Membrane assembly from purified components. I. Isolated M13 procoat does not require ribosomes or soluble proteins for processing by membranes

The coat protein of coliphage M13 is an integral protein of the host-cell cytoplasmic membrane prior to its assembly into virions. It is initially synthesized as procoat, a soluble precursor with a 23 amino acid leader sequence at its amino terminus. ³⁵S-labeled procoat accumulates during an in vitro translation reaction that contains ³⁵S-methionine and RNA from M13-infected cells. Radiochemically pure procoat has been isolated from in vitro translation reactions by extraction into an organic solvent and gel filtration through Sephadex LH-60. Radiochemically pure procoat can be used as substrate in rapid and quantitative assays for leader peptidase and for leader peptide hydrolase, an enzyme that degrades the leader peptide after its release from procoat. Procoat solubility, digestion by leader peptidase and processing by membranes are affected by the presence of Mg²⁺ ion. Isolated procoat is soluble in water at low ionic strength and mildly alkaline pH as well as in detergent solutions. It is cleaved to coat protein by purified E. coli leader peptidase and by inverted E. coli inner-membrane vesicles. These properties of the purified procoat mirror those of the procoat in crude extracts. This suggests that there are no other soluble components that are necessary for the assembly of procoat into the membrane and its conversion to coat; specifically, it provides powerful evidence that protein synthesis is not involved.     

M13 procoat inserts into liposomes in the absence of other membrane proteins

Procoat, the precursor form of the major coat protein of coliphage M13, assembles into the Escherichia coli inner membrane and is cleaved to mature coat protein by leader peptidase. This assembly process has previously been reconstituted using lipids and purified leader peptidase in a cell-free protein synthesis reaction (Watts, C., Silver, P., and Wickner, W. (1981) Cell 25, 347-353; Ohno-Iwashita, Y., and Wickner, W. (1983) J. Biol. Chem. 258, 1895-1900). We now report that procoat can also cross a liposomal membrane composed of only purified phospholipids; leader peptidase is not needed to catalyze insertion. When procoat is synthesized in vitro in the presence of liposomes with encapsulated chymotrypsin, the procoat inserts spontaneously through the membrane and is degraded. The protease was shown by several criteria to be in the lumen of the liposomes. These results demonstrate that the precursor form of an E. coli integral membrane protein can cross a membrane without the aid of leader peptidase or any other membrane proteins.     

Reconstitution of rapid and asymmetric assembly of M13 procoat protein into liposomes which have bacterial leader peptidase

The leader peptidase of Escherichia coli cleaves a 23-residue leader sequence from M13 procoat to yield mature coat protein in virus-infected cells. We have reconstituted pure leader peptidase into vesicles of E. coli lipids and found that these liposomes are active in the conversion of procoat to coat. Trypsin removes all but 10% of the leader peptidase, yet the vesicles retain nearly full capacity to convert procoat to coat, suggesting that only procoat which inserts across the liposomal membrane is a substrate for leader peptidase. This is confirmed by the finding that over 70% of the coat protein produced by these liposomes spans the membrane. The rate at which leader peptidase inside protease-treated liposomes cleaves externally added procoat is comparable to the rate of procoat cleavage by the same amount of leader peptidase in detergent micelles. Thus, procoat can rapidly integrate across a liposomal membrane and be cleaved to coat protein. These findings confirm the central part of the membrane trigger hypothesis that certain proteins (such as procoat) can cross a bilayer without the aid of a proteinaceous pore or transport system.     

Membrane assembly: Posttranslational insertion of M13 procoat protein into E. coli membranes and its proteolytic conversion to coat protein in vitro

The major coat protein (gene 8 product) of bacteriophage M13 is an integral membrane protein during infection of host cells. It is synthesized as a larger precursor (procoat) with a leader sequence of 23 amino acids at its amino terminus. In vivo studies have shown that procoat only inserts into the host-cell plasma membrane after its synthesis is completed. We now demonstrate that procoat can post-translationally insert into inverted cytoplasmic membrane vesicles from E. coli and can be processed proteolytically to yield coat protein. Procoat changes from an assembly-competent substrate to an incompetent (denatured) form within minutes after its synthesis; much of the procoat that accumulates during an hour of in vitro synthesis is therefore denatured. These studies emphasize the importance of stringent criteria for the demonstration of obligate cotranslational assembly.     

