A novel approach for sequential assignment of 1H, 13C, and 15N spectra of proteins: heteronuclear triple-resonance three-dimensional NMR spectroscopy. Application to calmodulin

A novel approach is described for obtaining sequential assignment of the backbone 1H, 13C, and 15N resonances of larger proteins. The approach is demonstrated for the protein calmodulin (16.7 kDa), uniformly (approximately 95%) labeled with 15N and 13C. Sequential assignment of the backbone residues by standard methods was not possible because of the very narrow chemical shift distribution range of both NH and C alpha H protons in this largely alpha-helical protein. We demonstrate that the combined use of four new types of heteronuclear 3D NMR spectra together with the previously described HOHAHA-HMQC 3D experiment [Marion, D., et al. (1989) Biochemistry 28, 6150-6156] can provide unambiguous sequential assignment of protein backbone resonances. Sequential connectivity is derived from one-bond J couplings and the procedure is therefore independent of the backbone conformation. All the new 3D NMR experiments use 1H detection and rely on multiple-step magnetization transfers via well-resolved one-bond J couplings, offering high sensitivity and requiring a total of only 9 days for the recording of all five 3D spectra. Because the combination of 3D spectra offers at least two and often three independent pathways for determining sequential connectivity, the new assignment procedure is easily automated. Complete assignments are reported for the proton, carbon, and nitrogen backbone resonances of calmodulin, complexed with calcium.     

Assignment of the backbone 1H and 15N NMR resonances of bacteriophage T4 lysozyme

The proton and nitrogen (15NH-H alpha-H beta) resonances of bacteriophage T4 lysozyme were assigned by 15N-aided 1H NMR. The assignments were directed from the backbone amide 1H-15N nuclei, with the heteronuclear single-multiple-quantum coherence (HSMQC) spectrum of uniformly 15N enriched protein serving as the master template for this work. The main-chain amide 1H-15N resonances and H alpha resonances were resolved and classified into 18 amino acid types by using HMQC and 15N-edited COSY measurements, respectively, of T4 lysozymes selectively enriched with one or more of alpha-15N-labeled Ala, Arg, Asn, Asp, Gly, Gln, Glu, Ile, Leu, Lys, Met, Phe, Ser, Thr, Trp, Tyr, or Val. The heteronuclear spectra were complemented by proton DQF-COSY and TOCSY spectra of unlabeled protein in H2O and D2O buffers, from which the H beta resonances of many residues were identified. The NOE cross peaks to almost every amide proton were resolved in 15N-edited NOESY spectra of the selectively 15N enriched protein samples. Residue specific assignments were determined by using NOE connectivities between protons in the 15NH-H alpha-H beta spin systems of known amino acid type. Additional assignments of the aromatic proton resonances were obtained from 1H NMR spectra of unlabeled and selectively deuterated protein samples. The secondary structure of T4 lysozyme indicated from a qualitative analysis of the NOESY data is consistent with the crystallographic model of the protein.     

Automated sequencing of amino acid spin systems in proteins using multidimensional HCC(CO)NH-TOCSY spectroscopy and constraint propagation methods from artificial intelligence

Summary We have developed an automated approach for determining the sequential order of amino acid spin systems in small proteins. A key step in this procedure is the analysis of multidimensional HCC(CO)NH-TOCSY spectra that provide connections from the aliphatic resonances of residue i to the amide resonances of residue i+1. These data, combined with information about the amino acid spin systems, provide sufficient constraints to assign most proton and nitrogen resonances of small proteins. Constraint propagation methods progressively narrow the set of possible assignments of amino acid spin systems to sequence-specific positions in the process of NMR data analysis. The constraint satisfaction paradigm provides a framework in which the necessary constraint-based reasoning can be expressed, while an object-oriented representation structures and facilitates the extensive list processing and indexing involved in matching. A prototype expert system, AUTOASSIGN, provides correct and nearly complete resonance assignments with one real and 31 simulated 3D NMR data sets for a 72-amino acid domain, derived from the Protein A of Staphylococcus aureus, and with 31 simulated NMR data sets for the 50-amino acid human type- transforming growth factor.     

