Structural analyses of DNA fragments integrated by illegitimate recombination in Schizosaccharomyces pombe

In order to elucidate the mechanisms of illegitimate recombination in eukaryotes, we have studied the structure of DNA fragments integrated by illegitimate recombination into the genome of fission yeast. Nonhomologous recombination was rarely identified when a long region of homology with the chromosomal leu1 ⁺ gene was present in the introduced leu1::ura4 ⁺ DNA fragment; but a decrease in length of homology leads to an increase in the ratio of nonhomologous to homologous recombination events. The introduced DNA fragments were integrated into different sites in the chromosomes by nonhomologous recombination. The results suggested that there are multiple modes of integration; most events simply involve both ends of the fragments, while in other cases, fragments were integrated in a more complicated manner, probably via circularization or multimerization. To analyze the mechanism of the major type of integration, DNA fragments containing the recombination junctions of three recombinants were amplified by inverted polymerase chain reaction (IPCR) and their nucleotide sequences were determined. There was no obvious homology between introduced DNA and chromosomal DNA at these recombination sites. Furthermore it was found that each terminal region of the introduced DNA was deleted, but that there were no or very small deletions in the target sites of chromosomal DNA. Two models are proposed to explain the mechanism of nonhomologous integration.     

Microhomologies between T-DNA ends and target sites often occur in inverted orientation and may be responsible for the high frequency of T-DNA-associated inversions

Sequence analysis of left and right border integration sites of independent, single-copy T-DNA inserts in Arabidopsis thaliana revealed three previously unrecognized concomitants of T-DNA integration. First, genomic pre-insertion sites shared sequence similarity not only with the T-DNA left and right border regions, as was previously reported, but also at high frequency with the inverted complement of the T-DNA right border region. Second, palindromic sequences were frequently found to overlap or lie adjacent to genomic target sites, suggesting a high recombinogenic potential for palindromic elements during T-DNA integration and a possible role during the primary contact between the T-DNA and the target DNA. Third, “filler” DNA sequences between genomic pre-insertion site DNA and T-DNA often derive from sequences in the T-DNA left and right border regions that are clustered around palindromic sequences in these T-DNA regions, suggesting that these palindromic elements are “hot spots” for filler DNA formation. The discovery of inverted sequence similarities at the right border suggests a previously unrecognized mode of T-DNA integration that involves heteroduplex formation at both T-DNA borders and with opposite strands of the target DNA. Scanning for sequence similarities in both direct and inverted orientation may increase the probability and/or effectiveness of anchoring the T-DNA to the target DNA. Variations on this scheme may also account for inversion events at the target site of T-DNA integration and inverted T-DNA repeat formation, common sequence organization patterns associated with T-DNA integration. Electronic Supplementary Material Supplementary material is available in the online version of this article at and is accessible for authorized users.     

Interplasmidic illegitimate recombination in Bacillus subtilis

Summary The illegitimate recombination between Staphylococcus aureus plasmids pE194 (or pGG20, the hybrid between pE194 and Escherichia coli plasmid pBR322) and pBD17 (plasmid pUB110 without HpaII C-fragment) was studied in Bacillus subtilis. Cointegrates were generated with the frequency of 1–3x10^-8. Among 22 hybrids analysed 9 types of recombinants were found. Nucleotide sequences of all three parental plasmids were involved in intermolecular recombination. Nucleotide sequencing of recombinant DNA junctions revealed that in 8 cases recombination occurred between short homologous regions (9–15 bp). One recombinant was formed using nonhomologous sites. The similarity was demonstrated between nucleotide sequences of the recombination sites of two types of cointegrates and those used for pE194 integration into the B. subtilis chromosome. Possible mechanisms of illegitimate recombination are discussed.     

