Lens Crystallins and Their Microbial Homologs: Structure,Stability, and Function

Referee: Franz Schmid, Biochemicshes Laboratorium, Universitaet Bayeuth, D-95440 Bayeuth, Germany

abg-Crystallins are the major protein components in the vertebrate eye lens — a as a molecular chaperone and b and g as structural proteins. Surprisingly, the latter two share some structural characteristics with a number of microbial stress proteins. The common denominator is not only the Greek key topology of their polypeptide chains but also their high intrinsic stability, which, in certain microbial crystallin homologs, is further enhanced by high-affinity Ca²⁺-binding. Recent studies of natural and mutant vertebrate bg-crystallins as well as spherulin 3a from Physarum polycephalum and Protein S from Myxococcus xanthus allowed the correlation of structure and stability of crystallins to be elucidated in some detail. From the thermo-dynamic point of view, stability increments come from (1) local interactions involved in the close packing of the cooperative units, (2) the all-b secondary structure of the Greek-key motif, (3) intramolecular interactions between domains, (4) intermolecular domain interactions, including 3D domain swapping and (v) excluded volume effects due to “molecular crowding” at the high cellular protein concentrations. Apart from these contributions to the Gibbs free energy of stability, significant kinetic stabilization originates from the high activation energy barrier determining the rate of unfolding from the native to the unfolded state. From the functional point of view, the high stability is responsible for the long-term transparency of the eye lens, on the one hand, and the stress resistance of the microorganisms in their dormant state on the other. Local structural perturbations due to chemical modification, wrong protein interactions, or other irreversible processes may lead to protein aggregation. A leading cataract hypothesis is that only after a-crystallin, a member of the small heat-shock protein family, is titrated out does pathological opacity occur. Understanding the structural basis of protein stability in the healthy eye lens is the route to solve the enormous medical and economical problem of cataract.     

Ageing and vision: structure, stability and function of lens crystallins

The -, β- and γ-crystallins are the major protein components of the vertebrate eye lens, -crystallin as a molecular chaperone as well as a structural protein, β- and γ-crystallins as structural proteins. For the lens to be able to retain life-long transparency in the absence of protein turnover, the crystallins must meet not only the requirement of solubility associated with high cellular concentration but that of longevity as well. For proteins, longevity is commonly assumed to be correlated with long-term retention of native structure, which in turn can be due to inherent thermodynamic stability, efficient capture and refolding of non-native protein by chaperones, or a combination of both. Understanding how the specific interactions that confer intrinsic stability of the protein fold are combined with the stabilizing effect of protein assembly, and how the non-specific interactions and associations of the assemblies enable the generation of highly concentrated solutions, is thus of importance to understand the loss of transparency of the lens with age. Post-translational modification can have a major effect on protein stability but an emerging theme of the few studies of the effect of post-translational modification of the crystallins is one of solubility and assembly. Here we review the structure, assembly, interactions, stability and post-translational modifications of the crystallins, not only in isolation but also as part of a multi-component system. The available data are discussed in the context of the establishment, the maintenance and finally, with age, the loss of transparency of the lens. Understanding the structural basis of protein stability and interactions in the healthy eye lens is the route to solve the enormous medical and economical problem of cataract.     

Calorimetric analysis of the Ca(2+)-binding betagamma-crystallin homolog protein S from Myxococcus xanthus: intrinsic stability and mutual stabilization of domains.

The betagamma-crystallin superfamily consists of a class of homologous two-domain proteins with Greek-key fold. Protein S, a Ca(2+)-binding spore-coat protein from the soil bacterium Myxococcus xanthus exhibits a high degree of sequential and structural homology with gammaB-crystallin from the vertebrate eye lens. In contrast to gammaB-crystallin, which undergoes irreversible aggregation upon thermal unfolding, protein S folds reversibly and may therefore serve as a model in the investigation of the thermodynamic stability of the eye-lens crystallins. The thermal denaturation of recombinant protein S (PS) and its isolated domains was studied by differential scanning calorimetry in the absence and in the presence of Ca(2+) at varying pH. Ca(2+)-binding leads to a stabilization of PS and its domains and increases the cooperativity of their equilibrium unfolding transitions. The isolated N-terminal and C-terminal domains (NPS and CPS) obey the two-state model, independent of the pH and Ca(2+)-binding; in the case of PS, under all conditions, an equilibrium intermediate is populated. The first transition of PS may be assigned to the denaturation of the C-terminal domain and the loss of domain interactions, whereas the second one coincides with the denaturation of the isolated N-terminal domain. At pH 7.0, in the presence of Ca(2+), where PS exhibits maximal stability, the domain interactions at 20 degrees C contribute 20 kJ/mol to the overall stability of the intact protein.     

