Three color cDNA microarrays: quantitative assessment through the use of fluorescein-labeled probes

Gene expression studies using microarrays have great potential to generate new insights into human disease pathogenesis, but data quality remains a major obstacle. In particular, there does not exist a method to determine prior to hybridization whether an array will yield high quality data, given good study design and target preparation. We have solved this problem through development of a three-color cDNA microarray platform where printed probes are fluorescein labeled, but are spectrally compatible with Cy3 and Cy5 dye-labeled targets when using confocal laser scanners possessing narrow bandwidths. This approach enables prehybridization evaluation of array/spot morphology, DNA deposition and retention and background levels. By using these measurements and the intra-slide coefficient of variation for fluorescence intensity we show that slides in the same batch are not equivalent and measurable prehybridization parameters can be predictive of hybridization performance as determined by replicate consistency. When hybridizing target derived from two cell lines to high and low quality replicate pairs (n = 50 pairs), a direct and significant relationship between prehybridization signal-to-background noise and post-hybridization reproducibility (R² = 0.80, P < 0.001) was observed. We therefore conclude that slide selection based upon prehybridization quality scores will greatly benefit the ability to generate reliable gene expression data.     

Statistical evaluation of differential expression on cDNA nylon arrays with replicated experiments

In this paper we focus on the detection of differentially expressed genes according to changes in hybridization signals using statistical tests. These tests were applied to 14 208 zebrafish cDNA clones that were immobilized on a nylon support and hybridized with radioactively labeled target mRNA from wild-type and lithium-treated zebrafish embryos. The methods were evaluated with respect to 16 control clones that correspond to eight different genes which are known to be involved in dorso-ventral axis specification. Moreover, 4608 Arabidopsis thaliana clones on the same array were used to judge statistical significance of expression changes and to control the false positive rates of the test decisions. Utilizing this special array design we show that differential expression of a high proportion of cDNA clones (15/16) and the respective genes (7/8) were identified, with a false positive error of <5% using the constant control data. Furthermore, we investigated the influence of the number of repetitions of experiments on the accuracy of the procedures with experimental and simulated data. Our results suggest that the detection of differential expression with repeated hybridization experiments is an accurate and sensitive way of identifying even small expression changes (1:1.5) of a large number of genes in parallel.     

Development and Testing of a DNA Macroarray To Assess Nitrogenase (nifH) Gene Diversity

A DNA macroarray was developed and evaluated for its potential to distinguish variants of the dinitrogenase reductase (nifH) gene. Diverse nifH gene fragments amplified from a clone library were spotted onto nylon membranes. Amplified, biotinylated nifH fragments from individual clones or a natural picoplankton community were hybridized to the array and detected by chemiluminescence. A hybridization test with six individual targets mixed in equal proportions resulted in comparable relative signal intensities for the corresponding probes (standard deviation, 14%). When the targets were mixed in unequal concentrations, there was a predictable, but nonlinear, relationship between target concentration and relative signal intensity. Results implied a detection limit of roughly 13 pg of target ml⁻¹, a half-saturation of signal at 0.26 ng ml⁻¹, and a dynamic range of about 2 orders of magnitude. The threshold for cross-hybridization varied between 78 and 88% sequence identity. Hybridization patterns were reproducible with significant correlations between signal intensities of duplicate probes (r = 0.98, P < 0.0001, n = 88). A mixed nifH target amplified from a natural Chesapeake Bay water sample hybridized strongly to 6 of 88 total probes and weakly to 17 additional probes. The natural community results were well simulated (r = 0.941, P < 0.0001, n = 88) by hybridizing a defined mixture of six individual targets corresponding to the strongly hybridizing probes. Our results indicate that macroarray hybridization can be a highly reproducible, semiquantitative method for assessing the diversity of functional genes represented in mixed pools of PCR products amplified from the environment.     

cDNA微阵列技术研究NaHCO3胁迫下星星草基因表达谱

为研究NaHCO3胁迫下星星草基因的表达,分别将荧光染料Cy5-dCTP和Cy3-dCTP用反转录方法标记在处理和对照星星草cDNA上制成探针,并与载有星星草基因的cDNA芯片进行杂交。通过对芯片的杂交信号强度分析来研究基因的表达情况。分析结果显示,共有25个基因在NaHCO3胁迫处理前后差异表达,其中17个基因在NaHCO3胁迫下表达下调,8个基因在NaHCO3胁迫下表达上调。生物信息学分析表明这些基因的功能涉及了信号传导与转录调控、细胞防御、细胞代谢等多个方面。从而获得了NaHCO3胁迫下星星草的基因表达谱,定量地阐述了NaHCO3胁迫和非胁迫条件下星星草基因的差异表达情况。     

