Recombination between repeats in Escherichia coli by a recA-independent, proximity-sensitive mechanism

We have examined the influence of proximity on the efficiency of recombination between repeated DNA sequences in Escherichia coli. Our experiments have employed a plasmid-based assay to detect deletions between direct repeats of 100 bp. The rate of deletion of the juxtaposed direct repeats was reasonably high at 6 × 10^–5 per cell. A comparison of recA+ and recA mutant strains showed that these deletion events are primarily the result of recA-independent recombination at these homologous sequences. Random restriction fragments of yeast or E. coli genomic DNA were used to separate the two repeats. Deletion rates decreased over two orders of magnitude with increasing separation of up to 7 kb. There was a surprisingly strong effect of even short sequence separations, with insertions of a few hundred base pairs exhibiting 10-fold reductions of deletion rates. No effect of recA on the efficiency of deletion was observed at any distance between repeats.     

Single Strand Annealing Plays a Major Role in RecA-Independent Recombination between Repeated Sequences in the Radioresistant Deinococcus radiodurans Bacterium

The bacterium Deinococcus radiodurans is one of the most radioresistant organisms known. It is able to reconstruct a functional genome from hundreds of radiation-induced chromosomal fragments. Our work aims to highlight the genes involved in recombination between 438 bp direct repeats separated by intervening sequences of various lengths ranging from 1,479 bp to 10,500 bp to restore a functional tetA gene in the presence or absence of radiation-induced DNA double strand breaks. The frequency of spontaneous deletion events between the chromosomal direct repeats were the same in recA+ and in ΔrecA, ΔrecF, and ΔrecO bacteria, whereas recombination between chromosomal and plasmid DNA was shown to be strictly dependent on the RecA and RecF proteins. The presence of mutations in one of the repeated sequence reduced, in a MutS-dependent manner, the frequency of the deletion events. The distance between the repeats did not influence the frequencies of deletion events in recA ⁺ as well in ΔrecA bacteria. The absence of the UvrD protein stimulated the recombination between the direct repeats whereas the absence of the DdrB protein, previously shown to be involved in DNA double strand break repair through a single strand annealing (SSA) pathway, strongly reduces the frequency of RecA- (and RecO-) independent deletions events. The absence of the DdrB protein also increased the lethal sectoring of cells devoid of RecA or RecO protein. γ-irradiation of recA ⁺ cells increased about 10-fold the frequencies of the deletion events, but at a lesser extend in cells devoid of the DdrB protein. Altogether, our results suggest a major role of single strand annealing in DNA repeat deletion events in bacteria devoid of the RecA protein, and also in recA ⁺ bacteria exposed to ionizing radiation.     

Asymmetric crossing over in the spontaneous formation of large deletions in the tonB-trp region of the Escherichia coli K-12 chromosome

The chromosomal tonB gene of Escherichia coli was used as a target for the detection of spontaneous deletion mutations. The deletions were isolated in both recA ⁺ and recA ^? cells, and mutants carrying large deletions were identified because they also lacked part or all of the trp operon. The frequencies of tonB-trp deletion were 1.79?×?10^?9 and 1.09?×?10^?9 for recA ⁺ and recA ^? cells, respectively. We analyzed 12 deletions from recA ⁺ and 10 from recA ^? cells by cloning and direct sequencing. The deletions ranged in size from 5612?bp to 15142?bp for recA ⁺ and from 5428?bp to 13289 for recA ^? cells. Three deletions from recA ⁺ cells and five deletions from recA ^? cells were found to have occurred between short sequence repeats at the termini of the deletion, leaving one copy of the repeat in the mutant sequence. Seven deletions from recA ⁺ cells and three deletions from recA ^? cells did not have repeats at their termini; in these cases, the DNA sequences that are adjacent to the deletion termini in the wild-type are characterized by short (2–4?bp) repeats. From these results, a model is presented for the generation of deletion mutations which involves formation of an asymmetric crossover mediated by repeated sequences of 2- to 4-bp.     

