Role of an active site guanine in hairpin ribozyme catalysis probed by exogenous nucleobase rescue

The hairpin ribozyme is a small catalytic RNA with reversible phosphodiester cleavage activity. Biochemical and structural studies exclude a requirement for divalent metal cation cofactors and implicate one active site nucleobase in particular, G8, in the catalytic mechanism. Our previous work demonstrated that the cleavage activity that is lost when G8 is replaced by an abasic residue is restored when certain nucleobases are provided in solution. The specificity and pH dependence of exogenous nucleobase rescue were consistent with several models of the rescue mechanism, including general acid base catalysis, electrostatic stabilization of negative charge in the transition state or a requirement for protonation to facilitate exogenous nucleobase binding. Detailed analyses of exogenous nucleobase rescue for both cleavage and ligation reactions now allow us to refine models of the rescue mechanism. Activity increased with increasing pH for both unmodified ribozyme reactions and unrescued reactions of abasic variants lacking G8. This similarity in pH dependence argues against a role for G8 as a general base catalyst, because G8 deprotonation could not be responsible for the pH-dependent transition in the abasic variant. Exogenous nucleobase rescue of both cleavage and ligation activity increased with decreasing pH, arguing against a role for rescuing nucleobases in general acid catalysis, because a nucleobase that contributes general acid catalysis in the cleavage pathway should provide general base catalysis in ligation. Analysis of the concentration dependence of cytosine rescue at high and low pH demonstrated that protonation promotes catalysis within the nucleobase-bound ribozyme complex but does not stabilize nucleobase binding in the ground state. These results support an electrostatic stabilization mechanism in which exogenous nucleobase binding counters negative charge that develops in the transition state.     

Nucleobase catalysis in the hairpin ribozyme

RNA catalysis is important in the processing and translation of RNA molecules, yet the mechanisms of catalysis are still unclear in most cases. We have studied the role of nucleobase catalysis in the hairpin ribozyme, where the scissile phosphate is juxtaposed between guanine and adenine bases. We show that a modified ribozyme in which guanine 8 has been substituted by an imidazole base is active in both cleavage and ligation, with ligation rates 10-fold faster than cleavage. The rates of both reactions exhibit bell-shaped dependence on pH, with pK(a) values of 5.7 +/- 0.1 and 7.7 +/- 0.1 for cleavage and 6.1 +/- 0.3 and 6.9 +/- 0.3 for ligation. The data provide good evidence for general acid-base catalysis by the nucleobases.     

A chemo-genetic approach for the study of nucleobase participation in nucleolytic ribozymes

A novel chemo-genetic approach for the analysis of general acid-base catalysis by nucleobases in ribozymes is reviewed. This involves substitution of a C-nucleoside with imidazole in place of a natural nucleobase. The Varkud satellite ribozyme in which the nucleobase at the critical 756 position has been replaced by imidazole is active in both cleavage and ligation reactions. Similarly, a modified hairpin ribozyme with the nucleobase at position 8 substituted by imidazole is active in cleavage and ligation reactions. Although the rates are lower than those of the natural ribozymes, they are significantly greater than other variants at these positions. The dependence of the hairpin ribozyme reaction rates on pH has been studied. Both cleavage and ligation reactions display a bell-shaped pH dependence, consistent with general acid-base catalysis involving the nucleotide at position 8.     

Role of an active site adenine in hairpin ribozyme catalysis

The hairpin ribozyme is a small catalytic RNA that accelerates reversible cleavage of a phosphodiester bond. Structural and mechanistic studies suggest that divalent metals stabilize the functional structure but do not participate directly in catalysis. Instead, two active site nucleobases, G8 and A38, appear to participate in catalytic chemistry. The features of A38 that are important for active site structure and chemistry were investigated by comparing cleavage and ligation reactions of ribozyme variants with A38 modifications. An abasic substitution of A38 reduced cleavage and ligation activity by 14,000-fold and 370,000-fold, respectively, highlighting the critical role of this nucleobase in ribozyme function. Cleavage and ligation activity of unmodified ribozymes increased with increasing pH, evidence that deprotonation of some functional group with an apparent pK(a) value near 6 is important for activity. The pH-dependent transition in activity shifted by several pH units in the basic direction when A38 was substituted with an abasic residue, or with nucleobase analogs with very high or low pK(a) values that are expected to retain the same protonation state throughout the experimental pH range. Certain exogenous nucleobases that share the amidine group of adenine restored activity to abasic ribozyme variants that lack A38. The pH dependence of chemical rescue reactions also changed according to the intrinsic basicity of the rescuing nucleobase, providing further evidence that the protonation state of the N1 position of purine analogs is important for rescue activity. These results are consistent with models of the hairpin ribozyme catalytic mechanism in which interactions with A38 provide electrostatic stabilization to the transition state.     

