Bacteriorhodopsin mutants containing single substitutions of serine or threonine residues are all active in proton translocation.

To study their role in proton translocation by bacteriorhodopsin, 22 serine and threonine residues presumed to be located within and near the border of the transmembrane segments have been individually replaced by alanine or valine, respectively. Thr-89 was substituted by alanine, valine, and aspartic acid, and Ser-141 by alanine and cysteine. Most of the mutants showed essentially wild-type phenotype with regard to chromophore regeneration and absorption spectrum. However, replacement of Thr-89 by Val and of Ser-141 by Cys caused striking blue shifts of the chromophore by 100 and 80 nm, respectively. All substitutions of Thr-89 regenerated the chromophore at least 10-fold faster with 13-cis retinal than with all-trans retinal. The substitutions at positions 89, 90, and 141 also showed abnormal dark-light adaptation, suggesting interactions between these residues and the retinylidene chromophore. Proton pumping measurements revealed 60-75% activity for mutants of Thr-46, -89, -90, -205, and Ser-226, and about 20% for Ser-141----Cys, whereas the remaining mutants showed normal pumping. Kinetic studies of the photocycle and of proton release and uptake for mutants in which proton pumping was reduced revealed generally little alterations. The reduced activity in several of these mutants is most likely due to a lower percentage of all-trans retinal in the light-adapted state. In the mutants Thr-46----Val and Ser-226----Ala the decay of the photointer-mediate M was significantly accelerated, indicating an interaction between these residues and Asp-96 which reprotonates the Schiff base. Our results show that no single serine or threonine residue is obligatory for proton pumping.     

Effects of individual genetic substitutions of arginine residues on the deprotonation and reprotonation kinetics of the Schiff base during the bacteriorhodopsin photocycle.

The rates are determined for the deprotonation and reprotonation of the protonated Schiff base (PSB) as well as of formation and decay of the UV transient in the photocycle of seven bacteriorhodopsin (bR) mutants in which Arg-7, 82, 164, 175, 225, or 227 are replaced by glutamine and Arg-134 by cysteine. The results show that all these mutations increase the rate of deprotonation of the PSB compared to ebR, (wild-type bacteriorhodopsin expressed in Escherichia coli) greatly increase the rate of the reprotonation of the SB (Schiff base) in the case of the Arg-164 and Arg-175 mutations and dramatically decrease this rate in the case of the Arg-227 mutation. Temperature studies on the latter mutant suggest that the observed change in its rate of reprotonation is due to large decrease in the energy and entropy of activation, similar to those observed for Asp-96 mutations (Miller, A. and D. Orsterhelt. 1990. Biochim. Biophys. Acta. 1020:57-64). These results suggest that the reprotonation process is changed to a proton diffusion-controlled mechanism in the Arg-227 mutant due to a change in the structure of the proton channel. The absorption intensity ratio (AUV/AMslow) of each arginine mutant relative to that of ebR is found to be similar to that for native purple membrane (PM) except for the Arg-227 mutant where it is greatly reduced, and for the Arg-82 mutant where it is not observed, suggesting that both Arg-227 and Arg-82 residues somehow play roles in inducing the UV transient absorption. All the above results are discussed in terms of the model for the structure of bR proposed by Henderson, R., J.M. Baldwin, T.A. Ceska, F. Zemlin, E. Beckmann, and K.H. Downing. (1990. J. Mol. Biol. 213:899-929).     

Substitution of membrane-embedded aspartic acids in bacteriorhodopsin causes specific changes in different steps of the photochemical cycle

