Cell Walls of Tobacco Cells and Changes in Composition Associated with Reduced Growth upon Adaptation to Water and Saline Stress

The relative mass of the cell walls of tobacco (Nicotiana tabacum L.) cells adapted to grow in medium containing 30% polyethylene glycol 8000 or 428 millimolar NaCl was reduced to about 50% of that of the walls of unadapted cells. Cellulose synthesis was inhibited substantially in adapted cells. The proportions of total pectin in walls of unadapted and adapted cells were about the same, but substantial amount of uronic acid-rich material from walls of cells adapted to either NaCl or polyethylene glycol was more easily extracted with cold sodium ethylenediamine tetraacetic acid solutions (NM Iraki et al. [1989] Plant Physiol. 91: 39-47). We examined the linkage composition of the pectic and hemicellulosic polysaccharides to ascertain chemical factors that may explain this difference in physical behavior. Adaptation to stress resulted in the formation of a loosely bound shell of polygalacturonic acid and rhamnogalacturonan. Pectins extracted from walls of adapted cells by either cold sodium ethylenediamine tetraacetic acid or hot ammonium oxalate were particularly enriched in rhamnose. Compared to pectins of unadapted cells, rhamnosyl units of the rhamnogalacturonans of adapted cells were more highly substituted with polymers containing arabinose and galactose, but the side groups were of greatly reduced molecular size. Possible functional roles of these modifications in cell wall metabolism related to adaptation to osmotic stress are discussed.     

Carbon Use Efficiency and Cell Expansion of NaCl-Adapted Tobacco Cells

Carbon use efficiencies (gram cell organic dry weight accumulated per gram sugar assimilated from the medium) of unadapted and NaCl-adapted (428 millimolar) cells of tobacco (Nicotiana tabacum L. var Wisconsin 38) were determined to evaluate metabolic costs associated with growth and survival in a saline environment. No net increase in carbon costs was associated with salt adaptation. At low substrate levels, carbon use efficiencies of unadapted and NaCl-adapted cells were not appreciably different (0.495 and 0.422, respectively) and at higher substrate levels carbon use efficiency of NaCl-adapted cells was clearly higher than that of unadapted cells. These results indicate that a homeostasis of metabolic efficiency is established after cells have adapted to NaCl. Altered carbon availability does not cause the reduced cell volume that results from adaptation to NaCl. This does not preclude, however, the possibility that altered intracellular partitioning of carbon affects cell expansion.     

Stable NaCl Tolerance of Tobacco Cells Is Associated with Enhanced Accumulation of Osmotin

Osmotin is a major protein which accumulates in tobacco cells (Nicotiana tabacum L. var Wisconsin 38) adapted to low water potentials. Quantitation of osmotin levels by immunoblots indicated that cells adapted to 428 millimolar NaCl contained 4 to 30 times the level of osmotin found in unadapted cells, depending on the stage of growth. Unadapted cells accumulated low levels of osmotin with apparent isoelectric points, (pl) of 7.8 and >8.2. Upon transfer of NaCl-adapted cells to medium without NaCl and subsequent growth for many cell generations, the amount of osmotin declined gradually to a level intermediate between that found in adapted and unadapted cells. NaCl-adapted cells grown in the absence of NaCl accumulated both pl forms; however, the form accumulated by cells adapted to NaCl (pl > 8.2) was most abundant. Adapted cells grown in the absence of NaCl exhibited absolute growth rates and NaCl tolerance levels which were intermediate to those of NaCl-adapted and unadapted cells. The association between osmotin accumulation and stable NaCl tolerance indicates that cells with a stable genetic change affecting the accumulation of osmotin are selected during prolonged exposure to high levels of NaCl. This stable alteration in gene expression probably affects salt tolerance.     

Enhanced H Transport Capacity and ATP Hydrolysis Activity of the Tonoplast H-ATPase after NaCl Adaptation

Tonoplast enriched membrane vesicle fractions were isolated from unadapted and NaCl (428 millimolar) adapted tobacco cells (Nicotiana tabacum L. var Wisconsin 38). Polypeptides from the tonoplast enriched vesicle fractions were separated by SDS-PAGE and analyzed by Western blots using polyclonal antibodies to the 70 kilodalton subunit of the red beet tonoplast H⁺-ATPase. These antibodies cross-reacted exclusively to a tobacco polypeptide of an apparent molecular weight of 69 kilodaltons. The antibodies inhibited ATP-dependent, NO₃⁻ sensitive H⁺ transport into vesicles in tonoplast enriched membrane fractions from both unadapted and NaCl adapted cells. The relative H⁺ transport capacity per unit of 69 kilodalton subunit of the tonoplast ATPase of vesicles from NaCl adapted cells was fourfold greater than that observed for vesicles from unadapted cells. The increase in specific H⁺ transport capacity after adaptation was also observed for ATP hydrolysis.     

