Assessment of Health Protectiveness of the Risk-Based Soil Remediation Standards of the Midwestern States

In the last decade, risk-based remediation following a framework similar to risk-based correction action (RBCA) has gained acceptance across the country and generic/Tier 1 Risk-Based Action Limits (RBALs) for hundreds of chemicals have been tabulated. However, there have been only a few studies that focused on understanding the causes of discrepancy among cleanup standards and policies of the hazardous waste programs among the states. This study aims to fill this critical need by examining the basis of generic (i.e., Tier 1) residential RBALs developed by the states, which are within the regulatory domain of U.S. Environmental Protection Agency's Region 5. Specifically, we seek to investigate the approaches/methodologies and the policy/technical rationale used in establishing RBALs, along with degree of inconsistency, and the causes and implications of inconsistencies. In addition, we developed RBALs for a case study site using both deterministic and probabilistic risk assessment approaches and compared these against RBALs developed by the states to infer about public health-protectiveness of the state-specific RBALs. We found three- and four-order-of magnitude difference among state RBALs for PAHs and VOCs, respectively. The degree of clean up deemed appropriate under Tier 1 evaluation by the midwestern states significantly differ from one another, which has both public health and economic implications.     

Applications of Citric Acid Industrial Wastewater and Phosphonates for Soil Remediation: Effects on Temporal Change of Cadmium Distribution

Citric acid industrial wastewater (CAIW) and phosphonates are potentially useful for enhancing remediation of metal-contaminated soil. This study aimed to investigate the effects of these enhancement agents on temporal change of Cd distribution in a clayey soil, which probably correlates with the metal lability and bioavailability in the environment. Sequential extractions were performed on the soil samples from batch desorption experiments between 5 and 4320 min. The CAIW primarily enhanced Cd extraction from weakly bound fractions (i.e., exchangeable and carbonate fractions), which was relatively fast and took place in the first 60 min. On the other hand, (nitrilotrimethylene)-triphosphonic acid (NTMP) and ethylene diaminetetra-methylenephosphonic acid (EDTMP) provided a more significant Cd extraction from exchangeable, carbonate, and oxide fractions, with the change of Cd distribution occurring over the first 300 min. The differences in the extent and temporal change of metal extraction reflected the weaker complexation strength of CAIW compared to that of NTMP and EDTMP. Moreover, an increase of pH from 4 to 10 shifted the remaining Cd from exchangeable fraction to carbonate and oxide fractions. These distribution changes indicated that both CAIW and phosphonates were efficient at removing weakly bound Cd fractions in a short period of time, but alkaline conditions could hinder their effectiveness.     

土壤Hg污染及修复技术研究

早在 2 0世纪 6 0年代初期 ,日本查明了“水俣病”[1] 是由甲基Ｈｇ污染造成的 ,引起世界范围内人们对Ｈｇ污染危害的重视 ,使其研究日益增多。Ｈｇ通过不同途径进入土壤环境 ,土壤中的Ｈｇ经过复杂的物理、化学反应 ,大部分以各种形态滞留在土壤中 ,同时Ｈｇ在作物可食部分积累并进入食物链循环 ,对人体健康构成威胁。我国被Ｈｇ污染的耕地面积有 3.2× 10 4 ｈａ ,每年产生污染环境的Ｈｇ达 1.9× 10 8ｋｇ[2 ] 。土壤一旦遭受Ｈｇ污染 ,对人类健康构成潜在的危害 ,因此土壤Ｈｇ污染的治理及生物修复技术研究应运而生。重金属污染治理的传…     

A Practical Examination of the Use of Geostatistics in the Remediation of a Site with a Complex Metal Contamination History

Targeted remediation strategies offer the potential to treat only those areas where contamination exceeds predefined threshold levels. We used geostatistical techniques to characterize spatial distribution of heavy metals across a contaminated site, with the aim of delineating the contaminants, which is essential for successful implementation of targeted remediation strategies. Samples collected from three depths, 0–20 cm, 20–40 cm and 40–60 cm at 50 sample locations, were analyzed for As, Sb, Hg, Pb, Cd and Cu contents. The geostatistical analysis of this data enabled the identification of a number of contamination hotspots and trends. The visual interpretation of the data was supported by the statistical analysis in the form of Spearman's rank correlation coefficient. Additionally, classical statistics, based on the central limit theorem, showed that, in terms of obtaining the true mean for each of the contaminants within acceptable limits of precision, the site has been more than adequately sampled.It has been demonstrated that kriging can offer the potential to map the spatial distribution of contaminants. However, the possibility of an undetected hotspot remains, even when probabilistic modelling and a secondary phase of validatory sampling are employed. This together with the large number of samples required may preclude the commercial use of geostatistics in the remediation of contaminated land.     