Assignment of the natural abundance 13C spectrum of proteins using 13C 1H-detected heteronuclear multiple-bond correlation NMR spectroscopy: structural information and stereospecific assignments from two- and three-bond carbon-hydrogen coupling constants.

Proton-detected heteronuclear multiple-bond 1H-13C correlations (HMBC) previously have been used for assignment purposes in a variety of isotopically enriched proteins. In the present study it is demonstrated that the technique yields an almost complete assignment of the natural abundance 13C spectrum of the protein basic pancreatic trypsin inhibitor (BPTI). In addition, the technique permits additional 1H assignments to be made for this well-studied protein. The intensities of observed correlations permit rough estimates to be made of 2J(C,H) and 3J(C,H) coupling constants. These couplings can be used for conformational studies of both the side chains and the backbone. Intra- and interresidue coupling between C alpha H and the carbonyl carbon provides information about the backbone angles psi and phi. Side-chain conformations can be determined from both two- and three-bond carbon-hydrogen coupling constants. The present study of BPTI together with its known high-precision solution structure yields an experimental correlation between resonance intensities and secondary structure. The spectra show the potential of the method in analyzing 13C NMR spectra of nonenriched proteins. The method yields 13C NMR chemical shifts, which are versatile parameters to be used to monitor structural changes, titrations, etc.     

Biosynthesis and characterization of [15N]actinomycin D and conformational analysis by nitrogen-15 nuclear magnetic resonance

We describe the production and characterization of actinomycin D labeled with 15N at all twelve nitrogen positions. Cultures of Streptomyces parvulus were incubated in the presence of racemic [15N]glutamic acid and, following an initial delay, labeled antibiotic was produced. Evidence is presented that the D enantiomorph of glutamic acid was ultimately used for actinomycin biosynthesis. The 15N NMR spectrum at 10.14 and 20.47 MHz of the labeled drug in CDCl3 is presented. All nitrogens except the phenoxazone chromophore nitrogen are inverted when spectra are obtained under broad-band proton irradiation conditions. All 15N resonances have been assigned, and the proton-nitrogen one-bond coupling constants were determined in CDCl3 to be 92.5 +/- 0.3 Hz for the valine and threonine amide protons by both 1H and 15N NMR. 15N NMR spectra were also obtained in dimethyl sulfoxide, methanol, and water in order to probe solvent interactions with the peptide nitrogens and carbonyl groups. Large downfield shifts (greater than 5 ppm) were seen for the Pro, sarcosine, and methylvaline resonances when the solvent was changed from dimethyl sulfoxide to water. Smaller downfield shifts were observed for the Val and Thr peaks. These results are discussed in terms of a model for the solution conformation of the actinomycin pentapeptide rings based on different hydrogen-bonding interactions in the monomer in organic solvents and the dimer which is formed in water.     

Determination of the functionally important heme peripheral vinyl group orientation in paramagnetic hemoprotein by 2D NMR

2D NMR spectroscopies have been successfully used to characterize the heme peripheral vinyl groups in paramagnetic hemoprotein in spite of the difficulties from the rapid paramagnetic relaxation and the low digital resolution of the 2D NMR map. The scalar coupling network system among the vinyl protons is clearly identified in the COSY spectra from its characteristic cross-peak pattern and the dipolar coupling connectivities of the vinyl proton resonances with other heme side-chain proton resonances not only provide the specific assignment of vinyl beta-proton resonances but also allow the determination of the vinyl group orientation with respect to the heme plane.     

Two-dimensional 1H, 15N-NMR investigation of uniformly 15N-labeled ribonuclease T1. Complete assignment of 15N resonances

Uniformly 15N-enriched ribonuclease T1 (RNase T1) was obtained from Escherichia coli by recombinant techniques. Heteronuclear 1H, 15N-shift correlation spectra were recorded utilizing proton detection. Direct 1H, 15N connectivities were established applying the heteronuclear multiple-quantum coherence technique. Additional 1H, 1H-TOCSY or 1H, 1H-NOESY transfer steps allowed for sequential assignments. Nitrogen atoms without directly bonded protons were detected by means of the heteronuclear multiple-bond correlation experiment. Signals emerging from 15NH and 15NH2 groups were distinguished by heteronuclear triple-quantum filtering methods. 119 nitrogen resonances out of the expected 127 were assigned unambiguously; in addition, previously obtained proton assignments were extended. Preliminary 1H, 15N NMR investigation were performed on the RNase-T1-3'GMP inhibitor complex. Results were interpreted with respect to nucleotide binding.     

