Colony formation in agar by adult bone marrow multipotential hemopoietic cells

Erythroid colony formation in agar cultures of CBA bone marrow cells was stimulated by the addition of pokeweed mitogen-stimulated spleen conditioned medium (SCM). Optimal colony numbers were obtained when cultures contained 20% fetal calf serum and concentrated spleen conditioned medium. By 7 days of incubation, large burst or unicentric erythroid colonies occurred at a maximum frequency of 40–50 per 10⁵ bone marrow cells. In CBA mice the cells forming erythroid colonies were also present in the spleen, peripheral blood, and within individual spleen colonies. A marked strain variation was noted with CBA mice having the highest levels of erythroid colony-forming cells. In CBA mice erythroid colony-forming cells were mainly non-cycling (12.5% reduction in colony numbers after incubation with hydroxyurea or 3H-thymidine). Erythroid colony-forming cells sedimented with a peak of 4.5 mm/hr, compared with CFU-S, which sedimented at 4.25 mm/hr. The addition of erythropoietin (up to 4 units) to cultures containing SCM did not alter the number or degree of hemoglobinisation of erythroid colonies. Analysis of the total number of erythroid colony-forming cells and CFU-S in 90 individual spleen colonies gave a correlation coefficient of r = 0.93 for these two cell types. In addition to benzidine-positive erythroid cells, up to 40% of the colonies contained, in addition, varying proportions of neutrophils, macrophages, eosinophils, and megakaryocytes. Taken together with the close correlation between the numbers of CFU-S in different adult hemopoietic tissues, including individual spleen colonies, the data indicate that the erythroid colony-forming cells expressing multiple hemopoietic differentiation are members of the hemopoietic multipotential stem cell compartment.     

Factors affecting the generation of mast cells from multipotential colony-forming cells

The cells responsible for the long-term in vitro generation of murine mast cells have been examined. Sequential analysis of all colony types obtained from cultures of spleen or bone marrow cells showed that only colonies derived from multipotential cells (mixed-erythroid colonies) or mast cell progenitors, contained cells responsible for mast cell generation in liquid cultures. Primary colony growth and subsequent maintenance of mast cells in liquid cultures was dependent upon pokeweed mitogen-stimulated spleen cell-conditioned medium (SCM). Mixed-erythroid colonies from 14-day cultures of spleen cells had the greatest capacity for mast cell generation. Analysis by clone splitting and transfer to high (20%) and low (2.5%) concentrations of SCM showed that the concentration of SCM used in either the primary colony culture or subsequent liquid culture phase altered both the proliferative capacity of the mast cells generated and the frequency of mast cell progenitors within individual mixed-erythroid colonies. Thus, mixed-erythroid colonies stimulated with 2.5% SCM contained the highest proportion of mast cell progenitors (34% of colonies) and when stimulated with 20% SCM, approximately fourfold higher numbers of mast cells were produced at weekly intervals from liquid cultures maintained in 2.5% SCM compared to parallel liquid cultures containing 20% SCM. These studies confirm the hemopoietic origin of mast cells and demonstrate that a factor(s) in SCM is able to modulate their proliferative potential.     

Presence of cells in B-cell lineage in mixed (GEMM) colonies from murine marrow cells

Recent progress in clonal cell culture techniques makes it possible to detect pluripotent hemopoietic precursors from murine marrow cells. The precursors can proliferate, differentiate and form mixed colonies containing erythroblasts, granulocytes, macrophages and often megakaryocytes in viscid culture medium. In the present investigation, the presence of cells of B-cell lineage in mixed colonies was investigated. Experiments on colonies containing cIgM, cIgG, sIgM and sIgG bearing cells using goat IgG fluorescein-conjugated anti-mouse IgM, goat F(ab')2 fraction fluorescein-conjugated anti-mouse IgG and immunobeads revealed the presence of cytoplasmic IgM bearing cells in 47% of the colonies and surface IgM bearing cells in 74-84% of the colonies. Mixed colonies, however, did not contain either cIgG bearing cells or sIgG bearing cells. The results may indicate that some CFU-MIX proliferate and differentiate along B-cell lineage to sIgM or cIgM bearing cells in vitro.     

