Potato spindle tuber viroid strains of different pathogenicity induces and suppresses expression of common and unique genes in infected tomato

Viroids are the smallest plant pathogens. These RNAs do not encode proteins and are not encapsidated, and yet they can replicate autonomously, move systemically, and cause diseases in infected plants. Notably, strains of a viroid with subtle differences in nucleotide sequences can cause dramatically different symptoms in infected plants. These features make viroids unique probes to investigate the role of a pathogenic RNA genome in triggering host responses. We conducted a comprehensive analysis of the differential gene expression patterns of tomato plants at various stages of infection by a mild and severe strain of Potato spindle tuber viroid (PSTVd). We also compared tomato gene expression altered by the PSTVd strains with that altered by Tobacco mosaic virus (TMV). Our analyses revealed that the two PSTVd strains altered expression of both common and unique tomato genes. These genes encode products involved in defense/stress response, cell wall structure, chloroplast function, protein metabolism, and other diverse functions. Five genes have unknown functions. Four genes are novel. The expression of some but not all of these genes was also altered by TMV infection. Our results indicate that viroids, although structurally simple, can trigger complex host responses. Further characterization of viroid-altered gene expression in a host plant should help understand viroid pathogenicity and, potentially, the mechanisms of RNA-mediated regulation of plant gene expression.     

Virp1 is a host protein with a major role in Potato spindle tuber viroid infection in Nicotiana plants

Viroids are small, circular, single-stranded RNA molecules that, while not coding for any protein, cause several plant diseases. Viroids rely for their infectious cycle on host proteins, most of which are likely to be involved in endogenous RNA-mediated phenomena. Therefore, characterization of host factors interacting with the viroid may contribute to the elucidation of RNA-related pathways of the hosts. Potato spindle tuber viroid (PSTVd) infects several members of the Solanaceae family. In an RNA ligand screening we have previously isolated the tomato protein Virp1 by its ability to specifically interact with PSTVd positive-strand RNA. Virp1 is a bromodomain-containing protein with an atypical RNA binding domain and a nuclear localization signal. Here we investigate the role of Virp1 in the viroid infection cycle by the use of transgenic lines of Nicotiana tabacum and Nicotiana benthamiana that either overexpress the tomato Virp1 RNA or suppress the orthologous Nicotiana genes through RNA silencing. Plants of the Virp1-suppressed lines were not infected by PSTVd or Citrus exocortis viroid through mechanical inoculation, indicating a major role of Virp1 in viroid infection. On the other hand, overexpression of tomato Virp1 in N. tabacum and N. benthamiana plants did not affect PSTVd KF 440-2 infectivity or symptomatology in these species. Transfection experiments with isolated protoplasts revealed that Virp1-suppressed cells were unable to sustain viroid replication, suggesting that resistance to viroid infection in Virp1-suppressed plants is likely the result of cell-autonomous events.     

Potato spindle tuber viroid: the simplicity paradox resolved?

Taxonomy:   Potato spindle tuber viroid (PSTVd) is the type species of the genus Posipiviroid , family Pospiviroidae . An absence of hammerhead ribozymes and the presence of a 'central conserved region' distinguish PSTVd and related viroids from members of a second viroid family, the Avsunviroidae .
Physical properties:   Viroids are small, unencapsidated, circular, single-stranded RNA molecules which replicate autonomously when inoculated into host plants. Because viroids are non-protein-coding RNAs, designation of the more abundant, highly infectious polarity strand as the positive strand is arbitrary. PSTVd assumes a rod-like, highly structured conformation that is resistant to nuclease degradation in vitro . Naturally occurring sequence variants of PSTVd range in size from 356 to 361 nt.
Hosts and symptoms:   The natural host range of PSTVd—cultivated potato, certain other Solanum spp., and avocado—appears to be quite limited. Foliar symptoms in potato are often obscure, and the severity of tuber symptoms (elongation with the appearance of prominent bud scales/eyebrows and growth cracks) depends on both temperature and length of infection. PSTVd has a broad experimental host range, especially among solanaceous species, and strains are classified as mild, intermediate or severe based upon the symptoms observed in sensitive tomato cultivars. These symptoms include shortening of internodes, petioles and mid-ribs, severe epinasty and wrinkling of the leaves, and necrosis of mid-ribs, petioles and stems.     

