经皮穴位电刺激治疗术后疼痛的研究进展

术后疼痛是术后常见的一种伤害性疼痛,随着舒适化医疗的倡导,经皮穴位电刺激因其无创、安全等优点受到关注。经皮穴位电刺激是将经皮神经电刺激与针灸穴位理论相结合的一种方法,虽有研究证实其频率、波形、强度、刺激时间的设定及不同穴位的配伍对镇痛效果均可产生较大的影响,但在规范化方面仍有不足。本文总结其使用方法及镇痛疗效,以期对经皮穴位电刺激应用于临床提供最优参数及穴位配伍,使之规范化,从而发挥出最佳镇痛效果。     

Antistress effects of diazepam and activation of the positive reinforcing system upon changes on corticosteroid excretion and lipid level after peripheral electric pain stimulation]

It was shown in experiments on rats that the reaction of self-stimulation (SS) decreased the enhanced level of 11-hydrohycorticosteroids (11-HCS) in the blood after electrical pain stimulation(EPS) of the feet. Diazepam (1 mg/kg) decreased the levels of 11-HCS and beta-lipoproteids and increased the level of phospholipids after self-stimulation and pain stimulation. Diazepam and preliminary electrical pain stimulation induced activation of self-stimulation. It is concluded that diazepam and the activation of the positive reinforcing system exert similar effects on 11-HCS excretion and lipid levels after pain stimulation.     

急性神经损伤引起脊髓背角C-纤维诱发电位长时程增强

神经损伤引起神经病性疼痛,表现为持续性痛超敏和痛觉过敏。目前对神经病性疼痛的机制尚缺乏了解。我们以往的工作表明强直电刺激坐骨神经可引起脊髓背角C-纤维诱发电位的长时程增强(long-term potentiation,LTP),该LTP被认为是病理性疼痛的突触模型。本研究的目的在于探讨急性神经损伤是否能在完整动物的脊髓背角诱发出C-纤维诱发电位LTP。在以测试刺激(10～20V,0．5ms)电刺激坐骨神经的同时在脊髓背角用微电极记录C一纤维诱发电位。分别用强直刺激、剪断或夹捏坐骨神经诱导LTP。结果发现：(1)剪断或夹捏坐骨神经都可以诱导脊髓背角C-纤维诱发电位的LTP,该LTP可持续到实验结束(3～9h),在剪断神经前10min用利多卡因局部阻滞坐骨神经则可完全阻断LTP的产生;(2)神经损伤诱导的LTP可被NMDA受体阻断剂AP5所阻断;(3)用单次强直刺激引起LTP后,切断坐骨神经可使LTP的幅度进一步增大,而用多次强直电刺激使LTP饱和后,损伤神经则不能使LTP进一步增大。切断神经引起LTP后,强直电刺激也不能使LTP进一步增大。这些结果表明,急性神经损伤可以诱导脊髓背角C纤维诱发电位LTP,且切断神经能更有效地诱导LTP。该试验进一步支持我们的设想,即脊髓背角C-纤维诱发电位LTP可能在病理性疼痛的形成中起重要作用。     

Elevated immunoreactive beta-endorphin level in ventricular fluid after analgesic electrical stimulation of posteromedial hypothalamus

Immunoreactive beta-endorphin (beta-EP) in the ventricular fluid of six carcinomatous patients was measured using a specific radioimmunoassay. The subjects were undergoing a surgical procedure for relief of chronic intractable pain. This procedure involved the focal stimulation and coagulation of the posteromedial hypothalamus. Samples of ventricular fluid were collected before and after the stimulation and serially after the coagulation. Prior to stimulation, beta-EP-like immunoreactivity (beta-EP-LI) was below 200 pg/ml. In all of the six patients with pain relief, electrical stimulation led to a marked increase in immunoreactive beta-EP. In three patients beta-EP levels remained high after electrical coagulation for 6-24 hrs. These results suggest that beta-EP-like material, released into the ventricular fluid, may contribute to the initial pain blockade that results from stimulation and coagulation of the posteromedial hypothalamus.     

Modification of Electrical Pain Threshold by Voluntary Breathing-Controlled Electrical Stimulation (BreEStim) in Healthy Subjects

Background

Pain has a distinct sensory and affective (i.e., unpleasantness) component. BreEStim, during which electrical stimulation is delivered during voluntary breathing, has been shown to selectively reduce the affective component of post-amputation phantom pain. The objective was to examine whether BreEStim increases pain threshold such that subjects could have improved tolerance of sensation of painful stimuli.