A Replicational Model for DNA Recombination between Direct Repeats

DNA rearrangement (recombination) mediated by direct repeats is a major cause of genome instability. InEscherichia coli, direct repeats in close proximity can mediate efficientrecA-independent intramolecular recombi nation, which produces multiple products. Using plasmid substrates, three basic forms of products have been revealed: the monomeric deletion product and two dimeric products. The frequency of recombination has been shown to be affected by structural factors such as the length of the repeat and the distance between the repeats. We show here that these factors also affect the relative abundance of each form of product. Recombination between very short tandem repeats yields exclusively the monomeric product. Lengthening the repeats increases the abundance of the dimeric products. Increasing the distance separating the repeats sharply reduces the formation of the monomeric product. These results can be explained by a model for DNA rearrangement (recombination) involving DNA replication. We propose that misalignment of the repeats at the replication fork creates a recombinogenic intermediate that can be differentially processed to form the three basic products. The proposed sister-strand recombination mediated by direct repeats might be a general mechanism for deletion and/or amplification of repeated sequences in both prokaryotic and eukaryotic genomes.     

Genetic deletions between directly repeated sequences in bacteriophage T7

Summary DNA sequence analysis of genetic deletions in bacteriophage T7 has shown that these chromosomal rearrangements frequently occur between directly repeated DNA sequences. To study this type of spontaneous deletion in more quantitative detail synthetic fragments of DNA, made by hybridizing two complementary oligonucleotides, were introduced into the non-essential T7 gene 1.3 which codes for T7 DNA ligase. This insert blocked synthesis of functional ligase and made the phage that carried an insert unable to form plaques on a host strain deficient in bacterial ligase. The sequence of the insert was designed so that after it is put into the T7 genome the insert is bracketed by direct repeats. Perfect deletion of the insert between the directly repeated sequences results in a wild-type phage. It was found that these deletion events are highly sensitive to the length of the direct repeats at their ends. In the case of 5 bp direct repeats excision from the genome occurred at a frequency of less than 10⁻¹⁰, while this value for an almost identical insert bracketed by 10 bp direct repeats was approximately 10⁻⁶. The deletion events were independent of a hostrecA mutation.     

Recombination between two TnA transposon sequences oriented as inverse repeats is found less frequently than between direct repeats

Summary Inverse repeats of the transposon Tn2660 in either a ColEl or an R6K replicon, with or without inversions of the parental DNA sequences between the repeats, show no detectable (<2%) evidence of recombination between the repeats after 60 generations of growth in either recA or recA ⁺ hosts. In contrast, attempts made to construct plasmids which carry two direct repeats by in vitro cleavage and ligation in a recA host were unsuccessful, although homologous plasmids with inverse repeats could be constructed, and other plasmids were found consistent with products of recombination between the direct repeats of a transient intermediate structure. It is concluded that in recA or recA ⁺ hosts recombination between direct repeats of a transposon is frequent, whereas recombination between inverse repeats of a homologous structure has not been observed. A model to explain this difference depends upon a mechanism that produces a nick in only one of the pair of strands at the internal resolution site (IRS) sequence of the transposon.     

Asymmetric crossing over in the spontaneous formation of large deletions in the tonB-trp region of the Escherichia coli K-12 chromosome.

The chromosomal tonB gene of Escherichia coli was used as a target for the detection of spontaneous deletion mutations. The deletions were isolated in both recA ⁺ and recA ⁻ cells, and mutants carrying large deletions were identified because they also lacked part or all of the trp operon. The frequencies of tonB-trp deletion were 1.79 × 10⁻⁹ and 1.09 × 10⁻⁹ for recA ⁺ and recA ⁻ cells, respectively. We analyzed 12 deletions from recA ⁺ and 10 from recA ⁻ cells by cloning and direct sequencing. The deletions ranged in size from 5612 bp to 15142 bp for recA ⁺ and from 5428 bp to 13289 for recA ⁻ cells. Three deletions from recA ⁺ cells and five deletions from recA ⁻ cells were found to have occurred between short sequence repeats at the termini of the deletion, leaving one copy of the repeat in the mutant sequence. Seven deletions from recA ⁺ cells and three deletions from recA ⁻ cells did not have repeats at their termini; in these cases, the DNA sequences that are adjacent to the deletion termini in the wild-type are characterized by short (2–4 bp) repeats. From these results, a model is presented for the generation of deletion mutations which involves formation of an asymmetric crossover mediated by repeated sequences of 2- to 4-bp. Received: 14 September 1998 / Accepted: 22 December 1998     

