The effects of seaweed harvesting on fishes: a critique

Synopsis Black & Miller (1991) concluded that there was no large impact of an experimental harvest of rockweed,Ascophyllum nodosum, on fishes. A critique of their study demonstrates that this conclusion cannot be substantiated by their data because of sampling biases, errors in experimental design and low statistical power. Further, evidence is presented which supports the hypothesis that rockweed may provide an important nursery habitat for juvenile fishes.     

Comparison of the structure of populations of Ascophyllum nodosum (Fucales,Phaeophyta) at sites with different harvesting histories

Changes in the structure of the Ascophyllum nodosum population at Pubnico, southwest Nova Scotia, Canada, at an experimental site subjected to mechanical harvest and at two control sites never subjected to mechanical harvest were monitored from 1991 to 1994. A bimodal population structure measured in terms of plant length was characteristic of all these sites before the experiment. The population structure of the experimental site became unimodal immediately after experimental harvest by machine and remained unimodal for the subsequent two years. However, a bimodal population structure began to appear in the third year. A bimodal population structure remained evident at the control site with bedrock as the substratum but was less evident at the other control site where the substratum is made up of boulders and cobbles. Movement of loose rocks with rockweeds still attached may have contributed to the less distinct modal structure of this control site. Other sites with different harvesting histories monitored in the summer of 1992 showed some interesting patterns. A unimodal population structure was evident in Argyle Sound and Pubnico Point South and at Charlesville, which had been harvested one and two years before, respectively. A bimodal population structure was more evident at Frenchman's Point, which had been harvested three years prior. The rate of change from a unimodal to a bimodal population structure may depend on the intensity of harvest. Extensive canopy removal in intensively harvested areas may be conducive to an influx of recruits and to regeneration from the holdfast. Hence, plant length modal structure may be a useful measure of the relative state of recovery of a harvested population.     

Changes in the population structure of Ascophyllum nodosum (L.) Le Jolis due to mechanical harvesting

The use of a Norwegian suction cutter to harvest populations of the brown alga Ascophyllum nodosum (L.) Le Jolis in southwestern Nova Scotia started in 1985. The impact of this type of mechanical harvest on the algal population structure was evaluated. Changes in the length and density of individual plants (clumps) within 0.25 m^–2 quadrats, as well as the length of individual shoots within clumps were monitored before and after an experimental harvest. The mechanical harvest cut mainly the longer plants, thus changed the initial bimodal size structure of the population to unimodal. There was a 20 to 36% plant mortality, reducing the plant density from 92.6 to 73.6 individuals m^–2. Pre-harvest size distribution of the tagged shoots was skewed to the right and became more normal after the harvest. Tagged shoots in the harvested quadrats suffered a 42% mortality as compared to 11% of those in the control quadrats. An understanding of the impact of the mechanical harvesting on the harvested population is essential in the design of a management strategy. Sources of variation in the impact of mechanical harvest include the tide level at time of harvest, length of time the machine operated in one site, skill of the machine operator, and sharpness of the machine cutting blades.     

The effect of a liquid seaweed extract from Ascophyllum nodosum (Fucales,Phaeophyta) on the two-spotted red spider mite Tetranychus urticae

This paper presents evidence from an initial trial in favor of claims that the liquid seaweed extract of Ascophyllum nodosum, marketed in the UK as Maxicrop, can reduce numbers of the two-spotted red spider mite Tetranychus urticae on crop plants. Seven applications of Maxicrop Triple over 20 days significantly suppressed the population build-up of two-spotted red spider mites on treated strawberry plants (Fragaria sp. var. Redgauntlet) raised under high polythene tunnels as compared to untreated controls.     

Effects of harvesting onAscophyllum nodosum (L.) Le Jol. (Fucales,Phaeophyta): a demographic approach

Although populations ofAscophyllum nodosum are harvested commercially, little is known about the effects on demographic vital rates (growth, reproduction, survival). This study examines the effects of harvesting season and harvesting intensity on growth, reproduction and mortality of intact fronds in four size classes and in fronds truncated by the harvest. Knowledge of size-specific vital rates was used to evaluate the response of the population to harvesting.Harvesting season and harvesting intensity did not exert a significant effect on growth. Growth in plots not subject to harvesting was less than in harvested plots. No major differences in growth, reproduction and survival between intact and severed fronds emerged. The number of fronds attaining reproduction was enhanced by increased harvesting intensity and by cutting in summer. Harvesting did not seem to induce breakage, and breakage appeared higher in the uncut plots. Most harvesting treatments did not influence survivorship and survivorship was similar among all size classes. Growth rates were inversely related to sizes of fronds.Assessment of variation across size classes yielded more accurate estimates of growth rates than those of previously used methods. Accurate size class specific-growth rates will be a useful criterion when regulating intervals between harvests. Furthermore, assessment of size-specific vital rates allows identification of the frond size classes most relevant to the preservation of resources. Because of their fast growth rates and abundance, fronds in class 1, and, to a lesser extent, class 2, are responsible for most of the population regrowth after harvest. In contrast, classes 3 and 4 contribute little to recovery. This finding provides a strong basis for a harvesting strategy that targets the largest fronds.Author for correspondence     

