Novel symmetric and asymmetric DNA scission determinants for Streptococcus pneumoniae topoisomerase IV and gyrase are clustered at the DNA breakage site

Topoisomerase (topo) IV and gyrase are bacterial type IIA DNA topoisomerases essential for DNA replication and chromosome segregation that act via a transient double-stranded DNA break involving a covalent enzyme-DNA "cleavage complex." Despite their mechanistic importance, the DNA breakage determinants are not understood for any bacterial type II enzyme. We investigated DNA cleavage by Streptococcus pneumoniae topo IV and gyrase stabilized by gemifloxacin and other antipneumococcal fluoroquinolones. Topo IV and gyrase induce distinct but overlapping repertoires of double-strand DNA breakage sites that were essentially identical for seven different quinolones and were augmented (in intensity) by positive or negative supercoiling. Sequence analysis of 180 topo IV and 126 gyrase sites promoted by gemifloxacin on pneumococcal DNA revealed the respective consensus sequences: G(G/c)(A/t)A*GNNCt(T/a)N(C/a) and GN4G(G/c)(A/c)G*GNNCtTN(C/a) (preferred bases are underlined; disfavored bases are in small capitals; N indicates no preference; and asterisk indicates DNA scission between -1 and +1 positions). Both enzymes show strong preferences for bases clustered symmetrically around the DNA scission site, i.e. +1G/+4C, -4G/+8C, and particularly the novel -2A/+6T, but with no preference at +2/+3 within the staggered 4-bp overhang. Asymmetric elements include -3G and several unfavored bases. These cleavage preferences, the first for Gram-positive type IIA topoisomerases, differ markedly from those reported for Escherichia coli topo IV (consensus (A/G)*T/A) and gyrase, which are based on fewer sites. However, both pneumococcal enzymes cleaved an E. coli gyrase site suggesting overlap in gyrase determinants. We propose a model for the cleavage complex of topo IV/gyrase that accommodates the unique -2A/+6T and other preferences.     

Hot-spot consensus of fluoroquinolone-mediated DNA cleavage by Gram-negative and Gram-positive type II DNA topoisomerases

Bacterial DNA gyrase and topoisomerase IV are selective targets of fluoroquinolones. Topoisomerase IV versus gyrase and Gram-positive versus Gram-negative behavior was studied based on the different recognition of DNA sequences by topoisomerase–quinolone complexes. A careful statistical analysis of preferred bases was performed on a large number (>400) of cleavage sites. We found discrete preferred sequences that were similar when using different enzymes (i.e. gyrase and topoisomerase IV) from the same bacterial source, but in part diverse when employing enzymes from different origins (i.e. Escherichia coli and Streptococcus pneumoniae). Subsequent analysis on the wild-type and mutated consensus sequences showed that: (i) Gn/Cn-rich sequences at and around the cleavage site are hot spots for quinolone-mediated strand breaks, especially for E. coli topoisomerases: we elucidated positions required for quinolone and enzyme recognition; (ii) for S. pneumoniae enzymes only, A and T at positions −2 and +6 are discriminating cleavage determinants; (iii) symmetry of the target sequence is a key trait to promote cleavage and (iv) the consensus sequence adopts a heteronomous A/B conformation, which may trigger DNA processing by the enzyme–drug complex.     

Clerocidin interacts with the cleavage complex of Streptococcus pneumoniae topoisomerase IV to induce selective irreversible DNA damage

Clerocidin (CL), a diterpenoid natural product, alkylates DNA through its epoxide moiety and exhibits both anticancer and antibacterial activities. We have examined CL action in the presence of topoisomerase IV from Streptococcus pneumoniae. CL promoted irreversible enzyme-mediated DNA cleavage leading to single- and double-stranded DNA breaks at specific sites. Reaction required the diterpenoid function: no cleavage was seen using a naphthalene-substituted analogue. Moreover, drug-induced DNA breakage was not observed using a mutant topoisomerase IV (ParC Y118F) unable to form a cleavage complex with DNA. Sequence analysis of 102 single-stranded DNA breaks and 79 double-stranded breaks revealed an overwhelming preference for G at the −1 position, i.e. immediately 5′ of the enzyme DNA scission site. This specificity contrasts with that of topoisomerase IV cleavage with antibacterial quinolones. Indeed, CL stimulated DNA breakage by a quinolone-resistant topoisomerase IV (ParC S79F). Overall, the results indicate that topoisomerase IV facilitates selective irreversible CL attack at guanine and that its cleavage complex differs markedly from that of mammalian topoisomerase II which promotes both irreversible and reversible CL attack at guanine and cytosine, respectively. The unique ability to form exclusively irreversible DNA breaks suggests topoisomerase IV may be a key intracellular target of CL in bacteria.     