A hotspot of spontaneous and UV-induced illegitimate recombination during formation ofλbio transducing phage

To study the mechanism of spontaneous and UV-induced illegitimate recombination, we examined the formation of theλbio specialized transducing phage inEscherichia coli. Because mostλbio transducing phages have double defects in thered andgam genes and have the capacity to form a plaque on anE. coli P2 lysogen (Spi^? phenotype), we selectedλbio transducing phage by their Spi^? phenotype, rather than using thebio marker. We determined sequences of recombination junctions ofλbio transducing phages isolated with or without UV irradiation and deduced sequences of parental recombination sites. The recombination sites were widely distributed onE. coli bio andλ DNAs, except for a hotspot which accounts for 57% of UV-inducedλbio transducing phages and 77% of spontaneously inducedλbio transducing phages. The hotspot sites onE. coli andλ DNAs shared a short homology of 9 bp. In addition, we detected direct repeat sequences of 8 by within and near both thebio andλ hotspots. ArecA mutation did not affect the frequency of the recombination at the hotspot, indicating that this recombination is not a variant ofrecA-dependent homologous recombination. We discuss a model in which the short homology as well as the direct repeats play essential roles in illegitimate recombination at the hotspot.     

Complementation of Bacteriophage Induction and Recombination Defects in <Emphasis Type="Italic">Escherichia coli</Emphasis> RecA<Superscript>−</Superscript> Mutants by Expression of the Cloned T4 Bacteriophage <Emphasis Type="Italic">uvsX</Emphasis> Gene

Previous workers reported that the T4 bacteriophage UvsX protein could promote neither RecA-LexA-mediated DNA repair nor induction of lysogenized bacteriophage, only recombination. Reexamination of these phenotypes demonstrated that, in contrast to these prior studies, when this gene was cloned into a medium but not a low-copy-number vector, it stimulated both a high frequency of spontaneous induction and mitomycin C-stimulated bacteriophage induction in a strain containing a recA13 mutation, but not a recA1 defect. The gene when cloned into a low- or medium- copy-number vector also promoted a low frequency of recombination of two duplicated genes in Escherichia coli in a strain with a complete recA gene deletion. These results suggest that a narrow concentration range of T4 UvsX protein is required to promote both high-frequency spontaneous and mitomycin C-stimulated bacteriophage induction in a recA13 gene mutant, but it facilitates recombination of duplicated genes at only a very low frequency in E. coli RecA⁻ mutants with a complete recA deletion. These results also suggest that the different UvsX phenotypes are affected differentially by the concentration of UvsX protein present. Received: 11 February 2002 / Accepted: 12 April 2002     

Intraplasmid recombination in Streptomyces lividans 66

Summary An Escherichia coli-Streptomyces shuttle plasmid pIF132 containing two direct mel repeats was constructed. While pIF132 replicated relatively stably in E. coli (Rec⁺ or recA), its structure was unstable in S. lividans: recombination between the mel repeats resulted in a smaller plasmid, pIF138. Furthermore, pIF132 formed oligomers extensively in E. coli but not in S. lividans.     

Direct and Inverted Repeats Elicit Genetic Instability by Both Exploiting and Eluding DNA Double-Strand Break Repair Systems in Mycobacteria