Enhanced leaf chlorophyll levels in plants treated with seaweed extract

Application to the soil of an aqueous alkaline extract ofAscophyllum nodosum resulted in higher concentrations of chlorophyll in the leaves of treated plants in comparison to control plants treated with an equivalent volume of water. Positive results were obtained with all species tested (tomato, dwarf French bean, wheat, barley, maize). When the seaweed extract was applied as a foliar spray, similar effects on leaf chlorophyll contents were obtained, except in the case of dwarf French bean plants, for which no significant difference was recorded between test and control plants. When the betaines present in the seaweed extract were applied as a mixture in the same concentrations as those in the diluted seaweed extract (-aminobutyric acid betaine 0.96 mg L^–1, -aminovaleric acid betaine 0.43 mg L^–1, glycinebetaine 0.34 mg L^–1), very similar leaf chlorophyll levels were recorded for the seaweed extract and betaine treated plants. This suggests strongly that the enhanced leaf chlorophyll content of plants treated with seaweed extract is dependent on the betaines present.     

Quantitative estimation of betaines in commercial seaweed extracts using overpressured layer chromatography

An off-line, overpressured layer chromatographic procedure has been developed for the evaluation of betaines in commercial seaweed extracts using Dragendorff's reagent for the detection of the compounds and densitometry for their quantitative estimation. Using continuous development and a low sample volume, the amounts of -aminobutyric acid betaine and -aminovaleric acid betaine can be estimated, but a larger sample volume is necessary for the estimation of glycinebetaine and minor betaines.The critical steps of this analytical method are the visualization and the quantitative evaluation of the spots produced. Temperature plays a major role in the resolution, sensitivity and precision after derivatization with Dragendorff's reagent; this has led to the adoption of standardized conditions.Author for correspondence     

Liquid seaweed extracts identified using <Superscript>1</Superscript>H NMR profiles

Aqueous extracts of Ascophyllum nodosum and several other brown seaweeds are manufactured commercially and widely distributed for use on agricultural crops. The increasingly regulated international trade in such products requires that they be standardized and defined to a degree not previously required. We examined commercially available extracts using quantitative ¹H NMR and principal components analysis (PCA) techniques. Extracts manufactured over a 4-year period using the same process exhibited characteristic profiles that, on PCA, clustered as a discrete group distinct from the other commercial products examined. In addition to recognizing extracts made from different seaweeds, analysis of the ¹H spectra in the 0.35–4.70 ppm region allowed us to distinguish amongst extracts produced from the same algal species by different manufacturers. This result established that the process used to make an extract is an important variable in defining its composition. A comparison of the ¹H NMR integrals for the regions 1.0–3.0 ppm and 3.0–4.38 ppm revealed small but significant changes in the A. nodosum spectra that we attribute to seasonal variation in gross composition of the harvested seaweed. Such changes are reflected in the PCA scores plots and contribute to the scatter observed within the data point cluster observed for Acadian soluble extracts when all data are pooled. Quantitative analysis using ¹H NMR (qNMR) with a certified external standard (caffeine) showed a linear relationship with extract concentration over at least an order of magnitude (2.5–33 mg/mL; R ² > 0.97) for both spectral regions integrated. We conclude that qNMR can be used to profile (or “fingerprint”) commercial seaweed extracts and to quantify the amount of extract present relative to a suitably chosen standard. Issued as NRCC no. 42,652.     

