LET dependence of lethality in <Emphasis Type="Italic">Arabidopsis thaliana</Emphasis> irradiated by heavy ions

To clarify the effect of heavy ions in plants, dry seeds of Arabidopsis were irradiated with carbon, neon, and argon ions with various linear energy transfer (LET) values. The relative biological effectiveness (RBE) for lethality peaked at LET values over 350 keV/microns for neon and argon ions. This LET giving the peak RBE was higher than the LET of 100-200 keV/microns which was reported to have a maximum RBE for other types of cells, such as mammalian cells. Furthermore, sterility showed a higher RBE at an LET of 354 keV/microns with neon ions than that at an LET of 113 keV/microns with carbon ions. Lethality and sterility are both considered to be caused by damage to DNA. The results indicate that the LET having a maximum of RBE for lethality is higher in Arabidopsis seeds than in other unicellular systems. The most likely explanation for this shift of LET is that the DNA in dry seeds has a different chemical environment and/or hydration state than the DNA in cells in culture.     

The RBE-LET relationship for rodent intestinal crypt cell survival, testes weight loss, and multicellular spheroid cell survival after heavy-ion irradiation.

This report presents data for survival of mouse intestinal crypt cells, mouse testes weight loss as an indicator of survival of spermatogonial stem cells, and survival of rat 9L spheroid cells after irradiation in the plateau region of unmodified particle beams ranging in mass from 4He to 139La. The LET values range from 1.6 to 953 keV/microns. These studies examine the RBE-LET relationship for two normal tissues and for an in vitro tissue model, multicellular spheroids. When the RBE values are plotted as a function of LET, the resulting curve is characterized by a region in which RBE increases with LET, a peak RBE at an LET value of 100 keV/microns, and a region of decreasing RBE at LETs greater than 100 keV/microns. Inactivation cross sections (sigma) for these three biological systems have been calculated from the exponential terminal slope of the dose-response relationship for each ion. For this determination the dose is expressed as particle fluence and the parameter sigma indicates effect per particle. A plot of sigma versus LET shows that the curve for testes weight loss is shifted to the left, indicating greater radiosensitivity at lower LETs than for crypt cell and spheroid cell survival. The curves for cross section versus LET for all three model systems show similar characteristics with a relatively linear portion below 100 keV/microns and a region of lessened slope in the LET range above 100 keV/microns for testes and spheroids. The data indicate that the effectiveness per particle increases as a function of LET and, to a limited extent, Z, at LET values greater than 100 keV/microns. Previously published results for spread Bragg peaks are also summarized, and they suggest that RBE is dependent on both the LET and the Z of the particle.     

Response of colony-forming units-spleen to heavy charged particles

Survival of colony-forming units-spleen (CFU-S) was measured after single doses of photons or heavy charged particles from the BEVALAC. The purposes were to define the radiosensitivity to heavy ions used medically and to evaluate relationships between relative biological effectiveness (RBE) and dose-averaged linear energy transfer (LET infinity). In in vitro irradiation experiments. CFU-S suspensions were exposed to 220 kVp X rays or to 20Ne (372 MeV/micron) or 40Ar (447 MeV/micron) particles in the plateau portion of the Bragg curve. In in vivo irradiation experiments, donor mice from which CFU-S were harvested were exposed to 12C (400 MeV/micron). 20Ne (400 or 670 MeV/micron), or 40Ar (570 MeV/micron) particles in Bragg peaks spread to 4 or 10 cm by spiral ridge filters. Based on RBE at 10 survival, the maximum RBE of 2.1 was observed for 40Ar particles characterized by an LET infinity of approximately 100 keV/micron. Lower RBEs were determined at lower or higher estimated values of LET infinity and ranged from 1.1 for low energy 40Ar particles to 1.5-1.6 for low energy 12C and 20Ne. The responses of CFU-S are compared with responses of other model systems to heavy charged particles and with the reported sensitivity of CFU-S to neutrons of various energies. The maximum RBE reported here, 2.1 for high energy 40Ar particles, is somewhat lower than values reported for fission-spectrum neutrons, and is appreciably lower than values for monoenergetic 0.43-1.8 MeV neutrons. Low energy 12C and 20Ne particles have RBEs in the range of values reported for 14.7 MeV neutrons.     