Repetitive DNA sequences with the potential to form alternative DNA conformations, such as slipped structures and cruciforms, can induce genetic instability by promoting replication errors and by serving as a substrate for DNA repair proteins, which may lead to DNA double-strand breaks (DSBs). However, the contribution of each of the DSB repair pathways, homologous recombination (HR), non-homologous end-joining (NHEJ) and single-strand annealing (SSA), to this sort of genetic instability is not fully understood. Herein, we assessed the genome-wide distribution of repetitive DNA sequences in the Mycobacterium smegmatis, Mycobacterium tuberculosis and Escherichia coli genomes, and determined the types and frequencies of genetic instability induced by direct and inverted repeats, both in the presence and in the absence of HR, NHEJ, and SSA. All three genomes are strongly enriched in direct repeats and modestly enriched in inverted repeats. When using chromosomally integrated constructs in M. smegmatis, direct repeats induced the perfect deletion of their intervening sequences ∼1,000-fold above background. Absence of HR further enhanced these perfect deletions, whereas absence of NHEJ or SSA had no influence, suggesting compromised replication fidelity. In contrast, inverted repeats induced perfect deletions only in the absence of SSA. Both direct and inverted repeats stimulated excision of the constructs from the attB integration sites independently of HR, NHEJ, or SSA. With episomal constructs, direct and inverted repeats triggered DNA instability by activating nucleolytic activity, and absence of the DSB repair pathways (in the order NHEJ>HR>SSA) exacerbated this instability. Thus, direct and inverted repeats may elicit genetic instability in mycobacteria by 1) directly interfering with replication fidelity, 2) stimulating the three main DSB repair pathways, and 3) enticing L5 site-specific recombination.     

RecA mediates MgpB and MgpC phase and antigenic variation in Mycoplasma genitalium, but plays a minor role in DNA repair

Mycoplasma genitalium, a sexually transmitted human pathogen, encodes MgpB and MgpC adhesins that undergo phase and antigenic variation through recombination with archived ‘MgPar’ donor sequences. The mechanism and molecular factors required for this genetic variation are poorly understood. In this study, we estimate that sequence variation at the mgpB/C locus occurs in vitro at a frequency of > 1.25 × 10^?4 events per genome per generation using a quantitative anchored PCR assay. This rate was dramatically reduced in a recA deletion mutant and increased in a complemented strain overexpressing RecA. Similarly, the frequency of haemadsorption‐deficient phase variants was reduced in the recA mutant, but restored by complementation. Unlike Escherichia coli, inactivation of recA in M. genitalium had a minimal effect on survival after exposure to mitomycin C or UV irradiation. In contrast, a deletion mutant for the predicted nucleotide excision repair uvrC gene showed growth defects and was exquisitely sensitive to DNA damage. We conclude that M. genitalium RecA has a primary role in mgpB/C–MgPar recombination leading to antigenic and phase variation, yet plays a minor role in DNA repair. Our results also suggest that M. genitalium possesses an active nucleotide excision repair system, possibly representing the main DNA repair pathway in this minimal bacterium.     

Electron microscope heteroduplex studies of sequence relations among plasmids of Escherichia coli. IV. The F sequences in F14

The structure of F14, in particular the arrangement of the F sequences on this plasmid, has been studied by the electron microscope heteroduplex method. F14 has a molecular size of 311 ± 10 kilobase pairs (M = (206 ± 8) × 10⁶daltons). It contains all of F (94.5 kilobases). A sequence of length 5.7 kilobases, which occurs once in F (with co-ordinates 2.8 to 8.5F), is directly repeated in F14. It occurs at the two junctions of F DNA with chromosomal DNA. Thus, F14 contains about 211 ± 10 kilobases of chromosomal DNA. A previously unidentified direct repeat has also been discovered on F itself; the sequence with co-ordinates 93.2 to 94.5F is directly repeated at 13.7 to 15.0F. Physical observations indicate that the population of closed circular plasmid molecules extracted from F14-containing strains is heterogeneous. In addition to F14 itself, molecules the size of F and 2.3 times the size of F were found. The latter molecules contain all the chromosomal sequences of F14 and one copy of the 2.8 to 8.5F segment. Such heterogeneity was observed in both recA^? and recA⁺ backgrounds. It is proposed that this heterogeneity is due to intramolecular recombination events occurring within F14 between the duplicated 2.8 to 8.5F sequences. Such recombination can account for the previously observed genetic instability of F14. Another F prime plasmid, F186, independently isolated from the Hfr parent of AB313, was found to be identical to F14.     