Cysteine residues in the transmembrane regions of M13 procoat protein suggest that oligomeric coat proteins assemble onto phage progeny

The M13 phage assembles in the inner membrane of Escherichia coli. During maturation, about 2,700 copies of the major coat protein move from the membrane onto a single-stranded phage DNA molecule that extrudes out of the cell. The major coat protein is synthesized as a precursor, termed procoat protein, and inserts into the membrane via a Sec-independent pathway. It is processed by a leader peptidase from its leader (signal) peptide before it is assembled onto the phage DNA. The transmembrane regions of the procoat protein play an important role in all these processes. Using cysteine mutants with mutations in the transmembrane regions of the procoat and coat proteins, we investigated which of the residues are involved in multimer formation, interaction with the leader peptidase, and formation of M13 progeny particles. We found that most single cysteine residues do not interfere with the membrane insertion, processing, and assembly of the phage. Treatment of the cells with copper phenanthroline showed that the cysteine residues were readily engaged in dimer and multimer formation. This suggests that the coat proteins assemble into multimers before they proceed onto the nascent phage particles. In addition, we found that when a cysteine is located in the leader peptide at the -6 position, processing of the mutant procoat protein and of other exported proteins is affected. This inhibition of the leader peptidase results in death of the cell and shows that there are distinct amino acid residues in the M13 procoat protein involved at specific steps of the phage assembly process.     

Conserved residues of the leader peptide are essential for cleavage by leader peptidase

Gene 8 of bacteriophage M13 codes for procoat, the precursor of its major coat protein. Gene 8 has been cloned into a plasmid and mutagenized. We have isolated mutants of this gene in which procoat is synthesized but is not processed to coat protein. We now describe mutants in the leader region of procoat, at positions -6, -3, and -1 with respect to the leader peptidase cleavage site. These positions are quite conserved among the leader peptides of various pre-proteins. Each of these mutant procoats is synthesized at a normal rate and inserts correctly into the plasma membrane, as judged by its accessibility to protease in intact spheroplasts. Procoat accumulates, largely in its transmembrane form, and is not cleaved to coat. In detergent extracts, the mutant procoats are very poor substrates for added leader peptidase. We conclude that these 3 residues are not conserved for insertion across the membrane but are part of an essential recognition site for the leader peptidase.     

Identification of potential active-site residues in the Escherichia coli leader peptidase.

Leader peptidase of Escherichia coli cleaves the leader sequence from the amino terminus of membrane and secreted proteins after these proteins insert across the membrane. Despite considerable research, the mechanism of catalysis of leader peptidase remains unknown. This peptidase cannot be classified using protease inhibitors to the serine, cysteine, aspartic acid, or metallo- classes of proteases (Zwizinski, C., Date, T., and Wickner, W. (1981) J. Biol. Chem. 256, 3593-3597). Using site-directed mutagenesis, we have attempted to place leader peptidase in one of these groups. We found that leader peptidase, lacking all of the cysteine residues, can cleave the leader peptide from procoat, the precursor to bacteriophage M13 coat protein. Replacement of each histidine residue with an alanyl residue was without effect on catalysis. Among all the serine and aspartic acid residues, serine 90 and serine 185 as well as aspartic acid 99, 153, 273, and 276 are necessary to cleave procoat in a detergent extract. However, only serine 90 and aspartic acid 153 were required for processing using a highly sensitive in vivo assay. In addition to the residues directly affecting catalysis, aspartic acid 99 plays a role in maintaining the structure of leader peptidase. Replacement of this residue with alanine results in a very unstable leader peptidase protein. This study thus defines two critical residues, serine 90 and aspartic acid 153, that may be directly involved in catalysis and provides evidence that leader peptidase belongs to a novel class of serine proteases.     

