The fundamental T cell proliferative repertoire in a nonresponder strain and its qualitative alteration by suppression

B10 mice, although genetically nonresponsive to hen egg-white lysozyme (HEL) after i.p. immunization due to suppressor T cells, make a vigorous helper and proliferative T cell response in the draining popliteal lymph nodes (P-LN) soon after footpad immunization with HEL. The fundamental specificity repertoire in B10 P-LN analyzed with cross-reactive lysozymes, was then compared with that found after the delayed appearance of suppression, in the PETLES. In contrast with B10.A mice, whose T cell specificity pattern was unchanged with time, or anatomical site, the onset of HEL-induced suppression in B10 mice led to a marked heteroreactive shift in specificity pattern. This shift did not occur after immunization with REL (ring-necked pheasant lysozyme), which fails to induce suppression.     

MHC-linked immune response suppression mediated by T cells bearing I-A-encoded determinants

The immune response to chicken egg-white lysozyme (HEL) is actively and specifically regulated by antigen-specific T cell-mediated suppression in mice bearing the H-2b haplotype; the suppression is therefore MHC-linked. In this report, we propose a possible mechanism for MHC-linked suppression of HEL-helper T cells based on expression of I region-encoded cell surface determinants. We determined whether inhibition of anti-HEL antibody responses correlated with expression of serologically detectable I-A-encoded cell surface determinants by antigen-specific helper, suppressor-inducer, or suppressor-effector T cells. It was observed that HEL-suppressor-effector T cells, but not helper or suppressor-inducer T cells, were eliminated after treatment with anti-I-Ab antibody and complement. Furthermore, suppressor-effector T cells co-express Thy-1, Lyt-2, and I-A cell surface antigens. These results raise the possibility that HEL-specific helper T cells become functionally inhibited after recognition of HEL and I-A alloantigen displayed by suppressor-effector T cells. Thus, the interaction between helper and suppressor T cells may be analogous to the mechanism of T cell-B cell interaction.     

Immunoregulation of lysozyme-specific suppression. III. Epitope-specific amplification of immunosuppression induced by monoclonal suppressor-T-cell products

The hen egg-white lysozyme (HEL)-specific suppression induced by soluble molecules produced by a monoclonal T-cell lymphoma line (LH8-105) obtained from HEL-specific suppressor T lymphocytes has been examined. Injection of I-J+ molecules from LH8-105 cell culture supernatant (TsFa) in HEL-primed mice during the afferent phase of the response induced Lyt-2+ second order suppressor T (Ts) cells which, upon transfer into HEL-CFA-primed syngeneic recipients, inhibit the delayed-type hypersensitivity (DTH) response to HEL. Transfer of spleen cells from TsFa-injected mice primed with HEL or human lysozyme suppresses the DTH response to HEL in recipient mice whereas this response is not affected by cell transfer from ring-necked pheasant egg-white lysozyme (REL)-primed and TsFa-injected mice, indicating that induction of second order Ts by TsFa is specific for a lysozyme epitope including phenylalanine at position 3. Fine antigenic specificity of second order Ts-cell induction is confirmed by similar results obtained upon injection of TsFa in mice primed with HEL N-terminal synthetic peptide or with an analog in which, as in REL, phenylalanine has been substituted by tyrosine at position 3. The same fine antigenic specificity observed in the induction of second order Ts cells is also present in the expression of TsFe suppressive activity. The similar antigenic specificity of Tsa and Tse suggests that Tse cells could result from amplification of the Tsa cell population or these two cell subsets could reflect different maturation stages of the same cell type rather than distinct T-cell populations activated in cascade.     

