Stability of telomeric G-quadruplexes

In most eukaryotes, telomeric DNA consists of repeats of a short motif that includes consecutive guanines and may hence fold into G-quadruplexes. Budding yeasts have telomeres composed of longer repeats and show variation in the degree of repeat homogeneity. Although telomeric sequences from several organisms have been shown to fold into G-quadruplexes in vitro, surprisingly, no study has been dedicated to the comparison of G-quadruplex folding and stability of known telomeric sequences. Furthermore, to our knowledge, folding of yeast telomeric sequences into intramolecular G-quadruplexes has never been investigated. Using biophysical and biochemical methods, we studied sequences mimicking about four repetitions of telomeric motifs from a variety of organisms, including yeasts, with the aim of comparing the G-quadruplex folding potential of telomeric sequences among eukaryotes. G-quadruplex folding did not appear to be a conserved feature among yeast telomeric sequences. By contrast, all known telomeric sequences from eukaryotes other than yeasts folded into G-quadruplexes. Nevertheless, while G(3)T(1-4)A repeats (found in a variety of organisms) and G(4)T(2,4) repeats (found in ciliates) folded into stable G-quadruplexes, G-quadruplexes formed by repetitions of G(2)T(2)A and G(2)CT(2)A motifs (found in many insects and in nematodes, respectively) appeared to be in equilibrium with non-G-quadruplex structures (likely hairpin-duplexes).     

Human telomeric sequence forms a hybrid-type intramolecular G-quadruplex structure with mixed parallel/antiparallel strands in potassium solution

Human telomeric DNA consists of tandem repeats of the sequence d(TTAGGG). The formation and stabilization of DNA G-quadruplexes in the human telomeric sequence have been shown to inhibit the activity of telomerase, thus the telomeric DNA G-quadruplex has been considered as an attractive target for cancer therapeutic intervention. However, knowledge of the intact human telomeric G-quadruplex structure(s) formed under physiological conditions is a prerequisite for structure-based rational drug design. Here we report the folding structure of the human telomeric sequence in K⁺ solution determined by NMR. Our results demonstrate a novel, unprecedented intramolecular G-quadruplex folding topology with hybrid-type mixed parallel/antiparallel G-strands. This telomeric G-quadruplex structure contains three G-tetrads with mixed G-arrangements, which are connected consecutively with a double-chain-reversal side loop and two lateral loops, each consisting of three nucleotides TTA. This intramolecular hybrid-type telomeric G-quadruplex structure formed in K⁺ solution is distinct from those reported on the 22 nt Tel22 in Na⁺ solution and in crystalline state in the presence of K⁺, and appears to be the predominant conformation for the extended 26 nt telomeric sequence Tel26 in the presence of K⁺, regardless of the presence or absence of Na⁺. Furthermore, the addition of K⁺ readily converts the Na⁺-form conformation to the K⁺-form hybrid-type G-quadruplex. Our results explain all the reported experimental data on the human telomeric G-quadruplexes formed in the presence of K⁺, and provide important insights for understanding the polymorphism and interconversion of various G-quadruplex structures formed within the human telomeric sequence, as well as the effects of sequence and cations. This hybrid-type G-quadruplex topology suggests a straightforward pathway for the secondary structure formation with effective packing within the extended human telomeric DNA. The hybrid-type telomeric G-quadruplex is most likely to be of pharmacological relevance, and the distinct folding topology of this G-quadruplex suggests that it can be specifically targeted by G-quadruplex interactive small molecule drugs.     

