Heat resistance of bacterial spores correlated with protoplast dehydration, mineralization, and thermal adaptation

Twenty-eight types of lysozyme-sensitive spores among seven Bacillus species representative of thermophiles, mesophiles, and psychrophiles were obtained spanning a 3,000-fold range in moist-heat resistance. The resistance within species was altered by demineralization of the native spores to protonated spores and remineralization of the protonated spores to calcified spores and by thermal adaptation at maximum, optimum, and minimum sporulation temperatures. Protoplast wet densities, and thereby protoplast water contents, were obtained by buoyant density sedimentation in Nycodenz gradients (Nyegaard and Co., Oslo, Norway). Increases in mineralization and thermal adaptation caused reductions in protoplast water content between limits of ca. 57 and 28% (wet weight basis), and thereby correlated with increases in sporal heat resistance. Above and below these limits, however, increases in mineralization and thermal adaptation correlated with increases in sporal resistance independently of unchanged protoplast water contents. All three factors evidently contributed to and were necessary for heat resistance of the spores, but dehydration predominated.     

Haemagglutination and surface structures in strains of Clostridium spiroforme

The low heat resistance (D100 = 0.554 min, z = 13.4 degrees C) of dormant lysozyme-sensitized spores of Bacillus sphaericus 9602 was correlated with a low protoplast wet density (1.305 g/ml) equivalent to a high protoplast water content (61.0%, wet weight basis). These values for these unusual spores were consistent with those correlated previously in 28 spore types of seven other species.     

Characteization of bacterial spores from high-temperature growth transformants ofBacillus subtilis

Spores from high-temperature growth transformants ofBacillus subtilis were examined for a number of sporal characteristics. Analyses showed a dramatic increase in both the calcium (Ca) and dipicolinic acid (DPA) contents, a slight increase in the Ca/DPA mole ratio, but a reduction in magnesium (Mg) content and the Mg/Ca mole ratio. The spore wet density increased, whereas the core/core+cortex volume ratio and protoplast water content decreased. Spore heat resistance increased but not to levels normally observed for thermophilicBacillus species. It is concluded that the biophysical and biochemical changes within the spores of the transformants are influenced by both the inherent mesophilic genotype and the transformant's inherited ability to grow at elevated temperatures.Florida Agricultural Experiment Station, Journal Series No. 8189     

Bacterial spore heat resistance correlated with water content, wet density, and protoplast/sporoplast volume ratio.

Five types of dormant Bacillus spores, between and within species, were selected representing a 600-fold range in moist-heat resistance determined as a D100 value. The wet and dry density and the solids and water content of the entire spore and isolated integument of each type were determined directly from gram masses of material, with correction for interstitial water. The ratio between the volume occupied by the protoplast (the structures bounded by the inner pericytoplasm membrane) and the volume occupied by the sporoplast (the structures bounded by the outer pericortex membrane) was calculated from measurements made on electron micrographs of medially thin-sectioned spores. Among the various spore types, an exponential increase in the heat resistance correlated directly with the wet density and inversely with the water content and with the protoplast/sporoplast volume ratio. Altogether with results supported a hypothesis that the extent of heat resistance is based in whole or in part on the extent of dehydration and diminution of the protoplast in the dormant spore, without implications about physiological mechanisms for attaining this state.     

Protoplast dehydration correlated with heat resistance of bacterial spores.