Effect of feeding sun-dried seaweed (Ascophyllum nodosum) on fecal shedding of Escherichia coli O157:H7 by feedlot cattle and on growth performance of lambs

Thirty-two steers orally inoculated with a four-strain mixture (10¹⁰ CFU) of nalidixic acid-resistant Escherichia coli O157:H7 had sun-dried Ascophyllum nodosum seaweed (Tasco-14™) added to their barley-based diet (860 g/kg barley grain and 90 g/kg whole crop barley silage, dry matter basis) to assess its effectiveness in reducing fecal shedding of the pathogen. Steers were housed in four groups of eight and received Tasco-14™ in the diet, in place of barley, at levels (as fed) of 10 g/kg for 14 days (T1-14), 20 g/kg for 7 days (T2-7), 20 g/kg for 14 days (T2-14), or not at all (i.e., control, CON). The dietary treatments commenced 7 days after E. coli O157:H7 inoculation and fecal shedding patterns were examined over 14 weeks. Water, water–trough interface, feed and fecal pat samples were also collected weekly and cultured for E. coli O157:H7. Detection of the pathogen in fecal samples was less frequent (P<0.05) in T1-14 (99/168) and T2-7 (84/168) versus CON (135/168) and T2-14 (115/168), and the concentrations of E. coli O157:H7 recovered in feces from T1-14 and T2-7 steers were lower (P<0.005) than from CON or T2-14 steers. Rates of decline in shedding of E. coli O157:H7 were similar among treatments, but final numbers of E. coli O157:H7 were lower (P<0.05) in T1-14 and T2-7 as compared to T2-14 and CON. Fecal volatile fatty acid concentrations and pH were similar among treatments, suggesting no fecal alterations that were antagonistic to survival. E. coli O157:H7 was present in 1 (from T2-7) of 56 cattle drinking water samples, 2 of 56 (T1-14, CON) feed samples and 32 of 56 fecal pats. A second experiment investigated effects of the dietary treatment on growth performance of non-inoculated sheep. Tasco-14™ was administered to 40 individually fed Canadian Arcott lambs beginning at day 56 of a 105-day finishing period. The lambs received Tasco-14™ at 0 g/kg (control, CON), at 10 g/kg for 14 days (T1-14), 20 g/kg for 14 days (T2-14), 10 g/kg for 28 days (T1-28) or at 20 g/kg for 7 days (T2-7) as a top-dress on their pelleted, barley grain-based diet (n = 8). E. coli O157:H7 was not isolated from fecal samples collected at 4-week intervals, but generic E. coli populations were lower (P<0.05) in T1-28 lambs than in other treatments. Average daily gain, feed intake, feed efficiency and carcass traits did not differ among treatments. Our challenge study supports past studies showing that Tasco-14™ decreases shedding of E. coli O157:H7 by cattle. The lamb study shows that this additive did not directly affect feed intake or animal growth.     

Formaldehyde,as its dimedone adduct,fromAscophyllum nodosum

Formaldehyde, as its dimedone adduct (formaldemethone), has been isolated fromAscophyllum nodosum and characterised by thin-layer and overpressured layer chromatography, and from proton nuclear magnetic resonance spectroscopic and electron impact mass spectrometric data. Formaldemethone was detected in extracts of both fresh and dry alga. It is postulated that during dynamic methylation and demethylation processes in the cells, hydroxymethyl groups may be formed, which dependent on pH, are in equilibrium with either free formaldehyde or ions such as iminium, oxonium and thionium; these species will react with dimedone to form formaldemethone. The amount of formaldehyde captured by the dimedone reagent increases as the concentration of dimedone is increased, until a maximum is reached.     

Induced resistance in intertidal macroalgae modifies feeding behaviour of herbivorous snails

Herbivory in terrestrial and marine systems can induce changes in plant chemistry affecting the foraging behaviour of herbivores. A model based on terrestrial plant-herbivore interactions predicts herbivory-induced changes in leaf chemistry to be manifested in (1) increased herbivore mobility, (2) increased feeding dispersal and (3) reduced tissue consumption by herbivores. This study is the first to demonstrate that herbivory-induced changes in the tissue chemistry of the brown seaweed Ascophyllum nodosum elicit the same response in the feeding behaviour of the gastropod Littorina obtusata as predicted for herbivorous insects, providing good evidence for the models validity across different ecosystems. The potential benefit of increased feeding dispersal to terrestrial plants as suggested by the model is the prevention of concentrated damage to apical tissues thereby preserving the plants ability to compete for light; A. nodosum does not conform to these predictions. Increased dispersal of feeding damage on A. nodosum away from primary frond tissues would reduce the likelihood of frond breakage implying a fitness benefit of induced resistance.     