Restriction enzymes increase efficiencies of illegitimate DNA integration but decrease homologous integration in mammalian cells

Mammalian cells repair DNA double-strand breaks by illegitimate end-joining or by homologous recombination. We investigated the effects of restriction enzymes on illegitimate and homologous DNA integration in mammalian cells. A plasmid containing the neo^R expression cassette, which confers G418 resistance, was used to select for illegitimate integration events in CHO wild-type and xrcc5 mutant cells. Co-transfection with the restriction enzymes BamHI, BglII, EcoRI and KpnI increased the efficiency of linearized plasmid integration up to 5-fold in CHO cells. In contrast, the restriction enzymes did not increase the integration efficiency in xrcc5 mutant cells. Effects of restriction enzymes on illegitimate and homologous integration were also studied in mouse embryonic stem (ES) cells using a plasmid containing the neo^R gene flanked by exon 3 of Hprt. The enzymes BamHI, BglII and EcoRI increased the illegitimate integration efficiency of transforming DNA several-fold, similar to the results for CHO cells. However, all three enzymes decreased the absolute frequency of homologous integration ~2-fold, and the percentage of homologous integration decreased >10-fold. This suggests that random DNA breaks attract illegitimate recombination (IR) events that compete with homology search.     

Homologous recombination between plasmid and chromosomal DNA in Bacillus subtilis requires approximately 70 bp of homology

Summary To determine the minimal DNA sequence homology required for recombination in Bacillus subtilis, we developed a system capable of distinguishing between homologous and illegitimate recombination events during plasmid integration into the chromosome. In this system the recombination frequencies were measured between is pE194 derivatives carrying segments of the chromosomal -gluconase gene (bglS) of various lengths and the bacterial chromosome, using selection for erythromycin resistance at the non-permissive temperature. Homologous recombination events, resulting in disruption of the bglS gene, were easily detected by a colorimetric assay for -gluconase activity. A linear dependence of recombination frequency on homology length was observed over an interval of 77 bp. It was found that approximately 70 bp of homology is required for detectable homologous recombination. Homologous recombination was not detected when only 25 by of homology between plasmid and chromosome were provided. The data indicate that homology requirements for recombination in B. subtilis differ from those in Escherichia coli.     

Genetic mapping of mitochondrial markers by recombinational analysis in Chlamydomonas reinhardtii

The mitochondrial genome of Chlamydomonas reinhardtii is a 15.8 kb linear DNA molecule present in multiple copies. In crosses, the meiotic products only inherit the mitochondrial genome of the mating type minus (paternal) parent. In contrast mitotic zygotes transmit maternal and paternal mitochondrial DNA copies to their diploid progeny and recombinational events between molecules of both origins frequently occur. Six mitochondrial mutants unable to grow in the dark (dk^– mutants) were crossed in various combinations and the percentages of wild-type dk⁺ recombinants were determined in mitotic zygotes when all progeny cells had become homoplasmic for the mitochondrial genome. In crosses between strains mutated in the COB (apocytochrome ) gene and strains mutated in the COX1 (subunit 1 of cytochrome oxidase) gene, the frequency of recombination was 13.7% (± 3.2%). The corresponding physical distance between the mutation sites was 4.3 kb. In crosses between strains carrying mutations separated by about 20 bp, a recombinational frequency of 0.04% (± 0.02%) was found. Two other mutants not yet characterized at the molecular level were also used for recombinational studies. From these data, a linear genetic map of the mitochondrial genome could be drawn. This map is consistent with the positions of the mutation sites on the mitochondrial DNA molecule and thereby validates the method used to generate the map. The frequency of recombination per physical distance unit (3.2% ± 0.7% per kilobase) is compared with those obtained for other organellar genomes in yeasts and Chlamydomonas.     

Analysis of Tn5 inversion events inEscherichia coli plasmids

The ability of the bacterial transposon Tn5 to undergo sequence inversion in Rec⁺ Escherichia coli cells as a result of recombination between its duplicated IS50 elements was examined using specially designed plasmid constructs. Surprisingly, recombination events in the IS50 elements that led to crossover and therefore Tn5 inversion could be detected at a frequency of only 10^–5. This was approximately an order of magnitude lower than the frequency of IS50 recombination that led to conversion events (i.e. non-reciprocal recombination) without crossover, and at least two orders of magnitude lower than the frequency of intermolecular recombination between IS50 elements on two different plasmids. These rare conversion and inversion events in Tn5 appeared to be due to intramolecular recombination and not simply to multiple rounds of reciprocal crossing over, since the heterodimeric intermediates that would be generated during the latter process could be readily isolated but were shown to yield a completely different set of plasmid products upon resolution.     