Development and Evaluation of Functional Gene Arrays for Detection of Selected Genes in the Environment

To determine the potential of DNA array technology for assessing functional gene diversity and distribution, a prototype microarray was constructed with genes involved in nitrogen cycling: nitrite reductase (nirS and nirK) genes, ammonia mono-oxygenase (amoA) genes, and methane mono-oxygenase (pmoA) genes from pure cultures and those cloned from marine sediments. In experiments using glass slide microarrays, genes possessing less than 80 to 85% sequence identity were differentiated under hybridization conditions of high stringency (65°C). The detection limit for nirS genes was approximately 1 ng of pure genomic DNA and 25 ng of soil community DNA using our optimized protocol. A linear quantitative relationship (r² = 0.89 to 0.94) was observed between signal intensity and target DNA concentration over a range of 1 to 100 ng for genomic DNA (or genomic DNA equivalent) from both pure cultures and mixed communities. However, the quantitative capacity of microarrays for measuring the relative abundance of targeted genes in complex environmental samples is less clear due to divergent target sequences. Sequence divergence and probe length affected hybridization signal intensity within a certain range of sequence identity and size, respectively. This prototype functional gene array did reveal differences in the apparent distribution of nir and amoA and pmoA gene families in sediment and soil samples. Our results indicate that glass-based microarray hybridization has potential as a tool for revealing functional gene composition in natural microbial communities; however, more work is needed to improve sensitivity and quantitation and to understand the associated issue of specificity.     

The influence of RNA integrity,purity and cDNA labelling on glass slide cDNA microarray image quality

The accuracy of gene expression measurements generated using cDNA microarrays is dependent on the quality of the image generated following hybridization of fluorescently labelled cDNA. It is not known how this image is influenced by sample preparation factors which such as RNA quality, cDNA synthesis and labelling efficiency. In this study we used a simple metric based on the ratio of the total feature (F) and background (B) fluorescence, which correlates with the visual assessment of 60 microarray images, to determine the influence of sample preparation on image quality. Results indicate that RNA purity (A260/A280) and integrity (18S:28S ratio) do not strongly influence microarray image quality. cDNA having an nucleotide to dye ratio greater than 100 produced poor microarray images, however, cDNA labelled more efficiently was not a guarantee of a better image. The data also indicate that the array image quality is not improved by loading more cDNA into the hybridization mixture however poor image quality did result from a disproportionate amounts of Cy5 and Cy3 labelled cDNA. This study provides insight into the source of variation in microarray image analysis introduced during sample preparation and will assist in the standardisation of cDNA glass slide microarray protocols.     

Improved procedure for the measurement of telomere length in whole cells by PNA probe and flow cytometry

Objectives: Peptide nucleic acid (PNA) probes hybridize to denatured telomeric sequences in cells permeabilized in hot formamide. In reported protocols, the hybridization was conducted in solutions with high formamide concentrations to avoid the DNA renaturation that can hamper binding of the oligo‐PNA probe to specific sequences. We postulated that telomeric DNA, confined in the nuclear microvolume, is not able to properly renature after hot formamide denaturation. Therefore, to improve hybridization conditions between the probe and the target sequences, it might be possible to add probe to sample after the complete removal of formamide. Materials and methods: After telomeric DNA denaturation in hot formamide solution and several washes to remove the ionic solvent, cells were hybridized overnight at room temperature with human telomere‐specific PNA probe conjugated with Cy5 fluorochrome, Cy5‐OO‐(CCCTAA)₃. After stringency washes and staining with ethidium bromide, the cells were analysed by flow cytometry and by using a confocal microscope. Results: Using three continuous cell lines, different in DNA content and telomere length, and resting human peripheral blood T and B lymphocytes, we demonstrated that the oligo‐PNA probe hybridized to telomeric sequences after complete removal of formamide and that in the preserved nucleus, telomeric sequence denaturation is irreversible. Conclusion: According to our experience, oligo‐PNA binding results is efficient, specific and proportional to telomere length. These, our original findings, can form the technological basis of actual in situ hybridization on preserved whole cells.     

Accumulation of muscle-specific RNA sequences during myogenesis

DNA complementary to rat skeletal muscle polyadenylated RNA was enriched for sequences specific for terminal differentiation by hybridization to RNA extracted from cloned mononucleated myogenic cells and subsequent removal of the hybridized cDNA. The remaining cDNA (musclespecific cDNA) was hybridized to RNA extracted from primary skeletal muscle cultures harvested at short time intervals during differentiation. The experiments indicate that sequences specific for terminal differentiation accumulate close to the time of cell fusion, possibly a few hours prior to it. DNA complementary to polyadenylated muscle RNA was fractionated by hybridization to its template at a low R₀t and separation of the hybridized (abundant) and nonhybridized (rare) cDNA. Hybridization of these fractions to RNA extracted from cultures harvested prior to or after cell fusion showed that the abundant cDNA is very much enriched for sequences specific for terminal differentiation.     