Toward the complete assignment of the carbon nuclear magnetic resonance spectrum of the basic pancreatic trypsin inhibitor

A total of 54 of the 58 alpha-carbon resonances and numerous side-chain carbon signals were individually assigned in the basic pancreatic trypsin inhibitor by using two-dimensional heteronuclear correlated and relayed coherence transfer spectroscopy with proton detection. No isotope enrichment was used, and the spectra were recorded in 5-mm sample tubes. The pulse sequences were optimized to eliminate, prior to phase cycling, the signals of protons attached to 12C. We have concentrated on assignments of carbons bearing a single hydrogen in view of a relatively easy interpretation of carbon relaxation times, and most of these carbon resonances could be assigned. Furthermore, we demonstrate that two-dimensional heteronuclear correlated and relayed coherence transfer spectra can be used to elucidate connectivities between degenerate resonances within proton spin systems that often occur in threonines and aromatic side chains.     

Heteronuclear NMR of DNA with the heteronucleus in natural abundance: facilitated assignment and extraction of coupling constants.

Two heteronuclear proton-carbon NMR experiments are applied to the DNA-octamer d(TTGGCCAA)2 with carbon in natural abundance. They lead to a complete assignment of the carbon resonances of the sugars and bases. In addition, several heteronuclear coupling constants, proton-carbon as well as proton-phosphorous and phosphorous-carbon, were determined. The information can be obtained in a reasonable measuring time and offers valuable information for a detailed picture of DNA structure.     

Studies of individual carbon sites of proteins in solution by natural abundance carbon 13 nuclear magnetic resonance spectroscopy. Strategies for assignments.

Natural abundance 13C Fourier transform NMR spectra (at 15.18 MHz, in 20-mm sample tubes) of aqueous native proteins yield numerous narrow single carbon resonances of nonprotonated aromatic carbons. Techniques for the assignment of these resonances are presented. Each technique is applied to one or more of the following proteins: ferricytochrome c from horse heart and Candida krusei, ferrocytochrome c and cyanoferricytochrome c from horse heart, lysozyme from hen egg white, cyanoferrimyoglobins from horse and sperm whale skeletal muscle, and carbon monoxide myoglobin from horse. In all of the protein spectra we have examined, methine aromatic carbons give rise to broad bands. Studies of the narrow resonances of nonprotonated aromatic carbons of proteins are facilitated by removal of these broad bands by means of the convolution-difference method, preferably from spectra recorded under conditions of noise-modulated off-resonance proton decoupling. We present a summary of the chemical shift ranges for the various types of nonprotonated aromatic carbons of amino acid residues and hemes of diamagnetic proteins, based on our results for hen egg white lysozyme, horse heart ferrocytochrome c, horse carbon monoxide myoglobin, and carbon monoxide hemoglobins from various species...     

Proton NMR studies of transforming and nontransforming H-ras p21 mutants

One- and two-dimensional nuclear magnetic resonance spectroscopy (1D and 2D NMR) and site-directed mutagenesis were used to study the influence of mutations on the conformation of the H-ras oncogene product p21. No severe structural differences between the different mutants, whether they were transforming or nontransforming, could be detected. Initially, selective incorporation of 3,5-deuterated tyrosyl residues into p21 and 2D NMR were used to identify the resonances representing the spin systems of the imidazole rings of the three histidyl residues in the protein, of six of the nine tyrosyl rings, and of four of the five phenylalanyl rings. The spin systems of the phenyl rings of Phe28, Phe78, and Phe82 could be assigned by using mutant proteins, since no severe structure-induced spectral changes in the aromatic part of the spectra of the mutant proteins were detected. Sequence-specific assignments of the histidine imidazole resonances could be obtained by comparison of the distance information obtained by nuclear Overhauser enhancement spectroscopy (NOESY) experiments with the crystal structure. The change in the chemical shift values of the Hl' proton and the alpha-phosphate of the bound GDP in the NMR spectra of the p21(F28L) mutant and the 28-fold increase in the GDP dissociation rate constants of this mutant suggest a strong interaction between Phe28 and the p21-bound nucleotide. In solution, the p21-bound GDP.Mg2+ has an anti conformation, and the phenyl ring of Phe28 is close to the ribose of the bound GDP.Mg2+.     

