Ultrastructural comparison of incompatible and compatible interactions in the barley powdery mildew disease

Summary In the powdery mildew disease of barley,Erysiphe graminis f. sp.hordei forms an intimate relationship with compatible hosts, in which haustoria form in epidermal cells with no obvious detrimental effects on the host until late in the infection sequence. In incompatible interactions, by contrast, the deposition of papillae and localized host cell death have been correlated with the cessation of growth byE. g. hordei. With the advent of improved, low temperature methods of sample preparation, we felt that it was useful to reevaluate the structural details of interactions between barley andE. g. hordei by transmission electron microscopy. The haustoria that develop in susceptible barley lines appear highly metabolically active based on the occurrrence of abundant endoplasmic reticulum, Golgi-like cisternae, and vesicles. In comparison, haustoria found in the resistant barley line exhibited varying signs of degradation. A striking clearing of the matrix and loss of cristae were typical early changes in the haustorial mitochondria in incompatible interactions. The absence of distinct endoplasmic reticulum and Golgi-like cisternae, the formation of vacuoles, and the occurrence of a distended sheath were characteristic of intermediate stages of haustorial degeneration. At more advanced stages of degeneration, haustoria were dominated by large vacuoles containing membrane fragments. This process of degeneration was not observed in haustoria ofE. g. hordei developing in the susceptible barley line.Abbreviations b endoplasmic reticulum extension, blebbing - er endoplasmic reticulum - f fibrillar material - g Golgi-like structure - h haustorium - hb haustorial body - hcw haustorial cell wall - hcy haustorial cytoplasm - hf haustorial finger - hocw host cell wall - hocy host cytoplasm - 1 lipid-like droplet - m mitochondrion - mt microtubule - mve multivesicular body - n nucleus - p papilla - ph penetration site of an infection peg - pl plasma membrane - s sheath - sm extrahaustorial membrane - v vacuole - ve vesicle     

Light and Electron Microscopy of the Compatible Interaction Between Arabidopsis and the Downy Mildew Pathogen Peronospora parasitica

In this study, we focused on compatible interactions between Peronospora parasitica isolate Emoy‐2 and wild‐type (Oy‐0) and mutant (Ws‐eds1) Arabidopsis thaliana accessions by using light and transmission electron microscopy (TEM). Light microscopy of compatible interactions revealed that conidia germinated and penetrated through the anticlinal cell walls of two epidermal cells. Rapid spreading of the hyphal growth with formation of numerous haustoria within the mesophyll cells was subsequently followed by profuse sporulation in the absence of host cell necrosis on both wild‐type and mutant accessions. TEM observations revealed that coenocytic intercellular hyphae ramified and spread intercellularly throughout the host tissue forming several haustoria in host mesophyll cells. Intracellular haustoria were lobed with the diameter of 6–7 μm. Each haustorium was connected to intercellular hyphae in the absence of apparent haustorial neck. The cytoplasm of the haustorium included the organelles characteristic of the pathogen. Callose‐like deposits were frequently observed at sites of penetration around the proximal region of the haustorial neck. Apart from a few callose ensheatments, no obvious response was observed in host cells following formation of haustoria. Most of mesophyll cells contained normal haustoria and the host cytoplasm displayed a high degree of structural integrity. Absence of host cell wall alteration and cell death in penetrated host cell of both accessions suggest that the pathogen exerts considerable control over basic cellular processes and in this respect, response to this biotroph oomycete differs considerably from responses to other pathogens such as necrotrophs.     

马铃薯对晚疫病水平抗性的组织细胞学观察

以马铃薯晚疫病水平抗性品种LBr-12和感病品种费乌瑞它为材料,采用普通光学和电子显微镜技术,系统研究了马铃薯与晚疫病菌(致病疫霉)互作的组织细胞学反应特征。观察结果显示:(1)接种后,水平抗性材料LBr-12出现过敏反应,病菌被限制在侵染点的几个细胞中,菌丝产生较少的分支和吸器。(2)感病品种费乌瑞它被侵染细胞呈蔓延趋势,菌丝产生较多的分支和吸器。(3)电镜观察发现,抗病品种上病菌的胞间菌丝、吸器母细胞、吸器在细胞和亚细胞水平均发生了一系列异常变化,包括原生质的电子致密度加深、液泡增多变大、菌丝细胞壁不规则增厚、细胞器排列紊乱及解体、吸器母细胞及吸器形态异常、病菌最终畸形坏死,同时发现抗病品种受病菌侵染时可迅速产生结构防卫反应,形成的细胞壁沉积物使胞壁极度增厚或细胞膜上产生乳突状结构。     