Localization of mRNAs for the Small and Large Subunits of Rubisco Using Electron Microscopic in Situ Hybridization

In situ hybridization coupled with electron microscopy has been used to locate mRNAs for the small and large subunits of ribulose 1,5-bisphosphate carboxlase in young leaf tissue of tobacco (Nicotiana tabacum L.) plants. The endogeneous mRNAs were hybridized with either a biotinylated DNA probe for the small subunit or large subunit and subsequently visualized using avidin-ferritin conjugates at the electron microscope level. In the tissue incubated with the small subunit cDNA probe, the cytoplasm was uniformly labeled with ferritin indicating the presence of the target mRNA; this was particularly visible in cells which had under-gone some structural damage. In the case of the LSU probe, the ferritin marker was shown to be exclusively associated with the plastid stroma in intact leaf cells. The compartmentation of cytoplasmic small subunit mRNA versus plastid large subunit mRNA has been confirmed by direct visualization of in situ hybridization.     

Exploring the in situ accessibility of small subunit ribosomal RNA of members of the domains Bacteria and Eukarya to oligonucleotide probes

The principle that the small subunit ribosomal RNA (ssu rRNA) is generally accessible to oligonucleotide probes designed to have high thermodynamic affinity was tested with Stenotrophomonas maltophilia, Rhodobacter sphaeroides, Bacillus subtilis, and Saccharomyces cerevisiae. Fluorescein-labeled probes, designed to have ΔG_overall° = −14 ± 1 and to avoid the potential of nucleobase-specific quenching, were used to target 20 randomly selected sites in each organism. A site was considered accessible if probe brightness was at least 10 times the background signal. With 30-h hybridizations, 71 out of 80 target sites passed the accessibility criterion. Three additional sites were demonstrated to be accessible with either longer hybridizations, which seemed to have a negative effect on some probes, or the addition of formamide to the hybridization buffer. The remaining 6 sites were demonstrated to be accessible by changing the fluorophore to Cy5, slightly modifying probe lengths, using dual-labeled fluorescein probes, or a combination of these approaches. Probe elongations were only needed in 4 probes, indicating a 95% success in correctly predicting ΔG_overall°, the key parameter for the design of high affinity probes. In addition, 94% of the fluorescein labeled probes yielded bright signals, demonstrating that nucleobase-specific quenching of fluorescein is an important factor affecting probe brightness that can be predicted during probe design. Overall, the results support the principle that with a rational design of probes, it is possible to make most target sites in the ssu rRNA accessible.     

Double Labeling of Oligonucleotide Probes for Fluorescence In Situ Hybridization (DOPE-FISH) Improves Signal Intensity and Increases rRNA Accessibility