Colony formation in agar by multipotential hemopoietic cells.

Agar cultures of CBA fetal liver, peripheral blood, yolk sac and adult marrow cells were stimulated by pokeweed mitogen-stimulated spleen conditioned medium. Two to ten percent of the colonies developing were mixed colonies, documented by light or electron microscopy to contain erythroid, neutrophil, macrophage, eosinophil and megakaryocytic cells. No lymphoid cells were detected. Mean size for 7-day mixed colonies was 1,800-7,300 cells. When 7-day mixed colonies were recloned in agar, low levels of colony-forming cells were detected in 10% of the colonies but most daughter colonies formed were small neutrophil and/or macrophage colonies. Injection of pooled 7-day mixed colony cells to irradiated CBA mice produced low numbers of spleen colonies, mainly erythroid in composition. Karyotypic analysis using the T6T6 marker chromosome showed that some of these colonies were of donor origin. With an assumed f factor of 0.2, the mean content of spleen colony-forming cells per 7-day mixed colony was calculated to vary from 0.09 to 0.76 according to the type of mixed colony assayed. The fetal and adult multipotential hemopoietic cells forming mixed colonies in agar may be hemopoietic stem cells perhaps of a special or fetal type.     

A stochastic model of self-renewal and commitment to differentiation of the primitive hemopoietic stem cells in culture

We recently identified a murine hemopoietic stem cell colony which consists of undifferentiated (blast) cells and appears to be more primitive than CFU-GEMM in the stem cell hierarchy. The progenitors for the colony which we termed “stem cell colony” possess an extensive self-renewal capacity and the ability to generate many secondary multipotential hemopoietic colonies in culture. We replated a total of 68 stem cell colonies from cultures of murine spleen cells and analyzed the number of stem cell–and granulocyte(neutrophil)-erythrocyte-macrophage-megakaryocyte (GEMM) colony-forming cells in individual stem cell colonies. Of the 68 stem cell colonies, 35 contained progenitors (abbreviated as “S”-cells) for stem cell colonies. The distributions of S-cells and CFU-GEMM in individual stem cell colonies were extremely heterogeneous. Neither the frequency distributions of S-cells nor CFU-GEMM in stem cell colonies could be fitted well by Poisson distribution. Rather, the frequency distribution of the s-cells could be approximated by a geometric distribution and that of CFU-GEMM by an exponential distribution, both of which are variates of the gamma distribution. Our observations are in agreement with those on the distributions of CFU-S in individual spleen colonies and provided support for a stochastic model for stem cell self-renewal and commitment in culture. Application of the theory of the branching process to the distribution of S-cells revealed a distributional parameter “p” of 0.589 which is also in agreement with the earlier report on the p value for reproduction of CFU-S.     

Preliminary observation of blood cells and hematopoietic organs in Lutjanus herenbergi and Lutjanus flaviflammus

The morphology of differentiated and differentiating cells of the red and white series in Lutjanus herenbergi and in Lutjanus flaviflammus is described. Early stages of red and white blood cells may be found only in smears of hemopoietic organs. Polychromatic erythroblasts, myelocytes and lymphoblasts may also occasionally be found in blood smears. Mature blood cells may be found both in blood smears and in hemopoietic organs. Differential white cell counts seem to demonstrate that the granulocytic series elements are the most common leukocytes in blood smears. Almost all granulocytes may be classified in the first three Arneth classes. An analysis of hemopoietic organs in these species was also performed. It was found that the only organs carrying on a hemopoietic function are the kidney and the spleen. The kidney is essentially a site of granulocytic differentiation while the spleen is a lymphopoietic organ. An erythropoietic activity may generally be observed in the kidney although weak erythropoietic activity may at times be found in the spleen.     