Histochemical Studies of the Non‐Host Resistance and the Role of Actin Cytoskeleton in Pepper Against Colletotrichum orbiculare

The penetration process and defence reactions (hypersensitive response, oxidative burst and cell wall fortification) of Colletotrichum orbiculare were studied histochemically on pepper cultivar ‘A11’ (non‐host) and susceptible cucumber cultivar ‘Changchun Thorn’ (host). The results indicate that C. orbiculare could hardly penetrate the non‐host pepper leaves. It was papillae rather than hypersensitive response and H₂O₂ that played an important role in resisting the colonization and development of C. orbiculare on the non‐host pepper. The depolymerization of the actin microfilament weakened the papilla deposition of pepper and allowed successful penetration of the non‐adapted C. orbiculare, suggesting that the actin cytoskeleton of pepper is significant in preventing the invasion of the non‐host pathogen C. orbiculare.     

Effects of host resistance on the development of haustoria and colonies of oat mildew

Colony development of Erysiphe graminis f.sp. avenae race 2 was studied on detached leaf segments of a range of Avena hosts with different levels of resistance, none of which possesses known specific gene resistance to this race. Resistance affected the length attained by mature primary haustoria, and also colony size as assessed by numbers of haustoria and conidiophores produced per colony 5 days after inoculation. A more accurate assessment of the size of mature haustoria was provided by the total length of their digitate processes. At the primary haustorium stage resistance affected not only haustorial size, but also haustorial efficiency measured as colony growth per unit size. Adult plant resistance of some hosts decreased haustorial size and/or efficiency in colonies on the fifth in comparison with the first formed leaf.     

Elektronenmikroskopische Untersuchungen des Gerstenmehltaus (Erysiphe graminis DC f. sp. hordei Marchal) nach Resistenzinduktion mit mikrobiellen Stoffwechselprodukten

Electron microscopical studies on Mildew of Barley (Erysiphe graminis DC f. sp. hordei Marchal) after induced Resistance with Products of Microbial Metabolism Ultrastructural studies of the infection progress of barley by Erysiphe graminis after induction of resistance with products of microbial metabolism showed that pathogen development was affected through inducer activated defence mechanisms. The formation of papillae-like structures and an accumulation of electron dense material below the host cell wall at the penetration site appeared to be associated with reduced penetration. The haustoria were also altered in the extrahaustorial membrane and electron dense material accumulated at the cell wall of haustorial body and neck, thus apparently impairing efficient functioning and allowing only limited growth of the pathogen.     

Observations on the ultrastructure of the uredinial stage ofPuccinia polypogonis onPolypogon monspeliensis

The ultrastructure of the uredinial stage of the rust fungus,Puccinia polypogonis onPolypogon monspeliensis is described, using scanning and transmission electron microscopy. This study examined the urediniospores, intercellular hyphae, and haustoria of the fungus. The formation and structure of urediniospores is similar to those of otherPuccinia species. The ultrastructure of intercellular hyphae and haustoria is similar to those of other rust fungi, but with some differences. No modifications are observed in the wall of the haustorial mother cells during penetration. A collar is found only around old haustoria. In most cases, one nucleus is detected inside the haustorial body and no nucleoli are seen in the nuclei of intercellular hyphae and haustoria. The host-parasite interface, including extrahaustorial matrix and extrahaustorial membrane, is also discussed and compared with those of other rust fungi.     

Histological Observations on Uromyces phaseoli and Puccinia recondita Infection in Allopurinol-treated Susceptible Plants

The development of rust after administering allopurinol, a specific inhibitor of xanthine oxidoreductase, via roots was studied at the histological level in leaves of susceptible‘Pinto 111’bean plants inoculated with Uromyces phaseoli and‘Thatcher',‘Mentana’and‘Leopardo’wheat plants challenged with Puccinia recondita. A marked reduction and delay in fungal growth was observed in allopurinol-treated plants starting between 24 h and 48 h post-inoculation, i.e. after differentiation of the first haustoria (onset of the biotrophic plant-parasite relationship). Infection hyphae often grew twisted and convoluted in treated hosts, sometimes producing small, irregularly shaped colonies. Differentiation of subepidermal stromata in fungal colonies was delayed and restricted by the treatment and uredospore yield severely reduced. Allopurinol administration also tended to increase the proportion of haustoria which became embedded in thick translucent sheaths during the late stages of infection. These results support the view that plant xanthine oxidoreductase activity is necessary for biotrophic development of rust fungi and suggest that the inhibition of this enzyme, which impairs the pathogen metabolism, may favour some natural host responses to attack such as haustorial sheath formation.     

