A mechanistic model for butyrylcholinesterase.

A plausible mechanism of action of horse serum butyrylcholinesterase is proposed. It includes substrate activation at the level of deacylation. The rate constant for the acylation of the enzyme appears to be much greater than the rate constant for the deacylation, at low substate concentrations. At higher substrate concentrations the rate constants become more similar. No interaction between the four subunits in binding of inhibitors or in the catalysis was observed. There is one esteratic and one anionic site per subunit apparent from labelling studies with [32P]diisopropylfluorophosphate and binding studies with N-methylacridine. Although the tetrametric form of the enzyme appears to be the native one, the monomeric and several other aggregated and dissociated states are catalytically active.     

Rate-determining step of butyrylcholinesterase-catalyzed hydrolysis of benzoylcholine and benzoylthiocholine. Volumetric study of wild-type and D70G mutant behavior.

The rate-limiting step for hydrolysis of the positively charged oxoester benzoylcholine (BzCh) by human butyrylcholinesterase (BuChE) is deacylation (k(3)), whereas it is acylation (k(2)) for hydrolysis of the homologous thioester benzoylthiocholine (BzSCh). Steady-state hydrolysis of BzCh and BzSCh by wild-type BuChE and its peripheral anionic site mutant D70G was investigated at different hydrostatic pressures, which allowed determination of volume changes associated with substrate binding, and the activation volumes for the chemical steps. A differential nonlinear pressure-dependence of the catalytic parameters for hydrolysis of both substrates by both enzymes was shown. Nonlinearity of the plots may be explained in terms of compressibility changes or rate-limiting changes. To distinguish between these two possibilities, enzyme phosphorylation by diisopropylfluorophosphate (DFP) in the presence of substrate (BzSCh) under pressure was studied. There was no pressure dependence of volume changes for DFP binding or for phosphorylation of either wild-type or D70G. Analysis of the pressure dependence for steady-state hydrolysis of substrates, and for phosphorylation by DFP provided evidence that no enzyme compressibility changes occurred during the catalyzed reactions. Thus, the nonlinear pressure dependence of substrate hydrolysis reflects changes in the rate-limiting step with pressure. Change in rate-determining step occurred at a pressure of 100 MPa for hydrolysis of BzCh by wild-type and at 75 MPa for D70G. For hydrolysis of BzSCh the change occurred at higher pressures because k(2) < k(3) at atmospheric pressure for this substrate. Elementary volume change contributions upon initial binding, productive binding, acylation and deacylation were calculated from the pressure differentiation of kinetic constants. This analysis shed light on the molecular events taking place along the hydrolysis pathways of BzCh and BzSCh by wild-type BuChE and the D70G mutant. In addition, volume change differences between wild-type and D70G provided new evidence that residue D70 in the peripheral site controls hydration of the active site gorge and the dynamics of the water molecule network during catalysis. Finally, a steady-state kinetic study of the oxyanion hole mutant (G117H) showed that substitution of the ethereal sulfur for oxygen in the substrate alters the final adjustment of substrate in the active site and stabilization of the acylation transition state.     

Methylmalonate-semialdehyde dehydrogenase from Bacillus subtilis: substrate specificity and coenzyme A binding