Clonal origin of murine hemopoietic colonies with apparent restriction to granuclocyte-macrophage-megakaryocyte (GMM) differentiation

We characterized murine hemopoietic colonies consisting of granulocytes, macrophages, megakaryocytes, and blast cells and yet lacking erythroid elements. Mouse marrow or spleen cells were cultured in methylcellulose media in the presence of 10% (v/v) pokeweek mitogen-stimulated spleen cell-conditioned medium (PWM-SCM) and 2 units/ml erythropoietin for 8 days. Granulocyte-macrophage-megakaryocyte (GEMM) colonies could be distinguished from granulocyte-erythrocyte-macrophage-megakaryocyte (GEMM) colonies because the former lacked the typical appearance of bursts with red color. Analysis of Y-chromosomes in mixing experiments with male and female marrow cells confirmed the clonal nature of the GMM colonies. Differential counts of GMM colonies revealed varying, but significant, numbers of blast cells in all of the day-8 and day-12 colonies and in seven out of ten day-14 GMM colonies. In general, the percentages of blast cells were inversely related to the length of incubation in culture. Replating experiments confirmed the absence of late erythroid precursors such as CFU-E and normoblasts in all of the 50 day-8 GMM colonies. However, six out of the 50 GMM colonies contained early progenitors capable of erythroid expression, such as BFU-E, CFU-EM, CFU-GEM, and CFU-GEMM. In contrast, the three day-14 GMM colonies which did not reveal blast cells failed to produce secondary colonies. Thus, while the progenitors for the latter colonies are restricted to only granulocyte-macrophage-megakaryocyte differentiation, some of the apparent GMM colonies containing blast cells may have originated in early progenitors close to pluripotent stem cells. Detailed cytological analyses and replating experiments are necessary for characterization of true differentiation potentials of mixed colonies in culture.     

A cytological study of the capacity for differentiation of normal hemopoietic colony-forming cells

A two-stage procedure has been used to obtain hemopoietic spleen colonies derived from single precursor cells containing radiation-induced chromosomal markers. Of a total of 46 colonies examined, 17 were found to contain cells with abnormal karyotypes. In each of the 17 marked colonies, 90% or more of the dividing cells in the colony carried the same marker. Cell suspensions prepared from each of the individual colonies were tested for their content of dividing cells possessing recognizable differentiated functions. Metaphase cells with peroxidase-positive granules in their cytoplasm were considered to be members of the granulopoietic series, while metaphase cells which contained Fe⁵⁵ were considered to be members of the erythropoietic series. Results were obtained for 12 of the marked colonies, and in nine of these, the percentage of metaphases lacking the marker was less than the percentage of metaphases which were scored as erythropoietic, and also was less than the percentage of metaphases scored as granulopoietic. This is the result which would be expected if the marker were present in both erythropoietic and granulopoietic cells. These results provide support for the view that colony forming hemopoietic stem cells are multipotent, and that differentiation along more than one pathway can occur during the formation of macroscopic splenic colonies.     

Correspondence between the development of hemopoietic tissue and the time of colony formation by colony-forming cells

The development of a haemopoietic tissue and the time when colony-forming cells in it formed detectable colonies were studied with in vivo spleen colony-forming units (CFUs) and in vitro high-proliferation-potential colony-forming cells (HPP CFC). Cells that form colonies first are developmentally more mature than those doing so later. Marrow containing mature spleen colony-forming cells formed fewer cells in the femora of recipients than that which contained early colony-forming cells. The growth curve of developmentally early high-proliferation potential-colony-forming cells was steeper than that of later cells. The time period before colony-formation occurs is a property of the colony-forming cell and is not due to regulatory mechanisms in the animal or to regulatory cells in the haemopoietic stroma.     