Changes in pectin structure and localization during the growth of unadapted and NaCl-adapted tobacco cells

Tobacco cells adapted to grow in high concentrations of NaCl exhibit a drastically altered growth physiology that results in cells whose fully expanded volume is only one-fifth to one-eighth those of unadapted cells. Comparison between NaCl-adapted and unadapted tobacco cells provides an opportunity to evaluate current concepts of the structural and mechanical determinants of cell wall expansion. Both biochemical studies of pectic polymers and the ultrastructural localization of pectic epitopes at three specific phases of cell culture, maximal cell division, maximal elongation, and stationary phase are reported here. One-half of the galactosyluronic acid units in wall polymers of NaCl-adapted cells are esterified throughout the culture period, while wall polymers of unadapted cells show a rise in esterified polygalacturonic acid from 50 to 80% during elongation and then a decrease to 70% at stationary phase. Methyl esters account for only a proportion of the total esterified polygalacturonic acid at any stage in both unadapted and NaCl-adapted cell walls. Using monoclonal antibodies, we show differences in the localization of relatively methyl-esterified and unesterified pectic epitopes at different stages of growth and corroborate the chemical determinations. Fourier transform infrared (FTIR) microspectroscopy of representative walls of both NaCl-adapted and unadapted cells confirms, at the single cell wall level, that results obtained from chemical analysis of bulk samples are applicable to the entire cell population. FTIR microspectroscopy also reveals an increase in wall protein in the walls of adapted cells. Images obtained by the fast-freeze, deep-etch, rotary-shadowed replica technique show clearly different cell wall architectures in NaCl-adapted compared with unadapted cells; walls of elongating unadapted cells contain long, thin fibres that show a net orientation with respect to the long axis of the cell, whereas walls of adapted cells have thicker, flatter bundles of fibres with no clear net orientation. Polarized FTIR microspectroscopy indicates that, in unadapted tobacco cells during elongation, pectin molecules may be oriented within the wall in a similar manner to cellulose. Possible ways in which pectin structure and conformation may affect the behaviour of the cellulose-xyloglucan network are discussed.     

Abscisic Acid accelerates adaptation of cultured tobacco cells to salt

Adaptation of tobacco (Nicotiana tabacum L. var Wisconsin 38) cells to NaCl was accelerated by (±) abscisic acid (ABA). In medium with 10 grams per liter NaCl, ABA stimulated the growth of cells not grown in medium with NaCl (unadapted, S-0) with an increasing response from 10⁻⁸ to 10⁻⁴ molar. ABA (10⁻⁵ molar) enhanced the growth of unadapted cells in medium with 6 to 22 grams per liter NaCl but did not increase the growth of cells previously adapted to either 10 (S-10) or 25 (S-25) grams per liter NaCl unless the cells were inoculated into medium with a level of NaCl higher than the level to which the cells were adapted. The growth of unadapted cells in medium with Na₂SO₄ (85.5 millimolar), KCl (85.5 or 171 millimolar), K₂SO₄ (85.5 millimolar) was also stimulated by ABA. ABA (10⁻⁸-10⁻⁴ molar) did not accelerate the growth of unadapted cells exposed to water deficits induced by polyethylene glycol (molecular weight 8000) (5-20 grams per 100 milliliters), sorbitol (342 millimolar), mannitol (342 millimolar) or sucrose (342 millimolar). These results suggest that ABA is involved in adaptation of cells to salts, and is not effective in promoting adaptation to water deficits elicited by nonionic osmotic solutes.     

Changes Related to Salt Tolerance in Thylakoid Membranes of Photoautotrophically Cultured Green Tobacco Cells

A line of cultured tobacco cells (Nicotiana tabacum cv. SamsunNN) was established that was able to grow photoautotrophicallyin a medium that contained 0.2 M NaCl or in a medium withoutNaCl. Thylakoid membranes of the NaCl-adapted cells had higheroxygen-evolving activities, on the basis of chlorophyll, thanthose of unadapted cells. Furthermore, the oxygen-evolving activitiesof thylakoid membranes from NaCl-adapted cells were more tolerantto high concentrations of NaCl than those from unadapted cells. Glycinebetaine at 1 M protected the oxygen-evolving activityof thylakoid membranes from unadapted cells but not that fromadapted cells. Examination of the dissociation of 23-kDa and33-kDa polypeptides from the water-splitting complex of photosystemII at high concentrations of NaCl indicated that the affinitywith which the 23-kDa polypeptide was bound to thylakoid membranesof salt-adapted cells had been altered. (Received March 22, 1993; Accepted November 15, 1993)     