Methylmalonate-semialdehyde dehydrogenase (MSDH) belongs to the CoA-dependent aldehyde dehydrogenase subfamily. It catalyzes the NAD-dependent oxidation of methylmalonate semialdehyde (MMSA) to propionyl-CoA via the acylation and deacylation steps. MSDH is the only member of the aldehyde dehydrogenase superfamily that catalyzes a β-decarboxylation process in the deacylation step. Recently, we demonstrated that the β-decarboxylation is rate-limiting and occurs before CoA attack on the thiopropionyl enzyme intermediate. Thus, this prevented determination of the transthioesterification kinetic parameters. Here, we have addressed two key aspects of the mechanism as follows: 1) the molecular basis for recognition of the carboxylate of MMSA; and 2) how CoA binding modulates its reactivity. We substituted two invariant arginines, Arg-124 and Arg-301, by Leu. The second-order rate constant for the acylation step for both mutants was decreased by at least 50-fold, indicating that both arginines are essential for efficient MMSA binding through interactions with the carboxylate group. To gain insight into the transthioesterification, we substituted MMSA with propionaldehyde, as both substrates lead to the same thiopropionyl enzyme intermediate. This allowed us to show the following: 1) the pK(app) of CoA decreases by ～3 units upon binding to MSDH in the deacylation step; and 2) the catalytic efficiency of the transthioesterification is increased by at least 10(4)-fold relative to a chemical model. Moreover, we observed binding of CoA to the acylation complex, supporting a CoA-binding site distinct from that of NAD(H).     

Phospholipase A2 at the bilayer interface.

Interfacial catalysis is a necessary consequence for all enzymes that act on amphipathic substrates with a strong tendency to form aggregates in aqueous dispersions. In such cases the catalytic event occurs at the interface of the aggregated substrate, the overall turnover at the interface is processive, and it is influenced the molecular organization and dynamics of the interface. Such enzymes can access the substrate only at the interface because the concentration of solitary monomers of the substrate in the aqueous phase is very low. Moreover, the microinterface between the bound enzyme and the organized substrate not only facilitates formation of the enzyme-substrate complex, but a longer residence time of the enzyme at the substrate interface also promotes high catalytic processivity. Binding of the enzyme to the substrate interface as an additional step in the overall catalytic turnover permits adaptation of the Michaelis-Menten formalism as a basis to account for the kinetics of interfacial catalysis. As shown for the action of phospholipase A2 on bilayer vesicles, binding equilibrium has two extreme kinetic consequences. During catalysis in the scooting mode the enzyme does not leave the surface of the vesicle to which it is bound. On the other hand, in the hopping mode the absorption and desorption steps are a part of the catalytic turnover. In this minireview we elaborate on the factors that control binding of pig pancreatic phospholipase A2 to the bilayer interface. Binding of PLA2 to the interface occurs through ionic interactions and is further promoted by hydrophobic interactions which probably occur along a face of the enzyme, with a hydrophobic collar and a ring of cationic residues, through which the catalytic site is accessible to substrate molecules in the bilayer. An enzyme molecule binds to the surface occupied by about 35 lipid molecules with an apparent dissociation constant of less than 0.1 pM for the enzyme on anionic vesicles compared to 10 mM on zwitterionic vesicles. Results at hand also show that aggregation or acylation of the protein is not required for the high affinity binding or catalytic interaction at the interface.     

Mechanism of Carboxypeptidase Y Catalyzed Hydrolysis and Aminolysis Reactions

The reaction mechanism of carboxypeptidase Y catalyzed reactions is investigated. Presteady state and steady state kinetic measurements are performed on the hydrolysis and aminolysis of an ester and an amide substrate. It is found that deacylation is the rate determining step in hydrolysis of the ester, pivalic acid 4-nitrophenol and acylation in that of the amide, succinyl-L-alanyl-L-alalyl-L-propyl-L-phenylalanine 4-nitroanilide.

The kinetic effects observed in the presence of a nucleophile, L-valine amide, where aminolysis occurs in parallel to the hydrolysis reaction are analysed in details. The results are described satisfactorily by a reaction scheme which involves the binding of the added nucleophile, (i) to the free enzyme, resulting in a simple competitive effect, and (ii) to the acyl-enzyme with the formation of a complex between the enzyme and the aminolysis product, the dissociation of which is rate determining. That scheme can account for both increases and decreases of kinetic parameter values as a function of the nucleophile concentration. There is no indication of binding of the nucleophile to the enzyme-substrate complex before acylation takes place.     