Analysis of pure and mixed murine mast cell colonies

Mast cells have been proposed to originate from diverse sources, including connective tissues, macrophages, T lymphocytes, and hemopoietic cells. Evidence for a hemopoietic origin of mast cells includes the presence of mast cell precursors in spleen colonies and the presence of mast cells in hemopoietic colonies in culture. Here we report a detailed analysis of mouse spleen mixed hemopoietic colonies containing mast cells. All of the colonies in cultures plated at low cell densities were individually removed for analysis by May-Grunwald-Giemsa staining on day 15 of culture. Examination of five dishes which contained a total of 82 colonies showed 16 pure mast cell colonies and 36 mixed mast cell colonies. Sixteen different combinations of cell types were seen and were not distinguishable from each other in situ. The most diverse type of mixed colony contained macrophages (m), neutrophils (n), eosinophils (e), mast cells (Mast), megakaryocytes (M), erythroid cells (E), and blast cells. The clonal origin of mixed mast cell colonies was established by the replating of single cells obtained from blast cell colonies. Individual cells were removed with a micromanipulator, replated, and allowed to grow for 15 days. Cytospin preparations of 10 such colonies showed diverse combinations of cell lineages which were seen in the different types of mixed mast cell colonies described above. Replating studies of mixed mast cell colonies were carried out and a high incidence of replating was seen. Approximately one half of these colonies formed only mast cell colonies upon replating. Further studies showed that pure mast cell colonies could be serially replated four to five times. The replating efficiency of cells in the primary mast cell colonies varied over a wide range (2.5–44%) with an average replating efficiency of 13%. The data also revealed that cells containing metachromatic granules possess significant proliferative capacity. From these studies of pure and mixed mast cell colonies, we concluded (1) that mast cells are in wide variety of types of mixed colonies and that the in situ identification of mixed colonies is unreliable, (2) that mast cells are derived from pluripotent hemopoietic stem cells, and (3) that mast cells with metachromatic granules can have a high proliferating ability.     

Effect of various factors on the differentiation of hematopoietic stem cells]

The treatment in vitro of bone marrow cells in mice by phytohemagglutinin, concanavaline, or antilimphocytic globulin resulted in the suppression of exogenous hemopoietic colonies in the spleen of lethally irradiated (830r) syngenic recipients, whereas lipopolysaccharide, tuberculin, anti-theta serum or nati-gamma-globulin serum exerted no influence on the colony-forming function of hemopoietic stem cells. The morphological analysis of the ratio and cell composition of hemopoietic colonies has revealed no marked differences between the experimental and control groups. The suppression of hemopoietic stem cells by mitogens might be due both to their direct effect and indirect one, possibly, through a humoral factor.     

Diffusion chamber and spleen colony assay of murine haematopoietic stem cells

Mouse bone marrow cells have been cultured in diffusion chambers and their capacity to form spleen colonies in irradiated mice investigated after different culture periods. The number of spleen colony-forming units (CFU) in the chambers decreased during the first day of culture. The number then increased rapidly to a level significantly above the original chamber value on the third to fifth day of culture. By that time large numbers of granulocytes and macrophages had also appeared. Histological examination of spleen colonies showed that prior culturing did not alter the ratio between the different types of colonies. Cultured bone marrow cells which were transferred to new chambers retained granulopoietic capacity. This capacity increased between the first and second day of primary culturing. At this time hydroxyurea injections to chamber hosts revealed that the progenitor cells were proliferating. The results show that the granulopoietic progenitor cells of the chambers are stem cells, and that one progenitor cell type is identical with the CFU.     

In vitro activation of the in vivo colony-forming units of the mouse yolk sac.

Experiments were performed to investigate the presence of colony-forming units (CFU) in the mouse embryonic yolk sac during the developmental period in which the yolk sac is the sole hemopoietic organ. Injection of yolk sac cell suspensions from normal embryos into syngeneic, lethally irradiated adult recipients evoked a very low number of spleen colonies. However, prior cultivation of yolk sacs in vitro caused a dramatic increase in the spleen colony-forming capacity--as high as 84-fold--following 48 hours in culture. The yolk sac origin of the spleen colonies was confirmed by: (a) Chromosomal marker analysis; (b) dose-response analysis; (c) demonstrating that the above colonies were not of endogenous origin induced by the mere injection of grafted cells. We conclude that the yolk sac contains many precursors of colony-forming cells which though undetectable by immediate grafting apparently become activated in culture by an as yet unknown induction process.     