Water content of the protoplast in situ within the fully hydrated dormant bacterial spore was quantified by use of a spore in which the complex of coat and outer (pericortex) membrane was genetically defective or chemically removed, as evidenced by susceptibility of the cortex to lysozyme and by permeability of the periprotoplast integument to glucose. Water content was determined by equilibrium permeability measurement with 3H-labeled water (confirmed by gravimetric measurement) for the entire spore, with 14C-labeled glucose for the integument outside the inner (pericytoplasm) membrane, and by the difference for the protoplast. The method was applied to lysozyme-sensitive spores of Bacillus stearothermophilus, B. subtilis, B. cereus, B. thuringiensis, and B. megaterium (four types). Comparable lysozyme-resistant spores, in which the outer membrane functioned as the primary permeability barrier to glucose, were employed as controls. Heat resistances were expressed as D100 values. Protoplast water content of the lysozyme-sensitive spore types correlated with heat resistance exponentially in two distinct clusters, with the four B. megaterium types in one alignment, and with the four other species types in another. Protoplast water contents of the B. megaterium spore types were sufficiently low (26 to 29%, based on wet protoplast weight) to account almost entirely for their lesser heat resistance. Corresponding values of the other species types were similar or higher (30 to 55%), indicating that these spores depended on factors additional to protoplast dehydration for their much greater heat resistance.     

Resistance, germination, and permeability correlates of Bacillus megaterium spores successively divested of integument layers

A variant strain that produced spores lacking exosporium was isolated from a culture of Bacillus megaterium QM-B1551. Two additional spore morphotypes were obtained from the parent and variant strains by chemical removal of the complex of coat and outer membrane. Among the four morphotype spores, heat resistance did not correlate with total water content, wet density, refractive index, or dipicolinate or cation content, but did correlate with the volume ratio of protoplast to protoplast plus cortex. The divestment of integument layers exterior to the cortex had little influence on heat resistance. Moreover, the divestment did not change the response of either the parent or the variant spores to various germination-initiating agents, except for making the spores susceptible to germination by lysozyme. The primary permeability barrier to glucose for the intact parent and variant spores was found to be the outer membrane, whereas the barrier for the divested spores was the inner membrane.     

Temperature dependence of thermal inactivation rate constants of bacterial spores in a glassy state

Summary Differential scanning calorimetry data obtained from corn embryos is consistent with the hypothesis of their glassy state. This work extends that hypothesis to explain the speculation about the high heat resistance of bacterial spores. By considering the protoplast to be in a glassy solid-state, it can be assumed that the configurational rearrangements of the key life dependent polymer chain backbones (DNA, etc.) are extremely slow, thereby ceasing thermal motions. It is assumed that at the glass transition temperature, the spore protoplast undergoes a discontinuity in the thermal expansion coefficient, and above this critical temperature, the rate of thermal inactivation of spores is free volume dependent and can be described adequately by the William, Landel and Ferry (WLF) equation. Glass transition temperatures forBacillus stearothermophilus andClostridium botulinum spores, obtained by fitting the inactivation rate data to the WLF equation, indicate a decrease in the inactivation rates with increasing glass-transition temperatures.     

Protoplast water content of bacterial spores determined by buoyant density sedimentation.

Protoplast wet densities (1.315 to 1.400 g/ml), determined by buoyant density sedimentation in Metrizamide gradients, were correlated inversely with the protoplast water contents (26.4 to 55.0 g of water/100 g of wet protoplast) of nine diverse types of pure lysozyme-sensitive dormant bacterial spores. The correlation equation provided a precise method for obtaining the protoplast water contents of other spore types with small impure samples and indicated that the average protoplast dry density was 1.460 g/ml.     

The effect of sporulation temperature on sporal characteristics ofBacillus subtilis A

Spores ofBacillus subtilis A were produced at different temperatures (23°–49°C) and examined for a number of sporal characteristics. Spore heat resistance increased with sporulation temperature to 45°C, with spores grown at 49°C showing a dramatic reduction in resistance. Spore crops showed biphasic thermal death curves whether enumerated on germination medium with or without calcium dipicolinate. This strain produces both rough and smooth variants. Of the spores produced at 23°C, 99% were rough, had a density of 1.305, and an average core/core + cortex volume ratio of 0.1838. At 49°C, 99% were smooth, had a density of 1.275, and an average volume ratio of 0.3098. Between these temperatures both spore types were produced. There appeared to be no direct correlation with sporulation temperature, heat resistance, and dipicolinate content. There was an increase in both the magnesium and calcium contents to 45°C with a dramatic reduction at 49°C. The 1.305 density spores had higher calcium and dipicolinate contents than the 1.275 spores, although both spore types showed biphasic thermal death curves. The mechanisms involved in determining which spore type (rough/smooth) is produced at a specific growth temperature is unknown.Florida Agricultural Experiment Station Journal Series Number R-00312.     