Scion on a Stock Producing siRNAs of Potato Spindle Tuber Viroid (PSTVd) Attenuates Accumulation of the Viroid

Plants can attenuate the replication of plant viruses and viroids by RNA silencing induced by virus and viroid infection. In higher plants, silencing signals such as small interfering RNAs (siRNAs) produced by RNA silencing can be transported systemically through phloem, so it is anticipated that antiviral siRNA signals produced in a stock would have the potential to attenuate propagation of viruses or viroids in the scion. To test whether this is indeed the case, we prepared transgenic tobacco (Nicotiana benthamiana) expressing a hairpin RNA (hpRNA) of Potato spindle tuber viroid (PSTVd) in companion cells by using a strong companion cell-specific promoter. A grafting experiment of the wild type tobacco scion on the top of the transgenic tobacco stock revealed that accumulation of PSTVd challenge-inoculated into the scion was apparently attenuated compared to the control grafted plants. These results indicate that genetically modified rootstock expressing viroid-specific siRNAs can attenuate viroid accumulation in a non-genetically modified scion grafted on the stock.     

Inhibition of cell growth and shoot development by a specific nucleotide sequence in a noncoding viroid RNA

Viroids are small noncoding and infectious RNAs that replicate autonomously and move systemically throughout an infected plant. The RNAs of the family Pospiviroidae contain a central conserved region (CCR) that has long been thought to be involved in replication. Here, we report that the CCR of Potato spindle tuber viroid (PSTVd) also plays a role in pathogenicity. A U257A change in the CCR converted the intermediate strain PSTVd(Int) to a lethal strain that caused severe growth stunting and premature death of infected plants. PSTVd with nucleotide U257 changed to C or G did not cause such symptoms. The pathogenic effect of the U257A substitution was abolished by a C259U substitution in the same RNA. Analyses of the pathogenic effects of the U257A substitution in three other PSTVd variants established A257 as a new pathogenicity determinant that functions independently and synergistically with the classic pathogenicity domain. The U257A substitution did not alter PSTVd secondary structure, replication levels, or tissue tropism. The stunted growth of PSTVd(Int)U257A-infected tomato plants resulted from restricted cell expansion but not cell division or differentiation. This was correlated positively with the downregulated expression of an expansin gene, LeExp2. Our results demonstrate that specific nucleotides in a noncoding, pathogenic RNA have a profound effect in altering distinct cellular responses, which then lead to well-defined alterations in plant growth and developmental patterns. The feasibility of correlating viroid RNA sequence/structure with the altered expression of specific host genes, cellular processes, and developmental patterns makes viroid infection a valuable system in which to investigate host factors for symptom expression and perhaps also to characterize the mechanisms of RNA regulation of gene expression in plants.     

Small RNA Derived from the Virulence Modulating Region of the Potato spindle tuber viroid Silences callose synthase Genes of Tomato Plants

The tomato (Solanum lycopersicum) callose synthase genes CalS11-like and CalS12-like encode proteins that are essential for the formation of callose, a major component of pollen mother cell walls; these enzymes also function in callose formation during pathogen infection. This article describes the targeting of these callose synthase mRNAs by a small RNA derived from the virulence modulating region of two Potato spindle tuber viroid variants. More specifically, viroid infection of tomato plants resulted in the suppression of the target mRNAs up to 1.5-fold, depending on the viroid variant used and the gene targeted. The targeting of these mRNAs by RNA silencing was validated by artificial microRNA experiments in a transient expression system and by RNA ligase-mediated rapid amplification of cDNA ends. Viroid mutants incapable of targeting callose synthase mRNAs failed to induce typical infection phenotypes, whereas a chimeric viroid obtained by swapping the virulence modulating regions of a mild and a severe variant of Potato spindle tuber viroid greatly affected the accumulation of viroids and the severity of disease symptoms. These data provide evidence of the silencing of multiple genes by a single small RNA derived from a viroid.     