Structural diversity and extreme stability of unimolecular Oxytricha nova telomeric G-quadruplex

Oxytricha nova telomeric DNA contains guanine-rich short-tandem repeat sequences (GGGGTTTT) n and terminates as a single strand at the 3'-end. This single-stranded overhang forms a novel DNA structure, namely, G-quadruplex, comprising four quartets. In this study, we investigated the structures and dynamics of unimolecular Oxytricha nova ( O. nova) telomeric G-quadruplexes by performing single molecule fluorescence resonance energy transfer (FRET) spectroscopy and bulk circular dichroism (CD) measurements. We observed that unimolecular O. nova G-quadruplexes exhibit structural polymorphism according to monovalent cations. In the presence of Na (+), only antiparallel conformation is detected, which was demonstrated in previous studies; however, in the presence of K (+), they fold into two different conformations, a parallel conformation and an antiparallel one different from that induced by Na (+). Furthermore, these G-quadruplexes show extremely high stability in their dynamics when compared with human G-quadruplexes. While human telomeric G-quadruplexes that possess three quartets display fast dynamic behavior (<100 s) at low K (+) concentrations or high temperatures, O. nova G-quadruplexes maintain their conformational state for a long time (>1000 s), even at the lowest K (+) concentration and the highest temperature investigated. This high stability is primarily due to an extra quartet that results in additional cation coordination. In addition to cation coordination, we propose that other factors such as base stacking and the size of the thymine loop may contribute to the stability of O. nova G-quadruplexes; this is based on the fact that the O. nova G-quadruplexes were observed to be more stable than the human ones in the presence of Li (+), which is known to greatly destabilize G-quadruplexes because of imprecise coordination. This extreme stability of four-quartet G-quadruplexes enables telomere protection even in the absence of protective proteins or in the case of abrupt environmental changes, although only a single G-quadruplex structure can be derived from the short single-stranded overhang.     

Telomeric repeat mutagenicity in human somatic cells is modulated by repeat orientation and G-quadruplex stability

Telomeres consisting of tandem guanine-rich repeats can form secondary DNA structures called G-quadruplexes that represent potential targets for DNA repair enzymes. While G-quadruplexes interfere with DNA synthesis in vitro, the impact of G-quadruplex formation on telomeric repeat replication in human cells is not clear. We investigated the mutagenicity of telomeric repeats as a function of G-quadruplex folding opportunity and thermal stability using a shuttle vector mutagenesis assay. Since single-stranded DNA during lagging strand replication increases the opportunity for G-quadruplex folding, we tested vectors with G-rich sequences on the lagging versus the leading strand. Contrary to our prediction, vectors containing human [TTAGGG]₁₀ repeats with a G-rich lagging strand were significantly less mutagenic than vectors with a G-rich leading strand, after replication in normal human cells. We show by UV melting experiments that G-quadruplexes from ciliates [TTGGGG]₄ and [TTTTGGGG]₄ are thermally more stable compared to human [TTAGGG]₄. Consistent with this, replication of vectors with ciliate [TTGGGG]₁₀ repeats yielded a 3-fold higher mutant rate compared to the human [TTAGGG]₁₀ vectors. Furthermore, we observed significantly more mutagenic events in the ciliate repeats compared to the human repeats. Our data demonstrate that increased G-quadruplex opportunity (repeat orientation) in human telomeric repeats decreased mutagenicity, while increased thermal stability of telomeric G-quadruplexes was associated with increased mutagenicity.     

Kinetically governed polymorphism of d(G₄T₄G₃) quadruplexes in K+ solutions

It has been generally recognized that understanding the molecular basis of some important cellular processes is hampered by the lack of knowledge of forces that drive spontaneous formation/disruption of G-quadruplex structures in guanine-rich DNA sequences. According to numerous biophysical and structural studies G-quadruplexes may occur in the presence of K(+) and Na(+) ions as polymorphic structures formed in kinetically governed processes. The reported kinetic models suggested to describe this polymorphism should be considered inappropriate since, as a rule, they include bimolecular single-step associations characterized by negative activation energies. In contrast, our approach in studying polymorphic behavior of G-quadruplexes is based on model mechanisms that involve only elementary folding/unfolding transitions and structural conversion steps that are characterized by positive activation energies. Here, we are investigating a complex polymorphism of d(G(4)T(4)G(3)) quadruplexes in K(+) solutions. On the basis of DSC, circular dichroism and UV spectroscopy and polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis experiments we propose a kinetic model that successfully describes the observed thermally induced conformational transitions of d(G(4)T(4)G(3)) quadruplexes in terms of single-step reactions that involve besides single strands also one tetramolecular and three bimolecular quadruplex structures.     