Clerocidin selectively modifies the gyrase-DNA gate to induce irreversible and reversible DNA damage

Clerocidin (CL), a microbial diterpenoid, reacts with DNA via its epoxide group and stimulates DNA cleavage by type II DNA topoisomerases. The molecular basis of CL action is poorly understood. We establish by genetic means that CL targets DNA gyrase in the Gram-positive bacterium Streptococcus pneumoniae, and promotes gyrase-dependent single- and double-stranded DNA cleavage in vitro. CL-stimulated DNA breakage exhibited a strong preference for guanine preceding the scission site (−1 position). Mutagenesis of −1 guanines to A, C or T abrogated CL cleavage at a strong pBR322 site. Surprisingly, for double-strand breaks, scission on one strand consistently involved a modified (piperidine-labile) guanine and was not reversed by heat, salt or EDTA, whereas complementary strand scission occurred at a piperidine-stable −1 nt and was reversed by EDTA. CL did not induce cleavage by a mutant gyrase (GyrA G79A) identified here in CL-resistant pneumococci. Indeed, mutations at G79 and at the neighbouring S81 residue in the GyrA breakage-reunion domain discriminated poisoning by CL from that of antibacterial quinolones. The results suggest a novel mechanism of enzyme inhibition in which the −1 nt at the gyrase-DNA gate exhibit different CL reactivities to produce both irreversible and reversible DNA damage.     

The role of DNA bending in type IIA topoisomerase function

Type IIA topoisomerases control DNA supercoiling and separate newly replicated chromosomes using a complex DNA strand cleavage and passage mechanism. Structural and biochemical studies have shown that these enzymes sharply bend DNA by as much as 150°; an invariant isoleucine, which has been seen structurally to intercalate between two base pairs outside of the DNA cleavage site, has been suggested to promote deformation. To test this assumption, we examined the role of isoleucine on DNA binding, bending and catalytic activity for a bacterial type IIA topoisomerase, Escherichia coli topoisomerase IV (topo IV), using a combination of site-directed mutagenesis and biochemical assays. Our data show that alteration of the isoleucine (Ile₁₇₂) did not affect the basal ATPase activity of topo IV or its affinity for DNA. However, the amino acid was important for DNA bending, DNA cleavage and supercoil relaxation. Moreover, an ability to bend DNA correlated with efficacy with which nucleic acid substrates stimulate ATP hydrolysis. These data show that DNA binding and bending by topo IV can be uncoupled, and indicate that the stabilization of a highly curved DNA geometry is critical to the type IIA topoisomerase catalytic cycle.     

Mechanism of fluoroquinolone action.

When fluoroquinolones bind to gyrase or topoisomerase IV in the presence of DNA, they alter protein conformation. DNA cleavage results with diminished religation, so the enzymes are trapped in ternary complexes with drug and cleaved DNA. Preferential localization of gyrase ahead of replication forks and topoisomerase IV behind them causes fluoroquinolone-mediated complexes with the two enzymes to have different physiological consequences.     

Purification and characterization of DNA topoisomerase IV in Escherichia coli.

The subunits of topoisomerase IV (topo IV), the ParC and ParE proteins in Escherichia coli, were purified to near homogeneity from the respective overproducers. They revealed type II topoisomerase activity only when they were combined with each other. In the presence of Mg2+ and ATP, topo IV was capable of relaxing a negatively or positively supercoiled plasmid DNA or converting the knotted P4 phage DNA, whether nicked or ligated, to a simple ring. However, supercoiling activity was not detected. The topoisomerase activity was not detectable when the purified ParC and ParE proteins were combined with the purified GyrB and GyrA proteins, respectively. This is consistent with the result that neither a parC nor a parE mutation was compensated by transformation with a plasmid carrying either the gyrA or the gyrB gene. Simultaneous introduction of both the gyrA and gyrB plasmids corrected the phenotypic defect of parC and parE mutants. The results suggest that DNA gyrase can substitute for topo IV at least in some part of the function for chromosome partitioning. Antisera were prepared against the purified ParC, ParE, GyrA, and GyrB proteins and used to investigate cellular localization of these gene products. ParC protein was found to be specifically associated with inner membranes only in the presence of DNA. This result suggests that one of the functions of topo IV might be to anchor chromosomes on membranes as previously proposed for eukaryotic topoisomerase II.     