Calcium-induced decrease of the thermal stability and chaperone activity of alpha-crystallin

Alpha-crystallin, one of the major proteins in the vertebrate eye lens, acts as a molecular chaperone, like the small heat-shock proteins, by protecting other proteins from denaturing under stress or high temperature conditions. alpha-Crystallin aggregation is involved in lens opacification, and high [Ca(2+)] has been associated with cataract formation, suggesting a role for this cation in the pathological process. We have investigated the effect of Ca(2+) on the thermal stability of alpha-crystallin by UV and Fourier-transform infrared (FTIR) spectroscopies. In both cases, a Ca(2+)-induced decrease in the midpoint of the thermal transition is detected. The presence of high [Ca(2+)] results also in a marked decrease of its chaperone activity in an insulin-aggregation assay. Furthermore, high Ca(2+) concentration decreases Cys reactivity towards a sulfhydryl reagent. The results obtained from the spectroscopic analysis, and confirmed by circular dichroism (CD) measurements, indicate that Ca(2+) decreases both secondary and tertiary-quaternary structure stability of alpha-crystallin. This process is accompanied by partial unfolding of the protein and a clear decrease in its chaperone activity. It is concluded that Ca(2+) alters the structural stability of alpha-crystallin, resulting in impaired chaperone function and a lower protective ability towards other lens proteins. Thus, alpha-crystallin aggregation facilitated by Ca(2+) would play a role in the progressive loss of transparency of the eye lens in the cataractogenic process.     

The X-ray crystal structure of human gamma S-crystallin C-terminal domain.

gammaS-crystallin is a major human lens protein found in the outer region of the eye lens, where the refractive index is low. Because crystallins are not renewed they acquire post-translational modifications that may perturb stability and solubility. In common with other members of the betagamma-crystallin superfamily, gammaS-crystallin comprises two similar beta-sheet domains. The crystal structure of the C-terminal domain of human gammaS-crystallin has been solved at 2.4 A resolution. The structure shows that in the in vitro expressed protein, the buried cysteines remain reduced. The backbone conformation of the "tyrosine corner" differs from that of other betagamma-crystallins because of deviation from the consensus sequence. The two C-terminal domains in the asymmetric unit are organized about a slightly distorted 2-fold axis to form a dimer with similar geometry to full-length two-domain family members. Two glutamines found in lattice contacts may be important for short range interactions in the lens. An asparagine known to be deamidated in human cataract is located in a highly ordered structural region.     

Controlling Liquid–Liquid Phase Separation of Cold-Adapted Crystallin Proteins from the Antarctic Toothfish

Liquid–liquid phase separation (LLPS) of proteins is important to a variety of biological processes both functional and deleterious, including the formation of membraneless organelles, molecular condensations that sequester or release molecules in response to stimuli, and the early stages of disease-related protein aggregation. In the protein-rich, crowded environment of the eye lens, LLPS manifests as cold cataract. We characterize the LLPS behavior of six structural γ-crystallins from the eye lens of the Antarctic toothfish Dissostichus mawsoni, whose intact lenses resist cold cataract in subzero waters. Phase separation of these proteins is not strongly correlated with thermal stability, aggregation propensity, or cross-species chaperone protection from heat denaturation. Instead, LLPS is driven by protein–protein interactions involving charged residues. The critical temperature of the phase transition can be tuned over a wide temperature range by selective substitution of surface residues, suggesting general principles for controlling this phenomenon, even in compactly folded proteins.     