A novel chair-type G-quadruplex formed by a Bombyx mori telomeric sequence

Recently, the human telomeric d[TAGGG(TTAGGG)₃] sequence has been shown to form in K⁺ solution an intramolecular (3+1) G-quadruplex structure, whose G-tetrad core contains three strands oriented in one direction and the fourth in the opposite direction. Here we present a study on the structure of the Bombyx mori telomeric d[TAGG(TTAGG)₃] sequence, which differs from the human counterpart only by one G deletion in each repeat. We found that this sequence adopted multiple G-quadruplex structures in K⁺ solution. We have favored a major G-quadruplex form by a judicious U-for-T substitution in the sequence and determined the folding topology of this form. We showed by NMR that this was a new chair-type intramolecular G-quadruplex which involved a two-layer antiparallel G-tetrad core and three edgewise loops. Our result highlights the effect of G-tract length on the folding topology of G-quadruplexes, but also poses the question of whether a similar chair-type G-quadruplex fold exists in the human telomeric sequences.     

Following G-quadruplex formation by its intrinsic fluorescence

We characterized and compared the fluorescence properties of various well-defined G-quadruplex structures. The increase of intrinsic fluorescence of G-rich DNA sequences when they form G-quadruplexes can be used to monitor the folding and unfolding of G-quadruplexes as a function of cations and temperature. The temperature-dependent fluorescence spectra of different G-quadruplexes also exhibit characteristic patterns. Thus, the stability and possibly also the structure of G-quadruplexes can be characterized and distinguished by their intrinsic fluorescence spectra.     

Folding dynamics and conformational heterogeneity of human telomeric G-quadruplex structures in Na+ solutions by single molecule FRET microscopy

G-quadruplex structures can occur throughout the genome, including at telomeres. They are involved in cellular regulation and are potential drug targets. Human telomeric G-quadruplex structures can fold into a number of different conformations and show large conformational diversity. To elucidate the different G-quadruplex conformations and their dynamics, we investigated telomeric G-quadruplex folding using single molecule FRET microscopy in conditions where it was previously believed to yield low structural heterogeneity. We observed four FRET states in Na⁺ buffers: an unfolded state and three G-quadruplex related states that can interconvert between each other. Several of these states were almost equally populated at low to medium salt concentrations. These observations appear surprising as previous studies reported primarily one G-quadruplex conformation in Na⁺ buffers. Our results permit, through the analysis of the dynamics of the different observed states, the identification of a more stable G-quadruplex conformation and two transient G-quadruplex states. Importantly these results offer a unique view into G-quadruplex topological heterogeneity and conformational dynamics.     

Interrogation of G-quadruplex-protein interactions

The ability to accurately examine the interaction of G-quadruplex DNA with proteins is essential for revealing the biological roles of these unusual DNA structures. In this regard, there are four primary G-quadruplex-related activities of proteins that have been studied including simple equilibrium binding, promotion or catalysis of G-quadruplex formation, dissociation of G-quadruplex structures, and covalent modification of G-quadruplexes, which includes both nucleolytic cleavage and nucleotide addition. Here, assays used to examine the interactions of G-quadruplexes with proteins will be reviewed and specific methods to study the interactions of G-quadruplexes from telomeric DNA sequences with a variety of proteins will be described. Importantly, this review emphasizes the importance of evaluating the integrity of the G-quadruplex being studied as single sequences can often form a variety of folded structures.     