Developmental kinetics of hemopoietic progenitors in the avian embryo spleen

By means of plasma clot clonal cultures, the content of the avian spleen in granulomonocytic progenitors was studied during ontogeny. Serum-free media were used that were supplemented with growth activities produced either by embryonic fibroblasts or adult spleen cells. These two conditioned media not only permitted the growth of M-CFC, G-CFC, and GM-CFC but also F-CFU (fibroblast colony-forming units) from quail or chick embryonic spleen cells. The presence of spleen cell-conditioned medium promoted the development of large colonies of immature granulocytes. In the chick the first hemopoietic progenitors appeared at E9 and their number displayed two peaks, one at E15 and a smaller one at E18. In the quail the first progenitors were detected as early as E7 and their number peaked at E10. In this species, hemopoietic progenitors disappeared definitively before hatching while in the chick some were still present at P3. The progenitor content of the chick embryo spleen was compared to that of the bone marrow. This content remained stable during all of embryonic life, while the bone marrow exhibited a very different profile, where a sharp peak at E16 was followed by an acute decline and a stabilization at a rather low level. The particular profile in the spleen speaks in favor of a special role of this organ in the development of the hemopoietic system.     

Variable expression of Qa-m7, Qa-m8, and Qa-m9 antigenic determinants on primitive hemopoietic precursor cells

Using monoclonal antibodies, we have analysed the distribution of three recently described Qa antigenic determinants (Qa-m7, Qa-m8 and Qa-m9) on murine clonable hemopoietic progenitor cells and spleen colony-forming units (CFU-S). Cytotoxicity experiments showed that Qa-m7 was expressed on almost all the progenitor cells (colony-forming cells, CFC) of megakaryocytes (MEG-CFC), erythroid cells (E-CFC), B lymphocytes (BL-CFC), and mixed colonies (MIX-CFC) as well as day 13 CFU-S, and a major proportion of granulocyte-macrophage colony-forming cells (GM-CFC) and day 8 CFU-S. Experiments using four sources of granulocyte-macrophage colony-stimulating activity suggested differential expression of Qa-m7 on subpopulations of GM-CFC, those preferentially forming macrophage colonies having lowest Qa-m7 antigen density. Immune rosetting techniques demonstrated the selective expression of Qa-m8 on approximately 50% of MEG-CFC, MIX-CFC and day 13 CFU-S, a pattern similar to that of Qa-m2. In contrast, Qa-m9 was not detected on any of the primitive hemopoietic precursors assayed. The results demonstrate the complexity of the Qa antigenic system, and suggest a possible role for these antigens in hemopoietic differentiation.     

Comparative studies on the characteristics of proliferation and differentiation of spleen colony-forming cells

Using a single spleen colony transplantation technique and sex chromosome typing as a natural cytogenetic marker, most spleen colony-forming cells (CFC) in adult bone marrow or fetal livers of inbred LACA or C57 mice re-established hemopoiesis in lethally irradiated mice when the spleen colonies were sampled at 13 days after transplantation. However, most of the spleen colony-forming cells in the peripheral blood of normal mice possess little potential for proliferation and are less efficient in the re-establishment of hemopoiesis in lethally irradiated mice. The CFC population is heterogeneous in the mice. From the subsequent retransplantation of colonies from colony-forming cells in the peripheral blood, the simple assessment of spleen colony-forming units (CFU-s) content, based on the number of splenic colonies, does not reliably represent the content of hemopoietic stem cells.     

Effect of estradiol on splenic repopulation by endogenous and exogenous hemopoietic cells in irradiated mice