Ecological effects of seaweed harvesting in the Gulf of California and Pacific Ocean off Baja California and California

The ecological effects of harvesting were investigated for two species, the giant kelp Macrocystis pyrifera and Eucheuma uncinatum, by using harvest records and aerial surveys that show yield changes and by using studies of recruitment, survivorship and community interactions. There were no ecological effects found for M. pyrifera harvested with contemporary methods, and there are no recommendations for changing current management practices for this species. It is recommended that E. uncinatum, which on occasion produces commercially significant standing crops, not be harvested unless special precautions are taken to leave some plants for regeneration of the harvested populations.     

Reduction of nitrate leaching from soil treated with an Ascophyllum nodosum based soil conditioning agent

A commercially available soil conditioning agent prepared from a brown marine alga, Ascophyllum nodosum, was tested for its ability to effect leaching rates of nitrate from two soil types. The use of the material led to a significant (p < 0.05) reduction of nitrate leaching from a soil composed of sand and compost (50:50). This revised version was published online in August 2006 with corrections to the Cover Date.     

Experimental confirmation of multiple community states in a marine ecosystem

Small changes in environmental conditions can unexpectedly tip an ecosystem from one community type to another, and these often irreversible shifts have been observed in semi-arid grasslands, freshwater lakes and ponds, coral reefs, and kelp forests. A commonly accepted explanation is that these ecosystems contain multiple stable points, but experimental tests confirming multiple stable states have proven elusive. Here we present a novel approach and show that mussel beds and rockweed stands are multiple stable states on intertidal shores in the Gulf of Maine, USA. Using broad-scale observational data and long-term data from experimental clearings, we show that the removal of rockweed by winter ice scour can tip persistent rockweed stands to mussel beds. The observational data were analyzed with Anderson’s discriminant analysis of principal coordinates, which provided an objective function to separate mussel beds from rockweed stands. The function was then applied to 55 experimental plots, which had been established in rockweed stands in 1996. Based on 2005 data, all uncleared controls and all but one of the small clearings were classified as rockweed stands; 37% of the large clearings were classified as mussel beds. Our results address the establishment of mussels versus rockweeds and complement rather than refute the current paradigm that mussel beds and rockweed stands, once established, are maintained by site-specific differences in strong consumer control. Electronic supplementary material  The online version of this article (doi:) contains supplementary material, which is available to authorized users.     

The effects of predation on the survival and size-distribution of estuarine fishes: an experimental approach

Synopsis The effect of southern flounder,Paralichthys lethostigma, predation on the survival and size-distribution of spot,Leiostomus xanthurus, was investigated using feeding experiments in outdoor tanks and estuarine ponds. In the outdoor tank experiments, southern flounder, 143 mm average standard length (SL), fed for 48 h on spot (25–30 mm SL), over a range of densities (4–20 m^–2). In these trials, flounder showed a Type II functional response to spot density. In the estuarine pond experiment, flounder density (2 or 4 flounders 70 m^–2) contributed significantly to spot mortality relative to predator-free controls. The effect of flounder density on spot mortality was non-linear; in the 4-flounder treatment the daily instantaneous mortality due to flounder (0.0177) was 3.5 times that in the 2-flounder treatment (0.0051). The total spot mortality rate in the 4-flounder treatment (0.028) was similar to that observed from published field observations. Flounder also altered the size distribution of spot relative to predator-free controls. Predation by flounder resulted in fewer intermediate-sized spot at the end of the experiment when compared to predator-free controls. Flounder also significantly reduced survival and mean length of two killifishes,Cyprinodon variegatus andFundulus heteroclitus, that invaded the pond. Flounder predation was a significant size-structuring force on the prey fish assemblage in the pond. Results from both the outdoor tank experiment and the pond experiment indicate that flounder may represent a significant source of mortality for juvenile estuarine fishes.     

Seasonal and environmental effects on the blood hemoglobin concentrations of some Panamanian air-breathing fishes

