Developmental profiles of three embryo-lethal maize mutants lacking leaf primordia: ptd*-1130, cp*-1418, and bno*-747B

The defective kernel (dek) mutants of maize are altered in both their embryo and endosperm development. Earlier studies have indicated that some of the dek mutants are unable to form shoot apical meristems or leaf primoirda. We have examined three embryo lethal dek mutants of this type, ptd*-1130, cp*-1418, and bno*-747B, to obtain a developmental profile for each. Allelism tests show that these three mutants are not allelic. Embryos were examined in early, mid-, and late kernel development as well as at kernel maturity by dissection and sectioning procedures and also at kernel maturity by scanning electron microscopy. All three mutants lag behind normal embryos in their rate of development. Embryos of ptd*-1130 reached the transition stage by early kernel development and progressed no further but underwent cell enlargement and necrosis during late kernel development. Embryos of cp*-1418 reached an early coleoptilar stage by midkernel development. They subsequently increased in size but did not form any leaf primordia. At kernel maturity, they no longer had a shoot apical meristem but often had a well formed root meristem. They appeared to remain healthy and did not become necrotic. Embryos of bno*747B reached the early coleoptilar stage by early kernel development but progressed no further. By kernel maturity, they had grown into masses of irregularly shaped embryonic tissue that no longer resembled any normal embryo stage but were not necrotic. None of these three mutants responded to attempts to support continued embryo development when cultured, but all three mutants formed callus on N6 and MS media supplemented with 2,4-D. These results indicate that these mutants are all uniformly blocked at specific stages early in embryonic development, have different subsequent developmental fates, and represent three different genes performing unique functions that are essential for embryogenesis.     

A maize defective-kernel mutant (longcell) characterized by tubular cells, severe morphological alterations and induction of cell death

Seeds of the longcell mutant in maize (Zea mays L) have a defective-kernel phenotype: the embryo aborts at the early coleoptilar stage and the endosperm is reduced in size. Mutant embryos have severe alterations in morphogenesis. They have a suspensor-, an embryo axis- and a scutellum-like structure, but the shoot apical meristem (SAM) is not formed. Scanning electron microscopy showed that most of the cells in longcell embryos are tubular and abnormally enlarged. The level of expression of several genes involved in basic metabolism is not severely affected during early and mid embryogenesis, but storage molecule accumulation is reduced. Genes which in normal conditions are only expressed after germination, are expressed during kernel development in the longcell seeds. Mutant embryos undergo cell death in late embryogenesis. Nuclei in dying embryos are TUNEL positive, and different genes coding for hydrolytic enzymes are up-regulated. The expression of genes related to oxidative stress is also altered in longcell embryos. These results lead us to suggest that the longcell mutant may be cytokinesis-defective.     

Embryo defective12 encodes the plastid initiation factor 3 and is essential for embryogenesis in maize

Embryo‐specific mutants in maize define a unique class of genetic loci that affect embryogenesis without a significant deleterious impact on endosperm development. Here we report the characterization of an embryo specific12 (emb12) mutant in maize. Embryogenesis in the emb12 mutants is arrested at or before transition stage. The mutant embryo at an early stage exhibits abnormal cell structure with increased vacuoles and dramatically reduced internal membrane organelles. In contrast, the mutant endosperm appears normal in morphology, cell structure, starch, lipid and protein accumulation. The Emb12 locus was cloned by transposon tagging and predicts a protein with a high similarity to prokaryotic translation initiation factor 3 (IF3). EMB12–GFP fusion analysis indicates that EMB12 is localized in plastids. The RNA in situ hybridization and protein immunohistochemical analyses indicate that a high level of Emb12 expression localizes in the embryo proper at early developmental stages and in the embryo axis at later stages. Western analysis indicates that plastid protein synthesis is impaired. These results indicate that Emb12 encodes the plastid IF3 which is essential for embryogenesis but not for endosperm development in maize.     