Methods

Eleven pain-free healthy subjects (7 males, 4 females) participated in the study. All subjects received BreEStim (100 stimuli) and conventional electrical stimulation (EStim, 100 stimuli) to two acupuncture points (Neiguan and Weiguan) of the dominant hand in a random order. The two different treatments were provided at least three days apart. Painful, but tolerable electrical stimuli were delivered randomly during EStim, but were triggered by effortful inhalation during BreEStim. Measurements of tactile sensation threshold, electrical sensation and electrical pain thresholds, thermal (cold sensation, warm sensation, cold pain and heat pain) thresholds were recorded from the thenar eminence of both hands. These measurements were taken pre-intervention and 10−min post-intervention.

Results

There was no difference in the pre-intervention baseline measurement of all thresholds between BreEStim and EStim. The electrical pain threshold significantly increased after BreEStim (27.5±6.7% for the dominant hand and 28.5±10.8% for the non-dominant hand, respectively). The electrical pain threshold significantly decreased after EStim (9.1±2.8% for the dominant hand and 10.2±4.6% for the non–dominant hand, respectively) (F_{[1, 10]} = 30.992, p = .00024). There was no statistically significant change in other thresholds after BreEStim and EStim. The intensity of electrical stimuli was progressively increased, but no difference was found between BreEStim and EStim.

Conclusion

Voluntary breathing controlled electrical stimulation selectively increases electrical pain threshold, while conventional electrical stimulation selectively decreases electrical pain threshold. This may translate into improved pain control.     

Thalamic stimulation for chronic pain

Electrical stimulation of the thalamus was found to be effective for the treatment of chronic intractable pain of various etiologies. Diencephalic recordings revealed spontaneous focal electrical discharge patterns with relatively low activation thresholds. Localization of the optimum thalamic discharge site is used as a guide for the electrode implant to be used for chronic stimulation. The thalamic sites which most frequently displayed the low threshold spontaneous focal discharge activity were the CM-Pf complex and related intralaminar nuclear structures. Generation of diencephalic pain-reverberating circuits was discussed in relation to explaining the pain syndromes herein described. The applied electrical stimulation is thought to electrophysiologically 'jam' the low threshold discharging systems and thereby alleviate pain.     

Pain relief following stimulation of the pontomesencephalic parabrachial region in humans: brain sites for nonopiate-mediated pain control

It has been demonstrated that stimulation of the pontomesencephalic parabrachial region (PBR) by microinjection of cholinergic drugs or electricity in the cat produces potent pain suppression which is not antagonized by the opiate antagonist, naloxone. We report the application of electrical PBR stimulation in 2 patients whose pain was resistant to conventional methods of treatment including morphine administration. Intermittent use of low-frequency PBR stimulation was found to relieve pain in these patients. The present results appear to suggest that PBR stimulation, unlike periaqueductal gray stimulation, may be useful for the control of morphine-resistant pain in humans.     

The perception of painful and nonpainful stimuli during voluntary motor activity in man

Previous studies have shown that voluntary movement diminishes the transmission of cutaneous afferent input through the dorsal column-medial lemniscal system, and also raises the threshold for detecting nonpainful, cutaneous stimuli (electrical shocks). Although there is some evidence that pain elicited by electrical stimulation is diminished during movement, no studies have tested the effect of movement on the perception of pain produced by natural stimulation. For this reason, we tested the effects of voluntary motor activity on the perception of noxious thermal stimuli in human volunteers. We first developed a motor paradigm in which the thermal stimulation could be applied to the immobile limb (isometric elbow flexion-extension). Both isometric and isotonic muscle contractions about the elbow increased the threshold for detecting weak cutaneous stimuli (electrical shocks) applied to the forearm, and to a lesser extent the detection of stimuli applied to the dorsum of the hand. Afterwards, noxious and innocuous heat stimuli were applied to the forearm during isometric contractions and at rest. Magnitude estimates for the intensity of the pain, as well as latency measures of the onset of pain, were recorded. We found no evidence that isometric motor activity diminished either the threshold for pain or the subjective intensity of the noxious and innocuous thermal stimuli. Thus, motor activity decreases the ability to detect weak low-threshold cutaneous inputs, but has no effect on the perception of warmth and heat pain.     

Familial Risk of Chronic Musculoskeletal Pain and the Importance of Physical Activity and Body Mass Index: Prospective Data from the HUNT Study,Norway

