Hydrogen turnover by psychrotrophic homoacetogenic and mesophilic methanogenic bacteria in anoxic paddy soil and lake sediment

Abstract The effect of temperature on CH₄ production, turnover of dissolved H₂, and enrichment of H₂-utilizing anaerobic bacteria was studied in anoxic paddy soil and sediment of Lake Constance. When anoxic paddy soil was incubated under an atmosphere of H₂/CO₂, rates of CH₄ production increased 25°C, but decreased at temperatures lower than 20°C. Chloroform completely inhibited methano-genesis in anoxic paddy soil and lake sediment, but did not or only partially inhibit the turnover of dissolved H₂, especially at low incubation temperatures. Cultures with H₂ as energy source resulted in the enrichment of chemolithotrophic homoacetogenic bacteria whenever incubation temperatures were lower than 20°C. Hydrogenotrophic methanogens could only be enriched at 30°C from anoxic paddy soil. A homoacetogen     

Effect of algal deposition on acetate and methane concentrations in the profundal sediment of a deep lake (Lake Constance)

Abstract In the profundal sediment ot Lake Constance (143 m depth) the temperature is constant at 4 °C. Despite the constant temperature, CH₄ concentrations changed with season between about 120 μM in winter and about 750 μM in summer, measured down to 30 cm depth. The acetate concentration profiles also varied between seasons. In summer, acetate concentration reached a maximum at about 100 μM in 2 or 4 cm depth. In winter, maximal concentrations of about 5 μM were observed over the entire depth. Input of organic material in late spring may be the reason for the seasonal change of both compounds. To simulate such a sedimentation event, intact sediment cores were covered with suspensions of Porphyridium aerugenium or Synechococcus sp. The addition of the phytoplankton material resulted in a drastic increase of acetate concentrations with a maximum at 2 cm depth, similar to in situ acetate concentrations measured in summer. The same applies for CH₄ for which increased concentrations were observed down to 6 cm depth. H₂ concentrations, on the other hand, showed no distinct increase. Treatment of intact sediment cores with ¹⁴C-labeled Synechococcus cells resulted in the formation of ¹⁴C-acetate, ¹⁴CH₄ and ¹⁴CO₂. Maximum concentrations of ¹⁴CH₄ were found at 4 cm depth, i.e. just above the depth to which ¹⁴C-acetate penetrated. The results show that phytoplankton blooms may cause a seasonal variation of acetate and CH₄ in profundal sediments of deep lakes despite the constant low temperature. They also indicate that acetate is the dominant substrate for methanogenic bacteria in the profundal sediments of Lake Constance.     

Methyl sulfides as intermediates in the anaerobic oxidation of methane

While it is clear that microbial consortia containing Archaea and sulfate-reducing bacteria (SRB) can mediate the anaerobic oxidation of methane (AOM), the interplay between these microorganisms remains unknown. The leading explanation of the AOM metabolism is 'reverse methanogenesis' by which a methanogenesis substrate is produced and transferred between species. Conceptually, the reversal of methanogenesis requires low H₂ concentrations for energetic favourability. We used ¹³C-labelled CH₄ as a tracer to test the effects of elevated H₂ pressures on incubations of active AOM sediments from both the Eel River basin and Hydrate Ridge. In the presence of H₂, we observed a minimal reduction in the rate of CH₄ oxidation, and conclude H₂ does not play an interspecies role in AOM. Based on these results, as well as previous work, we propose a new model for substrate transfer in AOM. In this model, methyl sulfides produced by the Archaea from both CH₄ oxidation and CO₂ reduction are transferred to the SRB. Metabolically, CH₄ oxidation provides electrons for the energy-yielding reduction of CO₂ to a methyl group ('methylogenesis'). Methylogenesis is a dominantly reductive pathway utilizing most methanogenesis enzymes in their forward direction. Incubations of seep sediments demonstrate, as would be expected from this model, that methanethiol inhibits AOM and that CO can be substituted for CH₄ as the electron donor for methylogenesis.     