Biological effectiveness of high-energy protons: target fragmentation.

High-energy protons traversing tissue produce local sources of high-linear-energy-transfer (LET) ions through nuclear fragmentation. We examine the contribution of these target fragments to the biological effectiveness of high-energy protons using the cellular track model. The effects of secondary ions are treated in terms of the production collision density using energy-dependent parameters from a high-energy fragmentation model. Calculations for mammalian cell cultures show that at high dose, at which intertrack effects become important, protons deliver damage similar to that produced by gamma rays, and with fragmentation the relative biological effectiveness (RBE) of protons increases moderately from unity. At low dose, where sublethal damage is unimportant, the contribution from target fragments dominates, causing the proton effectiveness to be very different from that of gamma rays with a strongly fluence-dependent RBE. At high energies, the nuclear fragmentation cross sections become independent of energy. This leads to a plateau in the proton single-particle-action cross section, below 1 keV/micron, since the target fragments dominate.     

Qualitatively different induction of germ cell mutations by heavy ions

Summary The problem of the dependence of the biological efficiency of ionizing radiation on the Linear Energy Transfer (LET) is still unsolved. Unexpected reactions of heavy ion irradiated cellular systems such as an increasing Relative Biological Effectiveness (RBE) up to a LET of about 100 keV/µm and then a decrease below 1 oblige to dismiss some conventional interpretations. Several years ago we suggested that, especially by higher ionization density in addition to the DNA, repair systems and (or) membraneous systems could also be injured (dual target theory). Our experiments with heavy ions at the Lawrence Berkeley Laboratory with LET's between 102–970 keV/µm on different types of mutations show a strict distinction between events connected with fusion modalities (repair or misrepair) and those associated with nonfusion. With very high LET misrepair reactions such as translocations disappear, suggesting the direct damage of the repair systems and confirming our previous experiments with peak pions and ions of LET's between 1100–4800 keV/µm.Dedicated to Prof. W. Jacobi on the occasion of his 60th birthday     

Inactivation of aerobic and hypoxic cells from three different cell lines by accelerated (3)He-, (12)C- and (20)Ne-ion beams

The LET-RBE spectra for cell killing for cultured mammalian cells exposed to accelerated heavy ions were investigated to design a spread-out Bragg peak beam for cancer therapy at HIMAC, National Institute of Radiological Sciences, Chiba, prior to clinical trials. Cells that originated from a human salivary gland tumor (HSG cells) as well as V79 and T1 cells were exposed to (3)He-, (12)C- and (20)Ne-ion beams with an LET ranging from approximately 20-600 keV/micrometer under both aerobic and hypoxic conditions. Cell survival curves were fitted by equations from the linear-quadratic model and the target model to obtain survival parameters. RBE, OER, alpha and D(0) were analyzed as a function of LET. The RBE increased with LET, reaching a maximum at around 200 keV/micrometer, then decreased with a further increase in LET. Clear splits of the LET-RBE or -OER spectra were found among ion species and/or cell lines. At a given LET, the RBE value for (3)He ions was higher than that for the other ions. The position of the maximum RBE shifts to higher LET values for heavier ions. The OER value was 3 for X rays but started to decrease at an LET of around 50 keV/micrometer, passed below 2 at around 100 keV/micrometer, and then reached a minimum above 300 keV/micrometer, but the values remained greater than 1. The OER was significantly lower for (3)He ions than the others.     

Heavy ion effects on yeast: inhibition of ribosomal RNA synthesis

Diploid wild-type yeast cells were exposed to beams of heavy ions covering a wide range of linear energy transfer (LET) (43-13,700 keV/microns). Synthesis of ribosomal RNA (rRNA) was assessed as a functional measure of damage produced by particle radiation. An exponential decrease of relative rRNA synthesis with particle fluence was demonstrated in all cases. The inactivation cross sections derived were found to increase with LET over the entire range of LET studied. The corresponding values for relative biological effectiveness were slightly less than unity. Maximum cross sections measured were close to 1 micron 2, implying that some larger structure within the yeast nucleus (e.g., the nucleolus) might represent the target for an impairment of synthetic activity by very heavy ions rather than the genes coding for rRNA. Where tested, an oxygen effect for rRNA synthesis could not be demonstrated.     