The sequence-specific assignment of the 1H-NMR spectrum of an enzyme, horse-muscle acylphosphatase

A complete range of two-dimensional NMR experiments was used for the assignment of the 1H-NMR spectrum of horse muscle acylphosphatase. Firstly the spin systems of some easily identifiable amino acid side chains were assigned. These side chains involved all the aromatic residues and all the leucine, valine, isoleucine, threonine, alanine, proline as well as some of the glycine residues. Analysis of nuclear Overhauser enhancement spectra in our previous work had identified the sequential and long-range patterns characteristics for secondary structure elements. This result had also provided the identification of the main-chain alpha and amide proton resonances. Several of the completely assigned spin systems were then identified as being part of the secondary structure units which led, after analysis of the primary amino acid sequence, to unambiguous sequence-specific assignments. The identification and assignment of the remaining side-chain resonances was then completed and are reported here. These results provide a complete data base for the three-dimensional structure determination of this enzyme in solution.     

Assignment of resonances in the 1H NMR spectrum of human lysozyme

Assignments in the 1H NMR spectrum for more than 120 resonances arising from 38 of the 130 amino acid residues of human lysozyme are presented. Assignments have been achieved using a combination of one and two-dimensional NMR techniques. Two-dimensional double-quantum correlated spectroscopy and relayed coherence transfer spectroscopy were found to be particularly useful for the identification of spin systems in the aromatic and methyl regions of the spectrum. These spin systems were assigned to specific residues in human lysozyme with reference to the X-ray crystal structure using one-dimensional nuclear Overhauser enhancement (NOE) data and a computer-based search procedure. Unique assignments were found for resonances of 27 amino acid residues even when a distance constraint on NOE effects of 0.7 nm was used in the search procedure; for the remaining residues closer constraints or additional information were required. The assignments include all but one of the resonances in the aromatic region of the spectrum and all the methyl group resonances in the region upfield of 0.6 ppm. The assignments presented here provide a basis for a comparison of the NMR spectra of human lysozyme and the more widely studied hen lysozyme.     

Proton resonance assignments of horse ferrocytochrome c

Two-dimensional nuclear magnetic resonance (NMR) spectroscopy was used to assign the proton resonances of horse ferrocytochrome c. Assignments were based on the main chain directed (MCD) and sequential assignment procedures. The fundamental units of the MCD approach, the main-chain NH-C alpha H-C beta H J-coupled subspin systems of each amino acid residue (NAB sets), were defined by analysis of direct and relayed coherence transfer spectra. Recognition of main-chain NOE connectivity patterns specified in the MCD algorithm then allowed NAB sets to be aligned in their proper juxtaposition within secondary structural units. The units of secondary structure were placed within the polypeptide sequence of identification of a small number of side-chain J-coupled spin systems, found by direct recognition in 2D spectra of some J-coupled spin systems and by pairwise comparisons of the J-correlated spectra of six homologous cytochromes c having a small number of known amino acid differences. The placement of a given segment in this way defines the amino acid identity of all its NAB sets. This foreknowledge allowed the vast majority of the side-chain resonances to be discerned in J-correlated spectra. Extensive confirmation of the assignments derives internally from multiple main-chain NOE connectivities and their consistency following temperature-induced changes of the chemical shifts of NOE-correlated protons. The observed patterns of main-chain NOEs provide some structural information and suggest small but potentially significant differences between the solution structure observed by NMR and that defined earlier in crystallographic studies at 2.8-A resolution.     