ABNORMAL DEVELOPMENT OF THE SUSPENSOR IN AN EMBRYO-LETHAL MUTANT OF ARABIDOPSIS THALIANA

Developmental arrest of the embryo proper in aborted seeds from mutant 50B, a recessive embryo-lethal mutant of Arabidopsis thaliana, was shown to be followed by abnormal growth of the suspensor. Each of the 12 aborted seeds examined in sectioned material contained an abnormally large suspensor and an embryo proper arrested at a preglobular stage of development. Analysis of serial sections revealed that mutant suspensors contained 15–150 cells whereas wild-type suspensors were composed of only six to eight cells. Development of the mutant endosperm continued to a late nuclear or early cellular stage even in the absence of further development of the embryo proper. These results suggest that the missing gene product in mutant 50B is required for development of the embryo proper but not for continued growth of the suspensor or endosperm tissue. The pattern of abnormal development observed in this mutant provides further evidence that continued growth of the suspensor during normal development is inhibited by the developing embryo proper and that the full developmental potential of cells in the suspensor is expressed only when this inhibitory effect is removed through a mutation or experimental treatment that is lethal only to cells of the embryo proper.     

fist: an Arabidopsis mutant with altered cell division planes and radial pattern disruption during embryogenesis

A T-DNA-tagged, embryo-defective Arabidopsis thaliana mutant, fist, was identified and shown to exhibit defects in nuclear positioning and cell division orientation beginning at the four-cell stage of the embryo proper. Cell division orientation was randomised, with each embryo exhibiting a different pattern. Periclinal divisions did not occur after the eight-cell embryo proper stage and fist embryos lacked a histologically distinct protoderm layer. Terminal embryos resembled globular-stage embryos, but were a disorganised mass containing 30–100 cells. Some terminal embryos (5%) developed xylem-like elements in outer surface cells, indicating that the fist mutation affects radial pattern. A soybean β-conglycinin seed storage protein gene promoter, active in wild-type embryos from heart stage to maturity, was also active in terminal fist embryos despite their disorganised globular state. This indicated that some pathways of cellular differentiation in fist embryos proceed independently of both organised division plane orientation and normal morphogenesis. Endosperm morphogenesis in seeds containing terminal fist embryos was arrested at one of three distinct developmental stages and appeared unlinked to fist embryo morphogenesis. The β-conglycinin seed storage protein gene promoter, normally active in cellularised wild-type endosperm, was inactive in fist endosperm, indicating abnormal development of fist endosperm at the biochemical level. These data indicate that the fist mutation, either directly or indirectly, results in defects in cell division orientation during the early stages of Arabidopsis embryo development. Other aspects of the fist phenotype, such as defects in endosperm development and radial pattern formation, may be related to abnormal cell division orientation or may occur as pleiotropic effects of the fist mutation. Received: 15 July 1997 / Accepted: 9 September 1997     

Defective kernel mutants of maize. I. Genetic and lethality studies

A planting of 3,919 M₁ kernels from normal ears crossed by EMS-treated pollen produced 3,461 M₁ plants and 3,172 selfed ears. These plants yielded 2,477 (72%) total heritable changes; the selfed ears yielded 2,457 (78%) recessive mutants, including 855 (27%) recessive kernel mutants and 8 (0.23%) viable dominant mutants. The ratio of recessive to dominant mutants was 201:1. The average mutation frequency for four known loci was three per 3,172 genomes analyzed. The estimated total number of loci mutated was 535 and the estimated number of kernel mutant loci mutated was 285. Among the 855 kernel mutants, 432 had a nonviable embryo, and 59 germinated but had a lethal seedling. A sample of 194 of the latter two types was tested for heritability, lethality, chromosome arm location and endosperm-embryo interaction between mutant and nonmutant tissues in special hyper-hypoploid combinations produced by manipulation of B-A translocations. The selected 194 mutants were characterized and catalogued according to endosperm phenotype and investigated to determine their effects on the morphology and development of the associated embryo. The possibility of rescuing some of the lethal mutants by covering the mutant embryo with a normal endosperm was investigated. Ninety of these 194 mutants were located on 17 of the 18 chromosome arms tested. Nineteen of the located mutants were examined to determine the effect of having a normal embryo in the same kernel with a mutant endosperm, and vice versa, as compared to the expression observed in kernels with both embryo and endosperm in a mutant condition. In the first situation, for three of the 19 mutants, the mutant endosperm was less extreme (the embryo helped); for seven cases, the mutant endosperm was more extreme (the embryo hindered); and for nine cases, there was no change. In the reverse situation, for four cases the normal endosperm helped the mutant embryo; for 14 cases there was no change and one case was inconclusive.     