Radiation effects in Caenorhabditis elegans, mutagenesis by high and low LET ionizing radiation

The nematode C. elegans was used to measure the effectiveness of high-energy ionized particles in the induction of 3 types of genetic lesions. Recessive lethal mutations in a 40-map unit autosomal region, sterility, and X-chromosome nondisjunction or damage were investigated. Induction rates were measured as a function of linear energy transfer, LET infinity, for 9 ions of atomic number 1-57 accelerated at the BEVALAC accelerator. Linear kinetics were observed for all 3 types of lesions within the dose/fluence ranges tested and varied strongly as a function of particle LET infinity. Relative Biological Effectiveness (RBE) values of up to 4.2 were measured and action cross sections were calculated and compared to mutagenic responses in other systems.     

Distinct Roles of Ape1 Protein,an Enzyme Involved in DNA Repair,in High or Low Linear Energy Transfer Ionizing Radiation-induced Cell Killing

High linear energy transfer (LET) radiation from space heavy charged particles or a heavier ion radiotherapy machine kills more cells than low LET radiation, mainly because high LET radiation-induced DNA damage is more difficult to repair. Relative biological effectiveness (RBE) is the ratio of the effects generated by high LET radiation to low LET radiation. Previously, our group and others demonstrated that the cell-killing RBE is involved in the interference of high LET radiation with non-homologous end joining but not homologous recombination repair. This effect is attributable, in part, to the small DNA fragments (≤40 bp) directly produced by high LET radiation, the size of which prevents Ku protein from efficiently binding to the two ends of one fragment at the same time, thereby reducing non-homologous end joining efficiency. Here we demonstrate that Ape1, an enzyme required for processing apurinic/apyrimidinic (known as abasic) sites, is also involved in the generation of small DNA fragments during the repair of high LET radiation-induced base damage, which contributes to the higher RBE of high LET radiation-induced cell killing. This discovery opens a new direction to develop approaches for either protecting astronauts from exposure to space radiation or benefiting cancer patients by sensitizing tumor cells to high LET radiotherapy.     

RBE for carcinogenesis following exposure to high LET radiation

Stochastic radiation effects following exposure to heavy ions and other high linear energy transfer (LET) radiation in space are a matter of concern when the long-term consequences of space flights are considered. This paper is an overview of the relevant literature, emphasizing uncertainties entailed from estimates of relative biological effectiveness (RBE) for different experiment end-points, making the choice of a single weighting factor for the prediction of cancer risk in man extremely difficult. Life-span-shortening studies in mice exposed to heavy ions and ongoing large-scale experiments in monkeys exposed to protons suggest that RBEs for all cancers are lower than 5. This does not exclude a much higher RBE for rare tumors such as brain tumors in monkeys or promoted Harderian gland tumours in mice at LET >80 keV/µm. Skin cancer studies in rats exposed to neon or argon resulted in similar RBE. Exposure to fission neutrons led to high RBE in all species, not excluding values much higher than 20 for specific cancers such as lung tumors in mice and all cancers in rats. The estimate of maximal RBE is, however, extremely dependent on the hypothesis made on the shape of the dose-response curves in the lower range of doses. These results suggest that neutrons may be the most hazardous component of high-LET radiation. There is only limited evidence from cancer experiments that LET >150 keV/µm results in highly decreased efficiency, but this has been found for bone cancer induction following exposure to fission fragments.Invited paper presented at the International Symposium on Heavy Ion Research: Space, Radiation Protection and Therapy, Sophia-Antipolis, France, 21–24 March 1994     