Calculation of mass and water content between the core,cortex, and coat ofBacillus stearothermophilus spores

The water contents and effective water activity of the core, cortex, and coat ofBacillus stearothermophilus spores in water, as well as the masses of the core, cortex, and coat in the dry state, were calculated from volumes, dry densities, and water absorption isotherms of the sporal components. The calculation depended upon the solution of simple simultaneous equations for the dry mass, dry volume, wet mass, and wet volume of the spore and its components. The effective water activity of the core and cortex was found to be 0.83.     

Spores of Bacillus subtilis: their resistance to and killing by radiation, heat and chemicals

A number of mechanisms are responsible for the resistance of spores of Bacillus species to heat, radiation and chemicals and for spore killing by these agents. Spore resistance to wet heat is determined largely by the water content of spore core, which is much lower than that in the growing cell protoplast. A lower core water content generally gives more wet heat-resistant spores. The level and type of spore core mineral ions and the intrinsic stability of total spore proteins also play a role in spore wet heat resistance, and the saturation of spore DNA with alpha/beta-type small, acid-soluble spore proteins (SASP) protects DNA against wet heat damage. However, how wet heat kills spores is not clear, although it is not through DNA damage. The alpha/beta-type SASP are also important in spore resistance to dry heat, as is DNA repair in spore outgrowth, as Bacillus subtilis spores are killed by dry heat via DNA damage. Both UV and gamma-radiation also kill spores via DNA damage. The mechanism of spore resistance to gamma-radiation is not well understood, although the alpha/beta-type SASP are not involved. In contrast, spore UV resistance is due largely to an alteration in spore DNA photochemistry caused by the binding of alpha/beta-type SASP to the DNA, and to a lesser extent to the photosensitizing action of the spore core's large pool of dipicolinic acid. UV irradiation of spores at 254 nm does not generate the cyclobutane dimers (CPDs) and (6-4)-photoproducts (64PPs) formed between adjacent pyrimidines in growing cells, but rather a thymidyl-thymidine adduct termed spore photoproduct (SP). While SP is formed in spores with approximately the same quantum efficiency as that for generation of CPDs and 64PPs in growing cells, SP is repaired rapidly and efficiently in spore outgrowth by a number of repair systems, at least one of which is specific for SP. Some chemicals (e.g. nitrous acid, formaldehyde) again kill spores by DNA damage, while others, in particular oxidizing agents, appear to damage the spore's inner membrane so that this membrane ruptures upon spore germination and outgrowth. There are also other agents such as glutaraldehyde for which the mechanism of spore killing is unclear. Factors important in spore chemical resistance vary with the chemical, but include: (i) the spore coat proteins that likely react with and detoxify chemical agents; (ii) the relative impermeability of the spore's inner membrane that restricts access of exogenous chemicals to the spore core; (iii) the protection of spore DNA by its saturation with alpha/beta-type SASP; and (iv) DNA repair for agents that kill spores via DNA damage. Given the importance of the killing of spores of Bacillus species in the food and medical products industry, a deeper understanding of the mechanisms of spore resistance and killing may lead to improved methods for spore destruction.     

Relationship between the heat resistance of spores and the optimum and maximum growth temperatures of Bacillus species

Heat resistance of spores of Bacillus strains was compared with the temperature adaptation of each strain as measured by the optimum and maximum growth temperatures and the heat resistance of vegetative cells. Maximum growth temperatures ranged from 31 to 76 degrees C and were little affected by the nature of the growth medium. The temperature giving maximum growth rate was closely correlated to the maximum temperature for growth, and about 6 degrees C lower. Vetetative-cell heat resistance, determined on exponential-phase cells, was also correlated with maximum growth temperature. The temperature at which spores were inactivated with a decimal reduction time of 10 min was in the range of 75 to 121 degrees C. This temperature was 46 +/- 7 degrees C higher than the maximum growth temperature and correlated with it and the other cell parameters. Spore heat resistance can be considered to have two components, the temperature adaptation characteristic of the species and the stabilization conferred by the spore state.     

