Auxin and Ethylene Regulation of Petiole Epinasty in Two Developmental Mutants of Tomato, diageotropica and Epinastic

The epinastic growth responses of petioles to auxin and ethylene were quantified in two developmental mutants of tomato (Lycopersicon esculentum Mill.). In the wild type parent line, cultivar VFN8, the epinastic response of excised petiole sections was approximately log-linear between 0.1 and 100 micromolar indole-3-acetic acid (IAA) and 2,4-dichlorophenoxyacetic acid (2,4-D) concentrations, with a greater response to 2,4-D at any concentration. When ethylene synthesis was inhibited by aminoethoxyvinylglycine (AVG), epinasty was no longer induced by auxin, but could be restored by the addition of ethylene gas. In the auxin-insensitive mutant, diageotropica (dgt), no epinastic response to IAA was observed at IAA concentrations that effectively induced epinasty in VFN8. In the absence of added IAA, epinastic growth of dgt petioles in 1.3 microliters per liter exogenous ethylene gas was more than double that of VFN8 petioles. IAA had little additional effect in dgt, but promoted epinasty in VFN8. These results confirm that tomato petiole cells respond directly to ethylene and make it unlikely that the differential growth responsible for epinasty results from lateral auxin redistribution. The second mutant, Epinastic (Epi), exhibits constitutively epinasty, cortical swelling, and root branching symptomatic of possible alternation in auxin or ethylene regulation of growth. Only minor quantitative differences were observed between the epinastic responses to auxin and ethylene of VFN8 and Epi. However, in contrast to VFN8, when ethylene synthesis or action was inhibited in Epi, auxin still induced 40 to 50% of the epinastic response observed in the absence of inhibitors. This indicates that the target cells for epinastic growth in Epi are qualitatively different from those of VFN8, having gained the ability to grow differentially in response to auxin alone. The dgt and Epi mutants provide useful systems in which to study the genetic determination of target cell specificity for hormone action.     

Ineffectiveness of ethylene biosynthetic and action inhibitors in phenotypically reverting theEpinastic mutant of Tomato (Lycopersicon esculentum mill.)

Five-day-old, dark-grown seedlings of theEpinastic (Epi) tomato mutant (Lycopersicon esculentum Mill.) and its parent, cultivar VFN8, were used as a system for assessing the role of ethylene in theEpi phenotype. The distinguishing features ofEpi seedlings are an increase in hypocotyl diameter and reduced hypocotyl length. Treatment of VFN8 seedlings with 0.5 l/liter ethylene closely mimicked theEpi phenotype. The rate of ethylene production by 5-day-old, dark-grownEpi seedlings was double that of VFN8 seedlings. Nevertheless, treatment ofEpi seedlings with inhibitors of ethylene biosynthesis (aminoethoxyvinylglycine or Co²⁺) or ethylene action (silver thiosulfate or norbornadiene) failed to normalize theEpi phenotype.Epi seedlings grown in sealed jars containing ethylene and CO₂ adsorbants also expressed the characteristicEpi phenotype. The results indicate that the physiological lesion resulting from theEpi gene mutation is not simply an overproduction of ethylene.     

Quantification of Indole-3-Acetic Acid in Dark-Grown Seedlings of the Diageotropica and Epinastic Mutants of Tomato (Lycopersicon esculentum Mill.)

Endogenous indoleacetic acid (IAA) levels were examined in 7-day-old, dark-grown tomato seedlings (Lycopersicon esculentum Mill. cv VFN8), and in two single-gene mutants, Epinastic and diageotropica. Gas chromatography-mass spectrometry was employed to quantify IAA using ¹³C₆-[benzene ring]indoleacetic acid as internal standard. IAA concentrations ranged from 89 to 134 nanograms per gram dry weight and were not significantly different for the three genotypes. Ethylene over-production by dark-grown Epi seedlings is not likely to result from increased IAA. Assuming similar recovery percentages for each genotype, indole-3-ethanol, a purported storage form of IAA, was identified by GC-MS and found to be more prevalent in the parent tomato, VFN8, with only trace amounts observed in Epi. No IEt was detected by high performance liquid chromatography/fluorescence in dgt (detection limit >100 picograms).     