Heavy ion-induced DNA double-strand breaks in yeast

Induction of DSBs in the diploid yeast, Saccharomyces cerevisiae, was measured by pulsed-field gel electrophoresis (PFGE) after the cells had been exposed on membrane filters to a variety of energetic heavy ions with values of linear energy transfer (LET) ranging from about 2 to 11,500 keV/microm, (241)Am alpha particles, and 80 keV X rays. After irradiation, the cells were lysed, and the chromosomes were separated by PFGE. The gels were stained with ethidium bromide, placed on a UV transilluminator, and analyzed using a computer-coupled camera. The fluorescence intensities of the larger bands were found to decrease exponentially with dose or particle fluence. The slope of this line corresponds to the cross section for at least one double-strand break (DSB), but closely spaced multiple breaks cannot be discriminated. Based on the known size of the native DNA molecules, breakage cross sections per base pair were calculated. They increased with LET until they reached a transient plateau value of about 6 x 10(-7) microm(2) at about 300-2000 keV/microm; they then rose for the higher LETs, probably reflecting the influence of delta electrons. The relative biological effectiveness for DNA breakage displays a maximum of about 2.5 around 100-200 keV/microm and falls below unity for LET values above 10(3) keV/microm. For these yeast cells, comparison of the derived breakage cross sections with the corresponding cross section for inactivation derived from the terminal slope of the survival curves shows a strong linear relationship between these cross sections, extending over several orders of magnitude.     

Investigation of lipid peroxidation in liposomes induced by heavy ion irradiation

Lipid peroxidation induced by heavy ion irradiation was investigated in 1,2-dilinoleoyl-sn-glycero-3-phosphocholine (DLPC) liposomes. Lipid peroxidation was induced using accelerated heavy ions that exhibit linear energy transfer (LET) values between 30 and 15 000 keV/μm and doses up to 100 kGy. With increasing LET, the formation of lipid peroxidation products such as conjugated dienes, lipid hydroperoxides, and thiobarbituric acid-reactive substances decreased. When comparing differential absorption spectra and membrane fluidity following irradiation with heavy ions and x-rays (3 Gy/min), respectively, it is obvious that there are significant differences between the influences of densely and sparsely ionizing radiation on liposomal membranes. Indications for lipid fragmentation could be detected after heavy ion irradiation. Received: 6 March 1997 / Accepted in revised form: 31 March 1998     

LET and ion species dependence for cell killing in normal human skin fibroblasts

We studied the LET and ion species dependence of the RBE for cell killing to clarify the differences in the biological effects caused by the differences in the track structure that result from the different energy depositions for different ions. Normal human skin fibroblasts were irradiated with heavy-ion beams such as carbon, neon, silicon and iron ions that were generated by the Heavy Ion Medical Accelerator in Chiba (HIMAC) at the National Institute of Radiological Science (NIRS) in Japan. Cell killing was measured as reproductive cell death using a colony formation assay. The RBE-LET curves were different for carbon ions and for the other ions. The curve for carbon ions increased steeply up to around 98 keV/microm. The RBE of carbon ions at 98 keV/microm was 4.07. In contrast, the curves for neon, silicon and iron ions had maximum peaks around 180 keV/microm, and the RBEs at the peak position ranged from 3.03 to 3.39. When the RBEs were plotted as a function of Z*2/beta2 (where Z* is the effective charge and beta is the relative velocity of the ion) instead of LET, the discrepancies between the RBE-LET curves for the different ion beams were reduced, but branching of the RBE-Z*2/beta2 curves still remained. When the inactivation cross section was plotted as a function of either LET or Z*2/beta2, it increased with increasing LET. However, the inactivation cross section was always smaller than the geometrical cross section. These results suggest that the differences in the energy deposition track structures of the different ion sources have an effect on cell killing.     

