In Situ Detection of nDNA Fragmentation during the Differentiation of Tracheary Elements in Higher Plants

Programmed cell death (pcd) is thought to occur during the autolysis of xylem vessels. Although several ultrastructural aspects of this differentiation process have been characterized, certain key aspects of this process remain unsolved. Here we demonstrate in pea (Pisum sativum) that nuclei of vessel elements undergoing pcd contain fragmented nDNA. This finding may provide evidence for the activation of a DNA degradation mechanism prior to the final disruption of the nucleus that occurs during the autolysis stage of this differentiation process. In situ detection of DNA fragmentation in nuclei of vessel elements undergoing pcd may therefore suggest that this death process involves the activation of a mechanism for DNA degradation, similar to that activated during apoptosis in animal cells. In addition, this differentiation process may serve as a useful positive control for the in situ detection of pcd in other developmental pathways and during the hypersensitive response of plants to avirulent pathogens.     

Inhibition of Programmed Cell Death in Tobacco Plants during a Pathogen-Induced Hypersensitive Response at Low Oxygen Pressure

The hypersensitive response (HR) of plants to invading pathogens is thought to involve a coordinated activation of plant defense mechanisms and programmed cell death (pcd). To date, little is known about the mechanism underlying death of plant cells during this response. In addition, it is not known whether suppression of pcd affects the induction of other defense mechanisms during the HR. Here, we report that death of tobacco cells (genotype NN) infected with tobacco mosaic virus (TMV) is inhibited at low oxygen pressure. In contrast, virus replication and activation of defense mechanisms, as measured by synthesis of the pathogenesis-related protein PR-1a, were not inhibited at low oxygen pressure. Bacterium-induced pcd was also inhibited at low oxygen pressure. However, pcd induced by TMV or bacteria was not inhibited in transgenic tobacco plants expressing the mammalian anti-pcd protein Bcl-XL. Our results suggest that ambient oxygen levels are required for efficient pcd induction during the HR of plants and that activation of defense responses can be uncoupled from cell death. Furthermore, pcd that occurs during the interaction of tobacco with TMV or bacteria may be distinct from some cases of pcd or apoptosis in animals that are insensitive to low oxygen or inhibited by the Bcl-XL protein.     

Cleavage of Nuclear DNA into Oligonucleosomal Fragments during Cell Death Induced by Fungal Infection or by Abiotic Treatments

It is often claimed that programmed cell death (pcd) exists in plants and that a form of pcd known as the hypersensitive response is triggered as a defense mechanism by microbial pathogens. However, in contrast to animals, no feature in plants universally identifies or defines pcd. We have looked for a hallmark of pcd in animal cells, namely, DNA cleavage, in plant cells killed by infection with incompatible fungi or by abiotic means. We found that cell death triggered in intact leaves of two resistant cowpea cultivars by the cowpea rust fungus is accompanied by the cleavage of nuclear DNA into oligonucleosomal fragments (DNA laddering). Terminal deoxynucleotidyl transferase-mediated dUTP nick end in situ labeling of leaf sections showed that fungus-induced DNA cleavage occurred only in haustorium-containing cells and was detectable early in the degeneration process. Such cytologically detectable DNA cleavage was also observed in vascular tissue of infected and uninfected plants, but no DNA laddering was detected in the latter. DNA laddering was triggered by [greater than or equal to]100 mM KCN, regardless of cowpea cultivar, but not by physical cell disruption or by concentrations of H2O2, NaN3, CuSO4, or ZnCl2 that killed cowpea cells at a rate similar to that of ladder-inducing KCN concentrations. These and other results suggest that the hypersensitive response to microbial pathogens may involve a pcd with some of the characteristics of animal apoptosis and that DNA cleavage is a potential indicator of pcd in plants.     

ABCA1-dependent but apoA-I-independent cholesterol efflux mediated by fatty acid-bile acid conjugates (FABACs)

PCD (programmed cell death) in plants presents important morphological and biochemical differences compared with apoptosis in animal cells. This raises the question of whether PCD arose independently or from a common ancestor in plants and animals. In the present study we describe a cell-free system, using wheat grain nucellar cells undergoing PCD, to analyse nucleus dismantling, the final stage of PCD. We have identified a Ca2+/Mg2+ nuclease and a serine protease localized to the nucleus of dying nucellar cells. Nuclear extracts from nucellar cells undergoing PCD triggered DNA fragmentation and other apoptotic morphology in nuclei from different plant tissues. Inhibition of the serine protease did not affect DNA laddering. Furthermore, we show that the nuclear extracts from plant cells triggered DNA fragmentation and apoptotic morphology in nuclei from human cells. The inhibition of the nucleolytic activity with Zn2+ or EDTA blocked the morphological changes of the nucleus. Moreover, nuclear extracts from apoptotic human cells triggered DNA fragmentation and apoptotic morphology in nuclei from plant cells. These results show that degradation of the nucleus is morphologically and biochemically similar in plant and animal cells. The implication of this finding on the origin of PCD in plants and animals is discussed.     