Effect of mutations in genes affecting homologous recombination on restriction enzyme-mediated and illegitimate recombination in Saccharomyces cerevisiae.

Restriction enzyme-mediated events (REM events; integration of transforming DNA catalyzed by in vivo action of a restriction enzyme) and illegitimate recombination events (IR events; integration of transforming DNA that shares no homology with the host genomic sequences) have been previously characterized in Saccharomyces cerevisiae. This study determines the effect of mutations in genes that are involved in homologous recombination and/or in the repair of double-stranded DNA breaks on these recombination events. Surprisingly, REM events are completely independent of the double-strand-break repair functions encoded by the RAD51, RAD52, and RAD57 genes but require the RAD50 gene product. IR events are under different genetic control than homologous integration events. In the rad50 mutant, homologous integration occurred at wild-type frequency, whereas the frequency of IR events was 20- to 100-fold reduced. Conversely, the rad52 mutant was grossly deficient in homologous integration (at least 1,000-fold reduced) but showed only a 2- to 8-fold reduction in IR frequency.     

Non-recombinant background in gene targeting: illegitimate recombination between a hpt gene and a defective 5′ deleted nptII gene can restore a Kmr phenotype in tobacco

Previously we have demonstrated gene targeting in plants after Agrobacterium-mediated transformation. In these initial experiments a transgenic tobacco line 104 containing a T-DNA insertion with a defective neomycin phosphotransferase (nptII) gene was transformed with a repair construct containing an otherwise defective nptII gene. Homologous recombination between the chromosomally located target and the incoming complementary defective nptII construct generated an intact nptII gene and led to a kanamycin-resistant (Km^r) phenotype. The gene targeting frequency was 1×10^–5. In order to compare direct gene transfer and Agrobacterium-mediated transformation with respect to gene targeting we transformed the same transgenic tobacco line 104 via electroporation. A total of 1.35×10⁸ protoplasts were transformed with the repair construct. Out of nearly 221 000 transformed cells 477 Km^r calli were selected. Screening the Km^r calli via PCR for recombination events revealed that in none of these calli gene targeting had occurred. To establish the origin of the high number of Km^r calli in which gene targeting had not occurred we analysed plants regenerated from 24 Km^r calli via PCR and sequence analysis. This revealed that in 21 out of 24 plants analysed the 5-deleted nptII gene was fused to the hygromycin phosphotransferase (hpt) gene that was also present on the repair construct. Sequence analysis of 7 hpt/nptII gene fusions showed that they all contained a continuous open reading frame. The absence of significant homology at the fusion site indicated that fusion occurred via a process of illegitimate recombination. Therefore, illegitimate recombination between an introduced defective gene and another gene present on the repair construct or the chromosome has to be taken into account as a standard byproduct in gene targeting experiments.     

A mutation of Streptomyces lividans which prevents intraplasmid recombination has no effect on chromosomal recombination

Summary A mutation (rec-46) of Streptomyces lividans, previously shown to prevent (or greatly diminish) homologous and illegitimate intraplasmid recombination, was shown to have no effect on generalised chromosomal recombination occurring in matings or in protoplast fusions, nor to affect homologous recombination between a recombinant plasmid and the host chromosome. By comparison with Escherichia coli mutants defective in various aspects of recombination, the rec-46 mutation is similar to those in recF, recJ, recO and topA.     

