Identification of novel fragment compounds targeted against the pY pocket of v-Src SH2 by computational and NMR screening and thermodynamic evaluation

Discovery of small molecule inhibitors of protein-protein interactions is a major challenge to pharmaceutical development. Fragment-based approaches have begun to be widely adopted as an effective way of exploring chemical space on a protein surface with reduced library size. On completion of a fragment screen, the subsequent selection of appropriate "hit" molecules for development is a key decision point. Thermodynamic parameters can be used in this decision process. In this work, a fragment identification protocol based on a virtual fragment analysis and selection followed by 19F NMR screening was directed at the phosphotyrosine binding site of the Src SH2 domain. Three new ligands were identified. Isothermal titration calorimetry was used to provide thermodynamic parameters for the physiologically relevant ligand and the selected fragments. One of these fragments possesses a highly favorable enthalpic contribution to complex formation compared to other fragments and to the physiologically relevant ligand suggesting that it would make a good candidate for compound development.     

Binding-Site Assessment by Virtual Fragment Screening

The accurate prediction of protein druggability (propensity to bind high-affinity drug-like small molecules) would greatly benefit the fields of chemical genomics and drug discovery. We have developed a novel approach to quantitatively assess protein druggability by computationally screening a fragment-like compound library. In analogy to NMR-based fragment screening, we dock ∼11000 fragments against a given binding site and compute a computational hit rate based on the fraction of molecules that exceed an empirically chosen score cutoff. We perform a large-scale evaluation of the approach on four datasets, totaling 152 binding sites. We demonstrate that computed hit rates correlate with hit rates measured experimentally in a previously published NMR-based screening method. Secondly, we show that the in silico fragment screening method can be used to distinguish known druggable and non-druggable targets, including both enzymes and protein-protein interaction sites. Finally, we explore the sensitivity of the results to different receptor conformations, including flexible protein-protein interaction sites. Besides its original aim to assess druggability of different protein targets, this method could be used to identifying druggable conformations of flexible binding site for lead discovery, and suggesting strategies for growing or joining initial fragment hits to obtain more potent inhibitors.     

Ligand specificity, privileged substructures and protein druggability from fragment-based screening

Fragment-based screening has now become an established method for the generation of lead molecules against therapeutic targets. Fragment molecules are simple, low molecular-weight compounds with few chemical functionalities. These characteristics lead to high hit rates for fragment screening as compared to the more classical High-Throughput Screening of drug-like molecules and raise the question of the specificity of fragment molecules. This review analyzes recent outcomes of fragment screenings published in the literature, showing that the specificity of the fragments can be related to their structures and physico-chemical properties. We also discuss both the concept of privileged fragment scaffolds and the role of fragment-based screening in predicting protein druggability, highlighted by recent publications in the field.     

Fragment-based virtual screening approach and molecular dynamics simulation studies for identification of BACE1 inhibitor leads

Traditional structure-based virtual screening method to identify drug-like small molecules for BACE1 is so far unsuccessful. Location of BACE1, poor Blood Brain Barrier permeability and P-glycoprotein (Pgp) susceptibility of the inhibitors make it even more difficult. Fragment-based drug design method is suitable for efficient optimization of initial hit molecules for target like BACE1. We have developed a fragment-based virtual screening approach to identify/optimize the fragment molecules as a starting point. This method combines the shape, electrostatic, and pharmacophoric features of known fragment molecules, bound to protein conjugate crystal structure, and aims to identify both chemically and energetically feasible small fragment ligands that bind to BACE1 active site. The two top-ranked fragment hits were subjected for a 53 ns MD simulation. Principle component analysis and free energy landscape analysis reveal that the new ligands show the characteristic features of established BACE1 inhibitors. The potent method employed in this study may serve for the development of potential lead molecules for BACE1-directed Alzheimer’s disease therapeutics.     