Aspects of programmed cell death during leaf senescence of mono- and dicotyledonous plants

Summary Leaf senescence is a highly regulated stage in the plant life cycle, leading to cell death, recently examined as a type of the programmed cell death (PCD). One of the basic features of PCD is the condensation of nuclear chromatin which is caused by endonucleolytic degradation of nuclear DNA (nDNA). In our investigations, we applied the technique of the single-cell electrophoresis system (“comet assay”) in order to determine the type of nDNA fragmentation during leaf senescence. The comet assay, a sensitive method revealing nonrandom internucleosomal damage that is specific for PCD, is especially useful for the detection of nDNA degradation in isolated viable cells. Simultaneously, we analyzed the mesophyll cell ultrastructure and the photosynthetic-pigment concentration in the leaves of two species,Ornithogalum virens andNicotiana tabacum, representing mono- and dicotyledonous plants which differ in the pattern of leaf differentiation. These investigations demonstrated that, in both species, the comet assay revealed nDNA degradation in yellow-leaf protoplasts containing chloroplasts that showed already changed ultrastructure (swelled or completely degraded thylakoids) and cell nuclei with a significant condensation of chromatin. There was no nDNA degradation in green-leaf protoplasts containing differentiated chloroplasts with numerous grana stacks and nuclei with dispersed chromatin. The analysis of intermediate developmental stage showed that the degradation of nDNA precedes condensation of nuclear chromatin. Thus the comet assay is a very useful and sensitive method for early detection of PCD. Moreover, results of our studies indicate that leaf senescence involves PCD.     

Veinal necrosis induced by turnip mosaic virus infection in Arabidopsis is a form of defense response accompanying HR-like cell death

In the pathosystems of Turnip mosaic virus (TuMV) with Brassicaceae crops, various symptoms, including mosaic and necrosis, are observed. We previously reported a necrosis-inducing factor TuNI in Arabidopsis thaliana, a model species. In this study, we show that the necrotic symptom induced by TuNI, observed along the veins, was actually a form of defense response accompanying a hypersensitive reaction (HR)-like cell death in the veinal area. The virus is often localized in the necrotic region. The necrotic response is associated with the production of H2O2, accumulation of salicylic acid (SA), emission of ethylene, and subsequent expression of defense-related genes. Additionally, this HR-like cell death is eased or erased by a shading treatment. These features are similar to the HR-associated resistance reaction to pathogens. However, unlike HR, two phytohormones--SA and ethylene--are involved in the necrosis induction, and both SA- and ethylene-dependent pathogenesis-related genes are activated. We concluded that the veinal necrosis induced by TuMV is regulated by a complex and unique network of at least two signaling pathways, which differs from the signal transduction for the known HR-associated resistance.     

Alternative, nonapoptotic programmed cell death: mediation by arrestin 2, ERK2, and Nur77

Programmed cell death (pcd) may take the form of apoptosis or of nonapoptotic pcd. Whereas cysteine aspartyl-specific proteases (caspases) mediate apoptosis, the mediators of nonapoptotic cell death programs are much less well characterized. Here we report that alternative, nonapoptotic pcd induced by the neurokinin-1 receptor (NK(1)R) activated by its ligand Substance P, is mediated by a MAPK phosphorylation cascade recruited by the scaffold protein arrestin 2. The activation of the protein kinases Raf-1, MEK2, and ERK2 is essential for this form of nonapoptotic pcd, leading to the phosphorylation of the orphan nuclear receptor Nur77. NK(1)R-mediated cell death was inhibited by a dominant negative form of arrestin 2, Raf-1, or Nur77, by MEK1/2-specific inhibitors, and by RNA interference directed against ERK2 or MEK2 but not ERK1 or MEK1 and against Nur77. The MAPK pathway is also activated in neurons in primary culture undergoing NK(1)R-mediated death, since the MEK inhibitor PD98059 inhibited Substance P-induced death in primary striatal neurons. These results suggest that Nur77, which is regulated by a MAPK pathway activated via arrestin 2, modulates NK(1)R-mediated nonapoptotic pcd.     