A mutational approach to the study of seed development in maize

The maize seed comprises two major compartments, the embryo and the endosperm, both originating from the double fertilization event. The embryogenetic process allows the formation of a well-differentiated embryonic axis, surrounded by a single massive cotyledon, the scutellum. The mature endosperm constitutes the bulk of the seed and comprises specific regions containing reserve proteins, complex carbohydrates, and oils. To gain more insight into molecular events that underlie seed development, three monogenic mutants were characterized, referred to as emp (empty pericarp) on the basis of their extreme endosperm reduction, first recognizable at about 12 d after pollination. Their histological analysis reveals a partial development of the endosperm domains as well as loss of adhesion between pedicel tissues and the basal transfer layer. In the endosperm, programmed cell death (PCD) is delayed. The embryo appears retarded in its growth, but not impaired in its morphogenesis. The mutants can be rescued by culturing immature embryos, even though the seedlings appear retarded in their growth. The analysis of seeds with discordant embryo-endosperm phenotype (mutant embryo, normal endosperm and vice-versa), obtained using B-A translocations, suggests that emp expression in the embryo is necessary, but not sufficient, for proper seed development. In all three mutants the picture emerging is one of a general delay in processes related to growth, as a result of a mutation affecting endosperm development as a primary event.     

Morphology and ultrastructure of 11 barley shrunken endosperm mutants

Summary Eleven Na-azide induced barley shrunken endosperm mutants expressing xenia (sex) were characterized genetically and histologically. All mutants have reduced kernel size with kernel weights ranging from 11 to 57% of the wild type. With one exception, the mutant phenotypes are ascribable to single recessive mutant alleles, giving rise to a ratio of 31 of normal and shrunken kernels on heterozygous plants. One mutant (B10), also monofactorially inherited, shows a gene dosage dependent pattern of expression in the endosperm. Among the 8 mutants tested for allelism, no allelic mutant genes were discovered. By means of translocation mapping, the mutant gene of B10 was localized to the short arm of chromosome 7, and that of B9 to the short arm of chromosome 1. Based on microscopy studies, the mutant kernel phenotypes fall into three classes, viz. mutants with both endosperm and embryo affected and with a non-viable embryo, mutants with both endosperm and embryo affected and with a viable embryo giving rise to plants with a clearly mutant phenotype, and finally mutants with only the endosperm affected and with a normal embryo giving rise to plants with normal phenotype. The mutant collection covers mutations in genes participating in all of the developmental phases of the endosperm, i.e. the passage from syncytial to the cellular endosperm, total lack of aleurone cell formation and disturbance in the pattern of aleurone cell formation. In the starchy endosperm, varying degrees of cell differentiation occur, ranging from slight deviations from wild type to complete loss of starchy endosperm traits. In the embryo, blocks in the major developmental phases are represented in the mutant collection, including arrest at the proembryo stage, continued cell divisions but no differentiation, and embryos deviating only slightly from the wild type.     

Effects of APETALA2 on embryo, endosperm, and seed coat development determine seed size in Arabidopsis

Arabidopsis APETALA2 (AP2) controls seed mass maternally, with ap2 mutants producing larger seeds than wild type. Here, we show that AP2 influences development of the three major seed compartments: embryo, endosperm, and seed coat. AP2 appears to have a significant effect on endosperm development. ap2 mutant seeds undergo an extended period of rapid endosperm growth early in development relative to wild type. This early expanded growth period in ap2 seeds is associated with delayed endosperm cellularization and overgrowth of the endosperm central vacuole. The subsequent period of moderate endosperm growth is also extended in ap2 seeds largely due to persistent cell divisions at the endosperm periphery. The effect of AP2 on endosperm development is mediated by different mechanisms than parent-of-origin effects on seed size observed in interploidy crosses. Seed coat development is affected; integument cells of ap2 mutants are more elongated than wild type. We conclude that endosperm overgrowth and/or integument cell elongation create a larger postfertilization embryo sac into which the ap2 embryo can grow. Morphological development of the embryo is initially delayed in ap2 compared with wild-type seeds, but ap2 embryos become larger than wild type after the bent-cotyledon stage of development. ap2 embryos are able to fill the enlarged postfertilization embryo sac, because they undergo extended periods of cell proliferation and seed filling. We discuss potential mechanisms by which maternally acting AP2 influences development of the zygotic embryo and endosperm to repress seed size.     

