Relationships among Bacterial Cell Size, Productivity, and Genetic Diversity in Aquatic Environments using Cell Sorting and Flow Cytometry

Abstract The study of relationships between cell size and productivity is of key importance in microbial ecology to understand which members of natural aquatic communities are responsible for the overall activity and/or productivity. Flow sorting of microorganisms from different environmental samples was used to analyze the activity of bacterial cells depending on their biovolume. Bacterial cells from five different natural samples taken along the Mediterranean coast including fresh- and seawaters were incubated with tritiated leucine, then stained with SYTO 13 and sorted by flow cytometry according to their average side-angle-scattered (SSC) light. In all samples, a bell-shaped relationship was found between cell biovolume and activity, whereas activity of a given cell-size class varied between samples. In contrast, an inverse relationship was found between biovolumes and abundances. These results suggest that medium-sized cells with highest growth rates are probably submitted to intense grazing. For one sample, bacteria within five different size classes were sorted and the genetic diversity of cells within each sorted size class and that of the whole community were analyzed by the denaturing gradient gel electrophoresis (DGGE) method. The genetic diversity, as determined at the community level was highly represented into the pool of small cells, whereas only few species were present into larger cell subpopulations. The results suggest that only a few genotypes may be dominant within the largest and most productive cells. Furthermore, cell size polymorphism as well as heterogeneous cellular activities were found within some species. Received: January 2000; Accepted: April 2000; Online Publication: 28 August 2000     

Separation of active and inactive fractions from starved culture of Vibrio parahaemolyticus by density dependent cell sorting

The co-existence of physiologically different cells in bacterial cultures is a general phenomenon. We have examined the applicability of the density dependent cell sorting (DDCS) method to separate subpopulations from a long-term starvation culture of Vibrio parahaemolyticus. The cells were subjected to Percoll density gradient and separated into 12 fractions of different buoyant densities, followed by measuring the cell numbers, culturability, respiratory activity and leucine incorporation activity. While more than 78% of cells were in lighter fractions, about 95% of culturable cells were present in heavier fractions. The high-density subpopulations also had high proportion of cells capable of forming formazan granules. Although this was accompanied by the cell specific INT-reduction rate, both leucine incorporation rates and INT-reduction rates per cell had a peak at mid-density fraction. The present results indicated that DDCS could be used to separate subpopulations of different physiological conditions.     

Effect of Protistan Grazing on the Frequency of Dividing Cells in Bacterioplankton Assemblages

Grazing by phagotrophic flagellates and ciliates is a major source of mortality for bacterioplankton in both marine and freshwater systems. Recent studies have demonstrated a positive relationship between clearance rate and prey size for bacterivorous protists. We tested the idea that, by selectively grazing the larger (more actively growing or dividing) cells in a bacterial assemblage, protists control bacterial standing stock abundances by directly cropping bacterial production. Samples of estuarine water were passed through 0.8-μm-pore-size filters (bacteria only) or 20-μm-mesh screens (bacteria and bacterivorous protists) and placed in dialysis tubing suspended in 7 liters of unfiltered water. Changes in total bacterial biovolume per milliliter (bacterial biomass), frequency of dividing cells (FDC), and average per cell biovolume were followed over a period of 24 h. In three experiments, the FDC increased more rapidly and attained higher values in water passed through 0.8-μm-pore-size filters (average, 5.1 to 8.9%; maximum, 15.5%) compared with FDC values in water passed through 20-μm-mesh screens (average, 2.7 to 5.3%; maximum, 6.7%). Increases in bacterial biomass per milliliter lagged behind increases in FDC by about 4 to 6 h. Grazed bacterial assemblages were characterized by lower total biomasses and smaller average cell sizes compared with those of cells in nongrazed assemblages. We conclude that bacterivorous protists control bacterial standing stock abundances partly by preferentially removing dividing cells. Selective grazing of the more actively growing cells may also explain, in part, the ability of slow-growing cells to persist in bacterioplankton assemblages.     

Green fluorescent protein-propidium iodide (GFP-PI) based assay for flow cytometric measurement of bacterial viability.