Structure of the Hybrid-2 type intramolecular human telomeric G-quadruplex in K+ solution: insights into structure polymorphism of the human telomeric sequence

Formation of the G-quadruplex in the human telomeric sequence can inhibit the activity of telomerase, thus the intramolecular telomeric G-quadruplexes have been considered as an attractive anticancer target. Information of intramolecular telomeric G-quadruplex structures formed under physiological conditions is important for structure-based drug design. Here, we report the first structure of the major intramolecular G-quadruplex formed in a native, non-modified human telomeric sequence in K⁺ solution. This is a hybrid-type mixed parallel/antiparallel-G-stranded G-quadruplex, one end of which is covered by a novel T:A:T triple capping structure. This structure (Hybrid-2) and the previously reported Hybrid-1 structure differ in their loop arrangements, strand orientations and capping structures. The distinct capping structures appear to be crucial for the favored formation of the specific hybrid-type intramolecular telomeric G-quadruplexes, and may provide specific binding sites for drug targeting. Our study also shows that while the hybrid-type G-quadruplexes appear to be the major conformations in K⁺ solution, human telomeric sequences are always in equilibrium between Hybrid-1 and Hybrid-2 structures, which is largely determined by the 3′-flanking sequence. Furthermore, both hybrid-type G-quadruplexes suggest a straightforward means for multimer formation with effective packing in the human telomeric sequence and provide important implications for drug targeting of G-quadruplexes in human telomeres.     

Clerocidin-mediated DNA footprinting discriminates among different G-quadruplex conformations and detects tetraplex folding in a duplex environment

Background

G-quadruplexes are polymorphic non-canonical nucleic acid conformations involved both in physiological and pathological processes. Given the high degree of folding heterogeneity and comparable conformational stabilities, different G-quadruplex forms can occur simultaneously, hence rendering the use of basic instrumental methods for structure determination, like X-ray diffraction or NMR, hardly useful. Footprinting techniques represent valuable and relatively rapid alternative to characterize DNA folding. The natural diterpenoid clerocidin is an alkylating agent that specifically reacts at single-stranded DNA regions, with different mechanisms depending on the exposed nucleotide.

Methods

Clerocidin was used to footprint G-quadruplex structures formed by telomeric and oncogene promoter sequences (c-myc, bcl-2, c-kit2), and by the thrombin binding aptamer.

Results

The easy modulability of CL reactivity towards DNA bases permitted to discriminate fully and partially protected sites, highlights stretched portions of the G-quadruplex conformation, and discriminate among topologies adopted by one sequence in different environmental conditions. Importantly, CL displayed the unique property to allow detection of G-quadruplex folding within a duplex context.

Conclusions

CL is a finely performing new tool to unveil G-quadruplex arrangements in DNA sequences under genomically relevant conditions.

General significance

Nucleic acid G-quadruplex structures are an emerging research field because of the recent indication of their involvement in a series of key biological functions, in particular in regulation of proliferation-associated gene expression. The use of clerocidin as footprinting agent to identify G-quadruplex structures under genomically relevant conditions may allow detection of new G-quadruplex-based regulatory regions.     

Structural properties of the [d(G3T4G3)]2 quadruplex: evidence for sequential syn-syn deoxyguanosines.

Two-dimensional 1H NMR studies on the dimeric hairpin quadruplex formed by d(G3T4G3) in the presence of either NaCl or KCl are presented. In the presence of either salt, the quadruplex structure is characterized by half the guanine nucleosides in the syn conformation about the glycosidic bond, the other half in the anti conformation, as reported for other similar sequences. However, 1H NOESY and 1H-31P heteronuclear correlation experiments demonstrate that the deoxyguanosines do not strictly alternate between syn and anti along individual strands. Thus we find the following sequences with regard to glycosidic bond conformation: 5'-G1SG2SG3AT4AT5A-T6AT7AG8SG9AG10A-3' and 5'-G11SG12AG13AT14AT1 5AT16AT17AG18SG19SG20A-3', where S and A denote syn and anti, respectively. This represents the first experimental evidence for a nucleic acid structure containing two sequential nucleosides in the syn conformation. The stacking interactions of the resulting quadruplex quartets and their component bases have been evaluated using unrestrained molecular dynamics calculations and energy component analysis. These calculations suggest that the sequential syn-syn/anti-anti and syn-anti quartet stacks are almost equal in energy, whereas the anti-syn stack, which is not present in our structure, is energetically less favorable by about 4 kcal/mol. Possible reasons for this energy difference and its implications for the stability of quadruplex structures are discussed.     