Cloning of theHelicobacter pylori recA gene and functional characterization of its product

The RecA protein is a key enzyme involved in DNA recombination in bacteria. Using a polymerase chain reaction (PCR) amplification we cloned arecA homolog fromHelicobacter pylori. The gene revealed an open reading frame (ORF) encoding a putative protein of 37.6 kDa showing closest homology to theCampylobacter jejuni RecA (75.5% identity). A putative ribosome binding site and a near-consensus σ⁷⁰ promoter sequence was found upstream ofrec A. A second ORF, encoding a putative protein with N-terminal sequence homology to prokaryotic and eukaryotic enolases, is located directly downstream ofrecA. Compared to the wild-type strains, isogenicH. pylori recA deletion mutants of strains 69A and NCTC11637 displayed increased sensitivity to ultraviolet light and abolished general homologous recombination. The recombinantH. pylori RecA protein produced inEscherichia coli strain GC6 (recA ^?) was 38 kDa in size but inactive in DNA repair, whereas the corresponding protein inH. pylori 69A migrated at the greater apparent molecular weight of approx. 40 kDa in SDS-polyacrylamide gels. However, complementation of theH. pylori mutant using the clonedrecA gene on a shuttle vector resulted in a RecA protein of the original size and fully restored the general functions of the enzyme. These data can be best explained by a modification of RecA inH. pylori which is crucial for its function. The potential modification seems not to occur when the protein is produced inE. coli, giving rise to a smaller but inactive protein.     

Suppression of Repeat-Mediated Gross Mitochondrial Genome Rearrangements by RecA in the Moss Physcomitrella patens

RecA and its ubiquitous homologs are crucial components in homologous recombination. Besides their eukaryotic nuclear counterparts, plants characteristically possess several bacterial-type RecA proteins localized to chloroplasts and/or mitochondria, but their roles are poorly understood. Here, we analyzed the role of the only mitochondrial RecA in the moss Physcomitrella patens. Disruption of the P. patens mitochondrial recA gene RECA1 caused serious defects in plant growth and development and abnormal mitochondrial morphology. Analyses of mitochondrial DNA in disruptants revealed that frequent DNA rearrangements occurred at multiple loci. Structural analysis suggests that the rearrangements, which in some cases were associated with partial deletions and amplifications of mitochondrial DNA, were due to aberrant recombination between short (<100 bp) direct and inverted repeats in which the sequences were not always identical. Such repeats are abundant in the mitochondrial genome, and interestingly many are located in group II introns. These results suggest that RECA1 does not promote but rather suppresses recombination among short repeats scattered throughout the mitochondrial genome, thereby maintaining mitochondrial genome stability. We propose that RecA-mediated homologous recombination plays a crucial role in suppression of short repeat-mediated genome rearrangements in plant mitochondria.     

Molecular mechanisms of deletion formation in Escherichia coli plasmids. I. Deletion formation mediated by long direct repeats.

Summary Derivatives of plasmid pBR327 with the tet gene interrupted by 165 pb or 401 by direct repeats were constructed. In cells harboring these plasmids, deletions which restored the wild-type tet gene gave rise to tetracycline-resistant colonies, thereby allowing a simple phenotypic test for deletion formation. The frequencies of deletions in these plasmids were measured in Escherichia coli strains proficient or deficient in general recombination. The structure of plasmid DNA isolated from tetracycline-resistant transformants was analyzed by agarose gel electrophoresis, restriction mapping and sequencing. The data presented here demonstrate that deletion formation is always associated with dimerization of plasmid DNA. Dimeric plasmids were of two types. Those which carried both a deletion and a compensating duplication were the major type in a Rec⁺ background and were rare in recA, recF, recJ and recO backgrounds. Dimers of the second type contained deletions, but no compensating duplications, and their formation was RecA-independent. The data presented demonstrate that deletion formation mediated by long direct repeats is mainly the result of unequal crossing-over between two plasmid molecules.     