Insensitivity of the diageotropica tomato mutant to auxin

The sensitivity of excised hypocotyl segments to indoleacetic acid (IAA) in two assays, ethylene production and elongation, was determined in the ethylene-requiring tomato (Lycopersicon esculentum Mill.) mutant, diageotropica (dgt), and its isogenic parent, cv VFN8. Endogenous (uninduced) ethylene synthesis rates were slightly lower in dgt hypocotyls than in VFN8 hypocotyls. Ethylene production was essentially unaffected by IAA in dgt, but was stimulated up to 10-fold by 10 micromolar IAA in VFN8. Elongation of dgt hypocotyls was also insensitive to concentrations of IAA as high as 100 micromolar, as compared to significant elongation of VFN8 hypocotyls in response to 0.1 micromolar IAA. A range of IAA analogs active in VFN8 was also ineffective in stimulating elongation of dgt hypocotyls, suggesting that the differences were not due to rapid metabolism of IAA by dgt tissues. Auxin-induced elongation of VFN8 hypocotyls was unaffected by 2,3,5-triiodobenzoic acid and naphthylphthalamic acid, indicating that polar auxin transport was not a factor in these experiments. Exogenous and auxin-induced ethylene had no effect on the elongation respone of either genotype, nor did exogenous ethylene restore the sensitivity of dgt hypocotyls to IAA. Despite their apparent insensitivity to auxin, dgt hypocotyls elongated dramatically and synthesized ethylene rapidly in response to 1.2 micromolar fusicoccin. These results suggest that the primary effect of the dgt mutation is to reduce the sensitivity of the tissue to auxin. As altered regulation of ethylene synthesis is only one symptom of this fundamental deficiency, dgt should more properly be considered to be the auxin-insensitive tomato mutant.     

Pathogenesis-related proteins and polyamines in a developmental mutant of tomato, epinastic

The polyamine level and the accumulation of pathogenesis-related (PR) proteins were studied in the ethylene overproducing Epinastic (Epi) tomato (Lycopersicon esculentum Mill.) mutant, as compared with its parent, cv VFN8. Neither a decreased putrescine level nor an enhanced production of PR proteins were detected in Epi, contrary to what could be expected from our previous studies (JM Bellés, J Carbonell, V Conejero [1991] Plant Physiol 96: 1053-1059). However, treatment with the ethylene-releasing compound 2-chloroethylphosphonic acid (ethephon) or silver nitrate at high doses induced a decrease in putrescine content and an enhancing of the synthesis of PR proteins in Epi as ascertained by immunoblot analysis using antisera raised against Rutgers tomato PR proteins.     

Stress-induced Ethylene Production in the Ethylene-requiring Tomato Mutant Diageotropica

Ethylene synthesis in vegetative tissues is thought to be controlled by indoleacetic acid (IAA). However, ethylene synthesis in the diageotropica (dgt) mutant of tomato (Lycopersicon esculentum Mill.) was much less sensitive to IAA than in the normal variety (VFN8). Yet, mechanical wounding stimulated ethylene production by the mutant. The dgt tomato provides an opportunity to study the regulation of stress ethylene independent of IAA effects. Waterlogging (i.e. anaerobic stress) stimulated production of the ethylene precursor, 1-aminocyclopropane-1-carboxylic acid (ACC), in the roots. The ACC was transported to the shoot where it was converted to ethylene. The dgt mutant efficiently utilized ACC for ethylene synthesis under aerobic conditions. The results confirm that the genetic lesion in dgt is located at a step prior to the formation of ACC. Furthermore, induction of ethylene synthesis by anaerobic or mechanical stresses in this mutant is independent of IAA action.     