Osmotically induced increase in thermal resistance of heat-sensitive, dipicolinic acid-less spores of Bacillus cereus Ht-8.

Thermal resistance in heat-sensitive, dipicolinic acid (DPA)-less spores of Bacillus cereus Ht-8 heated in sucrose solutions increased at and above a concentration of 2 M sucrose. The decimal reduction times at 75 degrees C for spores heated in 0.0, 1.8, 2.2, and 2.6 M sucrose were 2.0, 2.8, 4.5, and 12 min, respectively. Maltose, fructose, and glucose increased heat resistance above that observed in water but did not elevate resistance to the level observed with sucrose at the same osmolality. Cation-induced loss of thermal resistance in chemically sensitized spores was reversed in the presence of sucrose. Spores germinated in brain heart infusion were resistant when heated in sucrose. In the presence of sucrose, spores exhibited an increase in optical density at 700 nm. Electron micrographs of the DPA-less spores suspended in 2.2 M sucrose revealed a shrinkage of outer coats and exosporium membranes. The results suggested that the osmotic property of sugars increased thermal resistance in DPA-less spores. The osmotic pressure exerted by sugars may be similar to the pressure that usually exists within the cortex of normal spores containing DPA and may cause the dehydration of the protoplast and the consequent thermal resistance. The role of dehydration and the nonessential nature of DPA for thermal resistance in spores were confirmed.     

Osmotically induced increase in thermal resistance of heat-sensitive, dipicolinic acid-less spores of Bacillus cereus Ht-8.

Thermal resistance in heat-sensitive, dipicolinic acid (DPA)-less spores of Bacillus cereus Ht-8 heated in sucrose solutions increased at and above a concentration of 2 M sucrose. The decimal reduction times at 75 degrees C for spores heated in 0.0, 1.8, 2.2, and 2.6 M sucrose were 2.0, 2.8, 4.5, and 12 min, respectively. Maltose, fructose, and glucose increased heat resistance above that observed in water but did not elevate resistance to the level observed with sucrose at the same osmolality. Cation-induced loss of thermal resistance in chemically sensitized spores was reversed in the presence of sucrose. Spores germinated in brain heart infusion were resistant when heated in sucrose. In the presence of sucrose, spores exhibited an increase in optical density at 700 nm. Electron micrographs of the DPA-less spores suspended in 2.2 M sucrose revealed a shrinkage of outer coats and exosporium membranes. The results suggested that the osmotic property of sugars increased thermal resistance in DPA-less spores. The osmotic pressure exerted by sugars may be similar to the pressure that usually exists within the cortex of normal spores containing DPA and may cause the dehydration of the protoplast and the consequent thermal resistance. The role of dehydration and the nonessential nature of DPA for thermal resistance in spores were confirmed.     

Mineralization and responses of bacterial spores to heat and oxidative agents

Abstract: Mineralization of bacterial spores with Ca²⁺ and a variety of other mineral cations enhances resistance to heat damage. Part of the enhancement is associated with increased dehydration of the mineralized protoplast or spore core, while part is independent of dehydration and effective for resistance even to dry heat. Spore mineralization was found also to enhance resistance to oxidative damage caused by agents such as tertiary butyl hydroperoxide or H₂0₂. In contrast, mineral cations in the environment increased oxidative damage, presumably by catalyzing radical formation. Metal ion chelators such as o-phenanthroline protected spores against such damage.     