Suppression of the delayed-type hypersensitivity response to hen egg white lysozyme (HEL) by HEL peptides in a genetically high-responder mouse strain: evidence for requirement of the loop structure for induction of suppressor T cells

The delayed-type hypersensitivity (DTH) response of C3H/HeN mice to hen egg white lysozyme (HEL) can be blocked by a single iv injection of a solution of HEL in buffered saline 7 days before sensitization of animals with HEL in complete Freund's adjuvant (CFA). The minimal structure of HEL required for the suppression was examined by determining the abilities of various HEL-derivative peptides to inhibit HEL-DTH. Treatment of normal mice with Ploop I X II, sequence 57-107 (Cys64-Cys80, Cys76-Cys94), or P17 (sequences 1-27 and 123-129 linked by Cys6-Cys127) 7 days before immunization with HEL resulted in marked suppression of the DTH response. This inhibition of DTH involved generation of suppressor T cells (Ts). The results suggested that two suppressor pathways are involved. These data, together with another recent finding (1) that an entirely different portion of HEL is a suppressor determinant (SD) in A/J mice, indicate that different epitopes act as SDs in different strains of mice. Of the loop region peptides tested, Plc (intact loop I joined to a linear peptide, residues 84-97) was found to be the minimum structure capable of suppressing the HEL-DTH response; loop I or II alone did not cause suppression. Activation of Ts cells by the loop peptide depended on its conformational structure; completely reduced and carboxymethylated Ploop I X II did not cause suppression.     

Helper T cell interactions.

Studies of the relationship between carrier-primed helper T cell dose and the antibody response to a hapten on that carrier reveal evidence for two synergistic T helper cells. One of these two T cells is absent in agammaglobulinemic mice. This finding is not due to suppression; instead, T helper cells from these mice interact synergistically with T helper cells from normal mice, as would be predicted if two populations of cells are present in normal mice, while only one is present in the agammaglobulinemic mice. These findings, taken together with studies in similar systems, suggest that one of the two T helper cells recognizes immunoglobulin on B cells, while the other is specific for carrier. It remains to be determined whether both cells show the phenomenon of major histocompatibility complex restriction, or whether this a property of one of the cells only. It is also not clear whether the Ig-recognizing T cell is also carrier specific, or whether its apparent carrier specificity in this system reflects an ability of the carrier to bring together Ig and an I region gene product into a unique configuration on the B cell surface.     

Features of KLH-induced suppression in vivo: Characterization of two pathways of suppression

Keyhole limpet hemocyanin (KLH) given at high dose (4 mg ip) in mice induced a state of unresponsiveness related to the activation of suppressor T cells. An early pathway of suppression is observed within the first 24 hr following KLH injection and is characterized by its cyclophosphamide (CPM) sensitivity and by the specificity of its effector phase, at the level of KLH helper T cells. A late pathway of suppression occurs at Day 3 following KLH injection and is characterized by its CPM resistance and the nonspecificity of its effector phase acting at the B-cell level. Indeed the anti-FLu antibody response to FLu Ovalbumin or thymus-independent antigen FLu LPS were found altered when these antigens were given with TNP KLH. These two pathways of suppression were found to last 8 months. These results suggest that KLH can trigger in an independent manner two pathways of suppression characterized by different CPM sensitivity and different target cells.     

Role of Ly-1:Qa1- and Ly-1:Qa1+ inducer T cells in activation of Ly-23 effectors of suppression of antibody production in mice

Ly-2+ effectors of T cell-mediated suppression require inducing signals from antigen and a helper cell bearing the Ly-1+:Qa1+ surface phenotype. In this report, we have further examined the helper cell requirements for suppressor cell induction of antibody production in mice. By using the T cell subset education procedure in vitro, we have activated T cells to sheep red blood cells (SRBC) antigens and then purified Ly-2 cells before testing for suppressor activity in assay cultures of defined T and B cell subsets. We have confirmed our previous observations that Ly-1+:Qa1+ cells are required for activation of T suppressors, but have found that under the appropriate conditions, there is not a strict requirement for the Ly-123 subset of T cells. Furthermore, if Ly-23 cells are stimulated in the presence of Ly-1+:Qa1- T cells, effective suppressors can be obtained only if a source of Ly-1:Qa1+ inducers is added to the assay culture. If Ly-23 cells are activated by antigen in the absence of Ly-1 cells, subsequent exposure to the Ly-1+:Qa1+ subset under the conditions tested here is not sufficient to activate suppressors. These results show that effectors of suppression, like B cells and cytotoxic T lymphocytes, may respond to two helper cells.     