Mutator Phenotype Induced by Aberrant Replication

We have identified thermosensitive mutants of five Schizosaccharomyces pombe replication proteins that have a mutator phenotype at their semipermissive temperatures. Allele-specific mutants of DNA polymerase δ (polδ) and mutants of Polα, two Polδ subunits, and ligase exhibited increased rates of deletion of sequences flanked by short direct repeats. Deletion of rad2⁺, which encodes a nuclease involved in processing Okazaki fragments, caused an increased rate of duplication of sequences flanked by short direct repeats. The deletion mutation rates of all the thermosensitive replication mutators decreased in a rad2Δ background, suggesting that deletion formation requires Rad2 function. The duplication mutation rate of rad2Δ was also reduced in a thermosensitive polymerase background, but not in a ligase mutator background, which suggests that formation of duplication mutations requires normal DNA polymerization. Thus, although the deletion and duplication mutator phenotypes are distinct, their mutational mechanisms are interdependent. The deletion and duplication replication mutators all exhibited decreased viability in combination with deletion of a checkpoint Rad protein, Rad26. Interestingly, deletion of Cds1, a protein kinase functioning in a checkpoint Rad-mediated reversible S-phase arrest pathway, decreased the viability and exacerbated the mutation rate only in the thermosensitive deletion replication mutators but had no effect on rad2Δ. These findings suggest that aberrant replication caused by allele-specific mutations of these replication proteins can accumulate potentially mutagenic DNA structures. The checkpoint Rad-mediated pathways monitor and signal the aberrant replication in both the deletion and duplication mutators, while Cds1 mediates recovery from aberrant replication and prevents formation of deletion mutations specifically in the thermosensitive deletion replication mutators.     

Effect of lig-7 on strand joining in repair of damaged DNA and on cutting of intact homologous DNA (cutting in trans) in Escherichia coli

Genetic recombination in Escherichia coli depends on the recA⁺ gene and can be increased in frequency by certain treatments that damage DNA. In previous studies (Ross &; Howard-Flanders, 1977a,b), E. coli (λ) cells were infected with undamaged λ phages and then with λ phages that were either undamaged, or had interstrand crosslinks produced in their DNA by treatment with psoralen and light. When the superinfecting DNA contained psoralen crosslinks, the intact DNA was cut. This cutting, referred to as cutting in trans, occurred only in DNA genetically homologous to the damaged DNA, required recA⁺ and behaved as expected of a step in damage-induced genetic recombination.In the present studies, we investigated the effect on cutting in trans of lig-7, a thermosensitive allele of the structural gene for E. coli polynucleotide ligase and also of uvrA, which controls the excision of damaged bases from DNA. The ligase deficiency caused gaps due to the action of the uvrA⁺ endonuclease on damaged DNA to remain open for at least 25 minutes. For low levels of damage, cutting in trans was also enhanced in the lig-7 cells at non-permissive temperatures but was not increased in wild-type cells. The enhanced cutting in trans depended upon genetic homology, as expected if it reflected elevated levels of damage-induced genetic recombination. Presumably, the unrepaired gaps in the damaged DNA made it a good substrate for the enzymes that promote cutting in trans of its homologs.     

Inverted repeats as genetic elements for promoting DNA inverted duplication: implications in gene amplification

Inverted repeats are important genetic elements for genome instability. In the current study we have investigated the role of inverted repeats in a DNA rearrangement reaction using a linear DNA substrate. We show that linear DNA substrates with terminal inverted repeats can efficiently transform Escherichia coli. The transformation products contain circular inverted dimers in which the DNA sequences between terminal inverted repeats are duplicated. In contrast to the recombination/rearrangement product of circular DNA substrates, which is exclusively one particular form of the inverted dimer, the rearrangement products of the linear DNA substrate consist of two isomeric forms of the inverted dimer. Escherichia coli mutants defective in RecBCD exhibit much reduced transformation efficiency, suggesting a role for RecBCD in the protection rather than destruction of these linear DNA substrates. These results suggest a model in which inverted repeats near the ends of a double-strand break can be processed by a helicase/exonuclease to form hairpin caps. Processing of hairpin capped DNA intermediates can then yield inverted duplications. Linear DNA substrates containing terminal inverted repeats can also be converted into inverted dimers in COS cells, suggesting conservation of this type of genome instability from bacteria to mammalian cells.     

Gene sequence of recA + and construction of recA mutants of Vibrio cholerae

The recA ⁺ gene of Vibrio cholerae O1 has been cloned, its nucleotide sequence determined and the product characterized. A deletion mutation was constructed in the recA gene and mutants showed the typical sensitivity to UV and to DNA-damaging agents, as well as an inability to mediate homologous DNA recombination. The chromosomal recA deletion mutants in V. cholerae do not show altered virulence in the infant mouse cholera model and are thus ideal strains for use in complementation studies.