Millisecond photocycle kinetics were measured at room temperature for 13 site-specific bacteriorhodopsin mutants in which single aspartic acid residues were replaced by asparagine, glutamic acid, or alanine. Replacement of aspartic acid residues expected to be within the membrane-embedded region of the protein (Asp-85, -96, -115, or -212) produced large alterations in the photocycle. Substitution of Asp-85 or Asp-212 by Asn altered or blocked formation of the M410 photointermediate. Substitution of these two residues by Glu decreased the amount of M410 formed. Substitutions of Asp-96 slowed the decay rate of the M410 photointermediate, and substitutions of Asp-115 slowed the decay rate of the O640 photointermediate. Corresponding substitutions of aspartic acid residues expected to be in cytoplasmic loop regions of the protein (Asp-36, -38, -102, or -104) resulted in little or no alteration of the photocycle. Our results indicate that the defects in proton pumping which we have previously observed upon substitution of Asp-85, Asp-96, Asp-115, and Asp-212 [Mogi, T., Stern, L. J., Marti, T., Chao, B. H., & Khorana, H. G. (1988) Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. U.S.A. 85, 4148-4152] are closely coupled to alterations in the photocycle. The photocycle alterations observed in these mutants are discussed in relation to the functional roles of specific aspartic acid residues at different stages of the bacteriorhodopsin photocycle and the proton pumping mechanism.     

Regeneration of native bacteriorhodopsin structure following acetylation of epsilon-amino groups of Lys-30, -40, and -41

The chymotryptic fragment of bacteriorhodopsin, C-2 (residues 1-71), has been acetylated completely at its three lysines (residues 30, 40, and 41) by treatment with acetic anhydride. The triacetylated C-2 fragment is able to reassociate with fragment C-1 (residues 72-248) and the complex binds all-trans-retinal to form a native bacteriorhodopsin-like chromophore, which is essentially identical with that formed from fragments C-2 and C-1. Further, the kinetics and pH dependence of chromophore regeneration and the proton pumping of the reconstituted triacetylated C-2 and C-1 complex are indistinguishable from that of the unmodified C-2 and C-1 complex. However, the extent of regeneration of the chromophore from triacetylated C-2 and C-1 is less than that from fragments C-2 and C-1, suggesting that the acetylated C-2 fragment is less stable than unacetylated C-2 in the reconstitution medium. We conclude that the amino groups in Lys-30, -40, and -41 do not contribute to the stabilization of the folded bacteriorhodopsin structure and are not required for proton translocation.     

Structure-function studies on bacteriorhodopsin. VIII. Substitutions of the membrane-embedded prolines 50, 91, and 186: the effects are determined by the substituting amino acids

To study their role in the structure and function of bacteriorhodopsin, three prolines, presumed to be in the membrane-embedded alpha-helices, have been individually replaced as follows: Pro-50 and Pro-91 each by Gly and Ala and Pro-186 by Ala, Gly, and Val. The mutants of Pro-50 and Pro-91 all showed normal chromophore and proton pumping. However, the rates of regeneration of the chromophore in Pro-50----Ala, Pro-91----Ala and ----Gly with all-trans-retinal were about 30-fold slower than that in the wild-type, whereas the chromophore regeneration rate in Pro-50----Gly was 10-fold faster than in the wild-type. While, Pro-186----Ala regenerated the wild-type chromophore, the mutants Pro-186----Val and Pro-186----Gly showed large blue shifts (about 80 nm) in the chromophore regenerated with all-trans-retinal and showed no apparent dark-light adaptation. Pro-186----Gly first regenerated the wild-type chromophore with 13-cis-retinal which was thermally unstable and rapidly converted to the blue-shifted chromophore obtained with all-trans-retinal. High salt concentration restored the wild-type purple chromophore in the Pro-186----Gly mutant. Thus, in this mutant, the protein interconverts between two conformational states. Pro-186----Ala and Pro-186----Gly showed about 65%, whereas Pro-186----Val showed 10-20% of the normal proton pumping.     

The bacteriorhodopsin proton pump: effect of crosslinkings of lysine residues

All six available lysine residues in bacteriorhodopsin were amidinated with dimethyl-3,3'-dithiobispropionimidate, which is a crosslinking agent. The photocycle was studied by measuring light absorption and electric signals. The data show an essential change in the photocycle: instead of single components, the rise of the signal due to the M intermediate can be decomposed into two components, and the decay into three. The life-times and the intensities of these components and in general the proton pumping activity of bacteriorhodopsin depend only negligibly upon pH. Changes upon removing the crosslinks are not significantly different from those in the crosslinked samples. The lysine residues therefore may not be considered of primary importance in proton translocation.     

Guanidinium restores the chromophore but not rapid proton release in bacteriorhodopsin mutant R82Q.