New model for activation of yeast pyruvate decarboxylase by substrate consistent with the alternating sites mechanism: demonstration of the existence of two active forms of the enzyme

Pyruvate decarboxylase from yeast (YPDC, EC 4.1.1.1) exhibits a marked lag phase in the progress curves of product (acetaldehyde) formation. The currently accepted kinetic model for YPDC predicts that, only upon binding of substrate in a regulatory site, a slow activation step converts inactive enzyme into the active form. This allosteric behavior gives rise to sigmoidal steady-state kinetics. The E477Q active site variant of YPDC exhibited hyperbolic initial rate curves at low pH, not consistent with the model. Progress curves of product formation by this variant were S-shaped, consistent with the presence of three interconverting conformations with distinct steady-state rates. Surprisingly, wild-type YPDC at pH < or =5.0 also possessed S-shaped progress curves, with the conformation corresponding to the middle steady state being the most active one. Reexamination of the activation by substrate of wild-type YPDC in the pH range of 4.5-6.5 revealed two characteristic transitions at all pH values. The values of steady-state rates are functions of both pH and substrate concentration, affecting whether the progress curve appears "normal" or S-shaped with an inflection point. The substrate dependence of the apparent rate constants suggested that the first transition corresponded to substrate binding in an active site and a subsequent step responsible for conversion to an asymmetric conformation. Consequently, the second enzyme state may report on "unregulated" enzyme, since the regulatory site does not participate in its generation. This enzyme state utilizes the alternating sites mechanism, resulting in the hyperbolic substrate dependence of initial rate. The second transition corresponds to binding a substrate molecule in the regulatory site and subsequent minor conformational adjustments. The third enzyme state corresponds to the allosterically regulated conformation, previously referred to as activated enzyme. The pH dependence of the Hill coefficient suggests a random binding of pyruvate in a regulatory and an active site of wild-type YPDC. Addition of pyruvamide or acetaldehyde to YPDC results in the appearance of additional conformations of the enzyme.     

Tryptophan fluorescence monitors multiple conformational changes required for glutamine phosphoribosylpyrophosphate amidotransferase interdomain signaling and catalysis.

Single tryptophan residues were incorporated into each of three peptide segments that play key roles in the structural transition of ligand-free, inactive glutamine phosphoribosylpyrophosphate (PRPP) amidotransferase to the active enzyme-substrate complex. Intrinsic tryptophan fluorescence and fluorescence quenching were used to monitor changes in a phosphoribosyltransferase (PRTase) "flexible loop", a "glutamine loop", and a C-terminal helix. Steady state fluorescence changes resulting from substrate binding were used to calculate binding constants and to detect the structural rearrangements that coordinate reactions at active sites for glutamine hydrolysis and PRTase catalysis. Pre-steady state kinetics of enzyme.PRPP and enzyme.PRPP.glutamine complex formation were determined from stopped-flow fluorescence measurements. The kinetics of the formation of the enzyme.PRPP complex were consistent with a model with two or more steps in which rapid equilibrium binding of PRPP is followed by a slow enzyme isomerization. This isomerization is ascribed to the closing of the PRTase flexible loop and is likely the rate-limiting step in the reaction of PRPP with NH(3). The pre-steady state kinetics for binding glutamine to the binary enzyme. PRPP complex could also be fit to a model involving rapid equilibrium binding of glutamine followed by an enzyme isomerization step. The changes monitored by fluorescence account for the interconversions between "end state" structures determined previously by X-ray crystallography and define an intermediate enzyme.PRPP conformer.     

Regulation of fatty acid 18O exchange catalyzed by pancreatic carboxylester lipase. 1. Mechanism and kinetic properties.