An uncoupling screen for autonomous embryo mutants in Arabidopsis thaliana

Simple de novo screens in Arabidopsis thaliana have previously identified mutants that affect endosperm development but viable-embryo mutants have not been identified. Our strategy to identify autonomous embryo development was to uncouple embryo and endosperm fertilisation. This involved a male-sterile mutant population being crossed with a distinct pollen parent—the pollen was needed to initiate endosperm development and because it was distinct, the maternal progeny could be selected from the hybrid population. This process was refined over three stages, resulting in a viable approach to screen for autonomous embryo mutants. From 8,000 screened plants, a mutation was isolated in which the integument cells extended from the ovule and proliferated into a second complete twinned ovule. Some embryos from the mutant were normal but others developed fused cotyledons. In addition, a proportion of the progeny lacked paternal genes.     

Regulation of programmed cell death in maize endosperm by abscisic acid

Cereal endosperm undergoes programmed cell death (PCD) during its development, a process that is controlled, in part, by ethylene. Whether other hormones influence endosperm PCD has not been investigated. Abscisic acid (ABA) plays an essential role during late seed development that enables an embryo to survive desiccation. To examine whether ABA is also involved in regulating the onset of PCD during endosperm development, we have used genetic and biochemical means to disrupt ABA biosynthesis or perception during maize kernel development. The onset and progression of cell death, as determined by viability staining and the appearance of internucleosomal DNA fragmentation, was accelerated in developing endosperm of ABA-insensitive vp1 and ABA-deficient vp9 mutants. Ethylene was synthesized in vp1 and vp9 mutant kernels at levels that were 2–4-fold higher than in wild-type kernels. Moreover, the increase and timing of ethylene production correlated with the premature onset and accelerated progression of internucleosomal fragmentation in these mutants. Treatment of developing wild-type endosperm with fluridone, an inhibitor of ABA biosynthesis, recapitulated the increase in ethylene production and accelerated execution of the PCD program that was observed in the ABA mutant kernels. These data suggest that a balance between ABA and ethylene establishes the appropriate onset and progression of programmed cell death during maize endosperm development.     

Similarity of expression patterns of knotted1 and ZmLEC1 during somatic and zygotic embryogenesis in maize ( Zea mays L.)

Expression of knotted1 ( kn1) and ZmLEC1, a maize homologue of the Arabidopsis LEAFY COTYLEDON1 ( LEC1) was studied using in situ hybridization during in vitro somatic embryogenesis of maize ( Zea mays L.) genotype Hi-II. Expression of kn1 was initially detected in a small group of cells (5-10) in the somatic embryo proper at the globular stage, in a specific region where the shoot meristem is initiating at the scutellar stage, and specifically in the shoot meristem at the coleoptilar stage. Expression of ZmLEC1 was strongly detected in the entire somatic embryo proper at the globular stage, gradually less in the differentiating scutellum at the scutellar and coleoptilar stages. The results of analyses show that the expression pattern of kn1 during in vitro somatic embryogenesis of maize is similar to that of kn1 observed during zygotic embryo development in maize. The expression pattern of ZmLEC1 in maize during in vitro development is similar to that of LEC1 in Arabidopsis during zygotic embryo development. These observations indicate that in vitro somatic embryogenesis likely proceeds through similar developmental pathways as zygotic embryo development, after somatic cells acquire competence to form embryos. In addition, based on the ZmLEC1 expression pattern, we suggest that expression of ZmLEC1 can be used as a reliable molecular marker for detecting early-stage in vitro somatic embryogenesis in maize.     

Phenotypic analysis and molecular cloning of discolored-1 (dsc1), a maize gene required for early kernel development

Recessive mutations in the maize dsc1 locus prevent normal kernel development. Solidification of the endosperm in homozygous dsc1– mutant kernels was undetectable 12 days after pollination, at which time the tissue was apparently completely solidified in wild-type kernels. At later times endosperm did solidify in homozygous dsc1– mutant kernels, but there was a marked reduction in the volume of the tissue. Embryo growth in homozygous dsc1– kernels was delayed compared to wild-type kernels, but proceeded to an apparently normal stage 1 in which the scutellum, coleoptile, and shoot apex were clearly defined. Embryo growth then ceased and the embryonic tissues degraded. Late in kernel development no tissue distinctions were obvious in dsc1– mutant embryos. Immature mutant embryos germinated when transplanted from kernels to tissue culture medium prior to embryonic degeneration, but only coleoptile proliferation was observed. The dsc1 gene was isolated by transposon tagging. Analysis of the two different dsc1– mutations confirmed that transposon insertion into the cloned genomic locus was responsible for the observed phenotype. Dsc1 mRNA was detected specifically in kernels 5–7 days after pollination. These data indicate Dsc1 function is required for progression of embryo development beyond a specific stage, and also is required for endosperm development.     