BACKGROUND: Several staining protocols have been developed for flow cytometric analysis of bacterial viability. One promising method is dual staining with the LIVE/DEAD BacLight bacterial viability kit. In this procedure, cells are treated with two different DNA-binding dyes (SYTO9 and PI), and viability is estimated according to the proportion of bound stain. SYTO9 diffuses through the intact cell membrane and binds cellular DNA, while PI binds DNA of damaged cells only. This dual-staining method allows effective separation between viable and dead cells, which is far more difficult to achieve with single staining. Although SYTO9-PI dual staining is practical for various bacterial viability analyses, the method has a number of disadvantages. Specifically, the passage of SYTO9 through the cell membrane is a slow process, which is significantly accelerated when the integrity of the cell membrane is disrupted. As a result, SYTO9 binding to DNA is considerably enhanced. PI competes for binding sites with SYTO9 and may displace the bound dye. These properties diminish the reliability of the LIVE/DEAD viability kit. In this study, we investigate an alternative method for measuring bacterial viability using a combination of green fluorescent protein (GFP) and PI, with a view to improving data reliability. METHODS: Recombinant Escherichia coli cells with a plasmid containing the gene for jellyfish GFP were stained with PI, and green and red fluorescence were measured by FCM. For comparison, cells containing the plasmid from which gfp was removed were stained with SYTO9 and PI, and analyzed by FCM. Viability was estimated according to the proportion of green and red fluorescence. In addition, bioluminescence and plate counting (other methods to assess viability) were used as reference procedures. RESULTS: SYTO9-PI dual staining of bacterial cells revealed three different cell populations: living, compromised, and dead cells. These cell populations were more distinct when the GFP-PI combination was used instead of dual staining. No differences in sensitivity were observed between the two methods. However, substitution of SYTO9 with GFP accelerated the procedure. Bioluminescence and plate counting results were in agreement with flow cytometric viability data. CONCLUSIONS: In bacterial viability analyses, the GFP-PI combination provided better distinction between current viability stages of E. coli cells than SYTO9-PI dual staining. Additionally, the overall procedure was more rapid. No marked differences in sensitivity were observed.     

Genetic Diversity of Viable, Injured, and Dead Fecal Bacteria Assessed by Fluorescence-Activated Cell Sorting and 16S rRNA Gene Analysis

A novel approach combining a flow cytometric in situ viability assay with 16S rRNA gene analysis was used to study the relationship between diversity and activity of the fecal microbiota. Simultaneous staining with propidium iodide (PI) and SYTO BC provided clear discrimination between intact cells (49%), injured or damaged cells (19%), and dead cells (32%). The three subpopulations were sorted and characterized by denaturing gradient gel electrophoresis (DGGE) of 16S rRNA gene amplicons obtained from the total and bifidobacterial communities. This analysis revealed that not only the total community but also the distinct subpopulations are characteristic for each individual. Cloning and sequencing of the dominant bands of the DGGE patterns showed that most of clones retrieved from the live, injured, and dead fractions belonged to Clostridium coccoides, Clostridium leptum, and Bacteroides. We found that some of the butyrate-producing related bacteria, such as Eubacterium rectale and Eubacterium hallii, were obviously viable at the time of sampling. However, amplicons affiliated with Bacteroides and Ruminococcus obeum- and Eubacterium biforme-like bacteria, as well as Butyrivibrio crossotus, were obtained especially from the dead population. Furthermore, some bacterial clones were recovered from all sorted fractions, and this was especially noticeable for the Clostridium leptum cluster. The bifidobacterial phylotypes identified in total samples and sorted fractions were assigned to Bifidobacterium adolescentis, Bifidobacterium longum, Bifidobacterium infantis, Bifidobacterium pseudocatenulatum, and Bifidobacterium bifidum. Phylogenetic analysis of the live, dead, and injured cells revealed a remarkable physiological heterogeneity within these bacterial populations; B. longum and B. infantis were retrieved from all sorted fractions, while B. adolescentis was recovered mostly from the sorted dead fraction.     

Separation of leukemic myeloblasts and splenic lymphocytes based upon differences in light scatter profile.

Cell sorting based upon differences in light scatter profile was carried out to sort cells which differ in size. This technique permitted the acquisition of subpopulations of murine spleen cells enriched for leukemic myeloblasts or lymphocytes. Morphologic assessment of the sorted populations was confirmed by malignancy assay $\text{in}$$\text{vivo}$. The same technique has been applied to human leukemic cells and significant enrichment for proliferating and quiescent cells was accomplished.     