The exchange of 18O between H2O and long-chain free fatty acids is catalyzed by pancreatic carboxylester lipase (EC 1.1.1.13). For palmitic, oleic, and arachidonic acid in aqueous suspension and for 13,16-cis,cis-docosadienoic acid (DA) in monomolecular films, carboxyl oxygens were completely exchanged with water oxygens of the bulk aqueous phase. With enzyme at either substrate or catalytic concentrations in the argon-buffer interface, the exchange of DA oxygens obeyed a random sequential mechanism, i.e., 18O,18O-DA in equilibrium with 18O,16O-DA in equilibrium with 16O,16O-DA. This indicates that the dissociation of the enzyme-DA complex is much faster than the rate-limiting step in the overall exchange reaction. Kinetic analysis of 18O exchange showed a first-order dependence on surface enzyme and DA concentrations, i.e., the reaction was limited by the acylation rate. The values of kcat/Km, 0.118 cm2 pmol-1 s-1, for the exchange reaction was comparable to that for methyl oleate hydrolysis and 5-fold higher than that for cholesteryl oleate hydrolysis in monolayers [Bhat, S., & Brockman, H. L. (1982) Biochemistry 21, 1547]. Thus, fatty acids are good "substrates" for carboxylester lipase. With substrate levels of carboxylester lipase in the interfacial phase, the acylation rate constant kcat/Km was 200-fold lower than that obtained with catalytic levels of enzyme. This suggests a possible restriction of substrate diffusion in the protein-covered substrate monolayer.     

Reaction pathway and free energy profiles for butyrylcholinesterase-catalyzed hydrolysis of acetylthiocholine

The catalytic mechanism for butyrylcholineserase (BChE)-catalyzed hydrolysis of acetylthiocholine (ATCh) has been studied by performing pseudobond first-principles quantum mechanical/molecular mechanical-free energy (QM/MM-FE) calculations on both acylation and deacylation of BChE. Additional quantum mechanical (QM) calculations have been carried out, along with the QM/MM-FE calculations, to understand the known substrate activation effect on the enzymatic hydrolysis of ATCh. It has been shown that the acylation of BChE with ATCh consists of two reaction steps including the nucleophilic attack on the carbonyl carbon of ATCh and the dissociation of thiocholine ester. The deacylation stage includes nucleophilic attack of a water molecule on the carboxyl carbon of substrate and dissociation between the carboxyl carbon of substrate and hydroxyl oxygen of Ser198 side chain. QM/MM-FE calculation results reveal that the acylation of BChE is rate-determining. It has also been demonstrated that an additional substrate molecule binding to the peripheral anionic site (PAS) of BChE is responsible for the substrate activation effect. In the presence of this additional substrate molecule at PAS, the calculated free energy barrier for the acylation stage (rate-determining step) is decreased by ~1.7 kcal/mol. All of our computational predictions are consistent with available experimental kinetic data. The overall free energy barriers calculated for BChE-catalyzed hydrolysis of ATCh at regular hydrolysis phase and substrate activation phase are ~13.6 and ~11.9 kcal/mol, respectively, which are in reasonable agreement with the corresponding experimentally derived activation free energies of 14.0 kcal/mol (for regular hydrolysis phase) and 13.5 kcal/mol (for substrate activation phase).     

Interfacial catalysis by phospholipase A2: substrate specificity in vesicles.