Replacement of the Arg residue at position 82 in bacteriorhodopsin by Gln or Ala was previously shown to slow the rate of proton release and raise the pK of Asp 85, indicating that R82 is involved both in the proton release reaction and in stabilizing the purple form of the chromophore. We now find that guanidinium chloride lowers the pK of D85, as monitored by the shift of the 587-nm absorbance maximum to 570 nm (blue to purple transition) and increased yield of photointermediate M. The absorbance shift follows a simple binding curve, with an apparent dissociation constant of 20 mM. When membrane surface charge is taken into account, an intrinsic dissociation constant of 0.3 M fits the data over a range of 0.2-1.0 M cation concentration (Na+ plus guanidinium) and pH 5.4-6.7. A chloride counterion is not involved in the observed spectral changes, as chloride up to 0.2 M has little effect on the R82Q chromophore at pH 6, whereas guanidinium sulfate has a similar effect to guanidinium chloride. Furthermore, guanidinium does not affect the chromophore of the double mutant R82Q/D85N. Taken together, these observations suggest that guanidinium binds to a specific site near D85 and restores the purple chromophore. Surprisingly, guanidinium does not restore rapid proton release in the photocycle of R82Q. This result suggests either that guanidinium dissociates during the pump cycle or that it binds with a different hydrogen-bonding geometry than the Arg side chain of the wild type.     

Blue light effect on proton pumping by bacteriorhodopsin.

Proton pumping in closed vesicular systems containing bacteriorhodopsin that is initiated by an orange flash, is diminished by a subsequent blue flash. This blue light effect is due to light absorbed by the photocycle intermediate M412 (M), which was formed by the orange flash. A kinetic analysis of the blue-light-induced reduction of proton pumping shows that of the two components of M, only the slowly decaying component is involved in the reduction of proton movement. This may be the first correlation between a proton movement and a specific photochemical intermediate of bacteriorhodopsin. Furthermore, we report that blue light, acting on the slowly decaying intermediate, probably causes a movement of the protons in a direction opposite to that normally seen for light absorbed by bacteriorhodopsin.     

Vibrational spectroscopy of bacteriorhodopsin mutants. Evidence that Thr-46 and Thr-89 form part of a transient network of hydrogen bonds.

The role of Thr-46 and Thr-89 in the bacteriorhodopsin photocycle has been investigated by Fourier transform infrared difference spectroscopy and time-resolved visible absorption spectroscopy of site-directed mutants. Substitutions of Thr-46 and Thr-89 reveal alterations in the chromophore and protein structure during the photocycle, relative to wild-type bacteriorhodopsin. The mutants T89D and to a lesser extent T89A display red shifts in the visible lambda max of the light-adapted states compared with wild type. During the photocycle, T89A exhibits an increased decay rate of the K intermediate, while a K intermediate is not detected in the photocycle of T89D at room temperature. In the carboxyl stretch region of the Fourier transform infrared difference spectra of T89D, a new band appears as early as K formation which is attributed to the deprotonation of Asp-89. Along with this band, an intensity increase occurs in the band assigned to the protonation of Asp-212. In the mutant T46V, a perturbation in the environment of Asp-96 is detected in the L and M intermediates which corresponds to a drop in its pK alpha. These data indicate that Thr-89 is located close to the chromophore, exerts steric constraints on it during all-trans to 13-cis isomerization, and is likely to participate in a hydrogen-bonding network that extends to Asp-212. In addition, a transient interaction between Thr-46 and Asp-96 occurs early in the photocycle. In order to explain these results, a previously proposed model of proton transport is extended to include the existence of a transient network of hydrogen-bonded residues. This model can account for the protonation changes of key amino acid residues during the photocycle of bacteriorhodopsin.     

