electron oxidation, was also found.     

Phenotype/genotype correlations in Gaucher disease type I: clinical and therapeutic implications.

Gaucher disease is the most frequent lysosomal storage disease and the most prevalent genetic disease among Ashkenazi Jews. Gaucher disease type 1 is characterized by marked variability of the phenotype and by the absence of neuronopathic involvement. To test the hypothesis that this phenotypic variability was due to genetic compounds of several different mutant alleles, 161 symptomatic patients with Gaucher disease type 1 (> 90% Ashkenazi Jewish) were analyzed for clinical involvement, and their genotypes were determined. Qualitative and quantitative measures of disease involvement included age at onset of the disease manifestations, hepatic and splenic volumes, age at splenectomy, and severity of bony disease. Highly statistically significant differences (P < .005) were found in each clinical parameter in patients with the N370S/N370S genotype compared with those patients with the N370S/84GG, N370S/L444P, and N370S/? genotypes. The symptomatic N370S homozygotes had onset of their disease two to three decades later than patients with the other genotypes. In addition, patients with the latter genotypes have much more severely involved livers, spleens, and bones and had a higher incidence of splenectomy at an earlier age. These predictive genotype analyses provide the basis for genetic care delivery and therapeutic recommendations in patients affected with Gaucher disease type 1.     

The association of bacterial mutagenicity of hydrocarbon-derived 'bay-region' dihydrodiols with the Iball indices for carcinogenicity and with the extents of DNA-binding on mouse skin of the parent hydrocarbons.

The mutagenic activities of benz[alpha]anthracene, 7-methylbenz[alpha]anthracene, 7,12-dimethylbenz[alpha]anthracene, 3-methylcholanthrene and benzo[alpha]pyrene, together with those of the trans-dihydrodiols derived from these hydrocarbons that would be expected to yield 'bay-region' vicinal diolepoxides on further metabolism have been examined in assays with S. typhimurium TA100 using post-mitochondrial supernatant fractions prepared from the livers of 3-methylcholanthrene-treated rats. Mutagenic activities obtained have been compared with: (a) the extents of reaction with DNA that occur in mouse skin following treatment with these hydrocarbons; (b) the carcinogenicities of the hydrocarbons expressed as Iball indices; (c) their activities as tumour-initiating agents on mouse skin. Close positive associations were found between the microsome-mediated mutagenicities of the dihydrodiols that could yield "bay-region" diol-epoxides and: (a) the extents of reaction with DNA in hydrocarbon-treated mouse skin; (b) the carcinogenic potencies of the parent hydrocarbons; although these correlations are not perfect, the mutagenic activities of the hydrocarbons themselves in microsome-mediated assays with S. typhimurium show no correlation with their extents of DNA binding on mouse skin and a poor correlation with their activities as initiating agents. These comparisons also indicated a statistically-significant positive correlation between carcinogenicity and the in vivo DNA binding on mouse skin treated with the hydrocarbons. Differences in the metabolic pathways by which polycyclic hydrocarbons are activated in vivo and in vitro are discussed in relation to the improved correlations found with the dihydrodiols.     

Liposolubility as an aspect of nitrosamine carcinogenicity: quantitative correlations and qualitative observations

Carcinogenicity data for a number of nitrosamines have been examined for possible structure-activity correlations with liposolubility by the method of Hansch. Correlations were found in two cases which support a previous mechanistic suggestion and which also suggest a possible difference between the action of nitrosopiperidines and dinitrosopiperazines in inducing olfactory carcinomas. No correlations were found for non-cyclic nitrosamines.     

DNA-binding characteristics of cnidarian Pax-C and Pax-B proteins in vivo and in vitro: no simple relationship with the Pax-6 and Pax-2/5/8 classes

Cnidarians are the simplest animals in which distinct eyes are present. We have previously suggested that cnidarian Pax-Cam might represent a precursor of the Pax-6 class. Here we show that when expressed in Drosophila imaginal discs, Pax-Cam chimeric proteins containing the C-terminal region of EY were capable of eye induction and driving expression of a reporter gene under the control of a known EY target (the sine oculis gene). Whilst these results are consistent with a Pax-6-like function for Pax-Cam, in band shift experiments we were unable to distinguish the DNA-binding behaviour of the Pax-Cam Paired domain from that of a second Acropora Pax protein, Pax-Bam. The ability of a Pax-Bam/EY chimera to also induce eye formation in leg imaginal discs, together with the in vitro data, cast doubt on previously assumed direct relationships between cnidarian Pax genes and the Pax-6 and Pax-2/5/8 classes of bilateral animals.     