Model for general acid-base catalysis by the hammerhead ribozyme: pH-activity relationships of G8 and G12 variants at the putative active site

We have used nucleobase substitution and kinetic analysis to test the hypothesis that hammerhead catalysis occurs by a general acid-base mechanism, in which nucleobases are directly involved in deprotonation of the attacking 2'-hydroxyl group and protonation of the 5'-oxygen that serves as the leaving group in the cleavage reaction. We demonstrate that simultaneous substitution of two important nucleobases, G8 and G12, with 2,6-diaminopurine shifts the pH optimum of the cleavage reaction from greater than 9.5 to approximately 6.8 in two different hammerhead constructs. Controls involving substitution with other nucleobases and combinations of nucleobases at G5, G8, and/or G12 do not show this behavior. The observed changes in the pH-rate behavior are consistent with a mechanism in which N1 protonation-deprotonation events of guanine or 2,6-diaminopurine at positions 8 and 12 are essential for catalysis. Further support for the participation of G8 and G12 comes from photochemical cross-linking experiments, which show that G8 and G12 can stack upon the two substrate nucleobases at the reactive linkage, G(or U)1.1 and C17 (Heckman, J. E., Lambert, D., and Burke, J. M. (2005) Photocrosslinking detects a compact active structure of the hammerhead ribozyme, Biochemistry 44, 4148-4156). Together, these results support a model in which the hammerhead undergoes a transient conformational change into a catalytically active structure, in which stacking of G8 and G12 upon the nucleobases spanning the cleavage site provides an appropriate architecture for general acid-base catalysis. The hammerhead and hairpin ribozymes may share similarities in the organization of their active sites and their catalytic mechanism.     

A guanine nucleobase important for catalysis by the VS ribozyme

A guanine (G638) within the substrate loop of the VS ribozyme plays a critical role in the cleavage reaction. Replacement by any other nucleotide results in severe impairment of cleavage, yet folding of the substrate is not perturbed, and the variant substrates bind the ribozyme with similar affinity, acting as competitive inhibitors. Functional group substitution shows that the imino proton on the N1 is critical, suggesting a possible role in general acid-base catalysis, and this in accord with the pH dependence of the reaction rate for the natural and modified substrates. We propose a chemical mechanism for the ribozyme that involves general acid-base catalysis by the combination of the nucleobases of guanine 638 and adenine 756. This is closely similar to the probable mechanism of the hairpin ribozyme, and the active site arrangements for the two ribozymes appear topologically equivalent. This has probably arisen by convergent evolution.     

Energetic contribution of non-essential 5' sequence to catalysis in a hepatitis delta virus ribozyme

Hepatitis delta virus (HDV) ribozymes employ multiple catalytic strategies to achieve overall rate enhancement of RNA cleavage. These strategies include general acid-base catalysis by a cytosine side chain and involvement of divalent metal ions. Here we used a trans-acting form of the antigenomic ribozyme to examine the contribution of the 5' sequence in the substrate to HDV ribozyme catalysis. The cleavage rate constants increased for substrates with 5' sequence alterations that reduced ground-state binding to the ribozyme. Quantitatively, a plot of activation free energy of chemical conversion versus Gibb's free energy of substrate binding revealed a linear relationship with a slope of -1. This relationship is consistent with a model in which components of the substrate immediately 5' to the cleavage site in the HDV ribozyme-substrate complex destabilize ground-state binding. The intrinsic binding energy derived from the ground-state destabilization could contribute up to 2 kcal/mol toward the total 8.5 kcal/mol reduction in activation free energy for RNA cleavage catalyzed by the HDV ribozyme.     