The binding equilibrium of phospholipase A2 (PLA2) to the substrate interface influences many aspects of the overall kinetics of interfacial catalysis by this enzyme. For example, the interpretation of kinetic data on substrate specificity was difficult when there was a significant kinetic contribution from the interfacial binding step to the steady-state catalytic turnover. This problem was commonly encountered with vesicles of zwitterionic phospholipids, where the binding of PLA2 to the interface was relatively poor. The action of PLA2 on phosphatidylcholine (PC) vesicles containing a small amount of anionic phospholipid, such as phosphatidic acid (PA), was studied. It was shown that the hydrolysis of these mixed lipid vesicles occurs in the scooting mode in which the enzyme remains tightly bound to the interface and only the substrate molecules present on the outer monolayer of the target vesicle became hydrolyzed Thus the phenomenon of scooting mode hydrolysis was not restricted to the action of PLA2 on vesicles of pure anionic phospholipids, but it was also observed with vesicles of zwitterionic lipids as long as a critical amount of anionic compound was present. Under such conditions, the initial rate of hydrolysis of PC in the mixed PC/PA vesicles was enhanced more than 50-fold. Binding studies of PLA2 to vesicles and kinetic studies in the scooting mode demonstrated that the enhancement of PC hydrolysis in the PC/PA covesicles was due to the much higher affinity of the enzyme toward covesicles compared to vesicles of pure PC phospholipids. A novel and technically simple protocol for accurate determination of the substrate specificity of PLA2 at the interface was also developed by using a double-radiolabel approach. Here, the action of PLA2 in the scooting mode was studied on vesicles of the anionic phospholipid 1,2-dimyristoyl-sn-glycero-3-phosphomethanol that contained small amounts of 3H- and 14C-labeled phospholipids. From an analysis of the 3H and 14C radioactivity in the released fatty acid products, the ratio of substrate specificity constants (kcat/KMS) was obtained for any pair of radiolabeled substrates. These studies showed that the PLA2s from pig pancreas and Naja naja naja venom did not discriminate between phosphatidylcholine and phosphatidylethanolamine phospholipids or between phospholipids with saturated versus unsaturated acyl chains and that the pig enzyme had a slight preference for anionic phospholipids (2-3-fold). The described protocol provided an accurate measure of the substrate specificity of PLA2 without complications arising from the differences in binding affinities of the enzyme to vesicles composed of pure phospholipids.     

Properties of lactate dehydrogenase from the isopod, Saduria entomon

An anionic trypsin from pyloric caeca of chum salmon (Oncorhynchus keta) was purified by ammonium sulfate and acetone fractionation followed by affinity chromatography, gel-filtration, and DEAE-anion exchange chromatography. The apparent molecular mass was about 24 kDa as determined by SDS-PAGE. The anionic chum salmon trypsin was moderately active toward esterase substrates such as tosyl-L-arginine methyl ester and tosyl-L-lysine methyl ester. Its amidase activity for benzoyl-L-arginine p-nitroanilide was comparative to those of bovine and Streptomyces griseus trypsins. Kinetic characteristics of anionic chum salmon, bovine, and Streptomyces griseus trypsins toward inverse substrate (p-amidinophenyl ester) were compared. Inverse substrate behaved as a specific substrate for anionic chum salmon trypsin with specific binding, efficient acylation, and relatively slow deacylation.     

An NMR study of anion binding to yeast phosphoglycerate kinase

Anion binding to yeast phosphoglycerate kinase has been investigated using 1H-NMR spectroscopy. The use of anionic paramagnetic probes. [Cr(CN)6]3- and [Fe(CN)6]3-, has enabled the location of the primary anion binding site in the 'basic-patch' region of the amino-terminal domain. The anions interact most closely with Arg-65 and Arg-168. The binding of these and a variety of other anions to this site is directly competitive with the binding of the substrate, 3-phosphoglycerate. Binding of 3-phosphoglycerate and 1.3-bisphosphoglycerate is, however, stronger than expected on the basis of anionic charge and causes conformational changes in the protein not seen with any of the other simple spherical anions investigated. This must be part, at least, of the substrate specificity. Evidence for a secondary anion binding site involving the side chains of surface lysine residues is also presented. It is suggested that the primary anion site is responsible for the observed activation by anions at low concentrations while the secondary site leads to inhibition at higher anion concentrations. The kinetics fit these deductions and a scheme for kinase activity is presented.     