Enrichment of vitronectin- and fibronectin-like proteins in NaCl-adapted plant cells and evidence for their involvement in plasma membrane–cell wall adhesion

Cells of tobacco adapted to grow in high concentrations of NaCl develop tight zones of adhesion between the plasma membrane and cell wall, revealed by concave plasmolysis in osmotic solutions. Unadapted cells exhibit mostly convex plasmolysis and exhibit little or no adhesive character. Wall-less protoplasts isolated from the adapted cells retain the complementary adhesive character and adhere tightly to each other, whereas protoplasts from unadapted cells do not. The hexapeptide gly- arg-gly-asp -ser-pro, in which the arg-gly-asp represents the integrin-binding domain of several animal extracellular matrix proteins, specifically blocks adhesion of the protoplasts. A control hexapeptide, gly-arg-gly-glu-ser-pro, is ineffective in blocking adhesion. Tobacco proteins immunologically related to human vitronectin were found in cell walls and membranes of unadapted and NaCl-adapted cells, but the total extractable vitronectin-like protein was enriched in the adapted cells. Tobacco proteins immunologically related to human fibronectin were found in membranes and cell walls of NaCl-adapted cells but not in those from unadapted cells. Our observations indicate that plant cells possess cell-matrix adhesion complexes similar to animal cells, and these adhesion complexes accumulate in growth-limited cells adapted to saline stress.     

Enhanced Net K Uptake Capacity of NaCl-Adapted Cells

Maintenance of intracellular K⁺ concentrations that are not growth-limiting, in an environment of high Na⁺, is characteristic of NaCl-adapted cells of the glycophyte, tobacco (Nicotiana tabacum/gossii). These cells exhibited a substantially greater uptake of ⁸⁶Rb⁺ (i.e. an indicator of K⁺) relative to unadapted cells. Potassium uptake into NaCl-adapted cells was 1.5-fold greater than unadapted cells at 0 NaCl and 3.5-fold greater when cells were exposed to 160 millimolar NaCl. The difference in net K⁺ uptake between unadapted and NaCl-adapted cells was due primarily to higher rates of entry rather than to reduced K⁺ leakage. Presumably, enhanced K⁺ uptake into adapted cells is a result of electrophoretic flux, and a component of uptake may be linked to vanadate-sensitive H⁺ extrusion.     

Proteins Associated with Adaptation of Cultured Tobacco Cells to NaCl

Cultured tobacco cells (Nicotiana tabacum L. cv Wisconsin 38) adapted to grow in medium containing high levels of NaCl or polyethylene glycol (PEG) produce several new or enhanced polypeptide bands on sodium dodecyl sulfate-polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis. The intensities of some of the polypeptide bands (molecular weights of 58, 37, 35.5, 34, 26, 21, 19.5, and 18 kilodaltons) increase with increasing levels of NaCl adaptation, while the intensities of other polypeptide bands (54, 52, 17.5, and 16.5 kilodaltons) are reduced. Enhanced levels of 43- and 26-kilodalton polypeptides are present in both NaCl and PEG-induced water stress adapted cells but are not detectable in unadapted cells. In addition, PEG adapted cells have enhanced levels of 29-, 17.5-, 16.5-, and 11-kilodalton polypeptides and reduced levels of 58-, 54-, 52-, 37-, 35.5-, 34-, 21-, 19.5-, and 18-kilodalton polypeptide bands.

Synthesis of 26-kilodalton polypeptide(s) occurs at two different periods during culture growth of NaCl adapted cells. Unadapted cells also incorporate ³⁵S into a 26-kilodalton polypeptide during the later stage of culture growth beginning at midlog phase. The 26-kilodalton polypeptides from adapted and unadapted cells have similar partial proteolysis peptide maps and are immunologically cross-reactive. During adaptation to NaCl, unadapted cells synthesize and accumulate a major 26-kilodalton polypeptide, and the beginning of synthesis corresponds to the period of osmotic adjustment and culture growth. From our results, we suggest an involvement of the 26-kilodalton polypeptide in the adaptation of cultured tobacco cells to NaCl and water stress.