Heavy ion effects on cellular DNA: strand break induction and repair in cultured diploid lens epithelial cells

The relative biological effectiveness (RBE) for the induction of DNA strand breaks and the efficiency of repair of these breaks in cultured diploid bovine lens epithelial cells was measured, using accelerated heavy ions in the linear energy transfer (LET)-range up to 16,200 keV/micron. At LET values above 800 keV/micron, the number of DNA strand breaks induced per particle increases both with the atomic number of the projectile and with its kinetic energy. About 90 per cent or more of the strand breaks induced by ions with an LET of less than 10,000 keV/micron are repaired within 24 h. Repair kinetics show a dependence on the particle fluence (irradiation dose). At higher particle fluences a higher proportion of non-rejoined breaks is found, even after prolonged periods of incubation. At any LET value, repair is much slower after heavy-ion exposure than after X-irradiation. This is especially true for low energetic particles with a very high local density of energy deposition within the particle track. At the highest LET value (16,200 keV/micron), no significant repair is observed.     

Effects of pH on membrane fluidity of human erythrocytes

The effects of pH on the membrane fluidity of intact human erythrocytes, ghosts, and their lipid vesicles were studied by spin label techniques in the range of pH 3.0 to 9.1. Two fatty acid spin labels, 5-nitroxide stearic acid (5NS) and 12-nitroxide stearic acid (12NS), and a maleimide spin label were used for the labeling of the membrane lipids and proteins, respectively. The outer hyperfine splitting (T parallel) was measured as a parameter of membrane fluidity. In the case of 5NS, the T parallel values for intact erythrocytes and ghosts remained almost constant over the entire pH range at 22 degrees C but those for their lipid vesicles changed slightly, indicating the vertical displacement of the labels in lipid bilayers. On the other hand, the ESR spectra of 12NS incorporated into intact erythrocytes and ghosts, as compared with their lipid vesicles, showed marked pH dependence. By means of spin labeling of membrane proteins, the conformational changes of the proteins were observed in the pH range mentioned above. These results suggest a possible association between the strong pH dependence of the T parallel values and the conformation changes of membrane proteins. The pH dependence of the membrane fluidity was also investigated in cholesterol-enriched and -depleted erythrocytes. The effects of cholesterol demonstrated that the membrane fluidity was significantly mediated by cholesterol at low pH, but not at high pH.     

The relative biological effectiveness of 670 MeV/A neon as a function of depth in water for a tissue model

Linear energy transfer (LET infinity) spectra of identified charge fragments and primaries, produced by nuclear interactions of 670 MeV/A neon in water, were measured along the unmodulated Bragg curve of the neon beam. The relative biological effectiveness (RBE) values for spermatogonial cell killing, as reported on the basis of weight loss assay of mouse testes irradiated with beams of approximately constant single LET infinity, were summed over the particle LET infinity spectra to obtain an effective RBE for each charged-particle species, as a function of water absorber thickness. The resultant values of effective RBE were combined to obtain an effective RBE for the mixed radiation field. The RBE calculated in this way was compared with experimental RBEs obtained for spermatogonial cell killing in the mixed radiation field produced by neon ions traversing a thick water absorber. Discrepancies of 10-40% were observed between the calculated RBE and the RBE measured in the mixed radiation field. Part of this discrepancy can be attributed to undetected low-Z fragments, whose contribution is not included in the calculation, leading to an overestimated value for the calculated RBE. On the other hand, calculated values 10% greater than the measured RBE are explained as track structure effects due to the higher radial ionization density near neon tracks relative to the ionization density near the silicon tracks used to fit the RBE vs LET infinity data.     

Relative biological effectiveness of 12C and 28Si radiation in C57BL/6J mice

Study of heavy ion radiation-induced effects on mice could provide insight into the human health risks of space radiation exposure. The purpose of the present study is to assess the relative biological effectiveness (RBE) of (12)C and (28)Si ion radiation, which has not been reported previously in the literature. Female C57BL/6J mice (n = 15) were irradiated using 4-8 Gy of (28)Si (300 MeV/nucleon energy; LET 70 keV/μm) and 5-8 Gy of (12)C (290 MeV/nucleon energy; LET 13 keV/μm) ions. Post-exposure, mice were monitored regularly, and their survival observed for 30 days. The LD(50/30) dose (the dose at which 50 % lethality occurred by 30-day post-exposure) was calculated from the survival curve and was used to determine the RBE of (28)Si and (12)C in relation to γ radiation. The LD(50/30) for (28)Si and (12)C ion is 5.17 and 7.34 Gy, respectively, and the RBE in relation to γ radiation (LD(50/30)-7.25 Gy) is 1.4 for (28)Si and 0.99 for (12)C. Determination of RBE of (28)Si and (12)C for survival in mice is not only important for space radiation risk estimate studies, but it also has implications for HZE radiation in cancer therapy.     