RNAi-mediated resistance to Potato spindle tuber viroid in transgenic tomato expressing a viroid hairpin RNA construct

Because of their highly ordered structure, mature viroid RNA molecules are assumed to be resistant to degradation by RNA interference (RNAi). In this article, we report that transgenic tomato plants expressing a hairpin RNA (hpRNA) construct derived from Potato spindle tuber viroid (PSTVd) sequences exhibit resistance to PSTVd infection. Resistance seems to be correlated with high-level accumulation of hpRNA-derived short interfering RNAs (siRNAs) in the plant. Thus, although small RNAs produced by infecting viroids [small RNAs of PSTVd (srPSTVds)] do not silence viroid RNAs efficiently to prevent their replication, hpRNA-derived siRNAs (hp-siRNAs) appear to effectively target the mature viroid RNA. Genomic mapping of the hp-siRNAs revealed an unequal distribution of 21- and 24-nucleotide siRNAs of both (+)- and (–)-strand polarities along the PSTVd genome. These data suggest that RNAi can be employed to engineer plants for viroid resistance, as has been well established for viruses.     

RNA-dependent RNA polymerase 1 delays the accumulation of viroids in infected plants

RNA-dependent RNA polymerase 1 (RDR1) is essential for plant antiviral defence, but its role in plant defence against viroid infection remains unknown. The present study aimed to identify the function and mechanism of RDR1 in plant resistance to viroid infection. Overexpression of Nicotiana tabacum RDR1 (NtRDR1) delayed the accumulation of potato spindle tuber viroid (PSTVd) genomic RNA and PSTVd-derived small RNA (sRNA) in Nicotiana benthamiana plants at the early invasion stage, but not in the late stage of infection. Conversely, virus-induced gene silencing of tomato RDR1 (SlRDR1a) increased the susceptibility to PSTVd infection (increased viroid accumulation). Salicylic acid (SA) pretreatment induced SlRDR1a expression and enhanced the defence against PSTVd infection in tomato plants. Our study demonstrated that RDR1 is involved in SA-mediated defence and restricts the early systemic invasion by PSTVd in plants. The decreased PSTVd accumulation in N. benthamiana was not caused by efficient accumulation of PSTVd sRNAs. These results deepen our understanding of the mechanism of RDR1 in plant defence responses to viroid attack.     

Global analysis of tomato gene expression during Potato spindle tuber viroid infection reveals a complex array of changes affecting hormone signaling

Viroids like Potato spindle tuber viroid (PSTVd) are the smallest known agents of infectious disease-small, highly structured, circular RNA molecules that lack detectable messenger RNA activity, yet are able to replicate autonomously in susceptible plant species. To better understand the possible role of RNA silencing in disease induction, a combination of microarray analysis and large-scale RNA sequence analysis was used to compare changes in tomato gene expression and microRNA levels associated with PSTVd infection in two tomato cultivars plus a third transformed line expressing small PSTVd small interfering RNAs in the absence of viroid replication. Changes in messenger (m)RNA levels for the sensitive cultivar 'Rutgers' were extensive, involving more than half of the approximately 10,000 genes present on the array. Chloroplast biogenesis was down-regulated in both sensitive and tolerant cultivars, and effects on mRNAs encoding enzymes involved in the biosynthesis of gibberellin and other hormones were accompanied by numerous changes affecting their respective signaling pathways. In the dwarf cultivar 'MicroTom', a marked upregulation of genes involved in response to stress and other stimuli was observed only when exogenous brassinosteroid was applied to infected plants, thereby providing the first evidence for the involvement of brassinosteroid-mediated signaling in viroid disease induction.     