Urochordate betagamma-crystallin and the evolutionary origin of the vertebrate eye lens

A refracting lens is a key component of our image-forming camera eye; however, its evolutionary origin is unknown because precursor structures appear absent in nonvertebrates. The vertebrate betagamma-crystallin genes encode abundant structural proteins critical for the function of the lens. We show that the urochordate Ciona intestinalis, which split from the vertebrate lineage before the evolution of the lens, has a single gene coding for a single domain monomeric betagamma-crystallin. The crystal structure of Ciona betagamma-crystallin is very similar to that of a vertebrate betagamma-crystallin domain, except for paired, occupied calcium binding sites. The Ciona betagamma-crystallin is only expressed in the palps and in the otolith, the pigmented sister cell of the light-sensing ocellus. The Ciona betagamma-crystallin promoter region targeted expression to the visual system, including lens, in transgenic Xenopus tadpoles. We conclude that the vertebrate betagamma-crystallins evolved from a single domain protein already expressed in the neuroectoderm of the prevertebrate ancestor. The conservation of the regulatory hierarchy controlling betagamma-crystallin expression between organisms with and without a lens shows that the evolutionary origin of the lens was based on co-option of pre-existing regulatory circuits controlling the expression of a key structural gene in a primitive light-sensing system.     

Insights into the beaded filament of the eye lens

Filensin (BFSP1) and CP49 (BFSP2) represent two members of the IF protein superfamily that are thus far exclusively expressed in the eye lens. Mutations in both proteins cause lens cataract and careful consideration of the detail of these cataract phenotypes alerts us to several interesting features concerning the function of filensin (BFSP1) and CP49 (BFSP2) in the lens. With the first filensin (BFSP1) mutation now having been reported to cause a recessive cataract phenotype, there is the suggestion that the mutation could predispose heterozygote carriers to the early onset of age-related nuclear cataract. In the case of CP49 (BFSP2), there are now three unrelated families who have been identified with a common E233 Delta mutation. Very interestingly this is linked to myopia in one family. Despite the apparent phenotypic differences of the filensin (BFSP1) and CP49 (BFSP2) mutations, the data are still consistent with the beaded filament proteins being essential for lens function and specifically contributing to the optical properties of the lens. The fact that none of the mutations thus far reported affect either the conserved LNDR or TYRKLLEGE motifs that flank the central rod domain supports the view that this pair of IF proteins have unusual structural features and a distinctive assembly mechanism. The multiple sequence divergences suggest these proteins have been adapted to the specific functional requirements of lens fibre cells, a function that can be traced from squid to man.     

Calcium-induced decrease of the thermal stability and chaperone activity of α-crystallin

α-Crystallin, one of the major proteins in the vertebrate eye lens, acts as a molecular chaperone, like the small heat-shock proteins, by protecting other proteins from denaturing under stress or high temperature conditions. α-Crystallin aggregation is involved in lens opacification, and high [Ca²⁺] has been associated with cataract formation, suggesting a role for this cation in the pathological process. We have investigated the effect of Ca²⁺ on the thermal stability of α-crystallin by UV and Fourier-transform infrared (FTIR) spectroscopies. In both cases, a Ca²⁺-induced decrease in the midpoint of the thermal transition is detected. The presence of high [Ca²⁺] results also in a marked decrease of its chaperone activity in an insulin-aggregation assay. Furthermore, high Ca²⁺ concentration decreases Cys reactivity towards a sulfhydryl reagent. The results obtained from the spectroscopic analysis, and confirmed by circular dichroism (CD) measurements, indicate that Ca²⁺ decreases both secondary and tertiary–quaternary structure stability of α-crystallin. This process is accompanied by partial unfolding of the protein and a clear decrease in its chaperone activity. It is concluded that Ca²⁺ alters the structural stability of α-crystallin, resulting in impaired chaperone function and a lower protective ability towards other lens proteins. Thus, α-crystallin aggregation facilitated by Ca²⁺ would play a role in the progressive loss of transparency of the eye lens in the cataractogenic process.     