Human replication protein A unfolds telomeric G-quadruplexes

G-quadruplex structures inhibit telomerase activity and must be disrupted for telomere elongation during S phase. It has been suggested that the replication protein A (RPA) could unwind and maintain single-stranded DNA in a state amenable to the binding of telomeric components. We show here that under near-physiological in vitro conditions, human RPA is able to bind and unfold G-quadruplex structures formed from a 21mer human telomeric sequence. Analyses by native gel electrophoresis, cross-linking and fluorescence resonance energy transfer indicate the formation of both 1:1 and 2:1 complexes in which G-quadruplexes are unfolded. In addition, quadruplex opening by hRPA is much faster than observed with the complementary DNA, demonstrating that this protein efficiently unfolds G-quartets. A two-step mechanism accounting for the binding of hRPA to G-quadruplexes is proposed. These data point to the involvement of hRPA in regulation of telomere maintenance.     

Spectroscopic study on the binding of a cationic porphyrin to DNA G-quadruplex under different K+ concentrations

We have performed systematic spectroscopic titrations to characterize the binding reaction of cationic meso-tetrakis(4-(N-methylpyridiumyl))porphyrin (TMPyP4) with the G-quadruplex (G4) of human telomeric single-strand oligonucleotide d[TAGGG(TTAGGG)3T] (S24), for which special effort was made to examine the TMPyP4-G4 binding stoichiometry, the binding modes, and the conformational conversion of the G4 structure under different potassium ion (K+) concentration. It is found that, in the presence of 0, 10 mM, and 100 mM K+, TMPyP4 forms a complex with the anti-parallel G4 in a TMPyP4-to-G4 molar ratio of 5, 5 and 3, respectively, and the increase of K+ concentration would reduce the binding affinity of TMPyP4 to G4. For the TMPyP4-G4 complex, the end-stacking mode and groove binding mode were presumed mainly by the results of time-resolved fluorescence spectroscopy in the three cases. Most importantly, it is found that TMPyP4 can directly induce the formation of the anti-parallel G4 structure from the single-strand oligonucleotide S24 in the absence of K+, and that it can preferentially induce the conformational conversion of the G4 structure from the hybrid-type to the anti-parallel one in the presence of K+.     

Insulin-like growth factor type I selectively binds to G-quadruplex structures

Background

G-quadruplex has been viewed as a promising therapeutic target in oncology due to its potentially important roles in physiological and pathological processes. Emerging evidence suggests that the biological functions of G-quadruplexes are closely related to the binding of some proteins. Insulin-like growth factor type I (IGF-1), as a significant modulator of cell growth and development, may serve as a quadruplex-binding protein.

Molecular engineering of G-quadruplex ligands based on solvent effect of polyethylene glycol

Because various non-parallel G-quadruplexes of human telomeric sequences in K(+) solution can be converted to a parallel G-quadruplex by adding polyethylene glycol (PEG) as a co-solvent, we have taken advantage of this property of PEG to study the covalent attachment of a PEG unit to a G-quadruplex ligand, 3,6-bis(1-methyl-4-vinylpyridinium) carbazole diiodide (BMVC). The hybrid ligand with the PEG unit, BMVC-8C3O or BMVC-6C2O by substituting either the tetraethylene glycol or the triethylene glycol terminated with a methyl-piperidinium cation in N-9 position of BMVC, not only induces structural change from different non-parallel G-quadruplexes to a parallel G-quadruplex but also increases the melting temperature of human telomeres in K(+) solution by more than 45°C. In addition, our ligand work provides further confidence that the local water structure plays the key to induce conformational change of human telomere.     