Analysis of the N gene hypersensitive response induced by a fluorescently tagged tobacco mosaic virus

The hypersensitive response (HR) triggered on Nicotiana edwardsonii by tobacco mosaic virus was studied using a modified viral genome that directed expression of the green fluorescent protein. Inoculated plants were initially incubated at 32 degrees C to inhibit the N gene-mediated HR. Transfer to 20 degrees C initiated the HR, and fluorescent infection foci were monitored for early HR-associated events. Membrane damage, which preceded visible cell collapse by more than 3 h, was accompanied by a transient restriction of the xylem within infection sites. Following cell collapse and the rapid desiccation of tissue undergoing the HR, isolated, infected cells were detected at the margin of necrotic lesions. These virus-infected cells were able to reinitiate infection on transfer to 32 degrees C, however, if maintained at 20 degrees C they eventually died. The results indicate that the tobacco mosaic virus-induced HR is a two-phase process with an early stage culminating in rapid cell collapse and tissue desiccation followed by a more extended period during which the remaining infected cells are eliminated.     

Development of an apoptosis endonuclease assay.

A biochemical hallmark of cells undergoing programmed cell death, or apopotosis, is the endonucleolytic cleavage of genomic DNA at internucleosomal sites. To study further the nuclease involved in this process, an assay system was developed to measure internucleosomal DNA degradation. Micrococcal nuclease (MNase), a bacterial enzyme that cleaves chromatin at internucleosomal intervals, was used to validate the assay procedure. Thymocyte nuclear proteins obtained from glucocorticoid-treated chickens, a source of internucleosomal DNA-degrading activity, were incubated with chicken red blood cell nuclei, and genomic DNA was subsequently extracted and analyzed by agarose gel electrophoresis. Generation of internucleosomal DNA degradation products by the thymocyte protein extract required ATP and was both time and protein concentration dependent. This nuclease activity could be inhibited by EDTA, EGTA, alkylating agents, or heat denaturation. Addition of purified proteinases, RNases, or other types of nucleases to the assay failed to generate discrete internucleosomal lengths of DNA, thus confirming the nuclease specificity of this assay. On the basis of these data, we believe that this assay system will be instrumental in isolating and characterizing the nuclease(s) associated with apoptosis.     

Reprogramming of nuclear proteasomes in K562 cells undergoing apoptosis. I. Effect of glutathione-depleting agent, diethylmaleate

Here we have studied changes in the subunit composition, phosphorylation state and enzymatic activities of 26S proteasomes in cells undergoing the programmed cell death. Apoptosis in proerythroleukemic K562 cells was induced by glutathione-depleting agent, diethylmaleate (DEM). We have shown for the first time that proteasomes isolated from the nuclei of control and induces K562 cells differ in their subunit patterns, as well as in the phosphorylation state of subunits on threonine and tyrosine residues. We observed trypsin- and chymotrypsin-like activities on nuclear proteasomes and the specificity of proteasomal nucleolysis of several individual messenger RNAs (c-fos and c-myc) to be changed under effect of DEM on K562 cells. Treatment of K562 cells with DEM leads to modification of zeta/alpha5 and iota/alpha6 proteasomal subunits associated with RNAse activity of proteasomes. These findings confirm our hypothesis about so-called reprogramming of nuclear proteasome population in undergoing apoptosis K562 cells which is manifested by the changes in proteasomal composition, phosphorylation state, and enzymatic activities during the programmed cell death.     

ZEN1 is a key enzyme in the degradation of nuclear DNA during programmed cell death of tracheary elements

Tracheary elements (TEs) have a unique cell death program in which the rapid collapse of the vacuole triggers the beginning of nuclear degradation. Although various nucleases are known to function in nuclear DNA degradation in animal apoptosis, it is unclear what hydrolase is involved in nuclear degradation in plants. In this study, we demonstrated that an S1-type nuclease, Zinnia endonuclease 1 (ZEN1), functions directly in nuclear DNA degradation during programmed cell death (PCD) of TEs. In-gel DNase assay demonstrated the presence of a 24-kD Ca(2+)/Mg(2+)-dependent nuclease and a 40-kD Zn(2+)-dependent nuclease as well as ZEN1 in 60-h-cultured cells that included differentiating TEs. Such cell extracts possessed the ability to degrade the nuclear DNA isolated from Zinnia elegans cells in the presence of Zn(2+), and its activity was suppressed by an anti-ZEN1 antibody, indicating that ZEN1 is a central DNase responsible for nuclear DNA degradation. The introduction of the antisense ZEN1 gene into Zinnia cells cultured for 40 h specifically suppressed the degradation of nuclear DNA in TEs undergoing PCD but did not affect vacuole collapse. Based on these results, a common mechanism between animal and plant PCD is discussed.     

