Evolution of the mitochondrial genetic code III. Reassignment of CUN codons from leucine to threonine during evolution of yeast mitochondria

Summary Yeast mitochondria use UUR as the sole leucine codons. CUN, universal leucine codons, are read as threonine by aberrant threonine tRNA with anticodon sequence (UAG).The reassignment of CUN codons to threonine during yeast mitochondrial evolution could have proceeded by the disappearance of CUN codons from the reading frames of messenger RNA, through mutation mainly to UUR leucine codons as a result of AT pressure. We suggest that this was accompanied by a loss of leucine-accepting ability of tRNA Leu(UAG). This tRNA could have then acquired threonine-accepting activity through the appearance of an additional threonyl-tRNA synthetase. CUN codons that subsequently appeared from mutations of various other codons would have been translated as threonine. This change in the yeast mitochondrial genetic code is likely to have evolved through a series of nondisruptive nucleotide substitutions that produced no widespread replacement of leucine by threonine in proteins as a consequence.     

A minimalist mitochondrial threonyl-tRNA synthetase exhibits tRNA-isoacceptor specificity during proofreading

Yeast mitochondria contain a minimalist threonyl-tRNA synthetase (ThrRS) composed only of the catalytic core and tRNA binding domain but lacking the entire editing domain. Besides the usual tRNA^Thr2, some budding yeasts, such as Saccharomyces cerevisiae, also contain a non-canonical tRNA^Thr1 with an enlarged 8-nucleotide anticodon loop, reprograming the usual leucine CUN codons to threonine. This raises interesting questions about the aminoacylation fidelity of such ThrRSs and the possible contribution of the two tRNA^Thrs during editing. Here, we found that, despite the absence of the editing domain, S. cerevisiae mitochondrial ThrRS (ScmtThrRS) harbors a tRNA-dependent pre-transfer editing activity. Remarkably, only the usual tRNA^Thr2 stimulated pre-transfer editing, thus, establishing the first example of a synthetase exhibiting tRNA-isoacceptor specificity during pre-transfer editing. We also showed that the failure of tRNA^Thr1 to stimulate tRNA-dependent pre-transfer editing was due to the lack of an editing domain. Using assays of the complementation of a ScmtThrRS gene knockout strain, we showed that the catalytic core and tRNA binding domain of ScmtThrRS co-evolved to recognize the unusual tRNA^Thr1. In combination, the results provide insights into the tRNA-dependent editing process and suggest that tRNA-dependent pre-transfer editing takes place in the aminoacylation catalytic core.     

Suppression of Amber Codons in Caulobacter crescentus by the Orthogonal Escherichia coli Histidyl-tRNA Synthetase/tRNAHis Pair

While translational read-through of stop codons by suppressor tRNAs is common in many bacteria, archaea and eukaryotes, this phenomenon has not yet been observed in the α-proteobacterium Caulobacter crescentus. Based on a previous report that C. crescentus and Escherichia coli tRNA^His have distinctive identity elements, we constructed E. coli tRNA^His _CUA, a UAG suppressor tRNA for C. crescentus. By examining the expression of three UAG codon- containing reporter genes (encoding a β-lactamase, the fluorescent mCherry protein, or the C. crescentus xylonate dehydratase), we demonstrated that the E. coli histidyl-tRNA synthetase/tRNA^His _CUA pair enables in vivo UAG suppression in C. crescentus. E. coli histidyl-tRNA synthetase (HisRS) or tRNA^His _CUA alone did not achieve suppression; this indicates that the E. coli HisRS/tRNA^His _CUA pair is orthogonal in C. crescentus. These results illustrate that UAG suppression can be achieved in C. crescentus with an orthogonal aminoacyl-tRNA synthetase/suppressor tRNA pair.     