Comparing Binding Modes of Analogous Fragments Using NMR in Fragment-Based Drug Design: Application to PRDX5

Fragment-based drug design is one of the most promising approaches for discovering novel and potent inhibitors against therapeutic targets. The first step of the process consists of identifying fragments that bind the protein target. The determination of the fragment binding mode plays a major role in the selection of the fragment hits that will be processed into drug-like compounds. Comparing the binding modes of analogous fragments is a critical task, not only to identify specific interactions between the protein target and the fragment, but also to verify whether the binding mode is conserved or differs according to the fragment modification. While X-ray crystallography is the technique of choice, NMR methods are helpful when this fails. We show here how the ligand-observed saturation transfer difference (STD) experiment and the protein-observed ¹⁵N-HSQC experiment, two popular NMR screening experiments, can be used to compare the binding modes of analogous fragments. We discuss the application and limitations of these approaches based on STD-epitope mapping, chemical shift perturbation (CSP) calculation and comparative CSP sign analysis, using the human peroxiredoxin 5 as a protein model.     

Fragment-based screening using X-ray crystallography and NMR spectroscopy

Approaches which start from a study of the interaction of very simple molecules (fragments) with the protein target are proving to be valuable additions to drug design. Fragment-based screening allows the complementarity between a protein active site and drug-like molecules to be rapidly and effectively explored, using structural methods. Recent improvements in the intensities of laboratory X-ray sources permits the collection of greater amounts of high-quality diffraction data and have been matched by developments in automation, crystallisation and data analysis. Developments in NMR screening, including the use of cryogenically cooled NMR probes and (19)F-containing reporter molecules have expanded the scope of this technique, while increasing the availability of binding site and quantitative affinity data for the fragments. Application of these methods has led to a greater knowledge of the chemical variety, structural features and energetics of protein-fragment interactions. While fragment-based screening has already been shown to reduce the timescales of the drug discovery process, a more detailed characterisation of fragment screening hits can reveal unexpected similarities between fragment chemotypes and protein active sites leading to improved understanding of the pharmacophores and the re-use of this information against other protein targets.     

Fluorescence-based methods for screening writers and readers of histone methyl marks

The histone methyltransferase (HMT) family of proteins consists of enzymes that methylate lysine or arginine residues on histone tails as well as other proteins. Such modifications affect chromatin structure and play a significant regulatory role in gene expression. Many HMTs have been implicated in tumorigenesis and progression of multiple malignancies and play essential roles in embryonic development and stem cell renewal. Overexpression of some HMTs has been observed and is correlated positively with various types of cancer. Here the authors report development of a continuous fluorescence-based methyltransferase assay in a 384-well format and its application in determining kinetic parameters for EHMT1, G9a, PRMT3, SETD7, and SUV39H2 as well as for screening against libraries of small molecules to identify enzyme inhibitors. They also report the development of a peptide displacement assay using fluorescence polarization in a 384-well format to assay and screen protein peptide interactions such as those of WDR5 and EED, components of MLL and EZH2 methyltransferase complexes. Using these high-throughput screening methods, the authors have identified potent inhibitors and ligands for some of these proteins.     

Novel approach of fragment-based lead discovery applied to renin inhibitors

A novel approach was conducted for fragment-based lead discovery and applied to renin inhibitors. The biochemical screening of a fragment library against renin provided the hit fragment which showed a characteristic interaction pattern with the target protein. The hit fragment bound only to the S1, S3, and S3^SP (S3 subpocket) sites without any interactions with the catalytic aspartate residues (Asp32 and Asp215 (pepsin numbering)). Prior to making chemical modifications to the hit fragment, we first identified its essential binding sites by utilizing the hit fragment’s substructures. Second, we created a new and smaller scaffold, which better occupied the identified essential S3 and S3^SP sites, by utilizing library synthesis with high-throughput chemistry. We then revisited the S1 site and efficiently explored a good building block attaching to the scaffold with library synthesis. In the library syntheses, the binding modes of each pivotal compound were determined and confirmed by X-ray crystallography and the library was strategically designed by structure-based computational approach not only to obtain a more active compound but also to obtain informative Structure Activity Relationship (SAR). As a result, we obtained a lead compound offering synthetic accessibility as well as the improved in vitro ADMET profiles. The fragments and compounds possessing a characteristic interaction pattern provided new structural insights into renin’s active site and the potential to create a new generation of renin inhibitors. In addition, we demonstrated our FBDD strategy integrating highly sensitive biochemical assay, X-ray crystallography, and high-throughput synthesis and in silico library design aimed at fragment morphing at the initial stage was effective to elucidate a pocket profile and a promising lead compound.     