Features of transmembrane segments that promote the lateral release from the translocase into the lipid phase

Topogenic sequences direct the membrane topology of proteins by being recognized and decoded by integral membrane translocases. In this paper, we have compared the minimal sequence characteristics of helical-hairpin, reverse signal-anchor, and stop-transfer sequences in bacterial membrane proteins that use either the YidC or SecYEG translocases for membrane insertion. We find that a stretch composed of 3 leucines and 16 alanines is required for efficient membrane-anchoring of the M13 procoat protein that inserts by a helical hairpin mechanism, and that a stretch composed of only 19 alanines has a detectable membrane-anchoring ability. Similar results were obtained for the reverse signal-anchor sequence of the single-spanning Pf3 coat protein and for stop-transfer segments engineered into leader peptidase. We have also determined the contribution to the apparent free energy of membrane insertion of M13 procoat for all 20 amino acids. The relative order of the contributions is similar to that determined for a stop-transfer sequence in the mammalian endoplasmic reticulum, but the absolute difference between the contributions for the most hydrophobic and most hydrophilic residues is somewhat larger in the E. coli system. These results are significant because they define the features of a membrane protein transmembrane segment that induce lateral release from the YidC and Sec translocases into the lipid bilayer in bacteria.     

Conditional lethal mutations separate the M13 procoat and Pf3 coat functions of YidC: different YIDC structural requirements for membrane protein insertion

Conditional lethal YidC mutants have been isolated to decipher the role of YidC in the assembly of Sec-dependent and Sec-independent membrane proteins. We now show that the membrane insertion of the Sec-independent M13 procoat-lep protein is inhibited in a short time in a temperature-sensitive mutant when shifted to the nonpermissive temperature. This provides an additional line of evidence that YidC plays a direct role in the insertion of the Sec-independent M13 procoat protein. However, in the temperature-sensitive mutant, the insertion of the Sec-independent Pf3 phage coat protein and the Sec-dependent leader peptidase were not strongly inhibited at the restricted temperatures. Conversely, using a cold-sensitive YidC strain, we find that the membrane insertion of the Sec-independent Pf3 coat protein is blocked, and the Sec-dependent leader peptidase is inhibited at the nonpermissive temperature, whereas the insertion of the M13 procoat protein is nearly normal. These data show that the YidC function for procoat and its function for Pf3 coat and possibly leader peptidase are genetically separable and suggest that the YidC structural requirements are different for the Sec-independent M13 procoat and Pf3 coat phage proteins that insert by different mechanisms.     

Energetics and intermediates of the assembly of Protein OmpA into the outer membrane of Escherichia coli

OmpA is a major protein of the outer membrane of Escherichia coli. It is made as a larger precursor, pro-OmpA, which requires a membrane potential for processing. We now show that pro-OmpA accumulates in the cytoplasm of cells treated with carbonyl cyanide m-chlorophenylhydrazone, an uncouple which lowers the membrane potential. Upon restoration of the potential, this pro-OmpA is secreted, processed, and assembled into the outer membrane. Pro-OmpA made in vitro is also recovered with the postribosomal supernatant. It is efficiently processed to OmpA by liposomes which have bacterial leader peptidase that is exclusively internally oriented. These experiments show that: (i) the insertion of pro-OmpA into the plasma membrane is not coupled to its synthesis; (ii) insertion is promoted by the transmembrane electrochemical potential; (iii) pro-OmpA can cross a bilayer spontaneously; and (iv) pro-OmpA is processed by the same leader peptidase which converts M13 procoat to coat.     

Use of site-directed mutagenesis to define the limits of sequence variation tolerated for processing of the M13 procoat protein by the Escherichia coli leader peptidase.