Analysis of the negative allogeneic effect using B cells and helper T cell lines as an indicator system: B cells identified as target cells for suppression

The target cells for H-2b T lymphocytes mediating a negative allogeneic effect in vitro were analyzed by using carrier-specific helper T cell lines of H-2b, H-2d, or F1 origin and hapten-primed T-depleted spleen cells also expressing one or both of these haplotypes. The helper T cell lines were shown to be carrier specific and H-2b or H-2d restricted. Most importantly, the lines derived from H-2b homozygous mice were devoid of alloreactivity against H-2d and vice versa. Titration of naive H-2b T lymphocytes to the indicator cultures resulted in suppression of the secondary anti-DNP response of the indicator cells whenever the B cells expressed H-2d antigens. The lack of suppression observed in mixtures in which only the helper T cell lines expressed H-2d antigens was not reversed by the increased addition of naive H-2bxd cells, indicating that an insufficient amount of H-2d antigens present on the low number of helper T cells used did not account for this finding. Moreover, the polyclonal plaque-forming cell responses of F1 spleen cells to LPS were also suppressed by naive parental T cells. From these findings it is concluded that the suppressor T cells directly recognize and inhibit allogeneic B cells without the involvement of helper T cells. In addition, it was shown that the suppression of secondary anti-hapten responses by naive allogeneic T cells is blocked by monoclonal anti-Lyt-2 antibody added at the onset of culture. Addition late in culture had no effect, pointing to a functional role of the Lyt-2-bearing structure at an early stage of the suppressive events resulting in the negative allogeneic effect.     

Cellular interactions of L-glutamic acid60-L-alanine30-L-tyrosine10 (GAT)-specific suppressor factors. I. Inhibition of the activity of GAT-specific helper T cell clones by monoclonal GAT-specific suppressor T cell factors

Considerable information concerning the serology and biochemistry of antigen-specific, T cell-derived suppressor factors has been obtained with the use of T cell hybridomas as a source of homogeneous material. Similarly, knowledge of helper T cell products and receptors is accumulating from studies of helper T cell clones and hybridomas. Our strategy for studying the mechanisms by which suppressor factors inhibit responses was to determine whether monoclonal suppressor factors could inhibit antibody responses specific for L-glutamic acid60-L-alanine30-L-tyrosine10 (GAT) in cultures containing unprimed splenic B cells, macrophages, and GAT-specific T cell clones as a source of helper activity. The MHC-restricted, two chain suppressor factors, GAT-TsF2, inhibited these responses if the helper T cell clones and suppressor factor were derived from H-2-compatible mice. Furthermore, responses were inhibited by briefly pulsing T cell clones with GAT-TsF2 in the presence of GAT, indicating that suppressor factors need not be present continuously. In addition, helper T cell clones adsorbed syngeneic, but not allogeneic, GAT-TsF2 in the presence of GAT. Adsorption also requires a shared antigenic specificity between the H-2b-derived helper T cells and TsF2 factor. Thus, helper T cells can serve as the cellular target of antigen-specific, MHC-restricted GAT-TsF2, and cloned helper T cells can be used as a homogeneous target population for analysis of the molecular mechanisms of T cell suppression.     

Antigen-specific T helper clones in a nonresponder strain require augmentation for expression of helper activity. Evidence for a possible antigen presentation defect in B cells

Hen egg-white lysozyme (HEL)-specific Thy-1+, Lyt-1+2- T cell lines and clones were derived from the nonresponder C57BL/6 strain. Although the antigen-specific proliferative response of these T cells in the presence of syngeneic irradiated spleen cells as a source of antigen-presenting cells (APC) was normal, the same cells were incapable of stimulating B cells to secrete antibody in vitro. This deficiency could, however, be corrected by the addition of an excess of normal T cells or a supernatant from concanavalin A-stimulated rat spleen cells. Alternatively, the use of highly cross-reactive ring-necked pheasant lysozyme in the cultures allowed expression of efficient help, ruling out any inherent deficiency in the T cells. The antibody response was specific and required MHC compatibility between the T lines and responding B cells. By using (H-2b X H-2d)F1 B cells and another H-2d-restricted HEL-specific T line, it was shown that only the H-2b-restricted T-B collaboration required exogenous factors, and the H-2d-restricted collaboration did not. Because both proliferative and helper responses are dependent upon MHC-restricted antigen presentation by macrophage-APC and B cells, respectively, these results suggest that the defect in the nonresponder H-2b-restricted T-B collaborative pathway may relate to the inability of B cells to adequately process and present HEL to clonal T cells.     