Acetogenesis from H2 and CO2 by methane- and non-methane-producing human colonic bacterial communities

Abstract: The purpose of the study was to define the potential for reductive acetogenesis of colonic microflora from six non-methane- and four methane-excreting human subjects in relation to numbers of the different H₂-utilizing microorganisms. Faecal bacterial suspensions were incubated in the presence of NaH¹³CO₃ and under a gas phase composed of either 100% N₂ (control) or 80% H₂–20% N₂. The effects of a specific methanogenesis inhibitor or of sulfate supplementation were also determined. Quantitative nuclear magnetic resonance showed the presence of both single- and double-labelled acetate in all incubations under hydrogen. H₂/CO₂-acetogenesis appears to be a quantitatively important activity only in the presence of very low numbers of methanogens. Inhibition of methanogenesis induced a large increase in ¹³CO₂ incorporation into acetate in CH₄-producing samples. These results showed that methanogens can efficiently outcompete acetogens in human colonic contents. In contrast, no clear-cut competition for H₂ between acetogenesis and dissimilatory sulfate-reduction could be demonstrated. A slight reduction of the acetogenic activity was only observed at the highest sulfate addition (100 mM).     

Adaptation of soil bacterial communities to prevailing pH in different soils

Abstract: The bacterial community response to pH was studied for 16 soils with pH(H₂O) ranging between 4 and 8 by measuring thymidine incorporation into bacteria extracted from the soil into a solution using homogenization-centrifugation. The pH of the bacterial solution was altered to six different values with dilute sulfuric acid or different buffers before measuring incorporation. The resulting pH response curve for thymidine incorporation was used to compare bacterial communities from the different soils. There was a correlation between optimum pH for thymidine incorporation and the soil pH(H₂O). Even bacterial communities from acid soils had optima corresponding to the soil pH, indicating that they were adapted to these conditions. Thymidine incorporation was also compared with leucine incorporation for some soils. The leucine to thymidine incorporation ratio was constant over the tested pH interval when incorporation values were adjusted for isotope dilution. A good correlation was found between the scores along the first component (explaining 80% of the variation) and soil pH ( r ² = 0.85), if principal component analysis of the pH response curves for thymidine incorporation was used. The pH response curves differed most for the extreme pH values used, and a linear relationship was found between the logarithm of the ratio of thymidine incorporation at pH 4.3 to incorporation at pH 8.2 and the soil pH ( r ² = 0.86). Thus, a simplified technique using only two pH values, when measuring the thymidine incorporation, could be used to compare the response to pH of bacterial communities.     

Cloning and DNA homology of 3-isopropylmalate dehydrogenase genes from thermophilic bacilli

Abstract Clostridium thermoaceticum was cultivated heterotrophically under CO₂, carbon monoxide (CO), and H₂ gas phases. Formate dehydrogenase (FDH) levels increased 4-fold in CO cultures; formyltetrahydrofolate synthetase (FTS) levels were not influenced by the cultivation gas phases tested. While CO dehydrogenase (CODH) was slightly stimulated in CO cultures, CO-dependent acetyl phosphate-synthesizing system (APSS) activity increased sharply in both CO and H₂ cultures. Y _glucose values increased, whereas doubling times and acetate to biomass ratios decreased significantly in CO cultures, suggesting that CO cultures were energetically dissimilar to non-CO cultures. This finding, together with the absence of CO-dependent ATP-independent synthesis of formyltetrahydrofolate (formyl-THF), supports the hypothesis that conservation of CO-derived energy involves electron transport phosphorylation.     

Effects of raised CO2 on potential CH4 production and oxidation in, and CH4 emission from, a boreal mire

1 In a glasshouse experiment we studied the effect of raised CO₂ concentration (720 p.p.m.) on CH₄ emission at natural boreal peat temperatures using intact cores of boreal peat with living vascular plants and Sphagnum mosses. After the end of the growing season half of the cores were kept unnaturally warm (17–20 °C). The potential for CH₄ production and oxidation was measured at the end of the emission experiment.
2 The vascular cores ('Sedge') consisted of a moss layer with sedges, and the moss cores (' Sphagnum ') of Sphagnum mosses (some sedge seedlings were removed by cutting). Methane efflux was 6–12 times higher from the Sedge cores than from the Sphagnum cores. The release of CH ₄ from Sedge cores increased with increasing temperature of the peat and decreased with decreasing temperature. Methane efflux from Sphagnum cores was quite stable independent of the peat temperatures.
3 In both Sedge and Sphagnum samples, CO₂ treatment doubled the potential CH₄ production but had no effect on the potential CH₄ oxidation. A raised concentration of CO₂ increased CH₄ efflux weakly and only at the highest peat temperatures (17–20 °C).
4 The results suggest that in cool regions, such as boreal wetlands, temperature would restrict decomposition of the extra substrates probably derived from enhanced primary production of mire vegetation under raised CO₂ concentrations, and would thus retard any consequent increase in CH₄ emission.     