The role of ethylene in 2.4-D-induced growth inhibition

Summary Ethylene and 2.4-dichlorophenoxyacetic acid (2.4-D) inhibited the growth of etiolated soybean (Glycine max cv. Hawkeye) seedlings causing tissue swelling and an increase in RNA, DNA and protein content in the subapical hypocotyl tissue. 2.4-D increased ethylene evolution from soybean seedlings and it was found that some of the effect of this herbicide on soybeans was due to the increased ethylene production.Ethylene is responsible in part for the inhibition of elongation and of increase in weight that occurs at supraoptimal concentrations of 2.4-D applied to excised hypocotyl sections. Abscisic acid inhibits 2.4-D-induced tissue swelling and ethylene production in the excised, elongating section. The cotyledons of the soybean seedlings appear to regulate the 2.4-D-induced production of ethylene and the roots are necessary for the 2.4-D-induced tissue swelling.     

Evidence that Ethylene is not Involved in Red-light-induced Stimulation of Chlorophyll Formation in Etiolated Cucumber Cotyledons

The involvement of ethylene in red-light-induced stimulationof chlorophyll (Chl) formation was studied because one of thered-light effects on Chl formation (the lateappearing effect)interacts with the ethylene effect in 3-day-old excised etiolatedcotyledons of cucumber (Cucumis sativus L. cv. Aonagajibai).Ethylene production by etiolated cotyledons of intact seedlingsin the dark is enhanced by a red-light pulse, but the effectdoes not occur in excised cotyledons. Application of ethylenein the dark to 3-day-old intact seedlings has little effecton Chl formation in the cotyledon during subsequent continuousillumination, although ethylene pretreatment of 5-day-old seedlingssignificantly stimulates Chl formation. Removal of endogenousethylene by mercuric perchlorate [Hg(ClO₄)₂] does not specificallysuppress the red-light action on Chl formation in both attachedand excised cotyledons. Inhibition of ethylene synthesis byaminoethoxyvinylglycine does not affect the red-light effecton Chl formation in excised cotyledons. These facts indicatethat ethylene does not operate as a mediator of red light instimulating Chi formation in either attached or excised cotyledons. (Received December 13, 1981; Accepted March 30, 1981)     

Modulation of ethylene synthesis in acotyledonous soybean and wheat seedlings

The characteristics of ethylene production and ACC conversion in 8-day-old soybean seedlings were examined and a relationship between cytochrome P-450 activity and ethylene-forming enzyme (EFE) activity was found. An atmosphere containing 10% carbon monoxide (CO) significantly inhibited ethylene production and ACC conversion in control soybean seedlings, but had only a slight effect on soybean seedlings treated with uniconazole. Foliar application of triclopyr, a pyridine analogue of the phenoxy herbicides, significantly increased ethylene production and ACC conversion in control, but not in uniconazoletreated seedlings. Triclopyr treatment also resulted in a three-fold increase in extractable cytochrome P-450 of 5-day-old etiolated soybeans. At equimolar concentrations tetcyclacis was more effective than uniconazole in reducing shoot elongation and endogenous ethylene production. Although uniconazole and tetcyclacis did not inhibit ACC conversion in nonherbicide-treated soybean seedlings, they did prevent the observed increase in ACC-dependent EFE activity following triclopyr application. However, the rate of ACC conversion in etiolated soybean segments was sensitive to uniconazole, and tetcyclacis inhibited the rate of ACC conversion by 2.6-fold in etiolated soybean segments within 4 h after treatment. Microsomal membranes were isolated from 5-day-old naphthalic anhydride-treated etiolated wheat shoots as this tissue contains much higher cytochrome P-450 levels than soybean shoots. Optical difference spectroscopy demonstrated that ACC generated binding spectrum characteristic of a reverse-type-I cytochrome P-450 substrate when combined with reduced microsomes. In vitro conversion of ACC to ethylene by microsomal membranes was NADPH-dependent, inhibited by CO, and had an apparent K_m and V_max of 45 M and 0.345 nl/mg protein/h, respectively. These results suggest that cytochrome P-450-mediated monooxygenase reactions may be intimately involved in the conversion of ACC to ethylene in young soybean and wheat seedlings.     

