Synapsis of loxP sites by Cre recombinase

Cre recombinase catalyzes site-specific recombination between 34-bp loxP sites in a variety of topological and cellular contexts. An obligatory step in the recombination reaction is the association, or synapsis, of Cre-bound loxP sites to form a tetrameric protein assembly that is competent for strand exchange. Using analytical ultracentrifugation and electrophoresis approaches, we have studied the energetics of Cre-mediated synapsis of loxP sites. We found that synapsis occurs with a high affinity (Kd = 10 nM) and is pH-dependent but does not require divalent cations. Surprisingly, the catalytically inactive Cre K201A mutant is fully competent for synapsis of loxP sites, yet the inactive Y324F and R173K mutants are defective for synapsis. These findings have allowed us to determine the first crystal structures of a pre-cleavage Cre-loxP synaptic complex in a configuration representing the starting point in the recombination pathway. When combined with a quantitative analysis of synapsis using loxP mutants, the structures explain how the central 8 bp of the loxP site are able to dictate the order of strand exchange in the Cre system.     

Analysis of spacer regions derived from intramolecular recombination between heterologous loxP sites

In Cre-loxP recombination system, Cre recombinase binds cooperatively to two 13bp inverted repeats in a 34bp loxP and catalyzes strand exchange in the 8bp spacer region. Up to date, spacer sequences within the recombined loxP sites derived from two loxP sties that have different 8bp spacer regions have never been analyzed. In the present study, we analyzed the spacer sequences within the recombined products, resulted from intramolecular recombination between heterologous loxP sites including M2, M3, M7, M11, and 2272 in vivo and in vitro. From the analyses, it was found that loxP sites with aberrant 8bp spacers can be generated from Cre-mediated recombination between heterologous loxP sites at significantly high frequency, proposing the possibility that recombination between heterologous loxP sites would have not undergone typical formula of Cre-loxP recombination.     

Sequence of the loxP site determines the order of strand exchange by the Cre recombinase

Conservative site-specific recombinases of the integrase family carry out recombination via a Holliday intermediate. The Cre recombinase, a member of the integrase family, was previously shown to initiate recombination by cleaving and exchanging preferentially on the bottom strand of its loxP target sequence. We have confirmed this strand bias for an intermolecular recombination reaction that used wild-type loxP sites and Cre protein. We have examined the sequence determinants for this strand preference by selectively mutating the two asymmetric scissile base-pairs in the lox site (those immediately adjacent to the sites of cleavage by Cre). We found that the initial strand exchange occurs preferentially next to the scissile G residue. Resolution of the Holliday intermediate thus formed takes place preferentially next to the scissile A residue. Lys86, which contacts the scissile nucleotides in the Cre-lox crystal structures, was important for establishing the strand preference in the resolution of the loxP-Holliday intermediate, but not for the initiation of recombination between loxP sites.     

Mechanism of strand cleavage and exchange in the Cre-lox site-specific recombination system

The bacteriophage P1 recombinase Cre mediates site-specific recombination between loxP sites. The loxP site consists of two 13 base-pair inverted repeats separated by an eight base-pair spacer region. When DNA containing the loxP site is incubated with Cre, specific cleavages occur within the spacer region, creating a six base-pair staggered cut. The cuts are centered on the axis of dyad symmetry of the loxP site, resulting in a 5' protruding terminus: 5' A decreases T-G-T-A-T-G C 3' T A-C-A-T-A-C increases G. At the point of cleavage, Cre becomes covalently attached to a 3' PO4, and produces a free 5' OH. A series of experiments were carried out in which a radioactively labeled loxP site is recombined with an unlabeled loxP site to locate the point at which strand exchange takes place during recombination. The points of strand exchange coincide with the sites at which Cre cleavage of the DNA backbone had been detected.     