Determination of hepatitis delta virus ribozyme N(–1) nucleobase and functional group specificity using internal competition kinetics

Biological catalysis involves interactions distant from the site of chemistry that can position the substrate for reaction. Catalysis of RNA 2′-O-transphosphorylation by the hepatitis delta virus (HDV) ribozyme is sensitive to the identity of the N(–1) nucleotide flanking the reactive phosphoryl group. However, the interactions that affect the conformation of this position, and in turn the 2′O nucleophile, are unclear. Here, we describe the application of multiple substrate internal competition kinetic analyses to understand how the N(–1) nucleobase contributes to HDV catalysis and test the utility of this approach for RNA structure–function studies. Internal competition reactions containing all four substrate sequence variants at the N(–1) position in reactions using ribozyme active site mutations at A77 and A78 were used to test a proposed base-pairing interaction. Mutants A78U, A78G, and A79G retain significant catalytic activity but do not alter the specificity for the N(–1) nucleobase. Effects of nucleobase analog substitutions at N(–1) indicate that U is preferred due to the ability to donate an H-bond in the Watson–Crick face and avoid minor groove steric clash. The results provide information essential for evaluating models of the HDV active site and illustrate multiple substrate kinetic analyses as a practical approach for characterizing structure–function relationships in RNA reactions.     

Nucleobase catalysis in ribozyme mechanism

RNA performs a wide range of functions in biology including catalysis of chemical reactions. A major goal in the field of ribozyme chemical biology is to understand these functions in molecular terms. There is increasing evidence that ribozymes can use their nucleobases directly in chemical catalysis in a variety of ways. These include hydrogen bonding to the transition state, stabilizing charge development, and transferring protons as general acid-base catalysts. This article highlights recent kinetic, structural, single molecule, and synthetic approaches that have been used to probe the roles of ribozyme nucleobases in phosphodiester bond cleavage.     

Chemical rescue, multiple ionizable groups, and general acid-base catalysis in the HDV genomic ribozyme

In the ribozyme from the hepatitis delta virus (HDV) genomic strand RNA, a cytosine side chain is proposed to facilitate proton transfer in the transition state of the reaction and, thus, act as a general acid-base catalyst. Mutation of this active-site cytosine (C75) reduced RNA cleavage rates by as much as one million-fold, but addition of exogenous cytosine and certain nucleobase or imidazole analogs can partially rescue activity in these mutants. However, pH-rate profiles for the rescued reactions were bell shaped, and only one leg of the pH-rate curve could be attributed to ionization of the exogenous nucleobase or buffer. When a second potential ionizable nucleobase (C41) was removed, one leg of the bell-shaped curve was eliminated in the chemical-rescue reaction. With this construct, the apparent pK(a) determined from the pH-rate profile correlated with the solution pK(a) of the buffer, and the contribution of the buffer to the rate enhancement could be directly evaluated in a free-energy or Br?nsted plot. The free-energy relationship between the acid dissociation constant of the buffer and the rate constant for cleavage (Br?nsted value, beta, = approximately 0.5) was consistent with a mechanism in which the buffer acted as a general acid-base catalyst. These data support the hypothesis that cytosine 75, in the intact ribozyme, acts as a general acid-base catalyst.     

Ligand-pKa shifts through metals: potential relevance to ribozyme chemistry

Functional and crystallographic analyses of catalytically active RNA molecules ('ribozymes') have revealed a multitude of different routes by which nature accomplishes cleavage reactions of the RNA sugar-phosphate backbone. While there is agreement that these reactions involve general acid-base chemistry, the choice of 'acid' and of 'base' appears to be quite versatile. Among the numerous surprises that have emerged from these studies in recent years is the phenomenon of 'shifted pK(a) values' of nucleobases, hence, the fact that pK(a) values of isolated nucleobases in H(2)O can be shifted in either direction--upward or downward--into the physiological pH range, and that consequently allows these nucleobases to function as 'acids' or 'bases'. Another change in paradigm in recent years relates to the role of divalent metal ions in these catalytic reactions, which points to the possibility of an indirect involvement in the catalytic cycle rather than necessarily to a direct participation, as in the case with the hepatitis delta virus ribozyme. In this review, basic features of nucleobases and/or aqua ligand pK(a) shifts caused by metal coordination and H-bonding are discussed.     