Human bone marrow CFU-GM and BFU-E localized by light scatter cell sorting

Flow cytometric separation was performed on the normal human bone marrow (BM) by using the low-angle (0 degrees) or high-angle (90 degrees) light scatter. Four distinct subpopulations of cells can be enriched from normal human BM and these fractions were subsequently evaluated for their morphological properties as well as their clonogenic capacity in various progenitor cell assays. Our results indicate that human erythroid and granulocyte-macrophage progenitor cells can be separated from BM low-density cells by cell sorting, and these cells show similar 0 degrees and 90 degrees light scatter properties to those observed with murine bone marrow studies. Flow cytometric analysis also suggests that the majority of sorted BFU-E and CFU-GM resides in the blast cell subset of human BM mononuclear cells.     

Cells on microspheres: a new technique for flow cytometric analysis of adherent cells

Technical problems have previously prevented the application of fluorescence activated cell sorting to the study of adherent cell populations. We have developed a procedure for attachment of human monocyte-macrophages to 14-20 micrometer microspheres. These adherent cells on microspheres retained phagocytic capacity, could be stained for cell surface antigens using indirect immunofluorescence, and could be maintained in long-term culture. They could be examined and sorted on a fluorescence activated cell sorter while still in the adherent state. This technique facilitates the flow cytometric study of adherent cells and permits the isolation of subpopulations of these cells.     

Microproteomics with microfluidic‐based cell sorting: Application to 1000 and 100 immune cells

Ultimately, cell biology seeks to define molecular mechanisms underlying cellular functions. However, heterogeneity within cell populations must be considered for optimal assay design and data interpretation. Although single‐cell analyses are desirable for addressing this issue, practical considerations, including assay sensitivity, limit their broad application. Therefore, omics studies on small numbers of cells in defined subpopulations represent a viable alternative for elucidating cell functions at the molecular level. MS‐based proteomics allows in‐depth proteome exploration, although analyses of small numbers of cells have not been pursued due to loss during the multistep procedure involved. Thus, optimization of the proteomics workflow to facilitate the analysis of rare cells would be useful. Here, we report a microproteomics workflow for limited numbers of immune cells using non‐damaging, microfluidic chip‐based cell sorting and MS‐based proteomics. Samples of 1000 or 100 THP‐1 cells were sorted, and after enzymatic digestion, peptide mixtures were subjected to nano‐LC‐MS analysis. We achieved reasonable proteome coverage from as few as 100‐sorted cells, and the data obtained from 1000‐sorted cells were as comprehensive as those obtained using 1 μg of whole cell lysate. With further refinement, our approach could be useful for studying cell subpopulations or limited samples, such as clinical specimens.     

Bacterial Colonization and Ectoenzymatic Activity in Phytoplankton-Derived Model Particles: Cleavage of Peptides and Uptake of Amino Acids

Abstract Phytoplankton-derived model particles were created in laboratory from a mixture of autoclaved diatom cultures. These particles were colonized by a marine bacterial community and incubated in rolling tanks in order to examine the relationship between aminopeptidase activity and leucine uptake. Bacteria inhabiting particles and ambient water were characterized for abundance, biovolume, aminopeptidase activity, leucine uptake, and growth rate. Particles were a less favorable habitat than ambient water for bacterial growth since growth rates of particle-attached bacteria were similar or even lower than those of free-living bacteria. During the first ∼100 h of the particle decomposition process, there were not statistically significant differences in the aminopeptidase activity:leucine uptake ratio between attached and free-living bacteria. From ∼100 h to ∼200 h, this ratio was higher for attached bacteria than for free-living bacteria. This indicates an uncoupling of aminopeptidase activity and leucine uptake. During this period, attached and free-living bacteria showed similar hydrolytic activities on a cell-specific basis. In the free-living bacterial community, variations in aminopeptidase activity per cell were associated with variations in leucine uptake per cell and growth rates. However, in the attached bacterial community, when leucine uptake and growth rates decreased, aminopeptidase activity remained constant. Thus, after ∼100 h, particle-attached bacteria were not taking advantage of their high aminopeptidase activity; consequently the hydrolysed amino acids were released into the ambient water, supporting the growth of free-living bacteria. These results demonstrate that over the particle decomposition process, the relationship between hydrolysis and uptake of the protein fraction shows different patterns of variation for attached and free-living bacterial communities. However, in our experiments, this uncoupling was not based on a hyperproduction of enzymes by attached bacteria, but on lower uptake rates when compared to the free-living bacteria. Received: 4 February 1997; Accepted: 9 May 1997     