Observation of non-linear biomass-capacitance correlations: reasons and implications for bioprocess control

Electrical capacitance has been discussed as a real time measure for living biomass concentration in technical bioreactors such as brewery (fermentation) tanks. Commonly, a linear correlation between biomass concentration and capacitance is assumed. While following the growth and subsequent lipid formation of the yeast Arxula adeninivorans we observed non-linearity between biomass concentration and capacitance. Capacitance deviation from linearity coincided with incipient lipid formation and depended on the intracellular lipid content. As the extent of deviation between capacitance and biomass concentration was proportional to the lipid concentration, it was considered as a quantitative measure of intracellular product formation. The correlation between shifts in dielectric relaxation (summarized as characteristic frequency of the Cole-Cole equation) and lipid content could not be explained by interfacial polarization on the lipid droplets alone. However, the parameters of the Cole-Cole equation were found to be a clear indicator for different phases of growth and lipid production. Integrating all results in a redundancy analysis (RDA), we were able to accurately describe the formation of cellular lipid inclusions. Our measurements are thus potentially valuable as components of future bioprocess control strategies targeting intracellular products such as proteins or biopolyesters.     

Crystal structure of a pentamidine-oligonucleotide complex: implications for DNA-binding properties.

The crystal structure of the complex formed between the dodecanucleotide d(CGCGAATTCGCG)2 and the drug pentamidine, which is active against the Pneumocystis carinii pathogen in AIDS patients, has been determined to a resolution of 2.1 A and an R-factor of 19.4%. Analysis of the structure has shown the drug to be bound in the 5'-AATT minor groove region of the duplex, with the amidinium groups H-bonded to adenine N3 atoms in an interstrand manner. The drug molecule adopts an extended conformation, and the immediate binding site spans four base pairs. Structural details of the drug-DNA interactions are discussed, and comparison is made with the dodecamer complex of the structurally similar berenil ligand.     

Styrene oxide-induced 2'-deoxycytidine adducts: implications for the mutagenicity of styrene oxide

The reaction between 2'-deoxycytidine and styrene 7,8-oxide (SO) resulted in alkylation at the 3-position and at the O(2)-position through the alpha- and beta-carbons of the epoxide but at the N(4)-position only through the alpha-carbon. The 3-alkylated adducts were found to deaminate to the corresponding 2'-deoxyuridine adducts (37 degrees C, pH 7.4) with half-lives of 6 min and 2.4 h for the alpha- and beta-isomers, respectively. The N(4)-alkylated products were stable at neutral pH. The O(2)-alkylated products were unstable being prone to depyrimidation and to isomerisation between alpha- and beta-isomers. In SO-treated double-stranded DNA, enzymatic hydrolysis allowed the identification of the beta3-deoxyuridine and alphaN(4)-deoxycytidine adducts (1.9 and 0.5% of total alkylation, respectively), in addition to the previously identified DNA-adducts. The 3-substituted uracil may have implications for the mutagenicity of SO.     

Quantitative comparison of carcinogenicity, mutagenicity and electrophilicity of 10 direct-acting alkylating agents and of the initial O6:7-alkylguanine ratio in DNA with carcinogenic potency in rodents

The quantitative relationship between carcinogenicity in rodents and mutagenicity in Salmonella typhimurium was examined, by using 10 monofunctional alkylating agents, including N-nitrosamides, alkyl methanesulfonates, epoxides, β-propiolactone and 1,3-propane sultone. The compounds were assayed for mutagenicity in two S. typhimurium strains (TA1535 and TA100) and in plate and liquid assays. The mutagenic activity of the agents was compared with their alkylating activity towards 4-(4′-nitrobenzyl)pyridine and with their half-lives (solvolysis constants) in an aqueous medium. No correlations between these variables were found, nor was mutagenic activity correlated with estimates of carcinogenicity in rodents.

There was a positive relationship between carcinogenicity and the initial ratios of 7-: O⁶-alkylguanine formed or expected after their reaction with double-stranded DNA in vitro. The results suggest that alkylation of guanine at position O⁶ (or at other O atoms of DNA bases) may be a critical DNA-base modification that determines the overall carcinogenicity of these alkylating agents in rodents.     

Binding mode and affinity studies of DNA-binding agents using topoisomerase I DNA unwinding assay

A topoisomerase I DNA unwinding assay has been used to determine the relative DNA-binding affinities of a model pair of homologous naphthalene diimides. Binding affinity data were corroborated using calorimetric (ITC) and spectrophotometric (titration and T(m)) studies, with substituent size playing a significant role in binding. The assay was also used to investigate the mode of binding adopted by several known DNA-binding agents, including SYBR Green and PicoGreen. Some of the compounds exhibited unexpected binding modes.     

The effects of hydrostatic pressure change on DNA integrity in the hydrothermal-vent mussel Bathymodiolus azoricus: implications for future deep-sea mutagenicity studies

Comet and agarose gel electrophoresis (AGE) assays were used to show that haemocytes (blood cells) and gill tissues of vent mussels, Bathymodiolus azoricus, are sensitive to hydrostatic pressure change, but can repair DNA damage induced by retrieval from 840 m to the sea surface. In contrast, animals collected from 1700 m survived for only a few days in the laboratory, which was reflected in their poor DNA quality. These findings support the hypothesis of a physiological barrier to survival around 1000-1500 m depth, which these results show affects both vent and non-vent species alike. Based on in vitro experimental exposures to hydrogen peroxide and MMC, vent mussels appear to have sensitivities to the environmental mutagens that are not significantly different from those of coastal mussels.