SENSORY EVALUATION METHODS FOR TACTILE PROPERTIES OF FABRICS

Sensory evaluation of tactile properties of fabrics is a subject many researchers have studied for years and which still has importance and is also open to improvements. Particularly for suitings, the sensory evaluation of fabric handle or of other tactile properties has a greater importance. This article explains sensory evaluation techniques for stiffness, thickness and smoothness, which are the components of fabric handle of suitings. These sensory techniques are introduced by the authors and studied in 100% worsted wool suitings. The concordances of sensory test results are investigated by Kendall's concordance test, and correlation analyses are carried out to examine the relations between sensory results.     

SOME ISSUES IN THE DESIGN AND ANALYSIS OF SENSORY DATA: REVISITED

Sensory experimental data whether collected via the consumer or via the laboratory population have many characteristics in common. Among the more important characteristics are that they are relative, skewed, and difficult to replicate. These characteristics result from the use of human beings as instruments to measure multivariate stimuli as opposed to the use of a mechanical instrument. The use of human beings as instruments presents several problems in the design and analysis of sensory/consumer studies. In the clinical/medical applications of sensory evaluation, we have used people both as the experimental unit (panelists/subjects) and as the instrument (judges) to measure panelists’ responses. Thus it is my belief that sensory data are the most difficult scientific data to statistically analyze and interpret. Unfortunately, limited theoretical work has been done to tackle the resulting problems. These problems include the comparison of responses obtained from independent populations (monadic design), sample size estimation with special reference to time-dependent responses, analysis of degree of difference data, the invariance property of rating scales, effect of correlated errors in observations, and the use of laboratory panels to predict results from a consumer panel. Some solutions to these problems have been provided by experience. My purpose here is to discuss each of these problems in greater detail and offer some possible scientific solutions.     

ESTIMATES OF CARRY-OVER EFFECTS IN TWO-PRODUCT HOME USAGE CONSUMER TESTS

In-house use consumer test data from four studies dealing with three pairs of household products and a pair of antiperspirant products were examined for significant carry-over (product usage order) effects, which would confound the analysis of treatment (product) effects. In each study, two products were compared using a two-period crossover design. One hundred twenty panelists participated in each study. A forced choice preference scale or a 9-point hedonic scale was used to obtain responses from various sensory attributes. In all studies, the estimates of carry-over effects were not significant at the 5% level. Transformation of hedonic scale data into preference dichotomy also gave estimates of carry-over effects which were not significant at the 5% level, but led to a loss of test sensitivity for detecting treatment differences. The authors recommend that all comparative crossover design studies in sensory evaluation be monitored for carry-over effects and that statistically determined sample size should be used to reduce the possibility of obtaining significant carry-over effects.     

Generation of tactile maps for artificial skin

Prior research has shown that representations of retinal surfaces can be learned from the intrinsic structure of visual sensory data in neural simulations, in robots, as well as by animals. Furthermore, representations of cochlear (frequency) surfaces can be learned from auditory data in neural simulations. Advances in hardware technology have allowed the development of artificial skin for robots, realising a new sensory modality which differs in important respects from vision and audition in its sensorimotor characteristics. This provides an opportunity to further investigate ordered sensory map formation using computational tools. We show that it is possible to learn representations of non-trivial tactile surfaces, which require topologically and geometrically involved three-dimensional embeddings. Our method automatically constructs a somatotopic map corresponding to the configuration of tactile sensors on a rigid body, using only intrinsic properties of the tactile data. The additional complexities involved in processing the tactile modality require the development of a novel multi-dimensional scaling algorithm. This algorithm, ANISOMAP, extends previous methods and outperforms them, producing high-quality reconstructions of tactile surfaces in both simulation and hardware tests. In addition, the reconstruction turns out to be robust to unanticipated hardware failure.     

EFFECT OF QUESTION ORDER ON SENSORY PERCEPTION AND PREFERENCE IN CENTRAL LOCATION TRIALS

In the running of consumer studies aimed at obtaining information about products and services, it has become increasingly popular to include some sensory type questions about the characteristics of the test product as well as the standard question about overall preference. The implications of this for the resultant data are complex, and as Sudman and Schwarz (1989) point out question order effects have been implicated as one of the major causes of unreplicated or unexpected findings in survey research. This study aims to establish the effect of question order on overall preference scores and sensory scores in consumer studies. Results indicate that there is a significant effect of asking sensory questions on overall preference ratings and the position of the preference questions (relative to the sensory questions) also has implications for overall ratings of preference.     