Electron Microscopic Identification and Morphologic Preservation of Enriched Populations of Lung Cells Isolated by Laser Flow Cytometry and Cell Sorting: A New Technique

There is increasing need to verify the identities of cell subpopulations enriched by laser flow cytometry and fluorescence-activated cell sorting (FACS). When cell subpopulations isolated from whole organs or tissues have similar characteristics (e.g., size, granularity, staining), light, phase contrast or fluorescence microscopy may not provide sufficient resolution to identify isolated cells accurately and many flow cytometric parameters (e.g., viability, fluorescence) require the cells to be live at the point of analysis where the cell transects the laser beam. In some studies, cells identified by fluorescence microscopy as a highly enriched subpopulation were found by electron microscopy to contain significant populations of other cell types. A technique, fixation-in-flow (FIF), has been developed to increase ability to correlate morphological and laser analyses of cell subpopulations. Sheath fluid is replaced by fixative, permitting fixation to be initiated immediately after laser beam analysis of live cells. This new procedure yields improved cytoarchitectural preservation of recovered cell subpopulation(s) for evaluation by transmission or scanning electron microscopy. This report presents results from applying the methodology to identify more accurately cell subpopulations of the distal lung, specifically type II pneumocytes, Clara cells and pulmonary macrophages. A modification of this procedure was employed to isolate fibroblast subpopulations from murine lung fibroblasts grown in vitro and the procedure is being used to determine the responses of cultured fibroblasts to other permutations (e.g., X-irradiation, cytokines).     

Improved sensitivity in comparative genomic hybridization analysis of DNA heteroploid cell mixtures after pre-enrichment of subpopulations by fluorescence activated cell sorting.

Cytogenetic analysis of solid tumors with comparative genomic hybridization (CGH) is hampered by the dilution of DNA from individual tumor subpopulations with DNA from other cells. We investigated to what extent this dilution effect can be alleviated using fluorescence activated cell sorting (flow sorting) of experimental DNA heteroploid cell mixtures prior to CGH. From mixtures of normal lymphocytes with triploid K-562 cells the individual components were sorted according to stemline DNA content and processed by CGH in comparison with pure K-562 samples and the original mixtures. Compared with 30 autosome copy number imbalances found in pure K-562 samples, a mixture with 32% K-562 cells showed 16 imbalances, and none were detected in mixtures with 13% or 5% K-562 cells. In contrast, 29, 22 and 23 imbalances were detected in K-562 nuclei sorted from the 32%, 13% and 5% mixtures, respectively. This indicate that CGH analysis of flow sorted DNA aneuploid subpopulations enables a specific cytogenetic analysis of the individual subclones in a DNA heteroploid cell population.     

Cell sorting and microchemistry of cultured human fibroblasts: applications in genetics and aging research

Cell sorting is a way to isolate viable subpopulations of cells present in a mixture. The drawback of the isolation method is the shortage of material for subsequent biochemical determinations. We have employed a combination of (ultra-) microchemistry and cell sorting to overcome this problem. The methods enable determinations of protein and several enzyme activities on triton extracts of 5,000-10,000 sorted cells. In addition, using ultramicromethods we could determine enzyme activity in single sorted cells. This combination of methods is used for clinical genetic studies on heterozygote detection in Fabry's disease, an X-linked genetic disease. Moreover, microchemistry is used to study enzyme activities in sorted autofluorescent "aged" fibroblasts.     

Electron microscopic identification and morphologic preservation of enriched populations of lung cells isolated by laser flow cytometry and cell sorting: a new technique