小型核酶的结构和催化机理

自然界存在的小型核酶主要有锤头型核酶、发夹型核酶、肝炎δ病毒（HDV）核酶和VS核酶.锤头型核酶由3个短螺旋和1个广义保守的连接序列组成;发夹型核酶的催化中心由两个肩并肩挨着的区域构成;HDV核酶折叠成包含五个螺旋臂（P1～P4）的双结结构;VS核酶由五个螺旋结构组成,这些螺旋结构通过两个连接域连接起来.小型核酶的催化机理与其分子结构密切相关.金属离子或特定碱基都可作为催化反应的关键成分.锤头型核酶的催化必须有金属离子（尤其是二价金属离子）参与,而发夹型核酶则完全不需要金属离子.基因组HDV核酶进行催化时要有金属离子和特定碱基互相配合.     

Three conserved guanosines approach the reaction site in native and minimal hammerhead ribozymes

Native hammerhead ribozymes contain RNA domains that enable high catalytic activity under physiological conditions, where minimal hammerheads show little activity. However, little is known about potential differences in native versus minimal ribozyme folding. Here, we present results of photocross-linking analysis of native and minimal hammerheads containing photoreactive nucleobases 6-thioguanosine, 2,6-diaminopurine, 4-thiouridine, and pyrrolocytidine, introduced at specific sites within the catalytic core. Under conditions where catalytic activity is observed, the two substrate nucleobases spanning the cleavage site approach and stack upon G8 and G12 of the native hammerhead, two conserved nucleobases that show similar behavior in minimal constructs, have been implicated in general acid-base catalysis, and are >15 A from the cleavage site in the crystal structures. Pyrrolocytidine at cleavage site position 17 forms an efficient crosslink to G12, and the crosslinked RNA retains catalytic activity. Multiple cross-linked species point to a structural rearrangement within the U-turn, positioning residue G5 in the vicinity of cleavage site position 1.1. Intriguing crosslinks were triggered by nucleotide analogues at positions distal to the crosslinked residues; for example, 6-thioguanosine at position 5 induced a crosslink between G12 and C17, suggesting an intimate functional communication among these three nucleobases. Together, these results support a model in which the native hammerhead folds to an active structure similar to that of the minimal ribozyme, and significantly different from the crystallographic structures.     

The ionic environment determines ribozyme cleavage rate by modulation of nucleobase pK a

Several small ribozymes employ general acid–base catalysis as a mechanism to enhance site-specific RNA cleavage, even though the functional groups on the ribonucleoside building blocks of RNA have pK_a values far removed from physiological pH. The rate of the cleavage reaction is strongly affected by the identity of the metal cation present in the reaction solution; however, the mechanism(s) by which different cations contribute to rate enhancement has not been determined. Using the Neurospora VS ribozyme, we provide evidence that different cations confer particular shifts in the apparent pK_a values of the catalytic nucleobases, which in turn determines the fraction of RNA in the protonation state competent for general acid–base catalysis at a given pH, which determines the observed rate of the cleavage reaction. Despite large differences in observed rates of cleavage in different cations, mathematical models of general acid–base catalysis indicate that k₁, the intrinsic rate of the bond-breaking step, is essentially constant irrespective of the identity of the cation(s) in the reaction solution. Thus, in contrast to models that invoke unique roles for metal ions in ribozyme chemical mechanisms, we find that most, and possibly all, of the ion-specific rate enhancement in the VS ribozyme can be explained solely by the effect of the ions on nucleobase pK_a. The inference that k₁ is essentially constant suggests a resolution of the problem of kinetic ambiguity in favor of a model in which the lower pK_a is that of the general acid and the higher pK_a is that of the general base.     

The effect of universal fluorinated nucleobases on the catalytic activity of ribozymes

Four fluoro modified universal nucleobases have been synthesized. The universal nucleobases 1 and 2, containing a 2,4-difluorobenzene as nucleobase and a 4,6-difluorobenzimidazole, respectively, were chemically incorporated into a selected hammerhead ribozyme sequence which has already been retrovirally expressed as an anti-HIV ribozyme to investigate their effect on the catalytic activity of the ribozymes. The substitution of the natural nucleosides with either 1 or 2 results only in a small decrease of the catalytic activity. The Km value for the monosubstituted ribozyme with a 2,4-difluorobenzene is 309 nM(-1), the corresponding kcat is 2.91 x 10(-3) min(-1). A disubstituted hammerhead ribozyme carrying one of each modification has also been synthesized. For a further stabilization of the ribozyme/substrate complex 2'-(beta-aminoethoxy) modified fluorinated nucleosides 15 and 16 have been developed.     