The main objectives of the current study was i) to prospectively examine if chronic musculoskeletal pain in parents is associated with risk of chronic musculoskeletal pain in their adult offspring, and ii) to assess if these parent-offspring associations are modified by offspring body mass index and leisure time physical activity. We used data on 4,742 adult offspring linked with their parents who participated in the population-based HUNT Study in Norway in 1995–97 and in 2006–08. Family relations were established through the national Family Registry. A Poisson regression model was used to estimate relative risk (RR) with 95% confidence interval (CI). In total, 1,674 offspring (35.3%) developed chronic musculoskeletal pain during the follow-up period of approximately 11 years. Both maternal (RR: 1.26, 95% CI: 1.03, 1.55) and paternal chronic musculoskeletal pain (RR: 1.29, 95% CI: 1.06, 1.57) was associated with increased risk of offspring chronic musculoskeletal pain. Compared to offspring of parents without chronic musculoskeletal pain, the adverse effect of parental pain was somewhat stronger among offspring who reported a low (RR: 1.82, 95% CI: 1.32, 2.52) versus high (RR: 1.32, 95% CI: 0.95, 1.84) level of leisure time physical activity. Offspring of parents with chronic musculoskeletal pain and who were classified as obese had more than twofold increased risk (RR: 2.33, 95% CI: 1.68, 3.24) of chronic musculoskeletal pain compared to normal weight offspring of parents without pain. In conclusion, parental chronic musculoskeletal pain is positively associated with risk of chronic musculoskeletal pain in their adult offspring. Maintenance of normal body weight may reduce the risk of chronic musculoskeletal pain in offspring of pain-afflicted parents.     

Individual differences in the levels of pain sensitivity and analgesic effect of morphine in noninbred mice

The initial threshold of pain sensitivity and the degree of morphine analgesia (12, 12, 70 mg/kg, i. p.) were assessed during mechanical, thermal and electrical stimulation, respectively, in noninbred white male mice. Two tests were performed, the second a week after the first one. A slight positive correlation (r = +0.39) between the initial threshold of pain reaction and the analgetic effect of morphine was found only during electrical stimulation in the first test, and positive correlation between the first and the second test during electrical and mechanical stimulation (0.34 and 0.27, respectively) was determined. The degree of morphine analgesia in different animals during second testing could either increase or decrease. It is suggested that previous testing of morphine analgetic effect cannot predict the efficacy of analgesia during the second testing and that the initial threshold of pain sensitivity cannot serve as a reliable predictor of morphine analgesia level.     

A method for studying the peripheral mediators of the dental pain induced by electrical stimulation.

A useful method is described in this paper for studying the mediators released from tooth pulp of the dog during the electrical stimulation of dentine. This method is based upon the perfusion of the pulp and superfusing the return continuously over the isolated, in cascade, cat jejunum and rat stomach fundus strip. The presented evidences in this study indicate the possibility of the release of bradykinin and prostaglandin - like materials from the tooth pulp during the electrical stimulation of dentine. Possible relationship of these mediators and tooth pain due to the electrical stimulation of dentine is discussed.     

Changes in the activity of plasma beta-endorphin-like-immunoreactivity induced by transcutaneous stimulation of the brain

A newly devised technique of electrical transcutaneous brain stimulation has been applied to a population of cephalalgic patients in order to assess its proficiency in pain relieving and in increasing the concentration of serum endorphins. A significant pain relief associated with an increase in serum endorphins has been obtained only in those patients in which clinical and instrumental evaluations had identified the headache as one of "organic" origin. By contrast both in "non organic" and in control subjects the technique has proved to be effectiveless. Our results suggest that transcutaneous electrical brain stimulation can affect the release of endogenous opioids relieving pain at least in selected patients.     

Combined electrical stimulation of the periaqueductal gray matter and sensory thalamus

11 patients with chronic intractable pain of at least 3 years' duration underwent a morphine infusion test, the results of which suggested a syndrome of superimposed somatogenic and neurogenic pain components. They then underwent stereotactic implantation of a dual-channel brain stimulation system with two brain electrodes, one in the left periaqueductal gray matter (PAG) and the other in the sensory thalamus contralateral to the neurogenic pain. Using this system, all patients have obtained excellent simultaneous relief of both pain components (follow-up 12-36 months). The findings support a notion of two separate sensory modulating systems. They indicate that combined electrical stimulation of the PAG and sensory thalamus is a technically feasible and clinically satisfactory modality for the control of pain in humans, and they appear to indicate that better pain control is obtained by continuous, cycled stimulation of the PAG than by the conventional mode of stimulation.     

Model-based development of neuroprosthesis for paraplegic patients.

In paraplegic patients with upper motor neuron lesions the signal path from the central nervous system to the muscles is interrupted. Functional electrical stimulation applied to the lower motor neurons can replace the lacking signals. A so-called neuroprosthesis may be used to restore motor function in paraplegic patients on the basis of functional electrical stimulation. However, the control of multiple joints is difficult due to the complexity, nonlinearity, and time-variance of the system involved. Furthermore, effects such as muscle fatigue, spasticity, and limited force in the stimulated muscle further complicate the control task. Mathematical models of the human musculoskeletal system can support the development of neuroprosthesis. In this article a detailed overview of the existing work in the literature is given and two examples developed by the author are presented that give an insight into model-based development of neuroprosthesis for paraplegic patients. It is shown that modelling the musculoskeletal system can provide better understanding of muscular force production and movement coordination principles. Models can also be used to design and test stimulation patterns and feedback control strategies. Additionally, model components can be implemented in a controller to improve control performance. Eventually, the use of musculoskeletal models for neuroprosthesis design may help to avoid internal disturbances such as fatigue and optimize muscular force output. Furthermore, better controller quality can be obtained than in previous empirical approaches. In addition, the number of experimental tests to be performed with human subjects can be reduced. It is concluded that mathematical models play an increasing role in the development of reliable closed-loop controlled, lower extremity neuroprostheses.     