Plant mitochondria use two pathways for the biogenesis of tRNAHis

All tRNA^His possess an essential extra G_–1 guanosine residue at their 5′ end. In eukaryotes after standard processing by RNase P, G_–1 is added by a tRNA^His guanylyl transferase. In prokaryotes, G_–1 is genome-encoded and retained during maturation. In plant mitochondria, although trnH genes possess a G_–1 we find here that both maturation pathways can be used. Indeed, tRNA^His with or without a G_–1 are found in a plant mitochondrial tRNA fraction. Furthermore, a recombinant Arabidopsis mitochondrial RNase P can cleave tRNA^His precursors at both positions G₊₁ and G_–1. The G_–1 is essential for recognition by plant mitochondrial histidyl-tRNA synthetase. Whether, as shown in prokaryotes and eukaryotes, the presence of uncharged tRNA^His without G_–1 has a function or not in plant mitochondrial gene regulation is an open question. We find that when a mutated version of a plant mitochondrial trnH gene containing no encoded extra G is introduced and expressed into isolated potato mitochondria, mature tRNA^His with a G_–1 are recovered. This shows that a previously unreported tRNA^His guanylyltransferase activity is present in plant mitochondria.     

Mitochondrial leucine tRNA level and PTCD1 are regulated in response to leucine starvation

Pentatricopeptide repeat domain protein 1 (PTCD1) is a novel human protein that was recently shown to decrease the levels of mitochondrial leucine tRNAs. The physiological role of this regulation, however, remains unclear. Here we show that amino acid starvation by leucine deprivation significantly increased the mRNA steady-state levels of PTCD1 in human hepatocarcinoma (HepG2) cells. Amino acid starvation also increased the mitochondrially encoded leucine tRNA (tRNA^Leu(CUN)) and the mRNA for the mitochondrial leucyl-tRNA synthetase (LARS2). Despite increased PTCD1 mRNA steady-state levels, amino acid starvation decreased PTCD1 on the protein level. Decreasing PTCD1 protein concentration increases the stability of the mitochondrial leucine tRNAs, tRNA^Leu(CUN) and tRNA^Leu(UUR) as could be shown by RNAi experiments against PTCD1. Therefore, it is likely that decreased PTCD1 protein contributes to the increased tRNA^Leu(CUN) levels in amino acid-starved cells. The stabilisation of the mitochondrial leucine tRNAs and the upregulation of the mitochondrial leucyl-tRNA synthetase LARS2 might play a role in adaptation of mitochondria to amino acid starvation.     

The crystal structure of yeast mitochondrial ThrRS in complex with the canonical threonine tRNA

In mitochondria of Saccharomyces cerevisiae, a single aminoacyl-tRNA synthetase (aaRS), MST1, aminoacylates two isoacceptor tRNAs, tRNA₁^Thr and tRNA₂^Thr, that harbor anticodon loops of different size and sequence. As a result of this promiscuity, reassignment of the CUN codon box from leucine to threonine is facilitated. However, the mechanism by which a single aaRS binds distinct anticodon loops with high specificity is not well understood. Herein, we present the crystal structure of MST1 in complex with the canonical tRNA₂^Thr and non-hydrolyzable analog of threonyl adenylate. Our structure reveals that the dimeric arrangement of MST1 is essential for binding the 5′-phosphate, the second base pair of the acceptor stem, the first two base pairs of the anticodon stem and the first nucleotide of the variable arm. Further, in contrast to the bacterial ortholog that ‘reads’ the entire anticodon sequence, MST1 recognizes bases in the second and third position and the nucleotide upstream of the anticodon sequence. We speculate that a flexible loop linking strands β4 and β5 may be allosteric regulator that establishes cross-subunit communication between the aminoacylation and tRNA-binding sites. We also propose that structural features of the anticodon-binding domain in MST1 permit binding of the enlarged anticodon loop of tRNA₁^Thr.     

tRNAHis 5-methylcytidine levels increase in response to several growth arrest conditions in Saccharomyces cerevisiae

tRNAs are highly modified, each with a unique set of modifications. Several reports suggest that tRNAs are hypomodified or, in some cases, hypermodified under different growth conditions and in certain cancers. We previously demonstrated that yeast strains depleted of tRNA^His guanylyltransferase accumulate uncharged tRNA^His lacking the G₋₁ residue and subsequently accumulate additional 5-methylcytidine (m⁵C) at residues C₄₈ and C₅₀ of tRNA^His, due to the activity of the m⁵C-methyltransferase Trm4. We show here that the increase in tRNA^His m⁵C levels does not require loss of Thg1, loss of G₋₁ of tRNA^His, or cell death but is associated with growth arrest following different stress conditions. We find substantially increased tRNA^His m⁵C levels after temperature-sensitive strains are grown at nonpermissive temperature, and after wild-type strains are grown to stationary phase, starved for required amino acids, or treated with rapamycin. We observe more modest accumulations of m⁵C in tRNA^His after starvation for glucose and after starvation for uracil. In virtually all cases examined, the additional m⁵C on tRNA^His occurs while cells are fully viable, and the increase is neither due to the GCN4 pathway, nor to increased Trm4 levels. Moreover, the increased m⁵C appears specific to tRNA^His, as tRNA^Val(AAC) and tRNA^Gly(GCC) have much reduced additional m⁵C during these growth arrest conditions, although they also have C₄₈ and C₅₀ and are capable of having increased m⁵C levels. Thus, tRNA^His m⁵C levels are unusually responsive to yeast growth conditions, although the significance of this additional m⁵C remains unclear.     