Cre/lox-mediated recombination in Arabidopsis: evidence for transmission of a translocation and a deletion event

Cre recombinase was used to mediate recombination between a chromosomally introduced loxP sequence in Arabidopsis thaliana (35S-lox-cre) and transferred DNA (T-DNA) originating from Agrobacterium tumefaciens (plox-npt), carrying a single loxP sequence. Constructs were designed for specific Cre-mediated recombination between the two lox sites, resulting in restoration of neomycin phosphotransferase (nptII) expression at the target locus. Kanamycin resistant (Km^r) recombinants were obtained with an efficiency of about 1% compared with random integration. Molecular analyses confirmed that these were indeed due to recombination between the lox sites of the target and introduced T-DNA. However, polymerase chain reaction analysis revealed that these reflected site-specific integration events only in a minority (4%). The other events were classified as translocations/inversions (71%) or deletions (25%), and were probably caused by site-specific recombination between a randomly integrated T-DNA and the original target locus. We studied some of these events in detail, including a Cre-mediated balanced translocation event, which was characterized by a combination of molecular, genetic and cytogenetic experiments (fluorescence in situ hybridization to spread pollen mother cells at meiotic prophase I). Our data clearly demonstrate that Agrobacterium-mediated transfer of a targeting T-DNA with a single lox site allows the isolation of multiple chromosomal rearrangements, including translocation and deletion events. Given that the complete sequence of the Arabidopsis genome will have been determined shortly this method has significant potential for applications in functional genomics. Received: 29 December 1999; in revised form: 21 February 2000 / Accepted: 2 March 2000     

T-DNA recombination and replication in maize cells

T-DNA recombination and replication was analyzed in 'black mexican sweet' (BMS) cells transformed with T-DNAs containing the replication system from wheat dwarf virus (WDV). Upon recombination between the T-DNA ends, a promoterless marker gene (gusA) was activated. Activation of the recombination marker gene was delayed and increased exponentially over time, suggesting that recombination and amplification of the T-DNA occurred in maize cells. Mutant versions of the viral initiator gene (rep), known to be defective in the replication function, failed to generate recoverable recombinant T-DNA molecules. Circularization of T-DNA by the FLP/FRT site-specific recombination system and/or homologous recombination was not necessary to recover circular T-DNAs. However, replicating T-DNAs appeared to be suitable substrates for site-specific and homologous recombination. Among 33 T-DNA border junctions sequenced, only one pair of identical junction sites was found implying that the population of circular T-DNAs was highly heterogenous. Since no circular T-DNA molecules were detected in treatments without rep, it suggested that T-DNA recombination was linked to replication and might have been stimulated by this process. The border junctions observed in recombinant T-DNA molecules were indicative of illegitimate recombination and were similar to left-border recombination of T-DNA into the genome after Agro-mediated plant transformation. However, recombination between T-DNA molecules differed from T-DNA/genomic DNA junction sites in that few intact right borders were observed. The replicating T-DNA molecules did not enhance genomic random integration of T-DNA in the experimental configuration used for this study.     

A large-scale<Emphasis Type="Italic"> Agrobacterium</Emphasis>-mediated transformation procedure with a strong positive-negative selection for gene targeting in rice (<Emphasis Type="Italic">Oryza sativa</Emphasis> L.)

A large-scale transformation procedure handling an adequate number of stable transformants with highly efficient positive-negative selection is a necessary prerequisite to successful gene targeting by homologous recombination, as the integration of a transgene by somatic homologous recombination in higher plants has been reported to be 10^-3 to 10^-5 compared with random integration by non-homologous end joining. We established an efficient and large-scale Agrobacterium-mediated rice transformation protocol that generated around 10³ stable transformants routinely from 150 seeds and a strong positive-negative selection procedure that resulted in survivors at 10^-2 using the gene for diphtheria toxin A fragment as a negative marker. The established transformation procedure provides a basis for efficient gene targeting in rice.Abbreviations AS: Acetosyringone - 5-FU: 5-Fluorouracil - FW: Fresh weight - GT: Gene targeting - HR: Homologous recombination - NHEJ: Non-homologous end joining Communicated by H. Ebinuma     

T-DNA from Agrobacterium tumefaciens as an efficient tool for gene targeting in Kluyveromyces lactis