sHSP in the eye lens: crystallin mutations, cataract and proteostasis

α-Crystallin, a major component of the eye lens cytoplasm, is a large multimer formed from two members of the small heat shock protein (sHsp) family. Inherited crystallin mutations are a common cause of childhood cataract, whereas miscellaneous changes to the long-lived crystallins cause age-related cataract, the most common cause of blindness worldwide. Newly formed eye lens cells use proteostasis to deal with the consequences of mutations, whereas mature lens cells, devoid of the ATP-driven folding and degradation machines, are hypothesized to have the α-crystallin "holdase" chaperone function to prevent protein aggregation. We discuss the impact of truncating and missense mutations on α-crystallin, based on recent progress towards determining sHsp 3D structure. Dominant missense mutations to the "α-crystallin domain" of αA- (HSPB4) or αB-crystallin (HSPB5) occur on residues predicted to facilitate domain dynamics. αB-Crystallin is also expressed in striated muscle and mutations cause myopathy. The impact on these cellular cytoplasms is compared where sHsp multimer partners and metabolic constraints are different. Selected inherited mutations of the lens β- and γ-crystallins are considered in the context of their possible dependence on the "holdase" chaperone function of α-crystallin. Looking at discrete changes to specific crystallin polypeptide chains that can function as chaperone or substrate provide insights into the workings of a cytoplasmic proteostatic system. These observations provide a framework for validating the function of α-crystallin as a chaperone, or as a lens space filler adapted from a chaperone function. Understanding the mechanistic role of α-crystallins will aid progress in research into age-related cataract and adult-onset myopathy. This article is part of a Directed Issue entitled: Small HSPs in physiology and pathology.     

A biochemical characterization of the photophore lenses of the midshipman fish,Porichthys notatus Girard

The present study is a biochemical characterization of the photophore lenses of the midshipman fish, Porichthys notatus, a species that bears 800 photophores distributed over the body surface. The biochemical properties of the photophore lenses were compared with those of the eye lens with which they share a similar developmental origin and analogous function. To achieve a high refractive index, the vertebrate eye lens has a relatively high concentration of structural proteins (20–50%, depending on species) and a simple protein composition, that is, relatively few proteins are synthesized in comparison to other tissues. Similarly, the photophore lenses of P. notatus had a relatively high protein concentration (average = 29%, n = 5) and approximately 60% of the total soluble protein was represented by two subunit species of 33 kD and 35 kD on denaturing polyacrylamide gels. The structural proteins of the eye lens are of two principle types: 1) and polypeptides which belong to vertebrate lens-specific crystallin families, and, 2) enzymes recruited into the lens which take on the function of structural proteins. Here, we report that the two major photophore lens subunits of 33 kD and 35 kD are biochemically similar to each other, but are clearly distinct from any of the previously characterized crystallins. Therefore, we propose that photophore lenses appear to recruit a novel protein.     

Folding and self-assembly of the domains of betaB2-crystallin from rat eye lens

betaB2-Crystallin from vertebrate eye lens forms domain-swapped dimers, with subunits consisting of two all-beta domains connected by an eight-residue extended linker peptide. Topologically, the two domains show great similarity; however, they differ widely in their stability. As shown by urea-induced equilibrium unfolding experiments, the isolated monomeric C-terminal domain is more stable than complete betaB2. In contrast, the N-terminal domain exhibits marginal stability only in its dimeric state; upon subunit dissociation, at low protein concentration, unfolding takes place. The folding and association of intact betaB2 follows a sequential uni-bimolecular mechanism according to N2 <==> 2 I <==> 2U, whereas the isolated domains may be quantitatively described by the two-state model (N <==> U).     

Chordate betagamma-crystallins and the evolutionary developmental biology of the vertebrate lens