     

Alteration of the physical and chemical structure of the primary cell wall of growth-limited plant cells adapted to osmotic stress

Cells of tobacco (Nicotiana tabacum L.) adapted to grow in severe osmotic stress of 428 millimolar NaCl (−23 bar) or 30% polyethylene glycol 8000 (−28 bar) exhibit a drastically altered growth physiology that results in slower cell expansion and fully expanded cells with volumes only one-fifth to one-eighth those of unadapted cells. This reduced cell volume occurs despite maintenance of turgor pressures sometimes severalfold higher than those of unadapted cells. This report and others (NM Iraki et al [1989] Plant Physiol 90: 000-000 and 000-000) document physical and biochemical alterations of the cell walls which might explain how adapted cells decrease the ability of the wall to expand despite diversion of carbon used for osmotic adjustment away from synthesis of cell wall polysaccharides. Tensile strength measured by a gas decompression technique showed empirically that walls of NaCl-adapted cells are much weaker than those of unadapted cells. Correlated with this weakening was a substantial decrease in the proportion of crystalline cellulose in the primary cell wall. Even though the amount of insoluble protein associated with the wall was increased relative to other wall components, the amount of hydroxyproline in the insoluble protein of the wall was only about 10% that of unadapted cells. These results indicate that a cellulosic-extensin framework is a primary determinant of absolute wall tensile strength, but complete formation of this framework apparently is sacrificed to divert carbon to substances needed for osmotic adjustment. We propose that the absolute mass of this framework is not a principal determinant of the ability of the cell wall to extend.     

Adaptation of Tobacco Cells to NaCl

Cell lines of tobacco (Nicotiana tabacum L. var Wisconsin 38) were obtained which are adapted to grow in media with varying concentrations of NaCl, up to 35 grams per liter (599 millimolar). Salt-adapted cells exhibited enhanced abilities to gain both fresh and dry weight in the presence of NaCl compared to cells which were growing in medium without NaCl (unadapted cells). Tolerance of unadapted cells and cells adapted to 10 grams per liter NaCl was influenced by the stage of growth, with the highest degree of tolerance exhibited by cells in the exponential phase. Cell osmotic potential and turgor varied through the growth cycle of unadapted cells and cells at all levels of adaptation, with maximum turgor occurring at approximately the onset of exponential fresh weight accumulation.

Adaptation to NaCl led to reduced cell expansion and fresh weight gain, while dry weight gain remained unaffected. This reduction in cell expansion was not due to failure of the cells to maintain turgor since cells adapted to NaCl underwent osmotic adjustment in excess of the change in water potential caused by the addition of NaCl to the medium. Tolerance of the adapted cells, as indicated by fresh or dry weight gain, did not increase proportionately with the increase in turgor. Adaptation of these glycophytic cells to NaCl appears to involve mechanisms which result in an altered relationship between turgor and cell expansion.

     

Growth, water content, and solute accumulation of two tobacco cell lines cultured on sodium chloride, dextran, and polyethylene glycol

Simulated drought tolerance was compared for an NaCl-adapted and a nonadapted cell line of tobacco (Nicotiana tabacum var. Samsum) to determine the relationship of salt and drought tolerances. The osmotic adjustment and growth of these two lines was followed when cultured on solid media which contained isosmotic concentrations of NaCl, KCl, polyethylene glycol (PEG) or dextran. One line was adapted to growth on 130 millimolar NaCl, but the other was not.     

Hypocotyl growth of Pinus pinaster seedlings. Changes in the molecular weight distribution of hemicellulosic polysaccharides

Lorences, E. P., Suárez, L. and Zarra, I. 1987. Hypocotyl growth of Pinus pinaster seedlings. Changes in the molecular weight distribution of hemicellulosic polysaccharides.
The changes in the molecular weight distribution of water-soluble hemicelluloses and xyloglucan during hypocotyl growth of intact seedlings of Pinus pinaster Aiton were investigated. The mass-average molecular weight of total polysaccharides of the hemicellulose fraction soluble in 4% KOH dramatically increased during hypocotyl growth while xyloglucan slightly decreased. These phenomena were due to an increase in the degree of polymerization of an arabinogalactan and a slight depolymer-ization in the xyloglucan present in this fraction. In the hemicellulose fraction soluble in 24% KOH, xyloglucan increased its degree of polymerization from day 7 to 10 after which it decreased slightly. The xyloglucan of the hemicellulose fraction soluble in 4% KOH may thus be involved in cell wall loosening which makes cell wall expansion possible during hypocotyl growth.     