Communication between accessory factors and the Cre recombinase at hybrid psi-loxP sites

By placing loxP adjacent to the accessory sequences from the Xer/psi multimer resolution system, we have imposed topological selectivity and specificity on Cre/loxP recombination. In this hybrid recombination system, the Xer accessory protein PepA binds to psi accessory sequences, interwraps them, and brings the loxP sites together such that the product of recombination is a four-node catenane. Here, we investigate communication between PepA and Cre by varying the distance between loxP and the accessory sequences, and by altering the orientation of loxP. The yield of four-node catenane and the efficiency of recombination in the presence of PepA varied with the helical phase of loxP with respect to the accessory sequences. When the orientation of loxP was reversed, or when half a helical turn was added between the accessory sequences and loxP, PepA reversed the preferred order of strand exchange by Cre at loxP. The results imply that PepA and the accessory sequences define precisely the geometry of the synapse formed by the loxP sites, and that this overcomes the innate preference of Cre to initiate recombination on the bottom strand of loxP. Further analysis of our results demonstrates that PepA can stimulate strand exchange by Cre in two distinct synaptic complexes, with the C-terminal domains of Cre facing either towards or away from PepA. Thus, no specific PepA-recombinase interaction is required, and correct juxtaposition of the loxP sites is sufficient to activate Cre in this system.     

Cre induces an asymmetric DNA bend in its target loxP site

Cre initiates recombination by preferentially exchanging the bottom strands of the loxP site to form a Holliday intermediate, which is then resolved on the top strands. We previously found that the scissile AT and GC base pairs immediately 5' to the scissile phosphodiester bonds are critical in determining this order of strand exchange. We report here that the scissile base pairs also influence the Cre-induced DNA bends, the position of which correlates with the initial site of strand exchange. The binding of one Cre molecule to a loxP site induces a approximately 35 degrees asymmetric bend adjacent to the scissile GC base pair. The binding of two Cre molecules to a loxP site induces a approximately 55 degrees asymmetric bend near the center of the spacer region with a slight bias toward the scissile A. Lys-86, which contacts the scissile nucleotides, is important for establishing the bend near the scissile GC base pair when one Cre molecule is bound but has little role in positioning the bend when two Cre molecules are bound to a loxP site. We present a model relating the position of the Cre-induced bends to the order of strand exchange in the Cre-catalyzed recombination reaction.     

Altered directionality in the Cre-LoxP site-specific recombination pathway

The site-specific recombinase Cre must employ control mechanisms to impose directionality on recombination. When two recombination sites (locus of crossing over in phage P1, loxP) are placed as direct repeats on the same DNA molecule, collision between loxP-bound Cre dimers leads to excision of intervening DNA. If two sites are placed as inverted repeats, the intervening segment is flipped around. Cre catalyzes these reactions in the absence of protein co-factors. Current models suggest that directionality is controlled at two steps in the recombination pathway: the juxtaposition of loxP sites and the single-strand-transfer reactions within the synaptic complex. Here, we show that in Escherichia coli strain 294-Cre, directionality for recombination is altered when the expression of Cre is increased. This leads to deletion instead of inversion on substrates carrying two loxP sites as inverted repeats. The nucleotide sequence composition of loxP sites remaining in aberrant products indicates that site alignment and/or DNA strand transfer in the in vivo Cre-loxP recombination pathway are not always tightly controlled.     

The role of the loxP spacer region in P1 site-specific recombination.

The lox-Cre site-specific recombination system of bacteriophage P1 is comprised of a site on the DNA where recombination occurs called loxP, and a protein, Cre, which mediates the reaction. The loxP site is 34 base pairs (bp) in length and consists of two 13 bp inverted repeats separated by an 8 bp spacer region. Previously it has been shown that the cleavage and strand exchange of recombining loxP sites occurs within this spacer region. We report here an analysis of various base substitution mutations within the spacer region of loxP, and conclude the following: Homology is a requirement for efficient recombination between recombining loxP sites. There is at least one position within the spacer where a base change drastically reduces recombination even when there is homology between the two recombining loxP sites. When two loxP sites containing symmetric spacer regions undergo Cre-mediated recombination in vitro, the DNA between the sites undergoes both excision and inversion with equal frequency.     