COMPARISON OF ATTRIBUTE LIKING AND JAR SCALES TO EVALUATE THE ADEQUACY OF SENSORY ATTRIBUTES OF MILK DESSERTS

Just-about-right (JAR) scales and attribute liking questions are usually used to study consumer perception of the sensory characteristics of food products. The aim of the present work was to compare the performance of attribute liking and JAR scales to evaluate consumers' perceived adequacy of flavor and texture of milk puddings. Two groups of consumers were asked to evaluate eight milk desserts using (1) overall liking followed by attribute liking for texture and flavor and (2) overall liking followed by JAR scales for thickness, creaminess, sweetness and vanilla flavor. Overall liking scores were significantly different when JAR scales or attribute liking questions were considered. Texture, flavor and overall liking scores were highly correlated to each other, providing the same information. JAR scales correlated better with the intensity of sensory attributes evaluated by a trained sensory panel, being JAR percentages a reliable tool to study the adequacy of sensory attributes.

PRACTICAL APPLICATIONS

Results from the present work showed that consumers might not be able to independently evaluate their liking of different sensory attributes of a product. For this reason, the use of attribute liking questions for studying the adequacy of sensory attributes in complex products would not be recommended. JAR scales were better indicators of the adequacy of sensory attributes. Consumers were able to independently evaluate texture and flavor attributes using JAR scales. However, the influence of JAR scales on overall liking scores should be taken into account when including these scales on consumer studies.     

APPLICATIONS OF SENSORY SCIENCE WITHIN THE HOME CARE BUSINESS

Sensory evaluation methods and procedures originally developed for the food and beverage industry are also utilized to conduct evaluations of products for furniture and floor care, laundry care, air care, and insect control. In addition to measuring sensory properties and dealing primarily with “the other senses,” home care product evaluations incorporate assessments of perceived performance as the product interacts with a substrate. Consequently, laboratory evaluations employ a variety of controlled usage conditions — each having specific physical requirements, and evaluations of total performance are conducted under multi-environmental conditions with product users. This presentation examines how traditional sensory methods have been modified and expanded to accommodate the multidimensional aspects of home care products and R&D decisionmaking.     

SENSORY EVALUATION OF INDIAN-STYLE MARINATED CHICKEN BY MALAYSIAN AND EUROPEAN NAÏVE ASSESSORS

This study was carried out to determine the sensory acceptability of chicken breast fillets marinated with 13 different commercially available Indian-style marinades. Thirty-four naïve assessors (untrained panelists), 20 Malaysian and 14 European, were selected to assess the following sensory attributes: color, color uniformity, Tikka-Masala aroma, Tikka-Masala flavor, herblike flavor, hotness, authenticity, juiciness and overall acceptability. The color of the cooked samples and the pH, moisture and fat content of the marinades were analyzed instrumentally. Marinades were applied to the chicken fillets, which were then dry cooked at 170C for 15 min to an internal temperature of 73C. Sensory evaluation showed significant differences ( P <  0.05) in color uniformity, hotness and juiciness of the cooked marinated chicken perceived between groups. Samples marinated with marinades L and I received the highest score from the Malaysian panelists in terms of overall acceptability, whereas marinades A and F were chosen by the European group.

PRACTICAL APPLICATIONS

The findings from this research will benefit manufacturers of marinade and marinated chicken products in developing or optimizing their products for the local and international markets. The optimal characteristics of an ideal marinade were identified for each assessor group. These results are also of interest to individuals undertaking cross-cultural consumer studies, even though the results presented here used naïve assessors.     

EXPERTS VERSUS CONSUMERS: A COMPARISON

This paper compares experts and consumers to determine the degree to which they agree with each other on ratings of 37 sauce products, using the same sensory attributes. The paper also assesses the degree to which sensory attribute ratings correlate with objective physical measures. The ratings of experts (1-9 scale) and consumers (0–100 scale) agree quite highly, as shown by the high correlation between the two panels across the 37 products. The paper refutes the notion that consumers are incapable of validly rating the sensory aspects of products. The paper therefore presents the case for using consumers to assess the sensory characteristics of products.     