Regulation of B cell maturation and differentiation. I. Suppression of pokeweed mitogen-induced B cell differentiation by tumor necrosis factor (TNF)

Growth and differentiation of B cells into Ig-secreting plasma cells is regulated by both T cells and macrophages and/or their secreted factors. Although the regulatory role of various cell-derived factors has been examined, the involvement of the macrophage-derived factor, TNF, in human B cell growth and differentiation has not yet been investigated. In the present study we examine the role of rTNF in polyclonal B cell response of human PBL induced by PWM. The addition of rTNF at the initiation of the culture resulted in the dose-dependent inhibition of the generation of both IgG and IgM PFC. Inhibition of PFC development followed the same dose response as rTNF-mediated cytotoxicity against a TNF-sensitive tumor target. The mechanism of rTNF-mediated suppression was examined in different experimental systems. Recombinant TNF did not affect the viability or proliferation of either the T cell or B cell subpopulations, suggesting that TNF does not mediate its suppressive effect by cytotoxic mechanisms. Kinetic studies in which rTNF was added at different times after initiation of culture indicated that inhibition can be observed as late as 4 days of culture and suggested that TNF acts at a late phase of the growth and differentiation pathway of B cells. In further studies we examined the cellular level of TNF-mediated suppression. The addition of rTNF to supernatants containing helper factors and enriched B cells resulted in no inhibition, suggesting that TNF does not act at the B cell level. This was confirmed by demonstrating that rTNF does not inhibit spontaneous PFC development by the CESS B cell line. The effect of TNF on T cell subpopulations was examined by using normal or irradiated T cells, which inactivate suppressor cells. Addition of rTNF to B cells combined with either T cell population suppressed both IgG and IgM PFC development, indicating that the target cell for suppression is the T helper cell but not ruling out an effect on macrophages or the T suppressor cells. Combined, the observed results demonstrate that rTNF suppresses PWM-induced B cell differentiation without affecting B cell proliferation. TNF appears to mediate the suppression by acting directly on T helper cells or else by regulating the production of factors controlling T cell activation and lymphokine secretion.     

The surprising kinetics of the T cell response to live antigenic cells

Cooperation between CD4(+) and CD8(+) T cells is required for the proper development of primary effector and memory CD8(+) T cells following immunization with noninflammatory immunogens. In this study, we characterized murine CD4(+) and CD8(+) T cell responses to male-specific minor histocompatibility (HY) Ags following injection of live male cells into females of the same strain. Male cells are rejected 10-12 days after transfer, coinciding with the expansion and effector function of CD8(+) CTLs to two H-2D(b)-restricted epitopes. Although anti-HY CD4(+) T cell responses are readily detectable day 5 posttransfer, CD8(+) responses are undetectable until day 10. The early CD4(+) response is not dependent on direct presentation of Ag by donor male cells, but depends on presentation of the male cells by recipient APC. The CD4(+) T cell response is required for the priming of CD8(+) T cell effector responses and rejection of HY-incompatible cells. Unexpectedly, HY-specific CD4(+) T cells are also capable of efficiently lysing target cells in vivo. The delay in the CD8(+) T cell response can be largely abrogated by depleting T cells from the male inoculum, and donor male CD8(+) T cells in particular suppress host anti-HY CD8(+) responses. These data demonstrate dramatic differences in host T cell responses to noninflammatory Ags compared with responses to pathogens. We explain the delayed CD8(+) response by proposing that there is a balance between cross-presentation of Ag by helper cell-licensed dendritic cells, on the one hand, and veto suppression by live male lymphocytes on the other.     