Fluorescence in situ hybridization (FISH) with singly labeled rRNA-targeted oligonucleotide probes is widely applied for direct identification of microbes in the environment or in clinical specimens. Here we show that a replacement of singly labeled oligonucleotide probes with 5′-, 3′-doubly labeled probes at least doubles FISH signal intensity without causing specificity problems. Furthermore, Cy3-doubly labeled probes strongly increase in situ accessibility of rRNA target sites and thus provide more flexibility for probe design.Since its introduction almost 20 years ago (2, 7), the identification of microorganisms by fluorescence in situ hybridization (FISH) with singly labeled rRNA-targeted probes has found widespread application in environmental and medical microbiology (1, 16). Despite being a methodologically robust technique, standard FISH suffers from several limitations (26) that may prevent successful detection of target microorganisms. One of the most frequently reported FISH problems is a low signal intensity of the detected microbes.Dim signals can be caused by a low cellular concentration of the target molecules (16S rRNA or 23S rRNA), a feature typically found in microorganisms thriving in oligotrophic environments (19). In order to increase the sensitivity of FISH and make it suitable for the detection of microbes with a low ribosome content, several strategies have been developed (6, 13, 18, 19, 21, 25), of which catalyzed reporter deposition (CARD)-FISH has found the most widespread application. The CARD-FISH technique (18, 21) uses horseradish peroxidase (HRP)-labeled oligonucleotide probes and tyramide signal amplification and achieves a 26- to 41-fold-higher sensitivity than standard FISH (11). However, CARD-FISH is rather expensive, requires enzymatic pretreatment to allow the large horseradish peroxidase-labeled probes to penetrate the target cells (17), and causes a dramatically altered melting behavior of the probes (11).Another frequently encountered FISH problem is the low in situ accessibility of many regions of the 16S and 23S rRNA for singly labeled probes (9, 10). Probes targeting such regions, which comprise about one-third of the Escherichia coli 16S rRNA (10), confer signals which are very dim or even below the detection limit. In order to avoid the selection of poorly accessible target sites for FISH probe design, a consensus 16S rRNA accessibility map for prokaryotes has been established based on detailed accessibility maps of two bacterial model organisms and one archaeal model organism (3). Considering this consensus map during probe design is recommended, but it excludes many probes with useful specificities from FISH applications. Furthermore, accessibility of many 16S and 23S rRNA target sites varies between different microorganisms and thus cannot yet be reliably predicted in silico. Accessibility of target sites to probes can be improved by the following: (i) use of unlabeled helper probes (8), (ii) elongation of the hybridization time up to 96 h (30), (iii) elongation of the probes, resulting in an altered ΔG°_overall (30), or (iv) use of peptide nucleic acid probes (reference 26 and references therein). However, all these strategies have specific limitations. For example, the design of helper probes is often impossible for probes with broader specificities, the extension of the hybridization time might lead to unspecific probe or dye binding in complex samples, probe elongation is often not possible without narrowing its specificity, and previously published oligonucleotide probes cannot simply be converted into the expensive peptide nucleic acid probes without a dramatically changed specificity (26).In principle, using oligonucleotide probes labeled with multiple fluorescent dyes should provide a simple means to increase the FISH signal intensity. The first experiments with multilabeled oligonucleotides were performed briefly after the introduction of the technique in microbiology but resulted in a pronounced increase in unspecific staining of nontarget organisms and/or an unexpected decrease in the signal intensity of the target organism which was attributed to quenching effects (28). Inconsistent with these data, Spear et al. (23) reported a successful increase in the signal-to-noise ratio of FISH-detected fungal cells by application of a multilabeled 18S rRNA-targeted oligonucleotide probe. In this work, we systematically evaluated the effect of 5′- and 3′-doubly labeled oligonucleotide probes (which were not included in the previously published study of multilabeled probes [28]) on the FISH signal intensity of Gram-negative and Gram-positive cells and studied the influence of double labeling on the in situ accessibility of rRNA target sites.The double-labeling-of-oligonucleotide-probes (DOPE)-FISH approach was initially tested with four bacterial pure cultures. These included the gamma- and betaproteobacterial Gram-negative species Escherichia coli (DSM 498) and Burkholderia cepacia (DSM 7288), respectively. In addition, the two Gram-positive bacteria Bacillus subtilis (DSM 10) and Listeria monocytogenes (strain LO28) were used. E. coli, B. cepacia, and B. subtilis were grown according to the DSMZ instructions until they reached their stationary growth phase and were fixed with paraformaldehyde (E. coli and B. cepacia) or ethanol (B. subtilis) as described elsewhere (5). L. monocytogenes strain LO28 was grown on brain heart infusion for 5 h and fixed with ethanol as outlined previously (27). The oligonucleotide probes EUB338 (targeting the 16S rRNA of most but not all bacteria), NonEUB338 (a nonsense probe), GAM42a (targeting the 23S rRNA of many members of the Gammaproteobacteria), and five E. coli-targeted probes with a low 16S rRNA accessibility (10) were obtained as singly and doubly labeled derivatives from Thermo Hybaid (Interactiva Division, Ulm, Germany). More information about the applied probes can be found at probeBase (14) and in the publication by Fuchs et al. (10). FISH was performed by following the standard protocol (5) under the conditions recommended for each probe (14). If not stated otherwise, all hybridizations were carried out with identical hybridization (4 h) and washing times (10 min), respectively. Probe-conferred signal intensities were quantified using a confocal laser scanning microscope (CLSM) (LSM 510 Meta; Zeiss, Oberkochen, Germany) and the software program daime (4) by analyzing at least 1,000 single cells per experiment. For these measurements, individual cells were detected by image segmentation via edge detection.Regardless of the dye used (Cy3, Cy5, or FLUOS) and the respective target organism analyzed, hybridization with the doubly labeled probe EUB338 resulted in an increase in the