Some Physiological Characteristics of the Ethylene-requiring Tomato Mutant Diageotropica

The diageotropica mutant of tomato (Lycopersicon esculentum Mill.) is shown to require exogenous ethylene for normal growth and development. This single gene mutant is characterized by unsupported horizontal growth of shoots and roots, dark green hyponastic leaf segments, thin rigid stems, and primary and adventitious roots which lack lateral roots. Experiments with growth regulators indicate that the mutant does not produce normal amounts of ethylene in response to auxin treatment. Tests with ethylene-producing compounds or ethylene precursors demonstrate that the mutant requires ethylene for normality. Ethylene concentrations as low as 0.005 microliters per liter are capable of completely normalizing mutant characteristics. This mutant with its isogenic parent variety, cv. VFN8, should be a suitable tool for investigating auxin-stimulated ethylene production and their interrelationship in the control of plant morphology and physiology.     

On ethylene and stem elongation in green pea seedlings

Maximum elongation of excised internodal stem sections of light-grown pea (Pisum sativum L.) seedlings occurred at 10⁻⁵ molar indoleacetic acid (IAA), with submaximal responses occurring at 10⁻⁴ and 10⁻³ molar. Accompanying elongation at concentrations of IAA of 10⁻⁶ to 10⁻³ molar was production of ethylene, with the amount increasing up to 10⁻⁴ molar IAA and then becoming nearly constant. Elongation of light-grown sections was not inhibited by exogenous ethylene up to 10,000 ppm in the presence of 10⁻⁵ molar IAA. Marked (up to 50%) inhibition of elongation of internodal segments in situ was observed after treating whole light-grown seedlings with exogenous ethylene for 20 hours. It is concluded that ethylene is not responsible for the submaximal elongation responses of green pea stem sections at high auxin concentrations, but that IAA per se is accountable.     

Endogenous ethylene production is a potential problem in the measurement of nitrogenase activity associated with excised corn and sorghum roots

Endogenous ethylene production was evaluated as a source of ethylene during acetylene reduction assays with freshly collected roots of field-grown corn, Zea mays L. cv Funks G-4646, and sorghum, Sorghum bicolor (L.) Moench. cv CK-60A. Ethylene production was not detected when roots were incubated in air without acetylene. The presence of endogenous ethylene production was confirmed when roots were incubated anaerobically and in the presence of 40 millimolar sodium hydrosulfite. Ethylene oxidase activity was also associated with excised roots. The rate of ethylene oxidation was higher than the rates of ethylene accumulation during either acetylene reduction assays or anaerobic incubations. These results indicate that the procedure of incubating roots of grasses in air to monitor endogenous ethylene production is not a valid control in acetylene reduction studies with grasses. The presence of endogenous ethylene production during acetylene reduction assays was demonstrated by using either CO to inhibit nitrogenase activity or chloramphenicol to inhibit nitrogenase synthesis in freshly excised roots.     

Rapidly Induced Wound Ethylene from Excised Segments of Etiolated Pisum sativum L., cv. Alaska: I. Characterization of the Response

A rapidly induced, transitory increase in the rate of ethylene synthesis occurred in wounded tissue excised from actively growing regions of etiolated barley, cucumber, maize, oat, pea, tomato, and wheat seedlings. Cutting intact stems or excising 9-mm segments of tissue from near the apex of 7-day-old etiolated Pisum sativum L., cv. Alaska seedlings induced a remarkably consistent pattern of ethylene production. At 25 C, wound-induced ethylene production by segments excised 9 mm below the apical hook increased linearly after a lag of 26 minutes from 2.7 nanoliters per g per hour to the first maxium of 11.3 nanoliters per g per hour at 56 minutes. The rate of production then decreased to a minimum at 90 minutes, increased to a lower second maximum at 131 minutes, and subsequently declined over a period of about 100 minutes to about 4 nanoliters per g per hour. Removal of endogenous ethylene, before the wound response commenced, had no effect on the kinetics of ethylene production. Tissue containing large amounts of dissolved ethylene released it as an exponential decay with no lag period. Rapidly induced wound ethylene is synthesized by the tissue and is not merely the result of facilitated diffusion of ethylene already present in the tissue through the newly exposed cut surfaces. Previously wounded apical sections did not exhibit a second response when rewounded. No significant correlation was found between wound-induced ethylene synthesis and either CO₂ or ethane production.     