Effects of deoxycoformycin in mice. I. Suppression and enhancement of in vivo antibody responses to thymus-dependent and -independent antigens

The effect of 2'-deoxycoformycin (DCF) on the PFC responses of AKR mice to SE, TNP-Ficoll, and TNP-B. abortus was examined. Subcutaneous injection of DCF 4 days before antigen caused suppression of all three responses by 70 to 78%. In contrast, injection of DCF 1 day after antigen caused enhancement of both the anti-SE and the anti-TNP-Ficoll responses. Although a single high dose of cortisone acetate injected 4 days before antigen caused a similar suppression, the effect of DCF was not mediated via a steroid release, inasmuch as DCF also suppressed the immune response in adrenalectomized mice. The response of BALB/c mice to TNP-Ficoll was also inhibited by DCF pretreatment and enhanced by injection of DCF after antigen. In contrast, in athymic mice DCF caused suppression of the anti-TNP-Ficoll PFC response, whether injected before or after antigen. These results are interpreted as suggesting that DCF causes suppression primarily via an effect on B cells. The enhancement seen in normal but not in athymic mice may possibly be ascribed to an effect on suppressor T cells. Apparently the enhancement of both TD and TI responses caused by DCF injected 1 day after antigen in normal mice is the net result of these two opposing effects. The results imply that helper T cells are resistant to DCF.     

The helper and suppressor functions of primate T cells elicited by a 185K streptococcal antigen, as compared with the helper function elicited by a 4K streptococcal antigen

Helper and suppressor functions of human T lymphocytes that act on antibody-forming B cells were elicited by a large 185K streptococcal cell wall antigen. However, a small 4K streptococcal peptide elicited helper but no suppressor function. These differences in the functional activities of the large and small m.w. streptococcal antigens (SA) were confirmed by direct immunisation of rhesus monkeys with the 185K-SA and 4K-SA. Sequential studies have shown that whereas the 185K-SA elicits dose-dependent helper and suppressor activities, the 4K-SA elicits only helper function. Cell-depletion studies with human cells suggest that removal of T8+ cells by killing with OK.T8 and complement leads to a loss of suppressor and a broadening in the concentration of 185K-SA, which elicits helper activity. Because the 4K-SA does not elicit suppression, removal of T8+ cells does not affect this function. However, similar depletion of T4+ cells results in loss of the helper activities, both with the 185K-SA and 4K-SA, and again a broadening in the concentration of the 185K-SA, which elicits suppression. Direct comparison by autoradiography between 125I-labeled 185K-SA and 4K-SA suggests that both antigens can bind directly to monocytes or T8+ VV+ cells. Furthermore, both antigens can induce helper function if T4+ cells are reconstituted with either monocytes or T8+ VV+ cells. Attempts will now be made to sequence the amino acid determinants of the 185K-SA, so as to define the epitopes responsible for the two major regulating functions elicited by this antigen.     

An analysis of B cell memory. I. Interaction of helper and suppressor effects in the in vitro expression of IgM memory.

The pfc response of Srbc primed IgM memory cells has been characterized by limiting dilution analysis in vitro, in which LPS was used to maximize the response of spleen cells to Srbc. The analysis suggested that, even under these conditions, expression of B cell memory was not directly assayed and cell collaboration effects were still basic to the system.Two types of cells, as defined by function, appeared necessary to elicit optimal clonal proliferation of IgM B memory cells: firstly, helper T cells were essential for B cell proliferation even with LPS present in culture. Under appropriate conditions, helper activity could be provided by normal thymus cells. Secondly, activated T cells were required for the maximal conversion of normal thymus cells to helper cells. A third activity, T cell-dependent suppression, was observed at high cell doses. The implications of these results and the need for a comprehensive analysis of in vitro conditions for each individual type of experiment is discussed.     

Insulin-specific tolerance induction. II. Tolerant helper T cells can be rescued by insulin complexed to Brucella abortus

Murine antibody responses to heterologous insulins are under H-2-linked immune response (Ir) gene control. We previously demonstrated that the immune response to insulin in Freund's complete adjuvant (CFA) can be specifically inhibited by prior injection of soluble insulin i.v. Unresponsiveness requires at least 4 days after i.v. injection to develop, and once induced, it lasts 4 wk or more. Unresponsiveness is caused by T cell, but not B cell, tolerance; furthermore, we have been unable to demonstrate any role for suppressor T cells in this unresponsiveness. The following experiments examine the nature of the T cell tolerance induced by i.v. injection of insulin, and the data suggest that helper T cells were not clonally deleted by this procedure. The functional activity of the tolerized T cells can be rescued by stimulation with insulin covalently complexed to the type 1 T-independent (TI-1) antigen, Brucella abortus. This observation suggests that tolerance induced by soluble insulin is due to clonal anergy rather than clonal deletion of helper T cells; thus, this system could provide a model for determining the cellular events involved in tolerance induction and reversal in helper T cells.     