Intracellular antibodies and cancer: New technologies offer therapeutic opportunities

Since the realisation that the antigen‐binding regions of antibodies, the variable (V) regions, can be uncoupled from the rest of the molecule to create fragments that recognise and abrogate particular protein functions in cells, the use of antibody fragments inside cells has become an important tool in bioscience. Diverse libraries of antibody fragments plus in vivo screening can be used to isolate single chain variable fragments comprising VH and VL segments or single V‐region domains. Some of these are interfering antibody fragments that compete with protein‐protein interactions, providing lead molecules for drug interactions that until now have been considered difficult or undruggable. It may be possible to deliver or express antibody fragments in target cells as macrodrugs per se. In future incarnations of intracellular antibodies, however, the structural information of the interaction interface of target and antibody fragment should facilitate development of binding site mimics as small drug‐like molecules. This is a new dawn for intracellular antibody fragments both as macrodrugs and as precursors of drugs to treat human diseases and should finally lead to the removal of the epithet of the ‘undruggable’ protein‐protein interactions.     

Discovery of novel inhibitors of the ZipA/FtsZ complex by NMR fragment screening coupled with structure-based design

ZipA is a membrane anchored protein in Escherichia coli that interacts with FtsZ, a homolog of eukaryotic tubulins, forming a septal ring structure that mediates bacterial cell division. Thus, the ZipA/FtsZ protein-protein interaction is a potential target for an antibacterial agent. We report here an NMR-based fragment screening approach which identified several hits that bind to the C-terminal region of ZipA. The screen was performed by 1H-15N HSQC experiments on a library of 825 fragments that are small, lead-like, and highly soluble. Seven hits were identified, and the binding mode of the best one was revealed in the X-ray crystal structure. Similar to the ZipA/FtsZ contacts, the driving force in the binding of the small molecule ligands to ZipA is achieved through hydrophobic interactions. Analogs of this hit were also evaluated by NMR and X-ray crystal structures of these analogs with ZipA were obtained, providing structural information to help guide the medicinal chemistry efforts.     

Straightforward hit identification approach in fragment-based discovery of bromodomain-containing protein 4 (BRD4) inhibitors

A combination approach of a fragment screening and “SAR by catalog” was used for the discovery of bromodomain-containing protein 4 (BRD4) inhibitors. Initial screening of 3695-fragment library against bromodomain 1 of BRD4 using thermal shift assay (TSA), followed by initial hit validation, resulted in 73 fragment hits, which were used to construct a follow-up library selected from available screening collection. Additionally, analogs of inactive fragments, as well as a set of randomly selected compounds were also prepared (3?×?3200 compounds in total). Screening of the resulting sets using TSA, followed by re-testing at several concentrations, counter-screen, and TR-FRET assay resulted in 18 confirmed hits. Compounds derived from the initial fragment set showed better hit rate as compared to the other two sets. Finally, building dose-response curves revealed three compounds with IC₅₀?=?1.9–7.4?μM. For these compounds, binding sites and conformations in the BRD4 (4UYD) have been determined by docking.     

Knowledge-based Fragment Binding Prediction

Target-based drug discovery must assess many drug-like compounds for potential activity. Focusing on low-molecular-weight compounds (fragments) can dramatically reduce the chemical search space. However, approaches for determining protein-fragment interactions have limitations. Experimental assays are time-consuming, expensive, and not always applicable. At the same time, computational approaches using physics-based methods have limited accuracy. With increasing high-resolution structural data for protein-ligand complexes, there is now an opportunity for data-driven approaches to fragment binding prediction. We present FragFEATURE, a machine learning approach to predict small molecule fragments preferred by a target protein structure. We first create a knowledge base of protein structural environments annotated with the small molecule substructures they bind. These substructures have low-molecular weight and serve as a proxy for fragments. FragFEATURE then compares the structural environments within a target protein to those in the knowledge base to retrieve statistically preferred fragments. It merges information across diverse ligands with shared substructures to generate predictions. Our results demonstrate FragFEATURE''s ability to rediscover fragments corresponding to the ligand bound with 74% precision and 82% recall on average. For many protein targets, it identifies high scoring fragments that are substructures of known inhibitors. FragFEATURE thus predicts fragments that can serve as inputs to fragment-based drug design or serve as refinement criteria for creating target-specific compound libraries for experimental or computational screening.     