There is increasing need to verify the identities of cell subpopulations enriched by laser flow cytometry and fluorescence-activated cell sorting (FACS). When cell subpopulations isolated from whole organs or tissues have similar characteristics (e.g., size, granularity, staining), light, phase contrast or fluorescence microscopy may not provide sufficient resolution to identify isolated cells accurately and many flow cytometric parameters (e.g., viability, fluorescence) require the cells to be live at the point of analysis where the cell transects the laser beam. In some studies, cells identified by fluorescence microscopy as a highly enriched subpopulation were found by electron microscopy to contain significant populations of other cell types. A technique, fixation-in-flow (FIF), has been developed to increase ability to correlate morphological and laser analyses of cell subpopulations. Sheath fluid is replaced by fixative, permitting fixation to be initiated immediately after laser beam analysis of live cells. This new procedure yields improved cytoarchitectural preservation of recovered cell subpopulation(s) for evaluation by transmission or scanning electron microscopy. This report presents results from applying the methodology to identify more accurately cell subpopulations of the distal lung, specifically type II pneumocytes, Clara cells and pulmonary macrophages. A modification of this procedure was employed to isolate fibroblast subpopulations from murine lung fibroblasts grown in vitro and the procedure is being used to determine the responses of cultured fibroblasts to other permutations (e.g., X-irradiation, cytokines).     

Does the high nucleic acid content of individual bacterial cells allow us to discriminate between active cells and inactive cells in aquatic systems?

The nucleic acid contents of individual bacterial cells as determined with three different nucleic acid-specific fluorescent dyes (SYBR I, SYBR II, and SYTO 13) and flow cytometry were compared for different seawater samples. Similar fluorescence patterns were observed, and bacteria with high apparent nucleic acid contents (HNA) could be discriminated from bacteria with low nucleic acid contents (LNA). The best discrimination between HNA and LNA cells was found when cells were stained with SYBR II. Bacteria in different water samples collected from seven freshwater, brackish water, and seawater ecosystems were prelabeled with tritiated leucine and then stained with SYBR II. After labeling and staining, HNA, LNA, and total cells were sorted by flow cytometry, and the specific activity of each cellular category was determined from leucine incorporation rates. The HNA cells were responsible for most of the total bacterial production, and the specific activities of cells in the HNA population varied between samples by a factor of seven. We suggest that nucleic acid content alone can be a better indicator of the fraction of growing cells than total counts and that this approach should be combined with other fluorescent physiological probes to improve detection of the most active cells in aquatic systems.     

Defining the heterogeneity of skeletal muscle‐derived side and main population cells isolated immediately ex vivo

Myoblast transfer therapy for Duchenne muscular dystrophy (DMD) largely fails due to cell death and inability of transplanted cells to engraft in diseased muscles. One method attempting to enrich for cell subpopulations is the Hoechst 33342 dye exclusion assay, yielding a side population (SP) thought to be progenitor enriched and a main population (MP). However, in vitro and transplant studies yielded inconsistent results relative to downstream progeny. Cell surface markers expressed by skeletal muscle‐derived MP and SP cells have not been fully characterized directly ex vivo. Using flow cytometry, MP and SP cells were characterized based on their expression of several well‐accepted progenitor cell antigens. Both the MP and SP populations are heterogeneous and overlapping in the cells they contain. The percentages of cells in each population vary with species and specific muscle examined. MP and SP populations contain both satellite and multipotent progenitor cells, based on expression of CD34, Sca‐1, Pax7, and M‐cadherin. Thus, isolation using this procedure cannot be used to predict downstream differentiation outcomes, and explains the conflicting literature on these cells. Hoechst dye also results in significant mortality of sorted cells. As defined subpopulations are easily obtained using flow cytometry, sorting immediately ex vivo based on accepted myogenic precursor cell markers will yield superior results in terms of cell homogeneity for transplantation therapy. J. Cell. Physiol. 222: 676–684, 2010. © 2009 Wiley‐Liss, Inc.     

Does the High Nucleic Acid Content of Individual Bacterial Cells Allow Us To Discriminate between Active Cells and Inactive Cells in Aquatic Systems?

The nucleic acid contents of individual bacterial cells as determined with three different nucleic acid-specific fluorescent dyes (SYBR I, SYBR II, and SYTO 13) and flow cytometry were compared for different seawater samples. Similar fluorescence patterns were observed, and bacteria with high apparent nucleic acid contents (HNA) could be discriminated from bacteria with low nucleic acid contents (LNA). The best discrimination between HNA and LNA cells was found when cells were stained with SYBR II. Bacteria in different water samples collected from seven freshwater, brackish water, and seawater ecosystems were prelabeled with tritiated leucine and then stained with SYBR II. After labeling and staining, HNA, LNA, and total cells were sorted by flow cytometry, and the specific activity of each cellular category was determined from leucine incorporation rates. The HNA cells were responsible for most of the total bacterial production, and the specific activities of cells in the HNA population varied between samples by a factor of seven. We suggest that nucleic acid content alone can be a better indicator of the fraction of growing cells than total counts and that this approach should be combined with other fluorescent physiological probes to improve detection of the most active cells in aquatic systems.     