Toxicity of a heterologous leucyl-tRNA (anticodon CAG) in the pathogen Candida albicans: in vivo evidence for non-standard decoding of CUG codons

Plasmids containing derivatives of the Saccharomyces cerevisiae leucyl-tRNA (tRNA3 ₃ ^Leu ) gene that vary in anticodon sequence were constructed and transformed into the pathogen Candida albicans and S. cerevisiae. C. albicans could readily be transformed with plasmids encoding leucyl-tRNA genes with the anticodons CAA and UAA (recognizing the codons UUG and UUA) and expression of the heterologous tRNA^Leu could be demonstrated by Northern RNA blotting. In contrast, no transformants were obtained if the anticodons were UAG (codons recognized CUN, UUR) and CAG (codon CUG), indicating that the insertion of leucine at CUG codons is toxic for C. albicans. All tRNA^Leu-encoding plasmids transformed S. cerevisiae with equally high efficiencies. These results provide in vivo evidence that non-standard decoding of CUG codons is essential for the viability of C. albicans.     

Structural Studies of a Bacterial tRNAHIS Guanylyltransferase (Thg1)-Like Protein,with Nucleotide in the Activation and Nucleotidyl Transfer Sites

All nucleotide polymerases and transferases catalyze nucleotide addition in a 5′ to 3′ direction. In contrast, tRNA^His guanylyltransferase (Thg1) enzymes catalyze the unusual reverse addition (3′ to 5′) of nucleotides to polynucleotide substrates. In eukaryotes, Thg1 enzymes use the 3′–5′ addition activity to add G₋₁ to the 5′-end of tRNA^His, a modification required for efficient aminoacylation of the tRNA by the histidyl-tRNA synthetase. Thg1-like proteins (TLPs) are found in Archaea, Bacteria, and mitochondria and are biochemically distinct from their eukaryotic Thg1 counterparts TLPs catalyze 5′-end repair of truncated tRNAs and act on a broad range of tRNA substrates instead of exhibiting strict specificity for tRNA^His. Taken together, these data suggest that TLPs function in distinct biological pathways from the tRNA^His maturation pathway, perhaps in tRNA quality control. Here we present the first crystal structure of a TLP, from the gram-positive soil bacterium Bacillus thuringiensis (BtTLP). The enzyme is a tetramer like human THG1, with which it shares substantial structural similarity. Catalysis of the 3′–5′ reaction with 5′-monophosphorylated tRNA necessitates first an activation step, generating a 5′-adenylylated intermediate prior to a second nucleotidyl transfer step, in which a nucleotide is transferred to the tRNA 5′-end. Consistent with earlier characterization of human THG1, we observed distinct binding sites for the nucleotides involved in these two steps of activation and nucleotidyl transfer. A BtTLP complex with GTP reveals new interactions with the GTP nucleotide in the activation site that were not evident from the previously solved structure. Moreover, the BtTLP-ATP structure allows direct observation of ATP in the activation site for the first time. The BtTLP structural data, combined with kinetic analysis of selected variants, provide new insight into the role of key residues in the activation step.     