The soil bacterium Agrobacterium tumefaciens can transfer a part of its tumour-inducing (Ti) plasmid, the T-DNA, to plant cells. The virulence (vir) genes, also located on the Ti plasmid, encode proteins involved in the transport of T-DNA into the plant cell. Once in the plant nucleus, T-DNA is able to integrate into the plant genome by an illegitimate recombination mechanism. The host range of A. tumefaciens is not restricted to plant species. A. tumefaciens is also able to transfer T-DNA to the yeast Saccharomyces cerevisiae. In this paper we demonstrate transfer of T-DNA from A. tumefaciens to the yeast Kluyveromyces lactis. Furthermore, we found that T-DNA serves as an ideal substrate for gene targeting in K. lactis. We have studied the efficiency of gene targeting at the K. lactis TRP1 locus using either direct DNA transfer (electroporation) or T-DNA transfer from Agrobacterium. We found that gene targeting using T-DNA was at least ten times more efficient than using linear double-stranded DNA introduced by electroporation. Therefore, the outcome of gene targeting experiments in some organisms may depend strongly upon the DNA substrate used. Received: 11 May 1998 / Accepted: 16 October 1998     

Ionizing radiation and restriction enzymes induce microhomology-mediated illegitimate recombination in Saccharomyces cerevisiae

DNA double-strand breaks can be repaired by illegitimate recombination without extended sequence homology. A distinct mechanism namely microhomology-mediated recombination occurs between a few basepairs of homology that is associated with deletions. Ionizing radiation and restriction enzymes have been shown to increase the frequency of nonhomologous integration in yeast. However, the mechanism of such enhanced recombination events is not known. Here, we report that both ionizing radiation and restriction enzymes increase the frequency of microhomology-mediated integration. Irradiated yeast cells displayed 77% microhomology-mediated integration, compared to 27% in unirradiated cells. Radiation-induced integration exhibited lack of deletions at genomic insertion sites, implying that such events are likely to occur at undamaged sites. Restriction enzymes also enhanced integration events at random non-restriction sites via microhomology-mediated recombination. Furthermore, generation of a site-specific I-SceI-mediated double-strand break induces microhomology-mediated integration randomly throughout the genome. Taken together, these results suggest that double-strand breaks induce a genome-wide microhomology-mediated illegitimate recombination pathway that facilitates integration probably in trans at non-targeted sites and might be involved in generation of large deletions and other genomic rearrangements.     

Gene targeting in polymerase theta-deficient Arabidopsis thaliana

Agrobacterium tumefaciens-mediated transformation has been for decades the preferred tool to generate transgenic plants. During this process, a T-DNA carrying transgenes is transferred from the bacterium to plant cells, where it randomly integrates into the genome via polymerase theta (Polθ)-mediated end joining (TMEJ). Targeting of the T-DNA to a specific genomic locus via homologous recombination (HR) is also possible, but such gene targeting (GT) events occur at low frequency and are almost invariably accompanied by random integration events. An additional complexity is that the product of recombination between T-DNA and target locus may not only map to the target locus (true GT), but also to random positions in the genome (ectopic GT). In this study, we have investigated how TMEJ functionality affects the biology of GT in plants, by using Arabidopsis thaliana mutated for the TEBICHI gene, which encodes for Polθ. Whereas in TMEJ-proficient plants we predominantly found GT events accompanied by random T-DNA integrations, GT events obtained in the teb mutant background lacked additional T-DNA copies, corroborating the essential role of Polθ in T-DNA integration. Polθ deficiency also prevented ectopic GT events, suggesting that the sequence of events leading up to this outcome requires TMEJ. Our findings provide insights that can be used for the development of strategies to obtain high-quality GT events in crop plants.     