Effect of chlorsulfuron on ethylene evolution from sunflower seedlings

The effect of the herbicide chlorsulfuron (2-chloro-N-[(4-methoxy - 6 - methyl -1, 3,5 - triazin - 2 - yl)aminocarbonyl]benzenesulfonamide) on ethylene production in light-grown sunflower (Helianthus annuus L.) seedlings was examined. Application of chlorsulfuron to the apex stimulated ethylene production in all tissues examined: cotyledons, hypocotyls, and roots. The greatest stimulation occurred in the upper portion of the hypocotyl adjacent to, and including, the cotyledonary node. Ethylene evolution from hypocotyls excised from treated seedlings was stimulated over control levels 1 day after herbicide application and reached a maximum (approx. 75 x control or 17 nl/g f wt/h) 2 to 3 days after treatment. Labeling and inhibitor studies indicated that the ethylene produced was derived primarily from methionine. Chlorsulfuron treatment stimulated the rate of accumulation of the ethylene precursor, 1-aminocyclopropane-1-carboxylic acid (ACC), as well as the ability of the tissue to convert exogenous ACC to ethylene. Chlorsulfuron had little effect on ethylene production when administered to the hypocotylsin vitro. Removal of the cotyledons from treated seedlings reduced the rate of ethylene evolution from the hypocotyls. These results suggest that stimulation of ethylene production in sunflower hypocotyls by chlorsulfuron is not a wound response but rather is dependent on factors derived from the cotyledons.     

Effects of Kinetin, IAA, and Gibberellin on Ethylene Production, and Their Interactions in Growth of Seedlings

Kinetin in concentrations of 10⁻⁸ to 10⁻⁴ m, stimulated ethylene production in 3 and 4-day old etiolated seedlings of Alaska pea (Pisum sativum L. var. Alaska). Seedlings of other species responded similarly. The response to kinetin depended on the age of the seedlings.     

Xylem Transport of 1-Aminocyclopropane-1-carboxylic Acid, an Ethylene Precursor, in Waterlogged Tomato Plants

Waterlogging is known to cause an increase in ethylene synthesis in the shoot which results in petiole epinasty. Evidence has suggested that a signal is synthesized in the anaerobic roots and transported to the shoot where it stimulates ethylene synthesis. Experimental data are presented showing that 1-aminocyclopropane-1-carboxylic acid (ACC), the immediate precursor of ethylene, serves as the signal. Xylem sap was collected from detopped tomato plants (Lycopersicon esculentum Mill. cv. VFN8). ACC in the sap was quantitated by a sensitive and specific assay, and its tentative chemical identity verified by paper chromatography. ACC levels in both roots and xylem sap increased markedly in response to waterlogging or root anaerobiosis. The appearance of ACC in the xylem sap of flooded plants preceded both the increase in ethylene production and epinastic growth, which were closely correlated. Plants flooded and then drained showed a rapid, simultaneous drop in ACC flux and ethylene synthesis rate. ACC supplied through the cut stem of tomato shoots at concentrations comparable to those found in xylem sap caused epinasty and increased ethylene production. These data indicate that ACC is synthesized in the anaerobic root and transported to the shoot where it is readily converted to ethylene.     

