Pattern regulation in the embryonic chick limb: Supernumerary limb formation with anterior (non-ZPA) limb bud tissue

The formation of supernumerary limbs and limb structures was studied by juxtaposing normally nonadjacent embryonic chick limb bud tissue. A “wedge” (ectoderm and mesoderm) of anterior or mid donor right wing bud (stage 21) was inserted in a slit made in a host right limb bud (stage 21) at the same position as its position of origin or to a more posterior position. The AER of the donor tissue and host wing bud were aligned with each other. Donor tissue was grafted with its dorsalventral polarity the same as the host's limb bud or reversed to that of the host's. Depending on the position of origin of the donor limb bud tissue and the position to which it was transplanted in a host, supernumerary wings or wing structures formed. Furthermore, depending on the orientation of the graft in the host, supernumerary limbs with either left or right asymmetry developed. The results of experiments performed here are considered in light of two current models which have been used to describe supernumerary limb formation: one based on local, short-range, cell-cell interactions and the other based on long-range positional signaling via a diffusible morphogen.     

Supernumerary limb structures after juxtaposing dorsal and ventral chick wing bud cells

The formation of duplicated wing skeletal elements and/or extra wing muscles was studied by juxtaposing normally nonadjacent embryonic chick wing bud cells. A wedge of right or left stage 21 wing bud ectoderm and mesoderm was inserted in a slit made in a host stage 20 to 22 right wing bud at the same anteroposterior position as its position of origin. The distal edge of the donor wedge and host wing bud were aligned with each other. Donor tissue was grafted into a host wing bud in one of the following four axial relationships: both the anteroposterior and dorsoventral axes corresponded with each other (aadd); only the anteroposterior axes were opposed (apdd); only the dorsoventral axes were opposed (aadv); both the anteroposterior and dorsoventral axes were opposed (apdv). Of the 63 wings resulting from the control aadd operation and the 45 wings from the apdd operation, only 12 wings had a duplicated skeletal element; of the 69 wings sectioned from these two groups of operations, only one had an extra muscle. However, of the wings resulting from the aadv and apdv operations (48 and 52 cases, respectively), 23 had a duplicated skeletal element; of the 54 wings sectioned from these operations, 43 wings had one to four extra muscles. Furthermore, when the aadv operation was performed with a wedge of donor quail wing bud ectoderm and mesoderm or mesoderm alone, supernumerary muscles formed in these chimeric wings and they were made up of donor quail and host chick cells or only donor quail cells.     

Position of origin of donor posterior chick wing bud tissue transplanted to an anterior host site determines the extra structures formed

The formation of supernumerary limb structures was studied by juxtaposing normally nonadjacent embryonic chick limb bud tissue. Different “wedges” (ectodern and mesoderm) of posterior donor right wing bud (stage 21) were transplanted to a slit made in stage 20–23 host right wing buds. Donor posterior tissue was transplanted to an anterior position in a host wing bud or, as a control, to the same position as its position of origin. Transplanting different wedges of posterior tissue to the same anterior host position results in wings with supernumerary structures, and different extra structures form depending on the position of origin of the donor tissue. The identification of extra limb structures formed was based on the skeletal and integumentary patterns of resulting wings and the pattern of muscles as seen in serial sections of resulting limbs. The results of experiments presented here are considered in light of current models that have been used to describe the formation of supernumerary limb structures by the embryonic chick limb bud.     

Xwnt-8 modifies the character of mesoderm induced by bFGF in isolated Xenopus ectoderm.