Screening for Barley yellow dwarf virus-Resistant Barley Genotypes by Assessment of Virus Content in Inoculated Seedlings

The content of Barley yellow dwarf virus (BYDV) in roots and leaves of barley seedling plants differing in their level of resistance was assessed by quantitative ELISA 1–42 days after inoculation with the strain of BYDV (PAV). High virus accumulation in roots and low concentration in leaves was characteristic of the period 9–15 days after inoculation. In leaves, the differences in virus content between resistant and susceptible genotypes became significant after 15 days and resistance to virus accumulation was better expressed 30–39 days after inoculation. Roots of resistant materials exhibited evident retardation of virus accumulation and the greatest difference in virus content between resistant and susceptible plants was detected 9 days after inoculation. By these criteria, the selected winter and spring barley cultivars and lines (in total 44 materials) fell in to five groups according to field reactions and the presence or absence of the Yd2 resistance gene. There were highly significant and positive relations between ELISA values and 5‐year field data on symptomatic reactions and grain‐yield reductions due to infection. Using the described method, resistant and moderately resistant genotypes (both Yd2 and non‐Yd2) were significantly differentiated from susceptible genotypes. The possible use of this method in screening for BYDV resistance is discussed.     

EXPERIMENTAL INITIATION OF HAUSTORIA IN AGALINIS PURPUREA (SCROPHULARIACEAE)

The initiation and early developmental stages of the haustorium were studied in Agalinis purpurea (Scrophulariaceae). Plants were grown in a 0.9% agar inorganic medium with a 0.5% sucrose supplement. Root exudate collected from Lespedeza sericea induced the initiation of haustoria, with earliest stages evident in 6-12 hr. A 30-min exposure to exudate produced an increased frequency of haustoria and a 24-hr exposure yielded haustorial frequencies equal to the number that were initiated on control plants continuously exposed to root exudate for the 5-day growth period. The early cytological features of haustorial development are described and the possible significance of haustorial initiation in host recognition is discussed.     

The powdery mildew resistance protein RPW8.2 is carried on VAMP721/722 vesicles to the extrahaustorial membrane of haustorial complexes

Plants employ multiple cell‐autonomous defense mechanisms to impede pathogenesis of microbial intruders. Previously we identified an exocytosis defense mechanism in Arabidopsis against pathogenic powdery mildew fungi. This pre‐invasive defense mechanism depends on the formation of ternary protein complexes consisting of the plasma membrane‐localized PEN1 syntaxin, the adaptor protein SNAP33 and closely sequence‐related vesicle‐resident VAMP721 or VAMP722 proteins. The Arabidopsis thaliana resistance to powdery mildew 8.2 protein (RPW8.2) confers disease resistance against powdery mildews upon fungal entry into host cells and is specifically targeted to the extrahaustorial membrane (EHM), which envelops the haustorial complex of the fungus. However, the secretory machinery involved in trafficking RPW8.2 to the EHM is unknown. Here we report that RPW8.2 is transiently located on VAMP721/722 vesicles, and later incorporated into the EHM of mature haustoria. Resistance activity of RPW8.2 against the powdery mildew Golovinomyces orontii is greatly diminished in the absence of VAMP721 but only slightly so in the absence of VAMP722. Consistent with this result, trafficking of RPW8.2 to the EHM is delayed in the absence of VAMP721. These findings implicate VAMP721/722 vesicles as key components of the secretory machinery for carrying RPW8.2 to the plant–fungal interface. Quantitative fluorescence recovery after photobleaching suggests that vesicle‐mediated trafficking of RPW8.2–yellow fluorescent protein (YFP) to the EHM occurs transiently during early haustorial development and that lateral diffusion of RPW8.2–YFP within the EHM exceeds vesicle‐mediated replenishment of RPW8.2–YFP in mature haustoria. Our findings imply the engagement of VAMP721/722 in a bifurcated trafficking pathway for pre‐invasive defense at the cell periphery and post‐invasive defense at the EHM.     

Suppression of the powdery mildew pathogen by chitinase microinjected into barley coleoptile epidermal cells

An exogenous chitinase from Streptomyces griseus was introduced into coleoptile epidermal cells of barley (Hordeum vulgare) by microinjection, and the effect of injected chitinase on the growth or development of the powdery mildew pathogen (Erysiphe graminis f. sp. hordei) was examined. Prior to microinjection, an enzymatic degradation of fungal haustorium, the organ taking nutrients from host plant cells, was examined by treating fixed coleoptile epidermis harboring haustoria with this enzyme. The result showed that haustoria were effectively digested by chitinase, suggesting the effectiveness of chitinase treatment for suppressing the fungal development. Microinjection of chitinase was conducted using living coleoptile tissues inoculated with the pathogen. Epidermal cells in which the haustorial primordia had been formed, or in which the haustoria had matured, were selected as targets for injection. The result clearly indicated that injection at the stage of primordium formation was effective in completely digesting haustoria and suppressing the subsequent formation of secondary hyphae of the pathogen. In microinjection after haustorial maturation, hyphal elongation was considerably suppressed though there was no detectable morphological change in the haustoria. Thus, the present study provides the experimental basis for genetically manipulating barley to produce transgenic plants resistant to the powdery mildew disease.     