Absence attacks controlled by thalamic stimulation

Thalamic electrical stimulation in 3 patients alleviated chronic pain, absence attacks and spontaneously occurring delta and theta EEG discharges. It is suggested that diencephalic discharges may activate and/or lower the threshold for pain at the level of the diencephalon.     

痛觉诱发电位的研究进展

痛觉诱发电位的研究在过去的几十年内取得了重要进展 ,出现了许多用于被试的诱发明确疼痛感的刺激技术 ,并与诱发电位方法学联合应用 ,已经成为脑映像学研究中重要的组成部分。本文从刺激技术、痛觉诱发电位成分分析和偶极子源分析等方面出发 ,讨论了痛觉诱发电位的研究进展     

The dynamics of forming an active defensive reflex in cats]

Active defensive reflexes were elaborated in cats with pain stimulations of the forepaw by means of an electrical pricking device with a target attached to it. The elaboration was carried out during action of a flickering light used for the convenience of the EEG analysis. Repeated pain stimulation led to elaboration of an aggressive attacking reaction, chiefly manifested in the paw striking the target. At the beginning of the elaboration, passive-defensive reactions were manifest, which did not completely disappear even after formation of a stable attacking reflex. Two types of active defensive reflexes were elaborated: A-type reflex which helped the animal to get rid of the pain stimulation at the very beginning; B-type reflex which prevented the pain stimulation. The difference beteween these two types is discussed.     

Effect of dorsal column stimulation on pain-induced intracerebral impulse patterns.

Evoked electrical potentials were recorded via intracerebral electrodes in a patient with stump and phantom limb pain who had a previously implanted dorsal column stimulator. When pain was elicited by peripheral stimulation it was found that positive deflections appeared in the ventrolateral nucleus of the thalamus at time latencies corresponding to the propagation velocities of A delta- and C-fibres. Dorsal column stimulation completely eliminated the C-fibres. Dorsal column stimulation completely eliminated the C-fibre deflection and partially eliminated the A delta-fibre deflection.     

Motion control of the ankle joint with a multiple contact nerve cuff electrode: a simulation study

The flat interface nerve electrode (FINE) has demonstrated significant capability for fascicular and subfascicular stimulation selectivity. However, due to the inherent complexity of the neuromuscular skeletal systems and nerve–electrode interface, a trajectory tracking motion control algorithm of musculoskeletal systems for functional electrical stimulation using a multiple contact nerve cuff electrode such as FINE has not yet been developed. In our previous study, a control system was developed for multiple-input multiple-output (MIMO) musculoskeletal systems with little prior knowledge of the system. In this study, more realistic computational ankle/subtalar joint model including a finite element model of the sciatic nerve was developed. The control system was tested to control the motion of ankle/subtalar joint angles by modulating the pulse amplitude of each contact of a FINE placed on the sciatic nerve. The simulation results showed that the control strategy based on the separation of steady state and dynamic properties of the system resulted in small output tracking errors for different reference trajectories such as sinusoidal and filtered random signals. The proposed control method also demonstrated robustness against external disturbances and system parameter variations such as muscle fatigue. These simulation results under various circumstances indicate that it is possible to take advantage of multiple contact nerve electrodes with spatial selectivity for the control of limb motion by peripheral nerve stimulation even with limited individual muscle selectivity. This technology could be useful to restore neural function in patients with paralysis.     

Multimodal assessment of pain in the esophagus: a new experimental model

A new multimodal pain assessment model was developed integrating electrical, mechanical, cold, and warmth stimuli into the same device. The device, with a bag and electrodes for electrical stimulation, was positioned in the lower part of the esophagus in 11 healthy subjects. Mechanical stimuli were delivered with an impedance planimetric system. Thermal stimuli were performed by circulating water of different temperatures (5-50 degrees C) inside the bag. All subjects reported both nonpainful and painful local and referred sensations to all stimuli. Temporal summation to repeated electrical stimuli could be studied. For all stimuli, there was a relationship between stimulus intensity and pain intensity. The referred pain area increased with increasing intensity of the electrical and mechanical stimuli. There were several differences between the sensations evoked by the four stimulus modalities, indicating activation of different visceral nerve pathways. This model offers the possibility for controlled multimodal stimuli activating the superficial and deeper layers of the human gut and should be used in basic, clinical, and pharmacological pain studies.