Expression of human cytomegalovirus immediate early antigens is responsible for a novel chromatin structure of infected human embryonic lung cells

Whereas human embryonic lung (HEL) cells displayed chromatin fibers composed of a repeat of conventional nucleosomes of 15 nm in diameter, human cytomegalovirus (HCMV) infection induced transient appearance of a novel chromatin structure composed of a repeat of large ellipsoids of 45-65 nm X 15-30 nm with linkers of 50-60 nm long and 6-7 nm thick. Essentially the same change in chromatin structure could be induced when uninfected HEL cell nuclei were incubated in vitro with a 0.4 M NaCl nuclear extract from HCMV-infected HEL cells expressing immediate early antigens (IEA's) or with a similar nuclear extract from NIH/3T3 cells constitutively expressing HCMV IEA's. The latter cell line was established by transformation of the mouse cells with a plasmid carrying the HCMV major immediate early and immediate early 2 genes. These results together with those of control experiments suggest that the expression of IEA's is directly or indirectly responsible for the appearance of the novel chromatin structure in HCMV-infected HEL cells.     

Macrophage T lymphocyte interactions in the anti-tumor immune response: a mathematical model

In this paper we present a model of the macrophage T lymphocyte interactions that generate an anti-tumor immune response. The model specifies i) induction of cytotoxic T lymphocytes, ii) antigen presentation by macrophages, which leads to iii) activation of helper T cells, and iv) production of lymphoid factors, which induce a) cytotoxic macrophages, b) T lymphocyte proliferation, and c) an inflammation reaction. Tumor escape mechanisms (suppression, antigenic heterogeneity) have been deliberately omitted from the model. This research combines hitherto unrelated or even contradictory data within the range of behavior of one model. In the model behavior, helper T cells play a crucial role: Tumors that differ minimally in antigenicity (i.e., helper reactivity) can differ markedly in rejectability. Immunization yields protection against tumor doses that would otherwise be lethal, because it increases the number of helper T cells. The magnitude of the cytotoxic effector cell response depends on the time at which helper T cells become activated: early helper activity steeply increases the magnitude of the immune response. The type of cytotoxic effector cells that eradicates the tumor depends on tumor antigenicity: lowly antigenic tumors are attacked mainly by macrophages, whereas large highly antigenic tumors can be eradicated by cytotoxic T lymphocytes only.     

Stimulation of mouse lymphocytes by a mitogen derived from Mycoplasma arthritidis. IV. Murine T hybridoma cells exhibit differential accessory cell requirements for activation by M. arthritidis T cell mitogen, concanavalin A, or hen egg-white lysozyme

A T-cell mitogen present in culture supernatants of Mycoplasma arthritidis (MAS) is known to exhibit an absolute dependence on E alpha-bearing accessory cells (AC), which appear to function by binding the mitogen. We therefore compared the specificity and nature of the AC requirements for MAS and antigen-induced production of IL 2 in T hybridoma cell lines originating from a fusion by using hen egg-white lysozyme (HEL)-specific, H-2d-restricted T blasts. A marked specificity was noted in the ability of the hybridoma lines to become activated by Con A, MAS, or HEL antigen. Thus all three lines produced IL 2 in response to Con A without the addition of B lymphoma AC. Two lines responded to MAS, but only in the presence of AC, and only one line responded to HEL antigen in the presence of AC. Using the HEL responsive T hybridoma line, we demonstrated that disrupted AC and AC membranes could present MAS but not HEL. MAS rapidly associated with AC at 4 degrees C, whereas HEL failed to do so. Paraformaldehyde-fixed AC could absorb the mitogen in MAS and present it to T hybridoma cells within several minutes, whereas HEL antigen could only be presented by fixed AC if there was a prolonged period of incubation (greater than 30 min) at 37 degrees C before fixation. The combined data indicate that metabolically active cells are not required for the association of MAS with AC or for presentation of MAS to T hybridomas. In contrast, HEL antigen requires metabolically active cells for both of these processes. Thus, the mitogen in MAS can bind to AC without any processing requirements, and it is likely that the resulting complex of mitogen and Ia molecules can directly activate T hybridoma cells.