In Xenopus, growth factors of the TGF-beta, FGF and Wnt oncogene families have been proposed to play a role in generating embryonic pattern. In this paper we examine potential interactions between the bFGF and Xwnt-8 signaling pathways in the induction and dorsal-ventral patterning of mesoderm. Injection of Xwnt-8 mRNA into 2-cell Xenopus embryos does not induce mesoderm formation in animal cap ectoderm isolated from these embryos at the blastula stage, but alters the response of this tissue to mesoderm induction by bFGF. While animal cap explants isolated from non-injected embryos differentiate to form ventral types of mesoderm and muscle in response to bFGF, explants from Xwnt-8 injected embryos form dorsal mesodermal and neural tissues in response to the same concentration of bFGF, even if the ectoderm is isolated from the prospective ventral sides of embryos or from UV-ventralized animals. Our results support a model whereby dorso-ventral mesodermal patterning can be attained by a single mesoderm inducing agent, possibly bFGF, which is uniformly distributed across the prospective dorsal-ventral axis, and which acts in concert with a dorsally localized signal, possibly a Wnt protein, which either alters the response of ectoderm to induction or modifies the character of mesoderm after its induction.     

The ectodermal control in chick limb development: Wnt-7a, Shh, Bmp-2 and Bmp-4 expression and the effect of FGF-4 on gene expression

We have manipulated the chick limb bud by dorsoventrally inverting the ectoderm, by grafting the AER to the dorsal or ventral ectoderm and by insertion of an FGF-4 soaked heparin bead to the mesoderm. After dorso-ventral reversal of the ectoderm, Wnt-7a expression is autonomous from an early stage of limb development in the original dorsal ectoderm. Exogenous FGF-4 causes ectopic Wnt-7a expression and induces ectopic Shh. In addition, exogenous FGF-4 increases the thickness of cartilages and also shortens them, and both Bmp-2 and Bmp-4 may mediate this effect. The ectoderm outside the AER can regulate not only the dorso-ventral polarity of the underlying mesenchyme cells but also the cartilage formation, and both Bmp-2 and Bmp-4 may mediate this control.     

Inductive and axial properties of prospective wing-bud mesoderm in the chick embryo

Prospective wing-bud mesoderm, stripped of ectoderm mechanically through the use of glass needles, or chemically by means of EDTA or trypsin, was obtained from donor embryos of stages 11 through 21. Grafts were made in both homopleural (aadd and apdv) and heteropleural (aadv and apdd) combinations to the right flank of host embryos of the same range of stages. Flank ectoderm from the host healed over the graft in a few hours and, in combinations between donors and hosts in the range of stages 12 through 17, the composite formed, with high frequency, a limb bud capped by an apical ectodermal ridge, and then developed into a supernumerary wing in which all proximodistal levels were represented. When either member of the combination was older than stage 17, only incomplete limbs, if any, were formed. Regardless of their orientation on the host, the supernumerary limbs always showed the axial characteristics appropriate to their side of origin.Supernumerary wings failed to form if the grafts were inserted into a space tunneled between flank ectoderm and its underlying mesoderm. If the covering ectoderm were deliberately torn and forced to heal over the graft, however, an ectodermal ridge formed and a supernumerary limb developed.It is concluded, therefore, that: (1) the wing-bud mesoderm, appropriately combined with flank ectoderm, has the property of morphological and axial self-differentiation by stage 12; (2) the apical ectodermal ridge is induced in flank ectoderm by prospective wing-bud mesoderm; (3) this inductive power is restricted to prospective wing-bud mesoderm from donors of stages 12 through 17; (4) the response competence is limited to flank ectoderm that has healed over the mesoderm; and (5) this competence is lost by the end of stage 17.     

Inhibitory and stimulatory effects of limb ectoderm on in vitro chondrogenesis

Previous studies have indicated possible dual effects of the limb ectoderm in cartilage differentiation. On one hand, explants from early (stage 15) wing buds are dependent on contact with the limb ectoderm for cartilage differentiation (Gumpel-Pinot, J. Embryol. Exp. Morph. 59:157-173, 1980). On the other hand, limb ectoderm from stage 23/24 wing buds inhibits cartilage differentiation by cultured limb mesenchyme cells even without direct contact (Solursh et al., Dev. Biol. 86:471-482, 1981). In the present study, ectoderms from both stage 15/16 and stage 23/24 wings are cultured under the same conditions, and ectoderms from each source are shown to have two effects. Each stimulates chondrogenesis in stage 15 wing bud mesenchyme, and each inhibits chondrogenesis in older wing mesenchyme. The results suggest that the limb ectoderm has at least dual effects on cartilage differentiation, depending on the stage of the mesenchyme. One effect involves an early mesenchymal dependence on the ectoderm. This effect requires contact between the ectoderm and mesoderm (Gumpel-Pinot, J. Embryol. Exp. Morphol. 59:157-173, 1980) but also can be observed at a distance from the ectoderm. Later, the ectoderm can act without direct contact between the ectoderm and mesoderm to inhibit chondrogenesis over some distance.     