Bacteriorhodopsin mutants of Halobacterium sp. GRB. I. The 5-bromo-2'-deoxyuridine selection as a method to isolate point mutants in halobacteria

Halobacterium sp. GRB (Ebert, K., Goebel, W., and Pfeifer, F. (1984) Mol. & Gen. Genet. 194, 91-97) was used to isolate bacteriorhodopsin (BR) mutants. A procedure is described which allows the enrichment of any type of mutant unable to grow under the selection conditions applied. Its use for the isolation of phototrophically negative, retinal-positive mutants of Halobacterium sp. GRB is demonstrated. Single-cell clones of this phenotype were further characterized. The expression of bacterioopsin was tested with a monoclonal antibody directed against the C terminus of the protein. The expressed bacteriorhodopsins were characterized by their specific activity for proton pumping, their spectral properties, and photocycle kinetics. About 15 independent mutants carrying bacteriorhodopsins of three distinct phenotypic classes could be isolated, including BR with a different absorption maximum, BR of lower specific activity, and BR characterized by a slower photocycle and a lack of proton pumping activity.     

Trans/13-cis isomerization is essential for both the photocycle and proton pumping of bacteriorhodopsin.

We studied an analogue of bacteriorhodopsin whose chromophore is based on all-trans retinal. A five-membered ring was built around the 13-14 double bond so as to prohibit trans to 13-cis isomerization. No light-induced photochemical changes were seen, other than those due to a small amount (approximately 5%) of unbleached bacteriorhodopsin remaining in the apomembrane used for regeneration. The techniques used included flash photolysis at room and liquid nitrogen temperatures and Fourier-transform infrared difference spectroscopy. When the trans-fixed pigment was incorporated into phospholipid vesicles, no evidence of light-initiated proton pumping could be found. The results indicate that trans to 13-cis isomerization is essential for the photochemical transformation and function of bacteriorhodopsin.     

Electrogenic processes and protein conformational changes accompanying the bacteriorhodopsin photocycle

The possible mechanisms of electrogenic processes accompanying proton transport in bacteriorhodopsin are discussed on the basis of recent structural data of the protein. Apparent inconsistencies between experimental data and their interpretation are considered. Special emphasis is placed on the protein conformational changes accompanying the reprotonation of chromophore and proton uptake stage in the bacteriorhodopsin photocycle.     

Structure-function studies on bacteriorhodopsin. IX. Substitutions of tryptophan residues affect protein-retinal interactions in bacteriorhodopsin

Bacteriorhodopsin contains 8 tryptophan residues distributed across the membrane-embedded helices. To study their possible functions, we have replaced them one at a time by phenylalanine; in addition, Trp-137 and -138 have been replaced by cysteine. The mutants were prepared by cassette mutagenesis of the synthetic bacterio-opsin gene, expression and purification of the mutant apoproteins, renaturation, and chromophore regeneration. The replacement of Trp-10, Trp-12 (helix A), Trp-80 (helix C), and Trp-138 (helix E) by phenylalanine and of Trp-137 and Trp-138 by cysteine did not significantly alter the absorption spectra or affect their proton pumping. However, substitution of the remaining tryptophans by phenylalanine had the following effects. 1) Substitution of Trp-86 (helix C) and Trp-137 gave chromophores blue-shifted by 20 nm and resulted in reduced proton pumping to about 30%. 2) As also reported previously (Hackett, N. R., Stern, L. J., Chao, B. H., Kronis, K. A., and Khorana, H. G. (1987) J. Biol. Chem. 262, 9277-9284), substitution of Trp-182 and Trp-189 (helix F) caused large blue shifts (70 and 40 nm, respectively) in the chromophore and affected proton pumping. 3) The substitution of Trp-86 and Trp-182 by phenylalanine conferred acid instability on these mutants. The spectral shifts indicate that Trp-86, Trp-182, Trp-189, and possibly Trp-137 interact with retinal. It is proposed that these tryptophans, probably along with Tyr-57 (helix B) and Tyr-185 (helix F), form a retinal binding pocket. We discuss the role of tryptophan residues that are conserved in bacteriorhodopsin, halorhodopsin, and the related family of opsin proteins.     