Leader peptidase cleaves the leader sequence from the amino terminus of newly made membrane and secreted proteins after they have translocated across the membrane. Analysis of a large number of leader sequences has shown that there is a characteristic pattern of small apolar residues at -1 and -3 (with respect to the cleavage site) and a helix-breaking residue adjacent to the central apolar core in the region -4 to -6. The conserved sequence pattern of small amino acids at -1 and -3 around the cleavage site most likely represents the substrate specificity of leader peptidase. We have tested this by generating 60 different mutations in the +1 to -6 domain of the M13 procoat protein. These mutants were analyzed for in vivo and in vitro processing, as well as for protein insertion into the cytoplasmic membrane. We find that in vivo leader peptidase was able to process procoat with an alanine, a serine, a glycine, or a proline residue at -1 and with a serine, a glycine, a threonine, a valine, or a leucine residue at -3. All other alterations at these sites were not processed, in accordance with predictions based on the conserved features of leader peptides. Except for proline and threonine at +1, all other residues at this position were processed by leader peptidase. None of the mutations at -2, -4, or -5 of procoat (apart from proline at -4) completely abolished leader peptidase cleavage in vivo although there were large effects on the kinetics of processing.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)     

The purification of M13 procoat, a membrane protein precursor.

Many membrane proteins and most secreted proteins are initially made as precursors with an N-terminal leader sequence. We now report the isolation of M13 procoat, the precursor of the membrane-bound form of M13 coat protein. There are 40 000 copies of M13 procoat protein/cell during M13 amber 7 virus infection. Purified procoat is quantitatively cleaved by isolated leader peptidase to yield mature-length coat protein. Rabbit antibodies to M13 procoat will precipitate procoat but not coat, suggesting that the antibody molecules are specifically recognizing the leader sequence or the conformation which it induces in the whole procoat molecule.     

In vitro insertion of leader peptidase into Escherichia coli membrane vesicles.

Leader peptidase is an integral protein of the Escherichia coli cytoplasmic membrane whose topology is known. We have taken advantage of this knowledge and available mutants of this enzyme to develop a genetic test for a cell-free protein translocation reaction. We report that leader peptidase inserted into inverted plasma membrane vesicles in its correct transmembrane orientation. We have examined the in vitro membrane assembly characteristics of a variety of leader peptidase mutants and found that domains required for insertion in vivo are also necessary for insertion in vitro. These data demonstrate the physiological validity of the in vitro insertion reaction and strengthen the use of this in vitro protein translocation reaction for the dissection of this complex sorting pathway.     

A distinct signal peptidase for prolipoprotein in escherichia coli

We have previously demonstrated the modification and processing of Escherichia coli prolipoprotein (Braun's) in vitro (Tokunaga M, Tokunaga H. Wu HC: Proc Natl Acad Sci USA 79:2255, 1982). Using this in vitro assay of prolipoprotein signal peptidase and globomycin selection, we have isolated and partially characterized an E coli mutant which contained a higher level of prolipoprotein signal peptidase activity. In contrast, the procoat protein signal peptidase activity was not increased in this mutant as compared to the wild-type strain. Furthermore, E coli strains containing cloned procoat protein signal peptidase gene were found to contain elevated levels of procoat protein signal peptidase, but normal levels of prolipoprotein signal peptidase. These two signal peptidase activities were also found to exhibit different stabilities during storage at 4°C. Thus biochemical, immunological, and genetic evidence clearly indicate that prolipoprotein signal peptidase is distinct from procoat protein signal peptidase in E coli.     

Distinct domains of an oligotopic membrane protein are Sec-dependent and Sec-independent for membrane insertion.

Leader peptidase of Escherichia coli spans the plasma membrane twice with its amino terminus on the periplasmic surface of the membrane and its large carboxyl-terminal domain protruding into the periplasm. To monitor the transfer of the amino terminus of leader peptidase to the periplasm, we have constructed a fusion protein between the 18-residue amino-terminal periplasmic domain of Pf3 bacteriophage coat protein and the beginning of leader peptidase. We find that neither the SecA or SecY proteins nor a transmembrane electrochemical potential is required for insertion of the amino terminus, while the transfer of the carboxyl-terminal domain of leader peptidase has these requirements. The first 35 residues of leader peptidase, which include the first hydrophobic domain and the carboxyl-terminal positively charged cluster, are sufficient to insert the amino terminus. When positively charged residues are introduced before the first transmembrane segment, translocation of the amino terminus is abolished. These studies in protein membrane topogenesis, showing that there are different requirements for amino and carboxyl termini insertion, indicate that multiple mechanisms exist even within the same protein.     