Abnormal anteroposterior and dorsoventral patterning of the limb bud in the absence of retinoids.

We describe here how the early limb bud of the quail embryo develops in the absence of retinoids, including retinoic acid. Retinoid-deficient embryos develop to about stage 20/21, thus allowing patterns of early gene activity in the limb bud to be readily examined. Genes representing different aspects of limb polarity were analysed. Concerning the anteroposterior axis, Hoxb-8 was up-regulated and its border was shifted anteriorly whereas shh and the mesodermal expression of bmp-2 were down-regulated in the absence of retinoids. Concerning the apical ectodermal genes, fgf-4 was down-regulated whereas fgf-8 and the ectodermal domain of bmp-2 were unaffected. Genes involved in dorsoventral polarity were all disrupted. Wnt-7a, normally confined to the dorsal ectoderm, was ectopically expressed in the ventral ectoderm and the corresponding dorsal mesodermal gene Lmx-1 spread into the ventral mesoderm. En-1 was partially or completely absent from the ventral ectoderm. These dorsoventral patterns of expression resemble those seen in En-1 knockout mouse limb buds. Overall, the patterns of gene expression are also similar to the Japanese limbless mutant. These experiments demonstrate that the retinoid-deficient embryo is a valuable tool for dissecting pathways of gene activity in the limb bud and reveal for the first time a role for retinoic acid in the organisation of the dorsoventral axis.     

Disrupting the establishment of polarizing activity by teratogen exposure.

Between days 9.5 and 10, the forelimb buds of developing murine embryos progress from stage 1 which are just beginning to express shh and whose posterior mesoderm has only weak polarizing activity to stage 2 limbs with a distinguishable shh expression domain and full polarizing activity. We find that exposure on day 9.5 to teratogens that induce the loss of posterior skeletal elements disrupts the polarizing activity of the stage 2 postaxial mesoderm and polarizing activity is not subsequently restored. The ontogeny of expression of the mesodermal markers shh, ptc, bmp2, and hoxd-12 and 13, as well as the ectodermal markers wnt7a, fgf4, fgf8, cx43, and p21 occurred normally in day 9.5 teratogen-exposed limb buds. At stage 3, the treated limb apical ectodermal ridge usually possessed no detectable abnormalities, but with continued outgrowth postaxial deficiencies became evident. Recombining control, stage matched limb bud ectoderm with treated mesoderm prior to ZPA grafting restored the duplicating activity of treated ZPA tissue. We conclude that in addition to shh an early ectoderm-dependent signal is required for the establishment of the mouse ZPA and that this factor is dependent on the posterior ectoderm.     

Formation of supernumerary structures by the embryonic chick wing depends on the position and orientation of a graft in a host limb bud

The relationship between the position transplanted in a host limb bud, the orientation of a graft in a host limb bud, and the extra limb structures formed was studied by juxtaposing normally nonadjacent embryonic chick wing bud tissue. In one series of transplantation operations, two different wedges (ectoderm and mesoderm) of stage 21 right donor posterior wing bud tissue were transplanted to the middle of a host stage 20 to 22 right wing bud such that the dorsal-ventral polarity of the graft and host were the same or reversed. The results of these transplantation operations show that the formation of supernumerary limb structures depends on the position of origin of the donor tissue, the anterior-posterior position transplanted in a host limb bud, and the orientation of the graft in the host limb bud. In a second series of transplantation operations, the relationship between the proximodistal position where posterior donor tissue is transplanted in an anterior host site and the extra structures formed was studied. A wedge of posterior stage 21 right wing bud tissue was transplanted to an anterior proximal or anterior distal site of a stage 22 to 24 host right wing bud. The results of these transplantation operations show that when the donor tissue is transplanted to an anterior proximal position in a host wing bud, then limbs with only a duplicated humerus result, whereas, when transplanted to an anterior distal position, then limbs with a duplicated forearm element and extra digits result.     