Several animal lineages, including the vertebrates, have evolved sophisticated eyes with lenses that refract light to generate an image. The nearest invertebrate relatives of the vertebrates, such as the ascidians (sea squirts) and amphioxus, have only basic light detecting organs, leading to the widely-held view that the vertebrate lens is an innovation that evolved in early vertebrates. From an embryological perspective the lens is different from the rest of the eye, in that the eye is primarily of neural origin while the lens derives from a non-neural ectodermal placode which invaginates into the developing eye. How such an organ could have evolved has attracted much speculation. Recently, however, molecular developmental studies of sea squirts have started to suggest a possible evolutionary origin for the lens. First, studies of the Pax, Six, Eya and other gene families have indicated that sea squirts have areas of non-neural ectoderm homologous to placodes, suggesting an origin for the embryological characteristics of the lens. Second, the evolution and regulation of the betagamma-crystallins has been studied. These form one of the key crystallin gene families responsible for the transparency of the lens, and regulatory conservation between the betagamma-crystallin gene in the sea squirt Ciona intestinalis and the vertebrate visual system has been experimentally demonstrated. These data, together with knowledge of the morphological, physiological and gene expression similarities between the C. intestinalis ocellus and vertebrate retina, have led us to propose a hypothesis for the evolution of the vertebrate lens and integrated vertebrate eye via the co-option and combination of ancient gene regulatory networks; one controlling morphogenetic aspects of lens development and one controlling the expression of a gene family responsible for the biophysical properties of the lens, with the components of the retina having evolved from an ancestral photoreceptive organ derived from the anterior central nervous system.     

Influence of small molecules on the photo-stability of water soluble porcine lens proteins

The eye lens is a biconvex structure composed of lens fibres, cells that lack of blood and nerve supply and of any organelle, allowing for a high concentration of water soluble proteins that determine the lens transparency and refractive index. The lens water soluble protein pool in mammals is composed of α-, β-, and γ-crystallins, the latter being involved in calcium homeostasis and having structural importance, the first playing a crucial role in preventing protein aggregation and the consequent lens obfuscation, which leads to the clinical outcome of cataract. Among different factors, oxidative stress, free radicals, and reactive oxygen species (ROSs) generated by the exposure to UV light are widely recognized to cause cataract formation. Taking advantage of synchrotron radiation circular dichroism, fluorescence, and circular dichroism spectroscopies, in the present study we investigate the influence of different small molecules with the potential to either quench ROS generation or to stabilize protein conformation. Therefore, ascorbic acid, an excellent antioxidant agent already present in the eye aqueous humour, has been tested along with ceftriaxone, mannitol and trehalose, which osmolyte activity was demonstrated interfering with model proteins misfolding. Our results showed that ascorbic acid strongly inhibits the ROS production without, however, preserving the native protein structure, whereas mannitol had no effect on the ROS production but retained better the secondary structure of WS proteins. Collectively, the use of a mixture of ascorbic acid and mannitol could be used to better protect eye lens proteins from ROS damage preventing the cataract onset.     

Association of partially folded lens betaB2-crystallins with the alpha-crystallin molecular chaperone

Age-related cataract is a result of crystallins, the predominant lens proteins, forming light-scattering aggregates. In the low protein turnover environment of the eye lens, the crystallins are susceptible to modifications that can reduce stability, increasing the probability of unfolding and aggregation events occurring. It is hypothesized that the alpha-crystallin molecular chaperone system recognizes and binds these proteins before they can form the light-scattering centres that result in cataract, thus maintaining the long-term transparency of the lens. In the present study, we investigated the unfolding and aggregation of (wild-type) human and calf betaB2-crystallins and the formation of a complex between alpha-crystallin and betaB2-crystallins under destabilizing conditions. Human and calf betaB2-crystallin unfold through a structurally similar pathway, but the increased stability of the C-terminal domain of human betaB2-crystallin relative to calf betaB2-crystallin results in the increased population of a partially folded intermediate during unfolding. This intermediate is aggregation-prone and prevents constructive refolding of human betaB2-crystallin, while calf betaB2-crystallin can refold with high efficiency. alpha-Crystallin can effectively chaperone both human and calf betaB2-crystallins from thermal aggregation, although chaperone-bound betaB2-crystallins are unable to refold once returned to native conditions. Ordered secondary structure is seen to increase in alpha-crystallin with elevated temperatures up to 60 degrees C; structure is rapidly lost at temperatures of 70 degrees C and above. Our experimental results combined with previously reported observations of alpha-crystallin quaternary structure have led us to propose a structural model of how activated alpha-crystallin chaperones unfolded betaB2-crystallin.     