Light- and dark-adapted bacteriorhodopsin, a time-resolved neutron diffraction study

Recently, neutron diffraction experiments have revealed well-resolved and reversible changes in the protein conformation of bacteriorhodopsin (BR) between the light-adapted ground state and the M-intermediate of the proton pumping photocycle (Dencher, Dresselhaus, Zaccai and Büldt (1989) Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. USA 86, 7876-7879). These changes are triggered by the light-induced isomerization of the chromophore retinal from the all-trans to the 13-cis configuration. Dark-adapted purple membranes contain a mixture of two pigment species with either the all-trans- or 13-cis-retinal isomer as chromophore. Employing a time-resolved neutron diffraction technique, no changes in protein conformation in the resolution regime of up to 7 A are observed during the transition between the two ground-state species 13-cis-BR and all-trans-BR. This is in line with the fact that the conversion of all-trans BR to 13-cis-BR involves an additional isomerization about the C15 = N Schiff's base bond, which in contrast to M formation minimizes retinal displacement and keeps the Schiff's base in the original protein environment. Furthermore, there is no indication for large-scale redistribution of water molecules in the purple membrane during light-dark adaptation.     

Active site structure of bacteriorhodopsin and mechanism of action.

Pressure experiments with freeze-dried bacteriorhodopsin indicate that water is an essential part of the chromophore. This observation is combined with already known information on (a) the pH dependence of proton pumping, (b) the secondary protein-chromophore interaction with lysine-40, and (c) the proton transfer in the initial photochemical step to give a detailed structure of the active site and a mechanism for proton pumping which is consistent with the bacteriorhodopsin polypeptide sequence.     

Vibrational spectroscopy of bacteriorhodopsin mutants: evidence for the interaction of proline-186 with the retinylidene chromophore

Fourier-transform infrared difference spectroscopy has been used to study the role of the three membrane-embedded proline residues, Pro-50, Pro-91, and Pro-186, in the structure and function of bacteriorhodopsin. All three prolines were replaced by alanine and glycine; in addition, Pro-186 was changed to valine. Difference spectra were recorded for the bR----K and bR----M photoreactions of each of these mutants and compared to those of wild-type bacteriorhodopsin. Only substitutions of Pro-186 caused significant perturbations in the frequency of the C = C and C - C stretching modes of the retinylidene chromophore. In addition, these substitutions reduced bands in the amide I and II region associated with secondary structural changes and altered signals assigned to the adjacent Tyr-185. Pro-186----Val caused the largest alterations, producing a second species similar to bR548 and nearly blocking chromophore isomerization at 78 K but not at 250 K. These results are consistent with a model of the retinal binding site in which Pro-186 and Tyr-185 are located in direct proximity to the chromophore and may be involved in linking chromophore isomerization to protein structural changes. Evidence is also found that Pro-50 may be structurally active during the bR----K transition and that substitution of this residue by glycine preserves the normal protein structural changes during the photocycle.     

Effect of introducing different carboxylate-containing side chains at position 85 on chromophore formation and proton transport in bacteriorhodopsin.

During the initial stages of the bacteriorhodopsin photocycle, a proton is transferred from the Schiff base to the deprotonated carboxylate of Asp85. Earlier studies have shown that replacement of Asp85 by Asn completely abolishes proton transport activity, whereas extension of the side chain by an additional carbon-carbon bond (Asp85-->Glu) results in a functional proton pump. Here we show that extension of the Asp85 side chain by two additional bond lengths also results in a functional proton pump as long as the terminal group is a carboxylate moiety. These side chains were created by modification of the cysteine residue in the Asp85-->Cys mutant with either iodoacetic acid or iodoacetamide. In vitro chromophore formation studies show that the rate of Schiff base protonation in mutants that contain a carboxylate at residue 85 is invariably faster than in mutants that contain neutral substitutions at this position. We conclude that in bacteriorhodopsin, there is considerable tolerance in the volume of the side chain that can be accommodated at position 85 and that the presence of a carboxylate at residue 85 is important both for proton pumping and for stabilizing the protonated Schiff base.     

Molecular mechanism of spectral tuning in sensory rhodopsin II.