Assay of both activities of the bifunctional tRNA-modifying enzyme MnmC reveals a kinetic basis for selective full modification of cmnm5s2U to mnm5s2U

Transfer RNA (tRNA) contains a number of complex ‘hypermodified’ nucleosides that are essential for a number of genetic processes. Intermediate forms of these nucleosides are rarely found in tRNA despite the fact that modification is not generally a complete process. We propose that the modification machinery is tuned into an efficient ‘assembly line’ that performs the modification steps at similar, or sequentially increasing, rates to avoid build-up of possibly deleterious intermediates. To investigate this concept, we measured steady-state kinetics for the final two steps of the biosynthesis of the mnm⁵s²U nucleoside in Escherichia coli tRNA^Glu, which are both catalysed by the bifunctional MnmC enzyme. High-performance liquid chromatography-based assays using selectively under-modified tRNA substrates gave a K_m value of 600 nM and k_cat 0.34 s⁻¹ for the first step, and K_m 70 nM and k_cat 0.31 s⁻¹ for the second step. These values show that the second reaction occurs faster than the first reaction, or at a similar rate at very high substrate concentrations. This result indicates that the enzyme is kinetically tuned to produce fully modified mnm⁵(s²)U while avoiding build-up of the nm⁵(s²)U intermediate. The assay method developed here represents a general approach for the comparative analysis of tRNA-modifying enzymes.     

Toxicity of a heterologous leucyl-tRNA (anticodon CAG) in the pathogen Candida albicans: in vivo evidence for non-standard decoding of CUG codons

Plasmids containing derivatives of the Saccharomyces cerevisiae leucyl-tRNA (tRNA3 ₃ ^Leu ) gene that vary in anticodon sequence were constructed and transformed into the pathogen Candida albicans and S. cerevisiae. C. albicans could readily be transformed with plasmids encoding leucyl-tRNA genes with the anticodons CAA and UAA (recognizing the codons UUG and UUA) and expression of the heterologous tRNA^Leu could be demonstrated by Northern RNA blotting. In contrast, no transformants were obtained if the anticodons were UAG (codons recognized CUN, UUR) and CAG (codon CUG), indicating that the insertion of leucine at CUG codons is toxic for C. albicans. All tRNA^Leu-encoding plasmids transformed S. cerevisiae with equally high efficiencies. These results provide in vivo evidence that non-standard decoding of CUG codons is essential for the viability of C. albicans.     

Life without tRNAIle-lysidine synthetase: translation of the isoleucine codon AUA in Bacillus subtilis lacking the canonical tRNA2Ile

Translation of the isoleucine codon AUA in most prokaryotes requires a modified C (lysidine or agmatidine) at the wobble position of tRNA₂^Ile to base pair specifically with the A of the AUA codon but not with the G of AUG. Recently, a Bacillus subtilis strain was isolated in which the essential gene encoding tRNA^Ile-lysidine synthetase was deleted for the first time. In such a strain, C34 at the wobble position of tRNA₂^Ile is expected to remain unmodified and cells depend on a mutant suppressor tRNA derived from tRNA₁^Ile, in which G34 has been changed to U34. An important question, therefore, is how U34 base pairs with A without also base pairing with G. Here, we show (i) that unlike U34 at the wobble position of all B. subtilis tRNAs of known sequence, U34 in the mutant tRNA is not modified, and (ii) that the mutant tRNA binds strongly to the AUA codon on B. subtilis ribosomes but only weakly to AUG. These in vitro data explain why the suppressor strain displays only a low level of misreading AUG codons in vivo and, as shown here, grows at a rate comparable to that of the wild-type strain.     

Specificity of codon recognition by Escherichia coli tRNALeu isoaccepting species determined by protein synthesis in vitro directed by phage RNA.

Codon-anticodon recognition and transfer RNA utilization for the leucine tRNA isoaccepting species of Escherichia coli have been studied by protein synthesis in vitro directed by sequenced bacteriophage MS2 RNA. We have added radioactive Leu-tRNA^Leu isoaccepting species as tracers, rather than use a tRNA-dependent system, since in the presence of an excess of non-radioactive leucine, there is no transfer of radioactive leucine from one isoaccepting species to another. MS2-specific peptides containing leucine residues encoded by known codons were isolated and identified, and the relative abilities of the Leu-tRNA^Leu isoaccepting species to transfer leucine into these peptides compared. Sequenced tRNA₁^Leu and sequenced tRNA₃^Leu are of roughly equal efficiency in their ability to recognize CUC and CUA codons, while tRNA₃^Leu is highly preferred for the CUU codon; tRNA₄^Leu and tRNA₅^Leu both recognize UUA and UUG codons, with tRNA₄^Leu slightly preferred for the UUA codon. We conclude that: (1) wobble is greater than permitted by the wobble hypothesis; (2) there is still some discrimination in the third code letter, and that the CUX₄ (CUC, CUA, CUU, CUG) portion of the leucine family of six codons is not read by a simple “two out of three” mechanism; (3) a Watson-Crick pair (C · G) between codon and anticodon does not appear to be preferred over an unorthodox pair (C · C) in the wobble position; (4) a standard wobble pair (U · G) between codon and anticodon is preferred over an unorthodox pair (U · C); and (5) the extensive wobble observed in the CUX₄ leucine codon series is not paralleled in the UUX₄ leucine (UUG, UUA) and phenylalanine (UUU, UUC) codon series, where mistranslation would be the consequence of such wobble.     