Effect of sporulation and recovery medium on the heat resistance and amount of injury of spores from spoilage bacilli

AIMS: To assess the influence of sporulation media on heat resistance, and the use of stress recovery media to measure preservation injury of spores of five representative spoilage bacilli. METHODS AND RESULTS: Bacillus spores prepared on nutrient agar supplemented with Ca2+, Mg2+, Mn2+, Fe2+ and K+ were more heat-resistant than spores obtained from nutrient agar with Mn2+. This increased heat resistance correlated with a decrease in the protoplast water content as determined by buoyant density sedimentation. The degree of preservation injury severity could be assessed on media containing NaCl at moderate pH and organic acids at acid pH. Ca-DPA, K+ or proline were added to the recovery media to demonstrate that heat probably caused injury to both spore germination and the outgrowth system. SIGNIFICANCE AND IMPACT OF THE STUDY: The metal content of sporulation media can strongly effect the validity of preservation resistance studies. The distinctive recovery media developed here can be relevant for assessing and comparing new preservation technologies.     

Effect of the internal water activity of bacterial spores on their heat resistance in water

The water contents and effective a_w of the core, cortex, and coat of spores in water, as well as the masses of the core, cortex, and coat plus exosporium in the dry state, are calculated from volumes, dry densities, and water absorption isotherms of the sporal components. From data presented here for spores ofBacillus subtilis var.niger andBacillus cereus T, and from previously published data forBacillus stearothermophilus, the logarithm of the heat resistance of the spores in water is linearly related to the effective a_w of their core and cortex.     

Tailing of survivor curves of clostridial spores heated in edible oils

Tailing of survivor curves was observed for Clostridium sporogenes PA 3679 and Cl. botulinum 62A spores heated whilst suspended in edible oils, but not for the same spores suspended in buffer (pH 7.2) or mineral oil or for Bacillus cereus F4165/75 spores suspended in buffer or oils. The tailing cannot be ascribed to a genetic or developmental heterogeneity in the resistance of the spore population or to a heterogeneity of the treatment severity during heating. Heat adaptation due to the release of protective factor(s), to the selection for resistant spores or to the diffusion of oil constituents inside the spore protoplast to protect key molecules from heat denaturation was also ruled out. The tailing can be ascribed to spore clumping during the course of heating or to a heterogeneity in heat resistance of germination system(s) within spores, concurrently with the activation of a dormant germination system. It is probably caused by some oleic acid containing triglycerides.     

Tailing of survivor curves of clostridial spores heated in edible oils

Tailing of survivor curves was observed for Clostridium sporogenes PA 3679 and Cl. botulinum 62A spores heated whilst suspended in edible oils, but not for the same spores suspended in buffer (pH 7˙2) or mineral oil or for Bacillus cereus F4165/75 spores suspended in buffer or oils. The tailing cannot be ascribed to a genetic or developmental heterogeneity in the resistance of the spore population or to a heterogeneity of the treatment severity during heating. Heat adaptation due to the release of protective factor(s), to the selection for resistant spores or to the diffusion of oil constituents inside the spore protoplast to protect key molecules from heat denaturation was also ruled out. The tailing can be ascribed to spore clumping during the course of heating or to a heterogeneity in heat resistance of germination system(s) within spores, concurrently with the activation of a dormant germination system. It is probably caused by some oleic acid containing triglycerides.     

The influence of the cortex on protoplast dehydration in bacterial spores studied with light scattering

Individual, dormant spores ofBacillus sphaericus were studied with laser diffractometry. Correlation coefficients were obtained for the water content and radius of the protoplast and the water content and thickness of the integument of the spores. The coefficients showed that the states of the protoplast and the integument were interrelated. The water contents of the protoplast and the integument were positively correlated (=0.73), and spores with thinner integuments had more dehydrated protoplasts. The coefficients were compared with qualitative predictions based on current models of the mechanism responsible for protoplast dehydration. The results did not support models involving an expansion of the cortex as the cause of the dehydration, but were consistent with cortex contraction and the model in which the cortex maintained rather than produced the dehydrated state of the protoplast.