TOPSIS-Based Screening Method of Soil Remediation Technology for Contaminated Sites and its Application

A soil remediation technology screening system has not yet been established in China, and the existing supporting conditions for soil remediation technology cannot meet the supervision needs of contaminated sites’ remediation. Considering the soil remediation technology screening methods for contaminated sites in developed countries and the supervision requirements of contaminated sites in China, this article briefly introduces the main characteristics of decision-making methods, and the screening indices, including technical, economic, social, and environmental factors, are suggested. The technique for order performance by similarity to ideal solution (TOPSIS) was used to establish a screening process for soil remediation technology, and the analytic hierarchy process (AHP) method was utilized to obtain the weights of the screening indices. Tthe suggested screening method was then applied in a chromite ore-processing residue site in China, and suitable remediation technology (in-situ chemical reduction-oxidation) was proposed. The research results could provide scientific and technological support for the supervision of contaminated sites in China.     

Optimization of 2-D Electrode Configuration for Electrokinetic Remediation

A practical evaluation of one- and two-dimensional applications of electric fields for in situ extraction of contaminants is provided. The evaluation is based on contaminant transport by electroosmosis and ion migration. Parameters evaluated include electrode requirements, effectiveness of electric field distribution, remediation time, and energy expenditure. Formulation is provided for calculating cost components of the process, including electrode, energy, chemicals, posttreatment, fixed, and variable costs. Equations are also provided for evaluating optimum electrode spacings based on energy and time requirements. The derivations show that spacing between same-polarity electrodes is as significant in cost calculations and in process effectiveness as that between anodes and cathodes. Decreasing the same-polarity electrode spacing to half the anode-cathode spacing will result in a 100% increase in electrode requirements, but will decrease the area of the ineffective electric field by one half. Selection of the voltage gradient impacts the optimum electrode spacing. The analysis show that a minimum exists in the cost versus electrode spacings relationship.     

Fenton's Reagent-Based In Situ Chemical Oxidation Treatment of Saturated and Unsaturated Soils at a Historic Railroad Site

A targeted treatment program utilizing in situ chemical oxidation was used to remediate diesel fuel-derived petroleum compounds in unsaturated and saturated soils at a historic railroad facility. This program consisted of multiple injections at varying depths within temporary Geoprobe® injection points. The actual treatment time was less than 3 months. Overall concentrations of volatile and semivolatile organic petroleum compounds were reduced by approximately 70%, while the total petroleum hydrocarbon concentration was reduced by nearly 50%. Treatment efficiency in unsaturated soil was similar to that in saturated soil. The results of the remedial program indicate that the effect of grain size of the subsurface materials on treatment efficacy is significant. The project has shown that the use of this technology can be as effective as other in situ treatment technologies used for treating subsurface diesel fuel contamination.     

Risk-Based Corrective Action of Hydrocarbon Contamination at a Former Major Urban Petroleum Storage Site in the U.K.

The former site of a major petroleum storage facility adjacent to a major urban watercourse was found to have potentially significant concentrations of hydrocarbons in soil and groundwater that needed to be addressed prior to redevelopment. A series of intrusive investigations were undertaken to collect physical and chemical data for a Quantitative Risk Assessment (QRA) of potential impacts on human health and the wider environment, in order to derive a remedial strategy for redevelopment of the site for light industrial use. A site-specific QRA methodology was devel oped using both U.K. and U.S. guidance to produce Risk-Based Clean-up Levels (RBCLs) for benzene, and other petroleum hydrocarbons. The U.K. has no nationally based guidance on risk assessment and studies are designed by the consultant for submission to the U.K. Environment Agency (EA) for their approval. It is the EA's role to determine whether the work has been undertaken satisfactorily. To achieve these RBCLs, ex situ bioremediation was identified as the best practicable remedial option. This was carried out in windrows using mechanical aeration (to achieve oxygenation with ammonia nitrate granule and woodchip addition) for a total of approximately 5291?m³ of soil. The bioremediation process was successful in achieving the site specific RBCLs for benzene and for other hydrocarbons within an average of 5 to 6 weeks. This article describes the successful implementation of Risk-Based Corrective Action (RBCA) at this petroleum release site as a demonstration of how risk-based remedial standards for contaminated sites can be achieved with regulatory approval.     

