Phylogenetic analysis of the Argonaute protein family in platyhelminths

Argonaute proteins (AGOs) are mediators of gene silencing via recruitment of small regulatory RNAs to induce translational regression or degradation of targeted molecules. Platyhelminths have been reported to express microRNAs but the diversity of AGOs in the phylum has not been explored. Phylogenetic relationships of members of this protein family were studied using data from six platyhelminth genomes. Phylogenetic analysis showed that all cestode and trematode AGOs, along with some triclad planarian AGOs, were grouped into the Ago subfamily and its novel sister clade, here referred to as Cluster 1. These were very distant from Piwi and Class 3 subfamilies. By contrast, a number of planarian Piwi-like AGOs formed a novel sister clade to the Piwi subfamily. Extensive sequence searching revealed the presence of an additional locus for AGO2 in the cestode Echinococcus granulosus and exon expansion in this species and E. multilocularis. The current study suggests the absence of the Piwi subfamily and Class 3 AGOs in cestodes and trematodes and the Piwi-like AGO expansion in a free-living triclad planarian and the occurrence of exon expansion prior to or during the evolution of the most-recent common ancestor of the Echinococcus species studied.     

The coming of age for Piwi proteins

Piwi proteins, a subfamily of Argonaute (Ago) proteins, have recently been shown to bind endogenous small RNAs. However, differences between Ago proteins (which bind microRNAs and small interfering RNAs) and Piwi proteins and Piwi-interacting RNAs (piRNAs) suggest novel functions for Piwi proteins. Here, we highlight the recent progress in understanding Piwi function and the implications for germline and stem cell development.     

Argonaute 1 regulates the fate of germline stem cells in Drosophila

The Argonaute-family proteins play crucial roles in small-RNA-mediated gene regulation. In Drosophila, previous studies have demonstrated that Piwi, one member of the PIWI subfamily of Argonaute proteins, plays an essential role in regulating the fate of germline stem cells (GSCs). However, whether other Argonaute proteins also play similar roles remains elusive. Here, we show that overexpression of Argonaute 1 (AGO1) protein, another subfamily (AGO) of the Argonaute proteins, leads to GSC overproliferation, whereas loss of Ago1 results in the loss of GSCs. Combined with germline clonal analyses of Ago1, these findings strongly support the argument that Ago1 plays an essential and intrinsic role in the maintenance of GSCs. In contrast to previous observations of Piwi function in the maintenance of GSCs, we show that AGO1 is not required for bag of marbles (bam) silencing and probably acts downstream or parallel of bam in the regulation of GSC fate. Given that AGO1 serves as a key component of the miRNA pathway, we propose that an AGO1-dependent miRNA pathway probably plays an instructive role in repressing GSC/cystoblast differentiation.     

Identification,chromosomal mapping and conserved synteny of porcine Argonaute family of genes

The Argonaute proteins are recently identified and evolutionarily conserved family with two subfamilies Ago and Piwi, which play important roles in small RNA pathways. Most species have eight Argonaute members in their genomes, ranging from 1 to 27. Here we report identification of six Argonaute genes in pig, four members of the Ago subfamily (Ago1, Ago2, Ago3 and Ago4) and two members of the Piwi subfamily (Piwil1 and Piwil2), which were predicted to encode proteins of 857, 860, 860, 861, 861 and 985 amino acids, respectively. Phylogenetic analysis showed that the porcine Ago and Piwi genes were clustered into relevant branch of mammalian Argonaute members. The porcine Ago4- Ago1-Ago3 genes are linked together at the p12 of the chromosome 6, while Ago2 is located at the p15 of the chromosome 4. The porcine Piwil1 and Piwil2 are mapped together onto the chromosome 14, at the q14 and q11 respectively. Comparatively mapping of the Argonaute members on chromosomes showed that linkage group of the Ago4-Ago1-Ago3 and several neighborhood genes is evolutionarily conserved from chicken to mammals. The genes Piwil1 and Piwil2 are separated onto different chromosomes from fish to mammals, with exception to this tendency in both pig and stickleback, indicating an opposite tendency of recombination together or non-disjunction of these two genes during speciation. Further expression analysis showed an ubiquitous expression pattern of Ago members, oppositely a restricted expression pattern in gonads of the Piwi members, suggesting distinct potential roles of the porcine Argonaute genes.     

The interplay of transposon silencing genes in the Drosophila melanogaster germline