The different cleavage DNA sequence specificity explains the camptothecin resistance of the human topoisomerase I Glu418Lys mutant

Yeast cells expressing the Glu418Lys human topoisomerase I mutant display a camptothecin resistance that slowly decreases as a function of time. Molecular characterization of the single steps of the catalytic cycle of the purified mutant indicates that it has a relaxation activity identical to the wild-type protein but a different DNA sequence specificity for the cleavage sites when compared to the wild-type enzyme, as assayed on several substrates. In particular the mutant has a low specificity for CPT sensitive cleavable sites. In fact, the mutant has, at variance of the wild-type enzyme, a reduced preference for cleavage sites having a thymine base in position −1 of the scissile strand. This preference, together with the strict requirement for a thymine base in position −1 for an efficient camptothecin binding, explains the temporary camptothecin resistance of the yeast cell expressing the mutant and points out the importance of the DNA sequence in the binding of the camptothecin drug.     

DNA gyrase on the bacterial chromosome: DNA cleavage induced by oxolinic acid.

Treatments in vivo of Escherichia coli with oxolinic acid, a potent inhibitor of DNA gyrase and DNA synthesis, lead to DNA cleavage when extracted chromosomes are incubated with sodium dodecyl sulfate. This DNA breakage has properties similar to those obtained in vitro with DNA gyrase reaction mixtures designed to assay production of supertwists: it is oxolinic acid-dependent, sodium dodecyl sulfate-activated, and at saturating drug concentrations produces double-strand DNA cleavage with a concommitant tight association of protein and DNA. In addition, identical treatments performed on a nalA mutant strain exhibit no DNA cleavage. Thus the DNA cleavage sites probably correspond to chromosomal DNA gyrase sites. Sedimentation measurements of the DNA cleavage products indicate that there are approximately 45 DNA breaks per chromosome. This value is similar to the number of domains of supercoiling found in isolated Escherichia coli chromosomes, suggesting one gyrase site per domain. At low oxolinic acid concentrations single-strand cleavages predominate after sodium dodecyl sulfate treatment, and the inhibition of DNA synthesis parallels the number of sites that obtain a single-strand scission. Double-strand breaks arise from the accumulation of single-strand cleavages in accordance with a model where each cleavage site contains two independent drug targets, one on each DNA strand. Since the nicking-closing subunit of gyrase is the target of oxolinic acid in vitro, we suggest that each gyrase site contains two nicking-closing subunits, one on each DNA strand, and that DNA synthesis requires both to be functional.     

Fluoroquinolones stimulate the DNA cleavage activity of topoisomerase IV by promoting the binding of Mg2 + to the second metal binding site

BackgroundFluoroquinolones target bacterial type IIA topoisomerases, DNA gyrase and topoisomerase IV (Topo IV). Fluoroquinolones trap a topoisomerase–DNA covalent complex as a topoisomerase–fluoroquinolone–DNA ternary complex and ternary complex formation is critical for their cytotoxicity. A divalent metal ion is required for type IIA topoisomerase-catalyzed strand breakage and religation reactions. Recent studies have suggested that type IIA topoisomerases use two metal ions, one structural and one catalytic, to carry out the strand breakage reaction.MethodsWe conducted a series of DNA cleavage assays to examine the effects of fluoroquinolones and quinazolinediones on Mg^2 +-, Mn^2 +-, or Ca^2 +-supported DNA cleavage activity of Escherichia coli Topo IV.ResultsIn the absence of any drug, 20–30 mM Mg^2 + was required for the maximum levels of the DNA cleavage activity of Topo IV, whereas approximately 1 mM of either Mn^2 + or Ca^2 + was sufficient to support the maximum levels of the DNA cleavage activity of Topo IV. Fluoroquinolones promoted the Topo IV-catalyzed strand breakage reaction at low Mg^2 + concentrations where Topo IV alone could not efficiently cleave DNA.Conclusions and general significanceAt low Mg^2 + concentrations, fluoroquinolones may stimulate the Topo IV-catalyzed strand breakage reaction by promoting Mg^2 + binding to metal binding site B through the structural distortion in DNA. As Mg^2 + concentration increases, fluoroquinolones may inhibit the religation reaction by either stabilizing Mg^2 + at site B or inhibition the binding of Mg^2 + to site A. This study provides a molecular basis of how fluoroquinolones stimulate the Topo IV-catalyzed strand breakage reaction by modulating Mg^2 + binding.     