Elevated Soil Arsenic Levels at a Former Crude Oil Storage Facility-Assessment,Remediation, and Possible Sources

Surface and near-surface soil arsenic levels were measured at a former crude oil storage facility within the greater Los Angeles area of Southern California. Arsenic was present in soil within some portions of the site at concentrations defined as being hazardous by both the State of California and the United States Environmental Protection Agency. The elevated soil total arsenic concentrations ranged from about 30 to 2300?mg/kg and generally occurred in, and adjacent to, the former washing and storage tank locations and along piping runs. In contrast, background concentrations of arsenic in soil at the site ranged from less than the analytical method detection limits (0.5?mg/kg) to approximately 8.0?mg/kg. The elevated soil arsenic concentrations are believed to be the result of the use of arsenical corrosion inhibitors within production wells and possibly the use of arsenical biocides in washing and skimmer tanks. Flow lines from production wells within the oil field to the crude oil storage facility contained crude oil and produced (formation) water. Arsenical corrosion inhibitors placed into the oil wells may have flowed with the crude oil/produced-water streams into the washing and skimmer tanks. Over the course of approximately 55 years of operation, tankage and piping leaks at the facility may have contributed to the elevated soil arsenic concentrations encountered at the site. A site-specific cleanup goal of 22?mg/kg total arsenic was established by the regulatory agency with oversight for the site. Remediation of the arsenic-impacted soil was accomplished by excavation and on site treatment using a chemical fixation process. Confirmatory samples collected after the fixation process was completed verified that the treatment reduced the concentrations of arsenic that could by leached from the soil to nonhazardous levels. The treated soil was subsequently transported offsite to an asphalt recycling facility for incorporation into asphalt paving products.     

Extraction,Recovery, and Biostability of EDTA for Remediation of Heavy Metal-Contaminated Soil

Chelation removal of heavy metals from contaminated soil is seen as a viable remediation technique. A useful chelating agent should be strong, reusable, and biostable during metal extraction and recovery operations. This work tested the extraction, recovery, and biostability of EDTA as a potential remediating agent. Parameters, including EDTA concentration, soil type, soil content, washing cycle, precipitant concentration and type, and pH, were varied and tested during metal extraction and recovery operations. Factors, including EDTA concentration, aqueous and 5% soil slurry, presence of Pb, acclimated and unacclimated activated sludges, along with abiotic control, were varied and studied in the biodegradation of EDTA. The results showed that EDTA was able to extract lead completely from the tested soils, amenable to recovery by addition of cationic and anionic precipitants in the alkaline pH range, relatively biostable even under conditions very favorable toward biodegradation. Thus, EDTA is a strong, recoverable, and relatively biostable chelating agent that has potential for soil remediation application.     

Evaluation of Soil Vapor Extraction and Bioventing for a Petroleum-Contaminated Shallow Aquifer in Korea

The feasibility of soil vapor extraction and bioventing technologies was examined for a petroleum hydrocarbon-contaminated site. The test site was highly contaminated with toluene, ethylbenzene, and xylene, due to leakage from petroleum storage tanks. Three respiration tests demonstrated that the test site conditions were appropriate for application of air-based remediation technologies. The oxygen consumption rates ranged from 4.32 to 7.68 %-O₂/day and biodegradation rates ranged from 2.72 to 4.84?mg/kg-day in respiration tests. In a 120-day soil vapor extraction pilot test, high initial mass removals (with tailing effects) were observed. As expected for the soil vapor extraction, the volatilization rate was much higher than the biodegradation rate. In a bioventing trial, the biodegradation effect was predominant, but a tailing effect was not observed. From this study, the suggested sequence of remediation is to construct an integrated system of soil vapor extraction and bioventing and initially operate the soil vapor extraction system until the volatilization rate becomes smaller than the biodegradation rate. After that, the system needs to be changed over to a bioventing mode. Field demonstration supports the feasibility of the proposed integrated system.     