Subpopulations of Slowly Cycling Cells In S and G2 Phase In Mouse Epidermis

Evidence has been presented supporting the existence of heterogeneity in cell-cycle progression in mouse epidermis, the present study was undertaken to characterize this heterogeneity in more detail. Hairless mice were continuously labelled with tritiated thymidine every 4 hr for 4 days. Basal cell suspensions were prepared from slices of mouse skin at intervals during the experiment and subjected to DNA flow cytometry. Cell-cycle analysis was combined with sorting of cells from windows in G¹, S and G², phase, and the proportion of labelled cells within each window was determined in autoradiographs. Reanalysis and resorting to control the purity of sorted fractions were performed. Computer simulations of the data were made using a mathematical model assuming different S and G² phase characteristics. A good fit to the data was only obtained when heterogeneity in mouse epidermal cell-cycle progression was assumed, indicating the existence of slowly traversing, distinct subpopulations of cells in G² and S phase. These cells are assumed to contribute to about 40% of all cells in S phase and to about 70% of all in G² phase. the estimated residence times in the resting states were 38 and 32 hr in S and G² phase, respectively. Two-parameter sorting based on DNA and light scatter indicated that slowly cycling cells were larger than the average. There is no evidence of significant subpopulations of permanently non-proliferating keratinocytes in any of the cell-cycle phases.     

Responses of Escherichia coli, Listeria monocytogenes, and Staphylococcus aureus to simulated food processing treatments, determined using fluorescence-activated cell sorting and plate counting

Three common food pathogenic microorganisms were exposed to treatments simulating those used in food processing. Treated cell suspensions were then analyzed for reduction in growth by plate counting. Flow cytometry (FCM) and fluorescence-activated cell sorting (FACS) were carried out on treated cells stained for membrane integrity (Syto 9/propidium iodide) or the presence of membrane potential [DiOC2(3)]. For each microbial species, representative cells from various subpopulations detected by FCM were sorted onto selective and nonselective agar and evaluated for growth and recovery rates. In general, treatments giving rise to the highest reductions in counts also had the greatest effects on cell membrane integrity and membrane potential. Overall, treatments that impacted cell membrane permeability did not necessarily have a comparable effect on membrane potential. In addition, some bacterial species with extensively damaged membranes, as detected by FCM, appeared to be able to replicate and grow after sorting. Growth of sorted cells from various subpopulations was not always reflected in plate counts, and in some cases the staining protocol may have rendered cells unculturable. Optimized FCM protocols generated a greater insight into the extent of the heterogeneous bacterial population responses to food control measures than did plate counts. This study underlined the requirement to use FACS to relate various cytometric profiles generated by various staining protocols with the ability of cells to grow on microbial agar plates. Such information is a prerequisite for more-widespread adoption of FCM as a routine microbiological analytical technique.     

Subpopulations of slowly cycling cells in S and G2 phase in mouse epidermis

Evidence has been presented supporting the existence of heterogeneity in cell-cycle progression in mouse epidermis, The present study was undertaken to characterize this heterogeneity in more detail. Hairless mice were continuously labelled with tritiated thymidine every 4 hr for 4 days. Basal cell suspensions were prepared from slices of mouse skin at intervals during the experiment and subjected to DNA flow cytometry. Cell-cycle analysis was combined with sorting of cells from windows in G1, S and G2 phase, and the proportion of labelled cells within each window was determined in autoradiographs. Reanalysis and resorting to control the purity of of sorted fractions were performed. Computer simulations of the data were made using a mathematical model assuming different S and G2 phase characteristics. A good fit to the data was only obtained when heterogeneity in mouse epidermal cell-cycle progression was assumed, indicating the existence of slowly traversing, distinct subpopulations of cells in G2 and S phase. These cells are assumed to contribute to about 40% of all cells in S phase and to about 70% of all in G2 phase. The estimated residence times in the resting states were 38 and 32 hr in S and G2 phase, respectively. Two-parameter sorting based on DNA and light scatter indicated that slowly cycling cells were larger than the average. There is no evidence of significant subpopulations of permanently non-proliferating keratinocytes in any of the cell-cycle phases.