Effect of dilution on methanogenesis, hydrogen turnover and interspecies hydrogen transfer in anoxic paddy soil

Abstract Dilution of anoxic slurries of paddy soil resulted in a proportional decrease of the rates of total methanogenesis and the rate constants of H₂ turnover per gram soil. Dilution did not affect the fraction of H₂/CO₂-dependent methanogenesis which made up 22% of total CH₄ production. However, dilution resulted in a ten fold decrease of the H₂ steady state partial pressure from approximately 4 to 0.4 Pa indicating that H₂/CO₂-dependent methanogenesis was more or less independent of the H₂ pool. The rates of H₂ production calculated from the H₂ turnover rate constants and the H₂ steady state partial pressures accounted for only < 5% of H₂/CO₂-dependent methanogenesis in undiluted soil slurries and for even less after dilution. Upon dilution, the Gibbs free energy available for H₂/CO₂-dependent methanogenesis decreased from −28.4 to only −5.6 kJ per mol. The results indicate that methane was mainly produced from interspecies H₂ transfer within syntrophic bacterial associations and was not significantly affected by the outside H₂ pool.     

Enumeration of H2-utilizing methanogenic archaea, acetogenic and sulfate-reducing bacteria from human feces

Abstract: Fecal specimens from 19 healthy humans were used to enumerate H₂-utilizing microbial populations of methanogenic archaea (MA), acetogenic bacteria (AB) and sulfate-reducing bacteria (SRB). Eight subjects were methane (CH₄) excretors (CH₄+) and 11 non CH₄-excretors (CH₄−), based on breath methane concentrations. The mean ± S.E. of the logarithm of MA per gram wet weight feces were 8.8 ± 0.21 and 2.6 ± 0.39 for CH₄+ and CH₄−, respectively ( P < 0.001). SRB counts were 7.1 ± 0.43 and 7.3 ± 0.39, respectively (NS), while counts of AB were 4.6 ± 0.75 and 6.6 ± 0.38, respectively ( P < 0.02). Counts of AB were negatively correlated with counts of MA (r = −0.53; P < 0.05). These results confirm the potential importance of AB in the human colon, especially for CH₄— subjects, and suggest that a much greater competitive interrelation occurs in the human colon between MA and AB than between the former and SRB. We further report on the isolation of representatives of the dominant     acetogenic population. Three strains from two CH₄— subjects were characterized from 10⁻⁵-10⁻⁷ dilutions. They all consumed     and several carbohydrates to produce acetate as the sole metabolite. Phenotypically related to the species Peptostreptococcus productus , the strains used     via the acetyl-CoA pathway.     

Temporal change of gas metabolism by hydrogen-syntrophic methanogenic bacterial associations in anoxic paddy soil

Abstract Interspecies H₂ transfer within methanogenic bacterial associations (MBA) accounted for 95–97% of the conversion of ¹⁴CO₂ to ¹⁴CH₄ in anoxic paddy soil. Only 3–5% of the ¹⁴CH₄ were produced from the turnover of dissolved H₂. The H₂-syntrophic MBA developed within 5 days after the paddy soil had been submerged and placed under anoxic atmosphere. Afterwards, both the contribution of MBA to H₂-dependent methanogenesis and the turnover of dissolved H₂ did not change significantly for up to 7 months of incubation. However, while the rates of H₂-dependent methanogenesis stayed relatively constant, the rates of total methanogenesis decreased. The contribution of MBA to H₂-dependent methanogenesis was further enhanced to 99% when the temperature was shifted from 30°C to 17°C, or when the soil had been planted with rice. This enhancement was partially due to an increased utilization of dissolved H₂ by chloroform-insensitive non-methanogenic bacteria, most probably homoacetogens, so that CH₄ production was almost completely restricted to H₂-syntrophic MBA. The activity of MBA, as measured by the conversion of ¹⁴CO₂ to ¹⁴CH₄, was stimulated by glucose, lactate, and ethanol to a similar or greater extent than by exogenous H₂. Propionate and acetate had no effect.     