Inactivation of Bacillus cereus beta-lactamase I by 6 beta-bromopenicillanic acid: kinetics

The kinetics of the inactivation of Bacillus cereus beta-lactamase I by 6 beta-bromopenicillanic acid are described. Loss of beta-lactamase activity is accompanied by a decrease in protein fluorescence, by the appearance of a protein-bound chromophore at 326 nm, and by loss of tritium from 6 alpha-[3H]-6 beta-bromopenicillanic acid. It is shown that all of the above changes probably have the same rate-determining step. The inactivation reaction is competitively inhibited by cephalosporin C, a competitive inhibitor of this enzyme, and by covalently bound clavulanic acid, suggesting that 6 beta-bromopenicillanic acid reacts directly with the beta-lactamase active site. It is proposed that this inhibitor reacts initially as a normal substrate and that the rate-determining step of the inactivation is acylation of the enzyme. A rapid irreversible inactivation reaction rather than normal hydrolysis of the acyl-enzyme then follows acylation; 6 beta-bromopenicillanic acid is thus a suicide substrate.     

Unmasking tandem site interaction in human acetylcholinesterase. Substrate activation with a cationic acetanilide substrate

Acetylcholinesterase (AChE) contains a narrow and deep active site gorge with two sites of ligand binding, an acylation site (or A-site) at the base of the gorge, and a peripheral site (or P-site) near the gorge entrance. The P-site contributes to catalytic efficiency by transiently binding substrates on their way to the acylation site, where a short-lived acyl enzyme intermediate is produced. A conformational interaction between the A- and P-sites has recently been found to modulate ligand affinities. We now demonstrate that this interaction is of functional importance by showing that the acetylation rate constant of a substrate bound to the A-site is increased by a factor a when a second molecule of substrate binds to the P-site. This demonstration became feasible through the introduction of a new acetanilide substrate analogue of acetylcholine, 3-(acetamido)-N,N,N-trimethylanilinium (ATMA), for which a = 4. This substrate has a low acetylation rate constant and equilibrates with the catalytic site, allowing a tractable algebraic solution to the rate equation for substrate hydrolysis. ATMA affinities for the A- and P-sites deduced from the kinetic analysis were confirmed by fluorescence titration with thioflavin T as a reporter ligand. Values of a >1 give rise to a hydrolysis profile called substrate activation, and the AChE site-specific mutant W86F, and to a lesser extent wild-type human AChE itself, showed substrate activation with acetylthiocholine as the substrate. Substrate activation was incorporated into a previous catalytic scheme for AChE in which a bound P-site ligand can also block product dissociation from the A-site, and two additional features of the AChE catalytic pathway were revealed. First, the ability of a bound P-site ligand to increase the substrate acetylation rate constant varied with the structure of the ligand: thioflavin T accelerated ATMA acetylation by a factor a(2) of 1.3, while propidium failed to accelerate. Second, catalytic rate constants in the initial intermediate formed during acylation (EAP, where EA is the acyl enzyme and P is the alcohol leaving group cleaved from the ester substrate) may be constrained such that the leaving group P must dissociate before hydrolytic deacylation can occur.     

Terbium binding to rat brain acetylcholinesterase. A fluorescence probe of anionic sites

Studies are in progress to characterize the nature of ligand interactions at peripheral anionic sites on mammalian brain AChE, including the beta-anionic or "accelerator" anionic sites where enzyme activity is increased upon Ca2+ binding. Terbium was studied as a fluorescence probe of Ca2+ binding sites in partially purified AChE from whole rat brain. Scatchard analysis of Tb3+ binding in low ionic strength (2 mM) Pipes buffer revealed at least two populations of sites: high affinity sites with Kd(app) approximately 7.6 microM and low-affinity sites with a Kd(app) approximately 49.6 microM. Low-affinity binding was selectively inhibited by 50 mM NaCl; high-affinity binding was completely inhibited by 2 mM CaCl2; and all the bound Tb3+ could be displaced by 1 mM EDTA. The heterogeneity of Tb3+ binding sites is consistent with the multiple, concentration-dependent effects of Tb3+ on enzyme activity.     