Planar Polarity in the Ciliated Epidermis of Xenopus Embryos

The coordinated orientation of ciliary beat in the larval epidermis of amphibians, evident in an organized streamline pattern, suggests a planar polarity of the epithelium, i.e., a polarity within the plane of the cell sheet. It has been proposed that the direction of ciliary beat is determined at mid gastrula by a gradient of a diffusible factor produced by the mesoderm. To analyze whether ectoderm in isolation can establish a uniform direction of ciliary beat, and at what stage its polarity is specified in the embryo, ectoderm of Xenopus laevis embryos of different stages was cultured in vitro on substrates. On concanavalin A, ectoderm isolated at early gastrula stages, i.e., prior to any contact with mesoderm, can autonomously coordinate the direction of ciliary beat, at least in small regions. A uniform planar polarity is expressed by ectoderm explanted from the early mid gastrula onward. On fibronectin, which promotes migration, the direction of movement correlates well with the direction of ciliary beat, and directional migration can even override the inherent polarity specified prior to explantation. Embryos which lack dorsal mesoderm nevertheless develop a highly organized streamline pattern, excluding a strict requirement for dorsal mesoderm for the determination of planar polarity. However, in spite of the early specification of planar polarity found for isolated tissue, rotated ectodermal transplants in situ can readjust their polarity in accordance with that of the host.     

Initiation of dorso-ventral axis during chick limb development

We analysed spatio-temporal expression of dorso-ventral genes - Wnt-7a, En-1, Lmx-1 and Fgf-8 - during both normal and ectopic limb formation following fibroblast growth factor (FGF) application to the flank. We confirm that Wnt-7a is the first of these genes to be expressed in dorsal ectoderm in limb-forming regions. We also noticed patterns and kinetics of gene expression specific to chick that could account for differences observed in ridge formation between chick and mouse. We find that Wnt-7a expression, in dorsal ectoderm, is rapidly and locally induced by FGF application. In contrast, ectopic induction of Lmx-1 expression, in dorsal mesoderm, is much slower, occurs first at a distance from the FGF-2 bead and seems initially independent of direct Wnt-7a signalling during FGF-2 limb induction. Finally, we show that there is no contribution to extra-limb mesoderm from normal limb mesoderm and confirm that flank cells give rise to the extra limb. Furthermore, we suggest that an inhibitor present in the flank normally prevents Lmx-1 expression in this region and restricts its expression to limb-forming regions.     

Normal development of the skeleton in chick limb buds devoid of dorsal ectoderm

It has been suggested that the ectoderm on the dorsal and ventral faces of the limb bud plays a part in controlling the pattern of cartilage differentiation. To test this, the dorsal wing bud ectoderm in the chick embryo was destroyed by irradiation with ultraviolet light at stage 17-19, at the very beginning of limb bud development, but the apical ectodermal ridge was spared. The irradiated ectoderm disappeared within 24 hr (by stage 23-24) and did not regenerate thereafter; thus the dorsal surface of the limb bud was kept denuded throughout most of the period of skeletal pattern formation. By 6 or 7 days after the irradiation (stage 35), when the rudiments of all the adult skeletal elements are normally present in recognizable form, the irradiated wings could be placed into two categories, those that were approximately normal in shape and those that had curled dorsally. All of these limbs were reduced in size, to varying degrees, when compared to their controls and lacked dorsal soft tissues. The limbs that were normal in shape, however, even though sometimes denuded over practically the whole extent of their dorsal surface, almost always had a complete and normally proportioned cartilage pattern, suggesting that ectoderm (other than the apical ectodermal ridge) does not exert any direct control over the development of the limb cartilage pattern. However, many of those limbs that had curled as a result of the irradiation did have major pattern deformities, suggesting that the topology of cartilage differentiation does depend on the shape of the limb bud.     