Combined monitoring of changes in δ13CH4 and archaeal community structure during mesophilic methanization of municipal solid waste

Reconstituted municipal solid waste (MSW) with varying contents of putrescible and cellulosic waste was incubated anaerobically under mesophilic conditions. Standard physicochemical parameters were monitored, together with stable isotopic signatures of produced CH₄ and CO₂. δ¹³C values for CH₄ indicated a change of methanogenic metabolism with time. CH₄ was predominantly produced from H₂/CO₂ at the beginning of the incubations. This period was associated with important shifts in archaeal communities monitored by automated ribosomal intergenic spacer analysis (ARISA) and FISH of oligonucleotidic probes targeting specifically 16S rRNA gene of various methanogenic groups. The onset of the active methane generation phase was characterized by an increase of CH₄δ¹³C, indicating a progressive shift toward an aceticlastic metabolism. When the methane production levelled off, a decrease in the isotopic signature was observed toward values characteristics of hydrogenotrophic metabolism. ARISA profiles were, however, found to be stable from the beginning of the active methane generation phase until the end of the experiment. FISH observation indicated that members of the family Methanosarcinaceae were predominant in the archaeal community during this period, suggesting that these methanogens might exhibit a high metabolic versatility during methanization of waste.     

Metabolism of position-labelled glucose in anoxic methanogenic paddy soil and lake sediment

Abstract Turnover times of radioactive glucose were shorter in paddy soil (4–16 min) than in Lake Constance sediment (18–62 min). In the paddy soil, 65–75% of the radioactive glucose was converted to soluble metabolites. In the sediment, only about 25% of the radioactive glucose was converted to soluble metabolites, the rest to particulate material. In anoxic paddy soil, the degradation pattern of position-labelled glucose was largely consistent with glucose degradation via the Embden-Meyerhof-Parnas (EMP) pathway followed by methanogenic acetate cleavage: CO₂ mainly originated from C-3,4, whereas CH₄ mainly originated from C-1 and C-6 of glucose. Acetate-carbon originated from C-1, C-2 and C-6 rather than from C-3,4 of glucose. In both paddy soil and Lake Constance sediment acetate and CO₂ were the most important early metabolites of radioactive glucose. Other early products included propionate, ethanol/butyrate, succinate, and lactate, but accounted each for less than 1–8% of the glucose utilized. The labelling of propionate by [3,4-¹⁴C]glucose suggests that it was mainly produced from glucose or lactate rather than from ethanol. Isopropanol and caproate were also detectable in paddy soil, but were not produced from radioactive glucose. Chloroform inhibited methanogenesis, inhibited the further degradation of radioactive acetate and resulted in the accumulation of H₂, however, did not inhibit glucose degradation. Since acetate was the main soluble fermentation product of glucose and was produced at a relatively high molar acetate: CO₂ ratio (2.5:1), homoacetogenesis appeared to be the most important glucose fermentation pathway.     

Production, oxidation and emission of methane in rice paddies

Abstract Production and emission of methane from submerged paddy soil was studied in laboratory rice cultures and in Italian paddy fields. Up to 80% of the CH₄ produced in the paddy soil did not reach the atmosphere but was apparently oxidized in the rhizosphere. CH₄ emission through the rice plants was inhibited by an atmosphere of pure O₂ but was stimulated by an atmosphere of pure N₂ or an atmosphere containing 5% acetylene. Gas bubbles taken from the submerged soil contained up to 60% CH₄, but only < 1% CH₄ after the bubbles had passed the soil-water interface or had entered the intercellular gas space system of the rice plants. CH₄ oxidation activities were detected in the oxic surface layer of the submerged paddy soil. Flooding the paddy soil with water containing > 0.15% sea salt (0.01% sulfate) resulted in a strong inhibition of the rates of methanogenesis and a decrease in the rates of CH₄ emission. This result explains the observation of relatively low CH₄ emission rates in rice paddy areas flooded with brackish water.     