Substrate and product trafficking through the active center gorge of acetylcholinesterase analyzed by crystallography and equilibrium binding

Hydrolysis of acetylcholine catalyzed by acetylcholinesterase (AChE), one of the most efficient enzymes in nature, occurs at the base of a deep and narrow active center gorge. At the entrance of the gorge, the peripheral anionic site provides a binding locus for allosteric ligands, including substrates. To date, no structural information on substrate entry to the active center from the peripheral site of AChE or its subsequent egress has been reported. Complementary crystal structures of mouse AChE and an inactive mouse AChE mutant with a substituted catalytic serine (S203A), in various complexes with four substrates (acetylcholine, acetylthiocholine, succinyldicholine, and butyrylthiocholine), two non-hydrolyzable substrate analogues (m-(N,N,N-trimethylammonio)-trifluoroacetophenone and 4-ketoamyltrimethylammonium), and one reaction product (choline) were solved in the 2.05-2.65-A resolution range. These structures, supported by binding and inhibition data obtained on the same complexes, reveal the successive positions and orientations of the substrates bound to the peripheral site and proceeding within the gorge toward the active site, the conformations of the presumed transition state for acylation and the acyl-enzyme intermediate, and the positions and orientations of the dissociating and egressing products. Moreover, the structures of the AChE mutant in complexes with acetylthiocholine and succinyldicholine reveal additional substrate binding sites on the enzyme surface, distal to the gorge entry. Hence, we provide a comprehensive set of structural snapshots of the steps leading to the intermediates of catalysis and the potential regulation by substrate binding to various allosteric sites at the enzyme surface.     

Engineering substrate preference in subtilisin: structural and kinetic analysis of a specificity mutant

Bacillus subtilisin has been a popular model protein for engineering altered substrate specificity. Although some studies have succeeded in increasing the specificity of subtilisin, they also demonstrate that high specificity is difficult to achieve solely by engineering selective substrate binding. In this paper, we analyze the structure and transient state kinetic behavior of Sbt160, a subtilisin engineered to strongly prefer substrates with phenylalanine or tyrosine at the P4 position. As in previous studies, we measure improvements in substrate affinity and overall specificity. Structural analysis of an inactive version of Sbt160 in complex with its cognate substrate reveals improved interactions at the S4 subsite with a P4 tyrosine. Comparison of transient state kinetic behavior against an optimal sequence (DFKAM) and a similar, but suboptimal, sequence (DVRAF) reveals the kinetic and thermodynamic basis for increased specificity, as well as the limitations of this approach. While highly selective substrate binding is achieved in Sbt160, several factors cause sequence specificity to fall short of that observed with natural processing subtilisins. First, for substrate sequences which are nearly optimal, the acylation reaction becomes faster than substrate dissociation. As a result, the level of discrimination among these substrates diminishes due to the coupling between substrate binding and the first chemical step (acylation). Second, although Sbt160 has 24-fold higher substrate affinity for the optimal substrate DFKAM than for DVRAF, the increased substrate binding energy is not translated into improved transition state stabilization of the acylation reaction. Finally, as interactions at subsites become stronger, the rate-determining step in peptide hydrolysis changes from acylation to product release. Thus, the release of the product becomes sluggish and leads to a low k(cat) for the reaction. This also leads to strong product inhibition of substrate turnover as the reaction progresses. The structural and kinetic analysis reveals that differences in the binding modes at subsites for substrates, transition states, and products are subtle and difficult to manipulate via straightforward protein engineering. These findings suggest several new strategies for engineering highly sequence selective enzymes.     