FISH signal compared to the use of the singly labeled probe EUB338. For three of the four reference organisms, this increase was about 2-fold, while an even stronger signal amplification was observed for B. cepacia (Fig. ​(Fig.1A).1A). Consequently, the distance between the two dye molecules in 18-nucleotide probes labeled at both ends is sufficient to avoid quenching. This is in contrast to oligonucleotides which are multiply labeled at one end or within the probe (28). Hybridization of the four reference organisms with the singly and doubly labeled derivatives of probe GAM42a confirmed these results and demonstrated that double labeling does not increase the background fluorescence of nontarget microorganisms (Fig. ​(Fig.1B).1B). Consistent with these findings, hybridization of all reference organisms with a doubly labeled nonsense probe (with FLUOS, Cy3, and Cy5) resulted in signals below the detection limit of the CLSM if standard FISH settings were applied (data not shown). We also evaluated the influence of the hybridization time on the signal intensity achievable by DOPE-FISH by varying the hybridization time between 1 and 6 h. In these experiments, no significant difference in DOPE-FISH signal intensities of the Gram-positive and Gram-negative reference organisms were observed, indicating that the additional label of the DOPE-FISH probes does not dramatically influence the hybridization kinetics (data not shown).Open in a separate windowFIG. 1.(A) Effect of double labeling of the EUB338 probe on the FISH signal intensity of four reference organisms. For each organism, the signal intensity conferred by a doubly labeled EUB338 probe was normalized to the signal intensity obtained with the same probe as a singly labeled derivative. Hatched, light-gray, and dark-gray bars depict results with the Cy3-, Cy5- and FLUOS-labeled probe EUB338, respectively. (B) Effect of double labeling of the probe Gam42a (in the presence of the unlabeled competitor probe Bet42a, specific for most members of the Betaproteobacteria [14]) on the FISH signal intensities of four reference organisms. For each organism, the signal intensity conferred by the doubly labeled probe Gam42a was normalized to the signal intensity obtained for E. coli with the same probe as a singly labeled derivative. Hatched, light-gray, and dark-gray bars depict results with the Cy3-, Cy5-, and FLUOS-labeled probe, respectively. The weak unspecific signals observed with some DOPE-FISH probes for B. subtilis are also detectable at comparable intensities with singly labeled probes (data not shown). (C) Cy3-doubly labeled but not FLUOS-doubly labeled probes improve in situ accessibility of E. coli 16S rRNA target sites. E. coli was hybridized with five probes representing brightness classes V and VI (3). FISH signals were recorded for Cy3-singly and -doubly labeled probes and normalized to the FISH signal obtained for E. coli with the singly labeled probe EUB338. Light-gray and dark-gray bars depict results with Cy3-singly and doubly labeled probes, respectively. FLUOS-singly and -doubly labeled probes showed no signal. For all panels, all experiments were performed in triplicate. Error bars indicate the standard deviation. ND, not detectable.Although DOPE-FISH worked well with all tested reference organisms, it should be noted that the Gram-positive species L. monocytogenes showed a signal amplification only if it was treated with lysozyme (according to Wagner et al. [27]) prior to the application of the doubly labeled probe. Without this enzymatic pretreatment, application of the singly labeled probe EUB338 resulted in a stronger signal than was seen with the doubly labeled probe EUB338, indicating that for some Gram-positive microorganisms with dense cell walls, double labeling impairs probe penetration. The observation that lysozyme treatment of L. monocytogenes also enhanced the probe-conferred signal of the singly labeled EUB338 probe confirmed that the cell wall of this organism after ethanol fixation is also not freely permeable to singly labeled probes (27; also data not shown). Enzymatic pretreatment of fixed microbial cells is also routinely applied for successful application of CARD-FISH, but since this method uses peroxidase-labeled probes which are much larger than DOPE-FISH probes, such treatments are also used for Gram-negative bacteria (11). Although many microorganisms are detectable by CARD-FISH with enhanced signal intensities, appropriate pretreatment protocols are not yet available for all microbes. For example, the sheathed filamentous methane oxidizer Crenothrix polyspora can easily be detected by standard FISH (24), but only very few cells within the filaments show a signal after CARD-FISH even if harsh permeabilization pretreatments are applied (see Fig. S1A in the supplemental material), a phenomenon known for sheathed microorganisms (12). In contrast, detection of all Crenothrix cells with more than 2-fold-increased signal intensity is readily possible by DOPE-FISH (see Fig. S1B).Prior research has demonstrated that probe labeling with horseradish peroxidase for CARD-FISH dramatically alters the melting behavior of oligonucleotide probes (11). Therefore, we recorded melting curves for Cy3-, Cy5-, and FLUOS-singly and -doubly labeled probes EUB338 and Gam42a by applying increasingly stringent conditions in the hybridization and wash steps (5). Interestingly, these experiments showed that the FLUOS singly labeled probes formed less-stable duplexes with their target sequences than the respective Cy3- and Cy5-labeled probes (Fig. ​(Fig.2).2). This effect, which is consistent with recent data on the stabilizing effect of various fluorophores on model probe-target duplexes (15), indicates that FLUOS-labeled FISH probes are generally applied under more-stringent conditions than Cy3- or Cy5-labeled probes. Cy3- and Cy5-doubly labeled probes displayed with their target organisms probe dissociation profiles similar to those of the respective FLUOS singly labeled probes, demonstrating that Cy3 or Cy5 double labeling does not further stabilize but rather moderately weakens the probe-target hybrid. Consistent with these findings, doubly FLUOS-labeled probes showed the lowest T_m (Fig. ​(Fig.2).2). Importantly, double labeling of probe GAM42a did not adversely affect mismatch discrimination, as shown by its dissociation profiles if in situ hybridizations were performed at various stringencies with B. cepacia containing a single mismatch in the probe target site of its 23S rRNA. (Fig. ​(Fig.2B).2B). These results indicate that the specificities of DOPE-FISH probes can be regarded as identical to those of standard singly labeled FISH probes.Open in a separate windowFIG. 