SULPHIDE PRODUCTION FROM SULPHATE-ENRICHED SEWAGE SLUDGES

SUMMARY: Sterilized raw sewage sludge enriched with sulphate and inoculated with pure strains of Desulphovibrio desulphuricans produced negligible sulphide. Unsterilized sludge supplemented with 7% (w/v) CaSO₄.2H₂O and inoculated with crude cultures of sulphate-reducing bacteria obtained from sewage yielded 1·0% S^2- (wt S^2- produced as H₂S/vol. of raw sludge) in 6 months at 30°. By repeated subculture more active cultures developed which produced 1% S^2- in 7 days and 1·2–1·9% in 28 days. Digested sludge yielded only 0·1% S^2-. In semicontinuous fermentations at 30°, raw sludge without added sulphate produced 20 times its own volume of gas containing 70% CH₄ and 30% CO₂. When 5% CaSO₄.2H₂O and an active crude culture of sulphate reducers were added, gas production decreased steadily to zero. There were no differences in pH, temperature and redox potential in sludges producing methane or sulphide. The chief cause of inhibition appeared to be the action of sulphide: 0·02% soluble sulphide (S^2-) totally inhibited methane formation; 0·01% S^2- initially decreased gas production by one-quarter but there was a slow recovery to normal, suggesting acclimatization of the methane-producing organisms to sulphide.
Linked fermentations, in which gas from a methane fermentation swept H₂S from a sulphide fermentation, gave a final gas mixture of about 60% CH₄, 30% CO₂ and 5–10% H₂S. The yield of sulphide depended on the rate of sweeping.     

Bacterial production measured by leucine and thymidine incorporation rates in French lakes

1. Production of heterotrophic bacterioplankton was estimated monthly by the tritiated thymidine and leucine incorporation methods during the draining and filling of the mesotrophic Lake Pareloup (over a 2.5-years sampling program).
2. Rates of ³H-leucine (leu) and ³H-thymidine (thy _DNA) incorporation generally paralleled each other but the ratio of leu/thy _DNA incorporation rates was higher for the draining period (34.5 mean) than during and after filling (11.5 mean).
3. After draining, the highest ratios were observed during periods of low temperature and low bacterial specific activity, while DNA labeling by ³H-thymidine was reduced. However, bacterial production estimates obtained by ³H-leucine (BPL) and ³H-thymidine (BPT) incorporation methods were generally well correlated and the average BPL/BPT ratio was equal to 0.78.
4. In addition, both methods were applied during a diel cycle in three lakes of different trophic status. An increase of leu/thy _DNA incorporation rates was noted from the oligotrophic to the eutrophic system. In the absence of Cyanobacteria, BPL and BPT values were quite concordant on average.
5. In situations of unbalanced growth, BPL and BPT values can diverge but when considered over a sufficient period of time they were found to be in agreement.     

Bicarbonate-dependent production and methanogenic consumption of acetate in anoxic paddy soil

Abstract Acetate turnover was measured in slurries of anoxic methanogenic paddy soil after addition of carrier-free [2-¹⁴C]-acetate. Acetate concentrations stayed fairly constant for about 1–2 days indicating steady state between production and consumption reactions. Depending on the experiment, acetate concentrations were between 100 and 3000 μM. Turnover rates were determined from the logarithmic decrease of [2-¹⁴C]-acetate or from the accumulation of acetate in the presence of chloroform resulting in similar values, i.e. 12–13 nmol h⁻¹g⁻¹d.w. soil at 17°C and 36–88 nmol h⁻¹g⁻¹d.w. at 30°C. Acetate consumption was completely inhibited by chloroform. The respiratory index (RI) was < 0.27. Hence, acetate was apparently consumed by methanogenic bacteria. About 80–90% of the CH₄ produced originated from the methyl group of acetate. The role of homoacetogenesis for acetate production was studied by measuring the incorporation of radioactive bicarbonate into acetate. In different experiments, CO₂ incorporation accounted for fractions of 1–60% of the acetate produced, about 10% being the most likely value for steady-state conditions. The fraction increased at high H₂ concentrations and decreased at high acetate concentrations. The rate of H₂ production that was required for chemolithotrophic acetate production from CO₂ was two orders of magnitude higher than the actually measured rate. Hence, most of the CO₂ incorporation into acetate was caused by electron donors other than H₂ (e.g., carbohydrates) and/or by exchange reactions.     