Natural reassignment of CUU and CUA sense codons to alanine in Ashbya mitochondria

The discovery of diverse codon reassignment events has demonstrated that the canonical genetic code is not universal. Studying coding reassignment at the molecular level is critical for understanding genetic code evolution, and provides clues to genetic code manipulation in synthetic biology. Here we report a novel reassignment event in the mitochondria of Ashbya (Eremothecium) gossypii, a filamentous-growing plant pathogen related to yeast (Saccharomycetaceae). Bioinformatics studies of conserved positions in mitochondrial DNA-encoded proteins suggest that CUU and CUA codons correspond to alanine in A. gossypii, instead of leucine in the standard code or threonine in yeast mitochondria. Reassignment of CUA to Ala was confirmed at the protein level by mass spectrometry. We further demonstrate that a predicted is transcribed and accurately processed in vivo, and is responsible for Ala reassignment. Enzymatic studies reveal that is efficiently recognized by A. gossypii mitochondrial alanyl-tRNA synthetase (AgAlaRS). AlaRS typically recognizes the G3:U70 base pair of tRNA^Ala; a G3A change in Ashbya abolishes its recognition by AgAlaRS. Conversely, an A3G mutation in Saccharomyces cerevisiae confers tRNA recognition by AgAlaRS. Our work highlights the dynamic feature of natural genetic codes in mitochondria, and the relative simplicity by which tRNA identity may be switched.     

In vivo identification of essential nucleotides in tRNALeu to its functions by using a constructed yeast tRNALeu knockout strain

The fidelity of protein biosynthesis requires the aminoacylation of tRNA with its cognate amino acid catalyzed by aminoacyl-tRNA synthetase with high levels of accuracy and efficiency. Crucial bases in tRNA^Leu to aminoacylation or editing functions of leucyl-tRNA synthetase have been extensively studied mainly by in vitro methods. In the present study, we constructed two Saccharomyces cerevisiae tRNA^Leu knockout strains carrying deletions of the genes for tRNA^Leu(GAG) and tRNA^Leu(UAG). Disrupting the single gene encoding tRNA^Leu(GAG) had no phenotypic consequence when compared to the wild-type strain. While disrupting the three genes for tRNA^Leu(UAG) had a lethal effect on the yeast strain, indicating that tRNA^Leu(UAG) decoding capacity could not be compensated by another tRNA^Leu isoacceptor. Using the triple tRNA knockout strain and a randomly mutated library of tRNA^Leu(UAG), a selection to identify critical tRNA^Leu elements was performed. In this way, mutations inducing in vivo decreases of tRNA levels or aminoacylation or editing ability by leucyl-tRNA synthetase were identified. Overall, the data showed that the triple tRNA knockout strain is a suitable tool for in vivo studies and identification of essential nucleotides of the tRNA.     

Primary structure of three tRNAs from brewer's yeast: tRNA2, tRNA1 and tRNA2

The primary structures of three brewer's yeast tRNAs: tRNA^Pro₂ and tRNA^His_{1 and 2} have been determined

Full-size image (14K)

The U* in the anticodon U*-G-G of tRNA^Pro₂ is probably a derivative of U; tRNA^Pro₂ has 80 per cent homology with mammalian tRNAs^Pro. tRNA^His₁ and tRNA^His₂ differ by only 5 nucleotides; they have identical anticodons and may therefore recognize both codons for histidine; they have an additional nucleotide at the 5′ end. As in all other sequenced tRNAs^His this nucleotide is not paired with the fourth nucleotide from acceptor adenosine. All three sequenced tRNAs have a low degree of homology with their counterparts from yeast mitochondria.