Aspects of programmed cell death during early senescence of barley leaves: possible role of nitric oxide

Summary. Leaf senescence is a highly coordinated process which involves programmed cell death (PCD). Early stages of leaf senescence occurring during normal leaf ontogenesis, but not triggered by stress factors, are less well known. In this study, we correlated condensation of chromatin and nuclear DNA (nDNA) fragmentation, two main features of PCD during early senescence in barley leaves, with the appearance of nitric oxide (NO) within leaf tissue. With the help of the alkaline version of the comet assay, together with measurements of nDNA fluorescence intensity, we performed a detailed analysis of the degree of nDNA fragmentation. We localised NO in vivo and in situ within the leaf and photometrically measured its concentration with the NO-specific fluorochrome 4-amino-5-methylamino-2′,7′-difluorofluorescein. We found that both nDNA fragmentation and chromatin condensation occurred quite early during barley leaf senescence and always in the same order: first nDNA fragmentation, in leaves of 6-day-old seedlings, and later chromatin condensation, in the apical part of leaves from 10-day-old seedlings. PCD did not start simultaneously even in neighbouring cells and probably did not proceed at the same rate. NO was localised in vivo and in situ within the cytoplasm, mainly in mitochondria, in leaves at the same stage as those in which chromatin condensation was observed. Localisation of NO in vascular tissue and in a large number of mesophyll cells during the senescence process might imply its transport to other parts of the leaf and its involvement in signalling between cells. The fact that the highest concentration of NO was found in the cytoplasm of mesophyll cells in the earliest stage of senescence and lower concentrations were found during later stages might suggest that NO plays an inductive role in PCD. Correspondence: A. Mostowska, Department of Plant Anatomy and Cytology, Institute of Experimental Biology of Plants, University of Warsaw, Miecznikowa 1, 02-096 Warsaw, Poland.     

Characterization of nuclease activities and DNA fragmentation induced upon hypersensitive response cell death and mechanical stress

Programmed cell death (PCD) is activated during the response of multicellular organisms to some invading pathogens. One of the key aspects of this process is the degradation of nuclear DNA which is thought to facilitate the recycling of DNA from dead cells. The PCD of tobacco plants (genotype NN) infected with tobacco mosaic virus (TMV) is accompanied by the induction of nuclease activities and the cleavage of nuclear DNA to fragments of about 50 kb. We examined the correlation between the increase in nuclease activities and the fragmentation of nuclear DNA during TMV- and bacteria-induced PCD in tobacco. We found that the increase in nuclease activities did not always correlate with fragmentation of nuclear DNA. Thus, in addition to pathogens that induce PCD, mechanical injury and infiltration of leaves with 1 M sucrose or bacteria that did not induce PCD also resulted in an increase in nuclease activities. Analysis of nuclease activities in total leaf extracts, nuclear extracts, and intercellular fluid (i.e., apoplast) revealed that at least four different nuclease activities are induced during PCD in tobacco; of these at least three appear to be secreted into the intercellular fluid. Although the latter were also induced in response to treatments that did not result in DNA fragmentation, they may function in the recycling of plant DNA during late stages of PCD when the integrity of the plasma membrane is compromised. This suggestion is supported by the finding that DNA degradation occurred late during TMV-induced PCD in tobacco. In addition, the finding of induced nuclease activities in the intercellular fluid raises the possibility that they may serve a protective function by degrading the DNA of invading pathogens.     

Activities of nucleases in senescing daylily petals

The activity of nucleases during organ death was investigated using daylily petals (Hemerocallis hybrid cv. Stella d’Oro), in which the processes associated with senescence are rapid and clearly ordered. The number of nuclei with fragmented DNA as well as activities of various nucleases increase before certain other events that are related to senescence. Furthermore, DNA breakage and activities of nucleases occur earlier when senescence is accelerated by abscisic acid and occur later when senescence is retarded by cycloheximide. These results suggest that the activities of nucleases contribute to the senescence of daylily petals. Therefore, studying the regulation of nuclease gene expression may be useful for understanding components of the signal transduction system that leads to the death of these organs.     

Flow cytometric analysis of tracheary element differentiation in Zinnia elegans cells.