Robust and Systematic Drug Screening Method Using Chemical Arrays and the Protein Library: Identification of Novel Inhibitors of Carbonic Anhydrase II

The identification of specific interactions between small molecules and human proteins of interest is a fundamental step in chemical biology and drug development. Here we describe an efficient method to obtain novel binding ligands of human proteins by a chemical array approach. Our method includes large-scale ligand screening with two libraries, proteins and chemicals, the use of cell lysates that express proteins of interest fused with red fluorescent protein, and high-throughput screening by merged display analysis, which removes false positive signals from array experiments. Using our systematic platform, we detected novel inhibitors of carbonic anhydrase II. It is suggested that our systematic platform is a rapid and robust approach to screen novel ligands for human proteins of interest.     

Innovations in targeting RNA by fragment-based ligand discovery

A subset of functional regions within large RNAs fold into complex structures able to bind small-molecule ligands with high affinity and specificity. Fragment-based ligand discovery (FBLD) offers notable opportunities for discovery and design of potent small molecules that bind pockets in RNA. Here we share an integrated analysis of recent innovations in FBLD, emphasizing opportunities resulting from fragment elaboration via both linking and growing. Analysis of elaborated fragments emphasizes that high–quality interactions form with complex tertiary structures in RNA. FBLD-inspired small molecules have been shown to modulate RNA functions by competitively inhibiting protein binding and by selectively stabilizing dynamic RNA states. FBLD is creating a foundation to interrogate the relatively unknown structural space for RNA ligands and for discovery of RNA-targeted therapeutics.     

Robust and systematic drug screening method using chemical arrays and the protein library: identification of novel inhibitors of carbonic anhydrase II

The identification of specific interactions between small molecules and human proteins of interest is a fundamental step in chemical biology and drug development. Here we describe an efficient method to obtain novel binding ligands of human proteins by a chemical array approach. Our method includes large-scale ligand screening with two libraries, proteins and chemicals, the use of cell lysates that express proteins of interest fused with red fluorescent protein, and high-throughput screening by merged display analysis, which removes false positive signals from array experiments. Using our systematic platform, we detected novel inhibitors of carbonic anhydrase II. It is suggested that our systematic platform is a rapid and robust approach to screen novel ligands for human proteins of interest.     

Strategies to search and design stabilizers of protein-protein interactions: a feasibility study

Since protein-protein interactions play a pivotal role in the communication on the molecular level in virtually every biological system and process, the search and design for modulators of such interactions is of utmost importance. In recent years many inhibitors for specific protein-protein interactions have been developed, however, in only a few cases, small and druglike molecules are able to interfere in the complex formation of proteins. On the other hand, there are several small molecules known to modulate protein-protein interactions by means of stabilizing an already assembled complex. To achieve this goal, a ligand is binding to a pocket, which is located rim-exposed at the interface of the interacting proteins, for example as the phytotoxin Fusicoccin, which stabilizes the interaction of plant H+-ATPase and 14-3-3 protein by nearly a factor of 100. To suggest alternative leads, we performed a virtual screening campaign to discover new molecules putatively stabilizing this complex. Furthermore, we screen a dataset of 198 transient recognition protein-protein complexes for cavities, which are located rim-exposed at their interfaces. We provide evidence for high similarity between such rim-exposed cavities and usual ligands accommodating active sites of enzymes. This analysis suggests that rim-exposed cavities at protein-protein interfaces are druggable binding sites. Therefore, the principle of stabilizing protein-protein interactions seems to be a promising alternative to the approach of the competitive inhibition of such interactions by small molecules.     