Molecular Cloning of Osmotin and Regulation of Its Expression by ABA and Adaptation to Low Water Potential

In response to adaptation to NaCl, cultured tobacco cells (Nicotiana tabacum L. cv Wisconsin 38) synthesize a major 26 kilodalton protein which has been named osmotin due to its induction by low water potentials. To help characterize the expression of osmotin in adapted cells, a cDNA clone for osmotin has been isolated. Abscisic acid induces messenger RNA encoding osmotin. Levels of this mRNA in adapted cells are approximately 15-fold higher than in unadapted cells. Message for osmotin is present at constant levels through the growth cycle of adapted cells, while in unadapted cells, the level decreases during exponential phase of growth and increases again when the cells approach stationary phase. While abscisic acid induces the message for osmotin, a low water potential environment appears to be required for accumulation of the protein. An osmotic shock to unadapted cells does not increase the amount of message or protein present most likely because this treatment does not induce immediately the accumulation of abscisic acid. The increased expression of osmotin in adapted cells is not correlated with an increase in osmotin gene copy number. Osmotin is homologous to a 24 kilodalton NaCl-induced protein in tomato, as well as thaumatin, maize α-amylase/trypsin inhibitor and a tobacco mosaic virus-induced pathogenesis-related protein.     

Growth Yields and Maintenance Coefficients of Unadapted and NaCl-Adapted Tobacco Cells Grown in Semicontinuous Culture

Comparison of carbon utilization between unadapted and NaCl (428 millimolar) adapted tobacco (Nicotiana tabacum L.) cells under substrate limited growth conditions was facilitated using semicontinuous culture. Growth yields (Y_g) and maintenance coefficients (m) of unadapted and NaCl adapted cells were similar, indicating that the efficiency of carbon utilization for growth was not altered as a result of salt adaptation and that no additional metabolic costs were associated with growth of adapted cells in the presence of a high concentration (428 millimolar) of NaCl. The Y_g (0.588 grams organic dry weight gain per gram sugar uptake) and m values (0.117 grams sugar uptake per gram organic dry weight per day) were comparable in spite of substantial physiological and biochemical differences that exist between unadapted and NaCl adapted cells. Apparently, a metabolic homeostasis governs biomass production of cells before and after adaptation to salinity.     

Proton Fluxes as a Response to External Salinity in Wild Type and NaCl-Adapted Nicotiana Cell Lines

Addition of 100 millimolar KCl, NaCl, or Na₂SO₄ strongly promoted acidification of the medium by cells of Nicotiana tabacum/gossii in suspension culture. Acidification was greater in the case of NaCl-adapted than in that of wild type cells, and strikingly so in KCl medium when fusicoccin (FC) was present. Back-titration indicated that net proton secretion in KCl medium was increased 4-fold by FC treatment in the case of adapted cells; but was not even doubled in wild type cells. Membrane potential was higher in NaCl-adapted cells. FC treatment hyperpolarized wild, but not NaCl-adapted cells, suggesting a higher degree of coupling between H⁺ efflux and K⁺ influx in adapted cells; FC enhanced net K⁺ uptake in adapted but not in wild cells. Acidification by cells suspended in 10 millimolar KCl was highly sensitive to vanadate, but that after addition of 100 millimolar KCl or NaCl was much less sensitive. Addition of 100 millimolar NaCl to wild type cells already provided with 10 millimolar KCl briefly accelerated, then slowed down the rate of acidification. If the addition was made after acidification had already ceased, alkalization was observed, particularly in the presence of FC. The results are consistent with the operation of a Na⁺-H⁺ antiporter.     

Alterations in Ca2+-binding on plasma membrane after adaptation to salt stress of tobacco cells in suspension

Electrophoresis was used to study effects of salinity on the characteristics of Ca2+ binding to the outer surface of plasma membrane (PM) of protoplasts isolated from two types of tobacco (Nicotiana tabacum L., cv. Bright Yellow) cultured cells that were adapted (tolerant) and unadapted (sensitive) to 50 mM NaCl stress. Electrophoretic analysis of salt-sensitive NaCl-unadapted cells shows that Na+ induced an appreciably higher degree of reduction in the amount of Ca2+ bound to PM compared with K+ with increasing concentration from 0.1 to 30 mM. In salt-tolerant NaCl-adapted cells, however, both Na+ and K+ ions induced almost the same degree of reduction in the amount of Ca2+ bound to PM in the physiological concentration range of Ca2+ in the medium between 2 and 4 mM. These results suggest that, under the physiological conditions, PM of salt-sensitive NaCl-unadapted cells has an appreciable amount of PM-bound Ca2+ that is desorbed much easier by Na+ than K+, whereas PM of salt-tolerant NaCl-adapted cells has the PM-bound Ca2+ that can be equally desorbed by Na+ and K+.