Complexes of Piwi proteins and Piwi-interacting RNAs (piRNAs) carry out the repression of transposable elements in animal gonads. The Piwi protein clade is represented in D. melanogaster by three members: Piwi, Aub and Ago3. Piwi protein functions in the nuclei of somatic and germinal ovarian cells, whereas Aub and Ago3 are cytoplasmic proteins of germinal cells. Aub and Ago3 interact with each other in the perinuclear nuage organelle to perform piRNA amplification via the ping-pong mechanism. Previously, derepression of several transposable elements as a result of mutations in the piRNA silencing system was shown. Here we quantify the increase in expression level of an enlarged number of retrotransposons due to the mutations in the piwi gene, nuage components coding aub, mael and spn-E genes and the RNA helicase armi gene mutation that impairs Piwi nuclear localization, but not the ping-pong cycle. We reveal that piwi, armi, aub, spn-E and mael genes participate together in the repression of several transposons (HMS-Beagle, Gate and HeT-A), whereas silencing of land G elements requires the same genes except piwi. We suggest that Armi has other functions besides the localizing of Piwi protein in the nuclei. Our data suggest also a role of cytoplasmic Aub, Spn-E and Mael nuage proteins in Piwi-mediated repression of Gate and HMS-Beagle transposons in the germline nuclei. As a whole, our results corroborate the idea that genome stabilization in the germline is realized by different silencing strategies specific for different transposable elements. At the same time, our data suggest the existence of yet unknown mechanisms of interplay between nuclear and cytoplasmic components of the piRNA machinery in the germline.     

Interplay of transposon-silencing genes in the germline of <Emphasis Type="Italic">Drosophila melanogaster</Emphasis>

Complexes of Piwi family proteins with short piRNAs (Piwi-interacting RNAs) are responsible for silencing transposable elements in animal reproductive organs. In Drosophila melanogaster, three proteins (Piwi, Aub, and Ago3) are members of the Piwi family. Piwi is the nuclear protein of somatic and germinal ovarian cells, whereas Aub and Ago3 are cytoplasmic proteins involved in piRNA amplification in perinuclear granules that constitute special organelles of germinal cells called nuage. Mutations in genes of the piRNA system are known to cause derepression of several transposable elements. In this study, we compared quantitatively changes in expression of a larger number of elements in the case of mutations in the piwi gene, genes aub, mael, and spn-E, which encode proteins of nuage granules, and armi gene coding an RNA helicase, the lack of which does not interfere with cytoplasmic piRNA amplification but disturbs nuclear localization of Piwi protein. We found that the genes piwi, armi, aub, spn-E, and mael interact to induce silencing of some retrotransposons (HMS-Beagle, Gate and HeT-A); the same genes, except piwi, are involved in repression of I and G elements. We propose that Armi is involved in control of not only nuclear Piwi localization. Our data suggest the relation of nuage proteins Aub, Spn-E, and Mael to Piwi-mediated silencing of retrotransposons Gate and HMS-Beagle in the nucleus. In general, our results corroborate the idea of genome stabilization by means of various silencing strategies specific to different transposable elements. At the same time, our data suggest the existence of yet unknown mechanisms of interplay between nuclear and cytoplasmic components of the piRNA machinery in germinal cells.     

Slicing-Independent RISC Activation Requires the Argonaute PAZ Domain

Small RNAs regulate genetic networks through a ribonucleoprotein complex called the RNA-induced silencing complex (RISC), which, in mammals, contains at its center one of four Argonaute proteins (Ago1-Ago4) (reviewed in [1-4]). A key regulatory event in the RNA interference (RNAi) and microRNA (miRNA) pathways is Ago loading, wherein double-stranded small-RNA duplexes are incorporated into RISC (pre-RISC) and then become single-stranded (mature RISC), a process that is not well understood [5, 6]. The?Agos contain an evolutionarily conserved PAZ (Piwi/Argonaute/Zwille) domain [7, 8] whose primary function is to bind the 3' end of small RNAs [9-13]. We created multiple PAZ-domain-disrupted mutant Ago proteins and studied their biochemical properties and biological functionality in cells.?We found that the PAZ domain is dispensable for Ago loading of slicing-competent RISC. In contrast, in the absence of slicer activity or slicer-substrate duplex RNAs,?PAZ-disrupted Agos bound duplex small interfering RNAs,?but were unable to unwind or eject the passenger strand and form functional RISC complexes. We have discovered that the highly conserved PAZ domain plays an important role in RISC activation, providing new mechanistic insights into how miRNAs regulate genes, as well as new insights for future design of miRNA- and RNAi-based therapeutics.     

Phosphorylation of human Argonaute proteins affects small RNA binding

Argonaute (Ago) proteins are highly conserved between species and constitute a direct-binding platform for small RNAs including short-interfering RNAs (siRNAs), microRNAs (miRNAs) and Piwi interacting RNAs (piRNAs). Small RNAs function as guides whereas Ago proteins are the actual mediators of gene silencing. Although the major steps in RNA-guided gene silencing have been elucidated, not much is known about Ago-protein regulation. Here we report a comprehensive analysis of Ago2 phosphorylation in human cells. We find that the highly conserved tyrosine Y529, located in the small RNA 5'-end-binding pocket of Ago proteins can be phosphorylated. By substituting Y529 with a negatively charged glutamate (E) mimicking a phosphorylated tyrosine, we show that small RNA binding is strongly reduced. Our data suggest that a negatively charged phospho-tyrosine generates a repulsive force that prevents efficient binding of the negatively charged 5' phosphate of the small RNA.     