A Histological Evaluation of Induced Resistance to Phytophthora infestans (Mont.) de Bary in Potato Leaves

Systemically induced resistance against Phytophthora infestans in the potato cultivar ‘Bintje’ was studied histologically at the light microscopy level on the leaf surface, in the epidermis and in the mesophyll of challenged potato leaves. Systemic disease resistance was induced by a local pre-infection with the same fungus. On the leaf surface of induced plants, the germination of cysts was enhanced. In the epidermis of induced plants, papilla deposition increased and penetration decreased, whereas in the mesophyll of induced plants the spread of hyphae was reduced. It is suggested that the reduction of disease severity in induced plants is the result of the combined action of several successive defence reactions.     

Microscopy and proteomic analysis of the non-host resistance of <Emphasis Type="Italic">Oryza sativa</Emphasis> to the wheat leaf rust fungus, <Emphasis Type="Italic">Puccinia triticina</Emphasis> f. sp. <Emphasis Type="Italic">tritici</Emphasis>

Rice (Oryza sativa) cv. Nipponbare expresses non-host resistance (NHR) to the wheat leaf rust fungus, Puccinia triticina f. sp. tritici (Ptt). When the leaves of cv. Nipponbare were inoculated with Ptt, approx 93% of the urediniospores germinated on the leaf surface, but only 10% of the germinated spores formed appressoria over the stomata at one day post inoculation (1 dpi). Hydrogen peroxide (H₂O₂) accumulated in host cells around the appressoria at 3 dpi. Approx. 3% of the appressoria produced short hyphae inside the leaf, and fluorescence was observed in tissue invaded by the hyphae by 7 dpi. At 22 dpi, 0.2% of the sites with appressoria formed branching infection hypha in mesophyll cells, but no substomatal vesicles, haustorial mother cells or haustoria were observed. Proteins were extracted from leaves 3 dpi and analyzed by two-dimensional gel electrophoresis (2-DE). A total 33 spots were reproducibly up-regulated and 9 were down-regulated by infection compared to the water inoculated control. Of these, 30 were identified by MALDI-TOF Mass Spectrometry. The identified proteins participate in defense/stress responses, energy/carbohydrate metabolism, oxidation–reduction processes, protein folding/turnover/cleavage/degradation, signal transduction and cell death regulation. The results indicates that NHR of rice to Ptt is consistent with a shift in protein and energy metabolism, increased antimicrobial activities, possibly including phytoalexin accumulation and cell wall reinforcement, increased cell repair, antioxidive and detoxification reactions, and enhanced prevention of plant cell death. Nearly half of the up-regulated identified proteins were associated with chloroplast and mitochondrial physiology suggesting important roles for these organelles during NHR.     

Ultrastructure of the haustoria or intracellular hyphae in four different fungi

Summary An examination was made of the ultrastructure of haustoria or intracellular hyphae in four fungi: an obligate parasite (Puccinia hordei), a facultative parasite (Exobasidium japonicum) and two facultative saprophytes (Phytophthora palmivora and Sclerotinia fructigena). P. hordei haustoria showed the typical ultrastructure and host-parasite interface of most of the obligate parasites already studied. Connections between the host endoplasmic reticulum and host plasmalemma were observed at the encapsulation site. Tubules connecting the haustorial cytoplasm with the encapsulation, through the haustorial wall were occasionally seen. The host cell remained alive in the presence of the parasite. E. japonicum haustoria lacked a neck and encapsulation and were irregularly shaped, with branches which appeared to be partly surrounded by a sheath. Some of these branches showed cytoplasmic connections between the parasite and the host through the sheath. All the observed haustoria of E. japonicum were anucleate and contained only a few mitochondria and sparse membranes. The host cell was dead and its organelles disorganized. P. palmivora haustoria were simple with nucleus, endoplasmic reticulum, mitochondria and Golgi bodies. Neither sheath nor encapsulation was observed, and the host cell was also dead and disorganized. S. fructigena did not produce haustoria of any kind, the intercellular hyphae became intracellular by the degradation of the host cell walls, and the host cells were killed in advance of the growing hyphae.It is suggested that a new definition of haustorium is required to include all these intermediate haustorial bodies which cannot be included within the present concept of haustorium.     