Derivation of Risk Management Criteria for Chemicals of Unknown Toxic Potency at Contaminated Sites

Environmental investigations of former industrial sites often detect the presence of chemicals for which no soil criteria exist and for which regulatory agencies have not derived estimates of toxic potency. This poses a considerable problem for making informed risk management decisions involving sites where such chemicals are present. As a result, a methodology has been developed for making risk-based decisions for chemicals of unknown toxic potency in soil at contaminated sites. The method is based on principles and procedures used by the US Food and Drug Administration (USFDA), the US Environmental Protection Agency (USEPA) and the Canadian Council of Ministers of the Environment (CCME). After analyzing the data on hundreds of carcinogenic and non-carcinogenic substances, the USFDA and other leading researchers have concluded that, if no toxicological data is available on a chemical, exposures less than 1.5?µg/person/day (i.e., 0.02?µg/kg body weight/day) are unlikely to result in appreciable health risks even if the substance was later found to be a carcinogen. To develop maximum soil concentrations that will be protective of human health (i.e., Risk Management Criteria or RMC), the above exposure limit of 0.02?µg/kg body weight/day has been assumed to be protective of risks from exposure to chemicals lacking toxicological data. Using a stochastic risk assessment model for estimating exposures to chemicals from contaminated sites, our analyses indicate that a soil concentration of 2?µg/g would be protective of human health for land uses that include residential, commercial, and industrial development provided no major indirect pathways exist at the site. If indirect pathways exists (e.g., vapor infiltration of soil gases, uptake of chemicals into garden produce, etc.), alternate RMC could be developed, that include such indirect pathways, using the methodology provided in this paper. Used by experienced risk assessors, the approach is a scientifically defensible screening method that will preclude many chemicals from unnecessary evaluation, while allowing risk assessors to focus efforts on chemicals of greater concern and make informed risk management decisions.     

Microwave-Assisted Process (MAPTM) for the Extraction of Contaminants from Soil

Laboratory-scale tests were performed to evaluate the use of Environment Canada's patented Microwave-Assisted Process (MAP_TM) for the extraction of petroleum hydrocarbons from contaminated soil. The purpose of these tests was to determine the potential for using the process for large-scale processing of contaminated soil. Tests were performed using three soil types: a certified sediment and certified soil, both contaminated with polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons (PAHs), and spiked peat soil contaminated with long-chain petroleum hydrocarbons. The test methods used were based on existing MAP techniques that have been proven for the sample preparation of contaminated soils for analytical purposes. The parameters evaluated concentrated on those that are amenable to a continuous large-scale process running at atmospheric pressures. This meant using solvents that are inexpensive and readily available in large volumes, low solvent to material ratios, and optimized energy inputs. In general, it was found that microwaves could be used to enhance the solvent extraction of the contaminants from the soil and that the properties of the soil greatly affected the extent to which the contaminants were removed.     

A Human Health Risk Assessment Software for Facilitating Management of Urban Contaminated Sites: A Case Study: The Massa Site,Tuscany, Italy

The goal of this article is to present the Human Health Risk Assessment (HRA) software developed as one of the NORISC ^{1 1}NORISC is the acronym of the project “Network Oriented Risk assessment by In-situ Screening of Contaminated sites” realized under under the 5th European Union Community Framework Programme for Research, Technological Development and Demonstration Activities. View all notes decision support software system components that could be used as a tool for facilitating management of urban contaminated sites. The NORISC-HRA software provides sufficient technical and procedural support to conduct a simple site-specific risk assessment. The employed HRA methodology is generally based on U.S. Environmental Protection Agency (USEPA) procedures. The software determines the level and spatial distribution of human health risks at a given site and sets up site-specific preliminary Health-Based Remedial Goals (HBRGs)/Risk-Based Concentrations (RBCs) for soil and groundwater. The NORISC-HRA software is recommended for use when national soil and groundwater limit values are exceeded. Exposure pathways considered in this software are associated with three land use patterns—residential, industrial/commercial, and recreational. The aricle also presents the software testing results obtained at one of the NORISC test sites—the Massa site (Avenza-Carrara, Tuscany, Italy). Findings of the HRA indicated that the contaminated soil at the Massa test site might pose potential cancer and non-cancer risks to industrial workers in its present condition. Arsenic was the dominant substance responsible for most of the baseline risk and at the RBC of 1.77 mg/kg it was the primary driver of remedial decisions at the Massa site.     

A Quick,Onsite Test for Delineating Arsenic Contaminant Plumes in Soil

Dipping vats were used routinely in the southeastern U.S. in the early 1900s to eradicate the cattle fever tick. The legacy is many dip vat sites with arsenic (As)-contaminated soil and ground water. Assessing the extent of these As plumes can be time consuming and expensive. We describe a quicker and less expensive, onsite test for soil As. It is a modification of a commercially available test designed for As in water, taking about 10?min to complete, allowing large plume areas to be delineated in a single day. An As contaminant plume in Alachua County, FL, was delineated using the quick test. Soil samples taken from a large grid encompassing the plume were analyzed in the laboratory for As to confirm the results obtained with the quick test. The comparison showed that the quick test very accurately delineated the outer boundary of the plume as well as zones of higher As concentration within the plume.     