Isolation and characterization of cDNA encoding Argonaute, a component of RNA silencing in shrimp (Penaeus monodon)

We have identified a cDNA clone that encodes a protein with high sequence homology to Argonaute proteins of mammals and Drosophila melanogaster. The cDNA of Penaeus monodon (Pm Ago) consisted of 3178 nucleotides encoding 939-amino acid residues with a calculated molecular weight of 104 kDa. The primary structure of Pm Ago showed the presence of two signature domains, PAZ and PIWI domains that exhibit highest homology to their counterparts in D. melanogaster. The inferred protein sequence of Pm Ago was 80.8% identical with D. melanogaster and 82.1% identical with Anopheles gambiae Ago proteins. Phylogenetic analysis of Pm Ago with other invertebrate and vertebrate Argonaute proteins suggested that Pm Ago belongs to the Ago1 subfamily that plays crucial roles in stem cell differentiation or RNA interference (RNAi). Semi-quantitative RT-PCR analysis showed that the gene is highly expressed in the lymphoid organ and moderately expressed in intestine, muscle, pleopods and hemocytes. The expression of Pm Ago1 mRNA was 2-3-fold increased during the early period of viral infection but declined rapidly at 30 hour post infection. By contrast, infection of shrimp by a bacterial pathogen, Vibrio harveyi did not induce a reduction of Pm Ago1 mRNA suggesting that its expression is associated with virus infection.     

The Bombyx ovary-derived cell line endogenously expresses PIWI/PIWI-interacting RNA complexes

Genetic studies and large-scale sequencing experiments have revealed that the PIWI subfamily proteins and PIWI-interacting RNAs (piRNAs) play an important role in germ line development and transposon control. Biochemical studies in vitro have greatly contributed to the understanding of small interfering RNA (siRNA) and microRNA (miRNA) pathways. However, in vitro analyses of the piRNA pathway have been thus far quite challenging, because their expression is largely restricted to the germ line. Here we report that Bombyx mori ovary-derived cultured cell line, BmN4, endogenously expresses two PIWI subfamily proteins, silkworm Piwi (Siwi) and Ago3 (BmAgo3), and piRNAs associated with them. Siwi-bound piRNAs have a strong bias for uridine at their 5′ end and BmAgo3-bound piRNAs are enriched for adenine at position 10. In addition, Siwi preferentially binds antisense piRNAs, whereas BmAgo3 binds sense piRNAs. Moreover, we identified many pairs in which Siwi-bound antisense and BmAgo3-bound sense piRNAs are overlapped by precisely 10 nt at their 5′ ends. These signatures are known to be important for secondary piRNA biogenesis in other organisms. Taken together, BmN4 is a unique cell line in which both primary and secondary steps of piRNA biogenesis pathways are active. This cell line would provide useful tools for analysis of piRNA biogenesis and function.     

The multiple Tudor domain-containing protein TDRD1 is a molecular scaffold for mouse Piwi proteins and piRNA biogenesis factors

Piwi-interacting RNAs (piRNAs) are small noncoding RNAs expressed in the germline of animals. They associate with Argonaute proteins of the Piwi subfamily, forming ribonucleoprotein complexes that are involved in maintaining genome integrity. The N-terminal region of some Piwi proteins contains symmetrically dimethylated arginines. This modification is thought to enable recruitment of Tudor domain-containing proteins (TDRDs), which might serve as platforms mediating interactions between various proteins in the piRNA pathway. We measured the binding affinity of the four individual extended Tudor domains (TDs) of murine TDRD1 protein for three different methylarginine-containing peptides from murine Piwi protein MILI. The results show a preference of TD2 and TD3 for consecutive MILI peptides, whereas TD4 and TD1 have, respectively, lower and very weak affinity for any peptide. The affinity of TD1 for methylarginine peptides can be restored by a single-point mutation back to the consensus aromatic cage sequence. These observations were confirmed by pull-down experiments with endogenous Piwi and Piwi-associated proteins. The crystal structure of TD3 bound to a methylated MILI peptide shows an unexpected orientation of the bound peptide, with additional contacts of nonmethylated residues being made outside of the aromatic cage, consistent with solution NMR titration experiments. Finally, the molecular envelope of the four tandem Tudor domains of TDRD1, derived from small angle scattering data, reveals a flexible, elongated shape for the protein. Overall, the results show that TDRD1 can accommodate different peptides from different proteins, and can therefore act as a scaffold protein for complex assembly in the piRNA pathway.     

Residues that affect human Argonaute2 concentration in cytoplasmic processing bodies

Sequence-specific gene silencing triggered by double-stranded RNA is a fundamental gene regulatory mechanism present in almost all eukaryotes. Argonaute2 (Ago2) is the central protein component of RNA-induced silencing complex (RISC), and resides in cytoplasmic processing bodies (P-bodies). In the present study, we demonstrated one human mutant Ago2 protein containing 6 point mutations (G32W, F128L, R196Q, P458S, T741A, S752G) failed to accumulate in P-bodies. Analysis of the different Ago2 revertants indicates the S752 as a key amino acid for P-body localization of Ago2. The S752 is evolutionary conserved in the Piwi domain of Ago2 homologs from worms, insects, plants and mammals. We further showed the single point mutation S752G interfering the interaction between Ago2 and Dcp1a, a key component of P-bodies.