Determinants of product topology in a hybrid Cre-Tn3 resolvase site-specific recombination system

Many natural DNA site-specific recombination systems achieve directionality and/or selectivity by making recombinants with a specific DNA topology. This property requires that the DNA architecture of the synapse and the mechanism of strand exchange are both under strict control. Previously we reported that Tn3 resolvase-mediated synapsis of the accessory binding sites from the Tn3 recombination site res can impose topological selectivity on Cre/loxP recombination. Here, we show that the topology of these reactions is profoundly affected by subtle changes in the hybrid recombination site les. Reversing the orientation of loxP relative to the res accessory sequence, or adding 4 bp to the DNA between loxP and the accessory sequence, can switch between two-noded and four-noded catenane products. By analysing Holliday junction intermediates, we show that the innate bias in the order of strand exchanges at loxP is maintained despite the changes in topology. We conclude that a specific synaptic structure formed by resolvase and the res accessory sequences permits Cre to align the adjoining loxP sites in several distinct ways, and that resolvase-mediated intertwining of the accessory sequences may be less than has been assumed previously.     

Reversible dimer formation and stability of the anti-tumour single-chain Fv antibody MFE-23 by neutron scattering,analytical ultracentrifugation,and NMR and FT-IR spectroscopy

Cre recombinase uses two pairs of sequential cleavage and religation reactions to exchange homologous DNA strands between 34 base-pair (bp) LoxP recognition sequences. In the oligomeric recombination complex, a switch between "cleaving" and "non-cleaving" subunit conformations regulates the number, order, and regio-specificity of the strand exchanges. However, the particular sequence of events has been in question. From analysis of strand composition of the Holliday junction (HJ) intermediate, we determined that Cre initiates recombination of LoxP by cleaving the upper strand on the left arm. Cre preferred to react with the left arm of a LoxP suicide substrate, but at a similar rate to the right arm, indicating that the first strand to be exchanged is selected prior to cleavage. We propose that during complex assembly the cleaving subunit preferentially associates with the LoxP left arm, directing the first strand exchange to that side. In addition, this biased assembly would enforce productive orientation of LoxP sites in the recombination synapses. A novel Cre-HJ complex structure in which LoxP was oriented with the left arm bound by the cleaving Cre subunit suggested a physical basis for the strand exchange order. Lys86 and Lys201 interact with the left arm scissile adenine base differently than in structures that have a scissile guanine. These interactions are associated with positioning the 198-208 loop, a structural component of the conformational switch, in a configuration that is specific to the cleaving conformation. Our results suggest that strand exchange order and site alignment are regulated by an "induced fit" mechanism in which the cleaving conformation is selectively stabilized through protein-DNA interactions with the scissile base on the strand that is cleaved first.     

Cre-loxP recombination system for large genome rearrangements in Lactococcus lactis

We have used a new genetic strategy based on the Cre-loxP recombination system to generate large chromosomal rearrangements in Lactococcus lactis. Two loxP sites were sequentially integrated in inverse order into the chromosome either at random locations by transposition or at fixed points by homologous recombination. The recombination between the two chromosomal loxP sites was highly efficient (approximately 1 x 10(-1)/cell) when the Cre recombinase was provided in trans, and parental- or inverted-type chromosomal structures were isolated after removal of the Cre recombinase. The usefulness of this approach was demonstrated by creating three large inversions of 500, 1,115, and 1,160 kb in size that modified the lactococcal genome organization to different extents. The Cre-loxP recombination system described can potentially be used for other gram-positive bacteria without further modification.     