Estradiol treatment of irradiated mice during repopulation of their spleens by endogenous hemopoietic cells reduced the number of myelocytic colonies and increased the numbers of erythropoietic and undifferentiated colonies. The inhibitory effects of the hormone on myelopoiesis were not dependent on stimulation of erythropoiesis, since they occurred in the absence of erythropoiesis in mice made polycythemic by hypertransfusion. Treatment of bone marrow donors with estradiol reduced the ability of their marrow cells to form spleen colonies, particularly reducing the proportion of myelopoietic colonies relative to the total number of colonies of all types. Conversely erythropoietic colonies, though reduced in absolute number, were increased in relative number. Such treatment also decreased the volume and cell content of the marrow cavity through stimulation of endosteal bone formation. Estradiol treatment of lethally irradiated recipient mice did not detectably alter the total numbers or types of hemopoietic spleen colonies formed in these animals from transplanted marrow cells; however, without estradiol treatment, myelopoietic colonies were so few and erythropoietic colonies so numerous that the effects of the hormones may have been undetectable by the methods employed. The sex of the donor or recipient mouse did not affect the numbers or types of colonies formed, suggesting that endogenous levels of estradiol were too low to exert effects dectectable by the methods used. However, since our mice were only 8 weeks old, the data do not exclude the possibility that older female mice, with higher levels of estradiol, would have differed from males in relative numbers of myelopoietic as compared with erythropoietic colonies.     

Proliferation and differentiation of Abelson virus-infected murine myeloid leukemia cell lines does not involve an autocrine mechanism

Culture in agar of cloned promonocytic leukemia cell lines derived from Abelson virus-infected mice produced colonies of both a compact and diffuse morphology. Diffuse colonies contained fewer cells capable of forming colonies when recultured in agar than did compact colonies. Serial subcloning of cells from diffuse, but not compact, colonies ultimately led to the complete loss of colony-forming cells, i.e., to clonal extinction. The production of both compact and diffuse agar colonies was independent of the cell density of either the static liquid culture from which cells were taken for culture in agar, or the number of cells per agar culture. Furthermore, bioassays of culture supernatants indicated the leukemia cells did not secrete hemopoietic growth factors active on normal hemopoietic cells, transforming growth factors active on adherent cell lines, or factors that influenced the growth of the leukemic cells themselves. Collectively, these data suggest neither growth-factor independent replication nor the spontaneous differentiation of Abelson virus-infected myeloid cells involves autocrine secretion of growth regulators.     

Influence of major histocompatibility complex H-2LD class I molecules on spleen colony-forming units

To test whether the major histocompatibility complex class I genes are involved in the regulation of hemopoiesis, the stem cell activities of BALB/c-H-2dm2 (Dm2) mice, which are defective in the expression of H-2L antigens, have been compared with those of the wild-type, BALB/c-Kh, in in vivo and in vitro stem cell assays. In spleen colony-forming unit assays, Dm2 as hosts consistently supported a smaller number of colonies than did BALB/c-Kh. However, both Dm2 and BALB/c-Kh supported a comparable number of colonies in in vitro granulocyte-macrophage colony-forming unit and erythroid colony-forming unit assays. These observations together suggest that the mutation in Dm2 has not affected the hemopoietic potential of the stem cells but may probably affect the hemopoietic microenvironment for the development of the stem cells.     

A comparative study of the kinetic changes of hemopoietic stem cells in mice infected with lethal and non-lethal malaria.

The kinetic changes of hemopoietic stem cells in bone marrow and spleen were compared between lethal Plasmodium berghei- and non-lethal P. yoelii 17x-infected mice. P. yoelii 17x-infected mice showed more severe splenomegaly than those infected with P. berghei. P. yoelii 17x-infected mice also showed a greater degree of sustained increase in number of multipotent hemopoietic stem cells (colony-forming units in spleen: CFU-S) and committed stem cells for granulocytes and macrophages (CFU-GM) and for erythrocytes (CFU-E) than P. berghei-infected mice. Such an increase was predominantly seen in the spleen of P. yoelii 17x-infected mice. In P. berghei-infected mice, the number of CFU-S, CFU-GM and also CFU-E only transiently increased and then decreased to a subnormal level at the late stage of infection. The proportion of cycling CFU-S was higher in P. berghei-infected mice than in P. yoelii 17x-infected mice. The IL-3 producing activity per spleen was much higher in P. yoelii 17x-infected than in P. berghei-infected mice at any point in time during the infection. Thus, hemopoietic changes seen after malaria infection seem to be closely related to the pathogenicity of the malaria parasite.