Fragment library screening reveals remarkable similarities between the G protein-coupled receptor histamine H₄ and the ion channel serotonin 5-HT₃A

A fragment library was screened against the G protein-coupled histamine H(4) receptor (H(4)R) and the ligand-gated ion channel serotonin 5-HT(3A) (5-HT(3A)R). Interestingly, significant overlap was found between H(4)R and 5-HT(3A)R hit sets. The data indicates that dual active H(4)R and 5 HT(3A)R fragments have a higher complexity than the selective compounds which has important implications for chemical genomics approaches. The results of our fragment-based library screening study illustrate similarities in ligand recognition between H(4)R and 5-HT(3A)R and have important consequences for selectivity profiling in ongoing drug discovery efforts on H(4)R and 5-HT(3A)R. The affinity profiles of our fragment screening studies furthermore match the chemical properties of the H(4)R and 5-HT(3A)R binding sites and can be used to define molecular interaction fingerprints to guide the in silico prediction of protein-ligand interactions and structure.     

Discovery of Potent ALK Inhibitors Using Pharmacophore-Informatics Strategy

Anaplastic lymphoma kinase is a tyrosine kinase receptor protein belonging to insulin receptor superfamily. Gene fusions in anaplastic lymphoma kinase are associated with non-small cell lung cancer development. Hence, they are of immense importance in targeted therapies. Thus, for the treatment of non-small cell lung cancer, effective anaplastic lymphoma kinase inhibitors are of great significance. Therefore, our objective is to find hit compounds that could have better inhibitory activity than the existing anaplastic lymphoma kinase inhibitors. Keeping this in mind, in the present study pharmacophore based virtual screening was performed to identify possible anaplastic lymphoma kinase inhibitors. Initially, a five-point common pharmacophore hypothesis was generated based on twelve anaplastic lymphoma kinase inhibitors using PHASE module of Schrödinger. Subsequently, common pharmacophore hypothesis-based screening was conducted against in-trials subset of ZINC database and a total of 1000 hits were identified. The molecules obtained were further screened by three stages of docking using GLIDE software. The docking results reveal that six hit molecules showed higher glide score in comparison with the reference molecules. Finally, pharmacokinetic properties of the hit molecules were also analysed using QikProp programme. The results indicate that molecules namely videx, dexecadotril, chloramphenicol, naficillin were found to have good pharmacokinetic properties and human oral absorption. Moreover, videx, naficillin and chloramphenicol were found to have significant inhibitory activity for mutant (F1174L) anaplastic lymphoma kinase. It was also found that videx exhibited crucial interactions with the Met1199 residue of the native and mutant anaplastic lymphoma kinase protein. Furthermore, PASS algorithm predicted anti-neoplastic activity for all the four molecules. Thus these hits are found to be promising leads for anaplastic lymphoma kinase inhibitors. We believe that this study will be useful for the discovery and designing of more potent anaplastic lymphoma kinase inhibitors in the near future.     

Virtual screening against metalloenzymes for inhibitors and substrates

Molecular docking uses the three-dimensional structure of a receptor to screen databases of small molecules for potential ligands, often based on energetic complementarity. For many docking scoring functions, which calculate nonbonded interactions, metalloenzymes are challenging because of the partial covalent nature of metal-ligand interactions. To investigate how well molecular docking can identify potential ligands of metalloenzymes using a "standard" scoring function, we have docked the MDL Drug Data Report (MDDR), a functionally annotated database of 95,000 small molecules, against the X-ray crystal structures of five metalloenzymes. These enzymes included three zinc proteases, the nickel analogue of an iron enzyme, and a molybdenum metalloenzyme. The ability of the docking program to retrospectively enrich the annotated ligands as high-scoring hits for each enzyme and to calculate proper geometries was evaluated. In all five systems, the annotated ligands within the MDDR were enriched at least 20 times over random. To test the approach prospectively, a sixth target, the zinc beta-lactamase from Bacteroides fragilis, was screened against the fragment-like subset of the ZINC database. We purchased and tested 15 compounds from among the top 50 top-ranked ligands from docking, and found 5 inhibitors with apparent K(i) values less than 120 microM, the best of which was 2 microM. A more ambitious test still was predicting actual substrates for a seventh target, a Zn-dependent phosphotriesterase from Pseudomonas diminuta. Screening the Available Chemicals Directory (ACD) identified 25 thiophosphate esters as potential substrates within the top 100 ranked compounds. Eight of these, all previously uncharacterized for this enzyme, were acquired and tested, and all were confirmed experimentally as substrates. These results suggest that a simple, noncovalent scoring function may be used to identify inhibitors of at least some metalloenzymes.