2.Comparison of probe dissociation profiles of singly and doubly labeled probes. For each profile, the microscopic settings were adjusted for the lowest formamide concentration and subsequently kept constant. Dashed and solid lines represent sigmoid fittings for singly and doubly labeled probes, respectively. (A) Dissociation profiles of the singly and doubly labeled probe Gam42a with E. coli as the target organism. Empty circles, squares, and triangles represent data obtained with the Cy3-, Cy5-, and FLUOS-singly labeled probe GAM42a, respectively. Filled circles, squares, and triangles depict the data measured for the Cy3-, Cy5-, and FLUOS-doubly labeled probe GAM42a, respectively. (B) Dissociation profiles of the singly and doubly labeled probe Gam42a with B. cepacia as a nontarget organism having a single mismatch to probe GAM42a. Empty circles, squares, and triangles represent data obtained with the Cy3-, Cy5-, and FLUOS-singly labeled probe GAM42a, respectively. Filled circles, squares, and triangles depict the data measured for the Cy3-, Cy5-, and FLUOS-doubly labeled probe GAM42a, respectively. The melting curves for FLUOS-singly labeled and Cy5-doubly labeled probes are almost identical and thus overlap. In the presence of the unlabeled probe Bet42a as a competitor, no probe-conferred signal was recordable for both singly and doubly labeled GAM42a probes. (C) Dissociation profiles of the singly and doubly labeled probe EUB338 with E. coli as the target organism. Empty circles, squares, and triangles represent data obtained with the Cy3-, Cy5-, and FLUOS-singly labeled probe EUB338, respectively. Filled circles, squares, and triangles depict the data measured for the Cy3-, Cy5-, and FLUOS-doubly labeled probe EUB338, respectively. For all panels, error bars are not shown since they were always smaller than the symbols.In order to analyze whether the in situ accessibility of rRNA target sites to doubly labeled probes differs from that to those labeled with only one dye, we tested five probes targeting E. coli 16S rRNA. These probes were described as yielding only very dim signals with standard FISH as a consequence of limited target site accessibility and were thus assigned to the lowest brightness classes, V or VI (3, 10). Consistently, standard FISH with these five singly labeled probes (Cy3 and FLUOS) gave no or very weak signals (Fig. ​(Fig.1C).1C). Unexpectedly, however, Cy3-doubly labeled derivatives of these probes produced much brighter signals (Fig. ​(Fig.1C),1C), and for some of the probes (Eco468 and Eco1310), the DOPE-FISH signal intensity was higher than that measured for the Cy3-singly labeled probe EUB338 (Fig. ​(Fig.1C).1C). One could speculate that a Cy3 label at the 3′ end and not the double labeling might be responsible for the improved accessibility of rRNA target sites for Cy3 DOPE-FISH probes. However, since selected probes (Eco262, Eco468, and Eco1310) labeled with a single Cy3 molecule at the 3′ end did not result in increased fluorescence, this hypothesis can be rejected (data not shown). Interestingly, FLUOS-labeled DOPE-FISH probes did not show increased fluorescence, strongly indicating that the improved accessibility of Cy3 DOPE-FISH probes depends on the chemical structure of the fluorophore. This is consistent with the observation that Cy5 double labeling of the five E. coli probes also resulted in improved probe accessibilities (data not shown). While Cy3 and Cy5 double labeling decreases the probe-target duplex stability (Fig. ​(Fig.2),2), it apparently helps to resolve secondary or tertiary structures responsible for poor in situ accessibility of rRNA target sites. It is tempting to speculate that binding of Cy3 or Cy5 to double-stranded rRNA regions, analogous to the previously reported intercalation of certain cyanine class dyes in DNA (29) or other modes of nucleic acid binding by cyanine dyes (15), contributes to this phenomenon.The improved accessibility of rRNA target sites for Cy3 DOPE-FISH probes offers more flexibility for probe design because it enables the use of probes with excellent specificity but low standard FISH signal intensity for the successful in situ detection of microbes. This advantage of DOPE-FISH is nicely demonstrated by the probe Ntspa175 (5′-GAC CAG GAG CCG TAT GCG-3′), which targets the 16S rRNA (GenBank accession no. {"type":"entrez-nucleotide","attrs":{"text":"GU229885","term_id":"281398158","term_text":"GU229885"}}GU229885) of an uncultured nitrite oxidizer of the genus Nitrospira thriving in activated sludge. At 25% formamide in the standard FISH hybridization buffer (5), this probe is highly specific as demonstrated by Clone-FISH (22) using another activated sludge-derived 16S rRNA Nitrospira-like sequence with a single mismatch to probe Ntspa175 as a nontarget control (data not shown). Standard FISH of activated sludge with the Cy3-labeled probe Ntsp175, which targets the 175-to-193 region in the 16S rRNA, resulted in the detection of Nitrospira microcolonies with very variable FISH signal intensities. A considerable number of stained microcolonies had extremely dim FISH signals, indicating that these cells had a ribosome content too low to be reliably detectable by a standard FISH probe of a low brightness class. DOPE-FISH of the same sample with the Cy3-doubly labeled probe Ntspa175 led to a pronounced increase in signal intensity of the target cells (see Fig. S2 in the supplemental material) without causing increased background fluorescence if standard confocal-microscope settings were applied. In accordance with this observation, the relative biovolume-abundance of the detectable Ntspa175-stained population compared to the biovolume of those cells labeled by the Nitrospira genus-specific probe Ntspa662 (14) in the activated sludge increased by a factor of 1.81 ± 0.1 if a doubly labeled Ntspa175 probe was used (measurements made by the software package daime using confocal-microscope images as described previously [4]).In summary, DOPE-FISH with commercially available doubly labeled oligonucleotide probes is a straightforward modification of the standard FISH procedure which increases the signal intensity of standard FISH probes by at least a factor of 2 without causing specificity problems. Importantly, the influence of DOPE-FISH on the dissociation profile of probes is not larger than that caused by a dye switch from Cy3 to FLUOS if singly labeled probes are used for FISH. Thus, previously optimized hybridization and washing conditions for published probes can be applied for DOPE-FISH. Since DOPE-FISH unlocks previously inaccessible target sites on the rRNA, this new FISH approach offers more options for the design of specific probes, a task which becomes increasingly difficult with the rapid growth of rRNA databases (20).      