Sensory rhodopsin II (SRII) is unique among the archaeal rhodopsins in having an absorption maximum near 500 nm, blue shifted roughly 70 nm from the other pigments. In addition, SRII displays vibronic structure in the lambda(max) absorption band, whereas the other pigments display fully broadened band maxima. The molecular origins responsible for both photophysical properties are examined here with reference to the 2.4 A crystal structure of sensory rhodopsin II (NpSRII) from Natronobacterium pharaonis. We use semiempirical molecular orbital theory (MOZYME) to optimize the chromophore within the chromophore binding site, and MNDO-PSDCI molecular orbital theory to calculate the spectroscopic properties. The entire first shell of the chromophore binding site is included in the MNDO-PSDCI SCF calculation, and full single and double configuration interaction is included for the chromophore pi-system. Through a comparison of corresponding calculations on the 1.55 A crystal structure of bacteriorhodopsin (bR), we identify the principal molecular mechanisms, and residues, responsible for the spectral blue shift in NpSRII. We conclude that the major source of the blue shift is associated with the significantly different positions of Arg-72 (Arg-82 in bR) in the two proteins. In NpSRII, this side chain has moved away from the chromophore Schiff base nitrogen and closer to the beta-ionylidene ring. This shift in position transfers this positively charged residue from a region of chromophore destabilization in bR to a region of chromophore stabilization in NpSRII, and is responsible for roughly half of the blue shift. Other important contributors include Asp-201, Thr-204, Tyr-174, Trp-76, and W402, the water molecule hydrogen bonded to the Schiff base proton. The W402 contribution, however, is a secondary effect that can be traced to the transposition of Arg-72. Indeed, secondary interactions among the residues contribute significantly to the properties of the binding site. We attribute the increased vibronic structure in NpSRII to the loss of Arg-72 dynamic inhomogeneity, and an increase in the intensity of the second excited (1)A(g)(-) -like state, which now appears as a separate feature within the lambda(max) band profile. The strongly allowed (1)B(u)(+)-like state and the higher-energy (1)A(g)(-) -like state are highly mixed in NpSRII, and the latter state borrows intensity from the former to achieve an observable oscillator strength.     

Photochemical reaction cycle and proton transfers in Neurospora rhodopsin.

It was recently found that NOP-1, a membrane protein of Neurospora crassa, shows homology to haloarchaeal rhodopsins and binds retinal after heterologous expression in Pichia pastoris. We report on spectroscopic properties of the Neurospora rhodopsin (NR). The photocycle was studied with flash photolysis and time-resolved Fourier-transform infrared spectroscopy in the pH range 5-8. Proton release and uptake during the photocycle were monitored with the pH-sensitive dye, pyranine. Kinetic and spectral analysis revealed six distinct states in the NR photocycle, and we describe their spectral properties and pH-dependent kinetics in the visible and infrared ranges. The phenotypes of the mutant NR proteins, D131E and E142Q, in which the homologues of the key carboxylic acids of the light-driven proton pump bacteriorhodopsin, Asp-85 and Asp-96, were replaced, show that Glu-142 is not involved in reprotonation of the Schiff base but Asp-131 may be. This implies that, if the NR photocycle is associated with proton transport, it has a low efficiency, similar to that of haloarchaeal sensory rhodopsin II. Fourier-transform Raman spectroscopy revealed unexpected differences between NR and bacteriorhodopsin in the configuration of the retinal chromophore, which may contribute to the less effective reprotonation switch of NR.     

Substitution of amino acids in helix F of bacteriorhodopsin: effects on the photochemical cycle

The effects of amino acid substitutions in helix F of bacteriorhodopsin on the photocycle of this light-driven proton pump were studied. The photocycles of Ser-183----Ala and Glu-194----Gln mutants were qualitatively similar to that of wild-type bacteriorhodopsin produced in Escherichia coli and bacteriorhodopsin from Halobacterium halobium. The substitution of a Phe for either Trp-182 or Trp-189 significantly reduced the fraction of photocycling bacteriorhodopsin. The amino acid substitutions Tyr-185----Phe and Ser-193----Ala substantially increased the lifetime of the photocycle without substantially increasing the lifetime of the M photocycle intermediate. Similar results were also obtained with the Pro-186----Gly substitution. In contrast, replacing Pro-186 with the larger residue Leu inhibited the formation of the M photocycle intermediate. These results are consistent with a structural model of the retinal-binding pocket suggested by low-temperature UV/visible and Fourier transform infrared difference spectroscopies that has Trp-182, Tyr-185, Pro-186, and Trp-189 forming part of the binding pocket.