Proton resonance assignments of horse ferricytochrome c

Two-dimensional nuclear magnetic resonance spectroscopy (2D NMR) was used to obtain extensive resonance assignments in the 1H NMR spectrum of horse ferricytochrome c. Assignments were made for the main-chain and C beta protons of 102 residues (all except Pro-44 and Gly-84) and the majority of side-chain protons. As starting points for the assignment of the oxidized protein, a limited set of protons was initially assigned by use of 2D NMR magnetization transfer methods to correlate resonances in the oxidized form with assigned resonances in the reduced form [Wand, A. J., Di Stefano, D. L., Feng, Y., Roder, H., & Englander, S. W. (1989) Biochemistry (preceding paper in this issue)]. Given the complexity of the spectrum due to the size of this protein (104 residues) and its paramagnetic center, the initial search for side-chain spin systems in J-correlated spectra was successful only for the simplest side chains, but the majority of NH-C alpha H-C beta H subspin systems (NAB sets) could be identified at this stage. The subsequent search for sequential NOE connectivities focused on NAB sets, with use of previously assigned residues to place NOE-connected segments within the amino acid sequence. Selective proton labeling of either the slowly or the rapidly exchanging amide sites was used to simplify the spectra, and systematic work at two temperatures was used to resolve ambiguities in the 2D NMR spectra. These approaches, together with the use of magnetization transfer methods to correlate reduced and oxidized cytochrome c spectra, provide multiple cross-checks to verify assignments.     

The Potential Utility of Predicted One Bond Carbon-Proton Coupling Constants in the Structure Elucidation of Small Organic Molecules by NMR Spectroscopy

NMR spectroscopy is the most popular technique used for structure elucidation of small organic molecules in solution, but incorrect structures are regularly reported. One-bond proton-carbon J-couplings provide additional information about chemical structure because they are determined by different features of molecular structure than are proton and carbon chemical shifts. However, these couplings are not routinely used to validate proposed structures because few software tools exist to predict them. This study assesses the accuracy of Density Functional Theory for predicting them using 396 published experimental observations from a diverse range of small organic molecules. With the B3LYP functional and the TZVP basis set, Density Functional Theory calculations using the open-source software package NWChem can predict one-bond CH J-couplings with good accuracy for most classes of small organic molecule. The root-mean-square deviation after correction is 1.5 Hz for most sp³ CH pairs and 1.9 Hz for sp² pairs; larger errors are observed for sp³ pairs with multiple electronegative substituents and for sp pairs. These results suggest that prediction of one-bond CH J-couplings by Density Functional Theory is sufficiently accurate for structure validation. This will be of particular use in strained ring systems and heterocycles which have characteristic couplings and which pose challenges for structure elucidation.     

Two-dimensional NMR studies of staphylococcal nuclease: evidence for conformational heterogeneity from hydrogen-1, carbon-13, and nitrogen-15 spin system assignments of the aromatic amino acids in the nuclease H124L-thymidine 3',5'-bisphosphate-Ca2+ ternary complex

A combination of multinuclear two-dimensional NMR experiments served to identify and assign the combined 1H, 13C, and 15N spin systems of the single tryptophan, three phenylalanines, three histidines, and seven tyrosines of staphylococcal nuclease H124L in its ternary complex with calcium and thymidine 3',5'-bisphosphate at pH 5.1 (H2O) or pH 5.5 (2H2O). Samples of recombinant nuclease were labeled with 13C or 15N as appropriate to individual NMR experiments: uniformly with 15N (all sites to greater than 95%), uniformly with 13C (all sites to 26%), selectively with 13C (single amino acids uniformly labeled to 26%), or selectively with 15N (single amino acids uniformly labeled to greater than 95%). NMR data used in the analysis included single-bond and multiple-bond 1H-13C and multiple-bond 1H-15N correlations, 1H-13C single-bond correlation with Hartmann-Hahn relay (1H[13C]SBC-HH), and 1H-13C single-bond correlation with NOE relay (1H[13C]SBC-NOE). The aromatic protons of the spin systems were identified from 1H[13C]SBC-HH data, and the nonprotonated aromatic ring carbons were identified from 1H-13C multiple-bond correlations. Sequence-specific assignments were made on the basis of observed NOE relay connectivities between assigned 1H alpha-13C alpha or 1H beta-13C beta direct cross peaks in the aliphatic region [Wang, J., LeMaster, D. M., & Markley, J. L. (1990) Biochemistry 29, 88-101] and 1H delta-13C delta direct cross peaks in the aromatic region of the 1H[13C]SBC-NOE spectrum. The His121 1H delta 2 resonance, which has an unusual upfield shift (at 4.3 ppm in the aliphatic region), was assigned from 1H[13C]SBC, 1H[13C]MBC, and 1H[15N]MBC data. Evidence for local structural heterogeneity in the ternary complex was provided by doubled peaks assigned to His46, one tyrosine, and one phenylalanine. Measurement of NOE buildup rates between protons on different aromatic residues of the major ternary complex species yielded a number of interproton distances that could be compared with those from X-ray structures of the wild-type nuclease ternary complex with calcium and thymidine 3',5'-bisphosphate [Cotton, F. A., Hazen, E. E., Jr., & Legg, M. J. (1979) Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. U.S.A. 76, 2551-2555; Loll, P. J., & Lattman, E. E. (1989) Proteins: Struct., Funct., Genet. 5, 183-201]. The unusual chemical shift of His121 1H delta 2 is consistent with ring current calculations from either X-ray structure.     