Comparative High-Density Microarray Analysis of Gene Expression during Growth of Lactobacillus helveticus in Milk versus Rich Culture Medium

Lactobacillus helveticus CNRZ32 is used by the dairy industry to modulate cheese flavor. The compilation of a draft genome sequence for this strain allowed us to identify and completely sequence 168 genes potentially important for the growth of this organism in milk or for cheese flavor development. The primary aim of this study was to investigate the expression of these genes during growth in milk and MRS medium by using microarrays. Oligonucleotide probes against each of the completely sequenced genes were compiled on maskless photolithography-based DNA microarrays. Additionally, the entire draft genome sequence was used to produce tiled microarrays in which noninterrupted sequence contigs were covered by consecutive 24-mer probes and associated mismatch probe sets. Total RNA isolated from cells grown in skim milk or in MRS to mid-log phase was used as a template to synthesize cDNA, followed by Cy3 labeling and hybridization. An analysis of data from annotated gene probes identified 42 genes that were upregulated during the growth of CNRZ32 in milk (P < 0.05), and 25 of these genes showed upregulation after applying Bonferroni's adjustment. The tiled microarrays identified numerous additional genes that were upregulated in milk versus MRS. Collectively, array data showed the growth of CNRZ32 in milk-induced genes encoding cell-envelope proteinases, oligopeptide transporters, and endopeptidases as well as enzymes for lactose and cysteine pathways, de novo synthesis, and/or salvage pathways for purines and pyrimidines and other functions. Genes for a hypothetical phosphoserine utilization pathway were also differentially expressed. Preliminary experiments indicate that cheese-derived, phosphoserine-containing peptides increase growth rates of CNRZ32 in a chemically defined medium. These results suggest that phosphoserine is used as an energy source during the growth of L. helveticus CNRZ32.     