Monte Carlo Vadose Zone Model for Soil Remedial Criteria

Many vadose zone models are available for environmental remediation, but few offer the procedures for verifying model predictions with field data and for dealing with uncertainties associated with model input parameters. This article presents a modified model combining a one-dimensional vadose-zone transport model and a simple groundwater mixing model with a function of Monte Carlo simulation (MCS). The modified model is applied to determine soil remedial concentrations for methyl tertiary butyl ether (MTBE). The modified model generates a distribution of MTBE ground-water concentrations at the point of compliance. This distribution can be used to estimate the risk of exceeding groundwater quality standard given soil remedial concentrations. In a case study, soil remedial concentration for MTBE is established to be 5?µg/kg, with a 95% and 10?µg/kg with a 50% probability that groundwater concentration will not exceed the water quality objective of 13?µg/L. Furthermore, this study uses MCS to investigate uncertainties of model input parameter hydraulic conductivity (K). One set of data (K1) is based on the results of hydraulic conductivity laboratory tests, and the other (K2) is based on the results of slug tests conducted in the field. As expected, the laboratory data show smaller K values than the field data. The comparison of the MCS results obtained from the two sets of K data indicates that the MTBE groundwater concentrations calculated based on K1 are generally 160 to 625% greater than those calculated based on K2 at the same percentiles of the MCS distribution. A higher soil remedial concentration of9jig/kg is then calculated based on the MCS results from K2 at 95%ile and 19?µg/kg at 50%ile.     

富集培养及高质量DNA提取有利于从土壤宏基因组中获取新卤醇脱卤酶基因

目的:宏基因组技术作为一种不依赖于微生物纯培养的新方法,在挖掘新基因方面具有极大的潜力。本研究旨在建立一种从土壤中高效获取卤醇脱卤酶新基因的策略。方法:通过对现有DNA提取方法进行改进,同时结合富集培养途径以提高土壤宏基因组DNA质量和特异性;在此基础上,应用T-Coffee及CDEHOP程序设计特异引物并对目的基因进行扩增,同时采用正交法设计优化扩增条件,以提高获得卤醇脱卤酶基因的效率。结果:应用改进法提取的DNA质量较改进前有大幅度提高,其D260nm/D280nm及D260nm/D230nm值均大于1.8,且可以不经纯化直接用于PCR和相关酶切实验;PCR扩增目标基因的特异性增强,其中用经富集培养后所得DNA为模板扩增目标基因的特异性最强,TA克隆测序阳性结果比例最高。结论:富集培养和高质量DNA的获得有助于基于宏基因组途径获取新基因。     

Evaluating Critical Soil Acidification Loads and Exceedances for a Deciduous Forest at the Turkey Lakes Watershed

Critical soil acidification loads (CL) and related exceedances, base cation leaching, N leaching, and forest biomass growth were evaluated for a well-studied deciduous forest site within the Turkey Lake Watershed (TLW). The assessment was done by way of steady-state mass balance considerations of primary inputs for N, Ca, Mg, and K. Critical soil acidification rates were found to be high at TLW. These rates amounted to about 900 or 1400 eq/(ha yr) depending on the forest harvesting regime (selective harvest or maintainence of old-growth condition, respectively). The TLW soil substrate (till derived from basaltic bedrock) appeared to weather well, thereby buffering against natural and anthropogenic soil acidification. As a consequence, soil acidification exceedances were estimated to be relatively low for both the selective harvest and old-growth scenarios. In comparing overall S and N input/output data (atmospheric deposition data vs soil leaching losses), we found that the TLW site was essentially near or at S and N saturation. We also found that atmospheric deposition and soil leaching rates have been declining since about 1980. The figures for CL and exceedance varied to some extent depending on the quality of input data and related uncertainties. Estimated exceedances were increased when dry- as well as wet-deposition rates were considered. They varied depending on the yearly sulfate/nitrate/base-cation mix, and the definition of “acceptable acid leaching.” In addition, they were dependent on whether the forest was considered old growth or not. Received 5 October 1999; Accepted 1 November 2000.