Photosynthetically active suspension cultures of potato spindle tuber viroid infected tomato cells as tools for studying viroid — host cell interaction

Photosynthetically active callus and cell suspension cultures were established from uninfected Lycopersicon peruvianum plants and from uninfected and potato spindle tuber viroid (PSTVd) infected plants of Lycopersicon esculentum cv. Rutgers. Viroid infection was maintained in photoheterotrophic culture on media containing 3% sucrose, but during continuous photo-mixotrophic culture in low sucrose media (1% sucrose), the level of PSTVd accumulation decreased. Photoautotrophic cell suspensions could be established with uninfected, but not with viroid infected tomato cells. As compared to uninfected cells, PSTVd infected cells grew slowly, were morphologically different in size and shape, and formed tight cell aggregates. Electronmicroscopy showed that starch accumulation in chloroplasts, deformation of the chloroplast envelope and irregular plasmalemmasomes at the cell membrane were associated with PSTVd infection.Abbreviations 2,4-D 2,4-Dichlorophenoxyacetic acid - BAP 6-benzylaminopurine - CEVd citrus exocortis viroid - CSVd chrysanthemum stunt viroid - PSTVd potato spindle tuber viroid - TMV tobacco mosaic virus - phc photoheterotrophic cell culture - mcc photomixotrophic cell culture - pcc photoautotrophic cell culture     

Potato spindle tuber viroid as inducer of RNA silencing in infected tomato.

Potato spindle tuber viroid (PSTVd), an RNA plant pathogen encoding no known proteins, induces systemic symptoms on tomato plants. We report detection of small RNAs of approximately 25 nucleotides with sequence specificity to PSTVd in infected plants: an indication of the presence of RNA silencing. RNA silencing, however, did not appear to be responsible for the differing symptoms induced by a mild and a severe strain of PSTVd. The unique structural and biological features of viroids make them attractive experimental tools to investigate mechanisms of RNA silencing and pathogen counterdefense.     

A chimeric satellite transgene sequence is inefficiently targeted by viroid-induced DNA methylation in tobacco

In plants, transgenes containing Potato spindle tuber viroid (PSTVd) cDNA sequences were efficient targets of PSTVd infection-mediated RNA-directed DNA methylation. Here, we demonstrate that in PSTVd-infected tobacco plants, a 134 bp PSTVd fragment (PSTVd-134) did not become densely methylated when it was inserted into a chimeric Satellite tobacco mosaic virus (STMV) construct. Only about 4–5% of all cytosines (Cs) of the PSTVd-134 were methylated when flanked by satellite sequences. In the same plants, C methylation was approximately 92% when the PSTVd-134 was in a PSTVd full length sequence context and roughly 33% when flanked at its 3′ end by a 19 bp PSTVd and at its 5′ end by a short viroid-unrelated sequence. In addition, PSTVd small interfering RNAs (siRNAs) produced from the replicating viroid failed to target PSTVd-134-containing chimeric STMV RNA for degradation. Satellite RNAs appear to have adopted secondary structures that protect them against RNA interference (RNAi)—mediated degradation. Protection can be extended to short non-satellite sequences residing in satellite RNAs, rendering them poor targets for nuclear and cytoplasmic RNAi induced in trans.     

Movement of potato spindle tuber viroid reveals regulatory points of phloem-mediated RNA traffic

Increasing evidence indicates that the phloem mediates traffic of selective RNAs within a plant. How an RNA enters, moves in, and exits the phloem is poorly understood. Potato spindle tuber viroid (PSTVd) is a pathogenic RNA that does not encode proteins and is not encapsidated, and yet it replicates autonomously and traffics systemically within an infected plant. The viroid RNA genome must interact directly with cellular factors to accomplish these functions and is, therefore, an excellent probe to study mechanisms that regulate RNA traffic. Our analyses of PSTVd traffic in Nicotiana benthamiana yielded evidence that PSTVd movement within sieve tubes does not simply follow mass flow from source to sink organs. Rather, this RNA is transported into selective sink organs. Furthermore, two PSTVd mutants can enter the phloem to spread systemically but cannot exit the phloem in systemic leaves of tobacco (Nicotiana tabacum). A viroid most likely has evolved structural motifs that mimic endogenous plant RNA motifs so that they are recognized by cellular factors for traffic. Thus, analysis of PSTVd traffic functions may provide insights about endogenous mechanisms that control phloem entry, transport, and exit of RNAs.     