Processing of preproteins by liposomes bearing leader peptidase

Procoat, the precursor form of M13 coat protein, assembles into sealed liposomes bearing only internally oriented leader peptidase and is processed to yield transmembrane coat protein [Ohno-Iwashita, Y., & Wickner, W. (1983) J. Biol. Chem. 258, 1895-1900]. The precursors of maltose-binding protein and of outer membrane protein A (OmpA) are also processed by these liposomes, showing that these preproteins can at least partially insert across a lipid bilayer. The ability to insert into a bilayer may be a general property of preproteins. The cleavage products, mature OmpA and maltose-binding protein, are not sequestered within the liposomes, suggesting that an additional factor(s) is (are) required for complete translocation. Liposomes were also prepared with leader peptidase in a more physiological, membrane-spanning orientation. These liposomes were also active in the cleavage of externally added procoat, pro-OmpA, and pre maltose-binding protein, though the mature OmpA and maltose-binding protein were still not sequestered within the liposomes. Pretreatment of these liposomes with trypsin cleaved near the amino terminus of the leader peptidase, inactivating the enzyme. The function of this amino-terminal domain, on the opposite side of the membrane from the catalytic domain, is unknown.     

Inhibition of purified Escherichia coli leader peptidase by the leader (signal) peptide of bacteriophage M13 procoat.

The leader peptide of bacteriophage M13 procoat inhibited the cleavage of M13 procoat or pre-maltose-binding protein by purified Escherichia coli leader peptidase. This finding confirms inferences that the leader is the primary site of enzyme recognition and suggests a rationale for the rapid hydrolysis of leader peptides in vivo.     

The internal signal sequence of Escherichia coli leader peptidase is necessary, but not sufficient, for its rapid membrane assembly

Leader peptidase of Escherichia coli, a protein of 323 residues, has three hydrophobic domains. The first, residues 1-22, is the most apolar and is followed by a polar region (23-61) which faces the cytoplasm. The second hydrophobic domain (residues 62-76) spans the membrane. The third hydrophobic domain, which has a minimal apolar character, and the polar, carboxyl-terminal two-thirds of the protein are exposed to the periplasm. Deletion of either the amino terminus (residues 4-50) or the third hydrophobic region (residues 83-98) has almost no effect on the rate of leader peptidase membrane assembly, while the second hydrophobic domain is essential for insertion (Dalbey, R., and Wickner, W. (1987) Science 235, 783-787). To further define the roles of these domains, we have replaced the normal, cleaved leader sequence of pro-OmpA and M13 procoat with regions containing either the first or second apolar domain of leader peptidase. The second apolar domain supports the translocation of OmpA or coat protein across the plasma membrane, establishing its identity as an internal, uncleaved signal sequence. In addition to this sequence, we now find that leader peptidase needs either the amino-terminal domain or the third hydrophobic domain to permit its rapid membrane assembly. These results show that, although a signal sequence is necessary for rapid membrane assembly of leader peptidase, it is not sufficient.     

Recombinant forms of M13 procoat with an OmpA leader sequence or a large carboxy-terminal extension retain their independence of secY function.

The assembly of phage M13 procoat protein into the plasma membrane of Escherichia coli is independent of the secY protein. To test whether this is caused by the unusually small size of procoat, we fused DNA encoding 103 amino acids to the carboxy-terminal end of the procoat gene. The resulting fusion protein, which attains the same membrane-spanning conformation as mature coat protein, still does not require the secY function for membrane assembly. To determine whether the leader sequence governs interaction with the secY protein, we genetically exchanged the leader peptides between procoat and pro-OmpA, a protein which does require secY for its membrane assembly. Each of the resulting hybrid proteins assembles across the plasma membrane, though at a reduced rate. Membrane assembly of the fusion of procoat leader and OmpA required secY function, whereas assembly of the pro-OmpA leader/coat protein fusion was independent of secY. Properties of the entire procoat molecule, rather than its small size or a specific property of its leader peptide determines its mode of membrane assembly.