稳定同位素质量平衡混合模型的性能评估

稳定同位素技术可以用于消费者营养溯源,以确定多种营养来源对消费者营养的贡献比重。因此,稳定同位素质量平衡混合模型已经是消费者营养溯源分析的必要方法之一。通常使用贝叶斯混合模型来估计不同营养来源的贡献;此类模型提供了每个营养来源对消费者的贡献比例的概率分布特征。然而,混合模型拟合结果的好坏,及其与实际生态学理论的匹配水平,是模型性能的重要评价内容。例如,模型在不能很好地解析营养来源贡献时,仍将返回默认先验结果,给模型解释带来困难。为直接避免同位素构建消费者营养溯源分析中的诸多技术问题,文章将综述在拟合和评估贝叶斯混合模型时遵循的最佳实践。因此,文章基于实测的同位素数据集(蒙古鲌Culter mongolicus mongolicus同位素数据集),通过识别消费者营养功能类群特征、改变营养来源先验信息特征,构建系列贝叶斯模型;通过比较模型总体性能、实测值与预测值差异,及先验信息和后验信息差异等多种模型性能评价方法,来描述模型性能评价的方法和过程。通过这些方法的综合运用,将进一步提高消费者营养溯源准确性,为更深刻地认识食物网规律提供科学支撑。     

SELECTING PRODUCTS FOR CATEGORY APPRAISAL STUDIES — FEWER PRODUCTS DO ALMOST AS WELL AS MANY PRODUCTS

This paper analyzes the results of different strategies for selecting test products in category appraisals. The three strategies are random selection of products from the marketplace, selection on the basis of consumer sensory data, and selection on the basis of expert panel data. All three methods generate stable results for category appraisals. The stability of the results (e.g., in terms of 'drivers of liking') increases very quickly and then levels off, suggesting that the researcher does not have to work with a particularly large number of products in a category appraisal to understand the sensory-liking dynamics.
It appears in our case, that 18 products were an appropriate number to strongly reflect results for 50 products. Researchers need to be sensitive to the variation in each category. Some categories may require more or less than this number of products to cover all the sensory ranges within the specific category.     

MAPPING THE EFFECT OF INFORMATION ABOUT ANIMAL WELFARE ON CONSUMER LIKING AND WILLINGNESS TO PAY FOR YOGURT

Preference mapping identified different groups of consumers on the basis of their disconfirmations (occurring when the product is either better or worse than expected) and assimilations (occurring when actual liking [L] moves toward the expectations). The negative disconfirmation of a group of consumers (Group 1) was based on the information about animal welfare (the products were worse than expected because the information about animal welfare induced high expectations), whereas in Group 2 the sensory properties of the products prevailed in orienting consumer disconfirmation (products were worse than expected because the sensory properties of low-fat yogurt were disliked). The map of assimilation showed that consumers from Group 1 had higher assimilation for plain yogurt associated with high welfare standards as a consequence of the high discrepancy between blind and expected L for these products. A similar behavior was observed for Group 2 (higher discrepancy between blind and expected L corresponding to higher assimilation for low-fat yogurt paired with high welfare standards).

PRACTICAL APPLICATIONS

Consumers based their choices both on sensory properties (plain yogurts were preferred to low-fat yogurts) and on information about animal welfare (products associated with high welfare standards were preferred to the others). Preference mapping was able to identify groups of consumers behaving differently, as compared with the general trend, on the basis of their disconfirmations and assimilations.
Consumer willingness to pay reflected the hedonic behavior, thus validating the auction procedure for food liking evaluation purposes and providing a useful tool to obtain information about the real value (i.e., in monetary terms) consumers give to animal welfare.     

USE OF TACTILE AND VISUAL CUES IN CONSUMER JUDGMENTS OF APPLE RIPENESS

The relative importance of visual and tactile cues in consumer assessments of'Royal Gala'apple ripeness were studied in relation to commercial maturity indices which included background color, blush, weight and skin greasiness. Apples were evaluated by consumers under 3 sensory conditions to isolate their use of visual and tactile cues. Individual fruit were harvested to provide apples which independently varied in background color, blush and weight. Visual cues of skin color were found to be greater drivers of perceived apple ripeness than tactile cues of skin greasiness and apple firmness. Amongst the visual cues tested, the hue of the background color had the greatest impact on consumer judgments of'Royal Gala'apple ripeness. Consumer's ideal'Royal Gala'apple ripeness was achieved with a background color between chip levels 5 and 8, blush coverage between 33-66% and weighing between 130-142 g.