Mechanisms of RNA catalysis

Ribozymes are RNA molecules that act as chemical catalysts. In contemporary cells, most known ribozymes carry out phosphoryl transfer reactions. The nucleolytic ribozymes comprise a class of five structurally-distinct species that bring about site-specific cleavage by nucleophilic attack of the 2'-O on the adjacent 3'-P to form a cyclic 2',3'-phosphate. In general, they will also catalyse the reverse reaction. As a class, all these ribozymes appear to use general acid-base catalysis to accelerate these reactions by about a million-fold. In the Varkud satellite ribozyme, we have shown that the cleavage reaction is catalysed by guanine and adenine nucleobases acting as general base and acid, respectively. The hairpin ribozyme most probably uses a closely similar mechanism. Guanine nucleobases appear to be a common choice of general base, but the general acid is more variable. By contrast, the larger ribozymes such as the self-splicing introns and RNase P act as metalloenzymes.     

Electrostatic interactions in the hairpin ribozyme account for the majority of the rate acceleration without chemical participation by nucleobases

Molecular dynamics simulations using a combined quantum mechanical/molecular mechanical potential are used to determine the two-dimensional free energy profiles for the mechanism of RNA transphosphorylation in solution and catalyzed by the hairpin ribozyme. A mechanism is explored whereby the reaction proceeds without explicit chemical participation by conserved nucleobases in the active site. The ribozyme lowers the overall free energy barrier by up to 16 kcal/mol, accounting for the majority of the observed rate enhancement. The barrier reduction in this mechanism is achieved mainly by the electrostatic environment provided by the ribozyme without recruitment of active site nucleobases as acid or base catalysts. The results establish a baseline mechanism that invokes only the solvation and specific hydrogen-bonding interactions present in the ribozyme active site and provide a departure point for the exploration of alternate mechanisms where nucleobases play an active chemical role.     

The hairpin ribozyme

The hairpin ribozyme is a naturally occurring RNA that catalyzes sequence-specific cleavage and ligation of RNA. It has been the subject of extensive biochemical and structural studies, perhaps the most detailed for any catalytic RNA to date. Comparison of the structures of its constituent domains free and fully assembled demonstrates that the RNA undergoes extensive structural rearrangement. This rearrangement results in a distortion of the substrate RNA that primes it for cleavage. This ribozyme is known to achieve catalysis employing exclusively RNA functional groups. Metal ions or other catalytic cofactors are not used. Current experimental evidence points to a combination of at least four mechanistic strategies by this RNA: (1) precise substrate orientation, (2) preferential transition state binding, (3) electrostatic catalysis, and (4) general acid base catalysis.     

In vitro selection of second site revertants analysis of the hairpin ribozyme active site

We have used in vitro genetics to evaluate the function and interactions of the conserved base G8 in the hairpin ribozyme catalytic RNA. Second site revertant selection for a G8X mutant, where X is any of the other three natural nucleobases, yielded a family of second site suppressors of the G8U mutant, but not of G8C or G8A, indicating that only G and U can be tolerated at position 8 of the ribozyme. This result is consistent with recent observations that point to the functional importance of G8 N-1 in the chemistry of catalysis by this ribozyme reaction. Suppression of the G8U mutation was observed when changes were made directly across loop A from the mutated base at substrate position +2 or positions +2 and +3 in combination. The same changes made in the context of the natural G8 sequence resulted in a very large drop in activity. Thus, the G8U mutation results in a change in specificity of the ribozyme from 5'-N / GUC-3' to 5'-N / GCU-3'. The results presented imply that G8 interacts directly with U+2 during catalysis. We propose that this interaction favors the correct positioning of the catalytic determinants of G8. The implications for the folding of the ribozyme and the catalytic mechanism are discussed.     

Catalysis by the nucleolytic ribozymes

The nucleolytic ribozymes use general acid-base catalysis to contribute significantly to their rate enhancement. The VS (Varkud satellite) ribozyme uses a guanine and an adenine nucleobase as general base and acid respectively in the cleavage reaction. The hairpin ribozyme is probably closely similar, while the remaining nucleolytic ribozymes provide some interesting contrasts.