Auxin Physiology of the Tomato Mutant diageotropica

The tomato (Lycopersicon esculentum, Mill.) mutant diageotropica (dgt) exhibits biochemical, physiological, and morphological abnormalities that suggest the mutation may have affected a primary site of auxin perception or action. We have compared two aspects of the auxin physiology of dgt and wild-type (VFN8) seedlings: auxin transport and cellular growth parameters. The rates of basipetal indole-3-acetic acid (IAA) polar transport are identical in hypocotyl sections of the two genotypes, but dgt sections have a slightly greater capacity for IAA transport. 2,3,5-Triiodobenzoic acid and ethylene reduce transport in both mutant and wild-type sections. The kinetics of auxin uptake into VFN8 and dgt sections are nearly identical. These results make it unlikely that an altered IAA efflux carrier or IAA uptake symport are responsible for the pleiotropic effects resulting from the dgt mutation. The lack of auxin-induced cell elongation in dgt plants is not due to insufficient turgor, as the osmotic potential of dgt cell sap is less (more negative) than that of VFN8. An auxin-induced increase in wall extensibility, as measured by the Instron technique, only occurs in the VFN8 plants. These data suggest dgt hypocotyls suffer a defect in the sequence of events culminating in auxin-induced cell wall loosening.     

Ethylene and Ethane Production from Sulfur Dioxide-injured Plants

After alfalfa (Medicago sativa) seedlings were exposed to approximately 0.7 microliter per liter SO₂ for 8 hours, elevated ethylene and ethane production was observed. Ethylene production peaked about 6 hours and returned to control levels by about 24 hours following the fumigation, while ethane production peaked about 36 hours and was still above control levels 48 hours after the fumigation. Light had an opposite effect upon the production of the two gases: ethane production rates were higher from plants held in light, whereas ethylene production rates were higher from those held in the dark. Peak ethylene and ethane production rates from SO₂-treated plants were about 10 and 4 to 5 times greater, respectively, than those of the control plants. Ethylene appeared to be formed primarily from stressed yet viable leaves and ethane from visibly damaged leaves. The different time courses and light requirements for ethylene and ethane production suggest that these two gases were formed via different mechanisms. Light appears to have a dual role. It enhances SO₂-induced cellular damage and plays a role for repairs.     

Does Water Deficit Stress Promote Ethylene Synthesis by Intact Plants?

The effect of plant water deficit on ethylene production by intact plants was tested in three species, beans (Phaseolus vulgaris L.), cotton (Gossypium hirsutum L.) and miniature rose (Rosa hybrida L., cv Bluesette). Compressed air was passed through glass, plant-containing cuvettes, ethylene collected on chilled columns, and subsequently assayed by gas chromatography. The usual result was that low water potential did not promote ethylene production. When plants were subjected to cessation of irrigation, ethylene production decreased on a per plant or dry weight basis of calculation. No significant promotion of ethylene production above control levels was detected when water deficit-treated bean or cotton plants were rewatered. The one exception to this was for cotton subjected to a range of water deficits, plants subjected to deficits of −1.4 to −1.6 MPa exhibited a transient increase of ethylene production of 40 to 50% above control levels at 24 or 48 hours. Ethylene was collected from intact leaves while plants developed a water deficit stress of −2.9 megapascals after rewatering, and no significant promotion of ethylene production was detected. The shoots of fruited, flowering cotton plants produced less ethylene when subjected to cessation of irrigation. In contrast, the ability of bench drying of detached leaves to increase ethylene production several-fold was verified for both beans and cotton. The data indicate that detached leaves react differently to rapid drying than intact plants react to drying of the soil with regard to ethylene production. This result suggests the need for additional attention to ethylene as a complicating factor in experiments employing excised plant parts and the need to verify the relevance of shock stresses in model systems.     

An effect of light on the production of ethylene and the growth of the plumular portion of etiolated pea seedlings

The production of ethylene by etiolated pea epicotyls (Pisum sativum L., cv. Alaska) is confined to the plumule and plumular hook portion of the epicotyl, and occurs at a rate of about 6 μl·kg⁻¹·hr⁻¹. Such a rate is sufficient to give physiologically active concentrations of ethylene within the tissue. Exposure of etiolated seedlings to a single dose of red light caused a transient decrease in ethylene production and a corresponding increase in plumular expansion. Far-red irradiation following the red light treatment decreased the red effect to the level achieved by the far-red alone, suggesting that the ethylene production mechanism is controlled by phytochrome and thus that the ethylene intervenes as a regulator in the phytochrome control of plumular expansion.