Nuclear targeting by fragmentation of the potato spindle tuber viroid genome

Transient expression of engineered reporter RNAs encoding an intron-containing green fluorescent protein (GFP) from a Potato virus X-based expression vector previously demonstrated the nuclear targeting capability of the 359 nucleotide Potato spindle tuber viroid (PSTVd) RNA genome. To further delimit the putative nuclear-targeting signal, PSTVd subgenomic fragments were embedded within the intron, and recombinant reporter RNAs were inoculated onto Nicotiana benthamiana plants. Appearance of green fluorescence in leaf tissue inoculated with PSTVd-fragment-containing constructs indicated shuttling of the RNA into the nucleus by fragments as short as 80 nucleotides in length. Plant-to-plant variation in the timing of intron removal and subsequent GFP fluorescence was observed; however, earliest and most abundant GFP expression was obtained with constructs containing the conserved hairpin I palindrome structure and embedded upper central conserved region. Our results suggest that this conserved sequence and/or the stem-loop structure it forms is sufficient for import of PSTVd into the nucleus.     

Differential subnuclear localization of RNA strands of opposite polarity derived from an autonomously replicating viroid

The wide variety of RNAs produced in the nucleus must be localized correctly to perform their functions. However, the mechanism of this localization is poorly understood. We report here the differential subnuclear localization of RNA strands of opposite polarity derived from the replicating Potato spindle tuber viroid (PSTVd). During replication, (+)- and (-)-strand viroid RNAs are produced. We found that in infected cultured cells and plants, the (-)-strand RNA was localized in the nucleoplasm, whereas the (+)-strand RNA was localized in the nucleolus as well as in the nucleoplasm with distinct spatial patterns. Furthermore, the presence of the (+)-PSTVd in the nucleolus caused the redistribution of a small nucleolar RNA. Our results support a model in which (1) the synthesis of the (-)- and (+)-strands of PSTVd RNAs occurs in the nucleoplasm, (2) the (-)-strand RNA is anchored in the nucleoplasm, and (3) the (+)-strand RNA is transported selectively into the nucleolus. Our results imply that the eukaryotic cell has a machinery that recognizes and localizes the opposite strands of an RNA, which may have broad ramifications in the RNA regulation of gene expression and the infection cycle of pathogenic RNAs and in the development of RNA-based methods to control gene expression as well as pathogen infection.     

Advantages and disadvantages of using PCR techniques to characterize transgenic plants

The polymerase chain reaction (PCR) revolutionized molecular biology to a similar extent as the discovery of plasmids and restriction endonucleases. However, there are some limitations to the use of PCR. Transgenic plants containing potato spindle tuber viroid (PSTVd) cDNA constructs, demonstrated to become de novo methylated upon PSTVd infection, represent a good example to illustrate the advantages of PCR. PSTVd is a 359 nt long autonomously replicating plant pathogenic RNA where all of its enzymatic requirements are entirely provided by the host cell. In addition, viroids that propagate without a DNA intermediate barely tolerate nucleotide substitutions of their RNA genome without losing infectivity. PCR is the method of choice to characterize the sequence context of genome-integrated viroid cDNA or of reverse transcribed PSTVd RNA, and can hardly be replaced by any alternative procedure. Furthermore, the precise examination of DNA methylation patterns (genomic sequencing) is entirely dependent on PCR. In contrast, the use of PCR is critical for the determination of copy number and arrangement of transgene constructs. Here, the advantages and disadvantages of PCR are discussed and protocols for PCR amplification of cDNA, genomic DNA, and bisulfite-treated DNA from transgenic plants are presented.