Mutation of a conserved serine residue in a quinolone-resistant type II topoisomerase alters the enzyme-DNA and drug interactions

A Ser740 --> Trp mutation in yeast topoisomerase II (top2) and of the equivalent Ser83 in gyrase results in resistance to quinolones and confers hypersensitivity to etoposide (VP-16). We characterized the cleavage complexes induced by the top2(S740W) in the human c-myc gene. In addition to resistance to the fluoroquinolone CP-115,953, top2(S740W) induced novel DNA cleavage sites in the presence of VP-16, azatoxin, amsacrine, and mitoxantrone. Analysis of the VP-16 sites indicated that the changes in the cleavage pattern were reflected by alterations in base preference. C at position -2 and G at position +6 were observed for the top2(S740W) in addition to the previously reported C-1 and G+5 for the wild-type top2. The VP-16-induced top2(S740W) cleavage complexes were also more stable. The most stable sites had strong preference for C-1, whereas the most reversible sites showed no base preference at positions -1 or -2. Different patterns of DNA cleavage were also observed in the absence of drug and in the presence of calcium. These results indicate that the Ser740 --> Trp mutation alters the DNA recognition of top2, enhances its DNA binding, and markedly affects its interactions with inhibitors. Thus, residue 740 of top2 appears critical for both DNA and drug interactions.     

What makes a type IIA topoisomerase a gyrase or a Topo IV?

Type IIA topoisomerases catalyze a variety of different reactions: eukaryotic topoisomerase II relaxes DNA in an ATP-dependent reaction, whereas the bacterial representatives gyrase and topoisomerase IV (Topo IV) preferentially introduce negative supercoils into DNA (gyrase) or decatenate DNA (Topo IV). Gyrase and Topo IV perform separate, dedicated tasks during replication: gyrase removes positive supercoils in front, Topo IV removes pre-catenanes behind the replication fork. Despite their well-separated cellular functions, gyrase and Topo IV have an overlapping activity spectrum: gyrase is also able to catalyze DNA decatenation, although less efficiently than Topo IV. The balance between supercoiling and decatenation activities is different for gyrases from different organisms. Both enzymes consist of a conserved topoisomerase core and structurally divergent C-terminal domains (CTDs). Deletion of the entire CTD, mutation of a conserved motif and even by just a single point mutation within the CTD converts gyrase into a Topo IV-like enzyme, implicating the CTDs as the major determinant for function. Here, we summarize the structural and mechanistic features that make a type IIA topoisomerase a gyrase or a Topo IV, and discuss the implications for type IIA topoisomerase evolution.     

A strand-passage conformation of DNA gyrase is required to allow the bacterial toxin, CcdB, to access its binding site

DNA gyrase is the only topoisomerase able to introduce negative supercoils into DNA. Absent in humans, gyrase is a successful target for antibacterial drugs. However, increasing drug resistance is a serious problem and new agents are urgently needed. The naturally-produced Escherichia coli toxin CcdB has been shown to target gyrase by what is predicted to be a novel mechanism. CcdB has been previously shown to stabilize the gyrase ‘cleavage complex’, but it has not been shown to inhibit the catalytic reactions of gyrase. We present data showing that CcdB does indeed inhibit the catalytic reactions of gyrase by stabilization of the cleavage complex and that the GyrA C-terminal DNA-wrapping domain and the GyrB N-terminal ATPase domain are dispensable for CcdB's action. We further investigate the role of specific GyrA residues in the action of CcdB by site-directed mutagenesis; these data corroborate a model for CcdB action based on a recent crystal structure of a CcdB–GyrA fragment complex. From this work, we are now able to present a model for CcdB action that explains all previous observations relating to CcdB–gyrase interaction. CcdB action requires a conformation of gyrase that is only revealed when DNA strand passage is taking place.     