Acetylthiocholine binds to asp74 at the peripheral site of human acetylcholinesterase as the first step in the catalytic pathway

Studies of ligand binding to acetylcholinesterase (AChE) have demonstrated two sites of interaction. An acyl-enzyme intermediate is formed at the acylation site, and catalytic activity can be inhibited by ligand binding to a peripheral site. The three-dimensional structures of AChE-ligand complexes reveal a narrow and deep active site gorge and indicate that ligands specific for the acylation site at the base of the gorge must first traverse the peripheral site near the gorge entrance. In recent studies attempting to clarify the role of the peripheral site in the catalytic pathway for AChE, we showed that ligands which bind specifically to the peripheral site can slow the rates at which other ligands enter and exit the acylation site, a feature we called steric blockade [Szegletes, T., Mallender, W. D., and Rosenberry, T. L. (1998) Biochemistry 37, 4206-4216]. We also demonstrated that cationic substrates can form a low-affinity complex at the peripheral site that accelerates catalytic hydrolysis at low substrate concentrations but results in substrate inhibition at high concentrations because of steric blockade of product release [Szegletes, T., Mallender, W. D., Thomas, P. J., and Rosenberry, T. L. (1999) Biochemistry 38, 122-133]. In this report, we demonstrate that a key residue in the human AChE peripheral site with which the substrate acetylthiocholine interacts is D74. We extend our kinetic model to evaluate the substrate affinity for the peripheral site, indicated by the equilibrium dissociation constant K(S), from the dependence of the substrate hydrolysis rate on substrate concentration. For human AChE, a K(S) of 1.9+/-0.7 mM obtained by fitting this substrate inhibition curve agreed with a K(S) of 1.3+/-1.0 mM measured directly from acetylthiocholine inhibition of the binding of the neurotoxin fasciculin to the peripheral site. For Torpedo AChE, a K(S) of 0.5+/- 0.2 mM obtained from substrate inhibition agreed with a K(S) of 0.4+/- 0.2 mM measured with fasciculin. Introduction of the D72G mutation (corresponding to D74G in human AChE) increased the K(S) to 4-10 mM in the Torpedo enzyme and to about 33 mM in the human enzyme. While the turnover number k(cat) was unchanged in the human D74G mutant, the roughly 20-fold decrease in acetylthiocholine affinity for the peripheral site in D74G resulted in a corresponding decrease in k(cat)/K(app), the second-order hydrolysis rate constant, in the mutant. In addition, we show that D74 is important in conveying to the acylation site an inhibitory conformational effect induced by the binding of fasciculin to the peripheral site. This inhibitory effect, measured by the relative decrease in the first-order phosphorylation rate constant k(OP) for the neutral organophosphate 7-[(methylethoxyphosphonyl)oxy]-4-methylcoumarin (EMPC) that resulted from fasciculin binding, decreased from 0.002 in wild-type human AChE to 0.24 in the D74G mutant.     

Directed coevolution of stability and catalytic activity in calcium-free subtilisin

We have coevolved high activity and hyperstability in subtilisin by sequentially randomizing 12 amino acid positions in calcium-free subtilisin. The optimal amino acid for each randomized site was chosen based on stability and catalytic properties and became the parent clone for the next round of mutagenesis. Together, the 12 selected mutations increased the half-life of calcium-free subtilisin at elevated temperature by 15,000-fold. The catalytic properties of the mutants were examined against a range of substrates. In general, only mutations occurring at or near the substrate-binding surface have measurable effects on catalytic constants. No direct influence of stability on catalytic properties was observed. A high-stability mutant, Sbt140, was a more efficient enzyme in terms of k(cat)/K(m) than a commercial version of subtilisin across a range of substrates but had a lower k(cat) against tight-binding substrates. The reason for this behavior was discerned by examining microscopic rate constants for the hydrolysis of a tight-binding peptide substrate. Burst kinetics were observed for this substrate, indicating that acylation is not rate-limiting. Although acylation occurs at the rate of substrate binding, k(cat) is attenuated by the slow release of the N-terminal product. Natural evolution appears to have optimized catalytic activity against a range of sequences by achieving a balance between substrate binding and the rate of release of the N-terminal product.