Characterization of the two maize embryo-lethal defective kernel mutants rgh*-1210 and fl*-1253b: effects on embryo and gametophyte development

We have examined the effects on embryonic and gametophytic development of two nonallelic defective-kernel mutants of maize. Earlier studies indicated that both mutants are abnormal in embryonic morphogenesis as well as in the formation of their endosperm. Mutant rgh*-1210 embryos depart from the normal embryogenic pathway at the proembryo and transition stage, by developing meristematic lobes and losing bilateral symmetry. They continue growth as irregular cell masses that enlarge and become necrotic. Somatic embryos arising in rgh*-1210 callus cultures display the rgh*-1210 mutant phenotype. Mutant fl*-1253B embryos are variably blocked from the coleoptilar stage through stage 2. Following formation of the shoot apex in the mutant embryos the leaf primordia and tissues surrounding the embryonic axis continue growth and cell division, while the scutellum ceases development and becomes hypertrophied. Mutant fl*-1253B embryos are unable to germinate, either in mutant kernels or as immature embryos in culture, and the mutant scutellar tissue does not produce regenerable callus. Expression of the fl*-1253B locus during male gametophytic development is revealed by a marked reduction in pollen transmission as a result of mutant expression during the interval between meiosis and the initiation of pollen tube growth. In both mutants, there is considerable proliferation of the aleurone cells of the endosperm. Mutant expression of rgh*-1210 in the female gametophyte is revealed by the abnormal antipodal cells of the embryo sac. These results show that these two gene loci play unique and crucial roles in normal morphogenesis of the embryo. In addition, it is evident that both mutants are pleiotropic in affecting the development of the endosperm and gametophyte as well as the embryo. These pleiotropisms suggest some commonality in the gene regulation of development in these three tissues.     

Cytological characterization of the embryo-lethal mutantdek-1 of maize

Summary The recessive embryo-lethal mutantdek-1 of maize, showing arrest of embryo development at the proembryo stage, lack of carotenoids and anthocyanins and absence in the endosperm of the aleurone layer, was characterized at a cytological level. Cytofluorimetric analysis excluded endoreduplication or polyploidization events in mutant embryonic cells, in spite of an evident increase in nucleolus and nucleus diameters.The data seem to point to an involvement ofDek-1 in the progression of the embryo toward specific developmental steps and in the differentiation of the aleurone layer in the endosperm. Cellular proliferation is not affected by the mutation, as is shown by DNA replication even after the arrest in development and by the possibility of inducing callus from mutant embryos.Abbreviation DAP days after pollination     

Rice SNF2 family helicase ENL1 is essential for syncytial endosperm development

The endosperm of cereal grains represents the most important source of human nutrition. In addition, the endosperm provides many investigatory opportunities for biologists because of the unique processes that occur during its ontogeny, including syncytial development at early stages. Rice endospermless 1 (enl1) develops seeds lacking an endosperm but carrying a functional embryo. The enl1 endosperm produces strikingly enlarged amoeboid nuclei. These abnormal nuclei result from a malfunction in mitotic chromosomal segregation during syncytial endosperm development. The molecular identification of the causal gene revealed that ENL1 encodes an SNF2 helicase family protein that is orthologous to human Plk1‐Interacting Checkpoint Helicase (PICH), which has been implicated in the resolution of persistent DNA catenation during anaphase. ENL1‐Venus (enhanced yellow fluorescent protein (YFP)) localizes to the cytoplasm during interphase but moves to the chromosome arms during mitosis. ENL1‐Venus is also detected on a thread‐like structure that connects separating sister chromosomes. These observations indicate the functional conservation between PICH and ENL1 and confirm the proposed role of PICH. Although ENL1 dysfunction also affects karyokinesis in the root meristem, enl1 plants can grow in a field and set seeds, indicating that its indispensability is tissue‐dependent. Notably, despite the wide conservation of ENL1/PICH among eukaryotes, the loss of function of the ENL1 ortholog in Arabidopsis (CHR24) has only marginal effects on endosperm nuclei and results in normal plant development. Our results suggest that ENL1 is endowed with an indispensable role to secure the extremely rapid nuclear cycle during syncytial endosperm development in rice.