Norfloxacin-induced DNA cleavage occurs at the dif resolvase locus in Escherichia coli and is the result of interaction with topoisomerase IV

The dif locus is a site-specific recombination site located within the terminus region of the chromosome of Escherichia coli. Recombination at dif resolves circular dimer chromosomes to monomers, and this recombination requires the XerC, XerD and FtsK proteins, as well as cell division. In order to characterize other enzymes that interact at dif, we tested whether quinolone-induced cleavage occurs at this site. Quinolone drugs, such as norfloxacin, inhibit the type 2 topoisomerases, DNA gyrase and topoisomerase IV, and can cleave DNA at sites where these enzymes interact with the chromosome. Using strains in which either DNA gyrase or topoisomerase IV, or both, were resistant to norfloxacin, we determined that specific interactions between dif and topoisomerase IV caused cleavage at that site. This interaction required XerC and XerD, but did not require the C-terminal region of FtsK or cell division.     

The role of topoisomerase IV in partitioning bacterial replicons and the structure of catenated intermediates in DNA replication.

Mutants in bacterial topoisomerase (topo) IV are deficient in chromosomal partitioning. To investigate the basis of this phenotype, we examined plasmid DNA topology in conditionally lethal topo IV mutants. We found that dimeric catenated plasmids accumulated in vivo after topo IV inhibition. The catenanes were supercoiled, contained from 2 to > 32 nodes, and were the products of DNA synthesis. Electron microscopy and recombination tests proved that the catenanes have the unique structure predicted for replication intermediates. These data provide strong evidence for a model in which unlinking of the double helix can occur in two stages during DNA replication and for the critical role of topo IV in the second stage. The interlocks in the catenanes appear to be sequestered from DNA gyrase, perhaps by compartmentalization in an enzyme complex dedicated to partitioning.     

Intercalative antitumor drugs interfere with the breakage-reunion reaction of mammalian DNA topoisomerase II

Many intercalative antitumor drugs have been shown to induce reversible protein-linked DNA breaks in cultured mammalian cells. Using purified mammalian DNA topoisomerase II, we have demonstrated that the antitumor drugs ellipticine and 2-methyl-9-hydroxyellipticine (2-Me-9-OH-E+) can produce reversible protein-linked DNA breaks in vitro. 2-Me-9-OH-E+ which is more cytotoxic toward L1210 cells and more active against experimental tumors than ellipticine is also more effective in stimulating DNA cleavage in vitro. Similar to the effect of 4'-(9-acridinylamino)-methanesulfon-m-anisidide (m-AMSA) on topoisomerase II in vitro, the mechanism of DNA breakage induced by ellipticines is most likely due to the drug stabilization of a cleavable complex formed between topoisomerase II and DNA. Protein denaturant treatment of the cleavable complex results in DNA breakage and covalent linking of one topoisomerase II subunit to each 5'-end of the cleaved DNA. Cleavage sites on pBR322 DNA produced by ellipticine or 2-Me-9-OH-E+ treatment mapped at the same positions. However, many of these cleavage sites are distinctly different from those produced by the antitumor drug m-AMSA which also targets at topoisomerase II. Our results thus suggest that although mammalian DNA topoisomerase II may be a common target of these antitumor drugs, drug-DNA-topoisomerase interactions for different antitumor drugs may be different.     

The basis for camptothecin enhancement of DNA breakage by eukaryotic topoisomerase I.

The eukaryotic topoisomerase I (topo I) is the target of the cytotoxic alkaloid camptothecin (CTT). In vitro, CTT enhances the breakage of DNA by topo I when the reaction is stopped with detergent. Although breakage at some sites is enhanced to a great extent while breakage at others is enhanced only minimally, CTT does not significantly change the breakage specificity of topo I in vitro. It has been suggested that CTT acts by slowing the reclosure step of the nicking-closing reaction. To test this hypothesis, we have measured the rate of reclosure for different break sites in the presence of CTT after adding 0.5 M NaCl to a standard low salt reaction. In support of the hypothesis, we find that topo I-mediated DNA breakage is enhanced the greatest at those sites where closure of the break is the slowest. These results suggest a mechanism for the toxicity of CTT in vivo.