Visual observation of G-quadruplex DNA with the label-free fluorescent probe silole with aggregation-induced emission

AIE molecule silole 1 could be used to detect G-quadruplex formation using an exonuclease I hydrolysis assay. This visual observation of G-quadruplexes has been successfully used in investigating multiple G-quadruplexes, including the one-stranded telomeric, c-myc, c-kit, VEGF G-quadruplexes, and a d(G₄T₄G₄) inter-molecular G-quadruplex. The detection of G-quadruplex can be also applied to G-quadruplex isomers induced by small molecules.     

Effects of G-quadruplex topology on translational inhibition by tRNA fragments in mammalian and plant systems in vitro

The folding of tRNA fragments (tRFs) into G-quadruplex structures and the implications of G-quadruplexes in translational inhibition have been studied mainly in mammalian systems. To increase our knowledge of these phenomena, we determined the influence of human and plant tRFs and model G-quadruplexes on translation in rabbit reticulocyte lysate and wheat germ extract. The efficiency of translational inhibition in the mammalian system was strongly associated with the type of G-quadruplex topology. In the plant system, the ability of a small RNA to adopt the G-quadruplex conformation was not sufficient to repress translation, indicating the importance of other structural determinants.     

Xanthine and 8-oxoguanine in G-quadruplexes: formation of a G·G·X·O tetrad

G-quadruplexes are four-stranded structures built from stacked G-tetrads (G·G·G·G), which are planar cyclical assemblies of four guanine bases interacting through Hoogsteen hydrogen bonds. A G-quadruplex containing a single guanine analog substitution, such as 8-oxoguanine (O) or xanthine (X), would suffer from a loss of a Hoogsteen hydrogen bond within a G-tetrad and/or potential steric hindrance. We show that a proper arrangement of O and X bases can reestablish the hydrogen-bond pattern within a G·G·X·O tetrad. Rational incorporation of G·G·X·O tetrads in a (3+1) G-quadruplex demonstrated a similar folding topology and thermal stability to that of the unmodified G-quadruplex. pH titration conducted on X·O-modified G-quadruplexes indicated a protonation-deprotonation equilibrium of X with a pKa ∼6.7. The solution structure of a G-quadruplex containing a G·G·X·O tetrad was determined, displaying the same folding topology in both the protonated and deprotonated states. A G-quadruplex containing a deprotonated X·O pair was shown to exhibit a more electronegative groove compared to that of the unmodified one. These differences are likely to manifest in the electronic properties of G-quadruplexes and may have important implications for drug targeting and DNA-protein interactions.     

Sequence specificity of inter- and intramolecular G-quadruplex formation by human telomeric DNA

Human telomeric DNA consists of tandem repeats of the sequence 5'-d(TTAGGG)-3'. Guanine-rich DNA, such as that seen at telomeres, forms G-quadruplex secondary structures. Alternative forms of G-quadruplex structures can have differential effects on activities involved in telomere maintenance. With this in mind, we analyzed the effect of sequence and length of human telomeric DNA on G-quadruplex structures by native polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis and circular dichroism. Telomeric oligonucleotides shorter than four, 5'-d(TTAGGG)-3' repeats formed intermolecular G-quadruplexes. However, longer telomeric repeats formed intramolecular structures. Altering the 5'-d(TTAGGG)-3' to 5'-d(TTAGAG)-3' in any one of the repeats of 5'-d(TTAGGG)(4)-3' converted an intramolecular structure to intermolecular G-quadruplexes with varying degrees of parallel or anti-parallel-stranded character, depending on the length of incubation time and DNA sequence. These structures were most abundant in K(+)-containing buffers. Higher-order structures that exhibited ladders on polyacrylamide gels were observed only for oligonucleotides with the first telomeric repeat altered. Altering the sequence of 5'-d(TTAGGG)(8)-3' did not result in the substantial formation of intermolecular structures even when the oligonucleotide lacked four consecutive telomeric repeats. However, many of these intramolecular structures shared common features with intermolecular structures formed by the shorter oligonucleotides. The wide variability in structure formed by human telomeric sequence suggests that telomeric DNA structure can be easily modulated by proteins, oxidative damage, or point mutations resulting in conversion from one form of G-quadruplex to another.