BACKGROUND: Tracheary element (TE) differentiation in single cells in culture isolated from Zinnia elegans leaves involves programmed cell death (PCD) co-ordinated with key morphological developments. We have used flow cytometry to analyze physiological and nuclear changes in the differentiating cells. Flow cytometry allows the identification of subpopulations, thereby removing the obscuring effect of population heterogeneity that occurs with the use of other techniques. METHODS: Cell viability, plasma membrane integrity, oxidative activity, intracellular calcium and pH, cell wall thickening, the possible role of microtubule rearrangement, chromatin condensation, and DNA breakdown were followed by flow cytometry from the first stages of TE induction. RESULTS: TE differentiation could be enhanced and made more synchronous by a centrifugation step at 72 h after cell isolation. Size and shape changes were the first changes identified in differentiating cells, and these properties could be used to isolate differentiating populations by back-gating. Chromatin condensation and nDNA breakdown followed patterns characteristic of programmed cell death. CONCLUSIONS: We have used flow cytometry to characterize the morphological and physiological changes that occur during TE differentiation, and our findings indicate that this process is a form of autophagic PCD in which microtubule rearrangement appears to play a role.     

A plant caspase-like protease activated during the hypersensitive response

To test the hypothesis that caspase-like proteases exist and are critically involved in the implementation of programmed cell death (PCD) in plants, a search was undertaken for plant caspases activated during the N gene-mediated hypersensitive response (HR; a form of pathogen-induced PCD in plants) in tobacco plants infected with Tobacco mosaic virus (TMV). For detection, characterization, and partial purification of a tobacco caspase, the Agrobacterium tumefaciens VirD2 protein, shown here to be cleaved specifically at two sites (TATD and GEQD) by human caspase-3, was used as a target. In tobacco leaves, specific proteolytic processing of the ectopically produced VirD2 derivatives at these sites was found to occur early in the course of the HR triggered by TMV. A proteolytic activity capable of specifically cleaving the model substrate at TATD was partially purified from these leaves. A tetrapeptide aldehyde designed and synthesized on the basis of the elucidated plant caspase cleavage site prevented fragmentation of the substrate protein by plant and human caspases in vitro and counteracted TMV-triggered HR in vivo. Therefore, our data provide a characterization of caspase-specific protein fragmentation in apoptotic plant cells, with implications for the importance of such activity in the implementation of plant PCD.     

Preexisting systemic acquired resistance suppresses hypersensitive response-associated cell death in Arabidopsis hrl1 mutant

The hypersensitive response (HR) displayed by resistant plants against invading pathogens is a prominent feature of plant-pathogen interactions. The Arabidopsis hypersensitive response like lesions1 (hrl1) mutant is characterized by heightened defense responses that make it more resistant to virulent pathogens. However, hrl1 suppresses avirulent pathogen-induced HR cell death. Furthermore, the high PR-1 expression observed in hrl1 remains unaltered after avirulent and virulent pathogen infections. The suppressed HR phenotype in hrl1 is observed even when an elicitor is expressed endogenously from an inducible promoter, suggesting that an impaired transfer of avirulent factors is not the reason. Interestingly, the lack of HR phenotype in hrl1 is reversed if the constitutive defense responses are compromised either by a mutation in NON EXPRESSOR OF PR-1 (NPR1) or by depleting salicylic acid due to the expression of the nahG gene. The rescue of HR cell death in hrl1 npr1 and in hrl1 nahG depends on the extent to which the constitutive systemic acquired response (SAR) is compromised. Pretreating Arabidopsis wild-type plants with SAR-inducers, before pathogen infection resulted in a significant decrease in HR cell death. Together, these results demonstrate that the preexisting SAR may serve as one form of negative feedback loop to regulate HR-associated cell death in hrl1 mutant and in the wild-type plants.     

Changes in nuclease sensitivity of mammalian cells after irradiation with 60Co gamma-rays

Changes in sensitivity of mouse BALB/c 3T3 cells in the plateau phase to digestion with micrococcal nuclease were examined following gamma-irradiation. Immediately after irradiation, cell nuclei were more sensitive to micrococcal nuclease compared to unirradiated nuclei. However, there were no detectable changes in length of basic repeating subunits of 182 base pairs of DNA, which include the nucleosome cores consisting of approximately 140 base pairs of DNA, which When the cells were incubated at 37 degrees following irradiation, the sensitivity of cell nuclei to the nuclease first increased then decreased, reaching a similar level to unirradiated nuclei 6 h after irradiation. Both the initial increase and the subsequent decrease in sensitivity of nuclei to micrococcal nuclease were prevented when 15 microM novobiocin was present during the post-irradiation incubation, suggesting a possible involvement of type II DNA topoisomerase in repair of DNA lesions induced by gamma-rays.