Modified Cre-loxP recombination in Aspergillus oryzae by direct introduction of Cre recombinase for marker gene rescue

Marker rescue is an important molecular technique that enables sequential gene deletions. The Cre-loxP recombination system has been used for marker gene rescue in various organisms, including aspergilli. However, this system requires many time-consuming steps, including construction of a Cre expression plasmid, introduction of the plasmid, and Cre expression in the transformant. To circumvent this laborious process, we investigated a method wherein Cre could be directly introduced into Aspergillus oryzae protoplasts on carrier DNA such as a fragment or plasmid. In this study, we define the carrier DNA (Cre carrier) as a carrier for the Cre enzyme. A mixture of commercial Cre and nucleic acids (e.g., pUG6 plasmid) was introduced into A. oryzae protoplasts using a modified protoplast-polyethylene glycol method, resulting in the deletion of a selectable marker gene flanked by loxP sites. By using this method, we readily constructed a marker gene-rescued strain lacking ligD to optimize homologous recombination. Furthermore, we succeeded in integrative recombination at a loxP site in A. oryzae. Thus, we developed a simple method to use the Cre-loxP recombination system in A. oryzae by direct introduction of Cre into protoplasts using DNA as a carrier for the enzyme.     

Restoration of catalytic functions in Cre recombinase mutants by electrostatic compensation between active site and DNA substrate

Two conserved catalytic arginines, Arg-173 and Arg-292, of the tyrosine site-specific recombinase Cre are essential for the transesterification steps of strand cleavage and joining in native DNA substrates containing scissile phosphate groups. The active site tyrosine (Tyr-324) provides the nucleophile for the cleavage reaction, and forms a covalent 3′-phosphotyrosyl intermediate. The 5′-hydroxyl group formed during cleavage provides the nucleophile for the joining reaction between DNA partners, yielding strand exchange. Previous work showed that substitution of the scissile phosphate (P) by methylphosphonate (MeP) permits strand cleavage by a Cre variant lacking Arg-292. We now demonstrate that MeP activation and cleavage are not blocked by substitution of Arg-173 or even simultaneous substitutions of Arg-173 and Arg-292 by alanine. Furthermore, Cre(R173A) and Cre(R292A) are competent in strand joining, Cre(R173A) being less efficient. No joining activity is detected with Cre(R173A, R292A). Consistent with their ability to cleave and join strands, Cre(R173A) and Cre(R292A) can promote recombination between two MeP-full-site DNA partners. These findings shed light on the overall contribution of active site electrostatics, and tease apart distinctive contributions of the individual arginines, to the chemical steps of recombination. They have general implications in active site mechanisms that promote important phosphoryl transfer reactions in nucleic acids.     

Crystal structure of a wild-type Cre recombinase-loxP synapse reveals a novel spacer conformation suggesting an alternative mechanism for DNA cleavage activation

Escherichia coli phage P1 Cre recombinase catalyzes the site-specific recombination of DNA containing loxP sites. We report here two crystal structures of a wild-type Cre recombinase–loxP synaptic complex corresponding to two distinct reaction states: an initial pre-cleavage complex, trapped using a phosphorothioate modification at the cleavable scissile bond that prevents the recombination reaction, and a 3′-phosphotyrosine protein–DNA intermediate resulting from the first strand cleavage. In contrast to previously determined Cre complexes, both structures contain a full tetrameric complex in the asymmetric unit, unequivocally showing that the anti-parallel arrangement of the loxP sites is an intrinsic property of the Cre–loxP recombination synapse. The conformation of the spacer is different to the one observed for the symmetrized loxS site: a kink next to the scissile phosphate in the top strand of the pre-cleavage complex leads to unstacking of the TpG step and a widening of the minor groove. This side of the spacer is interacting with a ‘cleavage-competent’ Cre subunit, suggesting that the first cleavage occurs at the ApT step in the top strand. This is further confirmed by the structure of the 3′-phosphotyrosine intermediate, where the DNA is cleaved in the top strands and covalently linked to the ‘cleavage-competent’ subunits. The cleavage is followed by a movement of the C-terminal part containing the attacking Y324 and the helix N interacting with the ‘non-cleaving’ subunit. This rearrangement could be responsible for the interconversion of Cre subunits. Our results also suggest that the Cre-induced kink next to the scissile phosphodiester activates the DNA for cleavage at this position and facilitates strand transfer.     