Extracellular matrix and integrin signaling in lens development and cataract

During development of the vertebrate lens there are dynamic interactions between the extracellular matrix (ECM) of the lens capsule and lens cells. Disruption of the ECM causes perturbation of lens development and cataract. Similarly, changes in cell signaling can result in abnormal ECM and cataract. Integrins are key mediators of ECM signals and recent studies have documented distinct repertoires of integrin expression during lens development, and in anterior subcapsular cataract (ASC) and posterior caspsule opacification (PCO). Increasingly, studies are being directed to investigating the signaling pathways that integrins modulate and have identified Src, focal adhesion kinase (FAK) and integrin-linked kinase (ILK) as downstream kinases that mediate proliferation, differentiation and morphological changes in the lens during development and cataract formation.     

The pathogenic role of Maillard reaction in the aging eye

The proteins of the human eye are highly susceptible to the formation of advanced glycation end products (AGEs) from the reaction of sugars and carbonyl compounds. AGEs progressively accumulate in the aging lens and retina and accumulate at a higher rate in diseases that adversely affect vision such as, cataract, diabetic retinopathy and age-related macular degeneration. In the lens AGEs induce irreversible changes in structural proteins, which lead to lens protein aggregation and formation of high-molecular-weight aggregates that scatter light and impede vision. In the retina AGEs modify intra- and extracellular proteins that lead to an increase in oxidative stress and formation of pro-inflammatory cytokines, which promote vascular dysfunction. This review outlines recent advances in AGE research focusing on the mechanisms of their formation and their role in cataract and pathologies of the retina. The therapeutic action and pharmacological strategies of anti-AGE agents that can inhibit or prevent AGE formation in the eye are also discussed.     

Effect of chronic hyperglycemia on crystallin levels in rat lens

Crystallins are the major structural proteins in the vertebrate eye lens that contribute to lens transparency. Although cataract, including diabetic cataract, is thought to be a result of the accumulation of crystallins with various modifications, the effect of hyperglycemia on status of crystallin levels has not been investigated. This study evaluated the effect of chronic hyperglycemia on crystallin levels in diabetic cataractous rat lens. Diabetes was induced in rats by injecting streptozotocin and maintained on hyperglycemia for a period of 10 weeks. At the end, levels of α-, β-, γ-crystallins and phosphoforms of αB-crystallins (αBC) were analyzed by immunoblotting. Further, solubility of crystallins and phosphoforms of αBC was analyzed by detergent soluble assay. Chronic diabetes significantly decreased the protein levels of α-, β- and αA-crystallins (αAC) in both soluble and insoluble fraction of lens. Whereas γ-crystallin levels were decreased and αBC levels were increased in lens soluble fraction with no change in insoluble fraction in diabetic rat lens. Although, diabetes activated the p38MAPK signaling cascade by increasing the p-p38MAPK in lens, the phosphoforms of αBC were decreased in soluble fraction with a concomitant increase in insoluble fraction of diabetic lens when compared to the controls. Moreover, diabetes strongly enhances the degradation of crystallins and phosphoforms of αBC in lens. Taken together, the decreased levels of crystallins and insolubilization of phosphoforms of αBC under chronic hyperglycemia could be one of the underlying factors in the development of diabetic cataract.     

The molecular refractive function of lens γ-Crystallins

γ-Crystallins constitute the major protein component in the nucleus of the vertebrate eye lens. Present at very high concentrations, they exhibit extreme solubility and thermodynamic stability to prevent scattering of light and formation of cataracts. However, functions beyond this structural role have remained mostly unclear. Here, we calculate molecular refractive index increments of crystallins. We show that all lens γ-crystallins have evolved a significantly elevated molecular refractive index increment, which is far above those of most proteins, including nonlens members of the βγ-crystallin family from different species. The same trait has evolved in parallel in crystallins of different phyla, including S-crystallins of cephalopods. A high refractive index increment can lower the crystallin concentration required to achieve a suitable refractive power of the lens and thereby reduce their propensity to aggregate and form cataracts. To produce a significant increase in the refractive index increment, a substantial global shift in amino acid composition is required, which can naturally explain the highly unusual amino acid composition of γ-crystallins and their functional homologues. This function provides a new perspective for interpreting their molecular structure.