Processing the Loblolly Pine PtGen2 cDNA Microarray

PtGen2 is a 26,496 feature cDNA microarray containing amplified loblolly pine ESTs. The array is produced in our laboratory for use by researchers studying gene expression in pine and other conifer species. PtGen2 was developed as a result of our gene discovery efforts in loblolly pine, and is comprised of sequences identified primarily from root tissues, but also from needle and stem.^1,2 PtGen2 has been tested by hybridizing different Cy-dye labeled conifer target cDNAs, using both amplified and non-amplified indirect labeling methods, and also tested with a number of hybridization and washing conditions. This video focuses on the handling and processing of slides before and after pre-hybridization, as well as after hybridization, using some modifications to procedures developed previously.^3,4 Also included, in text form only, are the protocols used for the generation, labeling and clean up of target cDNA s, as well as information on software used for downstream data processing. PtGen2 is printed with a proprietary print buffer that contains high concentrations of salt that can be difficult to remove completely. The slides are washed first in a warm SDS solution prior to pre-hybridization. After pre-hybridization, the slides are washed vigorously in several changes of water to complete removal of remaining salts. LifterSlips™ are then cleaned and positioned on the slides and labeled cDNA is carefully loaded onto the microarray by way of capillary action which provides for even distribution of the sample across the slide, and reduces the chance of bubble incorporation. Hybridization of targets to the array is done at 48°C in high humidity conditions. After hybridization, a series of standard washes are done at 53°C and room temperature for extended times. Processing PtGen2 slides using this technique reduces salt and SDS-derived artifacts often seen when the array is processed less rigorously. Hybridizing targets derived from several different conifer RNA sources, this processing protocol yielded fewer artifacts, reduced background, and provided better consistency among different experimental groups of arrays.Open in a separate windowClick here to view.^{(39M, flv)}     

Application of Pseudomurein Endoisopeptidase to Fluorescence In Situ Hybridization of Methanogens within the Family Methanobacteriaceae

In situ detection of methanogens within the family Methanobacteriaceae is sometimes known to be unsuccessful due to the difficulty in permeability of oligonucleotide probes. Pseudomurein endoisopeptidase (Pei), a lytic enzyme that specifically acts on their cell walls, was applied prior to 16S rRNA-targeting fluorescence in situ hybridization (FISH). For this purpose, pure cultured methanogens within this family, Methanobacterium bryantii, Methanobrevibacter ruminantium, Methanosphaera stadtmanae, and Methanothermobacter thermautotrophicus together with a Methanothermobacter thermautotrophicus-containing syntrophic acetate-oxidizing coculture, endosymbiotic Methanobrevibacter methanogens within an anaerobic ciliate, and an upflow anaerobic sludge blanket (UASB) granule were examined. Even without the Pei treatment, Methanobacterium bryantii and Methanothermobacter thermautotrophicus cells are relatively well hybridized with oligonucleotide probes. However, almost none of the cells of Methanobrevibacter ruminantium, Methanosphaera stadtmanae, cocultured Methanothermobacter thermautotrophicus, and the endosymbiotic methanogens and the cells within UASB granule were hybridized. Pei treatment was able to increase the probe hybridization ratio in every specimen, particularly in the specimen that had shown little hybridization. Interestingly, the hybridizing signal intensity of Methanothermobacter thermautotrophicus cells in coculture with an acetate-oxidizing H₂-producing syntroph was significantly improved by Pei pretreatment, whereas the probe was well hybridized with the cells of pure culture of the same strain. We found that the difference is attributed to the differences in cell wall thicknesses between the two culture conditions. These results indicate that Pei treatment is effective for FISH analysis of methanogens that show impermeability to the probe.     

Direct Detection of 16S rRNA in Soil Extracts by Using Oligonucleotide Microarrays

We report on the development and validation of a simple microarray method for the direct detection of intact 16S rRNA from unpurified soil extracts. Total RNAs from Geobacter chapellei and Desulfovibrio desulfuricans were hybridized to an oligonucleotide array consisting of universal and species-specific 16S rRNA probes. PCR-amplified products from Geobacter and Desulfovibrio were easily and specifically detected under a range of hybridization times, temperatures, and buffers. However, reproducible, specific hybridization and detection of intact rRNA could be accomplished only by using a chaperone-detector probe strategy. With this knowledge, assay conditions were developed for rRNA detection using a 2-h hybridization time at room temperature. Hybridization specificity and signal intensity were enhanced using fragmented RNA. Formamide was required in the hybridization buffer in order to achieve species-specific detection of intact rRNA. With the chaperone detection strategy, we were able to specifically hybridize and detect G. chapellei 16S rRNA directly from a total-RNA soil extract, without further purification or removal of soluble soil constituents. The detection sensitivity for G. chapellei 16S rRNA in soil extracts was at least 0.5 μg of total RNA, representing approximately 7.5 × 10⁶ Geobacter cell equivalents of RNA. These results suggest that it is now possible to apply microarray technology to the direct detection of microorganisms in environmental samples, without using PCR.