Bacteriophage P1 Cre-loxP site-specific recombination. Site-specific DNA topoisomerase activity of the Cre recombination protein

Site-specific recombination in bacteriophage P1 occurs between two loxP sites in the presence of the Cre recombination protein. The structure of the 34-base pair loxP site consists of two 13-base pair inverted repeats separated by an 8-base pair spacer region. A mutation in the loxP site has been constructed which deletes one of the internal bases of the spacer region at the axis of dyad symmetry. This mutant loxP site shows a 10-fold reduction in recombination activity with a wild-type site both in vivo and in vitro. This low level of intramolecular recombination between a wild-type loxP site and the mutant loxP501 site is observed in vitro only when the DNA substrate is supercoiled. The majority of the supercoiled substrate is relaxed by the Cre protein, and on longer incubations, single-stranded nicks accumulate in the DNA. We have determined that these nicks occur in both the wild-type and the mutant sites. The positions of these nicks correspond to the positions of cleavage found during recombination of two wild-type sites, suggesting that the Cre protein is attempting to carry out recombination with the mutant site but most of the time this reaction is abortive. We have determined that the Cre protein relaxes a supercoiled topoisomer of a DNA substrate containing one wild-type site and one mutant site to yield a distribution of topoisomers whose linking numbers differ by steps of one, indicating that Cre can act as a type I topoisomerase.     

Cre-LoxP条件性基因敲除的实际应用策略

Cre-loxP系统是起源于P1噬菌体的高效重组系统,其根据loxP位点组合不同而发生特定重组的模式使其成为近年来基因编辑最常用的工具之一。本文聚焦于Cre-loxP系统的实际应用问题,首先分析了CRISPR/Cas9系统在插入Cre序列与loxP序列中的作用与优势,随后阐述了一系列Cre-loxP系统的实际应用问题。本文阐述了Cre重组酶序列的原位插入与安全位点插入的选用、loxP序列插入的策略、Cre重组酶的标签蛋白鉴定、“异位”表达的荧光鉴定、PCR鉴定法的引物设计与工具鼠的繁殖策略等。同时,介绍了Cre-loxP系统在条件性基因敲除中的优化应用,例如配体诱导型Cre、启动子激活型Cre、光诱导型Cre与活性改造型Cre等。通过这些优化应用,可以获得对条件性基因敲除的时间可控性,也可以调节Cre重组酶的活性,甚至可以规避Cre重组酶本身的毒性。最后,论述了Cre-loxP系统面临的缺陷与挑战,展望了未来Cre-loxP系统的发展方向。总而言之,本文综述了基于Cre-loxP系统的基因敲除的实际应用,总结了目前Cre-loxP系统最前沿的研究进展和优化策略,并对未来基于Cre-loxP系统的基因编辑进行展望。本文旨在提供解决基于Cre-loxP系统实际操作问题的理论指导,并为未来更精确、更可控、更具适应性的基因编辑提供新的研究思路。     

Reversed DNA strand cleavage specificity in initiation of Cre-LoxP recombination induced by the His289Ala active-site substitution

During the first steps of site-specific recombination, Cre protein cleaves and religates a specific homologous pair of LoxP strands to form a Holliday junction (HJ) intermediate. The HJ is resolved into recombination products through exchange of the second homologous strand pair. CreH289A, containing a His to Ala substitution in the conserved R-H-R catalytic motif, has a 150-fold reduced recombination rate and accumulates HJs. However, to produce these HJs, CreH289A exchanges the opposite set of strands compared to wild-type Cre (CreWT). To investigate how CreH289A and CreWT impose strand exchange order, we characterized their reactivities and strand cleavage preferences toward LoxP duplex and HJ substrates containing 8bp spacer substitutions. Remarkably, CreH289A had different and often opposite strand exchange preferences compared to CreWT with nearly all substrates. CreH289N was much less perturbed, implying that overall recombination rate and strand exchange depend more on His289 hydrogen bonding capability than on its acid/base properties. LoxP substitutions immediately 5' (S1 nucleotide) or 3' (S1' nucleotide) of the scissile phosphate had large effects on substrate utilization and strand exchange order. S1' substitutions, designed to alter base-unstacking events concomitant with Cre-induced LoxP bending, caused HJ accumulation and dramatically inverted the cleavage preferences. That pre-formed HJs were resolved via either strand in vitro suggests that inhibition of the "conformational switch" isomerization required to trigger the second strand exchange accounts for the observed HJ accumulation. Rather than reflecting CreWT behavior, CreH289A accumulates HJs of opposite polarity through a combination of its unique cleavage specificity and an HJ isomerization defect. The overall implication is that cleavage specificity is mediated by sequence-dependent DNA deformations that influence the scissile phosphate positioning and reactivity. A role of His289 may be to selectively stabilize the "activated" phosphate conformation in order to promote cleavage.     