The role of ultraviolet radiation, photosensitizers, reactive oxygen species and ester groups in mechanisms of methane formation from pectin

Ultraviolet (UV) radiation has recently been demonstrated to drive an aerobic production of methane (CH₄) from plant tissues and pectins, as do agents that generate reactive oxygen species (ROS) in vivo independently of UV. As the major building-blocks of pectin do not absorb solar UV found at the earth's surface (i.e. >280 nm), we explored the hypothesis that UV radiation affects pectin indirectly via generation of ROS which themselves release CH₄ from pectin. Decreasing the UV absorbance of commercial pectin by ethanol washing diminished UV-dependent CH₄ production, and this was restored by the addition of the UV photosensitizer tryptophan. Certain ROS scavengers [mannitol, a hydroxyl radical (^•OH) scavenger; 1,4-diazabicyclo[2.2.2] octane; and iodide] strongly inhibited UV-induced CH₄ production from dry pectin. Furthermore, pectin solutions emitted CH₄ in darkness upon the addition of ^•OH, but not superoxide or H₂O₂. Model carbohydrates reacted similarly if they possessed —CH₃ groups [e.g. methyl esters or (more weakly) acetyl esters but not rhamnose]. We conclude that UV evokes CH₄ production from pectic methyl groups by interacting with UV photosensitizers to generate ^•OH. We suggest that diverse processes generating ^•OH could contribute to CH₄ emissions independently of UV irradiation, and that environmental stresses and constitutive physiological processes generating ROS require careful evaluation in studies of CH₄ formation from foliage.     

Phosphate Induces Rapid H2O2 Generation in Soybean Suspension Cells

Abstract: Involvement of reactive oxygen species has been implicated in plant defence against pathogens. We report here a novel pathway of H₂O₂ generation induced by the addition of phosphate in soybean ( Glycine max L.) cell suspension cultures. This H₂O₂ generation was initiated shortly after the addition of phosphate, and lasted only approximately one hour, as opposed to several hours observed during an attack by an avirulent strain of the bacterial pathogen Pseudomonas syringae pv. glycinea (Psg). In addition, when cell cultures were treated with both phosphate and the avirulent pathogen, two distinct oxidative burst events were observed. In contrast to DPI-sensitive Psg -induced H₂O₂ generation, phosphate-induced H₂O₂ generation was insensitive to this NADPH oxidase inhibitor. This suggests that an NADPH oxidase-independent pathway may be involved in the phosphate-induced H₂O₂ accumulation, which could be involved in sensing of phosphate availability in the environment.     

Links between methanotroph community composition and CH4 oxidation in a pine forest soil

The main gap in our knowledge about what determines the rate of CH₄ oxidation in forest soils is the biology of the microorganisms involved, the identity of which remains unclear. In this study, we used stable-isotope probing (SIP) following ¹³CH₄ incorporation into phospholipid fatty acids (PLFAs) and DNA/RNA, and sequencing of methane mono-oxygenase ( pmoA ) genes, to identify the influence of variation in community composition on CH₄ oxidation rates. The rates of ¹³C incorporation into PLFAs differed between horizons, with low ¹³C incorporation in the organic soil and relatively high ¹³C incorporation into the two mineral horizons. The microbial community composition of the methanotrophs incorporating the ¹³C label also differed between horizons, and statistical analyses suggested that the methanotroph community composition was a major cause of variation in CH₄ oxidation rates. Both PLFA and pmoA -based data indicated that CH₄ oxidizers in this soil belong to the uncultivated 'upland soil cluster α'. CH₄ oxidation potential exhibited the opposite pattern to ¹³C incorporation, suggesting that CH₄ oxidation potential assays may correlate poorly with in situ oxidation rates. The DNA/RNA-SIP assay was not successful, most likely due to insufficient ¹³C-incorporation into DNA/RNA. The limitations of the technique are briefly discussed.     

Protonmotive force-driven synthesis of ATP during methane formation from molecular hydrogen and formaldehyde or carbon dioxide in Methanosarcina barkeri

Abstract Methane formation from formaldehyde and H₂ or from carbon dioxide and H₂, as performed by cell suspensions of Methanosarcina barkeri , was coupled to ATP synthesis. In correspondence with this, methane formation was inhibited by N , N '-dicyclohexylcarbodiimide (DCCD), which at the same time, caused a decrease of the intracellular ATP concentration but only a slow decrease of the membrane potential. Addition of the uncoupler tetrachlorosalicylanilide (TCS) led to a relief of the inhibition of methane formation from CH₂O + H₂, but not from CO₂+ H₂.