Experimental manipulation leading to induction of dorsal ectodermal ridges on normal limb buds results in a phenocopy of the eudiplopodia chick mutant

Elongation of chick limb buds depends on the presence of the apical ectodermal ridge which is induced by subjacent limb bud mesoderm. Recombination experiments have shown that the limb bud mesoderm loses the capacity to induce ridges by late stage 17. Moreover, in normal limb development only one ridge forms. However, in the eudiplopodia chick mutant accessory ectodermal ridges form on the dorsal surface of limb buds as late as stage 22. Tissue recombinant experiments show that the mutation affects the ectoderm, extending the time it responds to ridge induction (Fraser and Abbott, 1971a, Fraser and Abbott, 1971b while the mesoderm is normal. The result is polydactyly, with extra digits dorsal to the normal digits. Because eudiplopodia limb bud dorsal mesoderm can induce ridges at stage 22 but is unaffected by the gene, genetically normal dorsal limb bud mesoderm may also be able to induce ridges after stage 17. To test this possibility we grafted stages 14–18 flank ectoderm to normal limb bud dorsal mesoderm and found that mesoderm from stages 17 through 20 was able to induce a ridge and subsequently dorsal digits developed. Limbs with duplicate digits were similar to eudiplopodia limbs. In other experiments, stage 18, 19, and 20 leg bud dorsal ectoderm did not form ridges when grafted to leg bud dorsal mesoderm of the same stage, indicating a lack of response to the mesoderm. Finally, the inductive capacity of limb bud mesoderm appeared to be reduced compared to mesoderm at pre-limb bud stages. These experiments demonstrate a spatially generalized potential in limb bud dorsal mesoderm to induce ridges during the stages when the apical ridge is induced. The determination of where the ridge will form and the acquired inability of limb bud dorsal ectoderm to respond to induction by underlying mesoderm are necessary early pattern forming events which assure that a single proximodistal limb axis will form.     

Limb outgrowth in the chick embryo induced by dissociated and reaggregated cells of the apical ectodermal ridge.

Mesodermal cores of the stage 19 chick leg bud were capped with an intact apical ectodermal ridge (AER) or with strips cut from centrifugal pellets formed from Pronase-dissociated AERs. They were then covered with embryonic back-skin ectoderm and grown as grafts to the somite region of a host embryo. Control mesoderms were capped with centrifugal aggregates of nonridge limb ectoderm or similarly treated back-skin ectoderm, with ethanol-killed AERs or with no ectodermal cells other than the enveloping back-skin ectoderm.Controls were vascularized slowly and atypically and showed little outgrowth, forming only proximal skeletal structures. Recombinants equipped with AER cells were vascularized more fully and promptly and began vigorous growth after brief delay, forming legs with all skeletal segments represented, including claw-tipped toes. The latter were arranged in anteroposterior order corresponding to the original polarity of the mesoderm.Histological sections of recombinants made with cytologically distinctive quail AERs reveal that the cap of ridge cells, whether initially intact or reaggregated beneath the back-skin envelope, undergo a period of reorganization, forming a typical AER at the apex of the chimeric appendage after 48 hr. Meanwhile vigorous growth of the recombinant continues.These results show that the AER can cooperate with nonlimb ectoderm in promoting the morphogenesis of successively more distal levels of the limb skeleton. They also show that dissociated ridge cells can reorganize a typical AER at the apex of the limb mesoblast, meanwhile exercising their inductive effect on it.     