Synopsis Interspecific differences in blood hemoglobin concentration ([Hb]) occur among air breathing fishes. However, the effect on [Hb] of factors such as air-breathing organ structure and blood circulation pattern, air breathing behavior, as well as season and environmental conditions have not been fully examined. [Hb] in seven Panamanian species of air-breathing freshwater teleost fishes were compared and were monitored for most species during the wet and dry seasons and in hypoxic laboratory conditions. Fishes studied were Ancistrus, Hypostomus, and Loricaria (Family Loricariidae); Hoplosternum (Callichthyidae); Synbranchus (Synbranchidae); Piabucina (Lebiasinidae); and Dormitator (Eleotridae). [Hb] in these species ranged from 4.8 to 14.6 g 100 ml^–1 (g%). Ancistrus, Hypostomus, and Dormitator significantly increased [Hb] during the dry season and, with Piabucina, also increased [Hb] when acclimated to hypoxia in the laboratory. An increase in [Hb] during the dry season may precondition facultative air breathers for habitat hypoxia (and the need to respire aerially) in the event this occurs. Intraspecific differences in both [Hb] and in red cell Hb-phosphate ratio, an index of oxygen affinity, were found in populations of Hypostomus and relate directly to differences in habitat oxygen level. In all species tested alterations in blood hematocrit (Hmct) and mean corpuscular hemoglobin concentration (MCHC) occurred only with correspondingly large net changes in blood [Hb]. The [Hb] of Loricaria, Synbranchus, and Hoplosternum was not affected by season or hypoxia and this may be due to behavioral and physiological adaptations that reduce the transbranchial loss of aerially-obtained oxygen or to a ventilatory mode that precludes this possibility.     

Effect of Ascophyllum nodosum extract on growth performance, digestibility, carcass characteristics and selected intestinal microflora populations of grower–finisher pigs

The effects of an extract of the brown seaweed Ascophyllum nodosum (AN) in grower–finisher pigs are reported. In Experiment 1, the effect of dietary supplementation with increasing levels of AN extract (ANE) on growth performance, carcass characteristics and gastrointestinal microflora was investigated. A total of 360 pigs were randomly allocated, based on initial live-weight and sex, to one of four experimental treatments as follows; control diet (no ANE), control diet plus 3 g ANE/kg, control diet plus 6 g ANE/kg and control diet plus 9 g ANE/kg. These diets were fed ad libitum up to slaughter. In Experiment 2, eight male pigs were allocated to a control diet (no ANE) or the control diet plus 2.5 g ANE/kg to determine effects of ANE on coefficient of total tract apparent digestibility (CTTAD) of nutrients and nitrogen (N) balance. Supplementation with increasing levels of ANE in Experiment 1 resulted in reduced daily gain, carcass weight and kill-out yield during the combined grower–finisher period (P<0.05); however, there were no effects of treatment on feed intake, feed conversion ratio or carcass characteristics. Increasing levels of dietary ANE resulted in decreased ileal coliform counts (P<0.05). Increasing dietary ANE also tended to increase adherent lactobacilli in the colon (P=0.080) but caecal bifidobacteria declined (P<0.05). There were trends towards a linear reduction in colonic bifidobacteria (P=0.077) and towards a quadratic effect on rectal lactobacilli (P=0.077). Intestinal pH was unaffected by ANE supplementation (P>0.05). In Experiment 2, the CTTAD was unaffected by the inclusion of ANE (P>0.05). Overall, the intestinal coliform reductions obtained suggest that ANE may provide a dietary means to improve gut health and potentially reduce pathogen carriage in finishing pigs. However, the negative effects on growth performance observed in healthy animals will most likely limit the commercial use of dietary ANE as a feed additive.     

The demography of trout lily (Erythronium americanum Ker.) in Nova Scotia

The age structures of both native and transplanted populations of the perennial herb, trout lily (Erythronium americanum), were analysed and found to have age-independent mortality rates. Cohort survival was greatest in populations growing on hardwood forested flood plains (60%), less in populations from gently sloping terraces with pit-and-mound microrelief (53%) and smallest (45%) for colonies on slopes steeper than 15°. The former habitat-type is the optimum for trout lily in Nova Scotia and in it the proportion of flowering bulbs can reach 35%. The second named habitat is widespread and characterised by fewer flowering bulbs (5–10%). In the latter habitat flowering bulbs are uniformly rare. Trout lily bulbs tend to be sterile until at least their eighth year. The high mortality rates of populations on steeply sloping, hardwood forested ground ensure minimal survival of bulbs beyond their sixth year. In the other two named habitats sufficient numbers of bulbs reach ages of 8 or 9 years for some to make the translation from the sterile to the flowering form. In all the habitats studied in Nova Scotia, propagation is typically by either runners or, less importantly, daughter bulbs, with the peak of activity in the bulbs third and fourth years. The plants of flood plains showed the greatest rates of vegetative propagation, by cohort, but many of the bulbs from colonies growing on steep slopes lacked runners or daughter bulbs. As all bulbs for the transplant experiments came from a single clone it can be concluded that trout lily plants in Nova Scotia have a sufficiently large genetic endowment for them to behave in the same manner as native populations of the species in the several habitats represented in the province.The figures were drafted in the cartography section of the University of Canterbury. The National Research Council of Canada supported the research with a series of grants.