NMR study of thymulin, a lymphocyte differentiating thymic nonapeptide. Conformational states of free peptide in solution

The nonapeptide less than Glu-Ala-Lys-Ser-Gln-Gly-Gly-Ser-Asn (formerly called serum thymic factor) is a factor produced by the thymic epithelium, which needs a zinc ion to express its immunoregulatory properties. We report here on 1H and 13C NMR investigation of the conformational properties of the free peptide in aqueous medium and in dimethyl sulfoxide-d6 solution by a combination of homo- and heteronuclear one- and two-dimensional experiments. The various resonances have been assigned in a straightforward manner on the basis of 1H,1H COSY spectroscopy for the recognition of the proton spin systems; two-dimensional NOESY spectra with the correlation peaks across amide bonds and for the amino acid sequence assignment; amide bonds and for the amino acid sequence assignment; 13C,1H COSY experiments using selective polarization transfer from 1H- to 13C-nucleus via the 13C,1H long-range couplings for the attribution of the carboxyl and carbonyl groups; and 13C,1H COSY experiments with selective polarization transfer via the 13C,1H direct couplings for the assignment of all the aliphatic carbons. Other experiments such as pH-dependent chemical shifts, combined use of multiple and selective proton-decoupled 1H and 13C NMR spectra, the temperature and the concentration dependence of the proton shifts of the amide resonances, the solvent dependences of peptide carbonyl carbon resonances, and comparison of the spectra with three different analogues were performed. In aqueous solution, the data are compatible with the assumption of a highly mobile dynamic equilibrium among different conformations, whereas in dimethyl sulfoxide-d6, a more rigid structure is found involving three internal hydrogen bonds. These observations provide an insight into the conformational tendencies of this peptidic hormone in two different media.     

Structure elucidation of the O-antigenic polysaccharide from the enteroaggregative Escherichia coli strain 62D1.

The O-antigen polysaccharide of the lipopolysaccharide from the enteroaggregative Escherichia coli strain 62D1 has been determined. Sugar and methylation analysis together with 1H and 13C NMR spectroscopy revealed the components of the repeating unit. Two-dimensional NOESY and heteronuclear multiple-bond correlation experiments were used to deduce the sequence. 1H and 13C NMR spectra indicate heterogeneity in the polysaccharide. Methylation analysis and 1H NMR spectra of native and Smith-degraded material show that the majority (65%) of the repeating units has the following structure: Minor resonances in the NMR spectra are consistent with the presence of repeating units which lack the alpha-d-Galp terminal residue (35%).     

Identification of the 1H resonances of valine and leucine residues in dihydrofolate reductase by using a combination of selective deuteration and two-dimensional correlation spectroscopy

Lactobacillus casei dihydrofolate reductase (Mr 18 500) contains 16 valine and 14 leucine residues. By comparing the 2D COSY NMR spectra of normal and [gamma-2H6]valine enzyme we have been able to identify all 60 methyl resonances from these residues, and to connect the pairs arising from the same residue. This pairing of the methyl resonances was aided by the examination of the 2D RELAY spectrum which also allowed the C alpha H resonances (and hence the complete spin systems) of 14 of the valine residues to be identified. The combination of selective deuteration with 2D NMR techniques is shown to be a powerful general method for resolving 1H resonances in the complex spectra of proteins and for assigning them to amino-acid type.