THE HOST-PARASITE INTERFACE OF ALBUGO CANDIDA ON RAPHANUS SATIVUS

The fine structure of the intercellular hyphae of the obligate parasite Albugo candida infecting radish does not differ markedly from that described previously for cells of Peronospora manshurica. The stalked, capitate haustoria do not contain nuclei and are packed with mitochondria and lomasomes. The fungal plasma membrane and cell wall are continuous from the intercellular hypha throughout the haustorium except that there is no evidence of fungal cell wall around a portion of the haustorial stalk proximal to the haustorial head. Within the vacuolate host mesophyll cell, the haustorium is always surrounded by host plasma membrane and with at least a thin layer of host cytoplasm. The host cell wall invaginates at the point of haustorial penetration to form a short sheath around the region of penetration, but normally there is no host cell wall around the balance of the haustorium. About 1% of the haustoria observed were necrotic, and these were invariably walled-off completely from host cytoplasm by host cell wall. An amorphous, moderately electron-dense encapsulation lies between the haustorium proper and the host plasma membrane and extends into the penetration region between the sheath and the fungal cell wall. Invaded host cells contain more ribosomal-rich ground cytoplasm than uninfected cells. Glandular-like systems of tubules and connecting vesicles are often numerous in host cytoplasm in the vicinity of haustorial heads. These tubules open into the encapsulation, their limiting unit membranes being continuous with the host plasma membrane. We suggest that these represent a secretory mechanism of the host specifically induced by the parasite.     

Resistance to cucumber mosaic virus in potato

Reactions to two subgroup I isolates (Fny-CMV and Pf-CMV) and two subgroup II isolates (A9-CMV and LS-CMV) of cucumber mosaic virus (CMV) were studied in three non tuber-bearing wild potato species (Solanum spp.) of the series Etuberosa, and in two tuber-bearing interspecific potato hybrids and four potato cultivars using graft-inoculation. Three classes of phenotypic reactions (susceptible, hypersensitive, extreme resistance) were observed in the tuber-bearing genotypes. Susceptible genotypes developed mosaic or severe mosaic with leaf malformation and had high CMV titres. Hypersensitive genotypes developed either top necrosis or vein necrosis and/or necrotic spots on apical leaves, and had low CMV titres. Extremely resistant genotypes had no symptoms and no CMV was detected. The hybrid 87HW13.7 (S. tuberosum×S. multidissectum) developed top necrosis specific to infection with Fny-CMV. The hybrid ‘A6’ (S. demissum×S. tuberosum cv. Aquila) was hypersensitive to all CMV isolates tested. Extreme resistance was not functional against all CMV isolates. Neither hypersensitivity nor extreme resistance were related to the CMV subgroup.     

Analysis of In Vivo Protein Synthesis and Histological Studies of Haustorial Formation in Root Cultures of Witch weed (Striga asiatica L Kuntze)

We recently described an in vitro approach that uses root culturesto study haustorial formation in Striga asiatica. Previous studieshave used haustoria formed on intact radicles of Striga seedlings.In vitro cultured roots formed haustoria that appeared morphologicallysimilar to those formed by Striga radicles, but were 5–10-foldlarger. In this study, we provide biochemical and histologicalevidence to support further the similarity of root culture haustoriato haustoria formed on radicles of seedlings. We examined invivo protein synthesis during haustorial development on rootcultures and radicles by 2-D PAGE. Four proteins increased inabundance in both root cultures and radicles after 6 h of haustorialinduction. All four proteins appeared transiently in root culturesand radicles, being more abundant at 6 h, and less abundantafter 24 h of haustorial induction. Only three of the four haustorial-specificproteins were more abundant in root cultures after 2 h of haustorialinduction; all four had decreased in abundance after 12 h ofhaustorial induction. Using light microscopic analysis we comparedthe ontogeny of root culture haustoria to that of haustoriaon radicles. These studies revealed that root culture haustoriaundergo developmental changes similar to those reported forradicle haustoria such as early expansion of cortical cells,the emergence of haustorial hairs from epidermal cells, andthe development of densely staining cells at the haustorialapex. In addition, these changes occurred within a similar time-frameand sequence in root culture and radicle haustoria. Finally,root culture haustoria were found to be capable of attachingto sorghum host roots. Key words: Striga asiatica L., Kuntze, haustoria, root cultures, proteins, histology, 2D-PAGE