Directional resolution of synthetic holliday structures by the Cre recombinase.

The Cre recombinase of bacteriophage P1 cleaves its target site, loxP, in a defined order. Recombination is initiated on one pair of strands to form a Holliday intermediate, which is then resolved by cleavage and exchange of the other pair of strands to yield recombinant products. To investigate the influence of the loxP sequence on the directionality of resolution, we constructed synthetic Holliday (chi) structures containing either wild-type or mutant lox sites. We found that Cre preferentially resolved the synthetic wild-type chi structures on a particular pair of strands. The bias in the direction of resolution was dictated by the asymmetric loxP sequence since the resolution bias was abolished with symmetric lox sites. Systematic substitutions of the loxP site revealed that the bases immediately 5' to the scissile phosphodiester bonds were primarily responsible for the directionality of resolution. Interchanging these base pairs was sufficient to reverse the resolution bias. The Cre-lox co-crystal structures show that Lys(86) makes a base-specific contact with guanine immediately 5' to one of the scissile phosphates. Substituting Lys(86) with alanine resulted in a reduction of the resolution bias, indicating that this amino acid is important for establishing the bias in resolution.     

Symmetric DNA sites are functionally asymmetric within Flp and Cre site-specific DNA recombination synapses

Flp and Cre-mediated recombination on symmetrized FRT and loxP sites, respectively, in circular plasmid substrates yield both DNA inversion and deletion. However, upon sequestering three negative supercoils outside the recombination complex using the resII-resIII synapse formed by Tn3 resolvase and the LER synapse formed by phage Mu transposase in the case of Flp and Cre, respectively, the reactions are channeled towards inversion at the expense of deletion. The inversion product is a trefoil, its unique topology being conferred by the external resolvase or LER synapse. Thus, Flp and Cre assign their symmetrized substrates a strictly antiparallel orientation with respect to strand cleavage and exchange. These conclusions are supported by the product profiles from tethered parallel and antiparallel native FRT sites in dilution and competition assays. Furthermore, the observed recombination bias favoring deletion over inversion in a nicked circular substrate containing two symmetrized FRT sites is consistent with the predictions from Monte Carlo simulations based on antiparallel synapsis of the DNA partners.     

Bacteriophage P1 site-specific recombination. Purification and properties of the Cre recombinase protein

Bacteriophage P1 encodes a site-specific recombination system that consists of a site (loxP) at which recombination occurs and a gene, cre, whose protein product is essential for recombination. The loxP-Cre recombination event can be studied in greater detail by the use of an in vitro system that efficiently carries out recombination between two loxP sites. This paper presents a purification and characterization of the Cre protein (Mr = 35,000), which is the only protein required for the in vitro reaction. No high energy cofactors are needed. The purified Cre protein binds to loxP-containing DNA and makes complexes that are resistant to heparin. Cre efficiently converts 70% of the DNA substrate to products and appears to act stoichiometrically. The action of Cre on a loxP2 supercoiled substrate containing two directly repeated loxP sites results in product molecules that are topologically unlinked. Several models to account for the ability of Cre to produce free supercoiled products are discussed.