Induction of the Tn10 precise excision in E. coli cells after accelerated heavy ions irradiation

The influence of the irradiation of different kinds on the induction of the structural mutations in the bacteria Escherichia coli is considered. The regularities of the Tn10 precise excision after accelerated 4He and 12C ions irradiations with different linear energy transfer (LET) were investigated. Dose dependences of the survival and relative frequency of the Tn10 precise excision were obtained. It was shown, that the relative frequency of the Tn10 precise excision is the exponential function from the irradiation dose. Relative biological efficiency (RBE), and relative genetic efficiency (RGE) were calculated, and were treated as the function of the LET.     

Contribution of indirect action to radiation-induced mammalian cell inactivation: dependence on photon energy and heavy-ion LET

The contribution of indirect action mediated by OH radicals to cell inactivation by ionizing radiations was evaluated for photons over the energy range from 12.4 keV to 1.25 MeV and for heavy ions over the linear energy transfer (LET) range from 20 keV/microm to 440 keV/microm by applying competition kinetics analysis using the OH radical scavenger DMSO. The maximum level of protection provided by DMSO (the protectable fraction) decreased with decreasing photon energy down to 63% at 12.4 keV. For heavy ions, a protectable fraction of 65% was found for an LET of around 200 keV/microm; above that LET, the value stayed the same. The reaction rate of OH radicals with intracellular molecules responsible for cell inactivation was nearly constant for photon inactivation, while for the heavy ions, the rate increased with increasing LET, suggesting a reaction with the densely produced OH radicals by high-LET ions. Using the protectable fraction, the cell killing was separated into two components, one due to indirect action and the other due to direct action. The inactivation efficiency for indirect action was greater than that for direct action over the photon energy range and the ion LET range tested. A significant contribution of direct action was also found for the increased RBE in the low photon energy region.     

Development of modified microdosimetric kinetic model for relative biological effectiveness in proton therapy

To predict the biological effects of ionising radiation, the quantity of biological dose is introduced instead of the physical absorbed dose. In proton therapy, a constant relative biological effectiveness (RBE) of 1.1 is usually applied clinically as recommended by the International Commission of Radiation Units and Measurements. This study presents a new model, based on the modified microdosimetric kinetic model (MMKM), for calculating variable RBE values based on experimental data on the induction of DNA double-strand breaks (DSBs) within cells. The MMKM was proposed based on experimental data for the yield of DSBs in mammalian cells, which allows modification of the yield of primary lesions in the MKM. In this approach, a unique function named f(LET), which describes the relation between RBE and linear energy transfer (LET), was considered for charged particles. In the presented model (DMMKM), the MMKM approach was developed further by considering different f(LET)s for different relevant ions involved in energy deposition events in proton therapy. Although experimental data represent the dependence of the yield of primary lesions on the ion species, the DSB yield (assumed as the main primary lesion) is assumed independent of the ion species in the MMKM. In the DMMKM, by considering the yield of primary lesions as a function of the ion species, the α and β values are in better agreement with the experimental data as compared to those of the MKM and MMKM approaches. The biological dose in the DMMKM is predicted to be lower than that in the MMKM. Further, in the proposed model, the variation of the β parameter is higher than the constant value assumed in the MKM, at the distal end of the spread-out Bragg peak (SOBP). Moreover, the level of cell death estimated by the MMKM at the SOBP region is higher than that obtained based on the DMMKM. It is concluded that considering modified f(LET)s in the model developed here is more consistent with experimental results than when MMKM and MKM approaches are considered. The DMMKM examines the biological effects with full detail and will, therefore, be effective in improving proton therapy.