Chondrogenesis in mouse limb bud in vitro. I. Effect of the ectoderm

The role of the ectoderm in the chondrogenesis of mouse limb bud mesoderm was investigated in vitro at several developmental stages by analysis of the evolution of DNA content, the accumulation of sulfated glycosaminoglycans and histochemical procedures. Young limb buds or the undifferentiated apex of older buds (stages 17 and 19 of Theiler's table) from which the ectoderm had been removed with trypsin treatment initiated a large chondrogenesis but not morphogenesis. When the ectoderm was present, these limb buds showed a polarized proximal to distal outgrowth and differentiated skeletal primordia. Mesodermal cells of stage 20 limb bud apex were able to differentiate autopodial skeletons with or without the presence of the ectoderm: cartilaginous areas of the limb skeleton seem determined at this developmental stage. These results, which show the importance of the ectoderm in limb bud morphogenesis, are compared with results obtained using other methods with mouse or bird buds.     

Distribution of retinoids in the chick limb bud: analysis with monoclonal antibody

Retinoic acid induces anteroposterior duplicate formation in developing chick limb bud, and it may be a natural morphogen involved in limb pattern formation. Retinoic acid is produced from retinol locally in the limb bud via retinal, and thus, to elucidate the distribution of these retinoids in the limb bud seems to be important for the understanding of the morphogen formation. We produced a monoclonal antibody against the retinoids with BSA-RA (bovine serum albumin-retinoic acid) conjugate for antigen, and investigated the distribution of retinoids in the chick limb bud. The antibody predominantly bound to retinoic acid, but weakly to retinol and retinal. Retinoids appeared in the limb bud at stage 18 and were distributed through stages 20-24, when the pattern formation in distal mesoderm was in progress. Initially they were found evenly in the whole mesoderm, but disappeared gradually from core mesoderm and remained only in the region of peripheral mesoderm at stage 24. At stage 26, retinoids were detected only in ectoderm. These results support the idea that the retinoids actually play roles in limb pattern formation and suggest that the retinoids in the peripheral mesoderm are important for pattern formation. Further, the role of retinoids in epidermis development at later limb bud stages is also suggested.     

The establishment of the cartilage pattern in the embryonic chick wing, and evidence for a role of the dorsal and ventral ectoderm in normal wing development

Previous investigations have indicated that the limb bud behaves as a mosaic after some experimental manipulations and regulates after others. In light of new maps of the prospective cartilage-forming regions of the chick wing, we have reinvestigated the stability of the limb pattern by two experimental procedures. First, the prospective long bone regions were excised to examine the ability of the cells outside of the prospective long bone regions to form normal long bones. Second, the mesoderm, mesoderm + dorsal and ventral ectoderm, or dorsal ectoderm (with a small amount of subjacent mesoderm) of the prospective elbow region were rotated 180° to examine the ability of the limb to control and regulate the differentiation of the cells in the limb. We can conclude from these experiments that the cartilage-forming regions of the limb mesoderm gradually become stabilized between stage 22 and stage 24, and that the stabilization is due to the advanced state of differentiation and to the decreased rate of cell division after stage 22. In addition, the dorsal and ventral ectoderm have been shown to aid in stabilization of the cartilage pattern and to influence the development of the humerus. We conclude that the dorsal and ventral ectoderm play a significant role in limb development.     

Zebrafish wnt8 encodes two wnt8 proteins on a bicistronic transcript and is required for mesoderm and neurectoderm patterning.

In vertebrates, wnt8 has been implicated in the early patterning of the mesoderm. To determine directly the embryonic requirements for wnt8, we generated a chromosomal deficiency in zebrafish that removes the bicistronic wnt8 locus. We report that homozygous mutants exhibit pronounced defects in dorso-ventral mesoderm patterning and in the antero-posterior neural pattern. Despite differences in their signaling activities, either coding region of the bicistronic RNA can rescue the deficiency phenotype. Specific interference of wnt8 translation by morpholino antisense oligomers phenocopies the deficiency, and interference with wnt8 translation in ntl and spt mutants produces embryos lacking trunk and tail. These data demonstrate that the zebrafish wnt8 locus is required during gastrulation to pattern both the mesoderm and the neural ectoderm properly.