Efficient gene targeting in the filamentous fungusAlternaria alternata

To characterize homologous recombination of transforming DNA in the filamentous fungusAlternaria alternata, we have compared the frequencies of gene targeting by circular and linear DNA fragments in the fungus. TheA. alternata BRM1 gene, which is an essential gene for melanin biosynthesis, was selected as a target locus.BRM1 targeting events are easily identified because loss of function leads to a change in mycelial color from black to light brown. We constructed targeting vectors by inserting 0.6 to 3.1 kb internalBRM1 segments into a plasmid containing the hygromycin B phosphotransferase gene. When circular plasmids were used, melanin-deficient (Me1^–) transformants accounted for 30 to 80% of hygromycin B-resistant (Hy^R) transformants, correlating closely with the size of theBRM1 segment in the transforming DNA. Restriction enzyme digestion within theBRM1 region greatly enhanced the frequency of gene targeting: integration of the linear plasmids was almost completely attributable to homologous recombination, regardless of the size of theBRM1 segments. Plasmids carrying bothBRM1 segments and rDNA segments were transformed into the fungus to examine the effect of the number of target copies on homologous recombination. Using the circular plasmids, Me1^– transformants accounted for only 5% of Hy^R transformants. In contrast, when the linear plasmid produced by restriction enzyme digestion within theBRM1 segment was used, almost all transformants were Me1^–. These results indicate that homologous integration of circular molecules inA. alternata is sensitive to the length of homology and the number of targets, and that double-strand breaks in transforming DNA greatly enhance homologous recombination.     

Isolation of a LIM15/DMC1 homolog from the basidiomycete Coprinus cinereus and its expression in relation to meiotic chromosome pairing

The Escherichia coli gene recA is essential for homologous recombination and DNA repair, and homologs have been identified in eukaryotes. A basidiomycete, Coprinus cinereus, which has many advantages for the study of meiosis, was recently reported to have a homolog of one of these, RAD51. In the yeast Saccharomyces, mutations in the RAD5I gene cause defects in both somatic and meiotic cells. Based on this finding, we screened for a meiosis-specific homolog of recA, equivalent to Lilium LIM15 or Saccharomyces DMC1, in C. cinereus, and isolated a clone containing a 1.2-kb DNA fragment from a cDNA library constructed with Coprinus poly(A)⁺ RNA isolated from cells undergoing meiosis. The predicted amino acid sequence was 52% identical to the putative gene product of the lily cDNA clone LIM15 and 61% identical to Saccharomyces DMC1, and showed limited sequence similarity to the products of RAD52, 55, and 57. The synchrony of meiosis in Coprinus provides an ideal system for the investigation of differential gene expression in relation to meiosis and fruiting body development. Northern analysis indicated that Coprinus LIM15/DMC1 was expressed at meiotic prophase within 8 h after the onset of karyogamy, suggesting that the gene functions mostly at the stage at which the homologous chromosomes pair, but may not be essential at the point at which they recombine. The gene is not expressed in somatic cells. Received: 8 October 1998 / Accepted: 22 July 1999     

Integration of Agrobacterium T-DNA into a tobacco chromosome: Possible involvement of DNA homology between T-DNA and plant DNA

Summary We established tobacco tumour cell lines from crown galls induced by Agrobacterium. Restriction fragments containing T-DNA/plant DNA junctions were cloned from one of the cell lines, which has a single copy of the T-DNA in a unique region of its genome. We also isolated a DNA fragment that contained the integration target site from nontransformed tobacco cells. Nucleotide sequence analyses showed that the right and left breakpoints of the T-DNA mapped ca. 7.3 kb internal to the right 25 by border and ca. 350 by internal to the left border respectively. When the nucleotide sequences around these breakpoints were compared with the sequence of the target, significant homology was seen between the region adjacent to the integration target site and both external regions of the T-DNA breakpoints. In addition, a short stretch of plant DNA in the vicinity of the integration site was deleted. This deletion seems to have been promoted by homologous recombination between short repeated sequences that were present on both sides of the deleted stretch. Minor rearrangements, which included base substitutions, insertions and deletions, also took place around the integration site in the plant DNA. These results, together with previously reported results showing that in some cases sequences homologous to those in T-DNA are present in plant DNA regions adjacent to left recombinational junctions, indicate that sequence homology between the incoming T-DNA and the plant chromosomal DNA has an important function in T-DNA integration. The homology may promote close association of both termini of a T-DNA molecule on a target sequence; then TDNA may in some cases be integrated by a mechanism at least in part analogous to homologous recombination.Shogo Matsumoto is on leave from Biochemical Research Institute, Nippon Menard Cosmetic Co., Ltd, Ogaki, Gifu-ken 503, Japan